The commission met to determine minimum acceptable bicycle infrastructure for the Boston Avenue corridor alongside new Tufts University construction. Members voted on prioritized roadway cross-sections and established a working group to coordinate advocacy with the city and Tufts.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Uh, let's, um, let's kick off this sort of ad hoc meeting of the Medford bicycle advisory commission. Bruce, you want to call roll?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Uh, yes. Uh, Bruce Kulik, uh, secretary present. Chris Stivers, uh, chair present, uh, Emily O'Brien, vice chair present. Jared Powell present or people present. We have a quorum.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Great. All right, well, I guess I have I have some high level thoughts here. We convene this meeting to talk about Boston out. I think that's the only item on our agenda, right?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And to, and to discuss some discussion of minimal and acceptable infrastructure.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Yeah, that's related to.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I was thinking, I think if you're just before we jumped on, I guess, and let's just have some discussion to sort of frame the meeting before we dive in. I see is outputs from the meeting, maybe 3 or 4 things. 1, yeah, what is what is sort of our minimum acceptable.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Design point of order. Sorry we have 1 guest tonight. Jeremy Martin.
[Jeremy Martin]: Oh, yeah, thank you. We forgot to introduce. Hey, everyone good to be here in your virtual company. Thanks for the invite. I do have some background that I can share with the group when it's helpful. Emily is familiar with some of this from our conversations about the community advisory group for the Boston Avenue study that's going on. I also had a conversation with Rocco from Tufts today. So I can review your role. Well, I'm a guest of this group. I am a neighbor of Boston Avenue.
Medford resident. Is that what you needed?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And are you involved with the Tufts group at all or are you just a resident?
[Jeremy Martin]: I am on the community advisory group for the Boston Avenue study. I am also one of the neighbors who negotiated a settlement with Tufts that led to the Boston Avenue study. And for what it's worth, I am on the Conservation Commission with Dennis, and also on the Community Preservation Committee. So that's why I'm probably not a part of this commission, if I could be, because my plate is full elsewhere. But a frequent user of Boston Avenue in all modes.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Thanks for joining Jeremy appreciate your, your time here and work before and after 1 additional guest join. Yeah, we get, we get Zachary here. He's Zachary you're welcome.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Zachary reminded your Somerville resident, right?
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Correct.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I think.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: All right. Yeah, exactly. Just to recap, we've got one agenda item, as I think you're aware, we're just talking about the changes to Boston out in front of the top storm. Jeremy, I do want to come back maybe 1st thing to you just before we do that, though, just to sort of frame the meeting what we're trying to get out of it to make sure that's clear. 3 or 4 things I see, and it wants to go around and see if anyone else in the commission has other things we want to get out of tonight. But 1 is, yeah, what's the minimum acceptable. Design and I think there's probably multiple ways we can achieve that. But something it'd be really nice to leave this meeting like, look, we, we really need at least a bike lane. That's at least. X feet wide and this much. Space from a door zone, so we can put some numbers on it and that allows the design team to work with a few different options that we may have a preferred design and we can recommend that. But if we allow the sort of the team to go with some different options, I think that's going to be best received.
That's number 1 on my list. Anything else to add to that? Bruce or others? Emily's got her hand up. Sorry, I'm not seeing everyone right now. Go ahead, Emily.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So I just, you know, I looked over what Bruce sent as kind of a list of possible configurations that we can discuss for Boston Ave. And then I started thinking maybe it actually makes a little bit more sense to outline what we would consider to be a essential, basically first a minimal acceptable design Based on not the, not the constraints of any specific particular spot, just what we would consider to be an acceptable safe. Bike lane, if, you know. with or without dividing, with or without barriers, but like what's an acceptable amount of space? What's actually enough space to allow a cyclist to avoid the door zone and to get passed by a safe distance by large vehicles that are using the travel lane? And so my thinking with that is if we start with just kind of a high level, this is what we think is the minimum acceptable space For a bike lane in general, and this is why and then we start saying, okay, here's what we consider to be a acceptable compromise. On the basis that I know that we are, we don't have that much space. I know that the numbers that we would want are not available.
But I think if we then come back with a recommendation for Boston Ave, we can present it as being something that we know is going to fall short of what the minimum acceptable amount of space should be. And the reason I say that is because so much of these discussions call it a standard bike lane when it's this cross section that we've discussed over and over again. And no manual calls it a standard bike lane. That's a minimum, bare minimum, like scraping the bottom of the barrel bike lane. It's not standard. And so I think we should really make it clear that this is not, if we end up settling for a minimum configuration like that, that that's what it is. It's a minimum configuration and we're compromising and we are hoping that the city or the police or somebody will help us make this compromise work.
So that's my thinking.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, I can get Jared to comment and I do want to kind of circle back to that. So let's make sure before we get too far into the weeds in that conversation. And Bruce, do you need to interject?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, so I just wanted to point out there's two things that I'd like to at least touch upon tonight. One is the notion that Tufts in the meeting steadfastly refused to consider increasing the curb-to-curb width of the roadway. even though they admitted that they were going to reconstruct the sidewalks. That took a little bit of, if you recall, a little bit of pulling teeth to get them to admit that, yes, they were going to be rebuilding the sidewalks. Therefore, the opportunity to reset the curbs is there. That's the one thing which I will call review curb to curb. Then the second one is, While people mentioned it and brought it up, Tufts never embraced the idea that the garage that they have, although it is a private garage, could have space reserved for public use to replace the spaces that would be lost by removing a lane of heart. And while that's slightly less convenient for some people who want to just park on the curb and run over to the subway, it's at least an option. And I think at one point they did mention that there was considerable space in the garage, possibly underutilized.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Somebody also mentioned the parking lot behind the Cummings building or around the Cummings building.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, it's pretty far downstream from here though, isn't it? You mean 238?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, no, no. Just right around the corner from the T stop, that big new building on the corner.
[Jeremy Martin]: There isn't a parking lot back there now. I think there isn't. There's a parking lot down behind the Elliot Pearson School, but not behind the Cummins Center.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: If we're going too far into the weeds right now, I want to give Garrett a chance to comment, and then I want to just make sure we have an outline of what we want to accomplish in the next hour before we get too sucked in.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, thanks. Thanks, Chris. Um, in terms of thinking about what our goals of this meeting are, like minimum acceptable conditions, I think is a good, a good starting point. I don't think we can have that conversation until we agree on like what our actual design goal is though, like minimal acceptable conditions means different things depending on what, what our driving motivation is for this. Like, are we different members of this commission, different members of the public are going to have different ideas about what is acceptable and like, we need to decide what our goals are. Like, for example, my goal is to create a design here that serves potential users of this road. Not that simply serves the few of us who are comfortable on that road now under its present conditions. So I think if we, as a group. have different answers to what that goal is and like different thoughts on that. And you disagree with what I'm saying, then we're going to come to very different, very different decisions and have very different positions about what those minimal acceptable conditions are. So I think that that needs to be part of our discussion as well. I have a lot of thoughts. I've written them down, but I'll wait until we, I'll wait until we get there.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, and I just repository that I want to just a couple of thoughts. I have high level here. I think we want to ultimately have a consensus from the commission as to what. What we would like to see as a minimum setup. Yeah, and we, but that's really caught up in the bigger question of, like. What's the strategy of how we're going to proceed and try to get something done here? Because that kind of doesn't matter what we think if we don't have a way to make it happen. And so I think. Come up in terms of goals. Let's agree on something that we can get behind as a commission. Let's come up with what we think our strategy is for next steps. And then as needed, create working groups and assign tasks for commission members to go and disperse after this to do those actions. That's what I'm hoping to get out of this meeting. Cool. Emily.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So what I'm thinking just as a sort of as a top level minimum acceptable conditions. I would say we come up with a number for what size of bike lane, what size of buffer, et cetera, we would consider minimally acceptable for A, a bike lane that's in between a travel lane and a parking lane, B, a bike lane that's in between a travel lane and a curb, C, a bike lane that's in between a curb and the parking lane, and D, a bike lane that's buffered. We have those four possible things. What do we think is the minimum space for each of those possible ways of building a bike lane? You know what I mean? We're not saying that this is the one way to build a bike lane, but just that if it's going to be here, this is how much space it needs. If it's here, this is much space it needs. It's here, this is what space it needs and with just with some reasoning as to why that is, for example, nobody puts a parking protected bike lane. That's 5 feet wide between with 5 feet between parks cart between the parking lane and the curb and there's a reason for that. So, what's the minimum amount of space for that bike lane plus. The parking plus the buffer, and then where the parks cars go, what's the minimum that we think is a is an appropriate amount of space. to consider to be comfortable and safe and usable. And the same with all of those other ways. And then when we come back to recommendations for Boston Ave, we can say, here's what we recommend on the basis that we know that there's not going to be space for, like, my guess is that if we sit down and figure out all of those four possibilities, we probably aren't going to have room for any of them.
just so that we start with some explanation of why it actually does require this much space for a bicyclist to operate safely. And regardless of what configuration, each of those has its own slightly separate demands.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, before we dive into the weeds on that, I wanted to just say, I'd like to come out of this meeting with a concrete recommendation back to tops that may or may not involve. Uh, widening the street and may or may not involve asking them to use the garage for parking. Plus the recommendations that we're talking about now, at this point, I'm willing to talk about the details of space.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: We should let Jeremy provide some probably important contacts here. And then let's, let's pause and we can come back to this conversation. Jeremy, why don't you have at it?
[Jeremy Martin]: Thanks, Chris, I may jump the gun on a little bit of these things, but I'll try to keep it concise. Emily and I have been. part of the community advisory group on this Boston Avenue study. And that study came out of an agreement with Tufts that they would develop protected bikeways on both sides of Boston Avenue in front of the building. And also do the study to look at what that meant beyond the kind of limit of work of this current project that is being considered in front of the traffic commission right now.
In June, they presented the plans that had parking protected bikeways on both sides of the avenue, and it required eliminating parking on the north side.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Does anyone have a copy of that design?
[Jeremy Martin]: I do, and I can put it up on the screen when that'd be helpful. It's a publicly available presentation, so no worries about sharing that. The city came back with feedback that they wanted to not eliminate any parking on Boston Avenue. And that's what I've heard through Tufts. And so that's when the plan changed to just reverting back to the 2 unprotected lanes on either side.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Do you know where that request came from? because my sense was that someone said, yeah, the city told us and no one's been able to identify.
[Jeremy Martin]: I am fairly certain that that request came from Todd Blake. Something that I've heard from Tufts is that that was a directive that was given to them and that their plans would not be approved and so they retracted their plans to go back to the drawing table. More recently, in September, they presented the new plans to the community that had, I'll call them the status quo bike lanes, just reverting back to the pre-construction condition. And then finally, in October, they presented those plans to Emily and I and the other community advisory board members as part of the study in that conversation. We suggested a couple of alternatives. 1 would be.
a parking protected lane on the South side and a shared lane on the North side that would restore parking on the North side. And I think if we were to look at the numbers, it would be equivalent to what Tufts has proposed currently, which keeps all of the parking. And it would work without needing to move the curbs. And I just want to say on the point of moving curbs and some suggestions from the traffic commission meeting about maybe delaying the planting of trees. I want to. So I would ask that this group. Use this opportunity to advocate. Very strongly against that. The addition of those trees into the project was something that the community fought quite a bit to get. And it's very important to bring some scale to that streetscape and to the building.
Um, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and tree plantings. I also just, um, I appreciate Bruce, the idea of. Advocating for parking in the garage. I know through listening in some other Tufts proposals that they are up With the new aquatic center, and I have a feeling that that's not going to, it's going to be a non starter for toughs. And the traffic commission is going to say, that's really outside of their purview because it is, it's, it's not something they can speak to in that meeting. So, in terms of what we want to accomplish. For this traffic commission meeting for the approval of this specific project.
I just think we have to keep our focus on things that the traffic commission can decide on and that Tufts can implement in the next three weeks ahead of that hearing, because I don't think we're going to see another continuation of the matter going forward. I believe the next traffic commission is the second Tuesday in December. So I want to say that's the 8th, December 8th.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: The expectation that they would revisit this proposal in that meeting?
[Jeremy Martin]: That's correct. And so I spoke to Rocco DiRico today to ask him for an update. He said that their engineers are working on studying a version of the plan that would have the parking protected lane on the south side. the shared bicycle and traffic lane on the North side with parking on the North side as well, which is something that I have advocated for with them. And it was coming out of conversations that we had with the community advisory group. Just from my perspective, it sets up, it seems to set up the best potential for a future modification of that condition That would eliminate parking on the North and introduce that 2nd protected lane there, which was originally proposed.
Without requiring any modifications to the curbs. So, I know we'll get into the details on those different cross sections some more here, but I think that's the context I had to offer.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: There was a quick, just quick, Jeremy, maybe you know, because I'm kind of confused about some of this. There was some discussion of an additional study being done of the whole corridor that would essentially, in the traffic commission meeting, it sounded like this was being presented as kind of, this is what we're gonna build without changing this stuff very much right now. And then there's a bigger study that's ongoing that may include more changes. And I'm a little bit, I'm a little bit confused as to which things are which.
[Jeremy Martin]: Sure. The only two things that are happening right now is the traffic commission review of the Pachyderm Place proposal and the Boston Avenue study that we're a part of, Emily, that goes from Winthrop to College Ave. Those are the only two active Boston Avenue studies, I think the corridor as it was described was a misnomer for what's actually.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah, because at least some people in the traffic commission meeting, we're making it sounds like. The proposal will get approved for the package in place part so that the dorm can open, but that there'll be like a longer term ongoing thing. And maybe that is what we're part of, but that sounds like if it is, then that's misleading because they were making it sound like essentially there will be another opportunity to revisit this. in six months or a year or something, whereas the rest of that study, they were, as the way they've presented it to us, they're looking at it in these different segments. So when they're done with this one, then they'll deal with the others. But that doesn't sound like they're going to revisit this one.
[Jeremy Martin]: As far as I know, there are no other studies planned or active. It's only this section.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That brings me to my main concern, which I want to make sure I clarify. I appreciate your talking about the trees and how the neighborhood wants to beautify that section of the street. I like trees and I think it's laudable, but I think what I hear you telling me is then that the any notion that we could increase the curb to curb size is impossible now or in the future because no one's going to take trees out to redo the curbs in the future. But you also possibly said that that the so-called long-term study is moot and effectively non-existent because whatever gets approved and built now is what we're going to have for the next 10 years at least or we'll call it permanently because there really is no horizon that that proposes anything different. So let me clarify the two things. First by planting the trees as proposed it totally precludes the possibility of increasing the curb to curb width. Is that correct?
[Jeremy Martin]: I don't know if I can say that definitively, Bruce. What I understand is that there is a five-foot right-of-way outside of each curb, as it exists now, and the trees are proposed in that right-of-way, and the remainder of that sidewalk, we were talking about a 13-foot wide sidewalk and that offering space, much of that is on Tufts property. And I think what I've been told by Tufts is that if the curbs widen, it would preclude their ability to fit the trees into the city's right-of-way. I have not vetted that with a plan or an engineer. I'm relaying what I've heard.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Anecdotally, I believe that's true. I've looked at the overhead views and done some measurements, and I'm familiar with the road and the size. I believe there's six feet on the north side, currently with a sidewalk and five feet on the South side, and certainly adding any trees would require at least a 36 inch accessible space, which means at best, and I mean, truly at best, we would be able to get not quite in a foot of space out of that. And I don't even think that's possible. So I'm gonna walk away from this understanding that the notion of creasing the curb to curb is not feasible at this time. Nor in the short term future. So what we have to work with is the 44 feet. Is that what we came up with?
[Jeremy Martin]: I think they've acknowledged that probably varies a little bit through the stretch of the street, anywhere from 43 to 44 feet.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Which means that I'm trying to really triage what we need to consider tonight in the interest of expediency. It means that we really only need to consider what can fit curb to curb at 44 feet possibly with the eventual removal of a parking lane, but also an unlikely possibility, which means that I think we should come away tonight, assuming that removing the parking is impossible. And then with a pie in the sky proposal of what it might look like if we ultimately were able to remove parking, but we should not plan any proposal we have tonight on the likelihood or possibility that parking will be removed in the future, which brings me to a big concern that I have, which is I am vehemently opposed to a hybrid approach on this road because you're basically saying one direction gets great treatment while the other direction is thrown to the wolves. and does not fulfill the request that I believe it was Jared made that we design this for future people who want to travel this road as opposed to the people currently travel this road. That is a tough call. I don't see how we're going to do that because I just don't see the possibility of any protected lane, any buffered lane. I don't see any possibility to be on the seven, five, 10, 10, seven or five, seven configuration. I just don't see how that is equitable to both sides or how we're going to get anything different than that.
[Jared Powell]: I need, I need to jump in quickly here because I think we're, we're starting to negotiate against ourselves in a way that I don't think is necessary. Like when we actually. Like I, I can pull up my screen here, but like 44 feet gets us everything we want. Quite frankly, you can fit it. Like I think, and maybe we need six inches to play with them. They acknowledge that that much was possible, but, like, when we're getting into talk, I think we, it would be nice to leave here. With an actual proposed design. I'm happy to share my screen and play with some things in real time to let us visualize some things.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Because without visualizing it, it's difficult to discuss some of the specifics.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, can you bring it up, Jared? I have a couple of thoughts to share. I just want to clarify one thing, Jeremy. This whole subsequent study, what I heard in that traffic commission meeting, I'm so confused on this, was that there is a separate Planning study for that segment for winter for college out. That will be occurring over the 2027 year. And so that it's still a long ways away from any future changes that would that's not quite right.
[Jeremy Martin]: Chris. No, that study is ongoing. We started in. March of this year, and they expect it to wrap up in the beginning of 2027. And so the unfortunate part here is that the timing for the project is ahead of the outcome of the study. And so what is happening with this stretch with the traffic commission has actually negatively influenced the study because they've backtracked on some of their proposals. um, in the original, you know, more ambitious plan, I would say. So the, the, this.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: The other study is not likely to make any material changes, is what you're saying, from what we're going to come out of this with.
[Jeremy Martin]: I think that we need to go back with Tufts, and we've said this in our comments, that no, this other study should be more ambitious than what the traffic commission will allow currently. It should set the roadmap for a future condition, even if the city will not allow it now, based on their current priorities. There's some work to do for Tufts to bring those elements back into the study, but the study is not complete. So I would say that there is potential for future changes. I just want to flag for some context that if you go east or west of this particular stretch, the curb-to-curb narrows even further. And, um, you're all aware of it because you write it, but I don't, uh, I mean, what we can envision for this section is going to be the best condition on Boston Avenue because there's much more constraint beyond it.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And so I hear Bruce's section from Winthrop to university. Is that going to be looked at?
[Jeremy Martin]: We were looking at Winthrop to university. Yes. I thought that was where the 13 foot sidewalk was like near the bus stop. HAB-Michael Leccesereeeeeeeeee The likelihood of removing parking at this stretch may be highest, and it may still be pie in the sky, but there are no businesses immediately adjacent to this stretch of Boston Avenue.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I think there will be in the Packaderm Place building.
[Jeremy Martin]: There will, but I think we're talking about hopefully keeping parking on that side. We'll look at the scenarios. There would be one business there, but go ahead.
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: Zachary Stocks, PB – He, Him, Hissssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss that that's what Somerville did on Powderhouse. And that's kind of a better condition than, like, if we're trying to design something that someone who's not comfortable biking in an unprotected bike lane can use, at least then they can use that one way. We'd also talked before about, like, a door zone bike lane is not really a, That's not really a good bike lane like I might say it's kind of a not entirely truthful to call it a bike lane because it's a buffer where the door opens. And I'm I, I'm not a fan of that being striped as a bike lane at all. Like, you know, stripe it as a buffer zone or whatever. Um, where is like, if you have the parking protected bike lane one way and the other direction has a seven foot travel lane that can be turned into a two foot buffer and a five foot bike lane. If we win that fight down the road, even if we don't win it right now, um, if we do the seven, five, 10, 10, five, seven, then.
Even if we win the fight down the road for taking away lane of parking, that's a much bigger ask because you're asking them to remove striping rather than just close down a lane of parking. If we have the, you know, parking protected by claim one side and just parking on the other that later gets converted to a bike lane. You don't need to change any of the rest of the road to just add the, the, the additional stripe and vertical separation to that new bike lane side. So, we would also be lowering what we're asking for down the road if we can't get that right now.
And then I also want to just voice my agreement for the folks saying, like, let's not. I mean, I shouldn't say us, because I'm not actually on the committee, but I would like to see you all not compromise the vision ahead of time. Sure, you could say if we absolutely can't get rid of any parking, this is a thing that is used elsewhere, but I would hesitate to put something with unprotected door zone bike lanes as a recommendation because of That's not really quality infrastructure. That's something I feel like the city would go for if this body didn't exist. I don't see any reason this body needs to put any sort of approval on it.
Also, for the much earlier question of measurements, I have Peter first. I can link Peter first. Article about it's kind of dense, but it has some of his notes about them. The minimum was and recommended with for.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: All right, Emily, real quick. I got a couple of comments and then I want to turn most of it actually look like Jared's got here.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah. So the other the other thing that I wanted to mention, and this is part of why I think we. should lead with how much space we actually think it really requires for all of these to be the ideal situation and why is based on the conversation that we had earlier that day with the police department. I don't think they really quite get what it actually takes for somebody to use a bike lane in some of these configurations that were being discussed.
For example, if you've got that 7-5-10 configuration, if you've got that 7-foot parking lane and somebody is parked 6 inches into it, now you've got a 2-foot bike lane left. And you're a 2-foot wide bicyclist in a 2-foot wide bike lane next to a 10-foot wide drive lane with 10 foot wide trucks in it. And I kind of wish that these, um, that the graphics would actually show how wide a city bus is because it really looks pretty substantially different from if it's just, you know, sedans in the picture. Um, and so my, what I think, I think it's important to lead with. This is what actually, what we're actually requiring people to accommodate to, um, And so, and, and I would, and I wonder if in terms of a negotiating strategy, basically, I understand why it's not, you know, why it's not ideal to have like a good configuration on one side and nothing on the other side. But I think it may be like Zachary said a better. Um, a better negotiating position to have that, you know, nothing on the one side, which then we can come back and, and try to improve upon later if traffic can be removed.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Um, I mean, parking, parking, not traffic.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah. So jumping ahead a second here, I think we talk a little bit about like, what do we do? So we. Ultimately, I think after all the conversation here, I think we ultimately want to come out of this with one, two, three, however many design scenarios that we could get behind. And so we may prioritize, we prefer this one, here's our second choice, but these are the ones, these are the three or however many that we endorse. And anything less, we oppose. And ultimately, I think we got to put that into a letter that goes to the mayor. And I've already drafted a version, I think I sent it to Emily and Jared for initial review, but we can modify that to basically say, here are the designs that we stand behind, and this is what we think has to happen. We have a complete street policy in Medford, and anything less than these is not going by what we've committed to doing for any redesign of streets in Medford. And we need to get broad community support behind that. Jeremy, I hope you're part of that. Maybe we leave the trees in place. And ultimately, I think we want it to be something that people do support in the neighborhood. We know there are gonna be folks who are opposed to taking out parking, but this is a matter of pedestrian and cyclist safety, and we think that's important. I'll step back now. Bruce, any other comments before we actually talk nuts and bolts here?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, I just, I'm really concerned that we are taking an approach here which has no chance of coming to fruition. And I understand, I understand Zachary's design and the strategy of being able to say, okay, now that we have the sharrows on the one side, we're gonna take away the parking and put the bike lane there instead without having to repaint. Frankly, repainting is easy, but that's not the argument. I think that, I just think because of the T Station, it's going to be a really, really difficult sell to get parking removed. Just like in many of the residential streets in the city, there's no political will. We're not going to build a political will.
I fought a lot of political fights here in the city. I kind of have a feeling for where they go. This is not what I'm going to take. I just I just don't think it's going to it's going to happen. There are places where parking can be removed when. The utilization is well below 50%. You can say put it on one side and take it from the other side. High Street in West Medford that Ernie has been lobbying about is one such place, although I think they measured that and determined that there still wasn't quite enough room, which I don't quite believe. But that would be a place, for example, where parking lane could be removed. On High Street we saw where they were primarily residential places with driveways and the parking utilization was much lower except in front of the school. So they managed to figure out how to make that part work with a bike lane on one side, on the uphill side, and shadows on the other.
But in this particular case, I just don't think that that I think we're tilting it windmills here. If we think that parking is going to disappear on that side of the street. And therefore, where you are permanently setting up a situation in which. We don't we don't have even adequate protection of any kind. And I know there are many people who. won't ride their bike on a street without protected bike lanes. That's great if we can do it, but I just don't see how that's going to work in this area. And I don't want to see the bike lanes we have disappear. If they go away and we don't have the bike lanes, people have to ride on their own. And this sets up even more of a conflict for people to ride in the street because now there is no guidance for where automobile traffic ought to sit. Some people think that if there's no bike lanes, the bike shouldn't be there in the 1st place. And Emily, you've been concerned about harassment. I think that sets you up for more harassment by not. By not having having it spelled out. And in this case, I think that. You know, some places where bicyclists need to learn how to ride better, and if they don't, they're going to be uncomfortable riding there. And, you know, I mean, I'd like to see us have protected bike lanes everywhere like we have in Europe, but... You know, I'm not gonna see that in my lifetime. Maybe you will, Zachary, but not me. So just saying.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I wonder also if we should be kind of just keep in mind that the section between University and Winthrop is narrower and whatever protection we can get in this section if we were to go that route is probably not possible.
[Unidentified]: Yeah, that's going to be a transition for sure.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: It's going to be, and whatever we get here, it's going to be our best case scenario here is probably still going to be just a short stretch.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That's also why I lobbied for a bike lane end sign westbound in the design that they have that was missing. That's a real concrete thing we can do to make sure that both cyclists and motorists are aware that the bike lane ends and that traffic will be merging.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And my concern too is Basically, if somebody is using the 7510 bike lane, and they're riding on the very outside edge of it because they don't want to be doored, and they get side swiped, based on impressions that I've gotten, I'm not entirely sure that they won't be assigned a certain amount of blame for that crash.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: even though there's a four foot law in Massachusetts.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Even though, and I don't, I disagree with you on that. Well, I have it based on, based on another conversation that I had earlier on Tuesday. Um, and the, and my concern with that is that it's, I mean, it is, it's better to have the space than not to have it at all. but that it really does only work if people in the travel lane move over to the left to give the four feet. And they don't, and most of them don't even know about it. And so there's not really, and there's not really, we don't have a plan for getting them to cross the center line. A bus would have to move over the center line by four feet. And we don't have a way to get them to do that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I've got to say, frankly, I've never had a problem in that section of Boston Avenue.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I have.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Maybe that's just me. So we have different experiences. Maybe it's different timing, different time of day. I don't know.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And the timing definitely makes a difference.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Jared, you've been waiting.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, let's talk about some real stuff before we get too into the back and forth over the hypothetical things, I'd say. So I played with some different designs. I set the parameters at 43 and a half feet, which I, sorry, there's a little pop-ups here because I zoomed in a bit.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Oh, we're not seeing, are we seeing you? Yeah, are you are you not? Wait, sorry. I see it. Oh, you see. All right. Maybe I've got the window not upright.
[Jared Powell]: Excuse me. So I was playing with a. A street design tool, so I'm I'm new to it. So bear with me. But I set the parameters at 43 and a half feet. Which I believe was the number that I heard cited, though they did say. They thought that it would probably be not too challenging, Bruce, to your other point about how they were likely moving the curves anyway, to gain another half foot or so, maybe a foot. So, but to be conservative, I set it at 43 and a half and then just played with it and looked at like, what are the options that you could get? So I started from my own set of requirements, which is what are the things that I find unacceptable? On this particular stretch of the street, I find generally unacceptable. I don't like them. I think they're inappropriate for an arterial road with this level of traffic. And I think supports that.
So, I was looking for things that did not require in either direction. Other things that I view as a requirement here is a parking lane. On the dorm side, so the South side of the street, I view that as non negotiable. I don't think we should get rid of that. I think we should have parking though. Frankly, I think it should be. Almost entirely loading zone, maybe accessible disability parking as well. You know, like, but I think that space needs to be there.
Um, and this is 1 reason why I personally. Think that it's going to be a really bad move. I, we can, we can fight over this as much as we care to, but. I think a standard door ish zone bike lane. On the South side that is near the parked cars, loading zone, whatever you want to call it. Is going to be a problem for us because I think that. That might work for the current conditions of the road. I think that it does not work for the future conditions of the road, which is now there's going to be roughly 600 students in those two buildings, right?
Those students are going to be getting a lot of deliveries, a lot of delivery food, a lot of packages, a lot of drivers are going to be stopping there. So if we put a door-ish zone with paint as a buffer and paint is the only buffer to the left side of these parked cars here, we are going to end up with a bike lane that looks really nice at like 2 a.m. and almost every other time has cars parked in it, like all the time.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Explaining the loading zone is very important. I can confer with you on that.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, they specifically called out in the meeting that they had allocated, I think two, maybe three, two, which like, it's like, come on, that's not going to work. Like that's going to be double parked all day long, like with, with cars. So no sharrows, dorms, dorm zone, dorm side loading zone, parking. Um, and then I also don't like really narrow door zone bike lanes. So those were my main and 44 feet. So those are my main design parameters and coming up with this. Everyone's going to have their own. I recognize that. So this is what you can fit. That is the closest to what I would like to see. And I think that has, um, that has actual on the ground examples that we can look at that exist in Somerville.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'd like to take this proposal and make something really quick. I know I'm interrupting you here, but we've been thinking about moving the curbs wider. What if we thought about moving the curbs narrower such that we actually had a sidewalk level cycle track similar to what we see in some other cities? I've previously not been a big fan of those, but in this particular case, particularly your argument about the loading zone, makes a big, big difference, because you're right about people stepping out of cars, trucks double parked, I mean, all that kind of stuff. But by having something like, yeah, like you see here, well, we don't have 11 feet on the sidewalk, unfortunately, I don't think, not everywhere anyhow. But we could have, if we narrowed the buffer space, I think you got like tulips growing here, something between the curb and the traffic,
[Jared Powell]: Treat that as paint. That's just a limitation of the tool itself. I was imagining that was paint and maybe a bollard if appropriate.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: If that's gore striping or something of that nature, then effectively it means you've got five feet worth of bike lane to the right of parked cars plus shy space onto the sidewalk. which is one of my big objections about, about three feet of a bike lane is insufficient. I can't support that. That's just not enough.
[Jared Powell]: Right. So, so for, so for clarity in this design, this is kind of like, yeah, the, the tulips here, you know, in Cambridge, maybe they would put in like an actual curve. I was envisioning this as like the Gore painting, like maybe with a bollard and maybe this is four, maybe this is one, but like more or less, this is like five feet to the right of a car. Not ideal, but we do also know that like passenger doors are opened far less frequently than driver's side doors on the same level or elevated.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Well, it's important.
[Jared Powell]: I understand. I understand Bruce. And I have different, I have different scenarios here, but my first parameter was to try to figure out what could be done at road level within the constraints that we have, which is. We don't want to spend more money moving the curbs. Right. So like. If they're willing to play with the curbs, just like you're talking about, like moving them in in particular. Yes. I think you get a lot more flexibility. This is like, what can we do with what is here? Right. And this is basically what we can get moving.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: The curbs was on the table for this project.
[Jared Powell]: In the meeting, they specifically said that moving the curbs, well, moving them in, I don't think even came up. Moving them out was the thing. Moving them out toward the train tracks was the sidewalk to take up some of that sidewalk.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, they said they thought they could get like... It's hard to believe it's not negotiable.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, they thought they could maybe get like six inches or maybe a foot or something with like minor stuff that they were doing there. But like, this is kind of. This is basically what can fit with the space that they have. I like keeping parking on the North side. Let me tell you why, if you get rid of this, obviously you get a much more comfortable, nice space and you get like bike lanes that are as wide as can be. And everybody's going to love it. The reason I kept the parking lane here. is because I want to be very careful about, I mean, first of all, this is just a design exercise, but I want to be very careful about avoiding fights that we don't need to take and making sure that this is like winnable. I know people like parking. It doesn't look like Tufts is handing over 25 spots to T employees, which would really be the ideal thing because I think that's what half of the parking on that block actually is. It's T employees. So yeah, Tufts could just hand over some parking to those folks and call it a day and we'd probably be in pretty good shape. But I don't know if they're going to do that. Either way, keeping the parking here avoids people fighting us on that issue. It avoids us being the anti-parking people and I'm fairly agnostic on it. I just want it to be safe for cycling. I don't really care if there's parking or not, like in an abstract sense. But the benefit of parking here. is also that it really keeps these lanes really tight, right? Like that is its own very effective traffic calming measure. People cannot drive 50 miles an hour down a street when they're within three feet of a parked car. No one wants to lose their side mirror. So I imagine, I see something like this. It sounds very appealing to me. Like, yeah, I'd like this to be wider than five feet when it's next to a car. But I feel like I could ride in this like fairly comfortably and Somerville has been installing lanes very much like this around the city. That I ride in with some frequency, like Elm street now has one pretty much exactly like this. This is very much like what is on powder house. It's imperfect, but it's pretty nice to ride on quite frankly. And this avoids pissing off the people who don't want to lose parking. It gets us a safe, I think. Arguably almost flagship type thing for Medford. Uh, not, not perfect. And I do have some alternate designs here that paid more, that basically ignored where the curbs are and just said like, here is the total width that was in the diagram that Tufts provided, you know, the 70 or whatever feet. And if you just take it that way and you ignore where the sidewalks and the curbs are more or less, and you treat those as flexible. Well, then you can honestly fit in like anything you want and make something more like on Beacon and Somerville and get Lanes up on at the sidewalk level, like you were describing Bruce, like, that is very achievable within this width, but it requires moving things around a bit.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Important here is because of it's just paint. My experience has been that. Just like, we fear people park into the bike lane when there's only 7 feet. If it's on the other side of the cars. They're even more inclined to park in the bike lane, which means that now, instead of having a minimum of 4 feet, you got 2 feet to squeeze by a car in the curb. This has happened to be on. Uh, what's the road not college Avenue? Um. And zeal square from Davis square Avenue. Holland Avenue westbound there, there's not a lot of protection and sometimes cars will encroach in that area. And I haven't had a chance to do the one on Powder House, but it looks to me like it suffers the same design.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, you can get by that by having designated spaces with flex posts at the front part of the car where you're not going to open a door into it, but you can at least like, hey, if I'm parking in the
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: But if they're going to move the curbs anyway, if they have the opportunity to move the curb, they should. That was the point. If they're going to reconstruct the sidewalks and reset the curbs, what does it matter if they reset them 5 feet out from where they were?
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Sorry, Emily, you've got to give it up for a while. Why don't you jump in?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Just a quick question here. My guess is that if the parking moves in, they're probably going to require an extra foot for the double yellow line in between those two, just to allow bigger vehicles to pass each other. I'm guessing that the minimum we could get away with Would probably be a 10 foot and an 11 foot, which would account for that double yellow. And that might still even work if even without even if this is at street level, because if they really think they can get it up to like 44 and a half feet, then that would be fine. I'm also. If we do go with something like this, I would say that we need to ask for daylighting with like a whole bunch of big old bollards at the driveway entrance with regards, because speaking of what you were talking about with the deliveries and everything. What often happens with the parking protected ones is the actual parking spaces end with a daylight zone before the driveways so that you can see and not get right hooked, but then people park there anyway. And so we need to really specify that there has to be a substantial amount of protection to make sure that that doesn't happen, because with the deliveries and the drop-offs, that's going to be a problem.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: But pulling into the garage.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, no, but if there's a daylighting spot at the end, so, like, a row of parked cars, and then the garage driveway. If cars are parked right up to the garage driveway, then you have right hooks with the cyclists and the cars, because they're out of sight of each other right up until that moment. And so that's like daylighting at crosswalks. And a lot of times at crosswalks, you'll get the striped, no parking, but then people park there anyway, in which case you get that visibility issue. And so if we're going to rely on that visibility on that daylighting where there's essentially one spot. worth blocked off at the end of the parking area, then it needs to have bollards in it to keep people out of it. Otherwise, you get that no visibility. I'm also wondering if this is something that we want to talk about too.
It's maybe a little bit redundant, but I think we can also recommend a configuration like this, And sharrows in the travel lane as well and have signage that makes it clear that bicyclists are perfectly allowed to choose which facility they want to use. And the reason that I think that could be important is especially as more people use ebikes that are fast. Ideally, we would want for the slower people to be able to use that protected bike lane that's small and narrow without being run down by like people on e-bikes that are fast and even a close a class one e-bike. Is fast and there's somebody writing it gets pretty impatient about passing somebody on like, for example, a pedal powered cargo bike or or somebody who's slow and nervous. So I think it really is important if we can make it clear that a cyclist is free to choose. Whichever one makes sense for what they're doing, I think that's another way to really decrease the amount of friction here.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Point of information is, I can't quite tell from the construction that I see on Google Street View, are there projected to be garage entrances into the dormitories for utility vehicles or parking or Anything? No.
[Jeremy Martin]: All of the loading is behind the building.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: The white areas that I see are primarily to indicate lobby entrance?
[Jeremy Martin]: I assume so, but I can't say.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: It does raise the question of folks traveling, I guess that's what westbound towards Winthrop Street. If they're trying to get to the dorm, presumably, I think there's another crosswalk.
[Jeremy Martin]: There is going to be a crosswalk added at university that's not there now. Yeah, and there's some daylighting proposed. I'm not sure if that's quite the right term, but a widening of the space at the crosswalk that exists in front of the parking garage.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Will it be a raised crosswalk?
[Jeremy Martin]: It will not be, but it will have signaled. flashers. I had advocated for speed humps in the street and the response I got from Rocco relayed that he had heard from Todd that Todd did not support the raised or raised crosswalk or speed humps because he thought it would be detrimental to the MBTA soil nails and I don't think that's founded in anything just some context for it.
[Jared Powell]: What was that for? Soil nails?
[Jeremy Martin]: Yeah, so there's a big retaining wall that holds up that entire street section and it's got deep nails that extend into the ground. They're anchors. Horizontally. And Todd was concerned that vibration from speed dumps would Dislodges nails. I don't see how you can make that clear.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: You don't want to get that as bad. A building collapsing into a construction site?
[Jeremy Martin]: Yeah. The two years of construction and heavy trenching and all of the activity that's happened around there would have surely done something much more than a bus going over a speed hump. But anyway, that's an aside.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Especially if they slow down.
[Jeremy Martin]: Right. The whole point is to slow them down. Zachary, you want to add something?
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: Um, yeah, I had wanted to chime in with with the design that proposes the 3 foot. separated bike lane sidewalk level or not. I know the Elm Street bike lanes get pretty narrow at points. I don't think they get quite down to three feet with a two-foot buffer narrow. It's possible they're four feet with a one-foot buffer, which is still the same amount of space at a few points, but I think they're generally that minimum five or sorry, minimum six total feet that I was talking about in the chat. I'm tempted to, if I have time, go measure on the street sometime at a narrow point.
I also want to note, Emily was noting, like, people have e-bikes they go fast on or just like fast cyclists go fast. um we needed if if this were to be sidewalk level like yes that's more room for cyclists but because cyclists are gonna you wouldn't want to assume cyclists are going to be unable to use that room you'd want to discourage that because they're going to be pedestrians there um so i don't think i i think that i if the group is going to put forth like support for a design with unprotected doors on bike lanes, then I think the three foot bike lane is just as flawed, but in a different direction. And I'd like to see it put forth as well, just to like push the idea of like, can we do something there? But I think that you either end up compromising bike safety or compromise pedestrian safety to really make that happen.
I wanted to, on the point about day lighting, I think the group should push for daylighting regardless of the bike lane configuration because, I mean, it's out of the scope of a bike committee, but if there are pedestrians crossing that garage driveway when someone's turning in, you still need that daylighting zone so someone who's about to make the turn can see that there's a pedestrian walking into the driveway before they have a chance, before they're too close to stop before hitting the pedestrian.
I know this is a bike group, not a pedestrian group, but daylighting is just as important for that. If you're advocating for that, even if you don't get the bike lane now, then at least that clear zone is already established in the design.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I think there was some discussion of that already. I think it's mostly that, especially if we're looking at a parking protected bike lane, the daylighting becomes even more critical because people in the driving lane don't necessarily realize that there's somebody over there, whereas they at least know that there might be somebody on the sidewalk. The daylighting is really important either way. Yeah, absolutely. But the point is that I think it really needs to have a whole bunch of bollards in it because if it's just paint, then it's not daylight.
And I guess if it were up to me, the choice of a door zone bike lane against a curb versus a door zone bike lane against a 10 foot travel lane, at least the curb doesn't have 10 foot buses going by.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Actually, they're only eight and a half, Emily. I look that up to see because I thought 10 foot and 10 foot lanes would make it very difficult for two buses to pass, but they're only eight and a half feet.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: 30 and a half, but when you, when you center it in the lane, you end up with a pretty narrow market.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Right at least the bus drivers know how to pass each other. I mean, I'm. That was my concern that not so if we had the, if we had the lanes outside the parking.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, so I guess what this comes down to is, is there something here that we'd be wanting to propose? I think the categories that are coming out here are, one, it's eliminating parking. I think, Jared, you put it pretty well, that if that's something that's going to be floated, take it off the north side and keep parking on the south side. So that is one scenario that would give us protected bike lanes in both directions. Probably the probably the best scenario for a bike safety perspective. The other 1 that like, like, like this Chris, like, like, you're like.
[Jared Powell]: I have on the screen here. Yep.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yep. Yeah. The assuming that that's the, we're looking towards college out. The other scenario that ended up actually maybe being the best of all scenarios, depending on how you cut it is. The sidewalk level bike lanes. Um, where you take some of the sidewalk. Um, I, the only thing is, I don't know how this. How this gets divided up if you're trying to maintain. X feet for for tree plantings and. if you need what the minimum widths are and does that mean you have to move curbs on both sides because you're taking a little bit from the T side and you're taking a little bit from the other side and is that width of what we're seeing here, the cross section, is that only in front of the dorms or does that persist all the way down up to College Ave?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Well, there's basically one, um, I think there's about five feet less space between university and Winthrop. Oh, you're talking about the other direction. Sorry.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Well, I guess, I guess this would be, you get your, your tree planting with here, and then that disappears after the dorms in your back down to your sidewalk with Jeremy, you can, you can, uh, I just, um,
[Jeremy Martin]: Are you talking about taking the curbs and shifting them in board of where they are now on both sides of the street to create a sidewalk level bike lane? I think a few things that might undermine that approach are the transitions to go from what will likely be either no bike lane to the West or door zone bike lane to then shift all the way over onto the sidewalk. I think those transitions are going to take up a lot of parking. I think the city will object to that and it would only work in front of the dorm. It won't fit in front of the T station because there are turn lanes there and pull off lanes.
And I just think it's a very limited section that can't really be extrapolated to other sections of the street, whereas other solutions that are in the street profile at street level would.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That would happen with any protected bike lane. You'd have to have that transition take place.
[Jeremy Martin]: I agree, but I think the transition would be more extreme If you're going from the sidewalk, but I hear you, Bruce, it does have to happen anywhere.
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: Whether it's on the sidewalk or on the street level, it's the same shift over.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Since we're talking about transitions, do we have thoughts about how this transitions to the intersection at Boston and College? if you're heading towards Somerville. One question I have is at the moment, if you use the travel lane and you're gonna wait for the red light and not just ride through on the pedestrian signal, then you need to be in the left lane at the intersection. And that's a little bit hard to do from a protected bike lane on the right-hand side if you don't have a protected phase of that light
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: At the intersection, and if you're left during the college Avenue or continue on Boston Avenue.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Right.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And so. so if you so my and my concern there is yeah we are still providing for the ability to use either the travel lane or the bike lane but somebody who doesn't know the area and doesn't know a block and a half ahead of time that their life will be easier at college ave if they get into the travel lane instead of the bike lane Is now going to get to the intersection and be like, well, shoot, what do I do now? So, I think in that case, we need to. Advocate if we go with the protected bike lane method, then we need to advocate for a method along with it. for how you get people through that intersection if they're not just turning right onto College Ave. And maybe it is that we just ask for allowing cyclists to use the pedestrian signal. I think because of the configuration, I've tried to figure out how you could make the left turn box thing work. But because basically two of the possible movements in that intersection are essentially left turns, That's kind of hard. There's not really a great way to do it. And someone who needed to make a left onto college would then have to make like a three stage. left turn, and there wouldn't be really a lot of place to do that. So that I think is complicated if you don't have a good way of getting to that left turn.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: The bike lane ends, it looks to me, a good 500 feet, if not more. I haven't actually measured it yet, in order for there to be the right turn lane. So parking is discontinued, and let me measure that precisely to see where that happens.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah, I'm just concerned about how is somebody supposed to get.
[Jared Powell]: How about a really large bike box at the end of this bike lane? You can speed into that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: 300 feet. So 300 feet before the intersection, the parking lane disappears. And that would mean that you're right, Emily, you would need to know to merge across what's going to become the right turn lane to get to the center. Which, of course, many bicyclists are uncomfortable doing anyhow.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, I mean, you and I do it, but in which case you cross with the pedestrian signal.
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: No, but what you're saying, there's the design they use elsewhere. There's a green area at the front of the queuing. Yeah, of the bikes coming on the side and get in the bike box.
[Unidentified]: Yeah, does that really work?
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: It's, I mean, if we're saying if drivers don't drive in it, that also rules out the unprotected bike lanes. Like when drivers don't drive in it, yeah, it's a good way to get into the left turn lane without having to merge into the multi-lane.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And it only works when there's a stoplight and when it stops traffic, because you can't, you can't arbitrarily pull into the left turn box in the middle of traffic. You got to wait.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah, if you get there and the light is red and everybody stopped behind the stop line, then you can use the bike box. If you get there when the light is green, I'm not sure what you do. You just, although I guess in that case, you're to stop. Yeah.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And then at some point proceed to the left.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Now you're at this, at that point, you're to the left of the right turn lane. So you just have to stop and wait.
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: Someone who's comfortable turning left from the left turn lane. could be just riding in the mixed traffic lane and not using the protected bike lane. Someone who's not comfortable doing that maneuver can wait and then cross on the pedestrian signal, which is the closest you can do to a two-faced left.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: My only concern with that though, I know that most of us would be, we know that area and we would be able to make that decision. but we're talking about somebody having to decide whether to use the travel lane or that protected bike lane way back by University Ave. And if you don't know the area, and if you don't know the intersection, you don't know at that point, and you can't even see the intersection yet. You don't know at that point that this is where you have to make the decision and it's too soon.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: In fact, you don't know until the bicycle infrastructure totally disappears and the right turn takes over.
[CAS00002535_SPEAKER_05]: You're right, but I'm saying someone who's unfamiliar with this is also less likely to be comfortable merging across the lanes of traffic to turn left from the mixed traffic lane versus... I disagree with that.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I would disagree with that. I'm thinking of somebody who lives in JP and bikes all the time, and they just happen to be visiting somebody in Medford. They are, you know, they're, they're not any more or less comfortable on a bike than anybody else or in traffic than anybody else. And they might be more comfortable and they might be less. But the point is that they don't. They don't live here, so they don't know this road.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I find when I'm in a different area. I sometimes have to change my behavior because exactly this reason. I don't know several things I don't know. I don't know the habits of the intersection. I don't know the configuration of the intersection. And I often find myself needing to take a take a box turn for exactly that reason. Because by the time I realized I should have been over to the left, I can't get there. And my only choice is to make a box turn rather than a vehicular left turn.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And I feel like this is something that I run into when I use bike paths and multi-use paths a lot in areas that I don't know exactly like the back of my hand. And this is why I'm like, this is why I keep making a stink about wayfinding signage with DCR. is that a lot of this stuff is great if you're in your neighborhood and you know exactly which curb cut you need to take when to be where you need to be to be able to do the really useful thing that means you don't have to be in traffic. But if it's not where you live, then it's really opaque. It's just there's no help for you if you don't already know where you're going.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: What solution would you have here? Because I can't think of one.
[Jared Powell]: It really sounds like you guys are unintentionally advocating for like the removal of all infrastructure because some intersections are going to be complicated. And I don't think that's what we want to add to it.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: That's not what I'm getting from Emily and Bruce.
[Jared Powell]: What I think we need to do here, and I know it's not exactly in this proposal, but it will come up soon.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: is we need to advocate for signage that allows bicyclists to use the pedestrian signal. And for a couple of reasons, one, it's easier and it's more comfortable. Two, that's what they do anyway because it's easier and more comfortable.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: To proceed on pedestrian, just to be clear, you mean to proceed on the pedestrian phase, which is technically illegal unless authorized.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: HAB-Juliette Boone, COB.: : Right, yeah, just to authorize that they do that because they do it anyway for perfectly understandable reasons.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: HAB-Danny Teodoru, COB.: : And that can be part of this. HAB-Juliette Boone, COB.:
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: : And that's, and that's the easiest way to fix this.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: HAB-Danny Teodoru, COB.: : What I'm what I'm seeing. HAB-Danny Teodoru, COB.: : The street view is is I think they're To me, there's a way to transition this involved directions. If you're doing a parking protected by plane. Yeah, this is the current and this is now. Reconstruction, but parking ends here. If you guys can see my screen parking ends. Here, I have no idea what that distance is to the light. That is 300 feet. Yeah, and you see that the. The right hand turn lane essentially starts kind of right after.
[Jeremy Martin]: This car, that's a, that's a bus stop, Chris, sorry to interrupt, but that that's actually a relatively new photo there because they just moved this bus stop. Oh, no kidding.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: The bus stop is now here, you're saying?
[Jeremy Martin]: It is, yeah. It starts, you can see the sign, the two signs. Oh yeah, I thought it was around the corner.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Interesting.
[Jeremy Martin]: There is also one around the corner, but this one is more in front of the parking garage.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That gives more daylight space without taking away a parking space. I mean, the bus is only there sometimes.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, yeah, I mean, it is, it is, in some ways, you get more daylighting, but also it means that you do need to figure out how the cyclist can navigate around it when a bike, when a bus is stopped, are able to. And so, yeah, that is the right decision. Those of us will always agree to do that. Yeah, to me, that's not a showstopper for that design approach. That there is transition time here, too. If you want to get into that left-hand lane, there's time to do it safely. And honestly, a lot of the time here, if it's a green light, then, like, yeah, you got cars going, but the majority of time when you're coming here, it's going to be a red light. You've got some time to get over. Um, I actually, I like the idea of continuing this up to the light. And then having it be an easier clear way to do right. The opposite direction, what I'm seeing is. You know, there is a sort of built in area where you can do the transition.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, I think what sounds a lot easier.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, I mean, you keep these this, I. You keep these parking spots, you keep this little loading zone here. Oops. Um. I'll just zoom in. But yeah, there's there's enough room to transition whether or not you need to take out a parking spot for daylighting, but it just transitions into this. This would be swap it right parking and bike. It would be really nice to have. I actually I think I'm I don't know if the widths work. I like the sidewalk level as the best because I think it probably ends up being more efficient space-wise. I think it'd be a pain. Ideally, you'd push all this infrastructure back up a foot maybe and have a nicer paved sidewalk where you could actually use the full width all along here because the sidewalk's kind of a disaster.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Could we suggest the sidewalk level one on this side and the street level one on the other side?
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Possibly, I think my biggest concern about the, and I think we got to circle back to, like, what is it that we can ultimately get behind? I think. I do worry that the, the sort of. 3, you know, a net 5 foot, but 3, 2. Is kind of narrow and and I do think it's a fair point that you need to, you need to design in a way that cars cannot encroach on that in that space. 5 is already. Paper thin, um, and is that going to be safe enough? Because car doors can open 3 to 4 feet. You know, 2 feet is nice, but like, um, and especially if you're, if you're not at sidewalk level, a door opens, like, you're kind of screwed. Um, in that scenario, and we are, you know, big cargo bikes take up a lot more width. There's a lot of them in town now. I ride one, especially the big front baskets. Like that's an entire, you know, the width of your lane pretty much.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Oh, mine can absolutely be more than three feet.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah. So I do worry that that could, you know, and I've got the trailer on the back of the bike. That's pretty much three feet. So it is a little dicey.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah. Chris, can I say something on that one point? I'm with you. I like the sidewalk. Well, I like the sidewalk level ones too. I feel personally like less sure about the cost implications of that. Like, and that's, that's something that like, I don't feel like I understand here. Right. Like, cause part of what I was suggesting and like this kind of like designs that I was coming up with was like, these are things that aren't really going to cost anything extra. Right. Like, but like, as soon as we start moving curbs and like putting things on, on the sidewalk level that I like a lot, like I like those sites, those sorts of lanes. I don't know if that then becomes a reason for Tufts to be like, Oh, absolutely not. This adds like, you know, $750,000 to our costs, whatever that is, you know? And, and then they get to say no because of that. That is a complete unknown to me. So if that's not like a deal breaker for this, then like, cool, let's do, let's do stuff like that.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Yeah. I'd like to see it in Florida for sure.
[Jared Powell]: Gary. Yeah, yeah. Um, I also don't know. Specifically, like, what design limitations there are on those sidewalk level lanes as well. Like. Do they require, like, like, they can't be right on the curb. So there's usually, like, a foot. To between the curb and the lane, and then usually, like, a little bit of a space, you know, like, to kind of discourage. Pedestrian, so I just wasn't really sure how much more space those might end up taking up in effect. So, just to put that out there as a, as an unknown on my end.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Jeremy, why don't you jump in?
[Jeremy Martin]: Sure. I just want to remind everyone that the entire stretch that we're talking about here is not in the scope of Tufts project. If you all are proposing something that can only be completed in part of it and not the entire stretch, that that is going to be a real challenge. Even if the transitions, well, the scope doesn't include all the way To this to the intersection, it doesn't include all the way to the T station either. It stops. Yeah, remind us where that stops. I can pull up something on if I can share my screen, but they will eventually get back to the part that does include the.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: The intersection that's just not what this particular plan is about.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, it's a good point because, like, you can't you can't do a parking protected lane that. It's like, well, we're not going to do consumer. I can do anything beyond this point.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And maybe this is just a thing that we know that they're not going to deal with the intersection at this meeting. But it needs to, we need to be including it in our recommendation so that. when it does come up, it's not the first they've heard about it. I think we want to make sure that they know that we've taken those transitions into account and that we have a plan for that and that we've thought about it. Also, if we're going to ask for allowing bicyclists to use the pedestrian signal, for example, that it isn't a surprise the first time they hear about it.
[Jeremy Martin]: It's a good suggestion.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: So that spot on the right there, Jeremy, is that the garage? That building?
[Jeremy Martin]: This is the garage, yep. And this is the footprints to the other two buildings.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yes, up to the crosswalk or just past the crosswalk.
[Jeremy Martin]: More or less. It extends a little further on the north side. And I have another drawing that I can pull up that shows that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: But I guess what I'm getting... Blow that up again, because I thought that shows a separated bike lane.
[Jeremy Martin]: It does, it removes carpet.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Go to the right of the transition. I want to see how they propose at that point to do the transition. What are you talking about on this end, Bruce? Yeah, all the way to this end. So take a look at what they're doing here. They are shunting the bike lane from adjacent to the travel lane to the right, just like we proposed, except further upstream.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: So they're maintaining parking further east.
[Jeremy Martin]: Yeah, so I don't, I don't see the limitation of their scope.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Right? So this isn't a problem because. They would transition right here where it says 4 spaces removed. To the outer bike lane, just like, yeah, just like they're doing here.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: But this looks like they've this looks like they've removed parking along this whole stretch to make room for those protected bike lanes, right?
[Jeremy Martin]: On the North side. They have yes, this maintains the parking lane on the South side, but the transition is similar.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: It's not almost identical.
[Unidentified]: Yeah.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, this is what's the situation here?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: My point is that we were concerned about whether. This new proposal would be at odds with the fact that we can't do it along the whole stretch. And although it's a slightly awkward transition, it does look like it's feasible.
[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, 100%. Yeah.
[Jeremy Martin]: Yeah, I, I'm speaking more specifically to moving the curves and it still may well be feasible because the transitions are not different, but. the city may object to moving curbs for just one section of the street and not the entirety of this block to block. I don't know. My sense is that the city is not going to support a sidewalk level bike lane.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Go ahead. Back to get to a concrete suggestion. Jared, if you pull up the parking protected on both sides that you had. Just to get back to a concrete suggestion, I wonder if we can basically ask for that configuration that you showed with the bike lane being at sidewalk height and if they're not willing to move the curb just on the north side. And if they're not willing to do that, then have that configuration with it being at street level.
[Jared Powell]: And I think on the- So this, but you're saying put this at sidewalk level?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I don't see it yet.
[Jared Powell]: Oh, sorry. I selected the window and then didn't hit share.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: There we go.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, basically- You're talking about this one parking both sides and put this on the sidewalk level?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: put the one on the north side on the sidewalk level and the one on the south side where the dorm building is at street level. And if they say no to moving the curbs, then we just fall back on this.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I'm kind of arriving at a different place, because what I saw from Jeremy there, to me, that's the best case scenario.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Right, but that removes parking, and that sounds like that's, if we think that's off the table, then.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I mean, I think it's, and I'm gonna, Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His): Speculate a little bit here, but Jeremy, you said that you think it was Todd. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : Who's coming down on no removal parking and that's quite possible. I think if that's the case, it's probably because that sort of Todd's directive. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : And because it's it's just kind of contentious thing. And that's where I think we come back to strategy. If that's the appropriate design for safety and it has said we have to remove parking as a result, then then that's what I think we should advocate for. And look, if we say like, look, we agree that this design is also acceptable, then put that in there as well. But ultimately we want to get to a design that is going to be safe for cyclists now and future and the 660 kids that are going to be, many of whom are going to be biking around when they come into that dorm. And so I think Tufts has a vested interest in this as well.
To me, that's a design that is the safest removing parking. And if the barrier is, if the city is not allowing it, well, then that's why that's where the strategy comes in. Like, we need to go to the city with. You know, this is our proposal and not just us, but here are the other. Groups and advocates who also feel strongly about this. So this is not just us doing it alone. But we're getting the support of other groups. We're also. We're talking to the city about how this is in the complete street policy that you've adopted that every street be redesigned with best practices to ensure safety. And the way that it's currently proposed is not that way. So let's go back to what was proposed before.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Point of order, it's 9 o'clock, 902. And we should probably figure out how to come to a conclusion on this.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And we recommend that what we like best is what Jeremy showed a second ago, which removes parking, but gives us a protected bike lane on both sides. And if it's not possible to remove the parking, then the parking protected option is our preferred fallback.
[Jeremy Martin]: May I ask, does this group not support a parking protected lane on the south side? in a shared lane with parking on the north side in the case that parking cannot be removed? Because I think Zach made a point earlier that that seven foot lane can very easily parking.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'd like to be warned that we not support such a hybrid configuration.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I think the consensus is that, I think the consensus is probably a no on that one.
[Jeremy Martin]: And does that take into consideration that there are shared lanes that will almost certainly be continuous in either direction for that lane on Boston Avenue?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: There's a motion on the floor, by the way.
[Jeremy Martin]: My mistake.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Sorry, I didn't catch that. I didn't catch that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I moved that we vote not to support the hybrid approach of protected on one side and shared on the other.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah. I mean, I think it's, it's a, uh, Jeremy, you're, it's a fair point and a fair question for sure. I mean, I think for me, part of it becomes a question of like precedent, right? Like in this case, we have enough space for something good. Right. I think, I think we do. Um, whether that keeps parking on the north side or not. Um, I think we have the space for something good. I don't want in general. Our opportunities for something good to get limited by. The mediocre to poor pre existing conditions that exist in other places in the city. Because that's what we have a lot of, right? And so like, that's why in this particular case, if there's room to fit something better, I think we should take it because then that applies pressure in the reverse to make it so that maybe in the future we can think creatively and find some way to replace the sharrows. that exist on either side of this stretch with something better, because we say, Hey, look, people like this new stuff. It works well. Let's do more of that rather than more of the sharrows. It's like, that's kind of, that's kind of how I'm coming to it. Like for the same reason why, like the designs they're talking about it, like the Craddock bridge where they're redoing like South and Maine, like MassDOT came in and came up with a new design. that in my opinion had far too much of a car focus. Well, one of the justifications that they used for that was that, well, there's a lot of car lanes on like both sides of it. Whereas if we had made something better on both sides of it, then they probably would have felt pressure to make something more cycling focused and part of their design. So that's kind of my goal, like to kickstart a slightly more virtuous cycle, even if it, Even if we know it doesn't create like a full contiguous network, like I know I wish it did, but I know it doesn't.
[Jeremy Martin]: I appreciate that, Jared. And I just want to say that since the beginning of this process, I've advocated for something more virtuous and forward-looking than conforming to the existing. I know.
[Jared Powell]: We're so appreciative.
[Jeremy Martin]: We really are. But I think just from the terms of what people expect when they're on the street at the current condition, they expect to be in the lane. And Emily convinced me a month ago that a protected lane on one side and a very well-marked shared lane on the other side is better than two doors on bike lanes for sure. And I will just say that I am not confident that, um, that a sidewalk level lane or some other configuration will be considered seriously by the city at this point.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Jeremy, what do you think about what's on the screen right now?
[Jeremy Martin]: I don't think the dimensions work, do they? This adds up to 46 feet.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Or the version of it that doesn't.
[Jeremy Martin]: 40, 40, 44. I think I think it changed since I added did the math a moment ago. My experience with those 2 foot buffers next to 3 foot lanes is that the bollard often gets placed in the middle of that 2 foot buffer and cars parked tight to the bollard and hang into that 3 foot lane and it feels very narrow. It's true. I see that quite a bit, even on even on the 5 foot lanes on powder house, those cars parking to the striping and the lane. Feels narrow, so I think it is paper thin as someone described. I think it's better than what's currently on the table though. Let me say that. So.
I also just strategically know that Tufts, I have maybe faultily have advocated for a different condition and Tufts is now moving in that direction. And there's still an opportunity to influence that outcome, but the traffic commission is going to be evaluating what Tufts is proposing. This body should promote and support whatever scenario you feel is best, but it's gonna require someone on the Tufts engineering team to draw that and propose it. And if they don't support it, the traffic commission cannot force them to do it. So I just hope that the strategy takes into account the real mechanics of that traffic commission review to get something that doesn't just end up reverting back to unprotected lanes.
So I support reaching beyond with knowing that the fallback is something that's better than what's there now, that gives us the opportunity to get to something even better in the future.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Thank you, Jeremy.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Point of order, please. I've had a motion on the floor without a second for some time, so either I need a second or I need to withdraw the motion.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I was waiting for Jared to second it.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I probably want to have a discussion before I second it.
[Jared Powell]: Can I, I'd like to, I, I'm inclined to 2nd at Bruce, but I have a question for Jeremy 1st. Which is Jeremy, you said you thought. The city would be uninclined to support a sidewalk level. Bike lane, I think, like, Emily had suggested, like, for something like in the. In the picture here, putting the North side on the sidewalk, just to kind of get some more vertical separation as well. Could you explain what you mean by expecting resistance on that?
[Jeremy Martin]: Sure. Well, I think the first point of it is that Tufts would have to adopt it as well and make it a part of their proposal. But it is a, from my experience, an uncommon condition in Medford. And I see it many other places, the sidewalk level lane, On beacon street has a 2 or 3 foot buffer before you get to the parking next to it. I don't think we have the dimension here to do that.
You're sort of trading the door zone in the street for a door zone on the sidewalk. If you don't these are my personal feelings. So maybe not fully answering your question, Jared, but I think ultimately it's. It's unfamiliar it's. there will likely be questions about the MBTA review of that proposal, because this does go through the MBTA zone of influence. And I think that, I suspect that it's such a radical change from anything that's been presented so far that it may be seen as going too far beyond what people are familiar with.
[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, thank you for clarifying.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, I mean, I think there's a strategy element and Bruce, I think we've got to get back here. There's a strategy element here too, and I think this is ultimately the most important thing. How are we going to get any of this done? Tufts has to draft the plans, but they also have to draft plans that they think the city is going to approve. And so we need some confidence that there's going to be a sort of political will to implement something and, you know, anything that sort of. Doesn't require massive construction or removal of parking is going to be an easy. You know, sail through the traffic commission, but that all those solutions, um, maybe with the exception of the protected bike lane option, but the 2 to 3 on either side, all of those options are not not ideal for us. So then we're like, okay, if we're going to take out parking, we need the political will and Tufts is going to be a little reticent to design that up because they've already got that knocked down. So we need to get through. We need some affirmative from the city and that's probably that's the strategy of going. To the mayor and getting her to directly down to Todd that it's acceptable to to remove parking. Um, which I, I still think it's important. I still think we. We should voice that to the mayor. Even if we don't get that outcome, and I think it's important for us and not just us, but with a coalition. For us to say that look, mayor, there is. there is desire from your constituents for this to happen. And even if it doesn't happen now, we're starting to sound that alarm. And I was hoping that this would be our project to start shifting the status quo, as you suggested, Jared. And even if we don't win this battle, it's important for that voice to be heard. Um, so I still think that's an important strategy, but specifically for here, if that doesn't happen, then what is the sort of best. Um, solution that we can proceed, I think. Um, there's a question about whether the.
The protected parking protected by claim is the best alternative or whether it's 1 of these others. I think we probably owe it to Bruce to get back to his motion here. I'm just going to say one more thing, which is that I could get behind fully protected lane on one side and sharrows on the other side if there are traffic calming measures like speed bumps, speed humps that ensure vehicular speed is reduced to something like 20 miles per quart. And then I think you're, you're in a much better, safer situation on that kind of a street. If you're sharing the way, so I. I'll caveat my thoughts on that.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Just before we get back to Bruce's motion. I was going to, and maybe this is maybe this is an expansion on that and you would withdraw it Bruce, but. I wonder if we should start by saying that number one, the 7510 configuration is unacceptable. Two, no bike lane at all is unacceptable, and that we're debating about right now, so that we can come back to. Three, here are solutions in order of preference. One is the top preferred solution is the Tufts plan that Jeremy just showed that removes parking and has protected bike lanes on both sides. Followed by protected bike lane or parking protected bike lanes on both sides like this cross section of where the north side is at sidewalk level and followed by what's actually what's on the screen right now and the justification there is that. At least if you have a door zone and a curb, at least the curb is not a moving bus. Whereas with the 7510, you have a door zone on one side and a moving bus on the other side.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And so I think- I want to clarify the dimension just so that, and I also wanted to keep the motion clean, but I wanted to clarify the dimensions because I couldn't make them work in my head. Uh, I think that's just changed or maybe basically, basically the, the question is. Do we want to endorse 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7. Which is sort of the current de facto, or do we want to endorse. The hybrid, but I don't know if the dimensions of that would be. Maybe if you can cite the dimensions, I can put that down here.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Well, I guess the first thing is, are we talking about the 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7, I think we should say is unacceptable. I think we could say if it's going to be protected bike lanes on both sides and we can't remove parking, then 5 bike lanes, 7 parking, 10, 10, 7, 5, we can, that's basically everything the same except the two, the bike lane and the parking lane are switched. And that's what Jared had put up on the screen a second ago.
[Jared Powell]: I just got 10 different options.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: The motion is comparing two very specific situations. I want to get that clear because if I really can't support the other side and if I'm overruled, then I'll stop complaining about it.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Which other side do you mean?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: So we are the one proposal, which is seven, five, 10, 10, five, seven, and some other proposal, which is a hybrid with protection on one side and share us on the other. But I don't know what the dimensions of those are. So I can't make a motion that is precise.
[Jeremy Martin]: I'd be happy to put it on the screen if that's helpful.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Are you saying that you don't like that dimension?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'm saying I don't know what the dimensions are.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Are you saying that you don't like the hybrid approach?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That's beside the point. The answer is yes, I don't, but that's not what the motion's about. The motion is to choose one or the other.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Would you mind just restating the motion?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I will as soon as I understand the dimensions. Gotcha. Jeremy, you want to pull that up?
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, Jared, if you don't mind switching over. Yeah, yeah.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay, so we're looking at a six foot and a three foot buffer. followed by a seven foot parking lane, and a 10 foot traffic lane and 11 foot shared lane, and then a seven foot parking lane. Is that correct?
[Jared Powell]: You must have access to the higher tier version of this, Jeremy, to allow you to get buffers and stuff like that. Cause I didn't have access to all of these.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: So I think I got it right. Six foot with a three foot buffer, seven feet, 10 feet, 11 feet, seven feet. And that, and that comes to 44 feet as well. Is that right? 21 and 14. Someone help me do the math here. Yeah, it's 44. Okay. Okay, so my specific motion is whether or not we prefer the hybrid approach, which is the 6, 3, 7, 10, 11, 7 over the dual bike lane approach, which is the 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7. That's my proposal.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I prefer the hybrid approach over the 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'm now looking for a 2nd on that proposal.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I'll 2nd that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay, so you're going to 2nd that.
[Jared Powell]: Sorry, we're only talking. We're only talking about those 2 things, the.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: For the purposes of this motion, yes, because I want to get it clarified so I can get it out of my head. Whether to continue to support 1 or the other, and that doesn't deal with these other. More dramatic proposals that we stated.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: All right, the motion is is a. It's a, which one do you support?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: So my, my motion is that we prefer the 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7, over the 6, 3, 7, 10, 11, 7.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: That's the opposite of what you just said a 2nd, last time.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Okay, so. Bruce, your motion is to or. The dual bike lane. And reject the hybrid.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yes, that's that's what I meant to say. Sorry.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: If I said the polarity wrong previously, then I, then I, then I don't, I don't second that 1. Yeah, because I, I think the, the, the dual doors on bike lane in between the 7 foot parking and the 10 foot travel is. Is a problem and I don't think we should ever recognize.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay, so then, then, then, all right, then I will reverse the polarity. Which you said you would 2nd, which is motion to. Approve that we prefer the hybrid over. The 7, 5, 10, 10, 5, 7, and that you would 2nd. The vote ends up being the same either way, but.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So in other words, prefer the hybrid over the status quo. Right.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: So if people vote yes on this motion, it means they prefer the hybrid over the status quo. That's correct.
[SPEAKER_08]: I don't.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Right. I understand. That's the question. That's why I'm putting it as a motion and I want to get a vote and we can put it to rest.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Did you second it?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: For now.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I did second it so we can vote now all in favor. I were preferring the hybrid over the status quo.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Oh, I'd like to do a voice vote, please.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Roll call vote just to clarify. Yes, is that we prefer the hybrid over the status?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That is correct.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: OK, then yes, roll call vote.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Emily votes yes. Jared.
[Jared Powell]: I'm going to abstain. I don't really understand the purpose of this vote.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Okay. I'm going to say no. Okay.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Chris? And Bruce? Bruce, no.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah. There's a motion, two no's, one abstain, one yes, motion fails.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'm gonna... Oh yeah, the motion failed, right?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Can I suggest that we make a list of things that we do prefer in order of preference?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I would second that motion. Yeah, I like that.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And my suggestion is that this is the order of preference. 1st, is the proposal that Jeremy showed that has parking removed and gives us protected. But that gives us buffered bike lanes on both sides.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I'll be out to that as I think we get it is going to be. More accommodation for the loading zone, but otherwise.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: With more accommodation for the loading zone 2nd. Second preference is the 5 bike lane, 7 parking, 10, 10, 7, 5, meaning the parking in the bike lane, they're reversed from the status quo, and that on the north side, that bike lane is at sidewalk level, meaning that the curb has to be moved on the north side. and that number three, in order of preference.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Emily, can you hold on a second? I think I mistyped here. Number one, what's number one again?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Number one is the proposal that Jeremy showed that has parking removed on one side, which is the Tufts design from before with the addition of loading spaces.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Is that what we previously called the 6, 3, 7, 10, 11, 12?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, it's the actual document that Jeremy showed that has Okay, because there and there is an engineering drawing for that already. Um, it's this.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay, the parking removed on on North side.
[Jared Powell]: The challenge the challenge of that 1, I think is that it's. I mean, it sounds like it's politically unpopular because it loses parking on the North side.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I mean, that's why that's why we ask for that. And we have 2 more after it.
[Jared Powell]: Right, right. Yeah, I'm just thinking through the decision tree here that.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That could be moved on the North side and what's on the South side.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Parking protected bike lane, but it's a parking protected bike lane that has, like, a much more comfortable amount of buffer.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, yeah, it's spacious. So, so hold on. So looking at this diagram, which one's North to the left.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Correct.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So, in order of preference, it would be.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Well, hold that up please so I can get those dimensions. I'm sorry, I'm sorry, but it's okay.
[Jeremy Martin]: And I, I can share this around as well after the meeting.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I need I need it for the minutes. Sorry for being pedantic about it. You're good.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Oh, we appreciate it because then we'll have it.
[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, we do. Doesn't that look nice? That looks nice.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Okay. So this is our preference number 1. Okay.
[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Preference number 2 is what Jared showed before, but with the bike lane on the north side at sidewalk height, meaning that the curb has to be moved on that side. But it's moving in, not out.
[Unidentified]: Clarify.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So starting from, if I'm starting from the South side, that's five foot bike lane at street level, seven foot parking lane at street level, 10, 10, seven foot parking. Yeah, this, but with the bike lane on the North side at sidewalk level.
[Jared Powell]: Remind me, Emily, why that, why on the, I mean, I know I like those, but why would we be arguing for that on the North side and not the South side?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Because on the south side, there's like much more loading area and a lot more pedestrians and a lot of more people coming in and out. And I'm thinking that if they're willing to move the curb in a little bit, but not by that much, especially in the interest of getting emergency vehicles through when there's, that is what everybody talks about all the time. It seems like a more reasonable in between. Um, and especially with the positions of where the trees are going to have to go. Um, so that would be preference. Number two would be this with the North side at sidewalk level and then preference number three.
[Jared Powell]: Sorry. I have one, one cab, one caveat. Emily is. If they were to, sorry, I think all these pop-ups, uh, if they were to put the North side up on the sidewalk level, it's not immediately obvious to me that that width would have to be limited. by three and two, it seems like it could be different.
[Unidentified]: I don't know.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I think we could include in that proposal that there could, part of why we like it is that there's a little bit more possible room for getting a little bit more than that five feet. And it also means that you get the whole five feet because people can't park in it.
[Jared Powell]: Right. So that way they can move it to fit the trees, that kind of thing.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah. So that would be that would be preference number two and preference number three would be basically what this looks like with the bike lanes on both sides at street level with the parking protected. And it's a three foot bike lane with a two foot buffer.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I think that's number four, actually.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, no, no. Because one was one was the remove some parking and get something and get. what we talked about. Two was the what was on the screen a second ago with the north side at sidewalk level and three is this with the north side at street level.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Maybe the question for the group here, is there anyone who feels that this scenario is less desirable than what's being proposed now with the 5-7, sorry, 7-5 and 10-5-7?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I like this better than what's being proposed now. Even if nothing can be at sidewalk level and all we can do is reverse the order of the parked cars and the bike lane, you get a door zone either way, but at least with the bike lane against the curb, you don't have the buses.
[Jared Powell]: It's a less frequent door zone too. There's less often passengers. There's always a driver. There's sometimes passengers.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: But we're not pretending that you actually have enough space to avoid both passing traffic and a door zone in five feet, which is not usually even really five feet. And I think also if we include, we should include emphasis on the sharrows in the travel lane in addition, which means that faster riders can feel allowed and comfortable and it's clear to everybody that they're allowed to be there and that you have a choice, which will then make that super narrow bike lane a little bit less fraught for somebody who is slower, because they won't have to have the super fast the faster people and the impatient people and the hurried people and the e-bikers and so forth. I think it also makes it a little easier when it gets a little snowy, when it gets obstructed. It just makes it more clear that it's uncomfortable that you can be in the travel lane instead and that you have the choice.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay. So Emily, there's three choices you're proposing as well as confirming the sharrows and the travel lanes.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: The chairs and the travel.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, I want to make sure I've got everything right. So I'm going to reread. I'm going to reread the motion with all these dimensions and keep in mind all of these measurements. Left to right correspond to north to south. Does that make sense to everybody as if we're being inbound? Okay, number 1. Parking removed on north side. With a five foot bicycle lane, two foot buffer, 11 foot travel lane, 11 foot travel lane, seven foot parking lane, two foot buffer, five and a half foot bike lane.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: That's number one.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, and I'm not sure that those dimensions are the same as these other dimensions, but I'm going to leave it at that. The second proposal is 5 foot bike lane, 7 foot parking lane, 10 foot travel lane, 10 foot travel lane, 7 foot parking lane, 5 foot bike lane.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: At sidewalk level.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: At sidewalk level, that is why I've got it wrong. Got it. Yes.
[Jeremy Martin]: Thank you. That last bike lane on sidewalk level on the South side of the street on the North side.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Wait, hang on.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I'm reading from left to right.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: I'm reading the proposal. So we have a straight. We don't have a confusion here. So I'm going to recite number 2 again. 5 foot bike lane, 7 foot parking lane, 10 foot travel lane, 10 foot travel lane, 7 foot parking lane, 5 foot bike lane at sidewalk level. Number 3.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And the sidewalk level 1 is on the north side.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Wait, that's what I've got for number 3.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, that was number three was all the bike lanes are at street level. Number two and number three are the same dimensions. Got it. And the only difference is that number two has one of the bike lanes at sidewalk level.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: North side at sidewalk level. Number three is 5, 7, 10, 10, 7, 5 at street level.
[Unidentified]: Yeah.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: All right. I think I've got it. There we go. Bike lane at street level. Bike lane at street level.
[Jared Powell]: We would get an A on a group project in school.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Okay.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And for options two and three, share rows and corresponding signage for the general travel lane.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yes.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay. That is the motion. Was there anything else that I missed on that motion? Jared?
[Jared Powell]: a suggestion for adding, which would be in response to a point that Zachary made earlier, which was that there be lots of bollards separating those bike lanes and potentially, if possible, putting those bollards outboard of the bike lane so that they're not dead in the middle, so that they don't end up interfering with the usable width of the bike lane. So they're closer to the cars than the bikes, essentially. Not centered in the zebra stripes.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: So you're proposing that that takes away space from the combined travel and parking lane?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: No, just that they end up being, that the bollards end up being on the left-hand edge of the buffer, not in the middle of the buffer.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Got it. Got it. Yeah.
[Jared Powell]: Is making suggestions about a bike box at Boston and college and. Go through that's outside of that's outside of our.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: We should make this motion. We can, I would suggest that we could include a mention of that in our letter that we write. Just to show that we've thought about it.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Ultimately, I think that, but the detail, those kind of details are the kind of things ultimately, like, who's our audience for what we're with this. I think there's the big ask is going to go to the city of Medford in terms of, I think the best solution here is limiting parking.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Emily, you made a, you made a subtle. A subtle distinction here between what I wrote down as your motion. And. the notion of the bollards. So I think what I didn't include in the motion is that the bike lanes are actually three feet with a two foot buffer.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yes, because that was, then let's amend that because that's what it said on the graphic and that's kind of real life, but then also include that the bollards should be on the left-hand edge, not in the middle of the buffer.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: That's where I got confused initially by, What you said, so that's two foot buffer. I'm using particular nomenclature here to indicate to me.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I think the detail stuff, I think that's the kind of thing we would want to have sent to the top.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I mean, that's true, but I think this kind of stuff is worth including, and I think it's worth While we're at it, just to be really clear about why we prefer this over the status quo and the fact that this is the same amount of space and it's just in a different position. Like, why does that matter? And the reason it matters is because. A curb can't sideswipe you.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay. And after we pass this motion, what does that mean that. Chris will write up a draft or write up a letter.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And we presented to, I actually have to run because Jake is meeting outside to meet me.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: We got to ask him for five minutes because I think we can get this vote done real soon.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah, can we can we do the vote though?
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yeah, yeah, okay. A real quick final reading. All measurements from the north side. Number one, parking removed on the north side as shown by Jeremy's thing, we'll have to resurrect that. 5 with a 2-foot buffer, 11-11-7, 2-foot buffer, 5.5. Number 2, 3-foot bike lane, 2-foot buffer, 7-foot parking lane, 10-foot travel, 10-foot travel, 7-foot parking, 2-foot buffer, 3-foot bike lane, north side bike lane at sidewalk level. And for brevity, same thing, but both bike lanes at street level. Note 2 and 3 propose sharrows and corresponding signage in single travel lane and bollards at left-hand edge of buffers.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I guess one, sorry, one, um, tweak would be that the one that has the bike lane at sidewalk level, the buffer is also at sidewalk level.
[Unidentified]: Okay.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: That's all.
[Jared Powell]: Um, did we last thing I would, sorry, last thing I would say is that these are minimum requirements. And if, for example, this should not, if, if more space is found to be available when they are adjusting the curbs, that extra space should go into the bike lane and not be used elsewhere.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Emily. Yeah, that's hard.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: So I motion I move that what Bruce just is the recommendation that we adopt.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And I second that.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And we and we include Jared's mentioned that if they find extra space, then we want it.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Let's call roll.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Yep. Hold on.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: In no particular order, Bruce, yes. Emily, yes.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: Jared, yes. Chris, yes. All right.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Motion passes. Motion passes.
[CAS00002510_SPEAKER_06]: All right, Emily.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I think that we create a working group to
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Okay, I'm going to wrap this up and get it sent.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Jeremy, if you can do something real quick here, because I want to do this motion before Emily has to jump.
[Jeremy Martin]: I can be very quick. I appreciate that this will go to the mayor and to perhaps the traffic commission as a recommendation. I would ask that this group find a way to work with Tufts. If the recommended plans are not consistent with what Tufts is proposing, then we're at a stalemate.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And I want to work directly with Rocco.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I will whatever we whatever we send, I will forward to him as well. Yeah.
[Jared Powell]: Yeah, thank you. Thank you. Jeremy. We really appreciate it. Like, the, the strategic thought and the background and the context. We're very glad you joined on this and the previous calls. We really do appreciate the insight. It was super helpful.
[Unidentified]: Yeah, really.
[Jared Powell]: Thank you.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: And before you go, I want to motion that we create a working group. So that we can convene outside of the context of these meetings to continue. not just drafting the letter, but overall strategy and how we proceed, you know, based on the general guidance that we come to in this meeting.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah. I move that we create that working group.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Okay, Chris move, you second it?
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Yeah, I second it.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay, the motion passes, working group created. Who wants to be a part of that group? I see no reason it can't be. Jeremy, would you like to participate?
[Jeremy Martin]: If I may keep me in the loop, I'd love to.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, yeah, I think that would be great. I think it's going to get to be quite a bit on this. We'd love to have support from sort of broad facets of the community that get behind this.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Well, I'm happy to be a part of it or to, uh. Or not, if there's, if I, you know, if we're running up against quorum issues, although maybe that doesn't matter. Yeah, I think it can only be 2. I think it can only be 2 unless we get some more people.
[Jared Powell]: Or, or make the meetings public, which, you know, is it something we can do, but it's a pain.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Yeah, I suppose the working group can consistent more. We just can't meet all at the same time.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: And I will also caution working group that you cannot arbitrarily make decisions that go against the vote we made regarding the proposals without bringing it back to the group.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I think we could each individually review a draft letter
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Asynchronously, can we not inform information back to you to you? Yeah, Chris. Yes.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: And I, can I suggest that Chris is in charge of the working group and recruits one of their person and I have to run.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Yes. Sorry. Move to adjourn.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: Second, Jeremy, can you. If I drop my email in the chat, can you reach out and so we can. We need to get offline that sounds great. Great.
[Jared Powell]: Well, thank you all for talking all this through. I really appreciate it. This is, uh, important and challenging stuff. So yeah.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Thank you.
[Jared Powell]: Glad we were able to talk about it.
[Daniel Nuzzo-Mueller]: I think Dennis is the real hero for sticking it out.
[Unidentified]: This was fascinating.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: I am running though.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: Bye Emily.
[Vice Chair Emily O'Brien]: Thanks everybody. All right.
[Secretary Bruce Kulik]: It's on the floor to adjourn. Emily already did. Uh, okay. Oh, I'll do it. All right, thank you. All right, bye everyone. Sorry to be a pain in the ass with all this pedantic, what's the word I want? Whatever.
[Jared Powell]: No, we need the rules. The rules are helpful.
[Unidentified]: All right, bye everyone. Good night.
|
total time: 25.89 minutes total words: 4183 |
|||