MHS Building Project: Community Forum #7

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3.6-flash from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The Medford High School Building Committee hosted its seventh community forum to update the public on the high school building project. School leaders and the design team presented updates on the educational plan, architectural design, construction phasing, total cost estimates, and the timeline leading to a June 2026 debt exclusion vote.

  1. 6:02 Welcome and Agenda Overview — Building Committee Chair Jenny Graham welcomed attendees and introduced the forum's agenda covering educational priorities, building design, construction phasing, project costs, and next steps.
  2. 7:45 Educational Plan and Project Goals — Superintendent Dr. Suzanne Galusi detailed how the educational plan guides the project by expanding Career and Technical Education (CTE) from 17 to 19 shops, integrating the Curtis Tufts program, improving accessibility, and maintaining community services such as Kids' Corner and the Medford Family Network.
  3. 19:14 Architectural Design and Site Layout — Design team architects and civil engineers presented the preferred addition-renovation design, which preserves and renovates the existing pool and gymnasium while surrounding them with integrated academic and vocational spaces, net-zero sustainability features, and reconfigured athletic fields.
  4. 35:12 Construction Phasing Strategy — Matt Rice outlined a three-phase construction sequence designed to keep the existing school operational on-site without the use of temporary modular classrooms.
  5. 44:42 Project Costs, Reimbursement, and Timeline — Jenny Graham explained that design efficiencies reduced the total project cost estimate from $850 million to under $700 million, with an estimated $215 million in MSBA reimbursement anticipated prior to the June 8 debt exclusion vote.
  6. 53:29 Community Outreach and Schedule — The committee presented upcoming public engagement opportunities, including school building committee meetings, future community forums, and joint meetings with the City Council.
  7. 59:20 Public Question and Answer Session — Panelists answered public questions regarding student enrollment capacity, baseline code upgrade costs versus new construction, traffic and transit mitigation, fundraising efforts, and CTE student involvement during construction.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: MPS High School Building Committee

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Are we good to go? Hi, everyone. I was at a meeting a couple of weeks ago, and it was sort of one of those places where you could use a microphone or not, and somebody raised their hand and said, I work in AV, and if there is a microphone present, you use the microphone. That's the rule. So we're all going to use the microphone tonight, so you can all hear us. For those of you on Zoom, welcome. If you have questions when we get to the Q&A, please just put your hand in the air, and we'll unmute you. get your question out into the open here and we'll do our best to answer them.

We do have child care for those of you probably are already taking advantage. Our Medford Connects team is available if there are folks who need translation services. And I'm here to welcome you. My name is Jenny Graham. I'm the chair of the Medford Comprehensive High School Building Committee, and I'm the vice chair of the school committee. And I have a senior and a sophomore in this building. They will sadly not see the inside of what you're about to see as students.

But it's it's time and it's overdue and they could tell you all about it for days. So they were we didn't let them come tonight because we have other things to talk about. But I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Galussi. So the agenda for tonight is pretty straightforward. We're going to hear from Dr. Galussi about like why are we doing this from an educational perspective. Then we're going to let the design team sort of wow you with how the design has evolved in the building. And then I'll wrap up and talk a little bit about next steps, timeline, cost, and all of those things. So I'll turn it over to Dr. Galussi.

[Suzanne Galusi]: Thank you. Hi, good evening, everybody. Welcome. So happy that you're here this evening. I'm going to try my very best to not talk to too much. These are the slides that I could really spend a very long time talking about the why and how we got here to this place that we're at right now. I think we're just going to wait for the slide to advance. While we do, I do want to explain just a little bit to you that the whole process is guided by what's called an educational plan. And that educational plan was, oh, my lovely family. Those are my two daughters.

There we go. So the whole process is guided by an educational plan. The educational plan is the why and how of our educational delivery. It's really important for you to know that that plan was co-created And there were many voices at the table when we were writing and creating this educational plan. So it included administration, it included teachers, it included students, it included community members, caregivers. There were several voices involved in creating this plan for what we want to see out of the educational experience for this building, and then how we can make that come alive in the building. So you will see here what a new school means for Medford is greater accessibility. For those of you that have been in this building, you may have seen pieces of this. You may be experiencing it right now a little bit in this auditorium, but there are actual hard pieces of accessibility to this building where not all of our students or community members are able to really come in and have spaces in this building accessible. You can view it right here in the auditorium. The other piece is we don't know what education and community needs are going to look like 5 years from now, 10 years from now, 25 years from now. So what's really important for us, the priority for us, is to make this building flexible and adaptable so that it can meet the educational and community needs as the years progress. What does that look like? Making sure our spaces can adapt to the growing needs of education and what is needed to prepare our students for college and career in the current landscape. And that means spaces where students can expand. They can be involved in project-based learning experiences. They have the breadth and the space in their classrooms to break off into groups and to really get immersed into their learning.

If we could maybe, oh, and then I do want to kind of talk about these other two squares. So most of you know this. If you don't, we are a comprehensive high school. What that means is that we have a career technical education component to our high school. Currently, right now, we have 17 CTE shops. If we have time later, you can try and quiz me. I think I can tell you all 17 without having to peek. After this new school opens, we will be adding two more, so that will be a total of 19 CTE shops. Each freshman has the ability to enter into a CTE rotation, so they get a little experience and taste of what those 17 shops are. Each year that we have done this, since around the pandemic, half of our freshman classes have elected to stay in the CTE spaces. And so they are opting to enter a CTE program. That's half of our student population as they're moving through the grades. I think that's super important. And one of the things that we found doing a lot of this work is that our CTE spaces did not meet the Department of Education's requirements for space. So we found that they actually needed larger spaces for the flexibility and the safety of the shop. It also allows us to not have wait lists, meet the demand of some of these programs, and have the space in which to not only keep students safe, but also be able to add instructors as the demand needs.

And then the other piece, for those that do not know, our schools in Medford are community hubs. This one has always been a community hub. There are several things that happen at this high school and that are housed at this high school currently. We have our municipal daycare here. It's called Kids Corner. Several of our teachers. Municipal employees, including police, fire, city workers, have their children here in our daycare that's housed around the back of the auditorium. We also maintain seats for any of our students that need to send their child to Kids' Corner so that they can finish their high school education. We also have MFN, Medford Family Network, that's also housed here right near our Kids' Corner.

It has been here since its creation, decades ago, and so we're very proud of that relationship. Both are adjacent to our Welcome Center, when you came in this foyer, right in front of you is our Welcome Center, which houses our registration, but also allows our family the resource of Medford Family Network to provide some services. So we want to make sure we can maintain these services that we have for our Medford residents and our families by including an early childhood center.

So I spoke a lot about many of these things, but just so that we understand a little bit more on the educational side, this column here for academic offerings, I spoke about the CTE spaces. But some of those flexible spaces that we're talking about making sure we include so that we're preparing our students also include what is called innovation labs or tech labs. These are going to be spaces that allow for some larger group work that teachers can bring their classrooms to. When they have projects, we heard a lot from teachers, we heard a lot from students about having spaces where they can break off and do project-based work, and also kind of get involved in some hands-on, maybe like Makerspace or STEM-related activities. We also heard from our world language department, our health department about having a space where they could take classes to also do a little bit of cooking or health related activities or cultural related activities. These flexible spaces will allow various teachers, groups of students to be able to use the spaces as the demand or need arises. I also didn't talk about Curtis Tufts, our therapeutic high school program that is housed over in South Medford near Tufts Park and near the pool. This will also allow the location of Curtis Tufts to be up here. What this does for us is allow all of our high school students to be at the campus together, but it also allows for the thoughtful inclusion of Curtis Tufts, knowing that they may need a space where they have their own entrance. There's some space for them to be able to learn in a safe, manner, but when students are ready, they're able to have what's accessible to them here at the high school. Right now, they're not able to do that. They're not able to engage in a CTE class or use the gymnasium or participate in an art class. So, like, the equity part of where Curtis-Tufts is located really creates barriers. This will allow for all of our students to be in one building and have the small group setting that they require, but also the ability to access our programs. I think I spoke and then I think it's very exciting where you're sitting right now. You can look around There's limited seating, especially if there are chairs at work But the auditorium would expand stay within MSBA guidelines, but expand to 750 seats we have a very active theater group in the city of Medford and both within our schools and community organizations that love to use this space, and so we're really happy to be able to keep the arts thriving in Medford. The pool will remain, and I do think it's important to mention just the mechanical part of Medford High School. So if you don't realize, Medford High School has a failing mechanical system, so...

That's putting it nicely, isn't it, Alicia? And so controlled temperatures is not something that we have. We have fluctuations of when it's too hot, when it's too cold, lots of leaking, lots of dripping, the roof. Oh yes, the flickering lights that we had to turn off because what we were just told What we were told is it takes 40 minutes to warm up. So we just chose to turn them off. And I would say what we heard from students during all of the visioning work.

was one, this building restricts integration. And so our CTE is a separate wing. And so if you are a student that is not on the CTE track, you don't get to see all of the really cool things that the students are doing in those spaces because there's no visible access. Our art classes are the same way. They're above where we are right now. And if you don't take an art class and you don't walk down that hallway, you are not seeing the beauty of art displayed in that hallway. This plan, which they're gonna talk about in a second, is going to integrate all of our spaces so that CTE, learning, arts, special education, it's all integrated into one high school. So students are gonna be able to see their classmates genius on display all the time, and that's just super important to us. Do you think I missed anything?

Yes, thank you And so I see I started down that track and then I got very distracted So this building will also meet Medford's climate goals, which are very very important It will be an all-electric air to water heat pump And a hundred percent I might need help on this one and There we go. Thank you. Thank you. I think what they're going to get into a little bit later in the presentation, so you'll see a little bit of the mass timber alternates. So you'll, will they see a little bit of these?

Okay. Okay. I'm sorry about that. I wasn't prepared for that one. I can talk about education all day long, but some of these materials I might need a little help with, but I will be here at the end of the presentation if you have any questions. Am I passing it to you?

[Matt Rice]: Thank you. So my name is Matt Rice. I'm an architect, the principal in charge for SMMA. We are the designers for the new Medford High School project. And I'm going to walk you through really what is the preferred solution that was selected by the building committee back in June of this year. So we have been working since this option was selected. to develop it, and what we have to share with you this evening is a lot of, the culmination of a lot of thought, a lot of discussion that has gone into the process and has worked to evolve to what you're going to be seeing in front of you. So I'm going to cover first just the overall big picture of what this preferred option is, and then we're going to get a little bit more into the design of it. I have our lead civil engineer, Aaron Presilio, here as well as Mike Reed, our design architect. They're going to get into some more details. But I'm just going to start off with an overview. So if you look in the top right-hand corner of this image, you see a fairly small version of the massing of this particular option. This option is an addition renovation option, which means that we are salvaging and really reinvigorating some pieces of the existing building. Those pieces are the existing gymnasium, as well as the existing pool, the gymnastics gym that sit right out in front of it, as well as the fitness center and the spaces that are down below. But aside from the gym and the pool, which are getting renovated in their existing condition, the rest of it is really getting completely renovated down to the bones of the building and then built back up. So in that diagram, you see the dark blue masses are the renovated portions. You can see the pool and gymnasium volumes. The light blue portions are the new addition that we are building around those existing pieces that we are renovating. And so you will see that we are building north or towards Edgerly Field from the existing renovated pieces. We're also building to the south. And if you start to understand what's in that diagram, you'll also realize that we are building on top of the existing building. So this will be a phased renovation and addition project. We're gonna get a little bit into the phasing process as well to start give you some initial ideas of how this is all gonna happen in a very safe manner on the existing site. In terms of how the building is gonna be organized, you see that color diagram that has all the different blocks or wings of the building laid out around a central heart, a central core that is intended to bring together the different programmatic elements of the building. So the health and wellness wing is the one that I usually start with because it is the renovated gymnasium and the pool. So everyone can visualize that in their mind where you are and it sort of anchors you within that diagram. Out in front of the health and wellness wing is a performing arts wing. This is going to be where the new enlarged auditorium is going to be located, but we're also going to have programs that supplement that. So the new music spaces, the cosmetology, the film and TV, CTE programs will all be there. creating really a collective resource for the overall school. It is also the location of where there's going to be a community entrance into the building. So we are going to have the ability to separate out those programs that may be using the building after hours without having everyone just wandering out through the remainder of the building. That was one of the challenges that was identified with this building. Everyone experienced it when they walked into the building this evening, right? You could head down any corridor that you want, really, so it's difficult to manage and maintain security.

Back behind the health and wellness wing, wrapping around and sort of through the heart of the building, are what we're referring to as integrated learning communities. And so these are, to go back to what Dr. Galussi mentioned, spaces within the building that are intended to integrate both traditional academic classrooms, your math and your science and your English classes, as well as the CTE curriculum within the building. as well as special education within the building. So the idea is that we are bringing everyone together. This is how we are creating this unified, comprehensive Medford High School. We don't have a VOC wing. Sometimes students come up to me and ask, where is the VOC when we look at this new diagram? And the answer is that the VOC is everywhere, right? It is fully integrated within the rest of the building. There is no more delineation between spaces, between students, one Medford High School. And then lastly, that red volume that's out towards the front, which stretches out over where the existing parking lot is today, is what we refer to as the ECC wing, so the Early Childhood Center wing. It does contain both the new preschool that's going to be brought here to the building, as well as the new and enlarged daycare, the Kids' Corner daycare. as well as Medford Family Network, and then the district offices, which includes the Welcome Center, as part of that programmatic space. So that's really the organization of all the different parts and pieces that we have. And I'm just gonna introduce the concept of how we started to think about the building once the option was selected, and how do we actually start into the design of the building. And really the focus is on the connection between the city at large, and the Fells. The Fells surrounds this building. It is an amazing site that is here. It has its challenges in terms of constraints, but it is also a wonderful, rich source of inspiration, of ability for students, for the entire community to connect immediately with some really rich natural resources that surround the entire building. So what we're trying to do is investigate opportunities to let the building services bridge between the larger city of Medford as well as the fells that surrounds it.

I'm going to turn it over to Aaron.

[gy7C3zrS2D0_SPEAKER_02]: Erin Priscillio, Civil Engineer with SMMA. I have the pleasure to be here tonight to really talk at a high level right now about the planning on what's guiding, how we're reimagining the site to complement the building, the community, everyone who's going to be coming here to use this site. All right, so you'll see up on the screen our proposed site plan. The building in various shades of blue, the darker blue represents that renovated piece that Matt was speaking about, and the lighter blue is surrounding it with the new construction. What's guiding this plan is the big masses you'll see in green. Those are the new fields that will be used for recreation, for athletics, and ultimately we'll be supporting the educational plan that Dr. Galusi spoke of earlier. We are imagining a new facility up where Edgeley sits today. So by, again, reimagining that north end of the site, we're able to fit a new track and all of the field events that can support that program.

renovating the practice field that will sit today that's on the left side of the site, and introducing, really excited to introduce a new rectangle play field, kind of centrally located on the site. There's several benefits to this location, mostly it's adjacent to parking, whereas Edgerly, that's a challenge today, parking and also how we get up and circulate around to that field. The layers of circulation are complex on this site. We've spent a lot of time thinking about how arrival and dismissal works on the site, where we have yellow buses, MBTA buses. We have vans bringing students here, all of the parents that come morning and afternoon. Lots of engagement with first responders. Right now, fire trucks cannot circulate the building fully, and that's been a driving goal of the site design now.

And then also all of the spaces in between, you know, we're thinking about how these outdoor spaces support the students that are here, how we can design spaces to support needs for the CTE, how we deal with transitions from vehicular zones and outdoor zones into the building, how we support the kids' corner in the pre-K with their playground spaces located adjacent to those buildings. Yep, that's just a little bit about the site. I think I'm going to hand it to Mike Reed next. He's going to talk a little bit about more of the building design.

[WE27JYKbooc_SPEAKER_08]: All right, good evening. I'm Mike Reed. I'm one of the lead designers, architects. We have a huge team of people working on this, and I have the privilege of presenting what we're doing tonight. So you see this on the screen, but I want you to think back to the diagram that Matt talked about with the city and the fells. So I think right now you've been hit with a lot of information from Dr. Glusi and Matt and Aaron. This is a complex building. It's a complex, there's a lot of different programmatic elements, a lot of different learning spaces, the site, how we craft the building around the existing building, build it in phases, which you'll see later.

How we organize that into a building, a lot of times we need concepts. We need concepts to help organize how the building functions, not only in terms of the classroom layout, but also the feel of it, what we prioritize. This is an initial sketch I did just It's kind of an emotive sketch to say what do we want this building to be? And we want this building to be an integration of the city and the fells. It's an incredible resource around the school and it's also an inspiration and it's an analogy to what we're trying to do with the school itself. It's an integrated school of vocational and academic learning. But also in terms of how the pedagogy of learning is happening today, it's much more integrated model between disciplines. And so what this diagram shows is that integration of the fells into it, into the architecture of the building itself. So bringing some of those maybe like tree-like columns or inspirational spaces into the heart of the building itself.

So, we take that concept and then we start overlaying it on more reality. So, the massing of the building you saw. And so, this is, again, just an initial design sketch. I'm kind of letting you look under the hood a bit of kind of what we do in the studio as architects. but beginning to layering on these ideas of the inspiration of the fells onto the building itself. So it's not going to directly translate totally to this, but we begin to evolve through the design.

So here is our initial pass at the main entry of the school. So if you see in the lower left-hand corner of the slide is a little key map of the building itself and you see the little views of where we're looking at the building. So this is the main entry. The field that Aaron talked about is right in the foreground. And we're trying to make this a very open, light-filled area, bring a lot of transparency into the school so it's an inviting entry for the students. And it's really a clear, you have a clear idea where you go. You're not confused in terms of how you enter this building. As you can see, what we talked about earlier, the net zero energy goal for this project requires a lot of photovoltaics on the roof and on the site. We don't want that to just be an add-on to the building later. This has to be integrated into the design itself. So you can see on the top of the building, it's almost like a trellis canopy, but that's the photovoltaic array on the upper academic learning communities. up there, and so we're trying to make that integrate into the architecture itself. It can have some of those tree-like elements representing a canopy, and then we're also trying to bring those other canopies throughout the building to be evocative of the fells.

This is a view from the western side, so you'll be standing in the practice field. Here you can see in the center is an outdoor dining area, so that's kind of the opposite of that main entry. You can see straight through the school, there's an outdoor dining opportunity. This will also act as a secondary entrance for some of the buses and some of the special education vans that'll drop off here. We need loading. So we have a loading dock. So the kind of gray rectangle you see there. But we're trying to integrate in the building and hide it a bit. It can be closed down so it's not this visible kind of messy place outside of the building.

So it's a large building. There's a lot of programs. So we're trying to organize it in a way and break it up with some other glass elements, as you can see there. Next. This is a view from the north, so up on the track in the field, and you're looking, this, you know, we're engaging with Edgerly Field up into the north. So this is actually another kind of what we call more of an entrance for the athletic program, but also the CT program. So what you see here is the door, the bay doors for the automotive and metal fabrication CTE programs, so there's a lot of the CTE programs that need direct exterior access And so we're trying to accommodate that around the school. So this one you see the views of the that automotive CTE program as well. This canopy is also a little bit higher we have to Provide expansion space or space that they could eventually build more academic or vocational space in the future. We've identified that a third story could be built on top of this wing. So that structure for the PV canopy actually would be the structure for the roof of the expansion itself. So we're trying to, you know, be smart about this and build it with the future cost savings in mind.

This is just another view, kind of an approach view to the main entry into the school. So this shows a little bit of the materiality we're thinking about. It's going to have a masonry facade primarily, and that's a lot to do with durability and cost. But we're looking for the tones of the building to be more evocative of some granite-like material at the base and then some lighter masonry up the top. So that could be brick or other types of masonry. We're still in the process of developing that. And then these canopies, bringing some warmth into the canopies with some wood underneath.

Or wood look material may not be wood itself for durability. It may be a different material, but it would be evocative of kind of to soften the building. And then just some of these playful columns that are a little more evocative of the fells. Here's a view, more of distance view, kind of trying to capture the full breadth of the school. So you can see the EEC wing to the left-hand side, which would also have the district offices, the main entry. And then in the background, beyond the PV canopies in the parking, you'd see the, there would be the auditorium and the gymnasium. And that's basically it. More to come.

[Matt Rice]: All right, so I'm gonna talk about the fun part now, which is how we actually are going to build this and keep everyone safe at the same time as we're moving forward. So we have, as part of the schematic design phase, started a series of very intensive phasing discussions that includes the school district, ourselves, and now that we actually have our construction manager on board, we can involve the folks that are actually going to be building the building as part of those discussions. I'm going to preface everything that you're going to see that's coming up with the fact that we are still very much in progress with this. We know we have a deadline coming up, which is the middle of December, when we're going to be going out and generating our next cost estimate and our final cost estimate. So we are working to that goal to understand exactly how we're gonna move this very complicated building from where it is today to where it needs to be in the future. What you're gonna see is a very good pass at that. It is definitely recognizing all the various parts and pieces, but there is just an incredible level of complexity to this that we need to make sure that we have everyone's minds working on. And we have to make sure that we're accounting for all of the temporary costs that are associated here. If we go back all the way to the beginning of the project, right, that we had a pushback against the use of modular classrooms, temporary modular classroom buildings, we are not using those as part of the construction. But what that means is that we have to use different phases of the construction to move students and teachers into as they're completed to replace that. So we're sort of using the permanent building as our swing space as we go. And so that's why we have to move through the different phases. You're going to see a total of three different phases and some sub phases within those three different phases. I'll try to make that clear and we're certainly happy to answer any questions that folks have afterwards about the phasing and just understand that we're still going to be developing this as we go forward. The process has been a very good one, though, in terms of coming up with different ideas from different sources. We have found a way to maintain this auditorium space throughout the duration of construction until the new one is built, while previously we were thinking we might have to live without an auditorium for maybe two years. That's not gonna be the case any longer. So this process that we're going through, it's not predetermined in any sense. We're looking and listening to any good ideas that come up as part of the discussion.

So this is the existing site, the existing building as it stands. This is sort of the calm before the storm of all the different activity. I'm going to move forward because I'm probably not in the light here also. But everything that is here should seem familiar to everyone in terms of circulation. We're thinking about parking as this happens as well. We need to make sure that there is enough space for everything going on on the site to still happen, as well as construction activity.

We're going to move forward again. We have three different phases, phase 1, 2, and 3. And then we're going to have sort of an early part and a later part of each one of those phases. So an A and a B part to each 1, 2, 3. So this is our phase 1A activity. It's the very first thing that's going to be happening as part of construction. We're going to be starting towards the northern end of the site or towards Edgerly Field, right? And so you can see the footprint of that new addition basically goes out into the middle of Edgerly Field. There is a footprint portion of it that's going to remain. We're trying to find out if there that we can maximize the duration of the resources for everyone that can possibly use it. We just have to make sure that it's done in a safe manner. So as part of that, we're going to be removing some rock as part of what's underneath Edgeley Field to dig in some of the building to the north as we go. We also have to remove the existing mechanical room that's located on the northern end. We have to put in a temporary mechanical system to let the rest of the building live and breathe while we're building something new to the north.

Part of this as well is that we will be making some updates to Steve Miller Drive at the entrance to the school to allow for a construction access road to operate just adjacent to. There's enough land to do that, but we have to make sure that we can again have separate and safe traffic coming in and out. We're still going to have all those same traffic challenges that exist today on the site while bringing construction in. We also know that we can restrict the arrival times, delivery times of construction vehicles so that we're not overlapping specifically on the arrival time of the school in the morning. So that should help things.

Our phase 1B is where we're really now into the construction of that new northern addition. We're also renovating the gym and the pool at this time. We are trying to find ways to minimize the downtime for the pool and the gym. We know that those are valuable resources. We can't really create a temporary gym. So we're trying to find ways to do that as efficiently as possible and see if we can get it back online. But that's the majority of what phase 1B is, is building that new addition to the north and renovating the gym and the pool building.

Phase 2a starts to get a little bit more complicated towards the center of the site. Yes, and it's sort of in the midst of these two slides, right? So phase 1B, we don't see any building there. Phase 2A, you see a completed addition. So we get two things, actually. We move into that new building, but we also then, at that point, have the pool and the gymnasium back online and active for the school. There are two years in each of those major phases that we're thinking about. And this is what we get. At this point, though, what we have to do is actually allow students and teachers to be active in the remaining portions of the building. So the building B, which is the science wing and the central admin wing, building H, and a lot of building G, which is where the majority of the vocational programs are today.

We are also in part of the discussion that we've been having on phasing is that we've been looking to find ways to, again, keep this auditorium up and running. So while that diagram says building a demolition, we're actually only gonna be demolishing everything outside of that wall during this phase. And we're gonna keep the rest of the auditorium going, which it's a little bit tricky in terms of a process, but we know we can do it structurally. We know that we can do it operationally and in a safe manner. And again, we don't lose an auditorium for two years. But there will be construction going on between those new sections that we're now inhabiting at the northern end of the site in the existing portion, so we're going to have to work around those.

And so this slide, phase 2B, shows the new construction, the remainder of the addition being built, as well as the existing building, the B, G, and H buildings, as well as the new addition being used. There will be some connection up along the fells towards the top of the screen that you see there. That's the eastern side of the site. We're going to be moving students back and forth around the construction and renovation that's happening. And at the same time, we should at the completion of phase one, in addition to the building, that field at the northern edge, the one that will have the track and the football field and the stadium needs to be active. That is part of what the deed restriction and DCR is telling us as part of the field. We can only have either of those fields down for a maximum of two years. So they're going to align with the different phases. So the practice field that is to the south is the one that will be down in phase two. And the edgerly field to the north is the one that will be down in phase one. But again, we get it back sooner as part of the overall project.

Then we get into phase three. I think actually phase three has an A, B, and C portion just as we work our way around the parking lot. But essentially phase three involves the remaining demolition of the parts of the existing building that are no longer being used. So the B wing and the rest of the vocational wing and the auditorium that's gonna be here will all come down in this phase three A. And then we really start on the site work out front to build the new field as well as the new parking.

which you can see starting to take shape in this particular diagram. We need to make sure that, well, because school is still going to be going on during this particular phase, right? We need to make sure that we have that parking as we're building the new parking. And that's really the reason why this has been split up into three different phases. But eventually, we have the ability to construct a new field. And then we end up with our final built condition. We do have an updated physical model down here at the front of the room as well, for those of you that are here in the room. And unfortunately, you can't see it from home. But if you want to actually see the physical representation of that, we do have that up front for folks.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: And Matt forgot to tell you that students move into the rest of the building at the end of phase two. We get to move into the new space. That's like the most exciting part. So in terms of timeline, right, we're in the middle of schematic design. We'll be in schematic design until June. Lots of things are happening right now to move from sort of rough concept, like you saw maybe in the spring, to a level of detail that would allow construction folks to actually say how much will this cost to build. And all of the conversations about phasing are really pivotal to that on our project because it's so complex.

Once we finish schematic design, that culminates in a vote by the community to pass the debt exclusion that'll be required to fund this project. That is scheduled for June 8th. There'll be lots more to come about that. And then once we pass through that gate successfully, lots of work starts to really turn even those designs into something that allows people to put shovels in the ground. The entire project from beginning to end concludes in 2034. So this is definitely like a marathon instead of a sprint, especially because we have prioritized minimizing disruption to learning as best we can for the students who are going to live through this in this building in various ways. So choices against modular classrooms were really about the quality of learning, and that complicates an already complicated project on a very complicated site. As we think forward, these phases, you'll hear a lot more about them and what's happening in each of them, particularly for folks that have students in the school. A lot of those conversations are happening right now, so we don't have all the answers, but we're working our way there. If you can go to the next slide, Will.

I know one of the things that's on everybody's mind is how much will this project cost? And the answer is we don't have that just yet, but we have an idea, right? So at the beginning of February, we started with an estimate, not a construction estimate, but a design estimate. And that estimate for this option was about $850 million. Since February, we have been able to bring the price down on this project by $150 million. So it's a significant change.

and how this building has been priced out. We've done that through a whole variety of sort of diving deeper into all kinds of things. And if you are interested in some of those conversations, the building committee explored and reviewed every single facet of the program that will go into this building in our meetings from July through October 6th. What preceded that was hundreds of hours of meetings with educators going back to the design, thinking about what the educational needs were that we outlined in the ed plan and saying, are there changes that we could make to how we built the space to meet this need that would allow us to still do the things that we want to do and need to do from an educational perspective? But could we do it more efficiently? Could we share spaces? Can we nip and tuck different spaces without compromising what can happen in those spaces? And so all of that conversation did not happen in a vacuum. It didn't happen by me. It didn't happen by the project team. It happened by the educators who work in this building every single day and know what students need. Their work facilitated proposals to the building committee who could then sort of make change to make like programmatic change without compromising that educational plan that is the anchor. So this is just sort of a rundown if you're interested in the history of like what changed when, but the headline here is from $850 million in February to just under $700 million on October 6th.

So that number, that $700 million number is not a construction estimate, right? So the next thing for us to do is to really move that forward and say, what is the construction estimate that allows us to see this building sort of rise up and be completed? That work will be happening over the course of the next couple of months, and the city will get that information from the estimators. Suffolk Construction has an estimator. Leftfield, our OPM, has an estimator. They both independently estimate this project. They bring those numbers together, and they agree on them. That number becomes the anchor for what this project will be. So that number drives our written signed agreement with the MSBA. That is the number we have to stick to. It does not change. That is the number that drives sort of everything as it goes forward. It also is the number that sets the anchor point for what MSBA will reimburse us for this project. So they're going to provide a substantial grant based on a very complicated set of rules, but that set of complicated rules will be laid on top of the construction estimate, and that will help us go from $700 million to construction estimate to Medford's share of the construction estimate. So that's part of the evolution that needs to happen in the next couple of months. From there, we will ultimately be able to take that number, Medford's share of the construction estimate, and be able to translate that into what will this cost from a taxpayer impact perspective. If anybody tells you they know what this project costs right now, they're wrong, because nobody knows, because none of those numbers exist just yet.

Okay let's go to the next slide. So we've talked a little bit about this. There's a lot of work happening in the next couple of months to get to those numbers and to be able to provide the inputs that our city's finance team need to be able to then say to all of us like this is how we expect taxpayers to experience this over 30 years. This is a debt exclusion. It is not an override, which means that it is time limited. So this will happen over 30 years. And at the end of 30 years, that impact on your taxes will be removed. We will have and we'll talk about meetings in just a second But there will be a meeting a joint council school committee meeting where we will hear a presentation about that very topic So put that on your calendar if you are like really really interested in eager to hear about taxpayer impact that is that that is the day where that will be available and I'm gonna tell you it'll be very tight in the lead-up to that because the construction estimates have to come through they have to We have to then be able to ingest that. The city has to be able to work with their bond counsel and get it right. So all of those things are needing to happen and it will take some time. And then on June 8th is that special election where the community will be asked to go to the ballot and vote for this project.

We're just going to hold on for one second. We just heard that our YouTube audio isn't working, so we're just gonna try to get that fixed real quick. Yeah. I think, where's Ken? 300 seats in the auditorium, is that right? Little more than three, like 325? Yeah, yeah, about 325. So from a class size perspective, right, like a single class at Medford High can fit in here. In our new auditorium, two classes will be able to fit in the auditorium simultaneously.

Oh, OK, we have closed captions but no audio.

[Suzanne Galusi]: That's Ken Lord, our Chief Operation Officer. Running the Zoom is Will Pupicelli, our Communications Director.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: We're good? Okay, we're back. Thank you all for your patience. So one of the things that we're working really hard to do on this project is to make sure that there's lots of information available for people so that they can find the information that they need, that they want, and we recognize that not everybody wants the same information. If you have a student who will be here in 2032, you probably want to know a lot about phasing. If you don't have a student who will yet be here in 2032, you might not really care about the phases and the complexity that Matt talked about, right? So everybody has a different level of information that they want and need in this project. So there's a couple of big ways to get involved. We have scheduled these meetings out through June so people can put them on their calendars and know what to expect. We have SBC meetings. Those are our school building committee meetings. That is where we make decision. They are business meetings. So they are meetings where we have an agenda that we have to move through decisions that we're being asked to make. The public is welcome to come or join us on Zoom. The public is welcome to make comment on those items on the agenda. But they are sort of prescribed meetings that are there to serve a purpose and continue to move the project forward.

Second bucket, community forums, like the one that we're having right here tonight. They're a little bit different, right? We're here to give you information. We're trying to respond to what we think people want to hear. And then there's time for Q&A. A little bit more informal, these are the places to come ask your questions. And then the third bucket we have three joint meetings of the school committee and City Council So all of your communities elected officials in one room hearing about this project hearing about questions From the public providing answers and then ultimately again on February 2nd hearing about tax impact So lots of different ways to engage with the project on top of that if you belong to a community group If you belong to a board or Commission if you belong to a PTO and you would like to have us come and talk to your group about the thing that matters to them, you just need to reach out and let us know. We were at the Roberts last night. We gave a presentation at their PTO meeting. We'll be at the Senior Center on Monday, November 30th in the afternoon. Everybody is welcome to join us. We really are trying to make sure that we're meeting people where they are. One of the other members of the team was at the winter preparedness event at City Hall just before this event. So we really are like trying to be in lots of different places so that people can get access to the information that they need and want from trusted project sources. So if you have questions, there's lots of ways to get in touch with us. There's lots of information. Our website is brand new. We just rolled it out. It's lovely and it's super easy to understand what's going on on the project on the website now, which is something we've been working on for a really, really long time. So I'm really happy that we were able to pull that off before tonight. There's lots of places to come and get real information about the project and I would encourage you, if you have questions, to seek those trusted sources and not necessarily hang your hat on the things that you read on social media because we sort of know what happens out there. If you have friends, if you have neighbors who don't have kids in school, please answer their questions. Please point them in the right direction and let them know about all of these good ways to know what's happening in our community. This is a big project, and it's not just a project for kids. It's a project for all of us, right? If you use the pool, if you use the fields, if you use the fells, if you come to an auditorium event, This school is a community hub, and it's one of the few that we have. So we want to make sure over the course of this project that people are able to hear about all of those things that are happening. And I think, hopefully, to hear about the amazing things that happen here today for students who are doing great things in spite of a building that's not quite supporting their needs anymore. So education has changed, learning has changed. It's not like it was when we were in school, right? No longer do we sit in a desk and we look forward at the teacher. We want students to be thinking critically, to be working together, to be really exploring and learning through exploration. All those things are super hard to do in this building. That's just going to get worse as time goes on. And frankly, none of us knows really what education looks like in 30 years, right? And so trying to create a space that meets all the needs of today and does so thoughtfully about planning for the future is what we have been working so hard on. We are coming up on three years since we were awarded from the MSBA. We were awarded an invitation to this process. It's been three years.

And we're still about eight years from done. So it's a big effort. It's a huge undertaking. It's hundreds and thousands of hours of meetings. And so if you have a question, there is somebody with an answer, or we can tell you that that answer just simply doesn't exist quite yet because we're not ready. But yeah, we're here to answer any questions, and that's what we want to do for the rest of the time. So thank you all for coming. We'll pass the microphone for those folks who can best answer your questions. If there are folks on Zoom who want to answer a question, just please put your hand in the air. For the folks on Zoom, there's about 35 people in the room here. And for the folks in the room, there's about 15 or 20 people on Zoom. So hopefully, you all can get the answers for questions that you came with. But yeah. Here, I'm going to give the mic. Oh, you have one?

[John Anderson]: I wonder if you could remind us the design of the school is to accommodate how many students. And my other question is, The costs that you've presented, does that include the money already spent in the design effort and the consultants and the architects and so forth and so on?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Good questions. So first question is, what are we designing the school for in terms of number of students? So today we have 1,200-ish students. The building is being designed for 1395 high school students, about 200 pre-K students, and about 100 municipal daycare students. That number was arrived at through a study of our enrollment, both historical and planned. So we looked at the trajectory of enrollment. So, I mean, you hear all the time, right, out in the community, this school was built for 4,000 people and we don't have that many anymore. That is true.

We looked at, in the study done by MSBA, looks at and vets every project that they do. the history of our student population and then takes that forward 30 years. And as they look forward 30 years, they're looking at a bunch of things. They're looking at how the birth rate is expected to change. So we start all the way with birth rates when we start talking about those projections. They also looked at The real estate market in Medford, they looked at planned development in Medford. So some development that gets planned and built does not change matters for a school. But some of it does. And one of the things that was unique about our situation between the MBTA Communities Act and the kind of housing that is anticipated to be built here, Which is with a big focus on affordable housing affordable housing brings students One-bedroom apartments not so much and so they looked at the differential there of like what is planned and what are what? Exactly are those things and they actually had us go Alicia hunt was very helpful and useful in this process. They had us go look at at actual real apartment buildings in Medford that were like planned development so that we could equate growth based on the number of students from those apartment buildings in Medford to an extrapolate out for some of the like exceptions. So we worked for months with the MSBA to try to get that number right and Medford is, I think, a little bit unique. A lot of schools experience that that number shrinks or stays flat. The conditions in Medford, though, really necessitated something different, and that was corroborated and supported by the MSBA, who does this on every project that they build. And your second question was, Cost to date, okay, yes, yes. So the feasibility study that we are in right now, Medford allocated $3 million of free cash for the feasibility study, which takes us actually all the way through schematic design.

53% of that will be reimbursed by the MSBA. So that process, like we pay it, they reimburse, right? And that comes back into Medford's coffers. I believe the $3 million is in the 699 or does it sit completely outside? It is, okay. So the 699 includes that 3 million already like on the tab. Are there questions? What else? Yeah, so Sam's question was what was the construction manager selection process like? So we made a decision earlier this year to go construction manager at risk. What that allows is for us to bring the construction manager on board now in this phase so that they can help Design the school essentially and get to a point where we can Leverage them as we build our estimates so that there aren't surprises down the line We started with a request for qualifications. We had four firms that submitted a statement of qualification and worked with deemed qualified by the selection committee. They then had to submit a proposal. We then evaluated that proposal and had each firm come in and talk to us about their proposal. Every firm came in here with like 15 to 20 people.

Right, lots of people, lots of Medford residents actually. It was like kind of wild. There were Medford residents on every single team without exception. And they talked about their plans, their approach, what they were thinking about. They answered our questions and then we rated that evaluation. We rated their references and then the like aggregation of those three things led us to select Suffolk Construction as our construction manager. So, big process. This is a big project, so there's not just any construction firm is able to support a project this big.

Am I allowed to say that? I am, right? Consigli Construction, a joint venture between W.T. Rich and Bond, and Skanska. So big names in construction. Like, you know, you think about, if you hear Suffolk, you think about, like, you know, South Station and the Encore Casino. Like, they build big, complex stuff all the time. And they have a big practice, a big growing practice in K to 12. Yeah, Chris. Oh, hold on just one second. Let me get you the microphone. They need it on Zoom. They can't hear you on Zoom.

[hCz5uniVUiI_SPEAKER_13]: I wanted to circle back to the population of students. Given this is going to be a fantastic high school and voc tech, that will probably draw some kids from some of the private schools.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: the numbers that you it was only an additional how many about 200 195 yeah so it's a significant it's about a 15 increase if i'm thinking about it right um and we did we do talk about that that dynamic that you're talking about of families moving back into public school from charters and private schools after a building is done is something they have a lot of experience with because they can watch that happen over all of their projects So definitely that was taken into account as well.

[hCz5uniVUiI_SPEAKER_13]: And it's taken into account that we've got about 1,200 new apartments that will be built. And my other question was the vocational technical school. I understand there's more students in the voc tech than the regular high school at this point. I think it's about 50-50. It's close. But there's waiting lists on some of the shops. So conceivably, there could be more students In the Vogue, there could be more students in the Vogue Tech.

[Suzanne Galusi]: So this is the piece that I highlighted a little bit, but I'm glad you're elevating it now. So right now there are space constraints in our shops. Our shops per the Department of Education size is not at what it should be, it's smaller than what the Department of Ed would like to see it. So we do have some constraints or wait lists. We did bring on new shops, so we have been able to clear some of those wait lists with our new shops. It may not be students' first choice, but our wait lists right now are very small. However, we'll be able to fully clear them with this expanded room for our shops, two additional shops, and because of the expanded space, we will also be able to add instructors as the need requires for students that want to elect in that shop.

[hCz5uniVUiI_SPEAKER_13]: That's what my hope was, is that with the new shop space that some of the kids that really want to get into the voc tech, because we know this is a problem all over the state. There's just not enough slots.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Correct. I had to drop my son at Minuteman the other day, and it's the first time I had been over there. And he said, do we send kids to Minuteman? Why don't we send kids to Minuteman? And I said, well, Lucas, there's 600 kids in our vocational program. Minuteman would have to build a new Minuteman to take 700 kids. And he was like, oh. I didn't think of that, and I was like, yeah, it's not like sending three kids, right? So we are super lucky here to have that part of an educational program, not just for the kids who want to go into trade, but for the kids who want to be electrical engineers. For the kids who want to go into robotics, for the kids who want to go into biotech, all of those things are happening here in this building. And in other communities, they have to apply. There are all these crazy admission rules now. And they're space constrained. All these vocational schools have incredible demand, and they're space constrained. our kids get into their programs, you know, and that gets better and better as we have more capacity. So it's a huge selling point about living in Medford.

[SPEAKER_11]: I have two separate questions. One is, in addition to the, whatever this is, approximately 50 million that's excluded under the MSBA, what other sort of costs aren't covered by the MSIP, even considered in their, what is it, 53%, I think you said, calculation?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Thank you for asking that. I totally forgot about this slide, so I will cover this before we move on. So the MSBA has a very complex formula about how they will pay, and so when we say 53%, That is like the base of what of what they will reimburse based on eligible cost and that is an important caveat on top of that communities earn incentive points for various things like a being lead silver, yeah? Okay. So we can earn incentive points. So the number will never go below 53%. That number will be revisited because it is based on the Department of Education looking at like what can Medford afford to pay? So that number could fluctuate a little bit, probably not a lot. The incentive points get added on top. That creates the max of what they will pay. for eligible space. And then on top of that, to just make matters more complicated, there are limits to what they will pay for outside space, for inside space. And so all of those things add up. The effective reimbursement that we're expecting is just about like $215 million on $700 million. So that here in Medford is driven by those caps, those changes. and some of our non-reimbursable spaces. $30 million to renovate the pool. That is not something that the MSBA will share. Our kids' corner daycare, our MFN. So there are spaces, all those community hub spaces that we're talking about. Those are all spaces that the MSBA knows about, allows. This happens in every community.

Things happen in high schools, particularly in high schools, but things happen in schools all over the Commonwealth that are necessary to continue there, which is the case for a lot of these programs that belong here. They allow these things to happen, they just can't share in the cost because they are constrained. Their budget is built on one penny on the sales tax. That is how we fund schools here in Massachusetts. And so they're trying to sort of spread that penny on the sales tax. and meet the demand across the Commonwealth. And it's not just high schools, it's every level. So what we're looking at, we think, and all of this is still very much part of the conversation with the MSBA, is about $215-ish million in reimbursement. So it is a big number. It is worth being part of their process, because otherwise this school would not cost less, but it would cost us more.

[SPEAKER_11]: That's helpful. And then the second question was I assumed the debt exclusion is simply for the building construction It doesn't cover for example the expansion of the CTE programs and staffing for that and stuff, right?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: It does not cover operating costs. That's correct The school committee has been working through and continues to work through that. So we added two new shops this year plumbing and Infosecurity, so IT, those teachers were funded in our operating budget as part of what is new this year in our operating budget, right? And so if we needed a new teacher, that is something that would come online. At this point, though, we're talking about two new programs coming online when the building opens, so we're not talking about huge numbers of staff.

But yeah, that's actually a great question. One of the things that I'm hopeful for is we'll start spending a whole lot less money heating this building. It is shocking how much money it costs to heat this building, and it's not warm. I am looking forward to spending a lot less money. When we talk about net zero energy, that has real operating cost impact on our budget, on our municipal budget, on our school budget, and all those other things.

[SPEAKER_11]: Appreciate it.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Yeah. And then while people think about the next question, I will also mention one of the things that we have been talking about really for four or five months now is how do we make this project affordable for the community? And there's a lot of levers there, right? There's making sure that our senior tax deferral programs are at the maximum that the state allows so that if we have seniors who are having a hard time affording the taxes and staying in their home that there are programs available for them. So that's one thing that we're doing. Another thing that we're doing is starting a 501c3 because we think there are philanthropy dollars out there that we can capture. that can help offset some of these parts of the project that are not reimbursable by the MSBA. So we had a pool party at one of our SBC meetings where a huge contingent of people who use and rely on the pool came out to tell us how much they love and rely on the pool and really to ask us to not eliminate it.

I'm hopeful that that pool party will continue and we will talk about philanthropy to start to defray some of the costs there. So there's lots of things like that coming and just like the library, the library I think raised like $8 million and that was like a third of the project. I don't think we'll raise a third of the project here because of the difference of the scale. But anything that we can do to blunt the edge of that tax impact is something that we're talking about. To me, like all cards on the table, let's try to do as much as we can to make this project affordable. More to come about this 501c3. If you're interested in helping out, please let me know and I will connect you to the right people.

In the back.

[Harrison Green]: Also two questions one of them I guess involves this little guy Is with the different phases? Will you said that there was loss or someone said that there was loss of the gymnasium for around two years? Is there a loss of other of like MFN Kids Corner other programs loss of space?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: That's the first question No at the moment we have a phasing plan for all of the programs and There are some spaces like that like the gym and the pool There's just simply no option and there's like no alternative pool, right? But in terms of classroom spaces we are talking about like where do we have to when we take down a building? Where do those where do those classrooms go? Do they just get to go into the phase one part of the new building or do they have to make a temporary move? so There's no plan to have to shutter those programs for part of the process. We did decide last week, though, that the pre-K consolidation coming here to this campus will happen at the very end of the project, fall 2034. So that will be the very last thing that comes to campus.

[Harrison Green]: And second question is about transit and the mess that is Winthrop Street every morning. Is there, could there be a plan to initiate buses or something like that during the project to smooth that while we have additional construction vehicle traffic?

[gy7C3zrS2D0_SPEAKER_02]: We are always looking to mitigate loss during not only the construction period, but also improve logistics after we're gone and you have a new facility, a new site. I think that's something that we can talk about. Our experience is it's very difficult to change culture around arrival and dismissal, but we can certainly brainstorm ideas about educating folks about what it means to drive versus what alternatives are even available, perhaps incentivizing carpooling and look into some of those alternatives.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Thank you. Oh, the bikes. Can you talk about bike racks on the site? Sure.

[gy7C3zrS2D0_SPEAKER_02]: Yep. So we know that there's blue bikes parked here. We'll maintain those from the new plan. We're also proposing bike lanes to new bike racks strategically located around the site so that cyclists can get to the site when they need to in safe conditions and get into the building. We're still determining what's best whether it's a shared use path up above the curb or a dedicated lane On the pavement with vehicles, so it's all on the table right now, but there'll be plans for that There are bike lanes in Winthrop Street, yep

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: That's not us. You're going to have to talk to somebody else about that. Alicia? I have a question.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'll also tell you where you can direct that. So I biked here tonight and the two other bikes passed me on Winthrop Street in the bike lanes tonight at seven o'clock. So people do use them. The Director of Traffic and Transportation with the city, he monitors these. He's the one who helps us get bike lanes at all on Winthrop Street. There was a lot of pushback from members of the community. Medford has a Bicycle Advisory Commission. They are looking for new members to participate and help them with advocacy in the city. That was my advertisement. But as a resident because I am also a parent of a child. Well I will have had three children graduate from here. I was actually curious about a couple of things that I've seen. So I've talked, you started to mention the fundraising. I knew there was a call for that. I was sort of curious about that. And I've also sort of heard these rumors about who can and cannot campaign for the override. And if you can clarify anything about that and whether an override campaign committee is going to get. created that thank you that exclusion that exclusion committee is going to get Created and how people can find out about that because as a city employee, I don't actually know the answers This isn't just a planted question.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Yeah. Yeah. No, those are those are good questions. So I Yes, there is a fundraising group that is getting going and they will be looking at, you know, everything from like, are there grants out there to build a pool to do we have people who came through Medford High and have sort of made it to a point in their life where they're looking to give back and how can we help them do that here, right? So we'll be looking at all of those things. So that is happening and that's getting underway.

and is currently powered by volunteers and we'll see sort of where that goes. We cannot use city municipal resources to persuade when it comes to a ballot campaign. So the city's role in a ballot campaign, right, is to run the election, let people know that the election is happening, provide information about taxpayer impact. What you saw in the debt exclusion, in the override a couple of years ago is a good example of sort of the separation there. So the city authorized the ballot, the elections commission ran the election. There was a completely separate campaign powered by volunteers that went out and helped persuade people to come to the polls and say yes.

If you are interested in that activity, please see me offline. I'm happy to figure out where to point you to because there will undoubtedly be a lot of activity in that way coming up in the spring once we have more information about cost.

[John Anderson]: While we're talking about the debt exclusion, I'm sure we're not the first community to go through the process of having to do an override or a debt exclusion. How successful have these campaigns been in the last few years, and what would the contingency be if it got turned down?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: Sure. Debt exclusions for schools are wildly successful. They are like 85 to 95% yes votes. There have been a few in recent times that have gone in a different direction than that, but overwhelmingly, people say yes about schools. And usually, people say yes for a couple of reasons, right? Like, kids are the future of our community. That's one reason. The other reason is that buildings end up looking like this, and the cost of doing nothing starts to supersede the cost of the project. And that's right where we are right now. So one of the things we're required to look at is, what if we just brought this building up to code, just like it is? And so we know what that number is. It's about $475 million. I know, it's like shocking, right? It is shocking. But the roof over the pool is being held on by straps.

This would have to be completely gutted and replaced. There is no air conditioning in the vast majority of this building. And where there is heat, it doesn't work. So, if you think about trying to rehab a building of this size from a mechanical perspective, it is hugely expensive. So, we know that a code upgrade of this building would not meet the educational plan, so that means no reimbursement from the MSBA. and we know that that would cost $475 million. By comparison, where we are standing with this project, it's also going to cost $475 million. So how do you want to spend $475 million is usually the conversation that communities end up having, and they end up thinking about what is the cost of doing nothing? That's the cost of doing nothing if we did it right now, right? Like if we said we're not going to do this new project, we're just going to bring this place up to code right now, that's what it would cost. The harsh reality is in those places where these fail, it's not that the project doesn't happen. It's that the project happens many years later without the support of the MSBA, and it costs two to three times as much as it would have cost had they said yes. So that cost of doing nothing will probably become a very, very, very substantial talking point. sort of point of conversation for the community as we head into the spring. And so there'll be lots of information, I'm sure, available at that time to be able to help people understand, like, if we say no, what does that mean? And it's a huge risk. It's a huge risk for Medford. There is stuff that is just inevitable that has to happen in this building either way. So I think.

The process, if the debt exclusion fails, there is a short window of time where we would have to work with the MSBA and demonstrate to them that we believe with some adjustment to how the campaign works to persuade people that we could get to yes. The project scope doesn't change at that point and so it's like a revote essentially. So you have like maybe one shot at that if the MSBA agrees with you on your calculus that they think that you can get there and otherwise you have to withdraw from the MSBA pipeline. Any money that you expected to receive is gone. If you wanted to have another crack at that, you'd have to basically start over. And you would start over completely at the beginning. You wouldn't just pick up this design and carry it forward. So it would be years and years and years before we'd be ever entertained back into that pipeline.

What other questions in the back?

[MPS Member Paul Ruseau]: Escalation. Can you, when you say years and years, you know, we're always talking about how much inflation is, but the escalation in construction makes inflation seem like a delightful number. Can you talk about what, I mean, just since 2020, projects are what, 35% more expensive or more or something?

[Matt Rice]: So generally when we're estimating construction costs, especially when we're going out maybe eight years into the future, we are factoring in about 3% on average per year in its compounding per year as it goes forward. And so that's when it really starts to add up when you're going out at an extended amount of time. And when you look back and you think about say 2020 in particular, there was about a 15% single year rise due to escalation. So there are things that we don't know that are out there hopefully, like we all cross our fingers and we don't want anything like that to happen again. But at the same time, there's the unknown moving forward, right? And we can plan for what we do. So the industry standard is that 3% per year, but it does get very expensive as projects move out forward into the future.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: I would say the other thing that we heard, was it last night? We had some folks from Suffolk with us, and they were saying that every month that we delay this project, it's another $3 million. So it's real money. And that's part of why we're trying to move this along as quickly as we can, because every day that we wait, every day that we delay, just costs more money and had we done this 10 years ago this building would have be like half the cost or something crazy like that because of 2020 and so I think we can all like bemoan that we might have wanted to do that. I certainly wanted to do it 10 years ago because maybe my kids could see the inside of the building which would be amazing But here we are and the best decisions we can make right now are to make them now so that people aren't sitting here in 10 years saying, gee, I wish we did this 10 years ago. So that's the hard part of these projects is they're very fraught and all you can do is the thing that's right in front of you and really try to make the best decisions possible. So that's what the building committee is trying to do and I think the community, like all of you being here tonight, These are really important meetings. These are really important conversations. And it's real. This is a real big number. It is.

Is there anyone on Zoom with their hand in the air? No, OK.

[CC President Zac Bears]: Jenny just to add I think it's just important to know maybe matter you could talk about the escalation is Included in the six hundred ninety nine million number. I think that's really important for people to hear So, I don't know if you could talk a little bit more about that

[Matt Rice]: So I'm just going to start by repeating what you just said, that the escalation numbers to the start of the bidding that we have is included in that $699 million projection. So that is part of what we work through, again, with our own estimator as well as Suffolk Construction, to make sure that everyone's in agreement on what that percentage should be. And then what the overall dollar value is that's associated with it. So it is part of the calculus as we're looking at the overall number.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: We have time for maybe one more question. And I'm happy to stick around if people have other questions, but I do want to be respectful of people's time.

[MPS Member Erika Reinfeld]: So, my question is about the student experience during construction. Obviously, I'm looking at this and going, okay, my kid's in it, the construction, the whole time. What are the opportunities for students here? Like, I know we've got a fantastic electrical program, construction craft laborers, art students, all these students who are going to be living through this, but they're also going to be helping to shape this. I hear you. We're keeping them safe. We're making sure that the construction sites are secure. But what is the opportunity for learning for the students who are going to be on site while this construction is happening?

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: So from my perspective, one of the most exciting parts of helping select the CM was hearing about how these construction firms planned to engage with our students. They all had fabulous ideas and experiences doing that. Suffolk was no exception. wants to be our community partner. They want to create an environment where students that may be going off-site to co-op, there might be an opportunity for them to be co-oping right here on site during this project because something very unique is about to happen. Suffolk also talked with us about regular meetings and roundtables to describe for students what's going on, trying to bring kids in in a way that meets their curricular needs.

One firm, I can't remember who it was, talked about a project where they had to do some blasting, and there'll be some of that here. And they had a contest, and whoever won the contest got to push the button that day, right? So there's any number of opportunities. There will be a live construction site right here. that Suffolk is super excited. They already work with our CTE programs, right? In various ways, but they're excited to be able to sort of connect all of that. And we were talking about one of the shops just the other day about like, they're gonna be disrupted in the like pathway to phase three. And we talked about like, can we like rehouse them in a way that situates them like sort of right in the middle of the action. And so those are the kinds of conversations we're having.

[Suzanne Galusi]: That would be the only thing that I would add on is that we've already had several phasing meetings as a comprehensive group. So the OPM, SMMA, Suffolk, our internal team, Ken and I have had many meetings with the principal here, with the CTE director. Very thoughtful conversations about how we can do the phasing to create the most minimal impact for students, especially from getting from one place to the other. And Jenny already mentioned about the moving forward about the student voice, but I do think it's important for you all to know that student voice has been part of this entire process from the very beginning. So even to inform every phase of this work, we have worked collaboratively to bring in student voice so that they're talking about I mean just recently we were talking about transportation and site circulation with students. So their voice is embedded in all of these plans and will continue to be embedded in all of the transitional plans because they're the ones going through it and I know I mentioned it before, but when we worked with students in the visioning process, We also shadowed students for a day. The people that are on the school, all of us here, we shadowed students for a day. And it was very eye-opening. And I will tell you that the furniture is not very comfortable. And the way the classrooms are set up, it's not very comfortable. And they actually talked about that. And they verbalized that. And we actually saw what transitions were like for them to get from one place to another. So there was a lot of learning for the adults by actually walking in there. shoes for the day and that those are the things that we need to inform what is needed for this process in this project.

[MPS Vice Chair Jenny Graham]: All right, we're going to wrap up for tonight, but my plug is for you all to join us again on November 30th at City Hall. We'll be having our first of three joint meetings between the school committee and the council. There will be a brief presentation that we'll get maybe a little bit more detail about the educational plan. We'll get to see those We get to see those beautiful designs one more time, and then we will spend the rest of that evening fielding questions and understanding what are the questions the community is looking for us to answer. So all of that will be happening at City Hall and on Zoom on November 30th. So thank you everyone for coming. Thank you for those of you who are on Zoom for sticking with us. And please reach out if you have questions. We're happy, happy, happy to answer them. Thanks, everyone.

Jenny Graham

total time: 40.09 minutes
total words: 6603
Paul Ruseau

total time: 0.39 minutes
total words: 51
Zac Bears

total time: 0.2 minutes
total words: 52
Erika Reinfeld

total time: 0.53 minutes
total words: 107


Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: MPS High School Building Committee