The commission reviewed a proposal to install an underground geothermal well field beneath Columbus Park to support the Missituk School HVAC project. The commission voted to accept the presentation and asked to be kept updated as design and funding proceed.
[Reggie Graham]: All right, we have a meeting of the method. Commission. Today's Tuesday, November 17th 2026. We only have one item on the agenda, and we have some guests in the room. And, um. We'll ask you to come and present if you so good.
[Kenneth Lord]: This is Brian LaRoche from our OPM PCA 360. We do most of the talking. So we're appearing before you tonight. As you know, the Missittuck school is set to undergo, or the planning phase, let's just say, for an accelerated repair program. So the Brooks, the Roberts, and the Missittuck were all accepted to the MSBA as an accelerated repair program, which includes roof replacement, making it solar ready, replacing the HVAC system, upgrading to heat pumps, as opposed to gas-fired equipment, and also requires us to address any accessibility deficiencies in a boat. So the first part of the process, we go through a feasibility study, and that's where OPM 360, or OPM, and PCA 360, or OPM, and RFS Engineering, they first review different types of heat pump technology, primarily what's called air source and ground source. So we then bring that feasibility study to the school committee, offer the options, they examine the life cycle cost analysis, which one will cost the least over time. which one will offer the best carbon footprint, what is possible, what's feasible, and then the school committee looks at that cost and tries to decide what the best option to go is. We are much farther ahead in the Roberts process. In fact, I'm going to city council tonight to ask for the funding for the project. So they've already completed their feasibility study and schematic design. And at the Mississauga, they're a little further behind. We've just completed the feasibility study. presented that, and that school committee meeting, we went and suggested air source, which would be equipment on the roof. But upon further examination, the school committee wanted us to go with a ground source. We could not do that at the Roberts School, and it's unlikely we'll be able to do it at the Brooks. We don't know yet because of the space required. As you can see from the plans that PCA360 and I'm infested have drawn up, it takes quite a bit of space to drill these wells. And Brian's going to present to you what geothermal wells are, what they do, what they impact the ground, what it looks like after they're done, and all that sort of thing. So he'll be quite the technical expertise to give you some information.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Did you want to share the plan on the screen just so the ones that are at home can follow along too? Thanks for being here tonight. I know you scheduled this for us and appreciate you doing that. Um, so the, as Ken said, uh, you know, the Mississauga Tuck School has a great opportunity to do geothermal well, and the school committee, uh, chose that as the option for the feasibility, but it requires using the, uh, Columbus Park. And, um, because we don't have the area for the, uh, geothermal well. So the way, uh, the well system works is everything is underground. You see nothing above ground. It's, uh, completely buried. And so all of the uses of the park land would remain the same after the well field is done. So the school project would be responsible for restoring it back to the way it was. So it would be fully operational. The only thing that you would see above ground would be a couple of manhole covers. If you look at the plan, between the school property and the ball field, there's a vault chamber. And that would be right at the ground level. And you would just see two vault cover, manhole covers exposed. Everything else would be underground. And so, because we're at feasibility study, we haven't actually done any test wells. This is an assumption of what we think we're going to need for the number of wells. So, one of the early things we'll do Once we get the appropriation of funds, we'll do a test well to confirm how many wells we'll actually need. This is our best guess based on what we could find for USGS geological information for this area. So the well itself is shown in this diagram. This is just a diagram. It's just a blue dot. The reality is it's a 10-inch pipe. And that's it. It's inside that 10 inch pipe are two smaller pipes and then they fill that with grout and that's buried about five to six feet below the surface of the finished surface that you would see the playing surface and out of the top of that well pipe just turns. And then they have these connecting pipes that connect all the well heads together. So it's pretty far below grade, below frost line, and that's it. And so at the moment, they're showing 65 wells at 800 feet deep in order to handle both cooling and heating needs of the school. So we did have a preliminary call with the recreational department And it helped guide us to say, you know, hey, look, we have two fields here. One is the softball field, and it is in high demand. And the other one is a baseball field, which there are other fields in the city that are newly renovated. So of the two that you were to impact, the better of the two would be the ball field. So we've adjusted the plan so that we are not impacting the softball field.
It was like, well, how do we minimize our impact? And so the plan, high level, very early would be, it takes us about three to four months to do the drilling of the wells and then another couple of months to restore the site. So the goal would be to start in February, maybe March, get all the wells drilled. And then when the spring weather comes, we have good planting, get the park restored again.
[Chris Murphy]: So this would take this field off for a year.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: would, yeah, for a spring, for the baseball field would be impacted in the spring. Yeah. So at the moment, the plan that we're, you know, just for discussion, you know, we're trying to minimize, not, rather than impact both, we're impacting one. So that's, I don't know if there's anything more you'd want to.
[Unidentified]: Sure, I can do that. Yeah, so in,
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: So air source heat pump technologies, we use like your home air conditioner, you reject the heat for you, you know, so this can be reversible to use the air to do that. In this case, we're using the ground to do that. And so they're circulating just ordinary water through these wells. The water goes in, the heat is either extracted by the ground or it is pulled into the water depending on the time of year. So, we can do both heating and cooling with it and it's a closed system. So there's no chemicals in the water. It's just plain water and it's a closed system that stays within the school. There's no pumps. There's no equipment that needs to be maintained and.
The only thing we would do is we would put these buried disks underground to detect just like you would a gas line So if you needed to find something you could find it from above ground But there's nothing that would be expressed above ground.
[Reggie Graham]: You would not see it at all The only thing that could really possibly go wrong is you'd have a leak. We could have a leak. Yes That's about that's about the only thing that could go wrong. You said you had two To manhole covers, where are the manhole covers going to be located?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Sort of between the school property and the field, right where the path, there's a, there's a walking path there. It would be basically in the asphalt pathway there. So, as you would walk along the path, you would just see a manhole cover in the ground. You know, flush. So that's it. There's no electricity. There's no pumps. There's no, there's no equipment. All that vault is doing is all the pipes come and manifold together. and then from that chamber get brought in with two primary pipes supply and return. So it's pretty simple in there. So the schedule for this would be, this project is two phase, two summers, would be 2028 and 2029. So we probably would be looking to do the work in the winter, starting the work of the drilling in the winter of February Yeah, so we're, we're a ways away. I mean, this project hasn't even been funded by the city council. We still have to go through that design process and then has to go back to the math school building authority. who's paying a little over half of the project, the cost. So it's the reimbursement rate for the city of Medford is 53%, 53.32.
And so the state's picking up about $11 million of this project. And it's not, as Ken had mentioned, it's not just the heating system we're replacing the roof. And we're doing accessibility upgrades to the school. And of course, all the heating and air conditioning as well.
[Reggie Graham]: I'm sure that you probably are going to ask this question and so on and so forth, but what about maintenance and so on and so forth? Who does that?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: In the well field? Yeah. The school would be responsible for that. This system, the expectation is it doesn't need any work for 50 years. uh, as a 50 year lifespan and because of no moving parts and it's below frost, there's no expected operational, uh, maintenance on the system whatsoever. Uh, so if for some reason, you know, they had to top off the water or do anything that would all be done from within the school, um, because the pumps would reside in the school building. Um, so they don't expect any work that would have to be done. And that's the beauty of geothermal well. using the ground is there's there's the energy that you would spend you know with the air source heat pump on top of the building is pretty extensive and so this project pays for itself very quickly it saves the city operational cost it saves electricity because it's very simple to operate um so it is it is significant to pay back over time uh compared to it through the chair what's the cost to the city up front uh the for just the geothermal system?
[Unidentified]: The whole system, not just the geothermal. The whole system.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, the whole project's about 20. We haven't, we just got our estimates in yesterday, roughly about 24M, but we're, that's total project, everything, design costs, you know, all in, and I'm basing that based on uh, what we presented, uh, for feasibility studies. So we're still early, but that's our basic number. I don't have that in front of me, but it's very close.
[Unidentified]: Okay. So the amount will be on the hook for about 12 million. Roughly.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yes. Now, geothermal has a benefit of, uh, the IRA, the federal tax credits. Uh, we'll be going after that. Uh, and that's about $2 million, uh, in reimbursement. So the actual share for Medford for this school is a little less than what we're. predicting for Roberts and for Brooks because we get more incentives. The Mass Save program gives you better reimbursement too, that's the state level and then the federal tax credits. And then Ken and I had a call recently with the Mass School Greenworks and there's other grants that were opened up to us that we'll be applying for because of the geothermal, there may be even a lot more money. I mean, millions of dollars, a few more million dollars coming to the project if we get them. A lot of competition, so I can't really tell you for sure that we'll get them. It's a competitive process, but if we do, the share for Medford will go significantly down, and all of that has to do with geothermal.
[Unidentified]: So even though if is a two letter word, it's a pretty big word and methods also looking forward, looking forward to redo the high school and that $700 million. So just trying to figure out how does 10 million, 12 million fit into the whole process?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, that's a good question for you.
[Reggie Graham]: Michael, I don't think that's a question for the gentleman that's sitting here. So, I think we should just think about that. I hate to tell you.
[Unidentified]: Yes, I don't want to. Again, we don't want taxes to go up. They're going to go up anyways, but again. Do we really need geothermal? possibly probably better off than a high school, but we're at a point now where we need to balance what we're looking to do. That's why I'm asking where we're at, what the cost will be and going forward.
[Kenneth Lord]: So just a couple notes the high school project at $700 million projected cost right now, we're working through final cost estimations all the final numbers that also receive a significant amount of MSP reimbursement that will go to a debt exclusion override vote. So on June 8th, the taxpayers will be asked to vote on that project, and we'll know the exact number. And that is an add to the tax base. I'm not 100% sure the funding mechanism the city is using to accelerate repairs, but there are no planned debt exclusion override votes for them that I'm aware of. So they're trying to work this through their capital.
[Unidentified]: So what's your best guesstimate that will cost the city?
[Kenneth Lord]: About $12 million. But just the school or all three just that was cool. So these schools built in 2003 their heating systems are at end of lifespan, the roofs and inside. So we have to do something. By going to the MSBA and doing the heat pump conversion program, we're able to access state funds to do this. If we were to go forward and only just replace the boilers on our own and replace that, we would not be eligible for state reimbursement. The state reimbursement program only allows you to go forward with a heat pump system with either geothermal or air source equipment. There is a slight upfront cost to the geothermal, but we're seeing offsets in tax credits and other things that will help compensate for that and reimbursement.
[Chris Murphy]: I mean, the only thing that we really have to worry about is the field itself. So in that cost, it's making this field better than it was before you dug it up, it built into that cost.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Well, right now, because we're so early, we have the cost to restore it.
[Chris Murphy]: It's in the cost.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, it's in the cost.
[Chris Murphy]: I mean, we haven't designed... I just don't want to hear if I'm still here two years from now, three years from now, whatever it is. Hey, we did this, but we didn't factor in redoing the field.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Oh, no. It would be restored back to its use.
[Chris Murphy]: My other question, the equipment you're going to keep there, Is that able to be stored on the field that you're working on? Or are you going to take up the parking lot? Because the softball field is very used. And I don't want to hear that from parents that we can't park because there's construction vehicles in the parking lot. So is it just the field? or is it the field and staging floor?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Just the field. Okay. Yeah, because they would use two drilling rigs, and each rig gets maybe two workers. So you probably have maybe a total of six vehicles on the field, and they're only drilling in specific areas moving around the field. So everything would be contained to the baseball field.
[Unidentified]: Okay.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Good question.
[Unidentified]: Sorry, go ahead.
[SPEAKER_00]: So are you, do you actually have to dig up the whole field? Are you literally, because you mentioned drilling, are you just kind of making puncture holes all around to put the tubing, the 10 inch tube in?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, so the way, that's another good question too. So we have to get down to that five feet below finished surface to get to that top of the wellhead. So we will be digging a sizable hole to set uh, the drill rig down, and then you have to create all that network of piping that connects. So by the time you've done all that trenching, you've, you've heavily impact the field. And the other is when they're drilling, uh, there's a lot of water to be managed. And a lot of times what they'll do is they dig, uh, settling, uh, pits, uh, so that the water will try and infiltrate into the ground first. And then they pump out of that into frack tanks, uh, to clean the water before any drill water leaves the site, it has to look like a glass of drinking water. It's the standards that the EPA and DEP have for dewatering and removing water from drilling operations is extremely high. So this, a lot of our effort is cleaning the water and making sure that it's crystal clear.
[Kenneth Lord]: Can you talk a second, Brian, about the restoration process and how the Parks Commission might be involved in making sure this was done to their specifications?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Sure. I mean, we are going to be going through a process with our civil engineer to create the drawings that we'll use for bidding. And we will come back to you as we, once we get approval from the City Council for funding and we move into developing our bid documents, I will bring the design team to you or civil engineer, and we can go over the details of the plan of what we're going to do here.
[Reggie Graham]: I'll be fine. I think that. I see Mr. given this on the bump on the line. Um, you know, these are the P. W. I think I think he's right. And so I'm sure that Mr. will make sure that you put the field back the way it's supposed to. By the time, he might be mayor by then. At any rate, I'm sure that he'd be very important in making sure that you put the field back the way it's supposed to be, or the way he'd like it. Yes.
[Unidentified]: Reggie, through the chair, how many other cities and farms have already done this particular project?
[Kenneth Lord]: Accelerated repair or geothermal?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Geothermal.
[Kenneth Lord]: Geothermal. So, you just did 1 right?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: I'm in the, yeah, we just completed 1 recently, a similar situation, a school adjacent to a parkland. And we put the geothermal well field underneath the park. That was in Quincy at the school elementary school project. There are others for your high schools underwear right now. Thank you. Yeah, there are many others.
[Chris Murphy]: That was going to be my other question. Have you done this? You've done this with a park before?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yes.
[Chris Murphy]: And there have been no issues with the park?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: No.
[Chris Murphy]: So I'm assuming this is going to be no different than, say, having a park on top of water pipes or something. Or like piping, basically. So they're basically pipes. Correct. So it's no different than a water pipe going through my backyard. There's the green line.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: So there's a sewer easement. So Ken, your comment about the green line that cuts through the site. There's a city's has a sewer main that runs through there. So yeah, it'd be no different than that.
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's deep enough that it wouldn't negatively impact like field drainage.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: No. Yeah. We're well below all that. Yeah. Yeah. Great questions.
[Unidentified]: Excellent. Thank you.
[Reggie Graham]: people are going to be there. Are there any more questions from the commission? Do you want to just talk about the schedule for the potential test?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, thank you. I was just, yeah, so the red dot on your plan, when we do get a funding approval, which we will be in front of the city council in about four months for an appropriation of funds, shortly thereafter, we will want to do a test well. And so, we've identified an area that's not part of the field. So, you know, it's, it's a triangle of green space in between the two fields. Um, and so that area of disturbance would be very limited. We would fence it off a six foot high chain link fence and enclose the area. Uh, it would have the drilling rig. The drilling operation takes, uh, two days and then, um, then, so it's a day of sort of a little bit of digging. drilling and then put everything back. The whole thing is less than two weeks.
[Chris Murphy]: That won't affect.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: We can schedule that around the park. We'll make sure that it doesn't impact you.
[Kenneth Lord]: As well as necessary. How deep we do have to go, the performance of the well, it can affect the number of tunnels.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: That's awesome.
[Reggie Graham]: Can I get a timeline again? I know you said 2029. but I'm sure that when you start the test, the test is going to probably be sometime in 2027, 2028. Uh, yeah.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: So, uh, this, uh, in 27, uh, spring, uh, obviously we have to work with the baseball schedule. So I know that's a challenge. So we'll figure that out. But at some point in 2027, we need to do at least one test.
[Reggie Graham]: Well, well, you know, if, I mean, if the test well is between the two fields, I'm sure that the baseball won't be affected. So they're working seven to three. And it would be fenced in in a limited footprint.
[Chris Murphy]: So it would be would not impact anything going on.
[Reggie Graham]: But so let me let me see if I can get my arms with my head wrapped around the actual if you get everything Order to plan. Yeah When would you stop this project it would be?
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: like February March of 28 So and then our goal would be to be restoring the park in the spring growing season so we would want to try and get our sod established in that first growing season. Otherwise, if we miss that, then we have to wait through the summer and then plant in late August. So that would be our desire.
[Kenneth Lord]: The project in the school would start the summer of 2018, but that's all inside the school.
[Reggie Graham]: Right. But for our intents and purposes, we're talking about just the field. But either way... Excuse me. So for all intents and purposes, we're only talking about a three month window to perform the work, the drawing and service. And after that, we would receive, and so they would probably be able to get back on the field late fall of 28. If all goes well, right? If everything goes according to plan.
[Chris Murphy]: which we know is the best laid plans.
[Unidentified]: That's why I put it out there, because, you know, best laid plans.
[Reggie Graham]: Right. So, I mean, you know, at the end of the day, you know, we've had a process and the process has been up to this point, you know, we're at this process where we're trying to make sure that our piece of the project is taken care of. Uh, we don't want to disrupt the process because obviously other people have already made up our minds for us, to be honest with you. So, um, I just want to ask the committee if there's any more questions.
[Unidentified]: I have none. I'm all set.
[Chris Murphy]: Chris. No, I mean, I did. I, my only hope is that use baseball signups that you're on outrageous and we're looking for fields.
[Reggie Graham]: We'll figure it out when the time comes. We'll figure it out. No questions, but I
[CAS00002570_SPEAKER_12]: would just be curious as this process goes on to like keep us updated on if funding was approved, when you're gonna proceed with. They don't get the funding, I don't think they'll come back.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Sure, we'd be happy to keep you informed.
[Reggie Graham]: So if there are no more questions. Motion to accept. Motion to accept, I hear a second. We have a second. I'm gonna call the roll. Chris? Yes. Bill? Yes.
[Reggie Graham]: Michael?
[Unidentified]: Yeah.
[Reggie Graham]: And myself, yes. So, keep us informed. Absolutely. Thank you very much.
[SPEAKER_07]: Wonderful, wonderful presentation. Feel free to reach out to me at any time. Any questions you can think of. Are you, are you located at the high school department? It was a pleasure meeting you. Nice to meet you.
|
total time: 1.6 minutes total words: 285 |
|||