The Board held a hearing on persistent housing code violations at 465 Broadway, granted a grease trap variance for a nail salon, and discussed aligning tobacco license suspension language with state law.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Hey, good morning, everyone. Welcome to the November Board of Health meeting. I don't see anyone else in the waiting room, so we'll get started. And it's 1232. Dr. Plattowitz, would you like to open the meeting?
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, meeting's open.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Thank you. First on the agenda is review of the minutes of October meeting. Everyone get a chance to review. Dr. Plattowitz and Jenny, I know.
[David Pladziewicz]: You know, wasn't here then, but I read them motion to approve minutes.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Thank you. We'll take a role. Yes. Yes, yes. All right. On that note, I would like to welcome our new board of health member. Dina Palagio, right? Palagio, close enough. Palagio, there we go, sorry. Dina is a lifelong MedPen resident and a dedicated public health professional, particularly in the area of laboratory sciences. Dina, would you like to tell us a little bit about yourself?
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, sure. You know, I'm so happy to be on the Board of Health. I am. I have spent over 35 years of my life working in the field of public
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: Oh, you know, you're speaking on mute muted. Sorry.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Okay, cool.
[Dina Caloggero]: All right. So I'm, I'm really happy to be on the board of health. I am a clinical laboratory scientist. I've worked in the field of public health for over thirty five years of my life. Um, I started my early career in clinical lab science, worked at the major hospitals in the laboratory field and really got the bug with public health when I worked for newborn screening. I've worked at the state public health laboratory, infectious disease. I used to work with the Maven people. Dr. Alpha DeMaria hired me and I mean, I am just I think it's a great opportunity to give back to Medford and really serve with a lot of my expertise in the field. I'm currently a laboratory inspector. I was a federal inspector for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. And now I'm back at the state working for the Department of Public Health as a laboratory inspector. And I'm just really happy that I was chosen. And I just look forward to working with all of you. Thank you.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Thank you, Tina. We're really happy to have you. And we've seen several biolab applicants here, so it's nice to have that expertise on the board. That's great. That's great. So, thank you. Thank you very much.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: Welcome, Tina. Thanks.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: All right, next on the agenda we have a hearing for 465 Broadway unit 4. I know folks from Charles Gate are here. If you could just identify yourself and who wants to be speaking on behalf. Raven Beck is our inspector here that has had this case for several months. And I believe the tenant is also on the call, so nice to have you too. But if the Chelsea folks want to just identify themselves and who will be. Speaking on their behalf today, that would be great. So, yeah.
[SPEAKER_06]: Hi, I'm Kelly green. I'm the portfolio for pod 3 who oversees that building. Also with me are Julia and Gabriel. Gabriel is the most knowledgeable about this property, so he will be the one speaking for Charlesgate. Thank you.
[SPEAKER_10]: I'll also identify myself. Thank you. My name is attorney Natalie.
[Raven]: Natalie, we can just barely hear you. I don't know if it's something you can fix on your side.
[Raven]: What's going on?
[SPEAKER_10]: I had an update that was done on my computer last night. So, having some issues is that better?
[Unidentified]: Oh, yeah. Yeah. Perfect.
[SPEAKER_10]: Everybody will pass from Charles gate technology is my. So, my name is Natalie. I'm counsel for Charles gate. I don't know if I'm going to have any involvement here. I would certainly like it. For you to get information from the team, so I'll put myself on mute and if I, if I need to. If I want to clarify something, I'll, I'll do that, but I'll let I'll let the team here at child. Give an update.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Okay, thank you. Thank you. Natalie Raven. Do you want to open this up with background history? What's going on?
[Raven]: Yeah, for sure. Um, so we 1st received the complaint, um, back in September and the 1st inspection was done on September 9th. Um, at that time, there were 8 violations observed with, I believe. 3 of them being conditions deemed to endanger. I believe Charles gate received the inspection form in order to correct on September 16th, which would have started the timeframe for those corrections. My 1st, re, inspection was done on. Sorry, October 8th for those 24 hour violations and then they had not been corrected at the time of that reinspection.
Um, at that point, Charles gate did reach out to me, letting me know that they did have repairs scheduled for. Um, the following Monday, I believe, um, that would have been October 12th. Um, and then I conducted another re-inspection on October 19th. for the 30 day violations because that time frame would have lapsed on October 16th. During that re-inspection, one CDE violation had been corrected and one new one had been observed. No other violations had been corrected at that time. Then there was communication back and forth between me and Gabriel, I believe that there were Um, there was repairs going to be taking place on October 13th. so that's why I did the re, inspection as well on the 19th. Um. And then after that, another re, inspection was conducted on November 3rd. Um, I believe, because I did that re, inspection, because there should have been repairs done on Monday, November 11th. Um.
During that re-inspection, it seemed that pest control had been in the unit, but they had just placed sticky traps throughout the apartment. Dead insects were still observed in the kitchen cabinets, and no other violations were corrected at the time of that re-inspection. Since then, I have done one more re-inspection on November 12th. Because there were supposed to be repairs done on November 9th. At that time, 1 violation had been corrected. So now we're sitting at 6 violations remaining.
1 of the violations, but that was that there's not there was never a radiator. In the bedroom, the radiator has now been placed in the bedroom, but it is not connect connected, which means that it doesn't. Currently function properly, however, the ambient air temperatures do meet the minimum requirements in the unit. And then now we are here Tuesday, November 17th, trying to gain compliance for the remaining violations that were observed on September 9th. I know that's a lot of information, so if you have any questions, please let me know.
[David Pladziewicz]: Okay, why not? As of today was the current violations.
[Raven]: Okay, the current violation ending since September 9th. Yes. Yes.
[David Pladziewicz]: Fire away. Make a list.
[Raven]: So, um, even though pest control has been inside of the unit at my last re-inspection last week, um, insects were observed in the, um, sticky traps that had been placed. Um, I haven't received any other pest control reports, um, updating whether pest control has been back in the unit since their original visit. Um, the other one is that that radiator it's no longer missing from the bedroom, but, um, At my last re, inspection, it was not connected to function properly and then. There was evidence of excess moisture under a kitchen cabinet sink that's adjacent from. The kitchen sink that evidence is still there. Um.
There are cracks in the material that's surrounding the pipes in the bathroom. Whether that is asbestos containing material is unknown, but because it's plumbing pipes, we just want to make sure and get those cracks mitigated. And then there is a crack in the top portion of one of the bedroom windows that has not been addressed either. So those are the outstanding violations. And I just, I would like to also note that once violations are outside of the given original timeframe, they do become a condition deemed to endanger violations based off of 105 CMR 410, the state sanitary housing code.
[David Pladziewicz]: Well, those sound kind of easily correctable, I would think.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: except for the radiator possibly, but even though the radiator is there, it's not connected. So as far as I'm concerned, it might as well not be.
[Raven]: Yeah, so typically typically how the hearings do work, so I'll give my background information for the board and then we can some, like, we would open it up to both parties to.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Discuss yeah, we'll do that, but I just wanted to clarify the original said that have they been addressed?
[Raven]: Um, so out of the original CDs, 2 of them have been addressed. 1 of them is the past issue. Like I said, pest control has been in there initially. I don't know if they have been in there since then. They had just placed that sticky traps because from what I can tell, they were not aware of where the. The pest issue was, even though that is highlighted in the inspection report.
[John Intoppa]: Um, pest control is actually currently in the unit and so is the plumber.
[Raven]: Okay. Perfect. Yes, they did. They did let me know that there was going to be, um, a maintenance schedule today at 1230. And then I have a re I have a re-inspection scheduled tomorrow evening. All my re-inspections come after I have been told that repairs are going to be taking place in the unit.
[John Intoppa]: We also would like to add that the maintenance tech is also in the unit. I just got sent pictures of the kitchen cabinets and there are no pests at all present. And when I spoke to our pest control vendor, they expressed that the bugs could be related to the house plants that are within the home. The bugs that he saw evidence of were house plant pests, And like I said, he's he's in the unit right now is doing a follow up visit.
And I also wanted to add that the radiator installation pipes, those do not have asbestos. Those were purchased from Home Depot. We put them in all units that have radiator pipes and ASAP Environmental back in September Did lead and asbestos testing of that unit and there were none to be found.
[Raven]: Okay, that's great. If you can share those documents with us, that way we have them for documentation. That would be perfect.
[John Intoppa]: All of those reports already in your email. We shared them to you at the time of them taking place.
[Raven]: Okay, I will search for those. When did you say you sent those? Because my first email from you is on October 5th.
[John Intoppa]: I will look into my records and follow up with you via email, but I do know that when we did the inspection, we passed along the reports to you guys because someone from your office gave me a call when we spoke about it.
[Raven]: Okay, gotcha. Yeah, if you can just make sure that I'm on that because I don't see that in my inbox.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, I'll send it to you, no problem.
[Raven]: Okay, thank you.
[David Pladziewicz]: I got a couple of points. One, so the pest guy, the plumber guy, and the maintenance guy kind of over there today.
[John Intoppa]: Yes, they're currently working in the unit right now.
[David Pladziewicz]: Well, you could touch base. And the five things outstanding with the pest guy, the insects, and the sticky trap, and just that can be whatever. And the fruit flies, that can be addressed with him. The plumber can take care of the radiator hitch up, the excessive moisture in the kitchen cabinet, investigate that. and fix the cracks in the material around the piping in the bathroom, that's his job. And the maintenance guy can fix the crack on the bedroom window, then you're all done, from what I can see.
[Dina Caloggero]: Correct.
[David Pladziewicz]: So I'd recommend take care of all those five things today, you should be all set.
[SPEAKER_06]: We would like to, however, the tenant has only given us a timeframe up until 2 p.m. And then we will kick our team out. And that's been a problem ongoing, is we will set up appointments. And if she doesn't agree with them, or we don't have the materials needed at the time, so we need to push it a little bit later, and she won't agree.
[Dina Caloggero]: What is the time frame the tenant will allow you in the building?
[John Intoppa]: Today's appointment was 1230 to 2 p.m. We had requested 1230 to 4, but she declined.
[Raven]: I have given you information on how you can go about getting access to the unit. I'm not sure if that was ever pursued or not.
[SPEAKER_10]: So, this is where I think I may want to interject in terms of my communications with Charles gate. I can say that. I've been contacted about, you know, potentially having to escalate this and getting. That's really not Charles Gates preference, really. I mean, well, yeah, yeah, of course, that's sort of a, that's a force measure. That's something that, you know, getting tenants into court orders and getting, you know, and getting access. A, the courts don't like it. They certainly like it to be dealt with on the local level. That's Charles Gates preference as well. So I think that within, even within the context of this board, and I know, I think, I believe, She's here on this call. It's hopeful that this can be coordinated. I know appointments being canceled. And, um, and rescheduled everybody understands that has has, you know. You know, has has things and we want to coordinate that, but their vendors, there's plumbers, there's outside contractors. So, to the extent we can work on that and get access, because I know to your point, you've made a couple of appointments. You keep coming out to re, inspect. You know, if access isn't granted, it just makes the bottom. So there's an hour and a half today. Obviously, the radiators. that the plumbers are, you know, the utmost importance. And then if other things can be done, if we can agree on a time, I know Charles Gate will make themselves available to just get these done. They're not, I think, you know, David, I don't, I'm gonna, I have a very difficult last name too, so I don't wanna do that as well, but I'll just say David. If he's to his point, these aren't heavy items, it should be able to be resolved. And hopefully the next time you go out, It can be done.
[Raven]: Yeah, I think we all have the same end goal. You know, we just want to see the violations corrected and everything. I mean, that's that's my goal. And I think that would be Charles gates goal. That would be Miss Parsons goal. You know. Yeah, so thank you.
[David Pladziewicz]: Well, we could revisit in 4 weeks.
[SPEAKER_08]: may I have just a moment to clear some things up and respond if I may? Yes. Yeah, my name is Atusa Parsa. I'm the tenant currently living here. I moved in on at the end of August. And a couple of things that they just mentioned, they are not accurate. Unfortunately, they keep making inaccurate claims. Whatever I'm going to say to you today right now, I have written documentation I can share and I'm more than happy to share. First of all, regarding today's appointment, it was originally scheduled for 12 to 2 p.m. It was scheduled last week. And Gabriel LeBold, he rescheduled it yesterday afternoon, less than 24 hours before the start date. And it's just right now, I don't know if anybody mentioned this here right now, but after going through all these, I've been here for more than 11 weeks, and most of these issues have been present since day one. And even with the radiator, I asked them to include that in the list.
They confirmed it that it was taken care of via email. I can share all of this with you. And I moved in, I came in and the radiator wasn't there. So I've been dealing with this for more than 11 weeks. And everything here right now is currently in boxes. I haven't even had a chance to unpack. Great. So it's just, they are saying that they keep canceling and rescheduling appointments. and they put it on me. I've always been cooperative. I can provide all the documentation. If I may share my screen for a moment, I will show you actually. Hopefully, you can see this table that I made. You can see here the date for the appointment that they've made and then the status. For the appointment, I can share this after this meeting with you all, but and for every role that I have here, I can provide documentation. I just don't say things I have everything documented written documentation from Charles property management team.
They keep cancelling appointments about, again, about today's appointment. I've been more than flexible. Right now, I was forced to finally look for another place and terminate my lease. So, I'm looking. This is off-season, as you will probably know. So, I'm just touring different apartments. I have one tour after this call. That's why I told them you can't reschedule last minute because I'm going to be on the street on December 1st. They keep making these false claims. None of them is correct. I can also just say stuff about the pest control. Yes, they were right here, right now. And it's not just... I certainly understand.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: I appreciate all your documentation, too. And I guess my concern and my question would be to Charles Gate is, I'm glad you're there today, the day of the board health meeting when you were notified last week. But why since September 9th is it taken to November 17th for these items to be corrected, whether or not appointments were shifted or not, you've still had months to do this. I appreciate you doing it today, but regardless, I think going forward, we expect a little bit more responsiveness from your organization when requested by the Board of Health to address the issues.
[SPEAKER_08]: I'm sorry, can I make another point about Gabriel's point? He said that an inspection has been done here and there is no asbestos or lead in the pipe in the bathroom, and that is incorrect. I have the report from the inspector as well, and they did take samples, but from the kitchen ceiling. And that was a completely unrelated thing that happened on my first week here. The kitchen started leaking, and they just took samples from the kitchen ceiling and not the pipes in the bathroom. So I don't think, I'm not an expert, this is not my field of expertise, I don't believe that you can just reference that report and say that, yeah, the pipe in the bathroom is fixed. There is no worry. There is a violation there.
They just, as I mentioned, the Charles Gale Property Management Team, they just keep making these inaccurate claims over and over again. I've sent them more than 60 emails. I've documented more than 60 emails to them. Mostly they have been unresponsive to my emails. They don't answer calls at all. They don't answer text messages at all. And it's just, sometimes they answer emails. And it's been, I've been living through hell for all this time. And it's just, I keep cooperating with them. I can provide all the documentation. I never cancel a schedule appointment, confirm appointment at the last minute. Again, today's appointment, they just changed it last minute, yesterday afternoon. and I have an apartment to this afternoon. I just can't do it. Thank you so much for the opportunity to talk.
[SPEAKER_06]: Thank you.
[John Intoppa]: We'd like to add one more thing.
[SPEAKER_06]: Yeah, I would just like to add that at the time of that leak, we offered you to be let out of your lease without any penalties. And since then, you've changed your mind and are now moving out at the end of November.
[SPEAKER_08]: I'm sorry, have you ever tried to move out and move into a new apartment yourself alone? Have you ever done that? I had just moved into this apartment a week before your proposed offer. It's just, and you didn't even offer me to cover the cost of my moving. And as I repeatedly mentioned to you, I have a chronic illness. This hits me so hard on me. I have sent you two letters from my medical team, which you ignored.
I don't have anything else to say. It's just everything is clear. I don't know if you keep.
[Raven]: Again, it makes sense, but we will be conducting every inspection and and yeah, I'll keep I'll keep our re, inspection time for tomorrow to since repairs are taking place until 2 today and then we can, we can just go from there. And then I do just want to mention. To Gabriel and Kelly and just everyone at Charles gate. Even if, you know. Repairs are still taking place whenever a to some moves out before a new occupancy can start. Everything does have to be corrected before that can take place. So I just want to make sure we're all on the same page with that.
[SPEAKER_08]: Can I also make a final point? I'm sorry. And Kelly, to your point, your offer was not after the ceiling week. It was after Raven reached out to you and you told me specifically, Morgan, I think her name was, the regional manager, she told me that Since you went to the host department, we now have to move along and if you want to move out, you can tell me if you want to move out as soon as possible. It wasn't an offer made to me when the ceiling started leaking on the first week that I was here. It was after the violations were reported and the order of courage was sent to you. So it wasn't, some people may supposedly see that as a retaliation for my action actually. So yeah, I just wanted to mention that. Thank you.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: So, we can follow this up at the next board of health meeting. Yep.
[Raven]: Yep. I can I'll do the re, inspection tomorrow. Hopefully everything is corrected and then I can update at the December board of health meeting.
[SPEAKER_10]: Can I just ask one question? Sorry, I just have one question. Do you know, Raven, what time are you gonna be going tomorrow? Because I'd like, if that's the case and they're not able to finish today at two, I just think we can just try to coordinate a time to go. It's gonna be a short turnaround time. I understand Ms. Parza has a hard stop at 2 p.m. today, but if they're not able to finish, is there a time that they can go back in tomorrow so we can maybe arrange that? Because I just don't want you coming back, Raven. They weren't able to finish. You're still gonna find noncompliance. So, I don't know, right?
[Raven]: Yeah, I mean, whatever they can get done today, like, keep the reinspection tomorrow update, you know, the report. For whatever can be corrected today and then if more repairs have to be done, then just keeping me in the loop. You know, that's kind of like all. Yeah, the expectation is, is like, telling me when repairs are going to be made. Okay. I'll do a reinspection after those after the date that you're telling me repairs are going to be made. Update the inspection report and then, yeah, it's because typically, like.
I wouldn't do a re-inspection until the time frames are expired and everything. I wouldn't keep going out doing these re-inspections and everything because it's very time consuming. But we're a month past the time frames that were given originally. So that's why I keep having to do these re-inspections because I'm being told that repairs are being made, but then I do the re-inspection and I'm finding that repairs are not being made when I'm being told they are.
But I agree with you, like, if they can't get everything done today, then yeah, definitely try to schedule. Something like another maintenance repair, but if repairs are being made today, then I will do a re, inspection tomorrow to update.
[SPEAKER_10]: That wasn't my question. My question was, since you're going back in tomorrow, so not to have to keep doing this, is there, can we agree for Ms. Karza, is there a time frame that they can go in if they need to tomorrow to finish up? We just want to get this done. And hopefully, Raven, so when you do go back tomorrow, it's addressed so you don't have to keep going.
[SPEAKER_08]: So tomorrow's appointment for the inspection, because I also, I work full time. So during work hours, I have to work unless There is something that I know that it's going to happen and I plan for it and we schedule meetings and work during work hours. Great. And then Raven, I think we have the inspection tomorrow after work hours at 5.30 PM. If your maintenance team can come in the afternoon after work hours, yeah, you're welcome to come. And please let me know the time and yeah, you can come.
Otherwise, please give me a proper notice so I can just arrange my, you know, for today and move things around and plan for it.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: We'll let you kind of figure that out maybe this afternoon or via emails and then we can move on with this.
[Dina Caloggero]: Can I ask a question? So, did we get confirmation from Childsgate on whether They're on site right now. There's a plumber there, and I think you said the pest control. Can those issues be corrected today? Is there any confirmation on that?
[John Intoppa]: I can speak on this. Pest control is going to do their treatment today, and then he'll give me his report of what was done and what follow-up needs to be done, if any. For the bedroom radiator, that will be complete and done today. Then the bedroom window that has a crack, maintenance is going to measure it, take pictures, and get spec info so that I can then place an order with a contractor to get another window placed.
[Dina Caloggero]: How about the moisture under the sink? What was the other issue? The radiated connection will be done, and then the pest control, you'll have the report as well. It looks like the moisture under the sink issue, has that been resolved?
[John Intoppa]: There's no moisture under the sink at all. I'm looking at a picture of the cabinet right now and it's dry, white, and clean.
[Dina Caloggero]: Very good. You should have those reports and the repairs done today?
[CAS00002490_SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
[Raven]: It sounds like maybe the only one that wouldn't be addressed today is the window because you have to get the measurements and everything. Yeah. We'll just follow up with that.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Any other questions, comments?
[David Pladziewicz]: I got a quick question for Itusa. Do you work on robots?
[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, I'm a researcher. I work in AI and biology.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, we got a top scientist here in the room. Who knows?
[SPEAKER_08]: Thank you. You're so kind.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Well, thank you for being here everyone for this and we'll be following up. Appreciate your participation. Okay. Next on the agenda, we have a request for a grease trap variance for blist nails on station landing. And Josh is here to speak to that. Typically, we have a requirement for food establishments to have grease traps and to have them regularly pumped and cleaned. But Josh is here to present why he doesn't feel it's necessary.
[CAS00002490_SPEAKER_00]: Uh, yeah, so, uh, not sure how often you guys are going to get your nails done, but, uh, down in station landing, there's a nail salon. Um, I was initially called there because someone reported that they were serving food, uh, and they were pretty much just drinks, um, kind of like your teas, um, nothing really too complicated. So I'm working with them to get set up with the food establishment and a food permit. And, uh, 1 thing there. You know, having trouble with is getting a grease trap installed based on their operation. They will have a very minimal amount of grease put into the sewer system. Typically, I only receive things like milks, maybe some cream into the system, but there won't be any cooking or anything on site. It's going to be purely for the customers to sit. enjoy their drinks, primarily using prepackaged ingredients and containers. So in my head, I feel like it's a pretty minimal risk to the sewage system. And I might even think that all the station landing flows into a massive grease trap that is pumped, like five guys has their own, and it's all pumped into one big system. But that being said, this is just to get a variance for the grease trap for the three-day.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Any questions? Motion to approve the variance request? I second it. Second by Dina. Thank you. Okay, roll call. Jenny Cartel?
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: Yes.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Dr. Plowitz? Yes. And Dina? Yes. Thank you. Okay, motion passes variance granted. Thank you, Josh. Okay, we're following up on the agenda item that we've had the last couple of meetings regarding our tobacco regulation language in Regulation 18, the one that restricts the sale of tobacco products and nicotine delivery products. The question that we have had around our language as to shall be suspended versus the state's language around May be suspended for those seven and 30 day suspensions. Maureen is here. I did pick Maureen's brain yesterday, a little bit about, you know, if this has been discussed in other communities and what's, you know, if this is a common issue and what's been kind of going on out there. So Maureen, I don't know if we had a good discussion yesterday. I don't know if you want to share your thoughts or what you've known.
[Maureen Busby]: Um, sure, as far as the shell versus may, um. The 8 language actually was intended to be shell and somehow it ended up as may. So, many communities have gone back into the local regs and change the local regs to shell so that it's always the same that boards don't have to make a decision on an individual case by case basis and which. requires more meetings, more works for the board each time you have to decide whether there's going to be a suspension or not. And also it does kind of require very careful allegiance to non-discrimination. You want to make sure that when you listen to one retailer and that retailer describes his or her position and what happened and you know, it may be a compelling story and then you decide to not do a suspension in that case, then you have another retailer come in and maybe just isn't as articulate or doesn't tell as good a story, or maybe they don't even think to appeal it because they don't know the difference between the may and the shall. So for those reasons, many of the communities decided they wanted to change it to shall in their local reg, and then it would be the same all the time, wouldn't have to decide, there couldn't be any perception of favoritism even. So that's the discussion I've heard in other communities, not just in my region, but others as well. I did check in with some of my colleagues who voiced their support of encouraging boards to adopt the shall language and not use the may language, which just opens us up to a lot of discussion and decision making and more meetings, again, on a case by case basis.
[David Pladziewicz]: What does the state reg say?
[Maureen Busby]: The state law says may.
[David Pladziewicz]: Says may. Yeah, as a counter point, and I think what was driving considerations and is to be in sync with the state. And from where one consideration is, I don't think it's fair on the retailers to have different laws that are governing their activities. So that's why we brought it up about having the language be the same. It doesn't make sense to me for the state to say, use one word and then we use a different word. It's just creating ambiguity for these poor people. So I think that's why we just changed the word just to be in sync and use the same language.
So I would opine, if you think it should be shall, I would have the state change theirs first to shall. And then we'll worry about everyone else. They should do that and fix it, because they're the ones who made the error, not everyone else. And I don't have a problem keeping May at the city level, because we do need some discretion, because there are special circumstances. So until the state says, shall, we're just going to marrow what they're doing. They already said, use May. So we agree. We're going to use May. I mean, that's how we had left it. That was the rationale behind it.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: And I don't think we're moving away from the required suspension length.
[David Pladziewicz]: I think we're just the, this was the 1st 1. yeah, give us a little leeway.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: Right? I guess about making sure we're consistent from 1 case to another that we're, I think we are still aiming to do the 7 days. what we're working around is, does it have to be seven consecutive days versus breaking up the seven days over the course of a month or something like that, so.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, so I would just still follow the state just for simplistic.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, it allows flexibility.
[David Pladziewicz]: Let's all be on the same page, yeah, and in flexibility.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, it allows flexibility.
[David Pladziewicz]: And I think, Maureen, we usually, like what the state says, and we want to replicate the same language, with the only exception being the discharge, sort of discharge overflows, because that's a whole different issue. We got to be very stricter than they are on that. But for the most part, the state usually is OK, and we just follow what they say. We usually go with what's most restrictive, yeah.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Lauren, was there consecutive days in the state language?
[Maureen Busby]: It's consecutive days.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, it's consecutive.
[Dina Caloggero]: Let's be consistent with that.
[David Pladziewicz]: Nail that down.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah.
[David Pladziewicz]: We thought we could break them up before, but the language is consecutive. We just want to keep a little leeway on the shall and may with the first violation. And I don't think there's any harm in that. until the state changes this. Yeah, if they agree, if the state wants Shell, they should change this to Shell, and then we'll just follow them.
[Maureen Busby]: Dr. Plowdowitz, I'm so sorry, because I think I may have misled you. I thought when you were talking May and Shell, I thought you were talking about the second two violations. The first violation is Shell.
[David Pladziewicz]: from the state?
[Maureen Busby]: The state? The only decision that you would make on the first, I'm sorry, if the first violation is a sale to a minor, not any other violation. So if it's a flavor product that was banned by the state and that was found and that was the first violation, this does not apply. The suspension on the first violation only applies if it's a sale to a minor. Sale to a minor was treated separately from all other Violations if they were a first violation. I know that's confusing and that one is shall and that was the decision that you would be making on the first violation had to do with the suspension period from 1 to 30 days.
And most of the communities that I've heard about decided, rather than leaving it at 1 to 30 days, which is in the state law language, that they would decide on a number of days, 1, 3, 5, whatever it might have been, Um, and have that number of days apply to all 1st, say violations, so they wouldn't have to meet and decide on every single individual case and maybe decide 1 day for. 1, you know, for 1 store, 3 days for another store or whatever and.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Yeah, we did do that and we decided 3 days.
[Maureen Busby]: So that's the discussion. What I say first violation and then on the 2nd and 3rd violation.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Um, let me see the state languages may on the 2nd and 3rd violation.
[Maureen Busby]: So, on the fine show, okay. You know, this says, oh, you know what I've got I've got a, I'm sorry I'm looking at an updated draft and it says shall. For both the 2nd and the 3rd.
[Dina Caloggero]: for the state.
[Maureen Busby]: Yep.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yep.
[Maureen Busby]: So, um, when you did your right and I should have pulled this out and I don't have a paper copy of med for I think you worked with Cheryl Sabara. Yes, waiting regs last time. Yes, girl would have sent you a draft document with yellow highlights And highlights. So yellow highlights were to update your to match state law and green highlights were anywhere where the board could make a decision. And those are just simply suggestions or recommendations or possibilities or whatever. And then you decided on anything that was something that could be decided on by the board. Right. I don't have that in front of me and that would be helpful. I just don't happen to have a copy of that.
[David Pladziewicz]: Well, maybe we can recirculate that document just to refresh our memories too. And then we can revisit the next meeting.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Yeah. So we had the $1,000 violation, $1,000 fine, and the three consecutive business days we had the shell. And then for the second was $2,000 seven-day consecutive shell. And the third violation is the state's $5,000 with the 30 consecutive business days, again, saying shell.
[Maureen Busby]: Correct.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: And Mary and remind me again for those businesses that were in there, I believe they were mostly 2nd violations. Have we already communicated to them? It's the 2nd consecutive days and they're going through with that, or they're still waiting for that communication still wait for that communication display.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Okay.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: So, and I think part of it was changing the language from shout to me to shout and then deciding if it should be 7 consecutive days or broken up. But it sounds like from what we're saying here, it has to be 7 consecutive days.
[Maureen Busby]: The state law definitely says consecutive days, and I did, by the way, check in with Cheryl Sabara about that. And even if the state language wasn't consecutive days, I would strongly encourage you to do consecutive days, because I think it's more confusing for a store owner to have to take products off the shelf, put a sign on the door, no sales. then go two days or whatever, put the products back on the shelf. Customer comes and thinks, can I buy today or not today or whatever? And also more work for the inspectors to go back and make sure for these two days, the products were off the shelf. Okay, they're on for three days. Now they're off for one day or four day, whatever it might be. Consecutive days, I think it's easier for the retailer, the customer, the regular customers, and the inspectors.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, that makes sense.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Okay, so the draft of the state regs that you have in front of you that say shall.
[Dina Caloggero]: Are those where are they in the process?
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Yeah, they issued it. Are they. So, it was just a generic so it's not the current language of the state law is made.
[Maureen Busby]: That's not correct. You're specific. So I wish I had a copy of yours in front of me. I just pulled the specific, the general one that, and I didn't have Medford specific.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: I guess my question is right now currently in state law, the second third violations say may as opposed to shall.
[Maureen Busby]: Well, the one that I'm, let me see.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, that's the stuff we got to confirm. I think we need both both. side by side, I think.
[Maureen Busby]: This draft is 2022, so it's definitely after the 2020 state law, but I don't know what Cheryl gave you in your draft regs that you were looking when you voted to update your regs the last time. We did it in 2023. Okay, so you've
[David Pladziewicz]: Well, why don't we get the state law as on the books as of today and what ours is, and then we can reconcile next meeting.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Sounds good.
[David Pladziewicz]: Distribute ahead of time with the minutes so we can look at it before the meeting. Sounds good. It sounds like what Maureen said, some way, the differences with different colors or whatever, stuff that we can impact, stuff that we can't.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: I mean, we can change.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, and that will be helpful too.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Well, we had done that back in 2020.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, sounds like we got to revisit it. Yeah, we'll revisit it again.
[Maureen Busby]: Okay, thank you. Thanks, Bonnie. Thank you for also before before you go, since we're on the topic of updating regs, even since then, and you were some of the early adopters and updating your regs to match to sink the state law, which was good. But since then, the TAs, the technical advisors for the MTCP program program, have slightly changed some of the definitions to meet more current product lines, and I don't know if that's something that you want to take a look at at the same time, since now we're four more years out, and there have been new model regs, since I don't want to muddy the water, but if you're going to go back and look at that draft reg, maybe you want to look at the current definitions as well and see if there's anything that you want to update your regs. I wouldn't have suggested if it was just the definitions, but since you're going to look at the draft to deal with the shell in May and consecutive days, you might want to take a look at the updated definitions that they've done.
[David Pladziewicz]: Give us some examples of product lines.
[Maureen Busby]: Yeah, I think the definition of characterizing flavor is really more tightening up some language to make it clear, not changing anything that we're endorsing, but tightening clarity.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, I'd like to probably good idea, get it all because right, if people change in definitions, we should be aware of that too. So
[Maureen Busby]: Let me, I'll reach out to Cheryl.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, anything you think we should know, please send along an updated.
[Maureen Busby]: We call it a model reg, an update model reg.
[David Pladziewicz]: Sounds good.
[Maureen Busby]: Thanks. Bye. Sounds good.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: You all.
[Dina Caloggero]: Good.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Okay, next on the agenda, a couple of announcements. One good announcement is that we have secured the Dana-Farber mammography van to come to Medford. Yeah, that'll start this spring. So that's that's good news. The unfortunate news is that our current Mass General Community Care Van is not going to be able to continue with us. They are realigning their locations to communities that have lowest performance in hypertension control and colorectal cancer screening. So as part of that shift, they're kind of putting a pause on some of the recurring clinics. So that's unfortunate news, but they have been very courteous in saying that certainly if we have any big events that we'd like them to attend or special occasions or special events, that if we give them enough notice, hopefully they can align their schedule to be there for that.
[David Pladziewicz]: Yeah, the flip side of that comment is as a group for residents, not that bad compared to some of these other communities. That's a hidden message. That's correct. Right. That's a good thing.
[Dina Caloggero]: Can I ask a question? Can I ask a question, Marianne? Has there ever been, like, you just said that Mass General is going to delay it. The good news is that the population here doesn't meet the threshold. But have we reached out? Is there any reach out to maybe perhaps Lawrence Memorial Hospital at Tufts at that point to see perhaps they would do it? Maybe partner with them?
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Yeah. Certainly, like, they do offer these screenings and stuff. There was this that this was like, I don't think they have the mobile band kind of, but yes, we certainly can promote, I guess, the screenings that they do, obviously, and should and people should take it.
[Dina Caloggero]: We can check. Yeah.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: And this was nice because it was reaching, you know, underinsured folks out there that maybe have been able to take advantage of it. They did send us between the two visits here. The VN did see 24 individual community members. Two-thirds of them were female, one-third male. The average age was 68. Seventy percent of them identified with an ethnicity other than American. Over 21 percent spoke a primary language other than English. That was some demos that they did share with us.
They also, what did they say they had? 15 vaccines, 15 blood pressure checks, 3 colorectal cancer screenings, 2 diabetes screenings, and 21 social determinants of health screenings, which was really great. So the social determinants of health screenings are questions that identify non-medical social environmental factors that like housing and security, food and security, transportation, things that may outside of medical care may still impact treatment outcomes and health outcomes. So, yeah.
[Dina Caloggero]: So we'll check with Lawrence. Lawrence might be a nice partner for that.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: And then the only other announcements we have is to let you know that On Thursday, we have our winter preparedness event here at City Hall from 5 to 7 PM and that's our major event of the season where winter clothing giveaway is happening while supplies last. There'll be energy bill checkups so people can bring their gas or electric bills, mass health and health connector assistance, information on eating assistance. We'll also have some free food, a food pantry setup type thing. And Jill will be doing flu and coven vaccines for those 6 months and older. So yeah, so that's that was it was a really big event and very successful last year and we're hoping that we can repeat that this year again. That's this Thursday. 5 to 7 here at City Hall.
All welcome and I do Jill's on this call. I think she was I just want to give Jill a shout out. She's she's been out there working really hard pushing the flu and covert vaccines and she's done over 500 so far this season. So. Shout out for our public health nursing. So, Jill, do they have to have appointments for Thursday evening? Do they have to sign up or can they just come?
[MCM00001812_SPEAKER_07]: And we're encouraging them to have appointments just to make it quicker, but we will take walk ins as well. You're muted. Are you able to hear me now? Yeah, now we can hear you. Okay. So we encourage them to have appointments just to make things quicker, but we'll take walk ins as well.
[MCM00001745_SPEAKER_07]: Right. Thank you.
[Dina Caloggero]: Very good.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Hey, I think that's all. that I have any other questions, thoughts, comments, motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn, Dr. Kladowicz, did I hear you?
[David Pladziewicz]: Motion to adjourn, yeah, I thought I was on mute.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: I can second. I can second. Thank you, seconded by Tina. Okay, roll call, Jenny Beitel? Yes. Dr. Plowitz?
[David Pladziewicz]: Yes.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: And Dina? Yes. Thank you very much everyone.
[David Pladziewicz]: Happy Thanksgiving, Turkey Day.
[Director MaryAnn O'Connor]: Happy Thanksgiving.
[David Pladziewicz]: Cook the turkey. Be careful of that kielbasa, it'll give you a heart attack.
[Unidentified]: Take care everyone, thank you.
|
total time: 2.13 minutes total words: 355 |
|||