The Medford City Council approved a $23.6 million loan order for the Roberts Elementary School roof and HVAC replacement, passed the FY27 tax classification maintaining a 175% commercial tax shift, and voted to approve a supplemental Law Department appropriation alongside a request for a state audit of city legal expenditures.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: 20th regular meeting, Medford City Council is called to order. Clerk Siegel, please call the roll. Announcements, accolades, remembrances, reports and records 26203 offered by Councilor Mullane and Councilor Scarpelli. Resolution to invite residents to the Ward 2 Neighborhood Meeting on December 2nd. Be it resolved by the Medford City Council that we invite the residents of Ward 2 to attend the Ward 2 Neighborhood Meeting. on Tuesday, December 2nd at 7 p.m. in the cafeteria at the Roberts Elementary School. This meeting will be hosted by Councilor Mullane and Councilor Scarpelli and residents are welcome to attend and discuss improvements they would like to see in their neighborhood. For more information and for a Zoom link, please visit City of Medford events calendar. Is that still accurate or are we still not getting posted on the events calendar? All right, Councilor Mullane.
[Councilor Liz Mullane]: Thank you. Yes, so this will be the third award meeting that we'll be hosting. We've been really excited about the turnout that we've seen at the past two meetings that we've had for people coming and sharing their thoughts. Councilor Scarpelli and I are very excited to be hosting this one at the Roberts on Wednesday, December 2nd, starting at 7. There's an RSVP code out there. If you see it, please feel free. mandatory, but it helps us get a sense of the different issues you'd like to discuss. But again, it's open to anything people want to bring up and we'll answer as best we can and also try to just help facilitate any next steps from there. If you don't know your ward, which I realize that may still be where people are trying to figure that out, you can go to wheredoivotema.com and put in your address to get your ward to double check that, so please do. And there's a Zoom link available so you can join us virtually. But we really hope to get a good turnout. I look forward to it.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Mullane. Thank you. To my partisan friend, George Scarpelli, could you tell us a bit about the Ward 2 meeting as well?
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: We're so excited. My friend Liz and I have been planning a very exciting evening to talk about some very important issues for Ward 2. But I think most important, what no one else did, Dean is making cookies. So we're going to bring cookies. So even if you don't like us, The cookies are very good. So if that entices people to come out, and I think that's the important piece, to be serious, is really a forum where people can come out right into your backyard and share your concerns and issues or things you might like and things you might want to support as we move forward here in our journey in Medford. So thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. And all kidding aside, I just want to say thank you, Councilor Mullane, and you have been organizing these, scheduling them. You know, those of us who say we're co-hosting, we're certainly the second host of everything. So really appreciate all of your work on this. And if anyone is watching from the city administration really would just, please ask you to put it on the events calendar. These have been great meetings. Residents are talking about traffic safety. They're talking about issues in their neighborhood. They're talking about trees. There's literally zero reason this shouldn't be on the city events calendar. And I invite all of our neighbors to come join us.
Is there a motion? On the motion to approve by Vice President Lazzaro, seconded by? Seconded by Councilor Tseng. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? The motion passes. Records. The records of the meeting of November 10th were passed to Councilor Leming. Councilor Leming, how did you find the records?
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Found the records in order, move to approve.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: On the motion to approve by Councilor Leming, seconded by Council Vice President Lazzaro. All those in favor?
[Tom Lincoln]: Aye.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Opposed? Motion passes. Motions, orders and resolutions 26-208 offered by Councilor Leming. Resolution to request a master plan for the Tufts Park updates. Whereas the Community Preservation Committee is considering a grant for infrastructure improvements to Tufts Park and whereas the CPC funded lighting improvements to the Department of Recreation last year that are unable to be built until the infrastructure improvements are complete And whereas the city of Medford's facilities director is considering future municipal uses of the Curtis Tufts School. And whereas the city is seeking to secure state funding for these improvements. And whereas the office of planning, development and sustainability has secured most of the funds to renovate the playground. Be it resolved that these departments collaborate on a master plan for Tufts Park to be submitted to the community preservation committee and the city council. Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Yes, thank you, President Bears. So this and the next resolution that I submitted tonight are just related to the ongoing improvements to Tufts Park. But after some conversations with some volunteers and members of city staff, it's become pretty obvious that there are a number of parallel efforts that are happening with regards to the improvements of Tufts Park and not a whole lot of communication that's happening between these different parties. So even while we're, even while, you know, Person A, Department A is requesting money, the I just heard a recording in progress somewhere in the audience.
It's become, you know, other departments may not be fully aware of what's going on. So the purpose of these resolutions is to get, is to just really point out the problem, have a little bit of discussion on it, and then try to get some of these department heads, facilities director, CBC Office of Planning, Development and Sustainability to have a meeting and release an exact plan for how these different parallel efforts to improve Tufts Park are going to take place.
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Councilor Leming, because I think this is what we're seeing is that the beginning of something that is so important, but to tie that all in as well, I think that there's so much going on with the playground that was that we've already witnessed the work at Tufts and the question that's already brought up about the lighting and the options that we're going to have with the lighting. Now the flooding mitigations and also the questions with Tufts and what the CPC is doing with Tufts, with the Curtis Tufts School in the cupola and there's so much in that whole area and I think there's There are so many moving pieces that I think the master plan of bringing all the stakeholders together, because the little pieces that we don't think of, and I was thinking about it when I wrote it as a person that's worked in recreation, talking about fields, and an impact of what happens when one field is closed, how that trickle down affects so many. When we look at having our youth sports organizations involved and our director of recreation who oversees the permitting of those fields and making sure when we do projects, everybody's input is added because it does impact other groups that right now, because so many groups are doing so many different things, tying that all together is so important. And I think that's important as well because I know the school committee just, I know they just signed a project for the Missittuck, which will mean they'll be closing the Columbus possibly, Columbus Park. And that park, we have the high school teams, We have youth softball, we have Little League. So if let's say both of those projects went together at the same time because we're not communicating and we're not planning, what happens is all of a sudden, Ms. Scalusi is getting phone calls because we don't have a softball field for the high school teams to play on because we're doing a huge project on both fields. Or Little League can't get their season started, or a girls softball program has to shift and travel instead of stay home. I know that's little things because we're talking about these are really big projects and they're needed, and I think we're all on the same page here.
Councilor Leming is right on point. I think moving forward with this is making sure that we bring in all the stakeholders, not just the city staff and city departments, but look outside the box and look at the impact that it's going to make to our residents and our youth organizations, especially. So thank you for bringing this forward. And I hope that we can move forward with, administration can bring that all together and, you know, at least start with Kevin, with the recreation department and, to add him to any conversation because we don't wanna, we don't want this to fall, anybody to fall through the cracks. So thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. Councilor Leming, do you want to put that on our agenda with any sort of report due or deadline or refer that to a committee?
[Councilor Matt Leming]: I think the motion would be to send this to the Public Works and Facilities Committee and request a report be due in February. All right.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: On the motion of Councilor Scarpelli to refer this paper to the Public Works and Facilities Committee and request the report be due in February, seconded by? Seconded. Seconded by Councilor Mullane. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? The motion passes. Great. All right, 26-209, Resolution to Request a Master Plan for the Oak Grove Cemetery Expansion. Whereas the Community Preservation Committee has funded numerous historic preservation projects to the Oak Grove Cemetery and adjacent Brooks Estate, whereas the existing buildings don't fulfill the need for utility equipment and operations of the cemetery, whereas the findings of studies have been that the existing buildings in Oak Grove need tremendous resources to update and repurpose. Whereas the Dementford Department of Public Works is working on plans to expand the cemetery, and whereas the Oak Grove Cemetery and adjacent Brooks Estate share history and connectivity, and ML is working on an access drive and landscape restoration adjacent to the area designated for cemetery expansion. And whereas the Oak Grove Cemetery Board of Trustees has not released a master plan regarding the long-term use of Oak Grove to coordinate restoration, expansion, capital improvements, or sustainability. Now therefore be it resolved that these departments meet internally to coordinate efforts on these ideas and be it resolved that the Oak Grove Cemetery Board of Trustees release a further draft master plan for and obtain public input on plans for cemetery improvements. Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Yes, thank you. This is a similar issue which was brought up at the Tufts Park improvements. Oak Grove is potentially an even more complex case just because of the additional that are always thrown in there when you're talking about historic preservation projects. But once again, we have a situation where the state, the Department of Public Works, the Oak Grove Cemetery Board of Trustees are having their own meetings about this, having their own plans to expand it, replace utilities, requesting money for different improvements. But after communicating with with some staff and volunteers and City Hall. It's clear once again that there's not a whole lot of coordination between these bodies. Now, I understand that the Oak Grove Cemetery Board of Trustees, have some internal documents regarding a master plan. They are a group of volunteers, a group of very committed volunteers, but I think it would be helpful to have some collaboration with city staff and release something publicly in coordination with the other parties that are working on this as well, so that there's a bit more of a clear path forward, particularly with the expansion of it, as well as the chance to have more public input to that process as well.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Thank you. Any further discussion by members of the council? I'll just add very quickly that as a member of the MBEL board, the city council's representative on the MBEL board, I have been working with my colleagues on the MBEL board. to try to engage with DPW and the cemetery trustees, a board member and I did meet with a trustee. In that meeting, we had a really great conversation about how we really need all of us to be pulling in the same direction. Right now, it feels like the project is going in a direction where it may not be successful, but I think there is a way for us to figure out a better path that includes everyone involved. And, you know, the master planning process I think is really important as well. So that is my hope. I don't think where it's going right now is a good direction in terms of getting funding and then moving forward when you have a lot of the neighbors concerned about it and frankly a lot of residents in the city. I think the way that it's been seen so far I've gotten a lot of feedback from residents who are really not supportive of the project as it stands and I think that should be an opportunity for us to kind of take it back to the table. and come up with something that's a little more collaborative and engaging folks who haven't been engaged so far. So I appreciate you putting this forward. Seeing no further Councilors, are there members of the public either in person or on Zoom who would like to speak? If you're in person, please come to the podium. If you're on Zoom, please raise your hand. And give me one moment to get everything up and running.
[Tom Lincoln]: Does this make me look fat?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Oh, who turned your mic on? Oh, here we go. I think a little levity goes a long ways. Tom, one second, and I'll start this. Good to see you. This is former president of MBELT, Tom Lincoln, one of the people, I think, most responsible for the preservation and conservation of the Brooks Estate. So thanks for being here. You'll have three minutes.
[Tom Lincoln]: Thank you. Tom Lincoln. I live at 27. Gleason Street, yea, these many decades. I served as the head of the Brooks Estate Preservation Association, which predates almost everybody in this room, from 94 to 98, and then the M-Belt up through a couple of years ago. Having heard somewhat about this matter, I felt compelled to come down here this evening to talk about the Brooks Estate and the Oak Grove Cemetery. A bit of history is in order here, I think. Brooks Estate was acquired by the city of Medford in 1942. At that time, it was 82 acres. Brooks Village closed in 1954, and the Oak Grove Cemetery inherited jurisdiction over the property, developed 20 acres of cemetery in the flat portion south of Brooks Pond.
Much of the rest of the remaining 60 acres became a dumping ground, and the historical buildings were allowed to decay severely. In 1994, a group of Medford residents started fighting for the property's future as a public asset. BPA, Brooks State Preservation Association, conducted numerous cleanups, taking tons of stuff out of there, removed junk, construction debris, DPW castoffs, et cetera. After a three and a half year battle, the city of Medford enacted the permanent Brooks State Conservation and Preservation Restriction in 1998 as part of a good faith compromise with the cemetery, A seven-acre parcel was reserved on the property, quote, for future Oak Grove Cemetery expansion. This property has a separate deed with a few restrictions in it, too.
The compromise, excuse me, was based on several logical and practical principles and conditions. First, since the seven-acre portion is entirely surrounded by protected conservation land, it should blend in as much as possible. Visitors to the Brooks Estate should barely notice it. Any additional grave sites, if that becomes necessary, must be carefully designed to respect the contours of the land in a naturalistic design as possible. Second, grave markers would be limited to flat markers, which I believe is actually in the deed. And the access drives for the lawn should be minimal and simple and, again, follow the land contours. and not looking like a Walmart parking lot. This area is not entirely flat, which makes it quite different from the lawns developed south of the Brooks Pond.
I think the public has every right to expect the Cemetery Board, the DPW, to honor these principles if they wish to pursue expansion on this plot. Unfortunately, from what I've been told Council President Bears's made a reference to this, and from what I've seen, the preliminary design proposal is less than satisfying, to put it mildly. It applies a flat grid pattern, does not follow the land contours, require huge amounts of destructive grading. Even worse, the DPW has also proposed a large maintenance yard surrounded by tall retaining walls.
They wish to carve a secondary access road through portions of the Brooks Estate itself, which is conservation land. By the way, the seven acres were deliberately laid out with one entry exit to minimize their impact on the conservation land all around it.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Tom, you're a little over. If you could wrap it up. Thank you.
[Tom Lincoln]: Okay. Yeah. Okay. So I won't say more about the plan itself. But clearly a master plan is needed here. It must include appropriate design. It means flat markers, no maintenance yard, no secondary access road, and a naturalistic design. People in Medford preserved the Brooks Estate in perpetuity for public enjoyment. We didn't fight for this precious land to see a bad cemetery design at the center, disrupt the landscape, and implicitly degrade the values of the surrounding conservation land. I think the people deserve the very best design of any proposed expansion of the Oak Grove Cemetery. And we, the public, the city of Medford should not fund any expansion until we are confident that any project is held to these high standards. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Tom. If there are any residents, and then I'll go to you, Commissioner McIvern, after I hear from residents. Here, I see two on Zoom. Is there anyone else in the chamber on this matter? Please come to the podium, but I will go first to Roberta on Zoom, and I will turn on the video ability for folks to talk. Roberta, if you could give your name and neighborhood, and you'll have three minutes.
[Roberta Cameron]: Roberta Cameron, I live in the Hillside neighborhood. I appreciate your taking the time to talk about this this evening. I don't have a prepared statement as Tom did, but I'd like to echo the last thing that he said that we should not spend our precious taxpayer resources on this without first having a master plan for the cemetery. Over the past eight years, the Community Preservation Committee has funded several studies to look at the restoration needs of the cemetery. And one of the things that was highlighted in the studies by the Historic Preservation Architects was the condition of the garage building and the house on the cemetery, both of which are historic buildings, are landmarks, are visible from the neighborhood, from the community. And these buildings, as was mentioned in the statement that was read at the beginning, will require a tremendous amount of resources to restore and repurpose them because they don't exactly meet the needs of cemetery operations today. And between the historic preservation needs of these buildings of ensuring that we have the operational facilities that are needed for the cemetery in the future, and to be sure that seven acres will be enough in the future, that we have a sustainable plan for operating the cemetery going forward. as well as preserving and working together to coordinate improvements that are being made to both the cemetery and the Brooks Estate, both city-owned properties. We should be looking at this together so that we can spend the money where it's most needed to accomplish the most important objectives. And we need public input to identify what those most important objectives are before we charge ahead, making irreparable changes to this landscape, this historic and naturally preserved landscape. Thank you very much.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. I will go next to Doug Carr, then Carly Nessen. And then if there are no other residents, I will go to Commissioner McIver. Doug, if you could give your name and neighborhood and you'll have three minutes.
[Doug Carr]: Can you hear me, Zach?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: We can and you should be able to start your video if you want to.
[Doug Carr]: I'm afraid I can't at the moment, but I'll, I'll be very brief. I just want to, I just want to echo what, um, what Tom and Roberta said. I think they're spot on that. There's a great opportunity here, um, to have a comprehensive plan, to have an end game for the, for the Oak Grove cemetery that makes sense for the longterm needs of the city of Medford. And I think a great design for the cemetery expansion is possible. We're not there yet on that. but the integration is into the Brooks Estate and connecting it and making it feel part of it. What Tom said before, I completely echo that sentiment. And I think the master plan is a good step backwards just to kind of take in a larger vision so that we can work on the details. And we hope in a very short time to be able to come to the city council with a bond for the access drive to improve that for the cemetery and for the Brooks Estate. and the cemetery expansion as well. I think those two can go hand in hand, and I look forward to working with everyone, all parties, to make it happen. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Doug. And Doug, I'm going to ask you to unmute one more time. If you could just give us your name and neighborhood for the record.
[Doug Carr]: Sorry. Doug Carr. I have a house on Bristol Road.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. All right. I will go to Carly Nesson next, president of EMBL.
[MCM00001627_SPEAKER_00]: All right. Hello, I'm Carly Nesson. I live in South Medford and I am the current president of the Medford Brooks Estate Land Trust. You heard from my predecessor, Tom. Obviously you've already heard a lot of context on all of this, including The upcoming access drive work that we have planned as well and some landscape improvement work to include a forest management plan. I wanted to add to the conversation that the Medford Brooks Estate Land Trust is soon to be writing our own renewed master plan. We had one in 2011 that needs updating.
And that's forthcoming this year. And I think this is an opportunity for us to work with Oak Grove Cemetery to make sure that these master plans, of course, align in parallel as we do have our own missions and work. But as Doug mentioned, the bond possibility might be a good opportunity for us to think about the access drive overall the land overall as we do some of our work, I fear. That our work is and that will be undermined by some of the work of oak grove cemetery inadvertently. I don't think there's any malice there. I just think the Coordination needs to be tighter so that as Roberta mentioned that the funds can be most effective and we won't have to double back. One of the big things that it's easy to point to is our invasive management. If you're familiar with the Brooks estate forested area. We have quite a bit of invasive plant species and we're working to mitigate that to have healthier forest. But when we look at the cemeteries seven parcel seven acre parcel project that project, of course, would open up a lot of opportunity to undermine our work on tackling these invasives and really making us feel like our money is not going where we want it to go so That's an easy, quick example because that's the next thing on our list, but I feel like it's one of quite a few examples as we are neighbors with adjacent land and Tom mentioned that this seven acres is completely surrounded by conservation land and we don't take that lightly. So we look forward to finding ways to continue to collaborate with Oak Grove Cemetery and DPW as much as we can on this project, while knowing that we're also going to charge forward ahead with our Brooks Estate work as well.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Carly. All right. Is there any other comment on this matter from members of the public either in person or on Zoom? Raise your hand now or come to the podium now or we're going to close the public comment on this item. All right. Seeing none, are there any comments from members of the council before I go to Commissioner McGivern? Seeing none, Commissioner McGivern.
[Tim McGivern]: All right, thank you very much. Can everybody hear me? Yes, we can hear you. Fantastic. Thanks for all the comments. It's excellent feedback. I just have a couple of things to say, really, just responding to some of the comments that were made. So I think some of this conversation is a little bit premature. The seven acre project is really only gone through cost and feasibility study at this point to understand, A, can we do it? Do we have enough soil? And then what are the costs look like? The design does look aggressive. It's a kind of a schematic conceptual design to see what costs we're talking about to get the things that we think is a conservative project.
pre-coordination, it's pre-design development. So it's very, very early. The next phase that's planned is really some of the things that we're talking about tonight. So public input, the mayor wants to do a series of public meetings, more coordination with our neighbors, mbelt, I know they have, obviously things have been brought up tonight. So that's all a part of the plan. And currently, you know, the design doesn't preclude any further coordination. It doesn't preclude any sort of master planning or end game plan for the cemetery. So all that can still happen. And you know, nobody's really charging ahead here. I'm going really slow with this project. The cemetery board obviously wants, you know, wants the DPW to, to understand this project. And we have, as Roberta mentioned, some building projects as well. And one of the things we actually just finished was coming up with an alternative building project to compare to preserving two buildings for a very high cost. So this is all just to say that we're trying our best to sort of respond to all the feedback and the commentary, a little bit premature there's a lot more discussion and public input to be had for this project but we needed to understand feasibility we needed to understand cost and we haven't really presented any designs so to speak and we acknowledge all of the requirements that Tom brought up a lot of this work was already done a lot of this planning and agreement work was was done a long time ago and The cemetery board is, you know, committed to respecting that, those decisions. The maintenance yard, I'll just comment on that real quick, but we do have a need for cemetery material storage, especially when we open up lawn 13. So there is an operational need that we were trying to fulfill with this as well. So just wanted to get that information out there. And if there's any further questions, I can be here for a bit. Thanks.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Do we have any further questions from members of the council? Is there a motion? Is this approved? And then are we going to have a, sorry, council, let me.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Motion to approve, send to the relevant volunteers and department heads and refer to the Public Works and Facilities Committee. You're more in this. Do you think February's also?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Commissioner McGibbon says premature, so I don't know. We could check back in in February and then go from there if there's still more time needed.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: All right, well, still motion to refer it to committee and check back in in February. I still think that internal conversations would be extremely useful for this, regardless, even if they aren't fully put out into the public at that point.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right. On the motion of Vice President Lazzaro to approve as amended by Councilor Leming to accept the amendment. Is there a second on the motion? Seconded by Councilor Callahan. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Councilor Tseng.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Thank you, President Bears. I'd like to move to take 26207, that's the CPA appropriations. 26-606, that's the Roberts Elementary School paper. 26-210, that's the school vehicle lease purchase financing agreement. And 26-211, the stabilization fund appropriation request for the new high school building project, out of order.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: On the motion to suspend the rules to take papers out of order, papers 26207, 26206, 26210, and 26211 by Councilor Tseng seconded by. Seconded by Councilor Leming. All those in favor? Opposed? Motion passes. 26207, FY27 CPA Appropriation Requests Unitarian Universalist Church Roof Restoration and Condensed Child Lighting Improvement Contingency. Dear President Bears and City Councilors, on behalf of the Community Preservation Committee, I respectfully request and recommend that your Honorable Body approve the following fiscal year 27 recommendations of the Community Preservation Committee. requesting the appropriation of $10,000 from the CPA Historic Preservation Reserve to the Unitarian Universalist Church of Medford to provide emergency funds for the Rectory Roof Restoration Project, and requesting the appropriation of $50,000 from the CPA Open Space Reserve to the City of Medford's Recreation Department to provide contingency funds to the Condon Shuttle Lighting Improvement Project. These projects will be tracked in the Community Preservation Fund. The CPC Recommendation Letters are attached and incorporated. CPA Manager, Theresa DuPont, will be in attendance to address the Council. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully submitted, Breanna Lungo-Koehn, Mayor. And we do have Teresa DuPont here with us, the best CPA manager I know. So we are real excited to hear from you.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: I know we have some other items later on in the meeting to talk about, so I'll try to be brief here. But I am here tonight to support two appropriation requests. One is for the Unitarian Universalist Church. They are experiencing a little bit of an emergency roof repair needed over there. They have some water inundation coming in into the building. never a good thing, they need some funds. So they are requesting $10,000. I'll mention that, because I'm going to cut off Mr. Councilor Scarpelli. I just want to reiterate to the community at large that religious institutions are eligible to receive CPA funds under the Historic Preservation Fund. This is a building that serves as a community hub. It has four well over 140 years and it continues to this day. It houses a weekly food pantry on Thursday evenings as well as many different community events, organizations, classes, all kinds of fun stuff.
But yes, so also they are on the National Registry of Historic Places. They are under a preservation restriction. So there's a lot of folks above level that are also looking at this project in terms of preservationists. So I'll pause on that project to see if there's any questions, comments.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Do we have any questions from councilors? It's not fair? Councilor Scarpelli?
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: I ask Ms. DuPont one question every time she comes. She stole my thunder. We can pretend it didn't happen. No, thank you for sharing that because it's very important that people understand. So thank you again. And you are the best, by the way. I concur.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: The other project.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: I have one more thing. Sorry. I know. Right. Oh.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Okay. The other project is a continuation to support funding for the Condon show lighting project. This is a project that this body supported in fiscal 25. We got around to finally putting this out to bid and the bids came back a little higher than the money that they previously received. I do want to note that I go on the record by saying I appreciate director Bailey's approach to this. He came to us and said, okay, can we actually just reduce the funding that was received for the Tufts Park Field Lighting Project last year? Since that project is now on hold, as the aforementioned, we've got a lot going on at Tufts Park. So Director Bailey made the request to reduce that previous funding for a project that's on hold for right now to fund this Condon Shell Lighting Project, which is ready to rock and roll. So I just wanna say I appreciated him balancing this out. So technically at the end of the day, we're not asking for any additional funds here cuz we've already reduced that other award. But obviously there's still procedure here, and I'm here to ask for your support in that project. I'm happy to answer any questions about the Condon Shell lighting project as well.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Great, any questions from Councilors? Councilor Tseng?
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Well, I wanted to give you support for these two projects. Both the Condon Shell and the UU Church are I think really important centers of community. They have done, I mean, when you think of social events in the city and when you think of neighbors finding that third space, these two places are important, especially important to the city. So you have my support for this. I think on top of that, I just want to give you my utmost thanks on behalf of, or hopefully on behalf of the city council for your hard work for the city that I think a lot of residents really, really, really appreciate. And they see and they recognize that work that you do for us.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. I think Councilor Tseng. Any further discussion by members of the council? All right. Is there a motion on the motion to approve by Councilor Leming, seconded by Councilor Tseng? Clerk Siegel, please call the roll on this appropriation.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan? Yes. Councilor Leming? Yes. Councilor Moyne? Yes. Councilor Scarpelli?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Tseng?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Vice President Lazzaro? Yes. President Harris?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes. Seven in the affirmative, none in the negative. The motion passes. I was just trying out a new thing where I turn on a mic on each side to try to capture the voice votes at the request of a resident. So, God, they're close. It's tough being up here. Yeah. This is the least entertaining DJ set in the world. All right. We'll go at the DJ's discretion very briefly to 26210, the school lease agreement. Really, I think it'll take us two seconds and we'll just do yours last as the school one. We have approval for lease purchase financing agreement. Dear President Bears and members of the city council, I respectfully request and recommend that your honorable body vote to authorize. a lease purchase financing agreement under chapter 44, section 21C of the general laws for the acquisition of a Hyundai Elantra hybrid driver's education vehicle for Medford public schools, which will be funded through the driver's ed revolving account. Term of the agreement not to exceed five years and further that the school committee shall be authorized to enter any such agreement and any related documents on behalf of the city representative from Medford public schools will be here. And we do have the finance director, Noel Velez. So let us know what's going on here.
[Noel Velez]: How are you doing, everyone, today? So right now, for the past month or so, we've been looking to purchase a new vehicle to support our driver's ed program. We currently have one vehicle with just over 60,000 miles on it. While it is still usable, the vocational program had recommended that we get something a little bit more durable, as this vehicle we currently have is sometimes taken off the road for maintenance, safety maintenance, things of that nature. So our goal is ultimately to have this new vehicle and also have the second vehicle as a backup so that we can continue to have a good driver's ed program and hopefully be able to run two cars at a time instead of just having one car at a time, as we do have two driver's ed teachers at the moment.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right. Thank you. Do we have any questions on this matter? Seeing none, is there any discussion by the public on this matter? Seeing none, is there a motion? The motion approved by Councilor Scarpelli, seconded by? Seconded by Councilor Mullane. Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan? Yes. Councilor Lummi?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Keep talking. Use Councilor Mullane's.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Yes. I think seven in the affirmative. None in the negative. The motion passes. Thanks Noel. I'm doing the one in the middle.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Just very briefly as well, we have 26211 submitted by the Mayor General Stabilization Fund appropriation request for the Medford High School building project. And I have dear President Bears and members of the City Council, I respect the request and recommend that your honorable body approves an appropriation in the amount of $75,000 from the General Stabilization Fund to fund legal costs of the Medford High School building project. General Stabilization Fund, balance of the General Stabilization Fund before this vote is $5,900,523.56. Thank you for your kind attention to this matter. Respectfully submitted, Breanna Lungo-Koehn, Mayor. And I do have a note from School Building Committee Chair Jenny Graham. a support for appropriation of legal fees to support MHS project. Hello, everyone. I'm ready to express my support for the appropriation of legal fees to support the MHS project. In the coming months, we are anticipating a series of requests that will require legal support outside the scope of our school committee legal counsel around construction matters, contracts, and navigating legal requirements with state agencies. For expediency, we plan to use KP law. With this support in place, we can maintain our timeline and ensure a smooth path to the vote in June. I want to thank you all for your unwavering support of the project. This is a project we can all be proud of and I appreciate the time and care you are dedicating to it. Thanks, Jenny. So that's what we have on that. Is there any discussion or is there a motion?
Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Motion approved.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: on Councilor Leming's motion to approve, seconded by Councilor Mullane. Seeing no further discussion, Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Oh, God.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Yes. Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: 70 affirmative and a negative. Could have just done this without telling you. The motion passes.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: but I appreciate everyone trying to help out and make sure that our voice votes do get, or our roll call votes do get heard on Zoom. I appreciate that. All right, 26206 submitted by Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn. Roberts Elementary School roof and heat pump conversion replacement project construction manager at risk delivery method and loan order approvals. Dear President Bears and members of the City Council, I respectfully request and recommend that your Honorable Body approve the construction manager at risk, CM at risk, as the so-called delivery method for the Roberts Elementary School roof and heat pump conversion project, replacement project, as well as the below loan order, City of Medford loan order, Roberts Elementary School roof and heat pump conversion replacement, be it ordered that the City of Medford hereby appropriates the amount of $23,605,562, which excludes the $242,130 previously appropriated for the feasibility study and schematic design costs for the purpose of paying the costs of the roof and heat pump conversion replacement project at Roberts Elementary School, including the payment of all costs incidental or related thereto the project, which proposed repair project would materially extend the useful life of the school and preserve an asset that is otherwise capable of supporting the required educational program, and for which the City of Medford may be eligible for a grant from the Mass School Building Authority, MSBA, set amount to be expended under the direction of the Medford School Committee. To meet this appropriation, the Treasurer, with the approval of the Mayor, is authorized to borrow a set amount under Mass. General Law, Chapter 44 or pursuant to any other enabling authority. The City of Medford acknowledges that the MSBA's grant program is a non-entitlement discretionary program based on need as determined by MSBA, and any project cost the City of Medford incurs in excess of any grant approved and received by the MSBA shall be the sole responsibility of the City of Medford, provided further that any grant the City of Medford may receive from the MSBA for the project shall not exceed the lesser of one, 53.32% of eligible approved project costs as determined by the MSBA or two, the total maximum grant amount determined by the MSBA and that the amount of the borrowing authorized pursuant to this vote shall be reduced by any grant amount set forth in the project funding agreement that may be executed between the City of Medford and the MSBA. A representative of the Medford Public Schools will be available to speak to these requests. Respectfully submitted, Breanna Lungo-Koehn, Mayor. We also did receive from KP Law a loan opinion in accordance with the provisions of City Council Rule 30. We examine the above loan order as to its legality and respectfully transmit this letter in notification of our findings. In our opinion, let me see if I can summarize this one. This is in proper legal form and further the projects to be financed are valid purposes for which the city can borrow. So we have that. It's our city that understanding the city's bond council prepared and reviewed the loan order. With all of that, Brian LaRoche, you are Brian LaRoche on Zoom, correct? We will make you a co-host and you can share your screen and give us a presentation on this project for our Roberts Elementary School.
[Kenneth Lord]: Good evening. I'm Ken Lord. I'm the chief operations officer of the school district. I'm here tonight with Brian LaRose from PCA 360, who is our owner's project manager for our three accelerator repair programs for the Roberts, the Brooks, and the Mississippi elementary schools. And tonight, as President Bears said, we are here to present to you the schematic design and funding request for the Roberts Elementary School. So I'll turn it over to Brian, who will tell this much better than I can.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: Sure. Thank you very much for having me. Brian LaRoche, PCA 360. I'm the project director for all three projects. I'll present to you Roberts Elementary School. So briefly, this is a project that we're early in the process. We just completed the schematic design. The project was submitted to the MSBA and went to the MSBA board on October 28th. The board approved the project Now the matter is referred back to the community to vote the appropriation of funds for us to be able to move forward. So after we conclude the process with the city council and appropriation of funds, the project will move into the construction document phase and prepare the bid documents to go out to bid. So we're expecting this project to be built over two summers. Our intention is for next summer we'll start doing some of the enabling work and then we'll go into the summer of 2028.
So as mentioned in the vote language, this is an ARP project, an accelerated repair project with the Mass School Building Authority. So they are participating in funding the project, partially funding the project at 53.32%. And the scope of the work is to do several things. Primarily, it's an HVAC conversion project to electrify, decarbonize the building. And as part of that, they also are participating in the roof replacement as well. So those are the two biggest scopes of work that we're doing on the project. And as part of the dollar threshold that we're hitting, it causes us to have to look at the building from a code standpoint. So even though the building is not that old, it was opened in 2003, we did find some deficiencies in terms of accessibility. So as part of this project, we have to bring the building up to code for accessibility. work that's involved there and we're also going to be making the building future ready for electrifying other portions beyond the HVAC as well and I'll talk about that in just a minute. So this is an air source heat pump project. So currently there's a gas fired boilers that provide heat and the roof has a air-cooled chiller. So the project will be a new air source heat pump, so heating and cooling is going to be done through the air, all electric. that will replace the gas-fired boilers. The, we will have electric boilers that will be there on an emergency basis. But this design is designed to go down to about 5 degrees. So a little different than some of the heat pump technology of even 5 or 6 years ago. This is a cutting edge system that will be done. So as part of the work, we're going to be replacing all the unit ventilators throughout the building.
So, you know, the air handlers in the mechanical room, because of the tight space, we're going to be restoring those, replacing the guts, the coils, the fan, and so forth. So they'll essentially be new and we'll be putting in a brand new building automation control system throughout the building. So as I mentioned, as part of the planning, we're going to be upsizing the electric service to handle the increased electric need of the school with this air heat pump system. Currently, the commercial kitchen is gas fired equipment. We'll make sure that the new electric service that we're doing as part of the HVAC project will be sized large enough that if in the future that kitchen were converted to gas, or excuse me, from gas to electric, that the new electric system could handle that. And the same with the domestic hot water heaters. They were only just replaced within the last year. And because of that investment by the city, it doesn't make sense for us to replace them at this time. But we will put in the electric service so that the next time that they have to be replaced, that they can be converted to electric. So after that is done, the entire building will be fully electric and no fossil fuels in the building.
As part of the plan here too is to make the roof solar ready. So there's a roof layout that will have the electric needs of the school between 50 and 20 percent will be accommodated by the solar array panel. And just because the school's occupied year round, a portion of the electric generated will go back to the grid and will be sold back. So at the moment, the project budget is anticipating a purchase solar that the city of Medford would own, but the team has been talking about potential of a PPA as well. So that remains to be decided, but at this point is the planning and the budget that you have before you is anticipating that we will purchase the solar. So the total project budget, this is on the left, is a very summarized version of the Mass School Building Authority 3011 budget. But generally speaking, the soft costs about 3.2 million. Construction costs at 19 million. Other project costs at 200,000 and contingencies a little over a million. For a total project cost of 23,847,692.
We will be, because of the project with the heat pumps, we will be getting incentives from Mass Save. And because we're into a custom program, until it's fully engineered and designed, we won't get the final number. But this is the preliminary number that we received from Mass Save, just under 600,000. And the Mass School Building Authority, when you look at their participation, will be about 11.6 million. They do have some exclusions, which I put the portion of their detailed budget on the right, and you can see that there are $894,000 of exclusions. That's related to the purchase solar. So that's just the state excluding their participation and reimbursing the cost of a purchase solar. But they will participate fully in preparing the building Upgrading the electric conduits, the roof replacement is all part of making the building solar ready. All of that is fully reimbursed. So the 894 is just that purchased. So if we do do a PPA, that reimbursement rate to the total cost will actually go up because the MSBA doesn't exclude anything on a PPA because the third party fronts all of the capital costs. So with that, That is all I have for you. So if you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Councilor Scarpelli.
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: Thank you for your, your presentation. I think it's, it's very thorough. I think that when you hear the number $23 million, everybody gets nervous. And I think that I want everybody to take a deep breath and think back 15, 20 years ago, if we had the discussions about the project that's called the high school. And we think the money would have saved if we thought ahead. And I appreciate that we're thinking ahead and looking at a project that is probably covered half by the MSBA in reimbursement. So it's half of that, I believe. So I think it's very important.
Being someone that I love solar, and I think that it's important. Have we had any discussions to look at, you know, not just on the roof, but also our parking lots? And we're seeing that pop up everywhere to help with the cost, especially if we're going to full electric. I think we maximizing the opportunity, you know, I will be asking with the new high school project that we look at our parking lot being solar ready. like Lincoln Sudbury, I look at Hormel Stadium and the electrical cost of the hockey rink or the lights at the stadium and looking at that area to be solar ready. I do think there's other opportunities that I hope we can look into as we progress through this, not with this actual project, but as we look to move the city along with, you know, being, you know, with our green initiative and making sure that we're eliminating all fossil fuels, so. But I appreciate that.
[Kenneth Lord]: Sorry. Yep. The high school project does contemplate solar over a project.
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: Right. Thank you. But I appreciate the hard work and I just wanted to clear the numbers so we see. But it doesn't, it's not as painful as people sound. So if we fast forward 10 years and do nothing, we might be looking at three times that. So appreciate it.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. And, you know, I appreciate the work that you and the school team have done to really get us in on, I can't think of a school that's not working on an MSBA project right now. And that's really important because that funding helps us do these essential projects. Otherwise, we'd be paying 24 million instead of 11 and a half. So it's big savings, Councilor Tseng.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Thank you. I just wanted to highlight that it's fiscally responsible to do this now rather than to kick the can down the road, wait for costs to accrue, wait for inflation. kick in even more and ultimately be stuck with the higher bills. So I think it's important that we take action now. I'm also really impressed by the level of future-proofing that you guys are presenting to us tonight, especially with regards to being more climate-friendly and more accessible for our students. I just had a quick question on the project itself about, I know most of the work that's that we're trying to do is going to be in the summer. If it goes into the school year, do we have a plan with regards to where students and teachers are learning or kind of the effect that it might have on them? Or because it's the roof and HVAC system, there's not much of an effect? If you could speak to that. I can absolutely take that.
[7eh2EusWqec_SPEAKER_22]: So if we were to do, say, any work in between the two summers, it would be strictly limited to mechanical back house areas or if we're setting units on the roof. But the building has to remain fully occupied and operational throughout the two summers. So that's number one for us is making sure that that happens.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Great. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Do we have any further questions for the project folks, for members of the council? All right, I'm gonna stop the share. Do we have any comments from members of the public either in person or on Zoom? Please raise your hand on Zoom or come to the podium in person. All right, seeing none, on the motion of Councilor Scarpelli to approve, seconded by? Seconded by Councilor Leming. Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan? Yes. Councilor Leming?
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Mullane? Yes. Councilor Scarpelli? Yes. Councilor Tseng? Yes. Vice President Lazzaro? Yes. President Bears?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes, I've never been tempted to vote differently because of how someone's voting, but here we are. 7 in the affirmative, 9 in the negative, the motion passes. Congratulations on all the great work you're doing and we really look forward to any updates you may have in a few months on all of the projects that you're working on to make sure our schools are maintained. Thank you.
[Kenneth Lord]: Appreciate your support.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: You got it. All right, to the regular order of business, communications from the Mayor 26202, submitted by Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn. Supplemental appropriation for fiscal year 2027, the law department. Dear President Bears and members of the city council, I respectfully request and recommend that your audible body approves the following supplemental appropriation for fiscal year 2027 to fully restore the balance of the proposed law department budget originally presented on June 4th, 2026. Salaries $127,803.44, ordinary $141,492.37, $269,295.81 total. And to meet this appropriation that that sum be raised and appropriated from the fiscal year 2027 tax levy.
Chief of Staff Nazarian will be in attendance. That was at the last meeting. Chief of Staff Nazarian is not available tonight, which will be the last opportunity to levy the funds as the tax classification hearing has been scheduled. Approving these funds before, by or before would also avoid a scenario where we leave $269,000 unlevied. Thank you for your kind attention to this matter. Sincerely, Breanna Lungo-Koehn, Mayor. At the last meeting, We did table this. I had spoken with a number of folks in municipal finance who said that the levy deadline was not an end-all be-all on this project and that there were a number of other municipal finance tools that could be used to make sure that this funds could be levied. and then that we could continue with the agreement that I made alongside Councilor Mullane and Vice President Lazzaro earlier this month with the administration. The administration did reply to my messages and say, nope, take it or leave it. This is where we are. We're not going to explore those alternatives for a number of reasons. And today we received a number of messages from city department heads and staff Which leads me to believe that, you know, the administration has basically instead of, you know, coming to the meeting and to talk to us and try to come up to an agreement or at least an understanding has kind of put on, put the pressure campaign, put the screws to us as is the norm. So that's where we are. I just want to say very quickly to all the city department heads and staff and I do plan to try to send this out by email in just a second. that I'm very sorry that you've been dragged into this game of chicken by the administration. You don't deserve to be in the middle of brinksmanship and bad faith negotiation tactics. As the council has made repeatedly clear, there is no desire to interrupt legal funding, absolutely zero desire. The council has been asking for an independent third party review of our city's legal practices for over nine months. I've repeatedly implored the mayor and the chief of staff to come to agreement and then to stick to the agreement that we made earlier this month that will guarantee both legal funding and legal accountability. Only two weeks ago, the mayor and chief of staff had agreed to move forward with the review and begin to hire a firm or engage the state auditor. And the council immediately approved an additional month of funding for November that very day at a special meeting that we scheduled just to get that done. Councilors also stated that they would approve at least three to four months more of legal funding when the mayor and administration provided a progress report and the remainder of funding after the review was completed. Over the past few days, the city administration is now saying that they will not move forward with this agreement. and that they will put the city at grave risk by leveraging all of the city's legal funding on removing any power and ability for the city council to ensure that the independent review actually occurs. I and other Councilors have worked very hard to reach and move forward on a fair agreement with the mayor and her team. And it is incredibly disappointing that they've gone back on this agreement and caused so much anxiety and fear among our city staff. I'm credibly sorry that you've all been dragged into this. You and your teams do incredible work for our city and you deserve better than this. So I just wanted to say that out loud to all the city staff. The only folks we've heard about this from are city staff, and not from residents today, but they don't deserve this. So I apologize that you've been dragged into this by the city. With that, I'll go to Vice President Lazzaro, and then Councilor Leming, and then Councilor Mullane.
[Councilor Emily Lazzaro]: Thank you. As President Bears mentioned, he and I and Councilor Mullane met with the mayor and the chief of staff before last week's meeting. And I believed that we had an understanding about what we how we were going to proceed in which they had a set period of time to the they being the mayor and the chief of staff had a set period of time in which to find Three quotes from agencies that could do an audit, an independent audit of the city's legal expenditures.
Today, well, today I talked to the mayor on the phone. She said that it's been really hard to find agencies that would tell her how much it would cost to get an independent review. I don't think that that is the primary issue. I think it's a matter of prioritizing, and I think it's a matter of negotiation. And I won't win in a negotiation with Mayor Lungo-Koehn because it's more important to me that we not continue negotiating with the departments of our city that need to operate. And I think the mayor would carry this on until, I mean, a metaphor I used was that like if she was, I mean, if we were really having a high stakes negotiation, And we were violent people, like one of us would do something really appalling and one of us wouldn't. And I'm just not going to do anything ridiculous here. It's an audit of a law department. It's not difficult to call an office. The mayor said she had too many meetings to call during the day. She had to call in the evening. And funnily enough, other people in their offices, they were not there in the evening. and she couldn't reach them. So she couldn't get information about what it would cost for these people to audit our law department. So it was impossible. I just, like, don't think that's accurate. I think you can just ask somebody else to call those offices. President Bears gave you a list of five different agencies that could conduct this audit. It's not President Bears' job. President Bears managed it. Where did he find them?
The point is it's all so boring. I don't want to do this anymore. I just want to move forward and do the business of the city. I don't want to negotiate with Mayor Brianna anymore. I don't want to do it. And I would like the business of the city to carry on. And also we have received many emails from department heads today as though we have not been talking about this publicly for many weeks. I appreciate everybody's budgets being really important. I agree with you that your budgets are really important. I agree with you that legal representation is very important. I also received an email after talking to the mayor saying we're going to post the city solicitor position, and we're going to hire a city, well, theoretically, we're going to hire a city solicitor after we post this position. Tomorrow morning, once you guys pass this budget, we're going to post the city solicitor position, and then we're going to have a city, theoretically, we're going to have a city solicitor after that. Who knows if that will happen? There were a lot of meetings that I've had with Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn, where she said she'd do something, and then it didn't happen. So, I don't know.
I don't know. It's in writing. But does that, I don't know. It's not a signed contract. It doesn't matter. Nothing matters. So primarily, I don't want to talk about this anymore. I don't want to get any more emails. I don't want to talk about it anymore. It's ridiculous. I want to fund the fire department so they don't get hurt. I want to pay the librarians. Do you know why the librarians are getting paid? Because, I'm not getting into it. I can't get into it. It makes me insane. It makes me go insane. You guys know, like you guys know, you know, you all know, I can't do it anymore. Okay, I'm going to stop talking.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Vice President Lazzaro, thank you. I'm going to go to Councilor Leming and then via Councilor Mullane and then Councilor Tseng. Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: I agree. I'm also tired of talking about it. I've been on, I mean, in the times that I have, talked to the mayor on the phone. You can't really rely on her word. It just doesn't matter. As soon as it becomes inconvenient to keep it, anything that's said just gets thrown out the window. It is frustrating to deal with somebody like that, and it's why this has gotten as far as it has. I mean, truth be told, I don't really care about this as much as some of my other colleagues, but when it gets to the point where there's a request in February, nothing happens, I, like, One of my colleagues and I just asked her to fill out a spreadsheet with settlement amounts. She says she'll do it, then it doesn't, and now we're asking, you know, what, for the state auditor to audit the legal budget, and then that costs, like, what, $10,000 to do. You know, she said she would do it behind closed doors, and I think we're just going to kind of get the roll around. It's just because the mayor says she would do something doesn't mean it's going to happen.
When you're at the point where you can't get along with the city council, you can't get along with the school committee, you can't get along with the unions, and you have staff and department heads that are just leaving left, right, and center, you kind of have to wonder, why is all this happening? Like, I really just want to see some self-reflection on this issue. But, you know, I'm committed to voting no on this because we have been in this game of chicken before, and I just, I don't want to play it. I feel like we're, if, Bending bending on something like this is It sends a bad message considering that we haven't really gotten anything except a promise to post a position that's been vacant for a year, which in literally any other context is like, you know, very basic. You know, the city solicitor was fired a year ago and the position hasn't even been posted yet, which shows how seriously this issue is being taken. So that's what I got. Thank you. Thank you everybody for listening.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right. We'll go to Councilor Mullane and then Councilor Tseng and then Councilor Callahan. Councilor Mullane.
[Councilor Liz Mullane]: Thank you. I have to say, I have been so surprised about how long that this has gone on. As someone that, when I ran and I went to get a graduate degree within budgeting and finance, I truly thought this would not be that difficult of situation just to provide that information. I've worked with a variety of budgets in different amounts. Normally, if I need to pull how much I've spent on a vendor, I'm usually able to get that information quite easily. So, I honestly never thought we would be at this place going back and forth about how much money has been paid out, which is what has been so surprising to me in this entire conversation. I would never have imagined that this would be so difficult to do, and actually makes me, you know, maybe we should look at what our budgeting software and the rest of it is because this really shouldn't be this tough. As someone that was also on the conversation with Councilor Lazzaro and President Bears with the mayor, I thought we had approached a good faith conversation. I thought that we left there with some solid next steps and although I did find some of it a little bit circular in the conversation, going back to certain things. I honestly thought at the end of the day we had moved past it, moved forward.
And I think President Bears, because he was the one that actually brought the different places that could be called. I mean, everything that the City Council has done, Councilor Callahan has brought up a spreadsheet that we could use. Councilor Scarpelli has told us about budgets that he used to see in the past, or line item that we used to have. So all of it is just so surprising to me that this is so difficult. the threats and the emails coming through. And if this doesn't get passed, then all of these other things are in jeopardy. And honestly, I don't know, truly. I don't know where the truth in that lies. And I would love to be able to call a city solicitor and ask that question and figure that out. But again, we don't have that.
I am truly hopeful that we will be able to get a city solicitor posted, and I would like to go as far to say, and I say to all of the residents, let's get that posted and let's also hold the mayor accountable that it gets filled, that it's not just, you know, an open, vacant position going on and on. Because we're going to be stuck in the same position again. And I will not forget what happened in this entire budgeting. This was my first time through this experience. A lot of things surprised me about how we do things, how businesses run through the mayor.
Having this conversation over and over again, I too want to say to all of the city department heads who sent us emails, it has never been our intent at all. We were just trying to get the facts from the residents who have been asking us. Again, never thought it was going to be as difficult as this has been made out to be. And truly, we just want the business of Medford to move forward and You know, it's upsetting that we're in this situation. It's unfortunate, these kind of threats. And again, the mayor has the power in all of this. And we're just trying to point out the discrepancies that we're seeing and get some extra information on behalf of residents. And apparently, that's a very difficult thing to do. So I agree with Councilor Lazzaro. I don't want to keep having this conversation over and over again. I want to see things improve. And I will definitely remember this moving forward as we look at budgets because I have a whole new understanding and realization of things that need to be focused on a bit more moving forward. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. I'll go to Councilor Tseng, Councilor Callahan, and then Councilor Scarpelli.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Before I commit to any vote, I just had a few questions. Chief of Staff Nazarian is not present. Great.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes, no one from the administration is present. They did tell us they wouldn't be present.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Okay, I must have misread that letter.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes, and then.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: It does say will be in attendance. That was last week. I see. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I'll just pose the questions now, so folks know what I'm thinking about. I think my first question was, we've heard from We've heard that, or at least I have heard that the auditor will do this for $10,000, which really isn't a crazy amount for an audit like this. The state auditor's office are the state's experts on doing something like this. And they're doing it at cost. So I was curious why the city was still looking at private firms when we have something that we know is at cost and from the experts. So that was my first question. And my second question was just to get a commitment from the administration that they would start hiring for a city solicitor and that we would have a better view of, with regards to hiring and probation, what the administration's thinking about when they make those choices.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Tseng. Councilor Callahan.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: Thank you. So we began asking for information in February. By a couple of months later, when we still had not gotten any information, I looked back at what we had requested, because I was like, wow, is it really complicated? It was not. I converted it into a spreadsheet just to make it simpler for them, with six columns, not complicated. It's pretty standard information they should be able to answer. for all the different lawsuits that we've been involved in.
And then after essentially not, like we then used a more official means to try to get this information and still did not get the information that we asked for. At that point, we were in budget season and the mayor basically threatened that she would not give these library workers who are paid well below every other municipality our part-time library workers who were paid just so far below what any other library workers are paid, that she basically threatened to not give them their salary increase if we continued to ask questions.
I see this, what's happening right now, as a continuation of that. that basically she was willing then to punish people who had absolutely nothing to do with this, completely nothing to do with this question about legal spending. She's perfectly happy to just punish them because she knows that we are unwilling, we do not want them to be punished. This feels very similar. So she has now basically threatened that she's not going to let anyone in the administration have anything that they need from a legal standpoint. She will punish all the workers in the administration if we don't drop our requests for information.
Because there are a lot of ways this could be resolved very quickly. Among them, simply agreeing to do the audit or putting, we've suggested some other ways of like putting the money into a certain, a separate budget item where it would be spent appropriately, you know, it would be fiscally responsibly put into a separate line item that would then be able to be spent for these legal bills. this way of obviously sending a message throughout the administration saying that she will essentially punish all of these departments and the workers in these departments, I find it really incredibly off-putting and beneath the office of mayor for someone to use these kinds of tactics.
So I'm really very disappointed. You have to ask, why? You have to wonder, is the information that we are asking for that would be discovered in an audit really that bad? Or is it simply a personality type that will go to the ends of the earth and burn it all to the ground, because she doesn't get her way. And I can't really see any other options there. Either the information is that bad, or she's just perfectly happy to burn it all to the ground and punish innocent people, because she's going to get her way.
All of that being said, I do not want any of these departments being punished. I do not want any of the people in the administration to feel this horrible pressure and have their ability to do their job threatened. I also, even a month ago, two months ago, was very tired of this entire conversation. I think, frankly, we've gotten enough information at this point to understand that These bills were not, our legal bills have not been paid out of the legal budget line item, which we were told for years that they were. Now we're finding out they're paid out of the fire department budget, they're paid out of the school budget, they're paid out of all sorts of budgets where this money is supposed to be going to the fire department, and the schools, and the DPW, and all of these other things that we desperately need money for. Instead, it is going to pay legal fees.
I am going to vote to just approve the budget because I think we've gotten the information. I mean, obviously, I'd like more information, but I think we've gotten enough information to understand that things are not going well. And I don't want anybody to be punished. So that's where I stand.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Councilor Scarpelli.
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: Thank you. And I appreciate all my colleagues' words. This is something that this one Councilor can look back five years and started questioning these concerns and these issues five years ago. I still remember one budget season that the mayor sat at the podium mocking me and smiling with this condescending grin as if what I was saying wasn't valid or insightful or had any reasoning And we have to remember what we do here and what we did when we made a pledge and what we're supposed to do as city councilors. And it's our responsibility to be the fiscal stewards of what happens with our taxpayers' money. And starting way back at the beginning of the process, something very simple that we asked for a month-to-month actual, right? And we were getting them for some time in the gaps, and it wasn't steady, but we were getting them. And it was frustrating to me because we came from a financial advisor or a finance director that would give us all the information that we're asking for in a software in the system that we had that maybe was a little archaic, but it was done. She did the best she could with what she had. And then we were receiving from, not from the, not from our financial officer, but from the chief of staff. And we would get the breakdown and I would sit there every couple of months that we'd get two months at a time. And I'd go through with my highlighter and I'd see KP law, KP law, KP law, KP law, not in the law line. but in the school line, in the fire line, in the police line, in this line, in that line. To one, I believe, what I counted was $850,000 for one month. And I said, there's a problem here. And I want to identify it because we were in such fiscal constraints and we had so many problems with, remember, the schools and looking at overrides and looking at different avenues and how to bail the city out. And it was right in front of us, but we were mocked, we were laughed at, and we were dismissed, to the point where we don't even see an actual now. And it's simple. It's not difficult. See, I think what hurts most, why I get so angry, is because I work in a community where I see that every single month, as a department head and talking with the city councilors on a weekly basis in the community that I work in, where they see every penny that comes out, where they'll call me and they'll question, why do we need this? Just help me understand, George.
And that's how business gets done. There's no politics involved. It wasn't one side or the other. It was their responsibility to ask me where the city's finances are going, and as a department head, answering that. and being, what was that word that she ran on? Transparent. What bothers me more than anything, as this started growing, you started seeing the concerns and the issues even far greater than the financial responsibilities. You saw probably the most disturbing piece of all this is the effect it had on people.
and what this administration and our mayor was doing to our workers. And you can see it today, the fear. You could see, to this day, there's still departments coming to us asking us, we don't want to go to the law teams anymore. They come to the council to see if we can mediate. I think it was glaring right up until the fire department came up the other night to talk about 21 arbitrations, right? And winning 20 of them with 100 firefighters. And then sharing the information that the city of Boston in the same time period with 1,400 firefighters, they only had 20 arbitrations. I mean, that alone is glaring. But what we're seeing is we're seeing hundreds of thousands of dollars leave. And I know what we asked for. We asked, first we asked, we didn't get anything. Then we asked again, then we didn't get anything. Then we kept asking, still didn't get anything, to the point where we move forward with the legality, the legal way, with the FOIA. And we put it out there. And then the city came back and said, the mayor's office came back and said, what you're asking for is too daunting. It's too much work. So instead, we were getting reports of hours and hours of work that somebody did that answered nothing of what we were asking for. And in the meantime, we were still suing, we were still getting sued by city employees and losing lawsuits. I mean, we're not talking about $5,000 slip and falls. We're talking about firefighters that were dismissed, that won the case and that had to be paid back $150,000 on time that we've already paid employees.
And then the legal fees, on top of that, both our legal fees to fight it and the defense is legal fees. To the point where, okay, it was so daunting, Councilor Callahan came up with the simplest ask. Could you just put it in an Excel sheet and break it down into six different categories and just give us a number? Something so simple so people that aren't following this understand. the lawsuit, what it was, how much we paid to the attorney, our attorney. If we lost, how much we had to pay out. If we lost, if we had to pay the opposing attorney, how much we had to pay them.
And then if it was an arbitration, same situation. If it was mediation, how much was that? And then we hear in meetings that you know, talking to attorneys and saying, well, this lawsuit isn't, it's not coming from the city side. The residents aren't getting hurt by this. It's coming from our insurance. As if thousands of dollars coming from an insurance was appeasable to us. Oh, geez, in that case, that's fine. And then you realize, we still lost thousands on those ends.
So we talk about how we're hurting financially in this community. And over the last five years, we've had union heads come to us. So people understand this isn't us making things up with the actual lawsuits that were finalized in court that they shared with this council. Everything. We have those. That's why we said we need these reports. We need to know to the point here we are right now. Again, here we are right now again, and we're being told that, hey, if you don't give it to us this way, this is how it's going to affect the levy, and this is going to hurt, and we can't turn back. Enough that everybody's tired. Everybody wants to move on. I get it. And I don't discourage my colleagues to vote in favor of it and move on. I get it.
But where are they now? There's no one from the administration helping. There's no answering questions. We're never going to get the answers. And to Councilor Callahan's point, what is the answer? Why aren't we getting the answers? To me, that's more alarming than anything else. And that's what the community should be questioning and asking. But more importantly, I want everybody to understand my motives when I first started this wasn't vindictive in any way, because I know it wants to be portrayed that this Councilor or Councilors are doing things out of hatred, out of dissent to the mayor. That's not true. It's our responsibility to ask these questions, especially when we don't have the funding we need to perform basic city services.
That's one. But the most important thing is, I won't bring up his name, but there was one employee that worked for the city for a long time. And that employee had some issues. And he was brought in after working many, many years with DPW. And he was brought in in front of the HR director to see a physical, to have him do a physical test to see if he can still maintain his work. Even though they had legal documentation that said that he's not physically able to do it, and the fact that they moved on and they eliminated him.
And to hear what the union explained to me was probably one of the saddest comments they've ever heard, that this employee that was just dismissed says, don't worry about it. My wife and I can make wreaths, and we can sell them for money. That's what's driving me, just so everybody knows. When you have an employee of special needs that's worked for this community for so long, and he was committed, as much as he can do, he was committed for our community, into working for our community, and to turn your back to that person and hear that sequence is heartbreaking to me. These are real people that are being affected. These are the employees that take care of us every day.
When my mom fell or my dad fainted, it was the firefighters in the door. When it's a blizzard outside and nobody wants to be on the road, but the streets have to be cleared for an ambulance or for aid, it's the DPW workers that are on the street. When your sore backs up and it's the most vile smell you'll ever think in your life, they're in your basement taking care of you. when it's the veteran services director that's going above and beyond what he did for his job, saving lives, documented suicidal veterans, that our veterans director at the time was saving their lives, working, going above and beyond, and then being escorted out of this building by police.
Having probably one of the most competent financial directors in the Commonwealth working for us, a strong woman of color, being told that she can't speak, present the budget to the council, because at the time, the city administration felt that we were white men that wouldn't respect a woman of color to the point that that was another lawsuit that was settled. These are the things that hurt. These are real people. So I can go on and on, and I know Councilor Lazzaro wants to throw something at me, so I want to move on because it's too much time. But I will tell you, I brought this up years ago for a reason, and it was really because of people. And I still remember meeting with the mayor after the last election, and I said, please, I don't want this animosity anymore. We need to work together. All I want to do is please stop hurting the employees that are working in our city.
And this has nothing to do about how I feel about the mayor, because as a person, I've known her a long time. She's a great person. She really is a good person. When you talk about a mom and a former student athlete and a former colleague that sat next to me for years, this has nothing to do about personal. But we're at a point right now, here we are again, We're at the eve of setting the levy and we have to get this vote in or else it's going to hurt the people that need it the most. And that's our city employees and our tax base.
But nobody's here from the city side, the administration side, to talk about it. And we still haven't gotten the information that we need. So I respect all of my colleagues in their decision tonight. I will not be supporting this just because of the fact that I've stood on top of the soapbox for a long time, hoping for people to hear. And I appreciate it because I think people are hearing. And just the fact that my colleagues, that we can all look at an issue and put whatever politics we have aside to say, well, maybe he's right, or maybe she's right. I think that says a lot about this team.
Again, I apologize for me being winded, but I wanna make sure the people that just jumped into this process just now, that they understand how deep this went. This isn't something that is just political. It's not, it's about people and we're hurting people. So thank you, Mr. President.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. Councilor Tseng.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you to my colleagues for really moving remarks, regardless of how folks plan to vote tonight. When I first joined Councilors Scarpelli and Bears to ask for more transparency in our legal bills, I thought it was a simple request. Residents were asking me questions about our legal spending that I couldn't answer. And I believe that when a city councilor can't answer a question, it's our job to go find the answer. And that's all that this has ever been. It isn't personal. It's not about political opponents. I regret the games and the politicization that's come from across the hall. I regret that the mayor has punished city staff and held crucial city services hostage even when she didn't have the legal authority to do so. And I regret that people have gotten hurt over the last few years. But I do not regret asking tough questions because that is our job. And while the lack of cooperation does raise the question of why aren't we getting an answer, I do think just asking has made a difference. Before this council asked our questions, because this council asked our questions, residents now know several things that we didn't know six months ago. First, that the city has paid about $2.4 million to remain outside law firm KP Law since fiscal 2020, and more than $2.2 million in settlements and judgments. Second, we know that employee and labor disputes are the single biggest driver of these costs.
Our records show 22 unfair labor practice charges against the city in the decade before 2020. But in the five years since 2020, that number's risen to 74. And third, we know that for nearly $1 million of these settlements, the administration couldn't initially confirm which budget paid for them, which line item. And I think those are really answers, and point to really important work that we have to do ahead. Throughout this process, we've tried to be responsible. We've approved stop gap funding, so critical legal services never lapsed. We offered compromises, like holding the funds in a separate account. Councilor Callahan boiled down our request to a six line spreadsheet. And at every step, we looked for a way to get both transparency and stability. And I still believe we can have both. But under our charter, only the mayor can send us an appropriation. And the proposal in front of us is unfortunately the one that we got. If we don't approve it tonight, these funds are tied up until free cash is certified, which could take months. A smaller levy would also mean less revenue next year, and I just don't wanna see, I, I just don't wanna be in a position in a few months where we're facing service, service cuts and an austerity budget yet again. We've done this for my entire tenure on the city council. We've done this for my, my entire life living here in Medford. And making that choice would just, would put future projects like the new high school at risk and it puts badly needed revenue at risk as well. For years, And you can wind back the tapes. I've asked myself one question before every vote. Will this vote make our city a better place? And I stand by every vote I've taken on this issue. And tonight, that question leads me to say yes. But a yes vote doesn't close the book. And that's why I'd like the city council to consider passing a B paper tonight. to request the state auditor's office conduct an audit into what we asked for in the most recent request paper, which was 26-043. Under Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 11, Section 12, the law lets the auditor's office review city's books when the council votes to ask and when the mayor approves. And tonight, I think we can do half of that work, and we can ask the mayor to to sign that B paper or not.
So then the choice is the mayor's. If she signs, residents get the neutral, independent answers they've been asking for for months, and we can all move forward. If she refuses, that's her decision, and it will be hers to explain to the residents of the city. And in six months, we'll pick this all back up with a new budget, and I'll keep asking questions until residents have the full picture they deserve. This is a tough vote, and every councilor has to weigh it for themselves. Regardless of how we vote, I know the city council will maintain our commitment to the shared goals that unite the city, both in this building and on every street. Transparency, fiscal responsibility, and competent governance. So I'll leave my remarks at that, and I hope we consider the B paper option as well.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. We have a B paper from Councilor Tseng to request that the mayor sign under Mass General Law that we invite the auditor to conduct a review of the city. Seconded by Councilor Scarpelli. Do we have any further discussion on the B paper? Vice President Lazzaro.
[Councilor Emily Lazzaro]: I love having a Harvard Law student on Medford City Council. It's so useful. I was not aware that we could request, that we could vote for the state auditor to do an audit of. That's very exciting. And I think that solves a lot of problems for us. I think that B paper is an excellent idea. I think we can deliver that option to the mayor very easily and then she doesn't have to make any more hard phone calls because it's all taken care of. It's already written in the books. We don't have to do, I mean, the mayor was concerned about perceived unethical, you know, violations around like needing to have three, you know, estimates so that it didn't seem like we were just going with one estimate, you know, because of procurement rules. But that's not the case because if we just go ahead with the state auditor, that's already written into the law. So great catch, Councilor Tseng. I'm very supportive of this B paper. I think that solves a lot of problems for us. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Just to confirm, she would have to agree? She would have to agree. The mayor would have to agree. Okay, good. All right. We have the B paper and we have the main paper. Is there any motion on the main paper? There's a motion to approve on the main paper, seconded by Vice, by Councilor Tseng, seconded by Vice President Lazzaro. I do just want to say briefly, just, you know, look at the record this month. The only reason we're here is because no one showed up to this meeting in October. No one showed up to present on the paper, just sent it, never sent anyone, didn't really send many communications about it, acted like it wasn't important. We tabled it and suddenly all hell broke loose. We scheduled a special meeting right away for Monday. We reached out, myself, Councilor Mullane, Vice President Lazzaro, we met with the mayor. We came to an agreement. We voted that very day to fund the legal budget.
Then, you know, no outreach, no communications with us. We get a paper for the following week, please fund the whole legal budget, which isn't what we had agreed to. Come to the meeting, Nina says, yeah, it's not the agreement, but it's what we're demanding. We all gave our positions, said table it, we'll come up with solutions for a week. At that meeting, I offered to, meet with any potential firms. If they were having difficulties, if we couldn't get in touch with them, I'm happy to make some calls. I already sourced them. I already did all the research to give a list of firms. I know for a fact the state auditor's office actually has already been spoken to and said, absolutely, we'd be willing to do this. So it's not like this is some impossible task.
At the meeting, in the public meeting, I said, Madam Chief of Staff, if you need my help on it, give me a call. I then looked up alternative ways for us to avoid this levy issue. Talked to a number of municipal finance professionals about it. Came up with the list. Sent it to the chief of staff after I hadn't heard from anyone from the administration with any follow-up in a couple days. We did eventually get a reply basically saying, no, we're not gonna do that.
We have these opinions. Other people have told us we shouldn't We shouldn't be doing it that way. I think myself and maybe Councilor Leming replied, could you send us that information? Could you send us the third parties who said, no, we can't do this? No reply. And here we are, right? No one here to talk to about it. A number of people who are just trying to work really hard for the city, worried about their jobs, being told that if this goes down, everything's over and all hell will break loose. It's just not the way to run a city. So I'm disappointed. I don't know what else and what more we could have done to try to facilitate this process. We've given, I can't even begin to summarize what everybody said. Everything that Councilor Mullane did or Councilor Callahan or Councilor Tseng or Vice President Lazzaro or Councilor Leming or Councilor Scarpelli or myself, every single one of us over the last nine months, I think has offered like five or 10 different ways to try to get somewhere on this. And the answer has always been not good enough or not enough or no or just give us what we want. We don't really care what you think. So it's been incredibly disappointing. I don't think I can give in on it. Frankly, I don't think that I can. let someone just bully and bully and bully and bully and bully.
I just don't think it's fair. So that's that. I hope we get the answers. I hope we get the audit. I hope Councilors think it's B paperwork. And I hope everyone who works in this building can come to work tomorrow and know that their work can continue and be less worried. And I'm sending an email right after. our meeting to everyone to reiterate what I said at the beginning of this paper and let them all know how much we appreciate everything they do for our community and for our residents every day. So thank you all. I appreciate you giving me some space on that. On the B paper by Councilor Tseng, seconded by Councilor Scarpelli, correct?
Claire Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan. Yes. Councilor Fleming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: B paper. Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Mullane. Yes. Councilor Scarpelli.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Tseng.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Vice President Lazzaro. Yes. President Bears.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes. Seven in the affirmative, none in the negative. The B paper is approved. On the main paper, is there any further discussion by members of the council? Seeing none, is there any further discussion by members of the public, either in person or on Zoom? You can come to the podium in the chamber or raise your hand on Zoom. I do see Kevin from Medford Community Media.
[Station Manager Kevin Harrington]: Good evening, everybody. I think I want to start off by saying we broadcast all these meetings, you know, we've watched this disagreement for a long time. And, you know, while I'm here in my official capacity as department head. I also do kind of feel in a funny place, I feel like I'm stuck in the middle. I'm not here to, you know, Mr. Smith goes to Washington this thing and browbeat and castigate anybody. I know all of you value all of us departments, not just myself.
I appreciate that we all have the same goal, which is to serve the city, which is to serve the residents. And the main reason why I came out here tonight was just I did have a pit in my stomach about whether I would be able to continue to perform that duty for the community. I had a level of uncertainty about how much was hinging on tonight's vote on this paper. And honestly, I realized by the time I got here, I was really here to just be able to tell my community and the people I work with what to expect.
And, you know, so really what it comes down to is, like, I am not the only department that would be affected by this. You know, there's all sorts of different ways it would work out for folks. For us, the main thing is we have the ongoing cable renegotiation with Comcast and Verizon. And my only concern is as long as that is able to continue throughout the rest of this fiscal year so that we can fund our payroll, fund our equipment expenses, that's my only, my main concern. So I also appreciate what's already been said, you know, showing the appreciation for all of us folks.
And yeah, I think that does it.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Director Harrington, I appreciate it. I actually have one question for you. Oh, sure, please. Is there any way that you or the negotiators could provide us an update on the negotiation and is there any way for residents to advocate for you, you know? This is an interesting situation where residents are residents of the city, the city is negotiating with Comcast and Verizon, but many residents are also customers of Comcast and Verizon. So, you know, is there a way that we can, and this is the kind of collaboration we'd love to see more on, questions of negotiation and legal issues, because this could be a great way for residents to try to help you out, because I think we all know the share of subscribers is falling, and that may impact your budget. So if you have anything to add.
[Station Manager Kevin Harrington]: Yeah, I appreciate that. In terms of the, I don't have a ton of detailed info at the moment, but I can check up on that. But I can reach out and figure out, because I do know that there will probably be another public hearing. We had a public hearing a while ago, where the public has an opportunity to hear about the process itself, as well as When we did it, we presented a video about MCM and all the different things that we do. But yeah, I can look into that and get back to you, because I do think, yeah, if we have, you know, electronic means that people aren't able to go to any future hearings, being able to get their voices heard in a situation like that would be really helpful. So I can follow up on both of those for you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. That'd be much appreciated. And I'm sure we would be happy to co-host a public hearing with you if you'd like and get it out to anyone we know.
[Station Manager Kevin Harrington]: Well, you know I'm good for a live stream, so if you reach out ahead of time.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Director Herrington. Very welcome. Appreciate it. All right. Seeing a member of the public, we'll go to the podium. If you could give your name and your neighborhood, and you'll have three minutes.
[Andrew Castagnetti]: Thank you, Councilor Beardsley, Andrew Castagnetti, Cushman Street, East Medford, Mass. I'm not saying that you do not deserve an audit, not at all. It's not my business, actually. However, I want to reiterate from the last time you spoke about this, and that is you can't really be surprised you're not getting the audit because 72% of the Massachusetts voters voted for a state audit. of our tax money, and they haven't done it. It's been over two years and one week. So, good luck.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Do we have any further comments from members of the public? Seeing none, on the main paper, Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Mullane? Yes. Councilor Scarpelli? No. Councilor Tseng?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Vice President Lazzaro? Yes. President Bears?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: No. Four in the affirmative, three in the negative. The motion passes. 26205, Medford Tax Classification Hearing submitted by Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn. We have the city assessor here to talk about the hearing. The outcome of this today will be to take a classification vote. This is selecting the minimum residential factor. We currently use a split factor, a split tax rate between residential and commercial. We'll vote on whether to adopt a residential exemption and we'll vote on whether to adopt a small commercial exemption. And I think that assessor, our assessor probably has some of our questions from last time already in his mind. So maybe he'll present on them before we even ask them.
Floor is yours.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: I do. So first off, well, Oh, can we add you to Zoom to, are you on Zoom right now? That was gonna be my question. Yes. Do you have the link? So it should be joining now. Great. And once it joins, we can walk through the slides.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: We're not seeing you. Is it not coming through? No, I'm not. What's it say on your end? It's just spinning. Okay.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: And then I could try again to join one more time. If not, as a workaround, I believe you have the presentation.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: We do have them, but I think we could do it that way as well. Any chance a Councilor could share the slides? I believe they're in our email. We'll keep trying to get you in here. Yeah, for some reason it's not showing up that you're joining.
[SPEAKER_22]: Technology is great when it works and not when it doesn't.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Yeah, it just says loading.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Oh, okay. Councilor Leming's got it up. If you can get it in a presenter mode. I mean, that looks good to me. Okay. All right.
[SPEAKER_22]: All right.
[Station Manager Kevin Harrington]: Yeah, we can just walk through it.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Jared, if you could just tell Matt when to switch. Gotcha. Great. The floor is yours.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Okay. So as we know, we're here for the annual tax classification hearing. We'll walk through basically what my office has done throughout the entire year, go through and what has been approved so far by DLS and I'll walk through those numbers with you and then at the end we can go back and I can answer any questions on any of those slides. So slide two please. The purpose here is a classification hearing, so we'll be voting tonight for a residential factor, which would be applied for a split rate that we typically in other years take where we shift the maximum to the commercial properties and therefore give the residential properties the maximum allowable break by law.
Third slide, please. So these are the actions required. One is the vote for a single tax rate, or we maintain 175% shift from the residential class to the commercial industrial. And then the second vote would be the residential exemption, and the third is a small commercial exemption. Slide, please. So this here is just our budget revenue as amended. I believe that the state aid changed slightly, but the rest is accurate. So that just shows the pie basically of how much comes from real estate taxes versus other avenues of revenue for the city. Slide, please.
So the Appropriate Assessment Review, every year how we come up with our assessments is we look at arm's length sales from the previous calendar year to establish the fiscal year 25 assessments. The Master General Law requires us to keep those ratios between 90% and 110%. And then the Department of Revenue certified Medford's assessed values on October 9, 2026. We went through a recertification last year, I believe, as you all know. And then this year is an interim year. It's the same process, just on a different form. Next slide, please. So this is the form here that during the interim years where we go through the statistics and it's the LA-15 shows that we're in those guidelines and we are able to be approved by DLS for our valuations.
Next slide please. So the property assessment review, this just compares the fiscal 26 average to the fiscal 27 for the different types of parcel classes, single family, condominium, two family, three family, apartments, commercial and industrial. And the far right column is the percentage change from last year. The one that sticks out which I'm sure people would have questions is industrial. That was the loss of the Budweiser plant over on Riverside Ave that was part of that. The other was another industrial property that is now being converted to a apartment building going forward. Next slide please.
So this just compares where we are to some of the surrounding communities. This pulls from the DLS Data Bank. These are the ones that were available prior to submitting this for the agenda. So this just compares us where we fall compared to Everett, Malden, Melrose, Somerville, Winchester for the different types of properties, single family, condominium, twos, threes, apartments, commercial, and industrial. Next slide, please. And then the percentage changes. So just off those numbers, you can see the percentage changes in each relevant column for each one of those municipalities compared to us here in Medford. Next slide, please.
And then we get into new growth. So new growth, I think as you all know, I'll just say it for anyone listening in public, that is the amount of money that can be added on top of last year's levy. The Prop 2.5 allows us to go up 2.5% and then it's plus new growth. So new growth is anything new that was built. And we adopted Chapter 653 that allows us to capture new growth through June 30th. So any renovation project, any kind of major project, we go out and assess it as of June 30th. for this fiscal year. So this year we collected, we captured $206 million roughly which equates to $2,378,700 in levy growth that would be added to our levy as additional revenue to the city. The residential growth made up about 1.14 million and the commercial growth 1.2 million.
Next slide, please. And this is the LA-13 form that gets submitted to the state. This is how we report our new growth to the state. Again, it was that last slide just broken down in columns, and it breaks it out. It uses last year's tax rates to calculate the new growth, and in the far right column is the new growth that's calculated and was certified by DLS. Next slide, please. This is now just a, retrospective look at what we did for new growth and you can kind of see the patterns compared to last year, residential being in the bottom half and then commercial in the top half in orange. Next slide.
And then this is just a line chart. It shows where the total is versus the residential and also the commercial year to year. In the jump last year, we had, I think as you are aware, we had the pilot roll off on the MVDC, so that was the spike last year, which is one time. Until the next, they'll be rolling off as they reach their 15 year term in the MVDC, and I think we got all the cities, Medford, Malden, and Everett, in agreement on that last year, which was a good step forward. So now we have a path as those come off, and they'll be very helpful to the city when they do.
Next slide, please. And then this just breaks down the value by class. So we have the residential, commercial, industrial, and personal property. Next slide, please. And a typical tax rate, if it's a flat tax rate, it's just simply a tax levy divided by our taxable valuation. That gives us your flat rate. If we choose to continue on with the 175% shift, which is the maximum allowable, it will take that $9.45 flat rate, and it will bring the residential rate to $8.59. And it will push the commercial tax rate to $16.54. Next slide, please.
And it's just the historical percent of levy by class. So the residential, as you last four years, has been roughly flat. It would tick up if we started to lose commercial value. But it stayed pretty consistent, which is a good thing. So just, again, historical perspective of how it's split between residential and CIP, commercial, industrial, and personal property. Next slide, please. And then this is the residential factor. So when we choose to shift that rate, we come up with a .908635. That's what goes into the final DLS form to set the tax rate. And that's what you'd be voting on if we chose to do that maximum shift.
Next slide, please. So again, this just shows the difference between a split rate. We could go 1.5 and then the full 1.75 shift and the relevant tax rates on each one of those CIP factors. Next slide please. So this just gives a breakdown of the single family average tax bill if there was no shift, if it was a flat rate, if it was at 150%, and then if it was at 175. So it's a good slide to show what the shift actually does. It significantly helps the residential class as it pushes more of the levy to the commercial, industrial, and personal property. Next slide, please.
And again, historical recap of the single family tax bill. So this year, in the far right column, it's the percent change. We're going up roughly 4.3% there, or $319 on your average single family home. Next slide, please. And then the residential exemption, we talked about this in April. I believe it was April we came up and discussed that implementation and when we believed or I believed it would make sense, we looked at the apartment buildings that other cities and towns had that adopted this program versus us.
My office, through the study, came to the conclusion that in four years it would most likely make certainly more sense in four years than now, because we would have those larger apartment buildings to push that shift onto. So the residential exemption, it's zero-sum game. No monies get exempted from the levy. It's a valuation exemption. And it's pushed to the higher priced properties in the class one residential class. So those are your larger apartment buildings. So the more we have, the more we can disperse it. It's easier on the renters. And how much it's passed through, I know we debated that. There's certainly an amount, I can't say for certain.
That's where I think we came, that was just a summary of where we were at in the April talk on this presidential exemption. So in summary, there's 10 municipalities that have it, 10 being in the Cape, the other 10 being more urban centers with the larger apartment buildings that Medford could most likely be if we continue down the growth path. Next slide, please. And then the grantings, the small commercial exemption, which we typically do not do. These are the parameters to do that. The exemption is for the commercial. The previous calendar year, it would have to be assessed at a value of less than a million. And the intent is to give the tax deduction to small commercial property owners at the expense of the larger commercial industrial parcels.
We've never really adopted it. I think it's an unpopular exemption. I don't really know of any cities and towns that do do it. But yeah, that's something that could be done if wanted. Next slide, please. And then this is just a summary of the vote for tonight. So the minimum residential factor, if voted on at the .908635, which is that full shift, would yield those tax rates 859 and 1654. And then the vote for the residential exemption, and then also the vote for the commercial exemption.
[SPEAKER_22]: And next slide, please. I believe that's it.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Anything else you want to add before we go to questions from members of the council? I have no direct questions, but any questions for me? Great.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right. Any questions from members of the council? Councilor Scarpelli?
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: I just want to make just a comment. I think that, Jared, you're a great example of a leader in the city where you have been stoic in everything that this council has presented and a lot of the residents that had questions, especially when it came to abatement processes and your patience and your professionalism, your expertise, I think has really shined. And I think that you're a great example of what is making our city work because like I said, sometimes it's bad working in a municipality and you see what neighboring communities have for assessing teams and you're alone. You have two great administrative assistants in your office, but you're doing everything alone, and I just want to make sure that I commend you. I know that this is something that's very important, this process, and you've educated me enough over the last few years that I'm confident in the choices that we're making and the way that you're leading us and guiding us. I think it's important, but I just wanted to say, I know it's been a tough night with a lot of You know, a lot of concerns going on the city, but I just for one Councilor. I just wanted to make sure you knew because too often we don't say it and then we see department heads like someone that was here tonight that's leaving us and we didn't say it in time to make sure that maybe that little piece keeps you here. Jared in the future because the city needs you. I think that you've kept us above ground and I think I had to say that tonight because it I don't think sometimes you hear it from the people you need to hear it from, because as a municipal employee, sometimes it's all you want to hear. So I just want to make sure I share that with you. I think we're educated enough to move forward with these decisions tonight.
I think that, you know, that as we move forward, when we talk about future tax brackets and what we're looking at for tax implications, we might be looking at things a little bit differently. But I think where we are today, I think we're educated and prepared enough to move forward with decisions. So I just want to thank you for all your hard work. Thank you. Thank you for the kind words.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Thank you. With the residential exemption, can you just speak, I apologize if I'm asking you to repeat yourself, but just speak very plainly what you think would happen to renters if this were to be implemented? What would the effect there be in your estimation?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: So going off memory here from the April discussion, but there was a paper put up by I believe the Philadelphia Fed and they were saying it was anywhere from 50 to 80 cents passed through per dollar when there's a tax shock. So I believe that 61 of our larger apartment buildings we were talking about modeled out to be roughly a half a million dollar tax shock to them. in the year that it would be implemented, just because there's no other larger apartment buildings like that, or not enough, maybe three or four. So we did that study and said if we added three in the pipeline now and then more, it would.
just disperse that higher-valued property, we'd have more of it, and it wouldn't be such a tax shock. So short answer to your question, I think it's $0.50 to $0.80 on the dollar that gets passed through to the renters based on that paper. But there's a lot of discussion as to how accurate that is, and there's other studies out there as well.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: So putting this in terms of dollars and cents, people might better understand, and if you're not sure, the math right off the top of your head. With the knowledge that rents are largely set by the market, I understand that part of the economic picture. But assuming that somebody is paying $2,000 a month in rent in an apartment building that costs, or an apartment unit that costs like $500,000 if they were to buy it outright. And all of the costs are passed on to them if we were to pass that. How much would that $2,000 change?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Right. We'd have to look at that individually. It was more of the building as a whole. So that paper, if I remember correctly, I can find it and share it. I think it goes into detail about the exact amount on a typical rent. What building was it, Jared? What's that? Here are the paper that I'm referring to.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: No I know but just what building where you know you get that five hundred thousand dollar number just what building.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: It's our largest department building is the one across from Wegmans. Yeah I think it's here over on the mystic. Yeah. Yeah. So that's the one that it's our top taxpayer right now currently.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Councilor Leming. Thank you. Go to Councilor Callahan.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: Thank you. I do want to talk about the residential exemption. There are a number of reasons why I believe it is the right thing for our city. From simply the sheer number of comments that I got about absentee landlords as I was canvassing across many years. For so many reasons, I think they are a source of frustration for many, many, many, many people in our city. I also think from a big picture, and I know that everyone here cares about housing and the price of housing and the housing crisis that we are having in our city and in our region. When pure investors can buy up our housing and our property, that housing will go up more than if it is bought by people who live here.
Statistically speaking, people who live in one unit but they buy a two family, they live in one unit, they rent out the other unit, those are the people who charge the least in rent for many reasons. We don't have to get into it, but that's just a reality from a statistical standpoint. I think from my perspective, I think it's very clear that if we can make some effort to make it just a little bit pricier for people who do not live here to buy up our housing and use it purely for investment, purely for profit, to pull that money out of our community and take it wherever they live and use it for whatever they want, I think we should do that. I want to talk a little bit about the argument that a tax increase is going to, for landlords, is going to be passed on to renters. And I know that the claim is not that it would 100% be passed on, but that somewhere between 50 and a little bit of higher, 50% of that tax increase would be passed on to renters. Personally, I don't believe that that is true, especially for the larger buildings of peer investors.
economic papers, you can always find one or more economic papers that will support theories that support big investors, because there's plenty of money awash for research studies and for papers to be written that support those theories. I think the reality is that people who don't live here and are purely buying for investment and profit purposes, they charge the highest rent they can. They charge what the market will bear. The market is not going to bear more simply because their taxes go up. They are charging what they can. Because that's the purpose of a purely investment landlord relationship. So I do not personally believe that more than 50% of this tax is gonna be passed on to renters. I just think that that's an argument that, you know, there are many studies that show that. There are studies that show the opposite. I don't think that that is reality.
And I wanna talk a little bit about seniors. So I think an argument was made that majority of seniors would be hurt by the residential exemption. And the basic argument was that trusts if you do not own, directly own the property, that if the property is in a trust, which is true for many people who own property here, seniors or not seniors, that that would not be eligible. And I want to provide some information which I believe is accurate, and perhaps we can, you know, get, if you have some reflection upon what I'm presenting here, please feel free. But if it is in a trust, and the homeowner lives in the house, and they are a trustee and beneficiary of the trust, then they are eligible.
If they are a co-trustee with adult children, and they have sufficient beneficial interest, they are also eligible. for the residential exemption. If the homeowner lives, if they live in the house, but the children are the only trustees, they themselves are not eligible, but because the children who are trustees fall into that first category, that is eligible. The seniors are not gonna get it, but the children, will get the residential exemption because they are homeowners living in the house, they are beneficiaries of the trust. And if you think that the senior who is a parent of the children who own the house, who are trustees of the trust, if you think those parents don't benefit from their children getting that residential exemption, I think that that is not a valid argument. So there are many cases where houses that are in a trust are in fact would fall under the residential exemption eligibility.
So I, and the other thing to understand is, and I looked at a breakdown of all of our housing that I believe was provided by the assessor's office. When we see these averages that the average, and it's not up anymore, but the average single family price was like 890,000 or something like that. And then you look at the, the breakdown of all houses, all of the parcels, and what the value of that is on that parcel, what you see is that there are lots of... Which is a normal... This is a normal skew for things like this, that you have It's like a bell curve, right? But a bell curve that's very skewed on one side. And that side is more of the lower-priced homes. There are a lot more lower-priced homes. And there are very few very high-priced homes that increase the average, right? What we saw, I believe, is a mean and not a median as an average. And what that means is that there are way more lower-priced homes, way more, than there are higher-priced homes. And I did a little bit of a calculation here. I looked at how many homes were above the breaking point and how many homes were below the breaking point. And it's about 1,800 homes are above the breakeven point.
Less than 2,000 of these parcels. And it's about 14,000, over 14,000 that are below the breaking point. And this doesn't even break them into whether they are single families or two families. It seems to me that it's quite likely that more of the more expensive parcels are gonna be two families, and that is a person who has rental income. So to me, when I look at all of the data put together, it really seems like this is going to be of great benefit to the vast, vast majority of people who live in Medford.
And that the people who will be paying more are people who do not live in Medford. And this is the way it is designed. It's the way it is designed to be. So I will be voting, oh, the other piece of information that I did a little research on is I understand there is some trepidation about making this vote without having already done all of the research, having hired a couple more people in the assessor's office to put out applications many months in advance. And to, you know, have a better understanding of exactly how many people would apply and would be eligible for this.
And I simply want to say that the Department of Revenue does offer a calculator to allow us to do an estimation. And that, you know, I feel like I'm being put every year into a catch 22. where, oh, we can't do it this year because we didn't already do the work a few months ago, but then we never do the work, so we're not allowed to vote in favor of it. But I think cities do, in fact, vote to have a residential exemption, and they do that without perfect information. And they use the Department of Revenue's calculator. They make a very good guess. And that guess is pretty close. And they move forward from there. So part of this is simply frustration on my part. This is year three now that I have been in the same conversation where I'm told I'm not allowed to vote in favor of the residential exemption.
Because we didn't prepare and no matter what we do as a city council to ask the administration to prepare for this. There isn't the preparation. And I'm simply not convinced that that preparation is as necessary as it has been argued for. So I plan on voting yes, and I hope that if it does not pass, this will at least encourage the administration to actually prepare for this next year, which I've been asking for for three years now. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Callahan. Do we have any further comments from members of the council? Councilor Leming.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: So with 35, just a clarifying question, 35% is the max that we can go?
[SPEAKER_22]: That's correct.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Is it common for cities, for other communities to adopt a lesser number than that? Or is it typically binary?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: It's up to this body if it's between 5 and 35 percent. It can be anywhere in between there. But the problem back to Councilor Callahan's comment is it's not, it's a terrible time and it's flawed in the sense that you have to vote on it now because just the amount of time that you took to explain that one deed, we have to do that 14,000 times over. We have to look at every trust and make sure the kids live there. If they don't, they don't qualify. If they do, you're right, they do. So it's massively burdensome. We put it in the April. I don't have the exact one, but I think we said it's going to be 92 weeks of work, something like that, to just go through the deeds and see who's eligible. So if we got that wrong, if we voted now, it's not in the tax rate. Everyone who applied would be flooded with abatements and it would all come out of the overlay and put the city in a pretty bad spot budget-wise. So this is where it's good to have those conversations in April. Look at the data. And I'm not for it or against it. I'm just data driven. So I was looking at the apartments where it would need to be so it wouldn't really hurt the renters. If it does at all, we'll leave that for the time being. And then there'll be less losers, so to speak. I think the last time we looked at it, there was going to be 900 single families would actually get the exemption. They'd be granted it, but their taxes would go up still. In Malden, there's seven. We want to have less losers, and by adding the more apartments, we get less and less losers of single families. So it just, data-driven-wise, makes more sense to allow those to get built out and look at that when we have more of those high-valued class one properties on the tax rolls.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: But I do agree with my colleague's point, though, that, so you're making two points here, as I understand it. One, it would take a lot of time to go through the deeds and do the paperwork for this, which, and that's where I agree with my colleague saying, which is, you know, we have kind of played this Catch-22 game for a couple of years now. The other point that you're saying is that there are going to be potentially, like in the future, there are going to be bigger buildings, it's going to be urbanized here and then we're going to, it'll be more appropriate to do it then. Is that a summary of what you?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: That's correct. That's why it works in Malden. That's why they have seven that actually have their bill go up even when they're eligible and would have 900-ish. It will reduce the losers that, they'll become, think of this, they'll say, oh wow, I got a residential exemption, that's great. Then they get the tax plan, it goes up. There'll be 900 of them. There'll be more winners, sure, but the amount that the, we're looking at it, and I think I gave it to the council, that sheet which shows graduated, you know, we're talking, some people say 25, 50, but it's lumped in. It's not like everyone's saving this massive amount of money, but on the other side of it, it's massive. And you could argue, sure, we wanna hit the apartment buildings like that. Fine, but the data shows that the cities and towns that do adopt these and adopt them at the 30, 35% Somerville, Malden, Everett, they have much, much more apartment buildings than we do. And it makes sense, because it's dispersed on the high end that way.
So it's just, it's data-driven. It's not, you know, my opinion. It's all in that April study that we did.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Everybody going to talk? Councilor Tseng, then Councilor Callahan, then Vice President Lazzaro.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: I just had a quick question. I mean, I think This is a policy I've really wanted the city to pursue for a long time. And, you know, I acknowledge what Councilor Leming said about feeling like we're playing catch 22 and, you know, constantly kind of like being in circles about this. But at the same time, I feel hopeful that we'll have developments in a few years that make this easier to execute. I'm curious, the number that you're citing in terms of where we'll be in four years, is that based off of projects that we already have in the pipeline? Is it based off of zoning that's already been done, zoning that's yet to be done? Just curious.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: So as it stands right now, there's 657 units that are coming online and shovels in the ground actively being built. And then there's two that I know of that will be most likely having shovels in the ground next year. So now we have five large apartments. They'll be significant. And what else happens with Medford Square, the transom project? My thought there was to allow those to be built. The data's going to look a lot different after that. And then we take a year, we put the budget in place for it, we get prepared, we do it right, we have plenty of staff ready to look at all these deeds we're going to have to do, and then we'll have an appropriate tax rate in the year that you choose to adopt it and be ready for it, it'll be baked into the tax rate and the overlay won't get hurt. It's just that it's fiscally responsible for the city. If we did it any other way, in my opinion, this is my opinion, it wouldn't be fiscally responsible. It would hit the overlay too hard.
[Councilor Justin Tseng]: And with new zoning, if we were able to encourage the commercial development, the apartment development, that could feasibly move up the timeline if things get built sooner?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Absolutely. So the apartment buildings, they're class one. Even if they're mixed use, the portion that's class one, that absolutely helps. And that's why you see it in Everett, Malden, Chelsea. Yeah, you could just look at a DLS sheet, their apartment buildings versus ours. They're 2, 3x. Yeah.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Councilor Callahan.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: Thanks. I just want to because I have these charts right in front of me. I do want to talk about this idea of like the losers who do live in the city. And yet their taxes would go up. Yes, this is about incentivizing people to own homes here. Is it a residential exemption? And so I think, you know, a lot of people think, oh, if you live here, you will pay less. As we have come to understand, that is not the final outcome, that there is a break-even point in people who live here and their houses are worth more than that point they would pay more in taxes. So I just I in my opinion that is not necessarily bad and I want us to look at the reality of who would in fact pay more.
And unfortunately, I don't actually have a breakdown in this spreadsheet of whether they are two families or single families or what they are. But there's a whole group of parcels near the top. And maybe you can correct me if I am not understanding this, but listed at anywhere between $10 million and $164 million, which doesn't seem like it could possibly be residential. I don't know if those are commercial properties You know what those those are residential property.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Those are your class one apartment buildings.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: Oh those are the apartment building class one.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: That's why we need more of them.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: Okay, great. So, there's gotta be apartment buildings up there, you know, those 10 million, two hundreds each floor. So, this doesn't, this is not necessarily, it could be not even just single family, two families could be anything, gotcha. They are obviously gonna be paying a lot more. We get down into the five million dollar range, and those people are gonna be paying $12,000 more. We get down into the, Two million dollar range and most of those that are above the two million dollars we're talking like there's one parcel there's one parcel in in these different brackets you see these are not a lot of properties. Get down into the two million dollar range where there's you know twenty ten twenty between two million and three million. Those folks are going to pay like 3,000 more in taxes. You start getting down where there's more of these parcels, but the price is less.
And let's, for example, at 1.5 million, there's 113 between 1.5 and 1.6. Those people would be paying $1,200 more. By the time you get down to just above the break-even point, right, between 1.2 million and 1.3 million, each of those parcels would pay $300 more, and I presume that's per year?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: That's everything. It's the annualized tip.
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: $300 more per year.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: And that's just the way it works. It's every, as far, both sides. It's $25 less, $25 more. Absolutely. Widens that way. I mean, my point is,
[Councilor Anna Callahan]: I think the number of properties that would pay a little bit more, but also those are pretty highly valued properties, going up to the very, very few properties that would pay a lot more. I don't really see that as a negative consequence. I don't really think that the people who are low income seniors are living in these $2 million houses. The truth is that if they are, then we already have a tax deferral program for anyone who is, you know, earning underneath what we've maxed it out at the state level, the amount that we are allowed to by the state. So the truly low income seniors can defer, completely defer all of their taxes, including this increase in taxes, indefinitely. Either they sell the home or they, are, you know, pass away. I don't see this, even though there are, there would be people who, you know, live in Medford whose taxes would go up, I do not see that as a terrible consequence. So, you know, and, and, yeah, I'll just leave it there.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: Councilor Leming. What I'm considering is, you said it would take 92 weeks or something around that to go through all the deeds?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: A week, so it's in that file. I don't have it in front of me. It's not working, unfortunately. Yep, I think that's accurate, 92 weeks.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: So what I would like, what I would like to do is instead of just adopting the 35% exemption right off the bat, I would like to at least, you know, motion to adopt for a lower amount since I do hear what you're saying about the the lack of apartment buildings being built now. But I also, I mean, I, I also feel like this is a conversation that we, we, we do have every year and there just isn't really any, I, I don't feel like there's any real, Will behind behind doing that so I just I just want to know from from your perspective. It's like We if we adopted some if we did vote to adopt some exemption for some percentage tonight You know it would take what would the process look like from here, and how would you begin to go about that?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: Oh, so the timeline, the process, it's all, the 5% would just be the monies. The amount, the administrative burden is identical. We still have to review every exempt, we'd be flooded, 12,000 exemptions coming in in January when I'm dealing with abatements. We already maxed out with the staff we have. It'd be administratively impossible, and I'm not saying that's a fact.
[Councilor Matt Leming]: But will it be administratively impossible every year?
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: It won't be if we did or adopted it the way I just laid out, where we budgeted for one year. We have people in place in January. We can start taking exemptions early. pulls out the January to October timeline, and then we can bake it into the tax rate. To try to do it now, it will all come out of the overlay. There is no way we'd be able to get through all those applications and still keep that office running.
go fight the abatements that come in from attorneys and it just would not be possible. So that's why I laid it out that way. So we have to budget for it one year, then the next year we can adopt it and we're all ready for it. But it's a two-year process. And then with the data, if we planned for fiscal 31 adoption, we wouldn't be spinning wheels. Everyone would know what we're looking at. The data would support that. And we could get ready for it. We wouldn't be here in the last hour saying, you know, well, we want to do this, but we can't. I get that. I get that. So that's my take on it. That's all I got.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right. I will not go into a graduated tax versus a flat tax and all the stuff I normally do and what I did in April, but I do think there are some good long-term arguments for doing this. I was encouraged by what you were talking about. with the growth pattern and kind of shifting us in a direction where a lot more people would benefit as well as distributing potential costs over a broader base of folks. So appreciate that appreciate. I think you're being thoughtful about it. I understand my colleagues frustration and I'll stop there and I won't describe the chart that I really have a chart that I really I want us to make someday when we when we go forward with this. Are there any members of the public who would like to speak on this item either in person or on Zoom? If you'd like to speak in person, please line up behind the podium. If you'd like to speak on Zoom, please raise your hand. All right. Anyone in person, we'll start at the podium here. All right.
Mr. Kessler, you'll have three minutes and then I see one hand on Zoom.
[Andrew Castagnetti]: Thank you, Councilor Bears, Andrew Castagnetti, Cushing Street, East Medford, Massachusetts. I also agree with Councilor Scarpelli. Jared is one fine chief. And another Councilor, I want to commend you for all the homework you've done. I'm impressed. Thank you. I guess tonight we're going to set the tax rate. This is probably by 20, I don't remember, 23rd, 4th, or 5th year they have come here at this time in November to try to get you peoples to adopt Mass General Law Chapter 59, Section 5C, the owner-occupied real estate tax exemption. This Massachusetts exemption has been in effect for decades. Boston has a full shift at 35%, also adopted by Boston, Malden, Everett, Chelsea, Cambridge, Somerville, and others, but still not here in Medford.
I estimate that the Medford owner-occupied homeowners, on average, have lost out on $15,000. savings that they would have had in the last 41 years since they started this program. That is sad. 10 years ago, a Medford City Councilor told me that Medford will never pass and adopt this unoccupied exemption. Why? I don't know. He never said. But then a friend told me, two months ago that he does not want to save 300 bucks a year and then lose his mother's house to a nursing home.
So the reason is, his mother put the house in a trust, but put the house in someone else's name. So now this jeopardizes. So this tells me that they formed a trust to insulate and hide this house from any potential nursing home bills. P.S. This house probably cannot or definitely cannot qualify, depending on who the gifters and the recipients are, won't qualify for the owner-occupier exemption. But I'm not a lawyer. So after 24 years in my quest to get you, the city, to adopt Mass General Law, Chapter 59, Section 5C, I am tired, and I've decided to wash my hands of this mission for the time being. But make no mistake of this, the average Method owner occupied homeowner has lost out on over $15,000 and counting, period.
And imagine this, even the State House politicians felt bad, they felt bad for the owner-occupied real estate taxpayers, and they passed this law to help them. If they pass this, if you pass this, the Council, majority vote, and the mayor signs off, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts will immediately give us this real estate tax, real savings, to us, the cash cow of the city.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Andy, it's about, you're over 30 seconds over, if you could wrap up. I got one sentence. One sentence.
[Andrew Castagnetti]: I appreciate your help, Councilor Bears. 15 grand lost out is a lot of cash to me, a lot of money. Any questions or comments, please?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Andy. I'm going to go to Paul Geraghty next. Paul Geraghty on Zoom. Paul, if you could give your name and address.
[Paul Garrity]: Good evening, Council. My name is Paul Geraghty. I live at Cedar Road. I just had a couple of thoughts here in that there's a lot going on in the city financially. You know, the upcoming debt exclusion is looming on us. I listened this evening to potentially somewhere between 11 and 21 million bucks for repairs through one of the schools. So, My first question is I hope that in any of this consideration that the council looks to see what is going to be the impact on incomes for seniors on fixed incomes. I mean, will they consider or is there any way to adopt, you know, will it be a cap on what percentage of their income will be devoted to paying taxes? I mean, you combine not only the real estate tax, you've got your water bills and other, you know, excise taxes, et cetera. So what percentage of the Fixed income can support an ongoing increase in taxes. But it further underscores the issue that the council and the mayor and the whole city should really be looking at economic growth. Specifically, we have a piece of a real gem down on Mr. Gabb. And I really, really think that as part of this whole plan of assessments and abatements, We look to look seriously at serious economic growth, both from the clean industrial side that's not avoiding to bring in jobs, good-paying jobs that can develop within the community, as well as the high-end apartment buildings that a total package needs to be looked at when we approach this and saying, fine, can we support another cost, another tax with the abatement? Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Paul. Is there anyone else who'd like to speak on the tax issue? Would you like to speak? No? Okay, sorry, you just, you sat up. I wanted to make sure we got you. Thank you, Paul. All right, do we have anyone else who'd like to speak on this matter? Seeing none, Jared, I have one question for you. Just could you speak a little bit to the exemptions that are available for folks, and are there any that we could add or anything that we could increase for residents?
So this would be for seniors, some folks with disabilities, veterans, if you could just speak to that.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: So thank you for bringing that up. I meant to add that. So there are, and I wanted to put that in front of you. So we, I went through the whole list and we pretty much give out to our seniors and veterans everything we can. There's three adoptions that we could pass that would help. I'll go through them. So it's 17E, 17F, and 41D. 17E increases the maximum asset to qualify each year for the clause 17D exemption. It's the asset increases resulting from the adoption.
would operate cumulatively so it's basically a color adjustment that comes out every March from DLS or DOR and I think it was like 3.9% this year. So we're doing it for some of the veterans. This would put the color adjustment in place for the asset qualifications for 17-day. Then 17-F, that would increase the exemption amount each year for Clause 17-D. That would jump again by the COLA adjustment. Right now it's a flat 175. That would graduate each year on the COLA adjustment that comes out roughly every March. And then the lastly would be 41-D. It would increase the maximum income and maximum assets to qualify for 41-C.
The increases that increases the the income and assets senior citizens have to qualify for the annual senior low-income exemption 41 C. So again, that's another Kohler adjustment that would increase the income and assets So all these I believe are nice. They keep up with cost of living Sorry
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thanks, Jared. That's super helpful. I think if you could forward that to us in an email and we can get to work on maximizing our exemptions, that's something we talked about in our previous meeting. So, you know, especially with the major projects coming and the high school debt exclusion. I know we've done a few of them over the last few years. It sounds like there's three more we could do. I think that's really great. So I appreciate looking into that.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: I will. And I'll double check. But I think if we do pass those three, we have taken up everything that all, even the new ones that came in, mostly the COLA adjustments, which I believe are helpful. All right, great.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: All right, thank you. Okay, any further comments from members of the public? Seeing none and no questions from councilors, we're gonna move to the action required by the council. If you could stay at the podium just in case we have any questions on it, some of these are pretty technical. First item on the classification vote is whether to adopt the small commercial exemption. So that's a yes, adopt, or no, do not adopt. Does someone wanna make a motion on the small commercial exemption?
Motion to no, that's the tradition. Okay, so motion to not adopt. So, okay, so my apologies. So it's a motion to not adopt. So if you vote yes, it's a no. If you vote a no, it's a yes. Yeah. All right. On the motion of Councilor Scarpelli, seconded by Vice President Lazzaro, to not adopt, and therefore, if you want to not adopt a small commercial exemption, you would vote yes. All right. This is why I have Jared at the back.
Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Motion passes, we are not adopting the small commercial exemption. Number two, vote on whether to adopt a residential exemption. Is there a motion? We have a motion from Councilor Scarpelli not to adopt a residential exemption seconded by Vice President Lazzaro. A yes would mean to not adopt and no would mean to adopt. On that motion, Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan? No. Councilor Leming?
[Councilor Matt Leming]: No.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Mullane? Yes. Councilor Scarpelli? Yes. Councilor Hsieh?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Vice President Lazzaro? Yes. President Bears?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes. Five in the affirmative, two in the negative. We are not adopting this year a residential exemption, but you're not off the hook on it. And the last vote, this is the most consequential one and the one where the decimal point is six places deep. So we got to get it exactly right. This is a motion to select a minimum residential factor. So this is going to result in a split tax rate. The request is that, well. There's two options, a factor of one is a flat rate, a factor of 0.908635 is a split rate, and that is the, I think, the biggest split we can do, right? Maximum allowable by law. Yeah, all right. So is there a motion to adopt a minimum residential factor of 0.908635? Vice President Lazzaro. Yeah, motion to adopt a factor of 0.908635. All right, seconded by Councilor Callahan.
And that's right. If we pass that motion, we're good. That is correct.
[Chief Assessor Jared Yagjian]: That will make those tax rates in the 175 shift the correct tax rates.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Great. So on the motion to adopt a minimum residential factor of 0.908635 by Council Vice President Lazzaro, seconded by Councilor Callahan. Clerk Siegel, please call the roll.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Callahan? Yes. Councilor Leming?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Councilor Mullane? Yes. Councilor Scarpelli? Yes. Councilor Tseng?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes.
[City Clerk Laurel Siegel]: Vice President Lazzaro? Yes. President Bears?
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Yes. Seven affirmative, none negative. The motion passes. All right. Thank you. Thank you. We have public participation. Public participation on any matter before the public. If folks would like to speak on any matter, they can come to the podium or raise their hands on Zoom and they will have three minutes.
[Anita Nagem]: Anita Nagum, Medford Hillside. I'm coming here to speak about private ways because I know it's a subject. Is that booming? It sounds like it's booming to me.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: You're good. I'll reset your time. We'll try to turn it down a little bit, but we can hear you.
[Anita Nagem]: All right. Because the Public Works and Facilities Committee had a meeting about this last month, and it's an issue. I've lived on a private way in Medford since 1989. 15 or 20 or so years ago, there were a few issues that came up and I spoke with the city solicitor several times. He was very knowledgeable, very helpful, gave me a lot of excellent information. The term private way is a gray area, which a lot of people do not understand. It means that the city does not own the street. It does not necessarily mean that the residents, the abutters, own it. It could still belong to the developer who developed that property.
I had two neighbors until recently who were the grandchildren of people who had bought their houses from the developer 90 or so years ago. And from the conversations that I had with them, it leads me to believe that the developer still owns our street. I never, the city solicitor told me that the deed would have to be researched in order to determine ownership. I have not researched my deed, but at some point I will. But in order to determine ownership, the deed of every street in the city would have to be researched. A private way is not the same as private property.
My understanding is that the public has the right of passage on a private way. Even if I did own halfway to the center of the street along the frontage of my house, there are restrictions on what I could do with that. I could not put a fence around it. I could not do certain things. So it is a legal gray area. In the late 1980s, the city of Medford decided, as a matter of policy, to treat private ways the same as public ways because of the right of passage for public safety issues and because residents pay the same taxes as everyone else. I have some concerns about some of the things that have been going on recently.
First, I'm concerned that The law firm that is advising the City may not have the expertise to actually give accurate information to the City. The City of Medford has lost a lot of institutional knowledge, and I do not think that that can be replaced by an outside law firm. City employees also have lost institutional knowledge. If this issue were put to a public vote, I am very concerned about the public misinformation. I've seen several social media posts in the past few years. People automatically assume that the private way is private property, that we pay less in taxes. That is the most common thing. I'm almost done.
And they make up their own facts. If this actually did come up to a vote, it would be incumbent upon the city to make sure that the public was informed about the actual legal issues involved with Private Ways. And finally, I have a concern with the map of Private Ways that was put out by the city. I can tell you that it is not accurate. I looked at my street. It's not listed. My understanding is from previous information that there are more than 39% of streets in Medford that are not private ways. But in any case, it is not accurate as it stands.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you. Councilor Scarpelli.
[Councilor George Scarpelli]: Thank you, Anita. It's important that we started this dialogue, right? And I think that one of the reasons we really want to start the dialogue is so we could start getting the information out to the public and be educated to that point. Even tonight, today I received a few calls questioning, did we get a response about the legal question? I don't know if you remember the legal question we asked. We still, at least I haven't heard anything. I don't know if my colleagues have heard anything yet, but I know to the public we've asked, We've asked even the DPW director that we asked for a list if we can publish it, if we can put the basic rules and policies so people can understand it. And even in his own words, he said that he truly can't do that because he doesn't know yet. He doesn't know who does. We have people that have done their homework since that meeting that did research their deeds and went so far back to realize we have streets that have been voted on back in 1955 that identified streets that were private ways that are now public ways. But the city doesn't know that. So there's a lot of gray area, right. But I think what we started, at least I try to do, is with that process getting the ball rolling, is start the discussion. And I know that we're going to bring this to a subcommittee meeting to get more information. I think that that just leads to more information. So I appreciate your comments tonight. And again, I ask the city administration again if we can get some legal advice. And again, it's not going to be really the institutional advice that we really need. But you know, the question was, what happens if someone, I believe, fell in front of the private way that belongs to the so-called homeowner of that area who is held liable. So these are the questions that we need. But I appreciate it, Mr. President. I thank the resident for coming to the podium tonight, and I know we have a lot of work to do with this. And we know it's really cut fire just for the conversations. I mean, coffee shops, supermarkets, people are asking me, how do I know? I've had a great discussion with the Middlesex Registry of Deeds, and it's a nightmare for their office as well, because a lot of people are gonna be inundating her office with the whole understanding of what the answers are, so thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Councilor Scarpelli. Any further discussion of public participation? Seeing none in the chambers, I do see Paul Geraghty. Your hand's still up on Zoom. I'm not sure if that's for this, so I'm gonna just ask you to unmute, and you'll have three minutes.
[Paul Garrity]: Paul Doherty, Cedar Road, Medford. I was watching that conversation that Councilor Scarpelli alluded to, and I did do some research. Unfortunately, no one at this point in time can identify for me the liability. Again, the insurance company says to me, well, we'll cover you up to the currently recorded meets and bounds that is at the registry. But my understanding could be wrong, and this is one thing that definitely needs to be clarified. Where does the property line end? Does it end at the Meats and Bounds? Is it halfway out into the street that is adjacent to the Meats and Bounds of my property? What, because as I said at that meeting, if somebody slips and falls in front of my house, right now, I'm really at risk. The city is denying ownership of the property. I don't know if I own the property. But certainly I will be sued if someone gets injured out there. So I think it's imperative that sooner than later, some clarification that says, where does the property boundaries lie? And then who is responsible and has legal exposure if an accident happens on a piece of apparently public way, private way, adjacent to your property and someone's injured. Thank you.
[Councilor Zac Bears]: Thank you, Paul. Any further public participation? Seeing none, is there a motion? On the motion to adjourn by councilor.
|
total time: 36.1 minutes total words: 6434 |
total time: 5.14 minutes total words: 869 |
total time: 24.6 minutes total words: 3938 |
total time: 9.51 minutes total words: 1368 |
|
total time: 9.71 minutes total words: 1503 |
total time: 5.71 minutes total words: 882 |
total time: 20.26 minutes total words: 2787 |
total time: 4.45 minutes total words: 526 |