MCHSBC: New High School Schematic Design and Sustainability - 2026-11-16

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3-flash-preview from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The committee reviewed and approved several design and sustainability specifications for the Medford Comprehensive High School project. Key decisions included the selection of all-electric heating for the pool, the refinement of healthy material standards, and the approval of the 'Bridge to the Fells' architectural concept and site circulation plans.

  1. 6:58 Approval of Minutes — Approved the minutes from the October 6, 2026, committee meeting.
  2. 7:44 September and October Invoices — Approved project invoices for September ($106,357) and October ($116,257) for OPM and architectural services.
  3. 10:21 Feasibility Study Budget Update — Reviewed a high-level budget snapshot showing approximately $1.9 million spent to date against the $3 million feasibility study grant, with roughly $144,778 remaining in uncommitted funds.
  4. 15:42 Pool Heating System Selection — Approved an all-electric air-to-water heat pump system for the pool based on a 50-year life-cycle cost analysis showing significant operational savings over gas-fired boilers.
  5. 30:10 Red List and Healthy Materials Resolution — Approved a revised resolution to specify 'Red List Free' and healthy materials where economically feasible with at least three competitive equals to maximize indoor air quality and MSBA reimbursement.
  6. 38:25 Mass Timber Cost Alternates — Approved the elimination of full-frame mass timber options and the addition of two targeted alternates for the gymnasium roof and the early childhood center for the next round of cost estimating.
  7. 48:37 Educational Planning and Floor Plan Update — Reviewed updated floor plans and program adjacencies, highlighting the integration of CTE programs within academic learning communities and plans for a student locker usage survey.
  8. 57:54 Site Circulation and Safety Plans — Evaluated updated site circulation designs featuring a new teardrop-shaped loop to accommodate bus and special education traffic while improving emergency vehicle access.
  9. 1:25:00 Site Identification Signage — Approved a masonry school identification sign with external illumination for the Winthrop Street entrance in lieu of an LED message board.
  10. 1:33:29 Architectural Design and Exterior Materials — Reviewed the 'Bridge to the Fells' architectural concept, which utilizes biophilic design elements, glassy entrances, and masonry cladding integrated with solar canopies.
  11. 1:46:10 Interior Finish Standards — Discussed durable interior material selections, including linoleum and epoxy terrazzo flooring, wall tiles for high-traffic corridors, and acoustic ceiling baffles.
  12. 1:50:32 Informational Project Mailer — Approved a $10,000–$14,000 project mailer to be sent to all Medford households to provide information on upcoming forums and the 2027 debt exclusion vote.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: MPS High School Building Committee

[Unidentified]: That's the cause of a lot of change. I think we have a quorum here.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Welcome, everyone. Can you all hear me on Zoom?

[Unidentified]: OK. Yes, we're good.

[Member Jenny Graham]: OK. So I will read the meeting notice. Please be advised there'll be a full committee meeting of the Medford Comprehensive High School Building Committee in person at the Medford High School Library at 4889 Winthrop Street and via remote participation. The meeting can be viewed live on the Medford Public Schools YouTube channel and through Medford Community Media on your local cable channel, which is Comcast 98422 and for Verizon 4345 or 47. The meeting is being recorded and participants can call or log in using the Zoom meeting ID 97992034610. The public encouraged to reach out in multiple ways. If there's a question, Regarding the project for which an official response by the project team is requested, you can email us at mhsproject at medford.k12.mi.us. If you would like to share a comment or perspective, that would be forwarded to all members of the building committee. You can use mchsbc at medford.k12.mi.us. And with that, I will call roll.

Jennie Bam, here. Mayor Lungo-Koehn.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Present.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Palucci. Here. Verdica Brau. Here. Jen Lord. Here. Jen Belander. Libby Brown.

[SPEAKER_21]: Here.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Maria Dorsey. Brian Hilliard. Here. Frankie Keene.

[Unidentified]: Here.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Paul Malone. Nicole Morell. Here. Liz Mullane. Here. Erin Olapade. Here. Bob Dickinson? Kim Clinton? Here. Chad Fallon?

[Robert Carney]: Present.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Hodgson?

[Rosemary Park]: Present.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Fiona Maxwell? Here. Lisa Miller? Here. Will Pippicelli?

[Unidentified]: Here.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Paul Rousseau?

[Unidentified]: Here.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Bill Santos? And Dr. Talbot? Here. 11 present. for absence. We have a quorum. The first item on the agenda is approval of our minutes from the October 6th meeting. Is there a motion to approve? Motion to approve by Brian. Is there a second? Second.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Seconded.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. DeLuzzi. We'll call the roll. Jenny Graham, yes. Mayor London Herring, yes. Lucy, yes. Marta Cabral, yes. Ken Lord, yes. Jen Belanger, Libby Brown, yes. Maria Dorsey, Brian Hilliard, yes. Tracy Keene, yes. Paul Malone, Nicole Morell, yes. Liz Mullane, yes. Erin Olapade, yes. Luke Preissner. 11 in the affirmative, 0 in the negative. 4 absent. The minutes are approved. OK. Next on our agenda, we have September invoices. Go forward to that page. I'll turn it over to Jen. All right, thank you. As mentioned, we have two months of invoices up for approval this evening. We have September invoices. We have left field invoice for basic services in the amount of $25,000. An SMMA invoice for basic services as well in the amount of $81,357.

for a total in September of $106,357. Are these votes by month, or are we? Yeah, we have them listed as two separate things. So is there a motion to approve the September invoices for the amount of $106,357? So moved. I can. Is there a second? Second. Nicole, I'll call the roll. Cindy Graham, yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Galusi? Yes. Marty Corral? Yes. Ken Lord? Yes. Jen Blander? Libby Brown?

[Rosemary Park]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Maria Dorsey? Brian Hilliard? Yes. Gracie Keene? Yes. Paul Malone? Paul Morell? Yes. Liz Mullane? Yes. Erna Lupate? Yes. Lou Preissner? Yes. 11 in the affirmative, zero in the negative for absence. The September invoices are approved. Moving right along. We have again, those, those two, left field and SMA basic service invoices for actually the same exact amounts. And there is an additional invoice for SMA as part of that first invoice, but it represents consultant fees in line with their contract in the amount of $9,900 for the month of October and for approval for $116,257.

Is there a motion to approve?

[Unidentified]: So moved.

[Member Jenny Graham]: I can. Second?

[Unidentified]: Second.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Aaron? We'll call roll. Jenny Graham? Yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn?

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Galusi? Yes. Martin Braugh? Yes. Ken Lord? Yes. Jen Belanger? Libby Brown? Yes. Maria Dorsey? Brian Hilliard? Yes. Tracy Keene? Yes. Paul Malone? Nicole Morell? Yes. Liz Mullane? Yes. Erin Olapade? Yes. Luke Eisner? And then the affirmative, zero the negative, four absent. The October invoices are approved. On to item number five on our agenda with our project commitments. So I wanted to provide everybody a summary of where we are in terms of the spend of our feasibility study budget. So I'll turn this over to Jen. All right. So here you can see, this is a high level view of the feasibility study and schematic design budget. Those first three lines in white are OPM, Architectural and Engineering, and Environmental and Site, which is typically entered in architect. And starting below that line in the yellow, we have the other amount. As of right now, that amount is uncommitted, and in the amount of $248,117, The line right below that, which is a peachy orange color, is showing you what is up for approval at our next meeting in December. This is the CM schematic design pre-construction fee. It's not yet committed, but it is on the horizon, so we did want to highlight this. That is $75,000, and that would cover the CM's fee through the end of that design.

against that $3 million original feasibility study budget. We have committed to date to include that $75,000 of about $2.8 million and spent about $1.9 million. And just below that in green, you can see how that stacks up against MSBA reimbursement to date. We have, $693,274 that has been reimbursed back to Medford at this point. That represents 43.34% of the anticipated $1,599,600 maximum grant for this phase. And just to highlight again, the remaining uncommitted budget, the factor in that $75,000 for the CMV would be $144,778 remaining in the feasibility study against that $3 million.

[Unidentified]: Any questions?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any questions from the committee about the status?

[Suzanne Galusi]: Can you just like, it's not much, but can you just speak to what the difference between where it says environmental and site, what was budgeted, and what's been committed so far? Yes, that needs to be updated, actually. Sorry about that.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Because it does show that we are committing. Oh, that's the original amount. The original amount is that $617,000. And then committed to date, we have moved on and added a fee to SMA's contract through amendments. So that committed to date line reflects that amount and then the spend to date is how much, how many interests have been spent against those amounts.

[Suzanne Galusi]: I can make that a little clearer next month. But does that then draw from like the uncommitted line?

[Member Jenny Graham]: So it did originally. So this is meant to be more of a high level snapshot, but we do have, I can get more in the weeds on what shifts have happened behind the scenes from, budget line to budget line when we did start submitting those. We can just add a column for amendments so that the map works across and down. That would be great. Yep, absolutely. Great question. Any other questions before we shift forward to some really exciting stuff? Well, maybe some less exciting stuff and then some exciting stuff. I don't know what order we're going to go in here, but...

Okay, so while it's been a minute since we all last met on October 6th, our advisory teams have been very busy, as was always the plan, providing updates and advice and counsel to this group. And so we have a series of advisory team updates. We've heard a lot last time about the sustainability and MEP systems advisory team. And even though we resolved the questions about geothermal and all that good stuff at our last meeting, which was substantial from a project implications perspective and also certainly a cost perspective. That advisory team had a big set of asks and we have some updates for you all about that team and some of the work that they have done since October 6th. So I'm going to turn it over to Matt to go through what those updates are and give us some information to consider and vote to approve.

[Matt Rice]: Right. So I do also want to point out that this is also exciting material. Our team is also online with us as well and available for some questions if I go too far off course. I'm going to try and just give a high-level overview of what is probably inherently some very detailed information. So if there's questions and it gets above my pay grade, we can certainly pull Martine in. But what we're gonna be covering is, as Jenny said, there were three remaining pieces that we were looking for some feedback or guidance or affirmation of recommendations that came out of the advisory team discussion for sustainability and MEP systems. The first is associated with the heating for the pool, the hot water for the pool. as one item. We're also then going to talk a little bit about the one of the resolution pieces of language that the school committee issued in terms of guiding the sustainability considerations for the project focused specifically on red list materials and healthy materials. So we'll go through that. And then our last one that we're going to talk about is associated with, since we're all getting Mass timber. Yes. And embodied carbon. Um, so we're just, we're going to go back, revisit, um, two cost alternates that were initially put on the table at the end of the PSR phase. Um, we actually have some revised, um, alternates and recommendations that we want to put in front of the building committee and talk through. So to start off with the pool, um, hot water, um, approach, we, uh, ran through a separate life cycle cost analysis, the LCCA. for this because the pool, from an overall energy consumption standpoint, is a whole different animal than the rest of the building. The rest of the building, we talked about last time, we're using air-to-water heat pumps for the heating, ventilation, and cooling of the building as part of our system. We selected a system that did not involve geothermal systems, but it is an all-electric system, so sustainable and also cost-effective, especially when we looked at it over 50 years. We ran through a similar exercise for the pool heating to understand which system we would be selecting. And we really had two options here. One was a gas fired set of water heaters for the pool, which is really our baseline assumption in terms of looking at the cost of what it would be. Again, not just for cost, but looking about over 50 years. The second option we looked at is also actually an air to water heat pump and all electric system. Um, we didn't go into the geothermal, um, sort of considerations, just given the prior discussions that we had with the overall building mechanical system. So we were really looking at those two different systems. Um, and different considerations that came into play, obviously the gas boilers are a fossil fuel burning system, um, which from a sustainability standpoint, we're trying to, um, avoid that if possible, just in terms of avoiding adverse impact. And, um, as we ran out the different systems, there's a whole bunch of small texts down at the bottom, but I'll try to walk through sort of what the high points are. Um, the natural gas boilers, if we were to install those, uh, because we are in a specialized opt in stretch code community, it's meant for daily to do that. We can't just install gas systems as part of a baseline code. We have to also make the building in the system, um, all electric ready. So we have to put an infrastructure to do that. We have to put in photovoltaic panels as well. to be able to offset the fossil fuel consumption. So that's just part of the energy code. So when we looked at the initial costs associated with the natural gas boilers, that $819,000, that's not just the boilers themselves, it's also the potential electrification in the future as we go forward. So there's a bunch of things wrapped into that. The air to water heat pump, all by itself, if we're just looking at the boilers versus the all electric air to water heat pump, Those would probably be a little bit more expensive, but because they don't have to account for that additional electrification in the future, it ends up being a little bit less costly on the first cost, but it's only about $20,000 difference. And so in the grand scheme of what we're looking at, it's about cost neutral in terms of thinking about what the first cost is. We then go all the way to the right-hand side. If you look at the EUI again, that's the efficiency, the energy use intensity of the different systems. The air to water heat pump is actually a much more efficient system in terms of how it's using energy and then heating the pool water. You can see that compared, it's probably less than half of what it would take in terms of efficiency and natural gas boilers. So when we look out over the course of 50 years, there's actually a considerable savings to think about the air to water heat pump as opposed to the natural gas boilers from a cost analysis standpoint. The one caveat that I will put in there, that we have made an assumption in terms of that overall assessment, um, that in 25 years, because we're also, we're not focused just on first cost or operating costs, but also replacement costs. Um, and the assumption is that the pool hot water system, whatever we put in is only good for a certain amount of time over those 50 years. So after 25 years, we would have to factor in the replacement costs of the system. If we were to go out 25 years, it is our assumption that the state of Massachusetts, again, in a specialized stretch code community, probably will not allow for the installation of gas equipment that far out in the future. And you just sort of look at the trends of where things are. The savings in between the air to water heat pump is still less expensive over time. The difference is not quite as dramatic as $846,000. It's about $300,000 less.

Um, but we think that over time, um, there's probably going to be, um, a requirement to replace it with all electric systems. That's what those numbers, um, are all reflecting. So at the end of the day, um, the recommendation is to go with the air to water heat pump, all electric system for the pool hot water heating. Um, it is, it is less costly, um, in the long run. It is about cost neutral upfront. And we already have those costs. So we're not talking about a premium cost add to the project. It's really just selecting the system that we're going to be moving forward with.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Are there any questions from the committee?

[Matt Rice]: Ken is just pointing out in the bottom left-hand corner that we have a, this should probably be reading $27,000. That's a difference in between the 819 and the 792, because he's doing better math very quickly. Right.

[Martine Dion]: It's just a typo. It's just a typo, Matt.

[Matt Rice]: Thank you to whomever was doing that.

[Martine Dion]: When you add the rest, it's 846. I'm not sure why the one was there, but it's a typo.

[Matt Rice]: Did I miss anything in there, Martine?

[Kenneth Lord]: The one thing I was going to ask, we talked about it made more sense to not have just one gas system, but everything else is they have a water heat pump and you know, all the maintenance, just have something different. It makes sense either.

[Matt Rice]: It just to be, have a fair comparison is worth noting that all electric heating systems for pools is a little bit of a newer technology. We were able to sit in on the Tufts pool design as they were actually talking about the hot water system. That is what they are doing over there. So there is local precedent coming in terms of the approach, but we also think this is sort of where the industry is probably going over the long term. So while it's not like we would not be the first ones, we're not thinking any pigs running through this, it is a little bit of a newer technology. So that did factor into the discussion as we were going through, but again, still landed on that option too.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions from the committee?

[Unidentified]: Brian? question then, Matt, did you go through the same type of process of elimination to try to figure that out?

[Matt Rice]: I believe that they must have. Life-cycle cost analysis is part of what's required just by code in terms of evaluation as you go through things. We weren't privy to that as part of the presentation that we sat in. They went through sort of the nuances of the system itself as they went. It seemed like there was a pretty good plan in place, a lot of which we were learning from and probably will have opportunity to talk to them about it as we go forward as well.

[Unidentified]: Any other questions from the committee? I think with the correction of the 127 down to 27, I think that the sound is off. You're saying the 846, Lisa? Yeah, I think it should be 746.

[Matt Rice]: I'm getting that number too. Yes.

[Unidentified]: certainly correct that on the slide moving forward before we actually publish this to the site as well.

[Martine Dion]: Matt there's there's a little note at the bottom that should have the 740 16. Whoever. Thank you.

[Unidentified]: Any other questions, Tracy? Yeah, so Eric awarded the I'm sorry,

[Tracy Keene]: as you said, fairly new, but loose boilers, natural gas boilers, there are a lot of electricians, people who know how to take care of that. With that being new technology, what is the maintenance and what is our school committee, I mean, the maintenance department of the high school going to be able to troubleshoot any issues like that?

[Kenneth Lord]: We would hire up those to work. So we're having the McGuinn-Andrews just put air-to-water heat pump systems on that. We're looking at hiring companies specializing in that to maintain those things.

[Matt Rice]: And I think going back to Ken's other point, it's a real advantage to have at its core the air-to-water heat pumps for the HVAC system. And the one for the pool, it's still the same type of technology, even though it's doing something different. So you have one potential contract to go out through there. And we can also look at specifying it in a way that we get some consistency, ideally, in terms of manufacturers. Great.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions from the committee? I see we have a hand from a member of the public. Will, do you think you could unmute Robert Kearney? And once you're unmuted, your name and address for the record, and you have three minutes.

[Robert Carney]: Sure. Robert Carney, 50 HCSAB, Unit 6. Thank you very much for the time. Just had one question looking at the analysis, which is very detailed. I appreciate all this. You mentioned that we're participating in a specialized opt-in stretch code. And I'm curious, how would these numbers change if Medford hadn't opted opted into the specialized opt-in stretch code? And has your team done an analysis to see what is the overall difference in the cost of the project compared to a city like Medford's specialized opt-in stretch code versus a city that's not in the specialized opt-in stretch code in Massachusetts? Thank you.

[Martine Dion]: Matt, do you want me to take this?

[Matt Rice]: That's exactly where I was going to go.

[Martine Dion]: So to answer the first part of where OK, to answer the first part of your question, the one component that would change in this chart would be the estimated installation cost. That would be slightly lower, probably equivalent to the air to water heat pump. So that $27 savings may not be there, but all the other cost would remain. So it would still be more expensive over 50 years. The difference between the standard stretch codes and the specialized stretch code is the electrification. But I will put a little caveat with this, is the fact that by the time you would replace your natural gas boiler in 25 years, that specialized stretch code would probably be the code. And you would have to do the replacement, which is what we accounted for here in the replacement cost. So you would have to do the replacement. Let's say that you don't have the specialized stretch goal. So you saved on the electrification readiness now in five years. But in 25 years, you would have to spend for all kinds of upgrades to your electrical system That would be more expensive than doing it now. You would have to do it in 25 years and put in the electric system in 25 years. So in the end, it's still less expensive over 50 years.

Did I answer your question?

[Robert Carney]: You did. Very, very informative. Thanks very much.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Thanks, Martine. So with that, is there a vote to approve Sustainability MEP systems recommendation to include air water heat pump with backup electric boiler to serve the pool. So moved by Tracy, seconded by Libby. I will call the roll. Jenny Graham, yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn, yes. Dr. Galussi, yes. Marta Cabral, yes. Ken Lord, yes. Jen Belanger, Libby Brown, yes. Maria Dorsey, Brian Hilliard? Yes. Tracy Keene? Yes. Paul Malone? Nicole Morell? Yes. Liz Mullane? Yes. Erin Olapade? Yes. Luke Pressner? 10 in the affirmative, zero in the negative, five absent. The motion is approved.

Next from our sustainability and MEP system team, who has been working really hard. They have had a very big job.

[Matt Rice]: They have won the prize also for the highest number of advisor team meetings. I think they were up to eight. because we have been able to get into a lot of really amazing detail running through some very complex topics. So this is the next one that came up. Again, ties back to the topic of red list material, red list free materials, as well as healthy materials at a larger scale within the interior environment primarily. And we're really tying back into the school committee resolutions on sustainability that were made. This one in particular originally started out as you see at the top to prioritize the healthy material points to obtain the additional 1% MSBA reimbursement. After that initial version of it was issued, there was a revised amendment to language of that resolution Um, that dealt a little bit more specifically into the topic of red list free materials, healthy materials. And really the, the, the crux of the revised statement came in after that initial bolded statement where it says for all materials, except MEP FP, which is mechanical, electrical, plumbing and fire protection, um, and prioritize the healthy material credits necessary to obtain the maximum indoor air quality. Massachusetts School Building Authority reimbursement to ensure superior indoor air quality for students and staff. So the intent there was to create the healthy healthiest indoor environment possible for staff and students within the building. The reality though as we dissected that particular statement is that the all materials except MEPFP was a little bit broader probably than it was initially intended in terms of potentially driving some cost premiums in the project. Because when we look for all materials, there are some materials out there when we start thinking about everything that goes inside of a building, from the drywall to the finishes to the ceiling to the paints. Some of those things would actually not have three competitive equals in a competitive bidding environment. And when that happens, those manufacturers, they're just they're smart, they follow sort of market forces and they can raise the price of their material. I mean, it's more expensive for good reason, right? It has certain environmental benefits that are above and beyond, but without that competition, it will increase the cost to the project. And so the advisory team walkthrough is a revision to the language of the resolution that's still targeted getting the best indoor air quality, the healthiest indoor space for staff and students, Um, and really all community members, um, and all occupants. I think maybe you made a revision at the end there. It says the quality for all occupants at the end. Um, so we're also talking about the community members that are coming to the building, um, to use it, um, for any of the various purposes that we have here. Um, but we've gotten rid of that all materials qualification. And, um, what we're looking to do is specify red blister materials as economically feasible within the occupant breathable space. And so that focuses the selection of those non-harmful materials are things that are emitting or the potential to emit directly into the space that we all walk through and breathe in terms of air and focusing there in terms of red list free materials. And then we're also looking to specify healthy materials for all materials and prioritize need healthy materials credits necessary to obtain that maximum indoor air quality MSBA reimbursement. So we're still targeting the additional reimbursement point that is available from the MSBA to have this focus on healthy materials. And that is still written within the resolution. But we're pulling back a little bit from that all materials and focusing where we have, and it says economically feasible, that's really targeting where we have at least three competitive equals. And so the end result there is that we will not be imparting a cost premium on any of those materials to the project and driving the cost of the project up. we're looking to try to find the best of both worlds in terms of both the healthy environment and also the avoidance of added premiums on top. So that's a long way of saying what that is after. And there was a lot of discussion about that to get to this particular verbiage that was here. I'm certainly happy to answer any questions on how it was, what we ended up with.

[Unidentified]: Does that, do you think that will actually allow some of the NP and bioprotection vacuums in the mix for better fit? If there's anything that's creating or contributing to a favorable space, or is that still likely?

[Matt Rice]: I would say that we will look for any options that we have opportunities in terms of specified healthy materials, even if it's like ductwork insulation. If we have three different manufacturers that all have labeled. So when it comes to red list free materials, it is labeling as well that the manufacturers have to go out for and receive in terms of getting sort of that certification. But if we have three of those, we can do it. Yeah, there's certainly nothing we won't just go down like a a tried and true path if we have other better options. It's not prevalent in that area of the industry yet, but I'm sure it's coming as it comes to everything as we go along.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Libby? I have a question about the specs. I know things have to be equal, but say there's three products. One is red list free, two aren't, but their performance-wise are the same, but they may just actually as the declared label. can the language and specs say, like, preference given or like, you know, the contractor, often they'll just go with whatever they're more familiar with and they'd like to install it. But like, if they're like, oh, these are all the same to me, we could put them towards the one that's okay in the spec language, or is that too specific?

[Matt Rice]: No, no, no. There's definitely that opportunity available, not just for like healthy materials, but for other considerations as well. We always have a, substitution request form that goes in as part of the front end pieces of specs, right? And any subcontractor, any bidder, we don't usually do it during the bidding phase, but after an award, we will review an alternative that's submitted, provided that it has all the comparative data that we need to be able to make a fair evaluation. A lot of times we'll get a bidder just saying, well, we used this on the last project, so here you go. And so that goes back to them and says, no, please give us more information. But we could do exactly that type of thing. on the healthy material front. If a manufacturer knows that they have something that is comparable to what we specified and maybe doesn't have the certification, we can look at that and make an evaluation and say, yeah, there's a positive value to Medford to be able to go forward with that. Maybe it's an economic value, maybe it's an improved health value, but we have that sort of tool available to us as we go through the specs and the bidding process.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions? Is there a motion to approve this recommendation to the school committee?

[Unidentified]: So moved.

[Member Jenny Graham]: By Ken. Second. Second by Brian. Since you're sitting right next to me, my ear hurts. I'll call the roll. Jenny Brown, yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Galuski. Yes. Raul. Yes. Ken Lord. Yes. Jen Belanger. Libby Brown. Yes. Maria Dorsey, Brian Hilliard, Tracy Keene, Paul Malone, Phil Morell, Liz Lane, Aaron Olapodich, Ruth Preissner. 11 affirmatives or the negative for absent. The motion is approved. Next. Shaw. Mass Timber.

[Matt Rice]: So this is our last topic and also our last like all text slide if this is It's trying on your eyes, it's trying on my eyes as well. This topic ties into the larger topic of total carbon considerations within the project, which is broken down right into embodied carbon, the carbon that's in the materials that we build the building with, and operational carbon, whatever we're consuming, emitting in terms of carbon operating the building as we go forward. So there was a larger analysis than this on the full carbon front that looked both at what the existing building, how it's performing, both from embodied carbon and operational carbon versus where we were. At the end of the day, the embodied carbon is probably a smaller part of the overall carbon pie, if you will, as we move forward. It's not inconsequential, but the operational carbon, where we're having a tremendous beneficial impact versus how this building is operating today. It's operating with fossil fuels. We're switching to a much more efficient system with zero fossil fuels other than what is in the grid, and that's sort of a larger story, but we're using electricity, right, to power this building moving forward. But it doesn't mean that we want to completely ignore the topic of embodied carbon. We are renovating and salvaging a portion of the existing building, which is helpful when you're looking at embodied carbon. But the other piece that we can really have some impact on is if we consider an alternative structural system to the traditional steel or concrete, which are both very high embodied carbon approaches to a structure of a building. So mass timber building with wood is actually productive in terms of the embodied carbon. We can sequester carbon inside of wood as it grows, right?

The initial cost alternatives that we looked at during the previous feasibility study phase They were fairly simple. We were working at a very high level when we were looking in that part of the feasibility study phase. And we just looked at replacing the entirety of the addition structural frames that we were doing, either with 100% of mass timber or thinking that we would just replace 50% of the steel frame with a mass timber frame. Those two numbers that you see up top are the result of those two different cost alternates that we had. Um, they were 17.8 and $13.6 million to be able to do that. So, um, extraordinary costly, um, in terms of first cost impact to the project. And so we, we pulled away from those as considerations, um, with the advisory team as well. Rather than just abandoning it entirely though, we did want to put in, um, or at least on the table for consideration to additional, uh, mass timber, uh, top alternates. that will be less impactful upfront, we expect certainly than those two that are there, but allow us also to use some more knowledge that we have about the building moving forward, where we have better abilities to avoid sort of a really extreme cost premium for doing what we're doing. So the two potential cost alternatives that we have there, which we've labeled timber three and timber four, and we have some, maybe I'll just jump to the images here, because I think it's helpful to explain this.

So timber three would use what's called dowel laminated timber as a roof deck for the gymnasium. So the existing roof deck in the gymnasium is a tectum. It's like a wood fiber that has already been down to deteriorate because there's moisture and it doesn't hold up very well over time, certainly over 50 years. So we're going to have to replace it anyway. If we were not going to do a wood approach, we would replace it with what's called a metal deck that has an acoustic quality to it.

We're trying to help the acoustics of the gym. The dowel-liminated timber can also have the insulation in it. It has those slats of wood, just like the image that's up there. So it would be sort of a one-for-one swap out of the metal acoustic deck to the wood deck. Um, that roof deck in the gym does not need a fire rating to it. And that's one of the challenges with the wood overall. And the reason why there was such a cost premium to it for just replacing the entirety of the thing, because it's a certain height above the gym floor, it doesn't need to be rated. So we think that this is a good cost alternative. Just look at it. It's a very sort of simple cost per square foot A versus B. Um, and we can come back and we can let the building committee know sort of what that premium would be as an option. Um, the other one that we are, suggesting he looked at is to focus on the early childhood center wing of the building because working through with our code consultant we're also able to and will be treating that as a separate building from an overall code perspective. The rest of the high school building is a six story building. It's going to be take that away. It's probably five hundred and thirty thousand square. It's just it's enormous and it drives a certain level of fire safety from a code perspective. With the smaller building area, we have more opportunities available to us, again, with not having to go to those higher fire ratings. So we can swap out different parts and pieces of that structural frame. We'll work to find sort of the optimal one from a cost perspective. But we think it would be really nice to have the opportunity to have the youngest students that will be in the building have the ability to be exposed to a wood column, exposed wood structure, that type of thing, and have those connections to nature. Um, we talk about biophilic design before the connection to, uh, natural elements, I think really has, um, significant advantages when we're thinking about the youngest learners in the building. Um, so that would be the other, um, option that we would be looking at, um, again, much less costly, um, than those overall timber one and timber two alternates that we were looking at initially. So the plan here would be to, um, go out. to the cost estimating groups in about a month's time, get some prices back and then come back to this building committee as we're reviewing the overall cost and decide which of those might want to be included. It could be one, it could be both, it could be none as we go forward. So it's really just trying to get some additional costs and when this committee have an awareness and buy into it.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any questions from the committee? Brian?

[Unidentified]: So I think you just answered my question. Because what I was really hoping was that, as per some of the code plans, that maybe there was a, I'm going to say, a better place to cordon off the building and say, here's our timber frame. And I was hoping it's like the entry, the immediate center, or something like that. And I was trying to slice it off in my brain. But I think you answered it by saying, we're just not separating that part from the rest.

[Matt Rice]: Yeah. OK. We have a lot of other code challenges with the rest of the building in terms of like connected stories and heights and all those types of things. So I completely sympathize. And I agree with the sentiment, but this is the one place where it is just very fundamental need for us to separate it.

[Unidentified]: I do. I love the idea of the kids and then when they get to see it right out of the gate. What I was telling you is a little more public engaged. That this is great. I'm sure you've been sprinkling to me. It was wood cladding.

[Suzanne Galusi]: I think we might have mentioned at least in our other meeting, if not just not tonight, about not using it at the pool because of the mezzanine where the batting cages are too close.

[Member Jenny Graham]: And that was about fire rating, is that right? I thought that there were versions of this that were inherently like two hour rated because

[Suzanne Galusi]: you know, there's so much wood and it's charred and won't actually burn.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Is that not the case with the product you guys are looking at, or is there just something I'm really not aware of?

[Matt Rice]: We can do a little bit more research into it and see with like talking to the manufacturers of dowel laminate and timber, whether or not we can get to that rating. I think it would be like a one hour rating that we would need on the roof over there. So it's not above and beyond. If it was available to us, it's probably a lot cleaner and easier to continue one structural deck across the entirety from the gym into the pool as well. And I think we would just also talk to them about the preservative materials that we would have to go on to make sure that the new wood deck that we would put over the pool is not subject to the same moisture issues that the existing pectum deck.

[Unidentified]: Sure, moisture is up there too. Yeah, right.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Just curious.

[Unidentified]: We can definitely look into that though.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Other questions from the committee?

[Unidentified]: Lisa, just wondering, do any of these decisions about how much mass timber to use affect reimbursement?

[Matt Rice]: They do not, and I think it's really tied into that earlier decision that we made to go for the LEED version four versus LEED version five. LEED version five places a much higher premium in terms of integration of sort of carbon analysis into a lot of the different credits and prerequisites, whereas LEED version four just takes a slightly different approach in terms of where the focus is. So there will be no direct impact on like the LEED credits that we have or prerequisites, and so therefore there's not a direct connection into any of the reimbursement points that we have from those.

[Unidentified]: One, two, three.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions from the committee? Is there a motion to approve the elimination of timber one and timber two and the addition of three and four as alternates for the next round of cost estimating?

[Unidentified]: Motion to approve.

[Member Jenny Graham]: By Aaron. Second. Ready? OK. I'll roll. Jenny Graham. Yes.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Galusi? Yes. Marta Cabral? Yes. Ken Lord? Yes. Jen Ballantyre? Libby Brown? Yes. Maria Dorsey? Brian Hilliard? Yes. Grace Keane? Yes. Paul Malone? Liz Morell? Sorry, Liz Mullane? Yes. Nicole Morell? Yes. Erin Olapade? Yes. Sue Kreisner? 11 in the affirmative, zero in the negative. Four absent. On to our interior exterior design. Oh, sorry. Our occasional planning and equity team. Sorry. To provide some updates about the work that planning and equity team has been doing.

[Unidentified]: I think I'm going to turn it over to Rosemary here. So I don't know where we're.

[SPEAKER_20]: Should be good now, Rosemary.

[Rosemary Park]: Okay, thank you. I was like, I don't know how to tell them that I cannot unmute. Okay, so good evening, everyone. I'm just going to give us a quick high level overview of the current floor plans and some of the recommendations and comments that had come out of the Ed Planning and Equity Advisory Team meeting. Our goal during that meeting was to actually review the plans and see how the program adjacencies and the floor plans aligns with the team's recommended priorities from previous phases, the ones that had been established earlier during the feasibility phase. So at the first floor, at level one, we have the early education center.

So the early education center actually makes up the first two floors. of this kind of southern portion, and you can see that in that kind of burgundy maroon color. And at the first level, we have the Kids' Corner and Medford Family Network located there, and that's all that's located on level one. When we move to level two, we continue with the ECC spaces stacked directly above the Kids' Corner and MSN, and we have meet located right there on that southern portion of the building. This floor also has the main office, some community facing CT programs, the performing arts spaces, including the auditorium, as well as some community facing and community use spaces. Also at the second level, this really acts as the first floor to the high school. And so we have the main entrance to the high school at the center of the floor. And then there's a community entrance at the east end of the building, which will be used by the public to access the pool, the gym, the auditorium and other community facing spaces.

So if we move to the next slide. So level three at the southern wing, we've got, again, stacked above the ECC. At this floor, we have central offices, the Welcome Center and the Teen Health Center to the south in that wing. And so the location of this is pretty intentional in trying to separate out the circulation, that internal circulation from the non-high school related programs. So the third floor also has the gymnasium, the existing gymnasium, the pool, and the PE support spaces all in that orange, the large orange box.

The dining commons are also located on this floor with learning communities to both the north and the south. And this floor does have several CTE programs located here as well. A few public facing ones, as well as the construction cluster of CTE programs. And then when we move to level four, the fourth floor has that bright lime green that you see, that is the media center, which would be overlooking the main entrance plaza, potentially with some kind of outdoor terrace too.

And it has an adjacency to some of the computer technology related CT programs. And then level four is where we start to see these there are three within the building, and they're distributed across floors four, five, and six, and they're centrally located on the plans with integrated learning communities of general academics, special education, and intentionally clustered CT programs to both the North and the South. Then to the next slide. So at the fifth floor, we have the visual arts classrooms that are located at the center of the plan, that darker purple, with learning communities to both the North and the South. And one of these learning communities also includes the science and health-related cluster of CTE programs. And then on the sixth floor, this is where we'll also see some of the non-CTE technology and innovation labs. we'll start to see those kind of in the center of the plan with learning communities to both the north and the south.

And there is also this area, and you can't quite see the hatch here, I guess, but the team has also identified to the north, really to the northeast, a future expansion area on the roof of that roof. That's the CTE wing below. Um, if needed. Next, please. And so overall, you know, the advisory team thought that, uh, so we reviewed the plans. Um, and the team really felt that, uh, the both the circulation, um, the access throughout the building and the program adjacencies were pretty well aligned to the that we were able to, um. Recommended priorities from the previous phases. But just a few high level comments here. Um, they. They did appreciate the, um the lobby entrance at the auditorium for public and communal use, and they thought that that was a great way to be able to maintain that kind of access and separation from the They highlighted the need also to purpose build storage for instruments for performing arts, given that there are so many instruments and that there are different requirements regarding care and storage and handling of them.

They recommended that we also, that we continue to carry the proposed retractable seating in the large group instructional spaces. because this would allow for maximum flexibility given the anticipated frequency and variety of use, the projected variety of use of these rooms and of these spaces, both throughout the school day and then after hours. They also recommended that we ensure that there's ease of moving large objects throughout the school, especially at the auditorium. So there were a couple of discussions surrounding that.

they asked that the design team also ensure that Curtis Tufts has enough office space for any kind of student support needs. There was a lot of appreciation for the way that the team had thought about clustering and locating similar CT programs while still being integrated into the different learning communities with general classrooms and special education programs, but still trying to not isolate the CT programs and still giving them the ability to have their own identities as well.

And we did kind of end on this note on just overall locker usage. It's always a pretty big topic at high school, And so out of this, the group had come up with the recommendation to issue a survey to students just on what their daily, weekly, monthly locker usage might be. And so that's something that I think that we're looking to issue at some point soon. And that's it.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any questions about any of the conversations on the educational planning equity team? Okay. The next item on our agenda is interior and, oh, site safety and security, I'm wrong again. I was following, the votes aren't coming, so I'll take it away.

[Matt Rice]: Laura, are you going to take this over?

[Member Jenny Graham]: I'll take this one. Laura Swan, site civil engineer with SMMA. And I think the last time this committee saw sort of the overall site plan, the field had been moved up north and the parking had been sort of broken up. So they had a sea of parking. It's now kind of distributed. Sorry. The biggest thing that's happened since then So we had a lot of discussions about circulation and arrival and how to accommodate all the people coming to the site and how they would all get to the different doors that they need to get to and exit safely and in an orderly fashion, please. Right. So we say that every day. So the biggest change is that we added a teardrop shaped loop.

next to the dining commons. Oh yeah, that pointer is kind of hovering over it right now. And this would allow the school buses and the special education vehicles to have a place where they could pull over and be legally passed, right? As well as pass each other. So there is a lot of sort of flexibility and room in that additional loop. And it will allow the students who come into the sort of the same main area of the school. It would just be coming in the Diamond Commons side. The parent will go into the circulation. I don't want to get ahead of myself.

The other main changes, instead of having a roundabout at the top of Stephen Owen Drive, this has become a three-way intersection again. sort of another drop-off loop has been made in front of the ECCB.

[Member Aaron Olapade]: Aaron? Yeah, I had a quick question. There was a discussion, you know, many months ago about first responders and just the ease of access for fire trucks, ambulances, any other types of professionals in that regard. Have you, can you talk a little bit about what this, how this design will impact that consideration?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yes, so we do run simulations of emergency vehicles, usually an aerial ladder truck, through all the different possible loops and corridors and everything like that. So it is all accessible. The other thing too is this also gives a lot more opportunity for people to pass each other or turn around. There's, I don't know if you can quite tell from this scale, but there is a sort of like a drop-off queue lane for the parents. So hopefully those vehicles can kind of stay to the far right and allow for emergency vehicles to pass them on the left as they come up the drive and up the, I guess let's say the east side of the property.

[Matt Rice]: Maybe just to summarize on top of that, I would say the first responders, we've met with them a couple of times. I would say they're very happy with the site circulation all the way around. We have them, just as Laura said, showed them all their turning radii, so we know that we can get all the apparatus all the way 360 degrees around the building, which is a dramatic improvement, right, from what was there currently.

[Unidentified]: Thank you. I think it's worth pointing out. Brian. Brian. Number three is, I know Keith had mentioned there, being able to sort of their own little, I don't know if you're going to do bollards or something there, have their own little path that's accessible to the corner building. I think that was a nice concession on their part to allow access through there.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yes, we're looking at making this um right now it's going to be a pedestrian sort of corridor that um like sort of the main entry in that front loop down to the ECC entry in that plaza but it would also be at like mountain curb and be accessible by emergency vehicles only as well as allowing an emergency vehicle to get very close to the field.

[Unidentified]: More questions, Lisa? With the entrance to the school off of one term, is that a divided entrance now? I see a green line down the middle of that.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yes, it would have a median divider. And that was another sort of request by the first responders to be able to maybe control traffic in a, like by having some sort of way of dividing the two.

[Unidentified]: Will that entrance be widened then?

[Member Jenny Graham]: It will be widened. So it'll be two lanes and a, I mean, and I think it's like a nine foot queuing lane coming onto the property. And then we think it'd be two lanes and a bike lane, what we're looking at right now.

[Unidentified]: and also two lanes exiting as well, right? So there's a total of four.

[Member Jenny Graham]: So it'd be like four vehicular lanes. And then coming onto the property, we were looking at different ways of either putting the bikes at the same grade as the vehicles, or maybe up with the pedestrian, depending on other discussions and tweaking of the plan.

[Unidentified]: Any other questions before we Are we going to have a conversation on this topic later?

[Member Jenny Graham]: We're going to go through circulation diagram, but yeah. So if you want to know who's going to drop off where and everything like that, yeah. Lydia? I'm just curious, is there like a central area for bike parking?

[Suzanne Galusi]: Maybe you mentioned it, I'd hear it somewhere, like where do bikes come once they get past like number four?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yes, so we're still looking at that part and discussing it. But the idea is to have bike parking for 90 bikes as part of the leave by credit. That's kind of our guide. And that would probably be distributed a little bit with some up by main entrance, some around the field, some by the ECC. So it would probably all be kind of at this level, mostly at this level. instead of up at the field or something like that. Yeah, I'm just curious if they could not have to go the whole loop around. Yeah, that's what we're kind of looking at, because there's also a queuing lane and having bikes trying to travel that while people are trying to get over into that queuing lane sometimes causes a conflict.

[John Falco]: Paul? Are we doing covered bike parking?

[Unidentified]: That is required. A certain percentage of it needs to be covered. That's because I have long-term storage.

[Member Aaron Olapade]: This might be a later conversation about designated student versus staff parking, or is it a presumption to be integrated currently?

[Kenneth Lord]: I really can't answer that. HAB-Michael Lecceseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[Member Aaron Olapade]: we're visiting for a variety of reasons as well. It's going to drop off. Yeah.

[Suzanne Galusi]: Okay. I would say this has been an ongoing conversation and it's still going to be an ongoing conversation but also where you see that P at the top near where like the front door will be also has to be I believe um right some of the like pool parking or people that are visiting other places so pool parking might be on the east side over there okay but

[Kenneth Lord]: Handicap accessible parking, a loop in the front, turn and drop off, pick up, there's lots of things that have been in plans that it's hard to see from this level.

[Member Jenny Graham]: It's important that our site is north to south and slides go east to west. We could see a whole lot more if we had a different shape of site.

[Matt Rice]: I would just say that the parking up at the top here, this P, because they're proximate to other building entrances, just as it happens today, right? Staff is probably going to be assigned to those lots top. And if you're in proximity, wherever your classroom or shop spaces to those spaces, that's probably how it can get sorted out. There's going to be numbered spots moving forward as well. So that can be tracked and managed. But that just makes sense to allow people to enter the building as close as they can from a staff perspective.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Do we have a question here in the room? Do you want to come? We just need to come to the table so that people online can hear you.

[SPEAKER_21]: Your name and address for the record. Sure. My name is Yen Q. My address is 48 Brooklyn Street. One of my concerns with regard to parking is that sometimes this day and age, we're trying to accommodate electric vehicles. So when we are trying to accommodate them, we need to not put them in places that will block incoming school traffic. Working at Somerville High School, they decided to designated electric vehicle parking in the school loop where parents are driving and then staff is driving. So it renders the electric vehicle parking unusable. Nobody can use it because it's like in the everyday movement of cars. So that really creates many problems. just having a little bit more forethought about where electric vehicle parking gets put. It can't be put in the everyday access and ins and outs of the building.

Thank you. Any questions before we move on?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Okay. So this is when we start to get into who's going to drop off where. And yes, right now, this is a very flexible site plan though. So if things need to be adjusted and need to swap out one loop for another, it allows for that on this site plan. So right now, the idea is that A, by the front door would be where the passenger vehicles would drop off, mostly because allow for a very long queue on the site and that would keep all the parents keep going to the right and they wouldn't have to like cross into other traffic. So the idea is parents drop off at A and down at C that would be where the MBTA buses could pull up in queue and students could exit through the main Entry at one, walk down that plaza, get onto their buses, and several of them could line up at once and take off from there. And the new teardrop at B would be where the school buses could line up. They could get there early. They aren't going to interfere with any other queuing on the site. They could do their own lineup. And as soon as they're full, they can also get priority to leave the site and get onto their route, since they have a very sort of tight timeline to keep to.

[John Falco]: Paul? I've watched the current special ed buses coming and going, and also been a parent taking me to a special ed school where there's lines of these special ed buses which are coming from all over the place. And frequency, which nobody knows, which adds up, is very, very high. It's all these little buses coming from all over the place and they don't, you swap out a bus driver and everything's a mess. But the other thing I noticed, even at Medburn, is that there's often, it's a lot of time sometimes, get all the kids on, or ideally everybody just gets on when they're supposed to, everybody goes on their way, but then one is late.

When we're talking about the big buses, lateness isn't quite the same. I don't know, I just feel like there's a different level of timeliness required than the other buses. And that's probably just based on the volume of individual buses. My point is just, I'm worried about the kids that are going to be getting on those buses, sort of interacting with the big buses. And, you know, you did say there's going to be room for passing. I guess I'm struggling to explain it, but I'm just really concerned that these are different kinds of student populations in a very different needs. And I just, I think the flow here is what kind of worries me. Because I mean, I've been a parent in the loop now. You know, I get in the same loop with the buses. I have a pleasant experience. So I'm super glad that's going to be separated. And I think that will help a lot. I'm sure security will be happy to stop screaming at people like parents who are in the wrong lane.

But I am worried about the special ed buses. Can we just have another group somewhere else? Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, also like where their programming is, you know, the access programming I think is over on that side. So that's good that it's closed. But right now, I think it's a long hike to get to where the buses are today and pick them up. But I've just noticed that they are there sometimes for a long time.

And I'm worried about having some classes just taking up a lot of room when we're trying to do other stuff there. But I'm sure you're working on it, but. Dr. Galisti?

[Suzanne Galusi]: Yeah, and chime in, Kim. We've had a lot of conversations around this, which is part of what you're bringing up is also part of what helped create the teardrop. because we did want to be able to have space where there could be the pullover for vans, not every van, but some do require maybe some additional time based on what the physical needs are of students that are loading the van. So we definitely need the ability for our special occasion vans to be able to pull over and park so that you can have the onboarding and the offboarding. and not get stuck in some of the other traffic that's maybe on the other side of the building.

And this does allow, as Laura said, for the queuing to start a little earlier. I do think we also have some timing issues that we can be discussing and we can talk about. We don't want students going earlier waiting for the van, but the loading is definitely a piece that I think, you know, we can we can discuss but this provides accessibility right on that first floor where the dining hall is and I think there's you can see is that the other piece we talked about is right uh to the right of it where that little red star is there's going to be opportunities for like the queuing um that I think we'll be able to have separate queuing for where the yellow buses will be first where the special education beams would be or Is there anything else you wanted to add?

[Unidentified]: Thank you.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions from the committee?

[Member Aaron Olapade]: We've had a lot of discussion in the school committee from our student representatives and some surveys they've been doing about the queuing for the MBTA buses and kind of the all the things that come with that and so I know that we don't have direct control over the MBTA and what they do when it comes to designating certain bus routes and you know they kind of are in charge of those things but I know that that's a really big thing for our students and trying to negotiate how we're separating each individual queuing line so they feel safe and they don't think there's a just one mad dash to the front. Yeah there's a lot of pushing and just some concern about safety and things like that and I think you know they're all trying to get home and get to their sports queue lines as best as possible so our students feel like they have a little bit more ease at the end of their school day would be something I just want to kind of think about a little bit as well.

[Suzanne Galusi]: As you can see from this slide, that also was part of the conversation that Principal Cabral brought up too, which is I think why this also separates the yellow buses from the MBTA, so there's a whole separate queuing. for students that take the MBTA versus the North. As of right now, Lord knows what it will be a couple years from now, but the yellow bus that goes to North Mecklerd area and the square.

[Matt Rice]: And just that also, we have actually a conversation with students about that as well. So we've heard directly that type of feedback and it's It's really, it's interesting, right, because the difference between either you get pushed into the side of the bus or you get pushed into the side of those sort of guardrails that have been put in. There's lots more conversations that we need to have with the MBTA to understand what works well. We're going to do that in concert with the school as well to make sure that everyone is sort of finding, but I think that the best path to the solution for providing enough space where we can get all the buses queued up so. Maybe it's not a mad dash to that one first bus, like there could be three or four queued up that you can all sort of pick from. And then just like a subway car, you get a little bit more optionality in terms of where you're going, hopefully less squishing into the side of something. So you're going to eliminate the guardrails? So there weren't extra views of the guardrails.

[Unidentified]: There are extra views.

[John Falco]: distance from, because the ECC, it's not going to be a normal exit spot for students. Right. But I meant for the kids getting on campus. It's a long way from the exit of the building to there, which isn't a problem in my mind. But I would like us to think about covered spaces in that, sea area because, I mean, right now they, you know, it's pouring, you know, we're not getting too much rain anymore, but if it's pouring, they're inside the building, waiting, peering out, and then running out. But it's a lot closer now than what it will be. And I'm just worried about expecting people to just go stand out there and hope that the bus shows up on time. Or even if it is there already, you know, a quarter of them show up, they've got to get on.

It's just a very long distance from where you come out of the building to where you've got to get on a bus. And rather than waiting there for the bus, if it's late, rather than running from the building. And I mean, I'm looking at pictures of what you have up there now, but it feels like there's an opportunity there. I don't know.

[Matt Rice]: But then too, with the PV canopies, we haven't wrapped them all the way around there. Maybe there could be a section that comes through there that provides a little bit of cover. I think it's built for the PPA as opposed to through RSV.

[Member Jenny Graham]: We have one question online that I want to take from Adam Stewart.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Hi, thanks. This is Adam Stewart. I'm at 172. I'm on an off topic question, but I know there was a really a spot agenda for general like process questions and a question regarding the process from now to the completion of the cost estimate. If you guys can share some information or point to where that is of What are the steps between now and the completion of that cost estimate as far as is there a pencils down point that goes the cost estimate or comes back? Is it an iterative process? I think understanding a bit more of that process will help people know what's involved with getting from here to all the way out in January before we have a number.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Thanks. I can take a crack at that and then you all can keep me honest. There's a lot of conversation going on right now from a schematic design perspective where they're building out plan, like the plans that are required to get to a construction estimate, which is a different kind of level of detail than what we have been able to operate against in the past. So the architect is working on that with the SMA's work. Um, our construction manager at risk is Suffolk Construction and, um, our contract with them is in negotiations, but they are onboarding and asking lots of questions about, um, all the things that we are making assumptions about in terms of what would go into the cost estimate. Um, and so by the middle of December, a package with all of those questions and answers and assumptions and construction plans, drawings, and all of that good stuff goes to the estimators at mid-December so that the estimators, there's two sets of estimators, one at Suffolk, one at Left Field. They then do their independent cost estimation, and then they come together and do a reconciliation, and that becomes available to this body and to the city at the very end of January.

And at that time, that is the number that sort of comprises what will this project cost. So there is a pencils down date. It is December 14. But our anticipation is that the next SBC meeting in December, we'll be voting to send the project to the cost estimators. And then they'll have about a month to do their work. Does that help? Thumbs up. Thumbs up. OK. Thank you. OK. We still do have quite a bit to get through, so I just want to do a quick check and move us forward.

So it is 7.52. OK. I can speak to this next slide. It's very similar to the last one, so I don't think we'll have so many questions. This is just about how the early child care center circulation will work. Once again we're going to have use actually just the A and the C loops for this. There's kids corner. Anticipate the parents coming and dropping off in the C loop. There will be some reserved parking spaces, some visitor parking for parents to park and exit the vehicles and take the children inside. The larger program of course coming into the MEET program and the idea would be to have the parents use the same parent queue and drop off in that A loop and there is a that breezeway and a connection that would allow for perhaps entry onto like the north side of the building instead of going all the way down the sidewalk to enter at number three.

There's also special vehicles and those could go into the same sort of pull-out bus loop that we have for the META.

[Matt Rice]: Lori, I would just add that the key to all this working, right, is that we're not doing early education center drop-off and pick-up at the same time that we're doing high school or curriculum. These things are happening at different times. There's a lot of nuance to be worked out in terms of exactly what those times are. And that's something to be studied as part of a project evolves. We do have a lot of time to work through those details until the building is fully open and operational with everybody inside of it. But it certainly is, there's long queues and that's what these diagrams really show well, both for the high school parent drop-off as well as for the preschool drop-off coming through. And then it's really working around those big drivers on circulation.

[Member Jenny Graham]: So the last thing we talked about in our site safety and security advisory teams was school sign. What does it want to look like out on Winthrop Street? And the team recommendation was to have more of a masonry school identification sign, externally lit instead of having like an LED lit from the interior sort of sign. It doesn't mean you can't have some sort of LED message board elsewhere on site. It's just what would the presence be on the street? And this was their recommendation.

[John Falco]: Paul, sorry. It previously happens later, but their consideration of how that will interact with the memorial, Veterans Memorial, which is substantial, I mean I'm assuming that like there will essentially be no separation at that point.

[Member Jenny Graham]: We're looking at perhaps putting this sign within the median, be divided.

[Unidentified]: Any other questions? Nicole?

[Suzanne Galusi]: Building assuming, because I think he has like like dark skies, like the line would point downward, it wouldn't be like up and correct.

[Unidentified]: I think that that's a requirement. I see a star once again in my life. Are there questions? Lisa? I have a question from the previous discussion. We were talking a lot about pick up and drop off for the flow, but we didn't really talk much about athletic events, whether they're in the gym or on one of the playing fields. I don't know that. I'm assuming that's been discussed, but like, in terms of access to the gym or parking for big games that are up on the North field or their walkways, you know, and it looks like there's pretty limited parking if there has been part of the conversation for, because I think, you know, buses are coming and bringing other teams and all of that. And so that's all been accounted for in there. Yeah, there's been a lot of discussions about what we've put as much

[Member Jenny Graham]: as we could up at the field level, especially handicapped parking. And the bus loop itself could also be used by team buses at that teardrop. But a big part of the intention of the breezeway was to connect that larger parking lot for larger events up to the field level by basically making a shortcut. that would not require, say, opening up a building or for people to go up to the building. So the idea is that as much as people can, there's parking at the field levels. There's parking by the practice field too.

And there's a couple, you know, parking spots that'll be tucked back there. But if there's a very large event, then the idea is that pedestrians could use that breezeway to basically have a little shortcut and more pleasant experience going into the field. But there would be pedestrian walkways that are either accessible or have handicap ramps to make it possible for a pedestrian to circumnavigate the site up to that level.

[Unidentified]: And am I correct in that the CTE yard is also providing access to the gym?

[Matt Rice]: So staff and students could use that access, but in terms of the public coming for gym events, I don't think we want the general public coming back in through the CTER. We're going to be looking for them to come through the community entrance where we have the ability to really manage where and how much access they have to the rest of the schools. Just also add with the field question, it's interesting because we have a lot of different discussions about, is it better or more challenging to have the field separated on either side of the site? I think one of the nice things by having it down here is that you're taking half of your events and you're putting the parking immediately there right when you come into the site. So it actually greatly facilitates the access to half of sort of the field resource. Yes, the stadium is up top. And so all the things that were mentioned in terms of trying to make that a amenable pedestrian experience getting up there are absolutely still true, but you actually have a really great venue right in the site when you come in. And that's going to serve a lot of the functionality.

[Suzanne Galusi]: And I know it's been said, but just two other points that the breezeway is in between two and three and there will be like a cover, but it's open. So that's where people would access the pedestrian path. And then there are some accessible spots to the South of the stadium field, um, up here. Yes. Where the arrow is where there are some parking spots, there will be accessible spots there as well.

[Tracy Keene]: Have we determined how many spaces are in A?

[Member Jenny Graham]: We have determined how many spaces are on the site across all of the parking. And there are enough spaces for the number of cars we anticipate coming to the site.

[Suzanne Galusi]: Which is slightly more than we have now.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Correct. Okay, so back to our signs. The advisory team did make a recommendation that we are being asked to vote on, which is sign would include a masonry school identification sign with external illumination in lieu of an internally illuminated message board type sign. Is there a motion to approve? By Brian, is there a second? by Libby, can I just clarify one thing?

[Suzanne Galusi]: Sorry if I'm not aware, but based on this recommendation, do all four images, it doesn't look like all four of these images reflect what the recommendation is. So is that lower left? Yes.

[Kenneth Lord]: The two on the right. Something like that.

[Suzanne Galusi]: So it would not have like a message forward. It's just be strictly mason.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Okay. Yes.

[Suzanne Galusi]: Okay.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Let me call the roll. Uh, Jenny Graham. Yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Galuzzi.

[Unidentified]: No.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Meredith Cabral. Yes. Ken Lord. Yes. Jen Belanger. Libby Brown. Yes. Maria Dorsey. Brian Hilliard. Yes. Raising cane. Yes. Home alone. Nicole Morell. Yes. Liz lane. Yes. Aaron. I like two and then negative. Motion is approved. This is like a silly little I think the agenda is that the Interior and Exterior Advisory recommended this. But is the site safety and security? You are correct. I was like, oh, we're looking at this. So I have a letter that I didn't miss a thing. Sorry, site safety and security. Yes, but I'm going to tell you it's 8.02, and we have 30 more slides to go.

[John Falco]: Is there really a cost differential for these, the interior and exterior lighting?

[Matt Rice]: Yeah, yeah. The active LED message board, there's communications and there's power.

[Unidentified]: When it's broken and half the LEDs are working and it looks terrible. Don't give good reasons. I made Mike promise that he's going to go quickly here.

[SPEAKER_08]: I'm sorry. Hi, I'm Michael Reed, one of the designers, architects on the project. We did, we had a lot of discussion and a lot more slides about how we got to kind of the external design and the process, but I'll just give the highlights here is that the concept we're looking at is building is being an intersection between the bells. So we're looking at this project as being a bridge integration between those things as a, as a kind of organizing concept for the building itself.

So I think the Fells is an amazing resource right here next to the school. So we want to draw inspiration from that. So this is just an early kind of just a second sketch of what we're trying to do is that we're trying to bring in the Fells into the school itself. So kind of that biofilm design inspiration is a way to kind of organize the open spaces and those public spaces. Um, and then we feel this is really reinforces the educational approach of an integrated design. It's an integrated school. Um, we can create a lot of transparency and openness with this. Um, and also the idea of, excuse me, of promoting wellbeing, of having this kind of open airy space, uh, especially in these public main public spaces.

Okay. Um, so then we apply this design, you know, this concept to the building itself. So this is, this is just, you know, it's not meant to be the building literally, but it's beginning to overlay those concepts onto the building itself. So how do we, how do we enact that? We're looking at maybe these slow columns to be more evocative of trees, um, having the main entrance space being transparent and open, more like kind of an open glen. And then, uh, obviously we can't have everything be glass and open to other of the building having more opacity.

And so really looking at the site, we're trying to, you know, we're going to still develop more landscape around this, but bringing kind of the idea of these trees into the site, but also on top of where we're showing this aerial to show some of these rooftop garden spaces that we're going to be bringing that landscape nature into the building. So these are kind of sketchy images, but to be evocative of what we're looking at in terms of the architecture overall. So you can see the main entry space, it's glassy, it's inviting, having these floating canopies being reminiscent of the canopies of the trees, and then the columns being more playful to really draw people into that space. It's a tall building, You know, at this point, it's five stories. And then on top of that, what you're seeing also is the PV array. So we're looking at that as following the building form and almost being a canopy element in itself. So we want to craft that as part of the building and really control that and not have it look like an add-on that was just slapped on after the build was built.

We're looking also to bring in some warmer wood elements in some of the underside of these canopies. This is a view of the west side of the building. So kind of along with that teardrop drop off and the backside where we have the outdoor dining in the center. So this is that long ribbon. So we'll have, you know, the rhythm of the classroom building, classrooms with a bunch of openings, but we're also looking at different shading devices. along for those windows along the side that you'll see in other other slides later.

Just really creating a rhythm along this side of the building. This is moving to the north side. So this is up at the track and field looking from the northeast back towards what you see is the automotive CTE space. So those are the large group garage doors will open up into this space. And on top of that, this canopy is slightly higher. This is the area where we're talking about that could be an expansion area later for an additional square foot of the building. And so this structure that would hold up the PV would actually be the roof of whatever addition would be put up there later.

Again, back to the front entry, just a more close-up view of that, trying to do what we're trying to do with layering of these canopies, this glassy entrance, maybe looking at some kind of oculus through the canopy to bring in light into some of those spaces. Here in this view, you can see straight through the school. So this comes into the, this is the entry that you've seen through to the dining and then out to the other side to the outdoor dining.

This view is just trying to capture the whole school from the front, from the field. So you see the ECC, wing to the left-hand side, the main entry in the center, and then to the right-hand side are the gymnasium in the background and the auditorium. And the community entrance would actually be on the far right, which is obscured by the PV canopies at this point. But we wanted to be intentional to show the PV canopies that, you know, highly visited part of the school.

So that's a The initial concept kind of look of the school. We're still developing materiality, some of the other details of it, but generally this is the direction we're going in. I want to talk a little bit about exterior materials. This is a slide we've shown before just about cost of different materials, initial costs. And so we're looking more at masonry for the majority of the envelope of the school because it's a lower cost. It's a durable material.

And then using some of the other materials like form metal composite aluminum panel, phenolic, other things as accent materials. So this is an initial kind of material concept board. So we're showing the different materials we're looking at kind of so you can see them together. So the different masonries. So looking at ground face CMU, which With all that kind of bonding, so it's a more striated, so it doesn't look like just a solid wall, but it looks more evocative of the landscape.

Some also, the base having more granite-like and actually some stone accent pieces as well. Obviously, there's glass, a curtain wall, and windows. some wood look panels that could be either made out of aluminum or phenol panels, and then shading devices on the windows. So different types of aluminum surrounds on the windows and vertical elements to help shade the windows from glare, but also excessive heat gain. And we're working with our mechanical team on that. Any questions so far on this? What do we have?

[Unidentified]: Any questions? I have a question. Will any of the windows be able to be open?

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, so typically we have an operable window in every classroom. So that's just for the option of getting fresh air in there, even though the mechanical system brings in adequate fresh air for all the classrooms.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Libby? Well, the phone app is the one that you're doing the modeling, like it's one, they only open like four inches, right? So there's one, window open actually do much for a 950-square-foot classroom?

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, I mean, we'll study that. I mean, the windows we're looking at the operable are fairly large. So yeah, there will have some restriction for safety on them. It's a good consideration. We'll have to balance that with cost and other things.

[Unidentified]: I'd like to have them if we can, but if it's like a token and it's not really doing anything and it just creates complications for the mechanical system. Like have a few or have none. But if one doesn't do much, I don't see the point.

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, I think it's at least wrong. Every window unit itself would have an operable light. So if you have multiple ones in a classroom, they need to have more than one.

[Member Jenny Graham]: I think we have a question from a member of the public. Do you want to join us?

[SPEAKER_21]: Yes. Hi. Yeah. For Pink Street again. Yes to windows. When you open them, they do work. they open. So I have like four or five windows in Somerville. Oh yeah, it works. Number two is in Somerville some of the building tiles on the building have started falling off and we had to rope off parts of the building because they were unsafe and tiles were falling off. So as much as this is tiles are wonderful and they look great and they look really nice on Somerville, some of those red tiles even after five years have started falling off the building. So For whatever reason they're falling off, we have to be very careful when choosing about those things. And if they're really hard to install, or somebody can make a mistake, that could be a reason why we should be very careful. Thank you.

[Matt Rice]: I can't offer that those are terracotta panels. There are no terracotta panels that are currently part of this material board. These are all unit masonry. They're made up by a mason as we go up. Lisa?

[Unidentified]: From one of the earlier slides, is there a different exterior surface for the, it looks like for the arched wings and for the rest of the building, is that true?

[SPEAKER_08]: Some of the high portions of the auditorium, we're looking maybe at metal panel up there as opposed to the CMU or the masonry, that would be more at ground level. So part of that's to break up the, what we call the massing of the building, so it doesn't look so tall, but this sketch doesn't necessarily completely depict the materiality of that film at this point. But on the right-hand side of here, you can see that there will be masonry. This southern exposure will get a different treatment for the window shading, just because it's southern exposure. But we're looking at a consistent material palette for our film.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Any other questions before we move on? Okay.

[SPEAKER_08]: All right. So just again, we've talked about the Hardy schools and other concepts, and this is the work of the programmatic elements of the school overlap. So you have the health and wellness, the learning communities, the arts and music, and the administration and other offices. So again, we're trying to activate that space to be open. So these are just some interior images that we are working to develop to show kind of how open that space will be. If we let from either side, they'll be able to see clear through, you know, we're looking at more kind of a field of columns in this space to have that kind of a body of the fells and really open kind of linkage to the main corridor that runs north-south through the whole school. So this is a view looking at the kind of eating dining commons area and a learnings area right that goes down to the main entry.

Another aspect is this main what we're calling the waterfall stair. So this is an element right off the end of the gym adjacent to the entry and dining commons that is an organizing element vertically because it is a tall building. So we want a large open stair that you can always orient yourself where you are in the building and to move up and down. And it'll be double-sided for ease of communication. And this is just another view of that stair. This is early in development. This stair is definitely going to evolve in terms of how it looks, but we just want to give a sense of what it is spatially.

Now I'm going to shift to interior. This is not inside my wheelhouse. I work mostly with interior designers. We just wanted to touch on the typical materials we use in schools. And this is all geared towards getting it into the cost estimate, right? So we're going to have many more discussions and presentations on the interior of the school, but initially just want to show the different types of materials we use in the school. So flooring, generally we look at resilient flooring in the corners, like linoleum in the classrooms as well.

Epoxy terrazzo is something to use in main public spaces that go a lot of where. So you can think of that in the dining commons and entry spaces. Obviously, the gymnasium would get either wood athletic flooring or rubber athletic flooring, depending on which way we go. And then various tiles in kitchen, bathroom areas like that. You can see the little symbols. I won't go into too much depth, but we are identifying as many materials that are red list free as possible. There are some that simply the industry is not caught up with having three different manufacturers that offer that material, but we're actively scouring different manufacturers for that.

[Matt Rice]: Let me just add in as well that with the advisory team, we did go through this entire sort of catalog of materials and we basically solicited feedback from district perspective as well as the advisory team members that have expertise here. So as just one example of that, right, we did talk about flooring materials in toilet rooms and there was a strong preference against doing any sort of tile because the grout lines and the maintenance and the cleaning and just having that resinous epoxy material that you see in the bottom right hand corner. So this, what's going to be priced out as part of the estimate is a combination of what we do typically specifying, because we can bring a lot in terms of experiences of things that have worked and that have not worked. But we're also integrating in that Medford specific impact as part of the process.

[SPEAKER_08]: All the materials we would look to put in the school, we look for durability as one of the main criteria. So the different wall tiles, even if we have wood accents, we treat those in a way that we're looking for durability. So these are just some of the spaces, typical spaces with other projects we've done. So you can see we put in a porcelain wall tile and main quarter spaces, and that's for durability. And then also in terms of the flooring, we looked at linoleum as a very, relatively maintenance-free and very durable product that also can be repaired fairly easily. Another alternative is rubber flooring. That's another type or use that has those qualities as well, pluses, minuses, and there's also a price differential in those sometimes. So we're gonna be looking at maybe some alternate pricing as well. In the typical classrooms, it's what you'd expect, you know, the linoleum flooring, paint, gypsum board walls. We have definitely window treatments and then acoustical lay-in ceilings with a room base. So it's fairly typical as you'd see in most contemporary classrooms. Specialized spaces obviously get more specialized finishes, some wood accents, you know, display cases, and then different acoustical treatment on the ceiling. So either baffles or, you know, metal acoustic ceiling treatment that will evolve with the design. But these are really to help dampen down these spaces so they can perform well as learning spaces as well.

In bathrooms, high-use spaces, again, following on what Matt said, we're looking at epoxy as a recommendation for the flooring and bathrooms as opposed to tile just because of maintenance. That's basically it. So any questions on interior?

[Unidentified]: Questions?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Okay. Moving on. Our last item, if you all remember back in the spring, we talked about and approved a budget to send out an informational mailer to let the community know about the project at the time. And about the same time that we were preparing that draft, the deed restriction became a conversation that we had to have, the shifting of the building, And so in all of that timeline, there was enough uncertainty that it felt like the wrong thing to do to publish dates on a mailer that were like changing every single day as we were unfolding the impacts of that restriction. So we did not send the mailer at that time. The budget is still approved, but what we did do was revisit that idea now as we look forward over the course of the next several months. And we have a draft, so we wanted to share it with you for input and feedback. The other thing I can share with you is across three estimates to send mail to every, I think it's every door, EDDM, I think it's like every door, something, something, it's a code, it's like gets dropped with all mail, would range between $9,600 and $14,000, depending on the printer. There's three, re-estimates that range from folks that the city has used in the past to the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Pritchard. So that is the sort of budget range. And the concept for this mailer, as you can see, is to, on the front side, describe a little bit about what's in the project and a picture that demonstrates what the 2B project would look like. and a QR code that allows people to say, I want more information and we'll point them to our new website.

So that's the front side. And then on the backside, what it describes is ways to get involved in terms of upcoming meetings really that take us through June of next year and the debt exclusion, which is scheduled for June 8th of 2027. And again, lots of, pointing to the project website as the source of information on the project and all the resources folks might want to know about. So I think, you know, to the conversation that we had a couple of months back, there are lots of people in our community who are not tuning in tonight who may only know something about the project. They may know nothing about the project. And we want to make sure people have an opportunity to know how to engage. So that's the sort of genesis of this mailer. And we would love any feedback that you have. We're not meeting that January 1st. No, I just noticed that.

[John Falco]: Is the website address on the front or just a QR code?

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yeah.

[Unidentified]: The QR code is on the front.

[SPEAKER_08]: We can put the website address on the back. Yes. Yep.

[Tracy Keene]: when does this mailer supposed to drop?

[Member Jenny Graham]: I think the idea would be we would get it to friends and it would be in mailboxes between Thanksgiving and the holidays. So that as we head into January, when lots of information will be out and available, that will all be good information for people to have. It's probably not feasible to get it out into mailboxes by November 30th, which is the first joint school committee city council meeting that is coming up on the subject. So we can confirm that if we can get it out before that, we would certainly want to do that. Otherwise we'll amend so that it's just the two dates.

[Tracy Keene]: Would there be another, would there be another mailer after the cost in January is determined?

[Member Jenny Graham]: From the building, like from the, so the city's resources can be used to provide information. That money cannot be used to support how you should feel about the project, which is why the time is right right now to say, here is the project and here is how you can participate. I would anticipate that there will be other mail areas points in time in the lead up to the debt exclusion, but that is a completely different topic and it's like outside the scope of this. So as of right now, this one mail would be the plan from City.

[Suzanne Galusi]: Let me, I'm just following up on that because it says voting and project funding details to be announced in February, like that probably something on the website would be announced or not anticipating sending more information.

[Member Jenny Graham]: I'm sorry, what's the question? Well, it says under debt exclusion vote, it says voting and project funding details to be announced in February. So I'm curious, does that mean like that'll show up on the website or? Yeah, and it will be at the joint meeting of the school committee and the city council on February 2nd. Got it. So yeah, more about that in the meeting. We can clarify that language. Brian?

[Unidentified]: I just wonder if you could go back to the front. Sure. To the front there. And remind me, I guess, what size this is.

[Member Jenny Graham]: It's like roughly like a half page. It's like six by eight by 11, six by 11. It's like a rectangle. Yeah, it's a decent size. It can't be too small, or it's not eligible for this nail. And somebody's flat. Yeah, it's a flat, like, something. I presume it's because it's easy to shove in every nail that's going out.

[Unidentified]: So I think my only comment would be, just because I think pictures are worth a thousand words, that you literally could put an Edward High School building project across the top in the white space. Zoom in as much as we possibly could on that. There would be no white space. It's all white. Never mind. Don't put it up there.

[Member Jenny Graham]: But your point is well taken. Make the picture as big as possible.

[Unidentified]: You've got to squeeze every word. Nicole, this is just like pedantic food for thought.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Everything is in title case, and it becomes a little bit like everything's important, so nothing's important. I mean, just like on the backside, there's like two calls to action that are totally entitled case. And I don't have like a little loss to speak with the project team and visit project again. I'm not going to like, we can clean that up and you don't need the, um, just don't get a comment after February.

[Unidentified]: And that's every 2027 under the debt exclusion. I'm sure there was like a full date later for like a move and I'm on the ends or something.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Oh, yeah. Great. What else? So I think the question for this group that we wanted folks to weigh in on is whether this still feels like an important use of project funding to get the word out about what's about to what is coming down the line. Yes or no. And obviously we can make the changes that you all have suggested if the answer is yes. And if not, we can stop talking. But I think, you know, from my perspective, like for me, I do support sending this mailer out. I think it's important that people know that the budget is coming and that there's a lot that's going to happen in the next six months and people are welcome and invited to participate and have come and have their questions answered and all of those good things.

It's a really, really big project for the city.

[Member Aaron Olapade]: Aaron? How are we identifying the homes or houses that it'll be sent to? It's every house. OK.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yeah, the post office handles that. Sure. Brian?

[Unidentified]: Just wondering if, and seeing at risk, I know they do this all the time. Do they get to weigh in on this process? Do they say, you know, it should be big or it should be small, or it should not do it? I mean, they seem to have a lot of community do they have to wait?

[Member Jenny Graham]: So this is project funding. So there is budget in the feasibility study budget to be able to do this. We can definitely pass it by the CMs for their input and feedback, for sure. Absolutely welcome. And I think generally, they want to get the word out as much as we do. Yeah, so that people can be excited about the project.

[Unidentified]: or because they do it more than we do. They may say this has worked in the past, but that hasn't worked.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Yeah, we can solicit some feedback from them before it goes out the door. Liz?

[CC Councilor Liz Mullane]: I just want to say, I think this is a great idea to get started as soon as possible, because I think as we're learning, people are taking information from a variety of different ways and being able to get in front of every single household as best we can. with different opportunities for people to attend, I think is great. When people go onto the website and they see all of these different informational places, we'll have all of it rolling with dates, times, opportunities, just so people know that exactly when it is, where it's going to be. They can get up and speed wherever that is. Because I just think as much as possible to get this out, I think this is great for people to have more opportunity to learn and engage about the projects.

[Member Aaron Olapade]: I think to the end and something with emotion choice is that I think that we've heard from a lot of people in the community I think just individually and I know I definitely have about wanting to be as well versed as possible and just conversation and I find that on the I don't think we've seen the new website but it's incredible like I think what's been done so far it's continued to evolve and I think it's a lot more like manageable now so I think that just information is obviously the project we've been working on for years and so a lot of people that are going to be coming into this project going forward I think it's a really good way to kind of meet as many people as possible because there are people online and people don't use QR codes. So trying to negotiate how we're informing the public is obviously paramount at this point. So I'm happy to motion that we approve this design with the additional suggestions that the committee put forth. I second that.

[Member Jenny Graham]: All right. Motion to approve as amended by Aaron and seconded by Liz. Are there other questions, comments, thoughts? Okay, we'll call the roll. Jenny Graham, yes. Mayor Lungo-Koehn.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Calusi. Yes. Marnie Cabral. Yes. Ken Lord.

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Jen Belanger. Libby Brown. Yes. Maria Dorsey. Brian Hilliard. Yes. Stacey Keene. Yes. Paul Malone. Paul Morell. Yes. Liz Mullane. Yes. Aaron Lopate. Yes. Luke Prisner. 11 in the affirmative, zero in the negative, four absent. We will keep you posted as we finalize and get timing about when you should start to see those in your inbox. And that is the end of our agenda. Thank you for moving so quickly through the last 30 slides. I feel bad because of the short change of the most exciting slides, at least according to me. But thank you.

As a reminder, there is a community forum on Thursday night. We'll actually spend a bit more time with some of those pictures on Thursday night and a lot less time talking about some of the work of the advisory team.

[SPEAKER_20]: So please do join us for that.

[SPEAKER_21]: Will?

[SPEAKER_20]: And there's also a presentation at the Medford Senior Center on Monday, November 30th from 1 to 2.30 with some Medford high school students as well. That's open to everybody. not just the members of the Senate. Right.

[Member Jenny Graham]: And then, you know, just for you all to know, the other thing that we are starting to see an uptick in is different groups around the community wanting updates, presentations. We're happy to do that. We've actively reached out to all the PTOs, to all the folks who serve on boards and commissions. We met with the Chamber of Commerce today. We're meeting with the Roberts PTO on Wednesday. If you hear of a group that is interested in learning more about the project, from whatever their vantage point is, there is a link on the website where they can request a meeting. And so we're happy to figure out how to deploy the project team to those kinds of events. And then we also have lots of table events at various upcoming city events, school events, et cetera. And those would, the support and the conversation at those tables over the last couple of months has been tremendous and just reaching lots and lots of people who may not be the people who have the time to come to our meetings or the ability to watch online or what have you. So giving people lots of opportunities to interact with knowledgeable folks who know where the project is at and how to sort of field, what is just that almost endless set of questions that people could ask about the project has been really exciting and useful so far. So we'll keep doing that. And if there's an event that you know of that is not listed on our website, let us know and we'll reach out and figure out how we can be there.

And with that, is there a motion to adjourn? So moved. Second. by Dr. Lucy. I'll call the roll. Jenny Graham. Yes. Mayor logo card.

[Mayor Breanna Lungo-Koehn]: Yes.

[Member Jenny Graham]: Dr. Lucy. Yes. Mardika Brown. Ken Lord. Yes. Jennifer Lander. Libby Brown. Yes.

Jenny Graham

total time: 40.81 minutes
total words: 5561
Breanna Lungo-Koehn

total time: 0.05 minutes
total words: 9
Aaron Olapade

total time: 2.2 minutes
total words: 480
John Falco

total time: 4.8 minutes
total words: 695
Liz Mullane

total time: 0.67 minutes
total words: 139


Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: MPS High School Building Committee