The Medford Community Preservation Committee heard presentation proposals for FY27 CPA funding from the Mystic River Watershed Association and the Medford Affordable Housing Trust. The committee also approved an emergency roof repair grant for the Unitarian Universalist Church and reallocated $50,000 in funding for Condon Shell field lighting improvements.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: There we go. All right, I'm going to call to order the meeting of Medford's Community Preservation Committee on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, 6.30 p.m. We are meeting hybridly with some of us being located in room 201 of City Hall and some of us joining online. First, I will call the roll. Um, and starting with the folks in the room, I've got. Um, page. Yes. I'm sorry. I'm where I'm I'm very, very casual and in this route, right? Yeah. Um, Doug present.
Uh, Joe.
[Losa Julie Genevieve]: here.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Losa. Here. And am I missing anyone else online? No. Okay. And myself here. I'm in prison. All right. First item on the agenda is, um, continuing presentations on the projects that have applied for CPA funding in FY 27 The first applicant that we have on the agenda is the Mystic River Watershed Association. And I see Carl Alexander is here to talk with us. So welcome, Carl. Please tell us about your project.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Good evening. Can you hear me OK?
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Okay, great. And it sounds like I have 20 minutes total to present in Q&A, or roughly, if that works okay?
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Yes. And I'll put up a timer just if that's helpful, Carl. No pressure.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: It looks like I have a nifty timer on my Google Slides presentation as well. So I might be in the clear. Is it okay if I share my screen right now?
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Yes, I do believe I made you click. Perfect.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Does that work okay?
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Yes, perfect.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Well, thanks so much everyone for having us here this evening to present. My name is Carl Alexander. I serve as the senior manager for Greenways at the Mystic River Watershed Association. Our mission is to protect and restore the Mystic River and its tributaries. And I have the great pleasure of managing our Greenways program, which envisions 25 miles of connected paths and parks from the Mystic Lakes all the way down to Boston Harbor. And today I'll be presenting on our proposal to commence design development for the shoreline revitalization project along the Mystic River in West Medford.
I think a lot of people in the room, probably everyone, knows that West Medford is a really special neighborhood with a lot of awesome, unique character. It's a very tight-knit place. I've never lived in West Medford myself. I grew up in North Cambridge, work obviously in the area, live in Somerville now, but what I know of it as though it's a really tight-knit place where you can really get to know your neighbors. Just the urban form is really beautiful. It is also defined by a deeply rooted presence in the African-American community and the city as well.
Um, along the shoreline, um, also been kind of have, uh, really strong presence of Frederick homesteads, landscape architecture and design, which is still very present to this day. You have open lawn and tree groves and water based recreation and wildlife and active recreation playground at Duggar park, walking just connection overall to nature and water is, is really evident here. Present conditions, though, as you might be aware, include instances of limited access in a universal, universally speaking, shoreline erosion, invasive species, threats to pedestrian safety, roadways, lack of stormwater management. These all provide challenges for the environment and visitors. And we've heard from community members, DCR, City of Medford, that a comprehensive effort is needed to address persistent issues.
The City's Open Space and Recreation Plan supports improved connections to the City's natural resources, and the Mystic River in particular. So Goal 2 in the OSRP explicitly lists both MIRA and DCR as responsible parties working with the City to improve paths, water access, and advance DCR's Mystic River Master Plan. Our project goal is to seek a balance between really recreation and conservation that improves key ecological functions of the shoreline while supporting universal access for residents and visitors of all ages, abilities, and backgrounds. In a densely populated community like Medford, this area can and should feel comfortable for use by everyone and as if it was their own backyard. It's a place to restore, find wellness, and is really a healthy and vibrant shoreline. or it should be, and that ultimately as an outcome is good for both people and nature alike.
Uh, why now? I think just to provide a little bit of content, we're really kind of here meeting the moment of a lot of focused attention that is growing for revitalization in the area. So Mystic Valley Parkway on the Arlington side, and also the Route 60 Rotaries as a collective project are receiving investment on all levels of government now with a lot of community support and that kick started due to community planning efforts launched by Myra back in 2020. Similarly, we've completed planning work up along the eastern shoreline of the Mystic Lakes and Mystic Valley Parkway, and we're currently advocating for formal project adoption by DCR. It's a very intensive roadway project, really, that would implement a new path there. So we're waiting for project adoption by the agency itself. Um, and then then there's the West Medford shoreline and the context is slightly different only in the sense that use is typically more localized, right? You have regional bike connectivity that's been planned along the lakes on the Eastern shoreline. And then once you get to high street, the regional bikeway alignment shifts to the Arlington side. Of the river on the Western shoreline, um, so, uh, you know, the use, uh, you know, here and what we're looking at in the project area is definitely more localized and a little bit more passive, a little bit more slower use, maybe with the exception of park.
In 2025, we completed conceptual planning work for. the West Medford Shoreline, over 200 interactions with community members happened through in-person and online methods, and we got over a thousand comments. So if you did participate in that process, thank you very much. And generally folks overall supported the project vision and also identified that it was a way to help motivate stewardship and additional stewardship and programming efforts by community members and community groups, and also to promote better management practices by landowner, right? You revitalize it and you want to take care of it rather than just to kind of leave it in its current state. And just to give you one good example of that, right, is the Clippership Connector Project just outside of Medford Square. After DCR completed their capital investments a few years ago, stewardship has really taken form. This year, there's been a lot of invasive species removal. I was out over the weekend helping with native plant establishment and doing micro forest plantings. And DCR as well has really been kind of attentive and taking more care of these newer assets and been collaborative with partners.
Um, part of that conceptual planning process was convening of a 12 member steering committee. Shout out to Reg, who might do that. Sorry, Reg, this isn't the most active photo of you. I'm sorry. You were paying attention, I swear. We're very engaged. But we made a call for residents. We had over 70 applications, which allowed us to really get a nice cross-section of community members from a lot of different demographic backgrounds and also experience engaging in projects like this and from all different angles. So we had teenagers and senior citizens and folks who had never engaged on a project like this before and folks who do this professionally. So it was a really nice a good group of folks, and it helps to provide a really concentrated dialogue around project concepts, weighing project trade-offs, and also to help guide our community engagement process. There's a full summary of community engagement included in the plan report that I believe I included in our application, but it's also linked here in tonight's presentation.
Um, I wanted to show this photo just to really show you the project limits of what we're proposing. So, on the northern end, it's bounded by ravine road. and then goes along the Mystic River shoreline, a little bit of lower Mystic Lake too, Mystic shoreline, going southbound all the way along the shoreline, passing the confluence with the LA Brook, and then ending at Boston Ave. So it's a pretty large geographic and linear area. And you can think about it as the shoreline area owned by DCR between the river and the roadway that's immediately adjacent for all intents and purposes.
Included in that conceptual plan is approximately 1.5 miles of unpaved trail. 1.1 miles of that is accessible unpaved path. Think about a stone dust. So there is some engineering components to it to ensure that it stays level, uniform, well-graded, well-drained for universal access. And then about 0.4 miles of natural surface trail. The rationale for natural surface and where we placed that was really areas that had a lot of ecological sensitivity, like wetlands, or had a really steep grade to it and wasn't going to meet ADA compliance. And then we also include in the plan a robust ecological restoration, including shoreline stabilization, bioretention, rain gardens at two key erosion areas. I'll picture in a few slides. Some protection and enhancement of the tree canopy as well is really critical and component of this work. And then also recreational opportunities, though, along this linear path that we're proposing is scenic viewpoints. That's not really. Not in the sense that it's, like, constructed overlooks, but it's more just these kind of moments or viewing points along the route with, you know, co-located with maybe interpretive signage and seating for accessibility purposes and interpretive purposes. Three water access points, and then two small nature play areas where we've observed kind of families and folks interacting with kiddos. Um, there's also a really good opportunity across the project area to think about interpretive sign packaging, just to celebrate the areas, natural and cultural histories. I do have the full concept. Here's just like a really small snapshot of the conceptual plan. I do have the full conceptual plan and the different project areas that we can flip through during Q and a, if anyone's interested in a particular geographic area.
I just want to share a few perspective renderings to demonstrate the proposed improvements. Here you have an image of some, you know, people vote with their feet, right? It's a very democratic process, but there's definitely a lack of footpath delineation. What that can do is promote erosion and endangers tree health and endangers, you know, shoreline species health as well, and can, you know, degrade the landscape over time. What is proposed here is a delineated path, which allows for feet to stay where they should be going. It allows for a healthy tree canopy. You're not stepping on exposed roots and causing undue stress. And it also gives an opportunity for further ecological restoration along the shoreline. We really want to keep this existing vegetation healthy and restore conditions wherever possible.
During our engagement with the steering committee, and also with community members, what often came up in a very robust discussion was around the tradeoff of different path types. Um, and, uh, we, we did have some really thoughtful conversations around this engaged on this discussion. And, uh, as I mentioned, our plan does recommend for the primary alignment, um, and unpaved accessible paths, stone dust, not asphalt for this, for this, um, uh, project. And then, uh, no, really no more than really 6 feet in width. Um, we still need to evaluate what the, the most appropriate width is for this area, but our aim is not to have it be any more than 6 feet. Um, and then, um, uh, yeah, so really appreciative for, like, all of that robust dialogue and it's definitely paid off. So that will continue to come up during, during design development.
An example here too is also kind of making that decision about where to do natural surface paths. And so here you have the natural alignment. It's not 88 grade, but it's going right up to the high street bridge. And then here you have a natural surface put path kind of formalizing that beeline, protecting the shoreline. And then you do have a accessible path going to the planned intersection improvements that are going to be happening at the high street rotaries.
You might be familiar with this particular area on Mystic River Road. This is an example of a spot with short erosion control issues that we want to solve for while also optimizing public access. It's a really good place to put in if you're doing a kayak. And then what we're proposing here though is to harden a small area for non-motorized boat access. A very small number of dedicate handicapped or loading unloading parking spaces to accommodate recreational boating use. And then you have the buyer retention area as well to help with stormwater management. This is another trade off that was very much discussed is the use of jet skis. And then the increased use of jet skis along the water. A lot of them do come up from lower on the river, but some folks have become accustomed to putting in north of High Street. And that is a concern for immediate abutters is increased jet ski put-ins with new water access points. You know, there are folks who with Herculean strength, you know, and I don't want to diminish kind of concerns around that at all. Um, it's going to be a continued area of discussion for the project, but the intent is to design these put ins in a manner that it's not comfortable to put in a large motorized water craft. And it's really explicitly for non motorized use.
Um, We are at the tail end of a year of project development. Um, so we've met several times since we completed the plan, we've spent the past year doing project development. So we've met several times with the city staff presented to you all back in March, I believe, and other stakeholders like West Medford community center. And we used some additional online surveying with folks to help identify a preferred strategy for a very feasible project phasing. It's a large effort that we're looking at here. And so also wanted to noted that we do have a tentative approval from to proceed with this project. I wanted to make sure that we had that heading into tonight's meeting. No immediate concerns from them in regards to proceeding, but just considerations across their departments. We'll be having the formal approval form forthcoming in the next few weeks prior to the next CPC meeting in December.
What I do want to note is that this project is entirely within the floodplain, so it does really enhance scope needs related to regulatory review and permitting. After what we're proposing for funding during this cycle, which is the pre-permitting design scope, our plan is to get through permitting level designs, the permitting process as a collective, looking at the entire project area that I showed. And then after that 75% milestone, then phasing out the project through construction level documentation, bidding, and construction in a phased approach. If we can fund everything entirely in one construction phase, great. But the more likelihood is that it will need to be a phased construction due to the size of the geography and the scope of the project.
I'm taking a lot of time here, but what we're requesting for this cycle is for achievement of the 25 and 50% pre-permitting design milestones. We need to do some additional surveying, definitely extensive stakeholder engagement, two rounds of public engagement as well to match the 25 and 50%. milestone markers as well, and also a pre-filing consultation with the state's NEPA office as well. We as an organization are going to be able to provide match to cover staff time to deliver on this scope of work. We are also beginning to explore opportunities for funding that next upcoming round of 75% design as well through fiscal year 28 public sources.
And what we've really learned, though, is from other CPA funded open space projects we've completed in recent years in Boston and in Somerville, is that local investment kind of showing the interest and excitement for a project like this, as well as a matched private investment from our organization and private foundations as well, is a really great sign to and provides a huge boost of confidence for potential state and federal partners in helping to complete funding for project budgets.
With that, I'd like to thank you very much for the opportunity to present and happy to field any questions or discussion.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: All right, thank you very much. Questions from committee members.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Back to the map, Carl, of where this project is planned.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I'm sorry, could you repeat your question, Jim?
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Can you go back to the map? Okay.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Is this one helpful, Joan?
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Sure. So tell me, is this all Medford?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: This is all Medford.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: So the trail goes north into Arlington, right? Has that already been done?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: So there is a separate scope of work being there's two separate scopes of work being managed respectively by the town of Arlington and DCR that are handling the that are handling this green segment and what we are looking at for tonight's conversation is this segment entirely in Medford and then Winchester And then this area that goes all the way up to Winchester is separate. We're in discussions with DCR to try and get this section adopted by DCR for them to develop it.
It kind of veers into their parkways division and is typically outside of the norm of what a nonprofit would manage through design development.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Roberta, am I misremembering? Did we see a project similar to this in like the first year or the second year of CPA here in Medford?
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes, a project that would have done the Medford portion of the Mystic Lakes path improvements. And that was, I think, our first year. And that was the first and only project that was ever recommended by the CPC and rejected by City Council. And City Council's reasoning at the time was that they did not see buy-in from DCR to implement the project and they did not want to see Medford pay for planning that would potentially never be implemented. So that leads to a question. is what kind of expectation do we have that that funding package that you showed us in the very last slide is likely to come together to make sure that this project can eventually be implemented?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: So, um, always always the most important question, right? And I'm just going to flip through there. Um, so the intent on this proposed scope of work for West Medford is that the Mystic River Watershed Association would be the responsible party to manage the project through design development, permitting and eventually construction. This is a multi-year commitment being proposed by a 501c3 nonprofit with permission from the Department of Conservation and Recreation. That initial approval for design and permitting, as I mentioned, we've received tentative approval for that and we'll be receiving the signed permission within the next few weeks.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Just a follow-up question. The other piece that I think was brought up before is that, We might pay to get the work done and then who's going to maintain it after and I saw in your application that the intent is for DCR to be responsible to maintain. How strong is that intention?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Um, if we, you know, if we do, we've scheduled a site visit today, actually, for December 3rd with DCR, the head of the Mystic River Complex. So, for December 3rd to talk about their considerations, but that same exact language we submitted in our Formal proposal to DCR at the end of August. Um, and so, um, you know, if this is a project that they are, you know, they are giving permission on to to build and construct, they would be the ones managing, uh, these new assets being designed and constructed. Um, you know, my remains a robust, like, stewardship component in the mystic river, but that's mostly related to, like, invasive species management, um, you know, and to trash cleanup, right? Or we're, uh, you know, we're nonprofit, our expectation is that the landowners would be responsible.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: And so tonight is just about getting to 50% design and then next year get to 75% design. And then at some point, you know, construction drawings fitting in the construction.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. It's, you know, the. We were initially looking at getting through 75% design and permitting, but when our estimates came back in, mostly due to the scope of permitting for this project, we wanted to be able to put forward a manageable scope of work that could be done within the desired timeframe and also within a budget we felt would be appropriate.
[Ada Gunning]: Thanks. One of the maps includes like the lower section of the Mystic Lake and then the other map starts lower. What is the actual proposed area? Are you including that like lower right section of the lower Mystic Lake or no?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: This right here?
[Ada Gunning]: Yeah.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: So yes, this is included.
[Ada Gunning]: Okay, because on your other map, the It looks like that section is included in the other one above.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. Apologies.
[Ada Gunning]: Okay.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: This is the, this is the explicit project.
[Ada Gunning]: I mean, I think that's a great project. I do my walk. I'm a therapist. I do walking therapy on that path all the time. So I'm always there and it definitely needs your help. So I love this. Um, I'm concerned about DCR, like their buy-in to this. That's my only consideration. Yeah.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I would actually love to ask a follow-up question about a couple of questions. Number one about DCR. In other projects that you've done, to what extent have you managed construction on DCR property? Is it a relationship that you have with DCR in other projects in other communities?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: That's a really great question. Um, so, for construction management on property, it, I'm very well aware of the process, right? It's a construction access permit required. Um, and, uh, as, you know, Roberta, like, we manage the design process for blessing of the bay in Somerville, which was CPA funded, but then transitioned it to the city of Somerville for management. Um, we have. Uh, experience with construction management for a CPA funded project in the little mystic area, little mystic channel area of Charlestown. Um, it was an open space for that.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Who is the property owner for the Little Mystic?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Boston Public Schools. So it was a public agency. This would be our first, to my knowledge, I can follow up too with the MIRA staff if we've done any previously, but in my tenure, we haven't managed a construction project on TCR property in the past.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I feel as though it would be very helpful before we vote on a funding recommendation for you to have a communication from DCR that not only consents to your design, but that consents to kind of mapping out how the construction is going to proceed through the end of the project. So what I hope to avoid is a situation where we get to the construction phase and then realize, DCR realizes that they would actually prefer to handle the construction management and restructure the project at that late stage. So I'd really like to see the project structure agreement with DCR before the plan is funded.
I, you said that you were going to be meeting with them December 3rd. Yeah. So maybe that's something to, to work through in your, in your meeting with them. Reg.
[Reggie Graham]: I've had some dealings with DCR in the past would be revitalization of the park in that situation down there. And, um, it's my experience. that DCR has tremendous turnover, tremendous turnover from year to year, sometimes from six months to six months. So I don't think that you're wrong by asking for the consideration from DCR, but that will probably put a longer tail on this.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: What I anticipate is that it could be a contractual issue. And so, you know, I mean, let alone who is actually managing the project in the future. I want to make sure that the contractual path is clear for how they're going to get from this point to that point. So. Carl knows what I mean. Yeah.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. And I think, um, you know, it was clear, there's very clear guidelines, like laid out for construction access permit. Yeah.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: So I've seen public projects managed by a nonprofit organization, but the public entity that owns that. Um, that land needs to agree to it, I think, before you enter the project, so that it's there's just. Clear what everyone's respective roles is going to be before we really get very far. Doug.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, just a quick comment. I feel, I don't disagree with what anyone said about being cautious about the construction and the management side, but this is, we are at least two maybe plus years away from getting anywhere near construction, probably more. And the design to me, we're in the design stage, you know, early design. So, I guess, I think I agree with everything what you said, but I feel like. That can be worked out anything, the ownership, the maintenance, the actual construction. That's years down the road. I feel like. You know, that could change as Fred kind of alluded to that could be several iterations here. I think the design is more important to get going because. It's a couple of years of, I mean, it might, if I had to guess, the construction period here could be at least three to five years, if not more. We're going to be 10 years down the road before we know it at this point. So I think we're just early days, is all I'm saying.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yeah, agreed. Thank you. I had a couple of other questions if you can allow it.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: There's also a question from a member of the public.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Thank you.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I'm going to skip some of the questions that really don't pertain exactly to this project. I guess the one other question that I'm going to throw out there for you right now is, You mentioned, you showed the slide with the funding that you anticipate in the future, 5.5 million perhaps, or up to 6.5 million. What proportion of that do you anticipate you'll be able to raise from state, federal, and private sources?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: What we've typically I'm thinking to a recently approved construction contract for. An extension of the Boston Harbor walk that we fundraise for in, um. uh, in, in Charlestown, also in the little mystic channel is one of our, it's one of our like flagship areas where we're working on a lot of redevelopment. Um, that was around, uh, like a one third, one third, one for third split between private, local and state. There's no federal funds in that one. Um, the CPA funded project on the little mystic channel, I know that it was more of a 50 50 split that was around a million dollar project. Um, um, so we didn't seek any state sources for that. And then Blessing of the Bay Park you're familiar with was closer to a, I would say like a 40-40-80 split, or 40-40-20 split with 20 being the private. And then, you know, you have the state and local matches for around 50%. So it's somewhere between a third and a half. I think what we've made the most appropriate to be happy to follow up with, like, some specific precedents and numbers on recent projects we've worked on.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I would just keep in mind, and you're mapping out what the funding could look like that Medford has a smaller bank of CPA funds to draw from some of our neighboring communities. So, um. I, you know, thinking ahead about that might be helpful in the, in the project planning. Maybe the, you're facing strategy in the long run might be impacted by that.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, no, definitely definitely want to take that into consideration. Yeah.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Are there other questions from committee members? I did see one question from a member of the public that was in the chat.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Do you want to share that, Teresa? Yeah. This question comes from Ryan Hayward, who is a co-chair of the Medford Historical Commission. He asked, with this project, will DCR do archaeological testing in advance of the project? They have tested in the past along Mystic Lakes for another project, and it was sensitive. Apparently, there are potential remains of an 18th and 19th century of the Weir Dam near High Street. So, would that be in your scope, Carl?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yes, great question. So we've completed some. I forgot the due diligence. Archeological surveying for this project area. Part of the 75 percent design scope, so not what we're talking about or requesting here tonight, but the following one, includes an intensive archeological survey process that would be in coordination with DCR's Cultural Services Division, filing with the Mass Historical Commission, etc. That would be following this initially proposed scope of work.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: On behalf of the resident, thank you. And I just have to ask one more historic question about the bridges along this stretch. Is there going to be any attention given to the restoration needs, perhaps a condition assessment identifying what would be an appropriate treatment for DCR to apply to the bridges in this area?
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, not not in the scope of work. Roberta. Sorry. And Teresa and I had a conversation with with regarding this topic a month or so ago. Um, and it was really, um. Uh, it was with their complete streets division, and they said, you know, if if a, if a local, if the municipal proponent was interested in advancing. Um, you know, potential, uh, quarter redesign, or, you know, resurfacing could be considered as potentially as a part of a quarter redesign. there's obviously like engineering and load considerations. Um, that if, if the superstructure is deemed intact by DOT, um, who typically own the bridges, um, um, then they're not going to completely change the superstructure, but could kind of consider kind of historical preservation or, um, surface treatments as part of a locally, um, you know, project that's been brought forward by a local proponent. So, um, worth debriefing, but it's not a part of the scope of work, unfortunately.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you. All right any any further questions. Thank you very much for coming and talking with us. Thank you.
[CAS00002481_SPEAKER_01]: Thank you. Have a good night everyone.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: You too. Bye.
[Ada Gunning]: Can you remind us what the time thing is? Is 20 minutes inclusive of questions? It is.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Are we aiming for that or is that? We are aiming for that so we did go over on that one. Apologies. There's a good, deep, deep presentation there. It's a great presentation.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: All right, so next on the agenda, Medford Affordable Housing Trust FY27 annual tranche funding. And I see Lisa Davidson and Catherine Buckingham are here to share with us. So welcome and tell us what the Housing Trust is applying for.
[Housing Planner Katherine Buckingham]: Um, thank you. Yeah. So I will talk, although I just want to acknowledge our chair, Lisa Davidson for being here as well. And, um, I think I might be able to help make up for the time. Um, since you all are pretty familiar with our work and we've presented several times before. Let me just pull up my slides. Tell me as soon as you can see them. They're beautiful. Thank you, I need to get it into slide show mode. Okay, does that look good?
[Losa Julie Genevieve]: Perfect, yes.
[Housing Planner Katherine Buckingham]: Okay, so this is just a list of our trustees. The mayor serves on the board along with our chair and five others. This is an overview of the timeline of our accomplishments in the first year and a half or so since the trust has existed. So in 2023, our ordinance was adopted. In September, October of 2024, the Affordable Housing Trust started to draft out their action plan, which is kind of like their guiding document. Then moving into that winter, there were stakeholder focus groups getting feedback.
In January 2025, we had our Declaration of Trust recorded at the Registry of Deeds. Moving into that spring, continued engagement. Also, May 2025, the Trust issued their first NOFA for basically letting people know that the Trust existed, they had funding available. Then we followed up with another community meeting. Eventually, we later voted to approve funding to Medford Community Housing. I'll talk a little bit more about that in a second, which was our first loan. Very exciting. We finalized our action plan, and we actually voted to approve a second loan to Medford Community Housing later the winter of this year in, I think, April or March, something like that. So into the spring, I guess. And then this past September, a couple months ago, we had a big housing resource fair. So that's kind of high level, top accomplishments. This is just an overview of where our funding is at this time. Basically, our total revenue is right now about $1.3 million.
For lots of complicated reasons, the funding has not actually transferred over for our loans, so we have $200,000 set aside. So that means we essentially have about $1.17. left still. And as you can see, we are very, very grateful for the funding we've already gotten from CPA. In FY25, we got $300,000. FY26, $550,000. And we are very humbly requesting $600,000, which is the 25% of the budget that I believe CPC has allocated to set aside for the trust.
We talked a little bit about this before, but just high-level overview for folks who are new, this guiding document, the Medford Affordable Housing Trust Fund Action Plan and Guidelines came out, kind of high-level summary of our top priorities, creating and preserving diverse affordable housing opportunities to address local housing needs. I think really building and supporting housing is the primary goal. Of course, there are other things we want to do as well. Partnering with mission driven organizations like Medford Housing Authority, we anticipate that they will actually come to us in the next month or two for a request for funding for phase 2 of the Walkling Court project that I know CPA is familiar with from previous years.
Also looking into researching new programs, supporting first-time homebuyers, for example, maybe looking to down payment assistance, equity buy-down programs. We also had that resource fair, which I'll tell you more about, and expanding communications generally to the community. This was the loan I mentioned. We had two separate loans we voted to approve for $100,000. This is the development. It is finalized. Folks live in it now, which is very exciting. All three units are rented. There is one one bedroom and there are two three bedrooms which is exciting because there is a very real scarcity of three bedroom affordable housing units in Medford, and that they are rental properties so Medford Community Housing is continuing to oversee that.
And the housing resource fair that I described was a really great event. This was the first time we had had something like this. We had been brainstorming ways that the trust could kind of share with the public everything that they've been up to as well as helping residents access resources. And so we ended up inviting several organizations. We had 16 different organizations that came and tabled in an open house kind of format. And in addition to that, we had a really interesting discussion with Erika DeRoche from Housing Medford as our moderator, and the speakers were Dariela Villanueva from DMV Housing Partners, which is an affordable housing developer in Boston. We had Gabe Trigorello from Medford Housing Authority. and Nick Pittman from LISC, Massachusetts, which is the Local Initiative Support Corporation. And the focus was really on the importance of financing for affordable housing, the challenges, success stories. So it was an interesting discussion. We brought together both affordable housing advocates and folks just wanting to learn more. One thing that was exciting coming out of the event is there was a lot of interest in folks who were potentially interested in the creation of a community land trust. And so we've reached out to them. We're hoping to have some follow up meetings. But over 14, I think 14 people signed up that were interested in working on a community land trust. So that was really cool to have that come up. And then also another thing that was wonderful, thanks to Teresa for spreading the news with me, but ABCD let us know that three residents are now in the path to stable housing as a result of that event from tabling at that open house format. So that's one very lovely concrete thing that we know is a positive outcome from that event.
This is just like overview of what else the trust has been up to. We've done a lot of research into other options for programs to fund. Right now, some of these aren't really feasible given like staff time constraints, but things to think about later down the road, especially if the trust did ever get to a point where they could fund someone to work like as a part-time role. We're also starting to think more about how to involve the trust with the disposition of city-owned land for housing. So that's something that we're going to be looking into. We've also, since it's still a new trust, spent some time formalizing processes, like our application process, financial documents, et cetera. And the trust has been very actively involved in some other affordable housing initiatives. So helping create the new fractional payment ordinance, which helps generate revenue for the trust eventually, hopefully. That's very kind of nitty gritty details. If people want, I can talk about it. We also were involved with helping to establish affordable housing linkage fees, and that is in process. Hopefully it will be finalized soon. So that is pretty much it. Happy to answer any questions, and thank you so much for your time.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you, Catherine. Questions from committee members? All right, I'll jump in. I have a question. You mentioned in your presentation a housing production plan, or maybe, I don't know if it was in your presentation or in the application, you drew data from the housing production plan. And I wonder if Medford is in the process of preparing an update to our housing production plan. I think that's approaching five years old at this point.
[Housing Planner Katherine Buckingham]: I think there was, for reasons I don't fully remember, I think where it was kind of extended out to 2028 so it's not super imminent but it's definitely on our radar and One thing that is great about our housing production plan and also the action plan, both of those documents really provide a framework and backing around why it makes sense for the city to be interested in supporting housing. So as I was mentioning a little bit, like using city land for housing, that's something we're trying to look into. And there's also the new 21st Century Roads Act to federal housing, a federal bill that is supporting housing and there are a lot of various incentives kind of like sticks and carrots in that federal bill. And so the city and the trust I think together can use that as another example of why this work is important and how it can actually help us with getting more funding down the road as well.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you. Any questions? Loza, please.
[Losa Julie Genevieve]: I don't really have a question, but I just want to comment that the working court for the tenants that was there and those potential tenants that will be there in the future are very grateful for the support that the Housing Trust has provided to Medford Housing, and I, for one, a tenant of Medford Housing, and I'm very grateful and proud to be a part of this moving forward. Thank you.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you, Losa. Catherine, have you received any indication up to this point of how much the Housing Authority might be looking for for phase 2 of Auckland Court?
[Housing Planner Katherine Buckingham]: I just reached out to Gabe recently, more so about timeline. So because I think they were thinking earlier in the summer that they would want to be coming to us this fall. So I was just asking like where things stood and I think they're still kind of wrapping up the financials on phase one and they wanted to get that all sort it out before coming to the trust for phase two. I didn't ask him for figures. I think it's probably one of those things where they would be happy to take as much as possible.
But I'd be happy to report back once I have more info on that.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: That would be helpful. I've noticed construction fencing going up around Walk Lane Court, but I I haven't seen any information about a ribbon cutting. I mean, not a ribbon cutting a groundbreaking for that site. So I'd be really curious. I know that they sent a communication to the neighborhood about the timeline for the project, but I would love to see a public, you know, blah, because it's such a significant project for the CPC. Because we put already 2,000,000 dollars, close to 2,000,000 dollars of funding into phase 1 of walking or in the past and I'd really love to be able to celebrate that project getting off the ground.
[Housing Planner Katherine Buckingham]: Yeah, absolutely. I'll be sure to keep you posted. Roberta.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Thank you. Go ahead. I was just gonna say, I believe it's eminent because you're jogging my memory that last week that. the development team for Walkland Court reached out to me asking for artwork, because they're printing a banner, which now I'm kind of connecting the dots. That's probably for a groundbreaking ceremony. So between Catherine and I, we'll definitely get a timeline on that. Thank you.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: I have a question for you, Roberta, just in terms of the process. As you recall, we all wanted the housing trust so that uh, housing requests could go to the housing trust and you have an ABCD request on our plate and why they go to the housing trust is really my question.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: So, uh, that's a great question, Joan, um, because the relationship between the CPC and the housing trust is new. Um, last year we received application from the housing trust. And we also received applications from our existing housing stability program partners. And we, I don't know whether we means myself and or Teresa or the committee, I don't remember exactly at what level the decision was made, thought that it would make sense initially to continue to invite the housing stability partners to come directly to the CPC while the affordable housing trust focused on housing construction and creation projects.
That's a conversation that we can revisit going forward. Um, so it, it seemed like this is kind of a transitional, um, and maybe, maybe transitional, maybe permanent. Um, division of labor between the CPC and the affordable housing trust. Um, and I think like perhaps before the next funding round, we can have a conversation as a committee, whether we want to continue to invite. the housing stability programs to apply through the CPC or if we want to invite the affordable housing trust to take on that role in our place.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: I just am concerned about forum shopping. I don't want them. You know, deciding, oh, we'll go to CPC, CPA, because we think we have a better relationship. We don't know anything with the housing.
[Ada Gunning]: Wasn't part of the rationale that like the AHP did not have that much money. Yeah. At the time. So we were like, let's have like a gradual hand turning here. Yeah.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: But we should probably have that conversation again at some point.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yeah, we can revisit that. Absolutely. And I think At the outset of this application round, we made it appear to the housing stability partners that they should continue to apply through us. So they didn't decide who they should approach, at least on a staff level. or chair level, we guided them to come to us instead.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: I don't disagree that, you know, nobody did anything wrong. You know, everybody, we told them to, I just think that to have two different entities talking to, you know, giving housing money away, you know, that was the whole reason we got the housing trust to have one, you know, place to go. So just conversation. That's all.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yeah. Thank you. All right. Well, thank you very much. Thank you, Catherine. Thank you, Lisa. Hi, Catherine. Hi. All right, next on the agenda, the Department of Public Works Tufts Park Field Stormwater Mitigation. I believe we're going to hold off on that presentation until the next meeting because they were not able to be with us tonight. They had a conflicting meeting with City Council tonight. So we have with us today a small grant application for the Unitarian Universalist Church slate roof repair.
We did have a presentation on this last month, but committee members had questions about the the proposed treatment of the slate roof. Thank you for coming back for your patience waiting to come back and explain more about how you're treating the roof. I understand we also have Brian Hayward from the Historical Commission here to comment as well. Please. Thank you. Great.
[Ammons]: I haven't been talking, so I'm happy to be here. It may be a misnomer to call it a slate roof repair or renovation because slate is involved. But what it is, and I'll try to describe this, is where three parts of pitched roof that are slate come together, like this, this, this, and this, okay? And at the bottom is a flat rubber roof. And what happens is all the rainwater and snowmen comes down that slate, collects on the flat rubber roof, and creates leaks into the bathroom. The bathroom ceiling inside the church under that is ruined. It's very rotten and it doesn't go out into the gutter and then down a downspout. The contractor who has done a lot of roofing, including at the Unitarian Universalist Church. He's maintained our slate roof for, gee, I'd say 10 years, where slates are broken, where they're missing, and the church is from 1894, so it takes attention to these big slate areas to try to get there quickly enough that more damage is not done. So he crawls in the rafters, looks for leaks, comes over when they're downpours on his own multiple times to see if he can track them and so forth. So we have great confidence in his commitment to that roof and his ability. But this project is to address that flat rubber roof that was put on years ago that is now rotten. And so what he plans to do is tear out the rotten rubber roof and the foundation for it, go right down to the rafters there, rebuild a platform for it, then build a slightly slanted foundation for the rubber roof above that platform so the water, when it comes cascading down from the slate, can move to the gutter and then have a new gutter and downspout and it'll get off the roof and it won't take. This will show you I'm not an architect or a contractor. I made a little visual display. So this is one slate roof coming down. This is the second one. And this one actually comes over like on a lip. And under here is a lid, what I call flashing. So what he wants to do is take off a course or two of slate around here so that he can work and it'll go back on and then put in and then do all this foundation work. And then put in a, that's the little slanting roof foundation that goes in and rubber over that, then flashing from, or before the rubber goes on, flashing up onto where the slate has been liberated then put on the rubber, then reapply the two courses of slate so it will pour down onto the flashing, onto the rubber roof that's slanted, go into the gutter, and down the downspout.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Makes sense.
[Ammons]: Thank you so much.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: That is such a much clearer understanding now of what you're doing.
[Ammons]: And you had a concern about his nailing through rubber roofing, which you won't be doing because the rubber roof will be glued onto it.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Got it. Ryan, I would like to invite you to share your perspective on the appropriateness of this treatment
[Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I was just listening in and I was focused on the slate roof, but obviously the slate roof is not the problem here. It's the rubber roof. I would encourage a little bit of research here because I'm curious as to what the original material was in this particular location. I'm thinking because it's a low flat roof that there's a real possibility that it may have been a metal material such as lead or copper, and that it had been removed and replaced with something a little bit more easier for the roofers to install at some point. And I would consider going back to that just because it will work better in unison and longevity with the slate roof. And I know that you guys asked some questions on whether or not the slate roof can be repaired.
Yeah, obviously, it's been repaired over time and I absolutely think that there'll be no issue with taking apart pieces of that slate roof to incorporate the new materials for this flat roof section into that project without having to take apart the whole roof.
[Ammons]: Thank you. We don't have a record of what was there before. This has been there a long time. Let me just finish. Um, and the recommended, um, there is, um, there has been metal, probably lead flashing around the side, but it's a, uh, it probably was an asphalt, asphalt, um, compound over it. And then maybe for that metal, but that would be the only way back. So we're, we are planning on a rubber, uh, a good rubber roof with an angle to, um, let the water drain off. Is this visible from the street? No, it's not. No, it's not.
[Ryan Hayward]: The original architectural plans you'll find at the State Archives because it's a place just so the CPC knows for public buildings that had places of assembly or multifamily structures built between 1865 and 1965. They were reviewed by the State Department of Public Safety. All of those plans are available at the State Archives for polling, so I would encourage the plans just to be able to see what the original specifications were for the exterior.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you for that information and I don't know if you or Doug would have any experience to know what the differential of cost would be between what's proposed and a metal treatment here.
[Doug Carr]: Double, I would think.
[Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, yeah.
[Doug Carr]: I mean, if it depends on if it's, if it's copper, it's at least double, but copper is obviously a fortune these days. But I, I guess. I agree with Ryan, I think, you know, I look, we supported this building. I think this, this product obviously is there's an urgency here because it's an actively leaking roof. Like, I get that. Um. But usually for a project of any historic building that we've done, there's architectural drawings that show drainage and slope and details and flashing and stuff like that. So we know that it's done to the Secretary of the Interior standards, which obviously is our standard that we have to follow for all these buildings. But that obviously is not what's been done so far. And I understand why, because this is like, Bigger than a small repair, but not a full restoration. You know, like, this is kind of an in between project for that that I see, you know, and it's an urgent project because of the leaking, but, but I kind of agree with Ryan. It's like, I think we just need.
you know, there needs to be a band aid to get you through the winter, but I think we need just a little bit more details. And I think the cost is going to go up once we actually get to actual details, you know, the contractors put together a scope of work that is basically a list of construction, but doesn't show you how anything goes together. It's just, it's all words. There's no drawings, you know, about, about slopes about materials. Um, I, I, Probably, I don't know if this, Ryan, help me out here. I'm not sure the Secretary of Interior stands to allow for a membrane roof, would it, on a building of this age?
[Ryan Hayward]: Well, it depends on what the If the original materials are known and can be found out, you should always go back to materials that are proven longevity. The problem with this roof, which may have a corrective solution, is that the UV exposure is just going to continue to deteriorate it. So in 20 years, it'll be the same problem happening again. the roof will deteriorate and ultimately will be in the same place. Whereas if you say, oh, it was designed for and the space originally had a metal roof section or an asphalt section, then at least that will be known. And, you know, they sort of tried to figure it out. So, yeah. But I mean, at least we've done the research. I definitely would do a little research. And I would encourage, even at a minimum right now, fixing the slates that are allowing open water to get in because the EPDM could just, they could just tarp over it and give it a little bit of time.
[Doug Carr]: Is there under the slates, aren't there some compromised sheathing or covers that need to be replaced? I thought that was part of the scope if I remember from last month correctly. Is that correct? Yeah, that's correct. Okay. Yeah, I mean, so I don't know if it's, if it's, you know, heavy duty plywood, you know, ice and water shield, you know, there's all kinds of, again, I just think a little bit more detail that would go a long way.
[Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I'm also curious as to how the contractor would rehang the slate. Some slate people can figure out ways to nail them back in place. Others use copper hangers to sort of disguise their repair. So I'm really curious as to how he plans to do that, because it does make a difference.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yeah. I see. Reg?
[Reggie Graham]: We're talking about a repair for an immediate problem.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes.
[Reggie Graham]: I understand the significance of needing to maintain decorum and so on and so forth. But we're talking about additional damage while we're sitting around here, and they're asking for immediate relief, help, and getting this repaired.
[Ammons]: And I would only add, on something that is not visible, you'd have to send a drone up.
[Reggie Graham]: I'm all for getting the correct specifications and so on and so forth. But this is a more immediate problem that needs to be resolved sooner rather than later so that they don't come back to us in a year and say, oh, by the way, the bathroom is not the only thing that's broke, got leaks in it. It's right over here. I want to get this thing resolved quickly. I don't want to have to wait until something else happens. I mean, it's, you know, Going back to the original specifications is fine. But let's get this little project done first, and then we can go back and revisit the other piece. to be honest with you.
[Doug Carr]: Thank you. I would agree with that, Rich. I think a two-step process is the right one here. Put the bandaid on, get the building watertight, take the time to get the details right. That might not happen till the spring. I don't want that to be the case with nothing happening. I agree with you.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: And so I just want to clarify 2 step process means that we consider a grant right now to do this emergency repair and invite them to come back to make a more permanent repair. using proper materials and maybe expanding to the area that really needs to be treated. I just had one more question about materials. So Ryan, I think earlier suggested that it might have originally been copper, but a metal roof. I wonder if, especially since it's not visible, it doesn't make sense to use copper, but if it could make sense to use, if there is a lower cost metal alternative, so that it has whatever the functionality that metal would provide, but not the expense of copper.
[Ryan Hayward]: I mean, lead flashing is also appropriate. So I mean, that'll be fine.
[Reggie Graham]: I'd have a rubber roof.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: OK.
[Reggie Graham]: around it originally. I didn't put copper back. It works kind of nice.
[Doug Carr]: Of course my house- You don't have a historic preservation restriction on your house, Red.
[Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I, you know, I question whether or not the, you know, I don't think the Massachusetts Historical Commission, because it's not visible from the street, is going to worry about the particulars of this roof. They're more probably more concerned about the fact that water is getting into the building.
[Doug Carr]: Yes, we have two flat roofs at the Brooks Estate on the manor. They're flat seam copper roofs, but they were installed 20 years ago, you know, and at some significant costs, you know, so, you know, we had to put every change as is required through the Historical Commission at the state level for any exterior changes. And that's what that's what they said.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: But that building was under a preservation restriction. This building, if I recall, is under a local historic district?
[Ryan Hayward]: No, this is under a preservation restriction.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Oh, OK. I did not realize that.
[Ryan Hayward]: Received MPPF funding.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Got it.
[Ryan Hayward]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: OK. That does make a difference. So whatever the permanent solution is, that would need to be approved by the state historical commission. So that's yet another reason why to have a two-phase project. Whatever the funding is that we need to fix the problem now, do it. But please come back and ask for more to do it properly.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. And I think the Band-Aid might be cheaper than the $10,000 being asked.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: 10,000 being asked for a project that they estimate at 17,000. Okay.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: So, I don't go ahead and we don't have a proposal for a band aid fix. This is a more. Intense restoration, like, rebuilding a part of the roof.
[Ada Gunning]: We're calling it a band aid, but not literally a band aid.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: No, no, I know, but I mean. is the quote band-aid solution we're suggesting including rebuilding this roof?
[Ada Gunning]: Yes. I think that's what we're calling a band-aid in that conversation.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Doug, I'm not sure. I'm asking, is that what you intended, Doug?
[Doug Carr]: I'm concerned about the aesthetics of the band-aid because it's going to be replaced by a permanent higher quality roof come next year or whenever it makes sense, get them through six to 12 months. It could be what they're proposing. I don't actually have an issue with that as long as the long-term solution is consistent with the preservation restriction and the requirements that we have upheld for all historic buildings that have come before this commission, committee.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Okay. Thank you. What is the process for a building that's under preservation restriction with MHC? Does that, do they have to get permission for this project or is, does an emergency project?
[Doug Carr]: No, I don't think they need to get the permission for something that is not going to be deemed permanent. I don't, I don't, I don't think we've ever had to do that for the Brooks estate.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: So I have the impression before they came in here that your intention was that this was the final fix for this roof. So they would have considered this permanent. We're asking them to maybe rethink this as a, maybe ask your contractor to do what you need to do to stop the leak now. Maybe that lowers your budget a bit for now and to come back next year and ask for more money to, put a permanent fix in place that can be meet the requirements of your preservation restriction. So would that be?
[Ammons]: Well, I'll go back and check on and the requirements of the preservation restriction are that we have to do what was done in 1894 or If we don't use copper, we have to use lead or some other metal.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I think literally the requirements of the preservation restriction are that you get MHC approval for whatever you do. So you'll want to see what their standards are, and it's their standards, not ours, and determine what you'll need to meet their standards. That's...
[Doug Carr]: As an example, there was no waterproofing flashing materials in 1880 or whatever, 1700. So they're reasonable about choosing materials that are 21st century materials that provide the scientific watertightness for buildings. But they're going to use, like they made us use wood decking for wood decks, not treks. You know, we had to choose our hardwood. We used copper. We used, obviously, replacement matching slate. Everywhere we could use it, especially on the visible surfaces, they said, you have to use the same material. You know, use the wood where there was wood. But they allow you, you know, things behind the wood, you know, for waterproofing, for insulation. They allow all kinds of things like that because they understand that this is a 21st century construction project.
So, I think we, we pass something tonight. You know, with caveats about coming back, I would get, I would even include a couple of thousand dollars for a preservation architect to drop everything and to research it and include a bigger number coming back. That's probably going to be 2 or 3 times the number we're talking about tonight.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Perhaps. If you ask your contractor to scale back the construction to what's necessary to stop the leak but not necessarily finish the roof area, if you have funding left over that was going to be your match, you could use that to work with a historic preservation architect to prepare a plan that you can bring next year for a for a follow-up application. That would be my suggestion. So I feel like you can leave, you can stay, you can have a cookie. I feel like we've reached a consensus among the committee members about how we want to approach this project. So would anyone like to make a motion to recommend funding for this project?
[Reggie Graham]: Oh, I said Doug. Doug.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Oh, I did not. Well, I vote that we approve.
[Doug Carr]: we fund this project to the dollars listed until we know something. $10,000. If it's less, Teresa can obviously claw that back as she's prone to do, and just put the condition that this is a, I'm not saying temporary fix, but it's an emergency.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: It's an emergency fix.
[Doug Carr]: It's an emergency fix in that we're going to obviously look for the applicant to come back. sometime in 2027. It could be the regular cycle or special. This is not the actual verbiage of the vote here, but we need to put language in there that says this is an emergency fix, but that a full restoration consistent with the Secretary of Interior's standards and the preservation restriction will be designed and executed sometime in 2027.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: emergency fix with the goal of preserving the historic asset.
[Doug Carr]: Very good. Thank you, Jim.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Okay, I just wanted to think if there was anything to tweak about that condition. And that they will seek funding to execute it in 2027 or that they will, I don't I don't want to tell you that you have to come to us, because maybe a benefactor will contribute the money that you need. But I also don't want to tell you that you have to build it if nobody's giving you any money. So how do we want to phrase that? Maybe this is just me riffing. The applicant shall continue to prepare a permanent treatment. Oh, restoration, that's good. Permanent restoration that complies with the Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation.
[Doug Carr]: And the conservation restriction.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: and the conservation, the preservation restriction. And mentioned that it's held by the Massachusetts Historical Commission. And a plan shall continue to prepare Sure. Okay. Folks online aren't seeing this. Sorry, folks. See, show everyone, see if there are any last changes. And I heard a motion from Doug and a second from Reg. The funding is given on an emergency basis to provide urgent protection for the historical asset. The applicant shall continue to prepare a permanent restoration plan that complies with the standards for rehabilitation stated in the United States Secretary of Interior standards for the pavement and historic properties.
[Doug Carr]: Are we sure that's rehabilitation? I would just say standards. I wouldn't just say standards stated because there's four different categories and this might cover a couple of them.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Thank you.
[Unidentified]: That's true.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: All right, thank you. So I heard a motion and a second and I will call the roll. Reg? Yes. Paige? Yes. Ada? Yes. Doug? Yes. Joan? Yes. Losa? Yes. And myself, yes. Thank you very much for coming. Yes. Mental exercise. Ryan for for helping us to work our way through this application. Yeah. That is extremely helpful. All right, next on the agenda. We have an off-cycle application from Medford Recreation for the Condon Shell Field Lighting additional funding. Again, this is an application that we received last month and we asked for Medford Recreation to clarify exactly with documentation, exactly what was being requested.
So they submitted an off-cycle application formally and submitted a memorandum requesting that we take funding out of a previously funded project that is waiting for construction in the future so that we would have the money immediately available to be able to fund this project. So I think that I see two votes. that would be required for us to be able to move this forward unless there are further questions from committee members. Any other questions or discussion?
The votes that we would need would be first a vote to reduce the FY26 grant for Tufts Park lighting improvement by $50,000. You're looking for a motion?
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Yes.
[Reggie Graham]: I'll make that motion.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Okay.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Great. Then I will call the roll. Yep. Reg? Yes. Paige? Yes. Ada? Yeah. Doug?
[Doug Carr]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Joan? Yes. Yes. And myself, yes. And a second motion would be to recommend funding of $50,000 for the Condon Shell Lighting Improvement Project.
[Losa Julie Genevieve]: I'll make that motion.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Go ahead, Losa.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I heard Joan first and Losa second. All right, Reg.
[Unidentified]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
[Unidentified]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And myself. Yes. Thank you for. On behalf of recreation. Thank you for that. Yes. And good stuff. Yep. And we'll get this quickly to city council. Thank you for being able to.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: One thing to talk about as a CPC with our friend Ryan Hayward here. Ryan can probably speak a little bit more intelligently to this, but essentially this body has funded, I believe it was fiscal 24, a Thomas Brooks Park renovation project. For those who weren't around then, this project, and Ryan, feel free to stomp over me, but it's a renovation of the The original site of the Brooks family who was one of the founding families here in Medford. So there's been some tree work done through there, some relaying of pathways and walking paths. But I'll pause now, because I see, Ryan, that you've unmuted. So maybe you want to hop in here and save me.
[Ryan Hayward]: No, you're doing fine. I think it's a great project to summarize. You're doing good. So we did two rounds of archaeological testing. And the first one was sort of a shovel test pit. So we did a bunch of testing to see if we could locate the house site. We located the house site. We went back and did some more extensive digging. But we found a lot of great things. But 99.9% of all the artifacts that came out of the site came out of one test excavation.
we're having difficulty locating the actual house features. That's the center hearth and the foundation and outbuildings such as a privy and wells and all the things that you would have on an 18th and early 19th century building. So recently we are undertaking some ground penetrating radar testing and I got the opportunity to see it in the works with a recent presentation by Joe Bagley and the work that they did at the top of Bunker Hill Monument, looking for the historic features there at that site, it is amazing what ground penetrating radar can tell you without actually putting a shovel in the ground. So talking with the GPR people that did some scans for us for the cemetery project that we're working on, they were convinced that they could do a one acre scan, which is a pretty large area, given that the park is only six acres in total, for less than $10,000. I have that money in my budget already, I wouldn't need any more money from CPC, it would just be reallocating a portion of the project for other work that we had planned to the archaeological component. So I just wanted to make sure that CPC was okay with that. and didn't need me to either formally put it in writing and request it or anything like that. But I just wanted to give you guys the option to be aware that I really would like to do that scan so that we can see what sort of features remain. in and around the house site, and finally, finally be able to locate that and excitingly, because we don't need to go in the ground and we can sort of test it, there should be an earlier 17th century building right in front of this house so we're hoping that we can find that as well.
GPR guys tell me that burned remains, because the house burned in 1730, burned remains show up exceptionally well on GPR surveys. So that's really exciting to be able to possibly find it. Where is this? Thomas Brooks Park in West Medford on Grove Street.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: And the reason for the request, just to clarify, is it's In my mind, it kind of fell within the original scope that was presented, but I wanted to afford the committee the opportunity to tell me I'm wrong and chime in. So.
[Reggie Graham]: So when we just, we just had that same sounds like the same, almost the same situation with recreation.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: And I hear you and I might argue that this is the same project. Yeah.
[Reggie Graham]: It's a little bit of a scope for reallocation of funds.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Well, within the same project, the same project, like, so it's saying we're going to spend a little bit less money on this part of the project and a little bit more money on this other part of the project. But the goal of the project doesn't change the, whereas in the other case, they wanted to take money out of this project and put it over here.
[Reggie Graham]: So that's still, if it's the same project, why do we have to go on it?
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Oh, we don't. We wanted to ask whether we should. It was a professional courtesy thing. I could have just said, go for it. But I wanted to see if anybody had given the recent conversation with the recreation one. I didn't want to. OK, I appreciate that.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Oh, I really appreciate your having Ryan here to explain it all to us, though. This is an exciting kind of way that this project is playing out. Yeah. That's fun having him. Doug?
[Doug Carr]: I just want to echo, I think this could have been an administrative decision, frankly, Teresa, but I'm glad you brought it up because I learned a little bit more. This ground penetration radar, I can think of a dozen places in Medford where eventually we're going to use that because we have some Even the parking lot we're going to build in the Brooks Estate, who knows that there's archeology in there? There was a Native American site up there 400 years ago.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: What about the graveyards over in the parking lot behind Medford Square?
[Ryan Hayward]: We've already scanned those. That was the impetus for bringing them there. I'm patiently biting my nails waiting for the results of that.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: And we mentioned earlier archeology along the Mistip River. And I wonder whether this could also be an alternative. I mean, it sounds to me like the benefit is that you don't have to cap the site after you've excavated it. Right? So it may cost more upfront perhaps, but it sounds as though it's less disturbing.
[Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, well, it's non-disturbing at all. They don't do any digs. What the point of it would be is that I would be able to see the features under the ground, such as foundations and buildings and stones and all that, and how they're oriented so that I know exactly what the extents are that we would need to protect. They also do it, for example, if you have a The reason why they did it partially on Bunker Hill is because they were replacing the sprinkler system and needed to know where the sprinkler lines were without actually digging. So they physically scanned the entire site and had the added benefit of being able to get the archeological component in there as well. So it's very useful for all sorts of things like utilities and cemeteries. And this archeology could be used on streets if they don't know where the utilities are on the streets, easy to map. So it has all sorts of great opportunities.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Absolutely.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Thank you for the education about it. So go forward, Ryan, and have fun.
[Ryan Hayward]: Hey, don't worry. I will. I'll bring back the results. That'll be fun. I also am pushing the archaeologists to bring back the artifacts. They are done labeling them, and they were just working on the final report. It really is a beautiful cross-section of 18th, early 19th century life in Medford. The top 1%, but that is really illustrative of how people lived in those days. It's great.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: I would love for you to share that report with the committee once it's completed.
[Losa Julie Genevieve]: We'd be happy to see it.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: And you have to present dressed like that when you bring it.
[Ryan Hayward]: Okay, done.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Good deal.
[Ryan Hayward]: I love dressing like that. So absolutely.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: All right. Thank you. Thank you, Ryan.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: And so next on the agenda is meeting minutes from October.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: And I even refreshed. It's because they didn't get up.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Okay. So we will pause on the meeting minutes until next month. We cannot vote that we've received the meeting minutes.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Do we have any other administrative updates? I do have one, though. I hope if everybody could hang back for a moment, I just have an update to share that doesn't need to be publicly broadcasted. So I'd ask that we close the meeting, and then if everybody just hang back, it'll be very quick.
[Vice Chair Joan Cyr]: Okay, motion to close the meeting. Second. All right.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Reg?
[Reggie Graham]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Paige? Yes. Ada? Doug?
[Reggie Graham]: Yes.
[Chair Roberta Cameron]: Joan? Yes. Losa? Yeah. And myself, yes. All right, thanks everybody.