[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Good evening all. This is the November 9th meeting of the Medford Historical Commission. I will call the meeting to order at 7.07 p.m. Just a quick rundown of our agenda tonight. We're going to have a public hearing on 141 Grant Avenue, followed by under new business. We'll have some demo delay items. 33 Winchester Street, 387, 389 Main Street. We'll hear an update from the ICCM Medford about the Isaac Hall House. We'll review our 2027 dates, have some board officer information, and then we'll just have our regular updates for the various projects going on at the end of the meeting. So we'll start with the public hearing at 141 Grant.
So the building was determined to be significant by the Historical Commission last month. The demo delay process is a two-step process. We first determine whether the building's significant. And once the building has been determined significant, it gets a public hearing. So this is that second portion of it. To reiterate what significance means that we'll be reviewing later tonight, significant means any building or portion thereof not subject to a local historic district but which has been either listed on or pending listing of the National Register of Historic Places, listed on the Massachusetts Register of Historic Places, or was built within 75 years or older, which is determined by the commission to be significant building either because it is importantly associated with one or more historic persons or events or with the broad architectural, cultural, political, economic, or social history of the city or commonwealth, or it is historically or architecturally important in terms of period, style, method of building construction, or association with an important architect or builder either by itself or in the context of group of buildings. Significance is sort of a regular threshold. Tonight we'll be determining whether this building is preferably preserved. And what that is, is we'll be reviewing the building's integrity, whether or not there's enough historic fabric to warrant further discussion about the building. And in the definition is literally that the commission determines that it is in the public interest to be preserved and rehabilitated rather than demolished. So commissioners, I'd like to start with you to make a motion to open the discussion, and then we will have comments from the commissioners about the preferably preserved status, followed by public comments, starting with the owners, and then those for demolition and against demolition, and then we'll wrap up with final commission comments. We'll take a roll call vote and then discuss the next steps.
[Doug Carr]: I'll make a motion to find the property. Preferably be reserved.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll 2nd.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Okay, go ahead Doug. If you want to start the discussion.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, I don't think a lot has changed since the last meeting in terms of my thoughts on this building. There are probably a lot of Victorians in Medford, but this one is extremely prominent, a lot of integrity. The octagonal tower is a character defining feature, I think, of not only that building, but that area, that neighborhood, it's an important building, and I think we wanna do our best to adapt it to future use, but definitely find it, we've already found it significant, and I wanna take the next step.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great, thanks, Jen?
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yeah, just to echo on what Doug said, Queen Anne Victorians in Medford are rare, we don't have that many of them, and in my opinion, this home should be preserved on the exterior as it is as much as possible. And I will leave it at that.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Sarah, I see you next.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: In agreement. I mean, it's gorgeous. It would be a shame to lose any of those features. So I'm for preferably preserved.
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Great. Luke? Yeah, I agree with the former three. No further comments.
[Peter Miller]: Peter? No further comments.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Kit?
[Kit Nichols]: You know.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK, great. So now we're going to open it up to public comments. If anybody would like to speak about the matter, starting with the building owners, just raise your hand and I'll recognize you and then from there will go those in favor of demolition, those opposed to demolition, and then we'll close public comment. Go ahead, Rob. I just need your name and address for the record.
[CAS00002568_SPEAKER_14]: Hi, guys. My name is Rob Owen. I represent the owners. We have been in touch, obviously, with you guys already on the subcommittee. So, you know, we're hopeful we can come to, you know, a path forward here, you know, one way or the other. So, you know, I think, you know, we like, you know, we understand the preference of this building and, you know, the history of it. So we're hopeful we can come to something in subcommittee.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And just your address for the record? 141 Grant Avenue. Great. Thank you. Any further public comments? Raise your hand. All right, seeing none, I'm going to close public comment. Commissioners, anything else you want to add to this before we take a roll call vote? All right, seeing none, hearing none, there's a motion on the table to find for significance made by Doug Carr and seconded by Jen Keenan. I will go around roll call vote as I see you.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Ryan, just declare it's preferably preserved, not significance.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Oh, did I say significant? Sorry.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Preserved. Yeah.
[Doug Carr]: I do that all the time.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I did. I did it last month too. Well, it's important for the record because we're going backwards in time. Okay. Motion's been made for preferably preserved status, seconded by Jen. Starting with Doug. Yes. Jen.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Kit. Yes. Luke. Yes. Yes. Peter?
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Did I miss somebody? Doug?
[Doug Carr]: You started with me.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I started with you, right? Who am I missing?
[Doug Carr]: No one. No one, right? Unless you got a new members.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, no, no. I just, I, uh, it's 6 0 minus you. Yeah, no, I know. I was like, I, I just missed, uh, I missed a yes. That's all. So, okay. So, uh, what's going to happen is that imposes an 18 month up to 18 month demo delay of which the commission reserves the right to lift that. So, as the applicant noted, um, that they are working with the existing. subcommittee for the historical commission to try to refine their design and mitigate the demolition on this building. When the subcommittee is ready, they'll bring it back to the table for public information.
[Doug Carr]: I'll just say this, Ryan, that so far, each iteration has been an improvement, so we're heading in a good direction.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, great. All right, so we'll keep an eye out on, if people are interested in following this project, just keep an eye out on our blog. We have information, we post it to our website, www.medfordhistoricalcommission.org, and you go to the News and Updates section, and that will be where we post both our meeting information and we post our general updates for larger projects that we have between meetings. Okay, that concludes the public hearing for this meeting, so we'll move right on to 33 Winchester Street. Commissioners, I sent around the demolition application for this building and the MHC form B. We can roll right into significance determination after you accept the application.
a motion to start with the application.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Motion to accept the application.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Second. Jen got it.
[Jennifer Keenan]: It's all right, no worries.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: But thank you for the second. Doug Carr, second. Okay, roll call vote starting with Doug.
[Doug Carr]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Jen. Yes. Kit.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Peter.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Luke. Yes, Sarah. Yes, OK, 60 approved. Alright, I'll take a motion for. For or against significance for this property to kick start the discussion for determination of significance.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll make a motion to find for significance.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK. In a second. Just to kickstart the discussions.
[Peter Miller]: I can 2nd. Bearing in mind that I'm probably not going to vote for that.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, go ahead. Um.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I am going to vote for significance on this one. I feel that based on the age, being a pre-1900 structure, that alone meets the criteria for significance. And then in addition to the fact that the consultant recommended that this could be part of a historic district on the end of the Form B, I thought that was noteworthy and just You know, cause for further discussion. I don't know if it would ultimately be preferably preserved, but I do think it meets the definition of significance.
And I will leave it at that.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: All right. Go ahead Doug.
[Doug Carr]: The opposing side actually, I would oh, sorry.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: It was it was Peter got Peter. Sorry. My apologies. It was Peter. Yep.
[Peter Miller]: Yeah, I, for some reason, this house, I just feel like it's lost a lot of integrity. The flat roof and everything and.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Can I make a clarification and I just.
[Peter Miller]: What's that?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Let me I'll make a clarification after you're done.
[Peter Miller]: Okay. Yeah. I don't see this 1 possibly becoming perfectly preserved. So. I'm not in favor of significance for this 1.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I do want to clarify. The owner submitted a letter with this, making some claims about this building. There's an identical building next to this. Both those duplexes have flat roofs in this orientation, so it's sort of unusual. You know, flat roof duplexes are normally taller and they contain more stories, so this is sort of like a low-rise duplex. So I do think that's an original feature. I don't think it lost a roof line here. I don't, you know, that doesn't necessarily make or break it, but I suspect it's going to have the same details. If you guys look at the streetscape, it's probably going to have the same details as its neighbor. All right, I'm going to go to, let's go to Kit next.
[Kit Nichols]: I feel like there are enough questions about this. that we sort of need to figure out what it actually looked like originally. So I would be inclined to continue the conversation and find it significant.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Thank you. Doug, we'll come to you next.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. I went through the form. I don't see a lot of historic photos or any historic photos here. Is there more information available on this building?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: uh not readily available but if you go i hate to do this but like if people google the address there are some real estate photos so there are some period details inside of it um if it hasn't been gutted which i don't think it has yet um if you look at the wilson wolf real estate um ad it looks like you know there are some doors there's the staircase intact there's some woodwork um you know it's been renovated but it's You know, mostly there, the room arrangements are probably there.
[Doug Carr]: And I see that the building, it's so-called twin flat roof building next to it has had extensive renovations, or is that the original form maybe adapted with the porch?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I think the, I don't know, I think maybe our porch, because it's like six over one windows, may have been an addition later, but it's hard to tell. let's see, what does the Sanborn say? Did John include a Sanborn with that inventory form?
[Doug Carr]: And while you're looking for that, can I ask, I haven't had a chance to look at the demo plans, what's being proposed here?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: They're proposing to take off the front porch, push the front wall out to where the front porch is on both the first and second floor, add a gable roof to the top of this building, and add an addition in the back that also adds on to that. There's a little L that somebody pushed out in the 1990s or so. They're looking to beef up that. So they're basically maxing out this building, which is why I got flagged for demo review.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, no, I get it. I don't. And that's in the drawings. In the demo package has that, is that correct?
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, there's full exterior elevations. It is a pretty dramatic change to the roof line. Really? It's a full gable with big shed dormers off the sides.
[Unidentified]: Okay, thank you.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: It looks like the porches appear on the 1898 map of Medford, so perhaps that porch is an original feature. It wouldn't be a bad feature for a duplex on such a tight lot to have.
[Doug Carr]: Do you feel that the design is an original design?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I think it warrants some additional discussion. I think I might do something different. I'm not opposed to a third floor, but instead of doing a gable roof, I might actually echo the boxy shape and step it back so that you can see what the original is, but then also be like, oh look, they brought the box design up to another level and maybe got them to restore some of the details like that flared out roof. sort of parapet wall, you know, and not necessarily gut and strip this building. You know, I think it can be done tastefully. I'm not opposed to the renovation of this building. I just think that there are some changes that could be done that could make it cooler, you know, cooler in the sense of in the eyes of preserving the integrity of the building, I guess, so.
[Doug Carr]: Sure. All right. I'd like to hear from any other commissioners if there's other thoughts.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, Sarah?
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Yeah, I think regardless of how I feel about the current design, it sounds like it's pretty rare in Medford for there to be only potentially two of this kind of like shorter flat roof style. So that gives me a bit of pause. I do think the proposed plans are quite nice. It would look a lot more like its neighbors and sort of fit in a little bit better, but I am kind of a little bit torn about it being, you know, one of only two potentially.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. And Luke, that leaves you Luke.
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, I, um, my initial goal was kind of the same that, you know, that I don't, what's currently there, you know, It's not, you know, it's it's really it doesn't look like it's there's there's much worth saving, but I am like, after all the discussion, I am kind of inclined to pause and I don't know. I've just been I've been staring at, like, the elevations, the proposed elevations, particularly like the front 1. For just a couple of minutes now and. I don't they're just I'm having trouble kind of putting into words, but it's giving me pause as well. Yeah, they're just the way that. Yeah, I don't know, just the way that the gable and everything was handled. So that's where I'm at.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, and they're coming forward to try to line that second floor up with the porch below. So it's gonna, every house on the street that sort of stepped back and at that level is gonna look weird because this one's gonna be more prominent. So also another reason that I just look at this as a good project to review, that's all. Okay, great. Well, I think that's everybody. So we had a motion on the table. So we'll go circle back to the vote. So there was a motion on the table for significance that's been made and seconded. So yes would be for significance. No allows them to go on their way. So I'll do a roll call vote starting with Jen.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Doug? Yes. And Kit?
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Peter?
[Peter Miller]: No.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Luke? Yes. And Sarah?
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Yes. Game time.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Five to one approved. So I'll get the letter out to them and we'll have a public hearing next month for the December meeting.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, I'll take a close look at those drawings just to see what, you know, because it's, There's a project there. I don't know how they keep the porch to me is like. If you're trying to make that part of the building, it probably is these almost be rebuilt. I would imagine because it's just not there for the original design.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah. Okay, great. Moving on to 387, 389 Main Street commissioners. We accepted their demo applications, so we're reviewing for significance tonight. I sent around the MHC form B for the building. I'll entertain a motion to start the discussion. Or against, doesn't matter.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll make a motion to fine for significance.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Can I have a second?
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll second.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. All right, go ahead, Jen.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yeah, I mean, I think similar to the previous one, The age alone, I think, warrants the definition of significance. Again, it's pre-1900. It's mixed use. Obviously, it's this funky little commercial space with the house in the rear. And again, our consultant has Um, you know, said that this could be a potential. Part of a historic district, and I know we've looked at this, you know, kind of South Medford main street area before, you know. I remember years ago, we looked at by Charlie's and there's some kind of interesting things on this block. and these old kind of taxpayer block sections of Medford. So again, not sure that it would rise to the level of preferably preserved, but I think as far as the definition of significance goes, it meets the criteria for significance.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Sarah?
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: This one, I don't know. torn as well. I think that the renovations seem very thoughtful, and I'm inclined to say it looks almost the same. So why take more time than we need? But maybe you'll have to come back to me.
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Luke? Yeah. I'm also really torn on this one. I agree with Sarah that I'm looking at kind of the renderings and elevations of the renovation and it does look very well, you know, very thoughtful. They're, they're paying attention at least to some detailing and things like that. I mean, the biggest the biggest thing that jumps out to me and I know like the existing building. It's been reclad in vinyl and stuff, so there's not a lot of detail left, but the roof line of it with the strong gable matches the yellow house next to it, looking at the Form B. You know, you've got these kind of two existing houses that kind of form this roofline language. The house next to it that's peeking around the corner, the yellow house, has like a mansard roof, and so they're kind of mimicking, they're kind of taking a language that's nearby, so they're not really going completely off menu here. I think that was the main thing that kind of jumped out to me, is like, okay, but I'm a little torn as to whether I'm for or against Thank you. Doug, you want to jump in?
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, I agree with a lot of what Luke says. I think the challenge, I don't think this will ultimately be found perfectly preserved, but I think the design is strong, but I think the way it treats the front of the brick piece that was clearly tacked on decades later, I think Moving away from that aesthetic is better than reinforcing it at this point. And I think the example down the street on two houses over that Luke mentioned is a better example of that. I think there's a way to integrate that. So if I'm going to find it significant and perfectly preserved, it's going to be purely to just improve what I think is a really strong design that just needs a little tweaking at the front. Because I think the rest of it is perfectly acceptable and high quality. But I just think, you know, trying to like that brick is not great looking now. It's not really an attractive storefront. I feel like if we're going to go invest, you know, someone's going to invest many deep six figures in this, like making that first for retail piece. feel like it's part of that renovation, not separate from it, would be the direction that I would take. So I'm not, again, I know the building is probably, you know, I don't think it's, it's purely about design improvement at this point for me, frankly, which is kind of true for, frankly, all three tonight, to be honest. Let's, you know, that's just where we are.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Okay.
[Kit Nichols]: I agree with everything that's been said, I, I'm sort of on the fence about this one as well. But I don't think anything I mean, I recognize that it's easy for me to sit here and say this, but I don't think anything is made worse by a little more time and thought. And, and we've got kind of one shot to get this right. And it seems like let's make sure it fits in with the rest of the neighborhood in a historically sensitive way. So I agree with Doug.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Before I jump over to Peter, would it be helpful to have a site visit if we determine this building significant and just to see what's there?
[Doug Carr]: I don't think I need to get into it. I kind of think it's, I mean, it's, it's basically a gut renovation, right?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And on the inside, I mean, yeah, they're saying they're going to keep some of the existing building, but by and large, most of the buildings coming down, it's, yeah. most of the house in the back is yeah the front section uh staying you know whether that's it up or not you know through some through some renderings out there and there's some information on the drawings but like
[Jennifer Keenan]: I mean, I think the house is the least interesting part of this.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Frankly, I mean, it's sort of we're getting to the point where I mean, I look at it as we're getting to the point where South Medford, some of the oldest buildings are being phased out, right? So like we had a couple that were nearby this location. This is one that's on the commercial strip. Is it? you know, do I believe that it would be preferably preserved? No. So I believe it's just sort of getting its day here. But, you know, and the design, you know, I've seen the design. So like, I know what's going there. But, you know, I, I just it's, it's tough. It's a tough call. It's like one that I would be on the ice to just like all of you guys. So
[Jennifer Keenan]: Well, I think one thing that I didn't notice, and I appreciate whoever, I think it was Luke that pointed it out with the roof, you know, because on one one hand, it's like, OK, do you keep the gable? But then, you know, they went to the Mansard, which is where Corner Yoga is. And I appreciate what Doug said about incorporating the front part where they did on that, where it's all the same kind of look. Maybe it was brick at one point or whatever, but that building looks more cohesive for sure.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: It's sort of interesting that you guys picked up on the roof language. What I picked up on is actually the loss of the double bay on the front. I thought that was sort of an unusual feature. And I was like, oh, they're going from a front facade that has some sort of articulation, even though it's set back to just a flat, plain wall. So I was like, oh, maybe that might be something to say. But I'm not really worried about it. I don't necessarily need to echo the changes that were there. Buildings change all the time.
[Peter Miller]: Agreed 1 thing I was wondering about in those renderings was. How accurate they are in terms of the brick facade, because. It could be that, you know, they just kind of. put a brick pattern on there and didn't have time to put some of the detailing that's on the existing one, like the coins or whatever. So I was wondering about that. And I was also wondering, this is more of a kind of a zoning question, maybe for Doug.
If they're going to this much effort, I was just wondering, Why stick with one floor on the streetscape? I know it blends in with the adjacent buildings having these little one-story brick nodules on the front. Isn't this an area of potential densification? I mean, it's a kind of a major street corner. It just seems odd that somebody would put all this money into it, but not try to go up on that second floor over the front building.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Or at least bring it forward somehow and gain some square footage on that second floor.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I don't know. I think that isn't a consideration, but there's also other considerations that I'm sure the The owners, like, they may have said, or if they were before zoning relief or anything, like, they may have said, you know, you've got to keep it back with the other buildings that are along the street. So, like, even though they have 1 low. Front taxpayer blocks at the street level, they may have had to step the bell buildings back or keep the buildings back as is to not create more nonconformity in that front.
[Peter Miller]: Yeah, I was wondering about that. Like, I don't know if they're trying to seek zoning really. I mean, the gentleman is here. He's good.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, yeah, no, I did for not if you want to. If you want to unmute yourself. Let me see if I have to do that.
[SPEAKER_10]: Good morning. Good afternoon, everyone. Sorry. I have your name and address for the record just for yes, my name is Fernand Lewis addresses 287 289 Main Street.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: All right, we just had some clarification. We were looking for some direction on two things, I think, at this moment. One, I think the simpler one to answer is, is there a reason why you didn't bring the proposed building more forward? And then the second one was the accuracy of the proposed plans for the forward section, which is the little brick one-story taxpayer block, if you plan to do anything with that.
[SPEAKER_10]: Yes, to answer the first question, it had to do with zoning and regulation based off the, we did talk to Scott at the time when he was part of Medford Building Commissioner, and as well as Daniel Evan, and we weren't allowed to bring it forward because of setbacks.
[SPEAKER_10]: And to answer question number two, it has to do with the brick, the brick. I think the architect used some sort of glamorize to make the brick look essentially slightly different than what it is currently. So our plan is to just, we went, we have the brick we planted and keep it exactly the same.
[Peter Miller]: So probably those concrete or whatever they are, stone coins would be there and stuff.
[Doug Carr]: Peter, could you put that rendering on screen? I think it might be helpful for us to, I'll be looking at the same thing. Yeah. Cause I, I think the brick is, there's some infill in that brick. It's not a clean, it's not as clean as the rendering.
[Peter Miller]: Can you guys see this? Yes. So I was just talking about this detail here. Is that marble? What's that?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: It's probably like sandstone or cast concrete. It's probably missing an upper section.
[Jennifer Keenan]: If you look on Google Street View, you can see on the side, there was a door. There's an arch doorway on the side where the car is on Form B. If you look on Google, you can see it and likely an old window that has been thrown. Really pretty arch on the side.
[SPEAKER_10]: And sorry to interrupt and the pet store in the corner has the same thing where it looked like it used to be a window or door.
[Doug Carr]: Would you would you consider a design that takes the brick and tries to marry it to the language of the building behind it rather than being separate? That's what I was saying earlier to try to integrate it rather than make it different, even though they're programmatically different per your plans.
[SPEAKER_10]: Sorry to answer your question. Does that mean putting a facade, because in the building behind it, it's James Hardy, which is cement board. Would that mean putting the cement board on top of the existing brick?
[Doug Carr]: I, I think it might, although the detail I, I haven't thought through the detail. I'm just trying and I think I would ask Peter and Ryan, who I think have probably have more experience with this than I do. But I just wondered if that's. Because the brick is in rough shape, you'd be putting a lot of money to restore that brick and maybe I was saying, well, is it possible you just cover it and make it a different design that is something akin to what's behind it.
I don't know if it's desirable. There's probably a little bit more cost to do that. You trying to get a street view there, Peter?
[Peter Miller]: I'm trying to get there.
[Doug Carr]: Oh, there it is.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: I think that something could potentially be accomplished with some type of cap that mirrors the house on the corner or the building on the corner.
[Unidentified]: I see.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Adding some, you know, corbels could be nice way of, you know, kind of mirroring that design language.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. It's a good idea, Sarah. I think there's options here.
[Unidentified]: Yeah.
[Doug Carr]: Okay.
[Peter Miller]: You guys seen enough?
[Doug Carr]: Yes, that's helpful. Thank you, Peter.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, great. Going back to final comments. Peter, did you have anything else to add beyond what you just, you relayed for questions? Was that the end of?
[Peter Miller]: No, I mean, I like the proposed design as well. And, But I was kind of hung up on the gable thing, too. I mean, I can see there is a contextual argument for the mansard, the nice building down the way there. But it does kind of make a pair, as you suggested, with the adjacent house. And I think you could probably achieve almost the same or equivalent square footage by putting dormers on this, you know, enlarging the dormers on this, probably at less cost. So, but I don't know that for sure. So anyway, I don't, I kind of like the new design. I think it's quite nice and straightforward and, but I'm a little bit hung up on the side by side gables being lost or something anyway.
[Jennifer Keenan]: the NL
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: I think when you have big like long shed dormers like there's on the existing one there's like a small shed dormer but if you were to elongate that that would kind of dilute the I feel like that dilutes like the gable form and if they're trying to gain more of like the living space on the third floor And your options are the longer shed dormer versus the mansard. I think I'd take the mansard, because I think once they elongate that shed dormer, you're just going to dilute the gable anyway. So I think if that was the choice, I'd go mansard. I don't hate the look. It's different, but yeah.
[Jennifer Keenan]: And if you look diagonally across the street on Google, there's a gambrel roof. That doesn't, you know what I mean? Like, so if we lose the gable and gain the mansard, it's still, you know, in line with the street.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, there's a little bit of variety everywhere.
[Jennifer Keenan]: You could make an argument that the house in the middle needs to change to a mansard. And then the three in a row would match.
[Kit Nichols]: This makes me wonder what actually is historically significant about this building. I mean, if you took the front off of it, the retail space with the front off of it, it would look like How many other houses in Medford? And so it actually, to me, I think what makes it interesting and significant is the retail piece at the front. And I like the fact, I like the idea of keeping what is there, there. Because, I mean, that is retaining the streetscape.
And the house in back of it, I mean, I take your point, Ryan, about losing the two bays. But the mansard does fit in. The windows look like eyes in the new design to me, but whatever. But what is significant about this building? What are we trying to preserve?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I mean, it's got to meet one of the, I guess the bottom line is it's got to meet one of the criteria, right? Is it importantly associated with one of our historic persons or events? broad architectural, cultural, political, economic, social history of the City of the Commonwealth, or historically or architecturally important in terms of period style method of building construction or association with an important architect or builder, either by itself or in a context of building. So I would look at that. And what it's got going for it is maybe it's important to tell us the history of the development of South Medford, starting with As sort of a commercial enclave right at the tail end of Mystic Park, right? So mystic. So the reason why I step back for a second, the reason why these houses are on this side of the street, the older houses are on that side of the street is because right across the street, both sides of Harvard Ave, because Harvard Ave did not punch through to Mystic Ave like it does today, was the horse racing track, right? So the older stuff is going to be on that side. But then, you know, you know, it quickly converted over in the early 20th century to these neighborhoods. So I guess it tells a little bit about the development history. But does the building convey the social history and everything else that it's talking about? Not really. It's the economic history. Yeah, yeah, maybe I mean, it does have layers like, you know, that somebody was wealthy enough that they could put on the storefront and generate more revenue that paid it back. And there's some development history here, because you've got this house, you've got another one tucked behind it there. Obviously, we're on one lot at one time.
[Doug Carr]: But it's sounds like people want to continue the conversation.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I mean, worst case is we continue the conversation for 30 days, have a public hearing, hear the public out. I mean, it's the same as Burcelli's, right? Right down the street, the developer there was interested in doing something, going up, changing that building, and we put a delay on it to temporarily pause the process. And Burcelli's decided to stay as a result, right? So.
[Doug Carr]: I didn't think we were that mean.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Uh, well, the developer was sort of didn't want to be caged in there. So he, he walked away, but also decided to stay and reopen. So, I mean, that was that was a win win for both article there. Okay. Any further. Discussion, if not, we'll go to a vote. So there's a motion on the table for significance made by Jen and seconded by Sarah. So a yes vote for significance. We'll go to a public hearing next month. No allows them to move forward with their project. So Jen?
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Doug?
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Peter?
[Peter Miller]: I'm going to say no on this one.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yes. Sarah.
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Luke. Yes. Okay. Five to zero.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Oh, sorry. Five to one. I said to five to one. My brain it's fried. So we will have a public hearing next month.
[Doug Carr]: Okay, great. I think people should just think about. What as as kids said, what are you trying to preserve? And if you want to do something, what does it look like? There's some really good options. We've been talking about tonight and I don't actually don't have a horse in this in this race right now. There's a lot out there. Okay, great.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Next up is. Islamic cultural center of Medford with the update with the house. I don't. Is there somebody here? Oh, there you are. Yes, you're not name is not correct.
[Humayun Morshed]: I know. I know. I'm sorry.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I just wanted to make sure you really were here. All right.
[Humayun Morshed]: Yes. Hi, my name is I'm the trustee of 43 high street. high street and medfit islamic cultural center of medfit so um you know this building is i guess it's quite a almost 300 years old some of the part so we are thinking what's the possibility we can do because um i mean this is pretty really old and we we are thinking renovations or possibility is ground up. So just want to see your thought was the how was the best way we can preserve the history and also we need to improve this building as well.
So we don't have any architect yet. We're working with a couple architect. So just wanna you guys advise, then we're gonna move on the directions.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So you're looking for direction on what the commission might entertain for changes to the existing building?
[Humayun Morshed]: Correct, yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, so just as, um, let me take, let's take a step back for a second. So just so the commission understands the eye of the call house is one of Medford's oldest houses built in the early, early 18th century, although its present form presents in later 18th century architecture, because the three-story federal is very common to that time period. It served as the home of Isaac Hall, who was captain of Medford's militia at the time. Paul Revere inadvertently got directed towards Medford on April 19, 1775, when he almost got captured by patrol on Winter Hill, stopped in Medford first, and then went off to alert the rest of the countryside. So is the Hall family is very important to Medford for its connection to rum, connection to a lot of economic success, connection to slavery. So, and then at the end of the 19th century, Edward Gaffey purchased the building to use as a funeral home. It was a funeral home for more than a little bit over a hundred years. And then ICCM has owned it for how long guys?
[Humayun Morshed]: Since 2018.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: ICCM has received CPC funding, so one of the things I know that the commissioners will support is putting this building in a local historic district to get the design review. That is going to be a push from both CPC, I think, and the Historic District Commission to go back and look at the buildings that they've received funding and protect them. But I think the commission, as you saw tonight, we're pretty open to change. So I think that there is an opportunity. There's a lot of.
I would say. unsympathetic additions to the back of this building that could certainly be changed to accommodate new uses. But I think the goal of the forward half of the building is to see some sort of exterior level preservation inside. We don't have jurisdiction usually on the inside, although there's a good chance if you explore under the existing finishes put on by the later funeral home, chances are there's probably 18th and 19th century finishes still intact under those, what you see on the outside. So think of it like an onion. You're going to be doing a lot of peeling back if you do restoration, but that's a good thing because every once in a while it's good for a complete refresh on a house that age. So as long as you understand some of that may entail putting details back that you uncover. So that's my thought. But I'm open to hearing commissioners comments. Yeah, go ahead Doug.
[Doug Carr]: Yes, what are you hoping to achieve with, you know, are you looking to create more space or alter, like, what is your goal as an organization?
[Humayun Morshed]: Oh, okay, so this is the two piece of building. One is the old house, the other one, the extension. So that we have right now, it is the, we are praying the hall, the extension of it, but it's room by room. is not any open space. So we are planning to open it up, make a, you know, common space for praying. And also the basement, we're going to still keep the funeral home and possibility we can do the small size of kitchen. But mostly as right now, the whole site is the small room by room now. So no, we could do really gathering or, you know, the way we want to pray. So just to want to open it up, make a first floor as a praying service, second and third floor is possible. We could do some the communities, places and also the Islamic school for for younger one year for we can school.
[Doug Carr]: But that sounds like you're living within the volume of the house. You're just reconfiguring the inside, roughly? Right.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah. Okay. I'll just bring this to sort of a thought. Is there any thought about I would, I would give it hard thought on if there is a, if, if the volume is big enough to meet the demands of your. Or your future goals, right? So, if there's a, for example, I know. And I would immediately what immediately came to mind was while you're talking about the limitations of opening up the floor plan that. St. Joseph's has closed, right? So they're an open building with a larger floor plan that may become available in the future, right? So there may be a trade. The benefit to this building being it's a commercial building, right? I could foresee you setting yourself up where you could keep this building and also use it for educational programs. You could rent out the first floor for commercial space. That's income generating towards your you know, towards your larger project, right? So to offset costs and so that the congregation doesn't necessarily have to carry the cost of expansion of, you know, the mosque itself. So I think, you know, I think that you're thinking, you know, need to think hard about those things, but I think you're in the right direction looking for an architect that can sort of bring those ideas to the table and start talking about that.
[Humayun Morshed]: Right, right. Because, I mean, it's pretty costly. We don't, you know, what we can do, we have to do something because the world we have right now is you know, it's pretty limited space we have. So it's, community is growing and we just want to open the third, let's see. So we will hire the architect and we're going to get a couple sets of plan. Let's see which one is the budget come, you know, it's all about the number game. So if it's something we can afford it, then open it up, make a couple of storage. If it's not, then probably just open the space, just we can pray, you know?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Right.
[Humayun Morshed]: So that'll be plan B.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah. You are you currently you mentioned the funeral home. Are you currently having funerals? Yeah. Service and services there.
[Humayun Morshed]: We do that. We do have a service, but we don't keep the body right here. We don't have a fridge. So the body comes. We do the, you know, clean the body and also the prayer services. Then, you know, go to the cemetery.
[Doug Carr]: I think, Ryan, I guess I would suggest if they're considering some pretty significant potential rearrangement of spaces on the inside that your architect probably would need a structural engineer who knows wood frame buildings as well, because there is, I would imagine there'd be some issues there about maybe some bearing walls or maybe posts. I mean, what do you think, Ryan? You've been in that building, obviously.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, there's there's going to be multi generational changes. The rear L, the main block has it. The building was supposedly a salt box that then they changed to a federal. So there's heavy framing there. The L is also later, you know, early 19th century. So and that's butted right up against that concrete block structure. So it's got to be some weird, funky things there. It wouldn't be surprising if you opened up things and they said, ah, there's virtually no framing here, right? So they frame very lightly and you're bound to encounter those issues. So there's definitely anything that you plan for, you probably tack on that 15 to 20% added just as a fail-safe to make sure that you open up those walls and say, oh, look, more problems.
[Peter Miller]: Was there an elevator in this building?
[Humayun Morshed]: Yeah. It's not that real. It's just probably a couple hundred years old, small elevator. You can bring the body.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So it's more like a lift. It's not an ADA compliant elevator.
[Doug Carr]: Clearly not. Is this 1720, Ryan? Is that the year? Over 300 years?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I mean, the lower rooms are probably that old. It's a center chimney building, hall and parlor with potential for a rear L that was a salt box structure. That's what the analysis from uh... the met for historical register says and that the current form is you know obviously they added up quite a bit so i'm sort of intrigued as to how they connected those those major framing members uh... the lower part of the house in one corner i remember seeing a gun stock post that's where the uh... it flares out towards the roof line it's the base that it's literally the base of the tree weather bottom of the post, the top of the post rather, comes out with a tree sort of flared out at the bottom. And that's a very early, that's a very early feature.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: So this is a reminder.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Any other comments, questions?
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Would any CPC funding be able to go to like the facade? So like, as we can see, you know, a lot of the back has been added on or covered up, but there's, you know, extensive documentation of what the facade looked like. Anything that we can hope for for that?
[Doug Carr]: would be nice. I think there's a great possibility for that. I mean, the parsonage down the street, which is only maybe 30 or 40 years older than this one, got significant money from CPC over the years. We're finishing up our cycle tomorrow night, actually, for this year, so it would be the next year unless it was an off-cycle application. But I think the feasibility study That's the 1st step you really got to figure out what you want to do and then divide and conquer. You could face this. This is definitely a feasible project for sure. Um, spread it over the years, you know, structural changes in Syria exterior. But there are the CPC is an excellent source of potential funding for. Certainly the exterior, because your building obviously has a public mission, and that's one of the things that is important for funding buildings, especially religious buildings of any kind, that we want to know that the public has an ability to get in there, which they obviously do.
[Humayun Morshed]: Yeah. So probably next year, you know, we can think about it, you know?
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. The cycle starts in like June, July. That's when you kind of, if you get your plans done in the spring, you can get them kind of figured out and priced and they can start applying for and start talking to Teresa Dupont at the city of Medford, who's actually on this call right now, who's the coordinator for CPC. You would start to have conversations with her. As soon as you know something that you think you feel confident about.
[Humayun Morshed]: Yeah, I think she's the one who actually helped us together with the grant, so thank you for that. And so, especially we need to start with the architect, so do we need to have any regular architect or you have to have someone based on the historical experience? What do you guys think?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I would definitely start with somebody who had historic preservation experience. I would say any normal architect would be a non-starter. I know they're very competent, but you need to plan for the intricacies of multi-generational building here, and they're going to be able to look at that. And most importantly, they might say, oh, let's take a little bit of the sheetrock off to see what's underneath here and be able to peek behind and be like, yeah, look, the original woodwork is here, and this is what we're going to encounter in order to even get to the structure.
So I would definitely be looking in that direction. Most architects, they might charge a little bit more for that service and skill, but it's not, they should be right at par with where everybody else is.
[Kit Nichols]: Ryan, is this like, it must be one of the 10 oldest homes in Linford?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, this is one of the, like when I say there's 12 17th and 18th century buildings, this is one of them.
[Kit Nichols]: I mean, it's rare. The stewarding a building that's so important to not only Medford's history, but actually colonial history, as someone who has gotten herself involved in old building restoration, it's kind of a blessing and a curse. And so I'm just grateful that you've included the historic commission this early in your conversations, because we really want to support what you're trying to do in a way that preserves the history of Medford as well.
[Humayun Morshed]: Oh, absolutely. We love to preserve the history. And I think that's our intention. So we don't want to touch anything until the professionals start. So I think we just started thinking about it. So we're going to first thing, we're going to hire the architect and have a plan reviewed by you guys. As soon as the plan is ready, then we'll send it to you. So we're definitely going to work together. Hopefully next year, we can get some funding also. And let's see what we can do.
[Kit Nichols]: Well, you've come to the right place. I mean, the, the, the, the architects on this, on this committee are, you will not, you will not be steered astray. I say is not an architect.
[Unidentified]: Good.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay. Any other comments from the commissioners? All right. Hearing none, I think we're all set. We'll, um, If you let us know, if you have a preservation architect and get somebody on board, feel free to send us an email, just let us know. If you need advice, wanna ping us on that, feel free to ping us when you're ready to come back with a loose plan and direction, then we're happy to meet with you.
[Humayun Morshed]: Okay, sounds good. Thank you. Very nice to meet you, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, moving forward 2027 meeting dates, commissioners, Jen and I drafted the commission dates for 2027. Any questions, comments, omissions? Did we mess up? I don't think so. Jen's pretty spot on. If not, I'll take a motion to approve that. We'll sort of set our dates and deadlines for next year.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I did take the I think it was in 2024 and change the looking, looking at the calendar and change the date. So I would definitely double check everything.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay. With that caveat warning to approve.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll make a motion to approve since I wrote them.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, a second. Second, kids got it. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His): A roll call vote.
[Kit Nichols]: Jen.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yes. Doug.
[Kit Nichols]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Peter.
[Kit Nichols]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yes. Luke. Yes. Yes. All right, that's approved 6-0. OK, I sent around for 2027 officers and committees, I sent around a list of what I normally prepare. It's both a membership directory so that everybody can get a hold of everybody in case I get hit by a bus. And the second one is all the committees that we have that handle the various aspects If you see something on there and have a question about the particulars, reach out to me. If something looks interesting, like for example, if the design review committee looks good, you want to serve on that for 2027, just let me know. It's easy to set that stuff up for December for approval. Once we have that, I'll be looking at you all year, and I'll just shepherd information your way.
So the one thing is with Jen stepping down, that makes me chair for the December meeting. If somebody wants to consider running for chair position, I'm perfectly happy to be your right-hand man at the vice chair position. If somebody wants to step up, otherwise, if somebody wants to learn how to run the commission from the vice chair seat, happy to have that. And Peter, are you staying on as secretary for 27? Yes. Okay. that exempts you from, just so everybody knows, that exempts Peter from running for chair. So Peter just got himself.
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'll just say that I was chair my second year. And obviously Ryan trained me. And I feel we really just ran it together the whole time I was chair. But I would just say that I wouldn't, Don't be afraid to step up and be chair because there's some benefits in the sense of you can choose to vote or not really. A lot of it's just administrative. emails, communicating with people, and then making sure the documentation gets filed for the meetings. So there's some trade-offs in the sense of, you know, running the meeting versus voting and whatnot. And you guys saw, like, Ryan and I would jockey, like, oh, I feel like voting tonight. OK, you're going to run the meeting, et cetera. Like, it doesn't mean that you can never vote if you'd like to vote and vice versa.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, what would be a huge help is, you know, it's either sometimes running the meeting and doing some of the follow up with demo delay is difficult. So I think definitely having that two person position like the vice chair and the chair sort of switching off really will help. Like I really would like to delegate some of these draft form letters, you know, basically the letters for significance. And to lead up to the public hearing, most of that stuff has been hashed and rehashed. It's just a matter of picking the points of what was said during the meeting.
[Jennifer Keenan]: And most things are very, mostly everything's templated. So it's not, it doesn't take, usually on, you know, either Tuesday morning, the day after the meeting or Friday morning. I mean, Ryan and I will, it won't even take an hour and we just bust out everything. And clear out the permits, send people out their letters, make sure they get to the clerks and to Dennis so that they get filed. And then that's it for the rest of the month and just keeping an eye on the email. And then obviously, typically we would have a call. On Wednesday, so that we could do the agenda, we would usually do it together and then 1 of us emails it off just to make sure that we don't miss anything.
[Doug Carr]: Great who's been doing the permits recently.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Uh, well, I've been doing them, but Luke and Sarah did them once they are trained and how to do it. So now we're going to shepherd it off to Luke and Sarah again.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Okay, and I would just say on that front that when there is a new building commissioner. I would, you know, part of the part of, I think what I enjoyed about this job was. reaching out to the folks in the building department, building relationships with them, and other people at City Hall. And I think that our, I mean, I think we're in a good role, you know, kind of a good rhythm now, but I would say it's just always important to just make sure the guys in the building department know you, Get to know the commissioner just work together because there are partners in this and, um, you know, when people do stuff.
Without permits, or they demo something that they shouldn't. You know, I think in the 9 years I've been on this commission. It really started off very adversarial with different people in the office. And over time, I would say we have a very good working relationship. And I think continuing that on with the next commissioner will be critical.
[Peter Miller]: Is the current commissioner moving on?
[Jennifer Keenan]: So Scott did leave and the previous commissioner, who was Bill Forte, he is back.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Bill's gone.
[Jennifer Keenan]: He's gone as of Friday. OK, he was only coming in once a week, like on Wednesday nights, just to help the guys and kind of keep things moving. And I think probably covered some of the zoning meetings and things. So I'm not sure now. Maybe Teresa or Dennis might know what's happening down there.
[Community Preservation Manager Theresa Dupont]: Yeah, there's an interim building commissioner, I believe from Winchester, Tom Kennedy, who's helping out right now. But we are interviewing, and I believe the interviews, they're in the final stages of second and third round interviews, which is promising.
[Unidentified]: Great.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK. I have that up for 2027 if anybody wants to reach out just, you know, send me an email and we'll start jotting down things on the
[Jennifer Keenan]: And the guys in the building apartment, they'll email us or sometimes they would call me or Ryan and be like, hey, there's a permit in the queue. They're asking to move it along. What's going on? Again, it's like they'll reach out if they're getting heat from a property owner or vice versa. It's like, hey, we have a permit. We put a note in the system. We haven't heard anything. Do you guys know what's going on? they'll reach out to the homeowner if they're not getting back to us as well. So it's definitely a good relationship in that respect. Because just as much as we like to keep our queue of permits clean, they do too.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, so we'll forge ahead with that for next meeting. Uh, and then the only last thing I have for new business 33 Cape and Street. They emailed us about a demo permit. I they just said, you know, what do we have to fill out for a demo permit? And I wasn't clear whether they meant the garage or the house or both. Or, you know, so they never got back to me, so that may come up so.
[Kit Nichols]: Does that building belong to Tufts?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I'm not sure that's a good question. I'm just going to make a note. Is it tough? question mark. I guess that would explain why they would try to take it down to the garage if it's just like they don't want the liability of having an accessory outbuilding for their occupants. But I'm not, I'm not sure. I'll let you guys know though. Okay, that's it for new business. Is there anything else for new business that I forgot that wasn't anticipated or we move on?
All right, then I'm going to hopefully fly through most of these. So vacant seats, I sent out a notice that we were looking for new members. Got some promising leads, some people that were interested in just reviewing what we do before they make any sort of commitment. So hopefully they're enjoying all of the full breadth of everything that we do for this commission, because they're getting it all tonight. Hopefully something good will come out of that.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Did you check with Lisa in the office?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I did check with Lisa, yep.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Because I know the city put out a couple posts recently as well, just in general, just looking for all boards and commissions.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, zoning. Doug, is there anything upcoming on zoning? I know we rewrote that section on the zoning preliminarily, but we were going to talk to Danielle 1st before we.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah, we got it. That's definitely next in our list. We actually had a meeting last week where we started putting. All of the zoning cleanup stuff in various buckets and I think the historical 1 is certainly 1 of the largest, but it's going to be. kind of a quiet rest of the year on the zoning because the RFP for the next zone for the zoning rewrite is still out there. They haven't even had interviews yet for the three years for the next person if they change horses or if they keep in this. So it's going to be a good, you know, we're not going to be We had such a, it was a total like. 1000 miles an hour for most of 2026 and then then it's, you know, we finished boss and finish square. Uh, but we're, you know, we're going to be looking at Tufts next, but it's going to be. We won't have the consultant until the spring, so we're going to be looking at, you know, kind of just. doing our homework, looking at the Dover Amendment, things like that.
But next year, most of the oxygen is going to be consumed by the high school project, which obviously is on this list as well.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Any questions for Doug? All right, seeing none, we'll move forward. 321 Winthrop Street, we had a site visit to that building. I think those of you who are there probably maybe just best summed it up as wow. It's such a, such an impressive building. I, I think it has so much potential. There's so many options and I, I commend them solidly for thinking outside the box for a whole bunch of options but they're. I think it's good to just keep pressing forward with pressing them harder on this project because they can do better. Now I will say, I think, I don't know, did you see my note about they're getting some donations from Suffolk about the potentially for the cost so that that may be driving the bus but that should not be the only reason why we drive in one direction.
[Doug Carr]: Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His): Now they need a feasibility study for that building that in the whole site that is it's not a blank slate, but they need they need to think about every possibility there and I just don't think they've done that yet.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Right. So I think I We are, I think John Clemson did want to go back and take interior photos because it is worthy. There's so much decorative woodwork and all different finishes and fun stuff. So fireplaces to die for, it's just unbelievable.
[Peter Miller]: The woodwork's unbelievable in there. It's so intricate.
[Doug Carr]: Did you have some photos you guys? I know it was dark, but do you have anything you can share? Not now, but just- I don't.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I don't yet but I but I will I promise we're planning on going back over there as ASAP so I will let us all know when that is hopefully it's in the daytime so we can all look at it if we can yeah would it like a Saturday work better for you guys I mean if I or is it like or a weekday morning like early morning like eight or something They did say that the bartender's there after 11, so she's fine with letting us in whenever. I know that doesn't do much for you guys that might work in Boston or Lawrence. I forget where your main office is, but like, you know.
[Doug Carr]: It's now north end over, but I'm in Boston three days a week.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Oh, okay.
[Doug Carr]: So just set something up and I'll figure it out. Okay.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: All right. Yeah. Maybe I can take you guys on video tour. We'll just zoom it.
[Doug Carr]: I would love that.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I mean, that's also an option, right? I didn't even think of that one.
[Doug Carr]: I think it might be Blair Witch, though, in the basement.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I mean, there were some creepy things. It was very Stranger Things-ish. They had, for lights upstairs, they had Christmas lights. So it was, that's all I could think about was Stranger Things.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: I was really, like, struck by how it looked like they had just left one day and everything was in its place. Like, someone was working on a loft. for one of the doors and it was just like taken apart. And there was like, you know, lubricant from the 70s and like materials there that, you know, an old furniture, I don't know, Chernobyl happened or something. It looked a little bit like that. Yeah. And all the decorative stuff was still there. You know, all the drapery was, was Seemingly 70s. It was, yeah.
[Peter Miller]: Yeah, it was like the upside down in there though.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I mean it really, it really did look like they built the hall and then got excited super excited about the hall and just abandoned ship is that now the buildings, the house is the house. It's wild to me. I do think if they can't get off the ground with this big project, they really could just start small, do little things like fix the front porch and paint the deck and refinish the front door and then start thinking about the inside. It's small baby steps.
So we'll work on that. Medford High School. They emailed us. I've been trying to get information out of Medford School Committee and the contact for the school department about the history of the existing building and they've been completely unresponsive. And this morning they asked us if they wanted us to come talk to our board about the new building. not anything about the old building.
[Doug Carr]: So, um, why are we being stonewalled this 106 thing?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: We're being stonewalled because the project is moving forward with or without any sort of, uh, with or without any sort of, uh, like it's moving forward regardless of anything that stands in its way. That I think is the general consensus of that committee. So like, Our only thing here is the section 106 review. That's, you know, and I want to get the MHC inventory form in. I just don't even know if it will make a difference.
[Doug Carr]: Look, we all know that this project is going to happen. I don't disagree with that, but that doesn't mean the city of Medford should ignore their own process here. That building still needs to be cataloged like any other building in this city. It should not be just torn down at the earliest possible date because somebody's in a hurry here.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Would it be appropriate to, I guess we can ask the question, would it be appropriate to use some of our budget funding to request resources? For example, I can do a Freedom of Information Act request for that information to force them to come up with the documentation. What we're looking for specifically are files that should exist. the school committee records and meeting minutes of the discussion of the building of the original high school. Those are permanent records. Those should never have been thrown out or discarded or lost. So I'm assuming they have them. They just are unwilling to give us access to them because I've requested at three times, and I think three times is enough. But I could do a freedom of information request, however.
Yeah, it's a terrible way to go, and it could cost us money, right? I'm looking to just get access so we can take pictures of the records, get the information we need for the consultants, and move forward. A FOIA request, they could just turn around and say, yeah, it's going to take us this much and this much money to do it.
[Jennifer Keenan]: And who are you asking?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: The school committee. Everything's through the school committee, right?
[Jennifer Keenan]: I would just email Nina.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Well, the mayor, this person that I'm talking to came down from the mayor. That's who she told me as the head of the school committee to email, and they've been completely unresponsive. So maybe I'll just go back to the mayor.
[Doug Carr]: The drawings of this building are probably somewhere in the Vogue somewhere. I mean, they're in the archives.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Well, they exist at the state archives. They've told us that they'll give us access to it, to the drawings. That's not a problem. It's mainly the history leading up to the decision to move the high school from Medford Square to this site, and then the details of construction, who built it, you know, what were the numbers, any problems during construction, are there photos, there should be, you know, this is a big project for Medford, right, so there should be construction photos, site prep, all that good stuff, so.
[Doug Carr]: No, that's all good point, but I, what Once we get into January, February, this train's going to go about 1,000 miles an hour. And the sooner we can get some headway, and this is a good time to do it, if we can get the end of the year, just to get, you know, like, if we need to spend some money, I think we should.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I mean, we've already, this is the only thing that's holding up the MHC Form B, or A, depending on what they do. So, because there's no, there'll be no contextual information. That doesn't mean necessarily that we can't You know, try to assume, but. Like, I mean, I think everybody understands, like, the high school was built up there because it was convenient. The high school in Medford Square was aging. It burnt down. It was just. easy to do, move the building, but, you know, there could have been, it could have been much more contentious than that. It could have been, you know, it was, it too was a lot of money, right? You know, so.
[Doug Carr]: It was. It was also taking pieces of fells, which was, I'm sure that would be a big fight if they tried to do that today. You know, that, that was a different time.
[Peter Miller]: Hey, Ryan, did you get an email today from a guy named William Pipicelli?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, that's, that's what's prompting.
[Peter Miller]: Communications director.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, that's what's prompting this. What's mind blowing is that he's the guy that I believe that I've been emailing about asking for information. And he said he would check and then ghosted me. So this is sort of like, oh, not even like, oh, we're circling back to, we wanna talk to you about the new building, like just a complete ignoring of that request.
[Peter Miller]: I mean, they're all extremely busy over there. There's extremely short staff. They're all pulling their hair out over there. It's probably not malicious, but. There was every board in the city today. I mean, I wonder if it would be worthwhile.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: meeting with him just to establish a rapport you know i mean we can just say yes and bring this information with you yeah yeah i would just say that yes we want to meet and we want these records so that we can move forward with this this section 106 process yeah we probably just don't even know what that means or something Or, or, or what I believe may have happened, what happened with, you know, what may have happened is that they've already submitted it and they've gotten their approval for Mass Historical without comments from us. So, unless if there's no inventory form, Mass Historical is just gonna assume that they don't, you know, there's no, there's no, you know, it's not a historic resource.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Did you email Mass Historical? You should.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, but I don't.
[Jennifer Keenan]: You have a contact there, don't you?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Well, I do, but I'm even having difficulty reaching them for survey and planning grants, so they they too are pulling their hair and are overworked and there's only a handful of them. So we're really in a pickle here.
[Jennifer Keenan]: What if you went in person to a school committee meeting?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I could do that. So I'll start with the mayor again and see if I can be pushed a little bit.
[Jennifer Keenan]: She is- I would just email Nina and say, hey, this person you told me to talk to isn't getting back to me. Is there, who's the next person I can go to?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Just play them.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. We have friends in City Hall, you know, several of them on this call.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah. Okay. All right, so it seems like we'll just ask him, though. We'll say, yes, we're interested, but we're also seeking information. Yeah. You know, can we get back to that and then we'll meet with you? So, OK. I don't have any update on properties under demo delay. cross street. The gate is going back in. They're almost done with all the stones. I think they had some very minor cleanup, but I think they're pretty much done for the season. The gate has one side of the gate was remade. The other side is the original gate. It's all been painted, so as soon as that's up, I'll take some pictures and send it out and post on the website.
Hastings Heights, we're just waiting for Mass Historical to comment on the forms, hoping to wrap up by the end of the year. I submitted the grant for the survey and planning grant for Medford Square North. That's also done. And the only other thing for old business is the approval of the meeting minutes.
[Peter Miller]: Which there were two of, right?
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, there's only one right now because I forget. I don't know, were you at the first meeting? No, right, okay, so you didn't take meeting minutes. I may have to watch the meeting minutes and conjure up some things unless somebody wants to volunteer to watch the meeting minutes. What day was that, Ryan? You might have taken notes, Doug.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: I have the transcripts from my blog writing, if you would like it.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, we met on October 5, so either one of you, if you want to format it like Peter's meeting minutes and just, you know, if you want to send it to me and see if it matches my notes, that's fine. Those were only hearings that day, so. Okay, so we just have the approval meeting minutes of the meeting from the 19th, right? Yeah, the 19th. So I'll take a motion to approve those meeting minutes.
[Doug Carr]: So moved.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And a second?
[Doug Carr]: I'll second.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, second. All right, going around the room as I see you, Peter.
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Doug?
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Jen?
[Jennifer Keenan]: I'm going to abstain. I was not at that meeting.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: You were not there, yep. And Sarah?
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Luke? Yep. Okay, so that is 4-0-1, right? Because I don't vote.
[Jennifer Keenan]: 5-0-1.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, and then that's it for today, unless we have anything that we missed. The most important thing is that Jen is departing. Thank you, Jen, for eight years of wonderful service. Nine. Nine? Oh, it's nine?
[Jennifer Keenan]: Oh, it's nine. Nine, I was eight as chair.
[Kit Nichols]: Oh, eight as chair, right. So you could have made it a perfect decade.
[Doug Carr]: Yeah. Ryan, when we have this dinner, it has to be a Jen roast. Oh, jet roast, oh, okay.
[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: That's what I'm having.
[Doug Carr]: It's lightning, of course.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: He doesn't put anything in those drawers.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Well, it's, yeah, I think that's the... I'm sad, I'm not gonna lie, I'm a little sad, but also, you know, I don't know, I think there just comes a time when it's like, yep, I'm just ready to do something else.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And you're going to step into the next role and be super motivated and get stuff done.
[Jennifer Keenan]: We'll see if they'll have me.
[Doug Carr]: She could be coming my way. Yep.
[Jennifer Keenan]: We'll see.
[Doug Carr]: I'm trying to work on that.
[Jennifer Keenan]: If not, there's a plan B. There always is with you. You know, in my spare time. Clark's like, which of the 14 things that you do outside of your real job are you going to quit? I'm like, Yeah, not going to happen.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Now you can come to the meetings and just be the enthusiastic neighbor being like, yeah, that one's an awesome house, or nah, it's not such a great house.
[Unidentified]: It should be.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Everything around me is built in the 60s. Nothing ever happens with the 20 houses around me. They're all too new. Yeah.
[Doug Carr]: All right, well, let's get that dinner date locked down soon, and we can make some plans.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Thank you everybody. Thank you for a great. Great 9 years. I appreciate it. I've learned so much and I'm. You will all do good things on this commission. I am not. I'm not worried. I feel like it's being left in good hands and. You know, step up and help Ryan and take it to the next to the next generation.
[Doug Carr]: And we need we need more people.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, you definitely need more people.
[Jennifer Keenan]: Yeah, I mean, it's all still help spread the word. Of course, sure.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: This will just so everybody's aware. This is absolutely my last year. August of this coming year is 20 years on the commission. So.
[Doug Carr]: That's when you were 12.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: That's enough. No, I was the youngest serving historical commissioner. I was probably one of the youngest board members at 18. When McGlynn appointed me, I mean, there's a somewhere out there, there's an article about it. Allison wrote about it on her blog back in the day when she was keeping track of news. So here we are 20 years later. All right, thanks all. I'll take a motion to adjourn the meeting until next month.
[Doug Carr]: So moved.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Second. Second. For Jen's final motion. All right, I'll go around as I see you, Peter.
[Peter Miller]: Yes.
[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Jen. Yes. Doug. Yes. Sarah. Yes. Luke. Yes, it yes, and I am a yes. So, 70 and the affirmative. Thank you all have a good night.
[Kit Nichols]: Thanks. Everybody.
[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Good night. Thanks everyone.