Traffic Commission 11/10/26

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3.8-flash from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The Traffic Commission approved several parking variances, stop sign additions, accessible parking spaces, and regulatory language for parking enforcement fines. The commission tabled a proposed roadway and bicycle lane plan on Boston Avenue associated with Tufts University's Pachyderm Place project following extensive public comment.

  1. 1:17 Approval of Minutes — Approved the minutes of the September 8, 2026 meeting.
  2. 2:23 Permit Parking Variance: 359 Boston Avenue — Approved resident permit parking variances on Bellevue Street and Fairmont Street for a student residing on metered Boston Avenue.
  3. 8:38 Permit Parking Variance: 9 Edward Place — Tabled a request for a second-vehicle parking variance on Edward Street because the applicant was not present.
  4. 12:50 Permit Parking Variance: 429 Main Street — Approved a G-zone permit parking variance for an essential hospital employee living on Main Street.
  5. 19:56 Permit Parking Variance: 305 Riverside Avenue — Approved a parking variance on Honeywell Avenue for an applicant whose residential building provides only one off-street space per unit.
  6. 23:31 Stop Signs: Fairfield Street at Lincoln Street — Approved installing stop signs on Fairfield Street to create an all-way stop at the Lincoln Street intersection based on engineering support and neighbor petitions.
  7. 25:58 Veteran Meter Parking Permit — Approved creating an annual $25 metered parking permit for Medford veterans, requiring certification from the veterans services director and City Hall purchase.
  8. 41:26 15-Minute Parking: 34 Salem Street — Approved moving a 15-minute parking space to the front of Dunkin' at 34 Salem Street and converting the previous 15-minute space at the corner back to metered parking.
  9. 48:12 Stop Sign: Elliott Street at Trout Avenue — Approved installing a stop sign on the one-way portion of Elliott Street approaching Trout Avenue and Kenway Road to establish an all-way stop.
  10. 51:14 Pachyderm Place Boston Avenue Improvements — Tabled for one month the street redesign and cross-section plan for Boston Avenue adjacent to Tufts University's 664-bed dormitory project. Bicycle advocates and residents urged the commission to pause for further design alternatives, protected bike lanes, and coordination with an ongoing corridor study.
  11. 2:10:30 Accessible Parking Space: 132 Monument Street — Approved a designated on-street accessible parking space in front of 132 Monument Street to facilitate vehicle transfers for a disabled resident.
  12. 2:12:37 Accessible Parking Space: 48 Chipman Street — Approved an on-street accessible parking space at 48 Chipman Street for a disabled veteran.
  13. 2:17:49 Accessible Parking Space: 49 Bradshaw Street — Tabled an accessible parking space application for 49 Bradshaw Street pending clarification on whether the applicant has access to their private driveway.
  14. 2:22:29 Accessible Parking Space: 36 Evans Street — Approved an on-street accessible parking space in front of 36 Evans Street to accommodate frequent medical transportation needs.
  15. 2:26:50 Parking Violations and Schedule of Fines — Approved regulatory language prohibiting parking on city streets with expired or missing inspection stickers and registrations or beyond posted time limits, and formally affirmed the existing schedule of parking fines.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Traffic Commission

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay. All right. Good evening. Tonight is the November 2026 Traffic Commission meeting. I'm Lieutenant Hynett. I'll be here in the, I guess, doing the roll. Yeah, kind of running the show here with the Zoom. We also have, uh, to my right, your left, I have, uh, Alva Erickson, the, uh, traffic commission secretary. And then we also have a deputy chief Paul Covino, uh, with the other members of the board want to introduce themselves quick.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Let me give her in commissioner of public works, Alicia hunt and the director of energy. Oh my gosh, sorry. Planning development and sustainability.

[Jim Silva]: Jim Silva resident.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. I think we also have other people in here. We have Todd Blake, who's representing the traffic engineers department and Sarah McDermott, who is the director of parking in the city of Medford. At the beginning, I'd like to see if we can open the meeting by approving the minutes of the September 8th, 2026 meeting. Is there a motion to approve? I motion. Deputy chief motions. Is there a second?

[Jim Silva]: Second.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay. Jim second. All those in favor of roll call vote.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McKibbin?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Uh, deputy chief to be no.

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: That's for for for our for the affirmative affirmative. None of the negative. The minutes of the September 26 26 minutes are approved. There were no minutes for October 13th as the meeting was canceled. Yes, thank you, Rob. No, no minutes for the October meeting because it was canceled. Um Okay, so under new business, 2026 dash, is that where we're starting from? Yeah. 2026-50 permit parking variance. Samara McVay, 359 Boston Ave, unit two for Fairmount or Bellevue.

Mr. and Mrs. McVay, if you're on here. Let me see.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I see them raising their hands. Do you want me to unmute them?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, please. I couldn't see them.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I know it's hard in that room.

[SPEAKER_08]: Fantastic. Thank you very much. Thank you, sir. I am Samara McVeigh's father representing her.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Do you have anything you'd like to say or?

[SPEAKER_08]: Sure, I can just tell you that she is a student at Tufts University. She's currently living at 359 Boston Avenue in the second unit. She garages a car in Medford, but she's unable to get a parking permit because you can't permit in her house on Boston Avenue. The two adjacent streets are Fairmont and Bellevue, and we're asking if she can get a permit for those two streets.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Uh, if you could, could you pull up the map?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: We just confirm is the car registered in Medford? Yep.

[SPEAKER_08]: It's registered in garage in Medford. That's correct. Okay.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Did they send any appropriate paperwork out with them? Just a request. She doesn't have to send the registration. She would bring that to the parking department upon approval. Okay.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Our system won't work if it's not registered in Medford.

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, absolutely. Yep, it is registered there.

[Unidentified]: You can get one or the other, right?

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, so there's the map. So all of the spaces on Boston Avenue are metered, so you can't park there if you're a resident. And so Bellevue Avenue and Fairmont Street, I guess Bellevue Street and Fairmont Street, those are the two where she could park if she were to receive a Medford parking permit.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Sarah is Sarah on the, on the zoom.

[SPEAKER_08]: Unfortunately, she's not she's at her cross country practice tonight. I'm sorry. Okay. The parking department.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Oh, sorry. Oh, sorry. Okay. Yes. Sarah, let me say, I think I made her a co host. That's. Sarah McDermott. Can you tell us how many permits are on that street?

[Unidentified]: In one of both of them so we can decide. Yeah, give me just a second.

[Emily O'Brien]: Recording in progress.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Well, we don't need a minute because there's also, we've started selling 2027 permits, so I've got to. Make sure I don't include those. Well, I guess I maybe should, but I don't want to double count any that are at the same address.

[Todd Blake]: While we wait, can I ask, does your daughter have use of those garages that were seen in the picture?

[SPEAKER_08]: She does not unfortunately, yeah, the ones, the white ones, she does not. Those are not part of her rent.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: So, just something I've learned recently about toughs. Everybody is that the juniors and seniors of this class are the last. Students who, if they live off campus will be able to buy a permit to park overnight on campus. So freshmen and sophomores, once they are able to. You know, move off campus, or they do move off campus. They won't be able to buy any passes the park on Tufts campus overnight. Just FYI.

[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, that's correct. And that's actually in effect for the current juniors and seniors as well.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Oh, they told me otherwise. Sorry. Yeah, seniors were able to, but. So, can I ask a question?

[Jim Silva]: I believe those 2 stories, the G zone as well.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Bellevue and Fairmont was it?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Bellevue is and yeah, you're correct Jim. They are so either 1 would allow for parking on multiple streets. I'm sure Jim was probably about to say and for Bellevue, I've currently got 6 permits. For residents who live on Bellevue. And Fairmont.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, is there, the papers are in order, is there anyone that would like to make a motion on this at all?

[Unidentified]: Yeah, I motion to support it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, Deputy Chief Covino, motion to support.

[Jim Silva]: I'll second.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Approve.

[Jim Silva]: I'll second.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Jim Silva, second. Alva, could you please call the roll?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: All right, four in the affirmative, none in the negative. Is it for Bellevue or Fairmont? Both.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Both. Both.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Both.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both. Both

[SPEAKER_08]: Sounds great. Thank you very much, everyone.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Very good. Okay. 2026-51 permit parking variance, Shandana Shrestha, 9 Edward Place for Edward Street. Is Shandana in? Trying to see if I can see it. I apologize. If you can raise your hand, that would help out.

[SPEAKER_18]: I don't see.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Well, that's the case. Would there be a motion to table this for the next meeting?

[Jim Silva]: Could I ask a question? I believe that this is Edward's place, and I believe she actually was here last year. Is this, she received a variance, I believe, on Edward Street.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes, it's for Edward Street. Why would she need to come back?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right. If she got a variance last year, our policy is she shouldn't have to come back every year. That would make this meeting insane. It's for her second vehicle.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: That's true. If she didn't, if she, if she bought it for this year.

[Charlie Hartnett]: She's for her second vehicle, everyone.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So she wants a second one. So she has one variance and she's looking for a second variant. Yep.

[Jim Silva]: and there isn't any parking on Edwards Place, is that correct?

[Charlie Hartnett]: I'm trying to look at it in my head.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Todd? She says there is a parking spot on Edwards Place, but it's only for one car. One car, yeah. And who lives there?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is that building 9 Edwards Street right there as well? That's on the corner. I'm assuming that building probably uses it. Todd, can you see if that's 9 Edwards Street right there?

[Todd Blake]: Unfortunately, it's hard to see down the driveway. I'll check out the house.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, that might be a tough sell. I don't know.

[Unidentified]: Yeah, we've dealt with this a number of times. That's 40.

[Charlie Hartnett]: So why is it that it's all the way down?

[Unidentified]: Is that the only place? And she's at 9 Edmund Street. number eight is back here so nine is probably this one that my curse is over so eight's right there so nine's probably this one

[Jim Silva]: I believe the configuration in that location does not have any parking, and that was the reason why she was here last year. Just thought I'd mention.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: I still think we should probably table it. We don't know if circumstances changed. That's why she's not here tonight.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there a motion for a table at all?

[Tim McGivern]: I'll make the motion.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, uh, Mr. given motions. Is there a 2nd?

[Jim Silva]: I'll second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Jim Silva. 2nd, could you please call the roll? Commissioner given.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yes, commissioner hunt. Yes. Commissioner Silva.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley. Yes. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't want to nothing. The item is tabled.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Okay Uh, next item up for business is 2026 5 to permit parking variants. Kristen Rude 4 29 Main Street. Let me see if Kristen. Kristen Rude. Okay, I will unmute you asking you and I'm you.

[SPEAKER_25]: Hello. Can you hear me?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes,

[SPEAKER_25]: So I am asking for variance because I am a speech pathologist at an acute care hospital. I work at UMass Memorial in Worcester, and I'm considered an essential employee. And so my concern is that I live on Main Street where no permits are required, but there's a very small section where cars are parking. And when winter comes, I'm concerned about snowstorms, the availability of parking on that street, as well as You know, I'll be, my hours are 7 to 5.30, so I leave by 6 in the morning and home by about 6.30 at night. So shoveling out my car in the dark on Main Street concerns me, given that road and the traffic on that road. And so I'm asking for variants so that I could park on one of the side streets for safety and honestly more efficiency for getting to and from work especially in the event of potential snowstorms.

[Charlie Hartnett]: What side street specifically were you looking for?

[SPEAKER_25]: Marion Street's the one that's closest to me.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: She lives the side of the Tufts Creative School.

[SPEAKER_20]: It's a gas station and then Marion Street.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So given that this Marion Street, that side of Main Street is in the G zone, the question is not which street she would get a permit for, but whether she'd get a G zone permit, right?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Ms. Ruud, let me ask. So your concern is that you're going to be ticketed for permit parking during the winter?

[SPEAKER_25]: No, my concern is, so right now I park on Main Street. You'll see that block there, there are spots, there's probably seven cars can park on the side of the street that I'm on, maybe five on the other side. And I'm concerned both about the availability of parking in the winter with snowstorms, as well as safety, my own safety, shoveling out my car at four in the morning on Main Street. Also, given that, you know, getting home, I work for days a week in a row. So those are potentially.

Long evenings trying to find somewhere to park if there are no spots available on main street.

[Charlie Hartnett]: The only concern is that kind of. everyone on Main Street will probably have the same exact issue because of the fact that during a declared snow emergency, permit parking is lifted and people cannot park on Main Street as well. And they do have to park on the side streets, which is, I just wanna give that clarification for everyone in the room, is that this wouldn't be, this would be everyone on Main Street having this issue.

[SPEAKER_25]: It's not so much the snow emergencies, just as in general, when there is snow that requires shoveling, even maybe more, especially when it's not an emergency. Where it's it's.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, I don't know if any of the commissioners have anything to say.

[Jim Silva]: I have a quick question. The availability of the driveway and the parking back.

[SPEAKER_25]: It's not available. There is one spot that they allow a tenant on the second floor to use, but otherwise, there are no cars allowed to park back there, unfortunately.

[Jim Silva]: I have a question for Director McDermott. In Tufts Square, there is a parking lot that is in front of the stores. Is that a rated parking lot?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: That is just free parking. It's kind of 1st, come 1st served. It's still, you know, you can't park for more than 48 hours, just like any other spot in Medford, but there's no meters or other restrictions in that area that I know of.

[Jim Silva]: So, that's basically the other, the only other location.

[Todd Blake]: Correct Jim, that's about 415 feet from the house.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Any other commissioners, or if anyone would like to make a motion or anyone. From the audience, if you want, raise your hand.

[Tim McGivern]: I just had a question and it's kind of for you, Charlie. So is the compelling reason here. And I guess the, the proponent to is the compelling reason here work schedule. Is that what I'm hearing? Because it wouldn't be the snow emergency because everybody has that problem on the snow emergency.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I, I believe so. I believe that is the issue.

[Tim McGivern]: Okay, I just wanted to make sure I understood that from the applicant standpoint, Kristen, that's so you basically your work schedule and availability of parking on Main Street.

[SPEAKER_25]: Yeah, and I don't have the flexibility that a lot of people might have to work from home during inclement weather either. I have to go in.

[Tim McGivern]: Got it. All right. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there anyone who would like to make a motion?

[Jim Silva]: I make a motion to approve. We have approved other folks for this variance on Main Street.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, Jim Silva's motion. Is there a second?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'll second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I'll second. Alva, could you please call the roll?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley? Oh, well, in the affirmative.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. The motion passes. Uh, uh, Mr. Once you, uh, what is it? Once you get notification from you, Alva?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: No, she can go to the parking department or the parking department.

[Charlie Hartnett]: See, Sarah. and she'll give you your variance.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: So long as your address on your registration and everything's in order already. Garage and Medford, and you need a proof of address, great.

[SPEAKER_25]: It is, yeah.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Thank you so much, I appreciate it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, thank you, Ms. Rood. Okay, next item, 2026-53, permit parking variance. Adam Hecker, 305 Riverside Ave, 4 Honeywell Ave. Adam Hecker, I am unmuting you. Go ahead, sir, you got the floor.

[SPEAKER_09]: Hello, my name is Adam hacker. I recently moved into apartment at 3 or 5. Riverside, I'm asking to for a parking variance on seeing as directly across from me. I'm unable to park in the parking lot there. Because my roommate is taking up the 1 spot that we have. I work at mass general hospital. I unfortunately, I'm still at work. and there are times where I need to get to work rather quickly. I'm also, as the last participant said, worried about the snow, but I guess you guys kind of answered that.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, so again, if everyone will be looking on the side streets for parking anyways during a declared snow emergency, but obviously Riverside Ave, there's no parking on it. Does anyone from the audience have any questions? Any of the commissioners? Would any commissioner like to make a motion?

[Tim McGivern]: What was that? Charlie, any issues with parking capacity on Honeywell? Do we have any issues with that?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Sarah, could you answer that? I don't know if you can or not.

[SPEAKER_09]: I'd like to say I do rarely see that.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: But I know that so yeah, so we've got 8 permits from these brand house at least and then it looks like. Oh. Okay, those are spray house. We've got about 20 to 2530 permits, including visitor permits and some households have 2 visitor permits. So. Yeah, total between about 25 and 30.

[Tim McGivern]: And those driveways that I see, is it a street with driveways?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, they have driveways on Honeywell. Okay, I don't know about every house, but.

[Tim McGivern]: Yeah, but there are a good number with, and you do not have a parking space in your building.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: No, I do not that building just gives 1 space per unit. We've, we've had someone from that building before asking for a variance for Honeywell.

[Tim McGivern]: Got it. Thanks. I get everything I need.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, anyone else commissioners anyone have any final thoughts? I want to make a motion.

[Jim Silva]: I make a motion to approve.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, Jim Silva, motion to approve. Is there a second?

[Jim Silva]: Yeah, I'll second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Tim McGiven, second. Alva, please call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGiven?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All in the affirmative. None in the negative. The motion is approved. Thank you, Mr. Hecker. I can go over to parking and get your variance. Awesome, thank you very much. All right, next up is 2026-54, on petition, stop signs on Fairfield Street, both directions, making this into a section, a four-way stop. Alba, who brought this up?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Anthony Higgins, I believe. Shannon.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Can I just ask, has Director Blake reviewed this yet?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: OK.

[Charlie Hartnett]: OK, Shannon.

[SPEAKER_00]: Hi. Hi, everyone. So as the petition says, I am a resident of Lincoln Street. They're near the intersection of Fairfield Street. There is a stop sign currently on Lincoln Street, but there's none on Fairfield Street. There's a tremendous amount of traffic that comes down Fairfield Street coming from, because it ends right at Duggar Park. And we have a lot of children on our street that have been running around and playing frequently. And I truly believe that a stop sign here would make the neighborhood significantly safer for our children.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Todd, have you reviewed this at all? And your thoughts on this as the traffic engineer of the city?

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, I also want to point out that I think there was a large petition for this as well. So it's not just one person. Um, yeah, I'm in support of the always stop here. It's a little unclear which street should have the right away and it's consistent with some of the other nearby streets on Fairfield.

[Charlie Hartnett]: So I'm supporting any other commissioners.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: If Todd thinks it's appropriate, then I would support it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Would you like to make a motion?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'll make a motion to approve it unless somebody wants to talk.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Alicia, I'm on the motion to approve. Is there a second?

[Jim Silva]: I'll second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Jim Silver seconds. Alva, please call the roll. Commissioner McGibbon?

[Jim Silva]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes. Commissioner Silva? Commissioner Hunt, did you give a yes?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes. Sorry, I have to stop muting myself.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Chief Buckley? Yes. Four in the affirmative, none in the negative. The motion is approved. All right, so let's just give time for the DPW to put those signs up, okay? Okay, thank you very much. All right. All right, 2026-55, veteran meter permit. Parking Director Sarah McDermott and Veterans Director Veronica Shaw. Sarah, I'm assuming that you'll be speaking for Veronica?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Oh, she might be here. She said she was gonna attend, but it's possible she's not here.

[Unidentified]: I don't see her in here.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: That's okay. Okay, so I was approached by director Veronica Shaw, will now former director and she had an idea to allow easier access to parking for veterans who live in Medford. And so we propose. a new type of permit, which essentially, if you all are familiar with the senior meter permit, it's essentially the senior meter permit, but for veterans who reside in Medford. It would be available to Medford veterans with a registered, vehicle registered in their name, vehicle garaged in Medford. They have to provide their DD-214 that the veterans director for Medford would verify, would rather certify before the permit would be issued. 2 documents confirming their bed for residency would be required. In addition to the DD to 14.

Only available for the metered parking, not permit parking. There's no limit to the number of vehicles because the same applies to the senior meter permit. It would be 25 dollars per year per vehicle, just like the senior meter permit. It would only be available for purchase in the office at city hall, not online, and it would not be available to those dishonorably discharged from the military. Um, 2 other things we're happy to accept this as on a trial basis. If we want to do a pilot in 2027 and see how many people participate and see, maybe that's going to be too much of a strain on our. You know, how many based on the number of veterans living in that Veronica. Discussed with me before proposing this, I don't know that it would have any more negative impact than providing it for the seniors, but still happy to do a pilot. If the commission thinks that's the way to go. And the 2nd thing is, we don't want to start selling this permit until February 1st, because at this point, the parking department is already underway with 2027 permit renewals and the clerks and I do not have time to implement a new permit. Before the beginning of the year, we have this on the agenda earlier this year and it just. We would have been able to offer it during this renewal season if we had gotten it approved before now.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Sarah commission. Does anyone have anything regarding this? Anyone will make it a motion.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Do we at all want to talk about like, is there any sense that it. It makes life easier for the veterans, which is great. Like, does it have a financial burden on the city? Should we be aware when we're making financial decisions for the city? There's I don't think there's any way to estimate how much people spend on parking meters in Medford.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Well, that's why I was proposing a trial basis so that I could compare meter revenues between February. I could compare it next year or well, I should let me backtrack. I could compare after 2027. if we run a pilot, I could compare meter revenues from 2026. To 2027 with that permit implemented and see the financial impact it may have had see if the amount of permits we sold helps make up for that. So, yeah, you're correct that there's not a good way to know the impact how much interest there would be if any in this type of permit, but it's. It's something that we can.

Look into after a trial this, we did we did run this by the mayor's office as well because originally Veronica was proposing a free permit and that didn't fly. So, the proposal was to make it similar in nature to the senior meter permit.

[Charlie Hartnett]: So, Sarah, I just want to see if I can clarify because there are different definitions as well about being a veteran as well. So. Like, for example, like, like I want to say, so I'm a, whatever, veteran for combat, but, but there are veterans who do serve, um, you know, 90 days in the state of Massachusetts on active duty that will be considered veterans. So, I mean, are you considering this combat veterans? Are you considering this like disabled veterans? Um,

[Director Sarah McDermod]: I believe Veronica's proposal was anybody with the DD 214 that was valid. Yeah. I mean, that would, that would mean include the folks you're talking about, right?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Everyone. Yeah. I mean, the DD 214 is you don't even need to necessarily be a combat veteran or a state veteran. Like you, everyone gets a DD 214. So that's.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: That's the only thing, I mean, I wish that the director shower here so that she could. I know she has an idea of how many veterans. With that, even the ones you're referring to live in Medford, she had some idea that I'm assuming.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I mean, there's probably a lot of veterans in the city of. And being 1, you know, I. I don't know, I would say you'd have to look at. those definitions of what a veteran is in the state of Massachusetts. And I hate to get nitty gritty with it, but you know, if it was disabled veterans, that'd be one thing. And even that can be a lot as well. But I don't know if that's just my two thoughts, my two cents, sorry.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: That's okay, I appreciate it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Does anyone else have any thoughts?

[Tim McGivern]: Sarah, I was wondering if you guys talked about any concerns with doing a pilot where you implement it and then you take it away from the, from them. So, if you do it for a set period of time, and then you have to take it away, did you guys talk about that?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: No, but. I mean, that's just something we could make them aware of during the. Permanent sales, they're coming to the office, we can have the clerks, let them know, like, this is a trial basis. This may or may not be available in subsequent years.

[Tim McGivern]: Because I'd love to see the data. I mean. You know, to see how many sign up for it, how many use it. I'd like to see that, you know, before proving it as a program, because, you know, if there are a lot of them, then there, you know, there's a measurable, meaningful financial impact here and we should understand that.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Uh, Sarah, did you say this was run through by the mayor?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yes. So the, the, when I submitted to Alva, the email I submitted work was all given the go ahead by the mayor to present to traffic commission as is.

[Unidentified]: Okay.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Um, all right. If, uh, I'm going to open it up to public comment. That's okay with the commission. I see some, uh, see a hand raised. Elizabeth, you have the floor.

[SPEAKER_18]: Oh, sorry.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Hold on. Let me see. I think maybe. Oh, here we go. All right. All right. Thank you.

[Elizabeth Bayle]: Thank you. I couldn't figure out how to unmute there. I. I just wanted to say, I live with a veteran who's also a senior, so it probably doesn't affect him. But I was just going to say, as a senior who has a $25 a year parking permit, we both do. I'm sure that we don't use $25 worth of parking. So it's actually, I think, at least with us, the city is making money on us. We're doing it because it's just a lot more convenient and easy. But if you took the amount that we would spend on meters versus the amount we spend on the parking permit, I think the amount that we spend on the parking permit per year is more. So I just want people to take that into account when you're looking at what the financial impact is, that not all those veterans that would get a permit are going to be spending more money you know, more parking that is than $25 would cover. That's just my only thing to think about. I don't know, but just bringing it up. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you. Very good point. Is there anyone else who would like to speak and wants to raise their hand?

[Todd Blake]: Charlie, someone posted something in the chat echoing what Elizabeth just said. Yeah, okay. That's true for me as well. Okay.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I actually think that that may be not a bad argument, that there may be some people who go every day to the library and park at a meter, but that's probably not your majority, or go every day to the senior center and don't pay for parking in that lot because of this, because of the senior permit, but that's not how a veteran would be using it either.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Right and the thing Elizabeth mentioned as well, is that her husband is a senior and a veteran. So there are people who are going to qualify for a 25 dollar a year permit, regardless of veteran status. But a number of the veterans who live in Medford are going to be over 65 already and qualify for the other permit. So. I mean, I'm being completely honest. I'm, I'm fairly neutral on this. I presented it with Brian. I think it's a, it's an opportunity to provide something for the veterans. The city of Salem provides free parking at meters for veterans and she, there's a couple of other cities that are fairly local that do as well. Which is why she proposed free permits from the beginning, but that, like I said, didn't fly. I don't think that would and I agree with the mayor on this that if we offer veterans free permits for meters, and we're charging the seniors 25, then. That wouldn't have gone over very well in all likelihood. So, but I don't I don't want y'all to think I'm going to take anything personally. I just this is kind of working with director Sean this. And if. We want to table it and adjust it or table it and get more information from director shop. You want to give me some questions for her? I can get in touch with her and we can maybe bring it up again next month. Cause like I said, I don't really want to start selling them until early next year. Anyway.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: I just like to throw a comment in there. I think this is a great plan. I think it's a great idea for the veterans, but I also think it would be tragic if we put this on a trial basis. I mean, there's not, this is not the type of, uh, Benefit you hand out to a veteran and then make a decision on later to pull it away. So we're all in or we're all out. And I think we should be all in from my point of view.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there any other comments or would anyone like to make a motion?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I will say that at this point, I'm either in favor or in favor of getting a little bit more information. I don't want to belabor this to December, but if we thought that most of more information and besides you're not going to implement it till February anyhow, the difference would be how long there is out there to advertise it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Oh, Sarah, would that would that if if something was to be tabled for a few months, would that hinder your ability to get this program going?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: A few months. Yeah, if it was. I mean, like, Alicia just said, I'm sorry.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I'm sorry.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: If we, if we had to table till December and, you know. Respond to any follow up questions that the commission might have. I don't think that director show would have a problem answering those questions. I'm really surprised she's not here tonight, but that's okay. There's just certain questions about veteran population that I can't answer that. I'm. Certain that she can so. Yeah, but if we belabor it until January, February, then, you know, we don't put it out till March, April and then it's they're paying 25 dollars and I'm getting the full year and it's it's still a good deal. If you use it, but it's less and less a value the later into the year. We start selling them. So. Yeah, but I mean, go ahead.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Anyone would like to make a motion to either table approve or deny.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I mean, I'm inclined to approve it tonight. I think it's a good thing. It's a benefit. And I have a feeling that it's gonna be more making a matter of convenience for people than it's gonna be costing the city money. I just know there's been a big deal made about like meters. And if you change a meter to not be a paid meter or like, I think we have to apply those kinds of things across the board. But I mean, I think this one would probably be revenue neutral.

[Charlie Hartnett]: And just to make sure this is not a trial, it's a full implementation of the veteran meter permit. Correct.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right and I feel like your motion is on down the road. If we find out that we sold 2000 of them and we think we're losing money. We actually, if we sold 2000, we probably would make good money on it. So, you know.

[Tim McGivern]: In other words, if we needed to, we could change things in the future. That was kind of what I was trying to get around at earlier, is because you don't want to pull the rug out from under him once he issued the benefit. But at the same time, it sounds like we all seem to agree that it's a relatively small, if any, financial risk for us. That's what it sounds like, just talking through it.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: I mean, it's not like it's there is the added step, but the added little hurdle of, like, you got to get your duty to DD to 14 approved. You got to get to city hall during the hour. Like, you got to come in to get it. So it's kind of like, is it worth it? I think that people who would go for it would genuinely want. To use it, which I don't know, maybe they would maybe they think they would, but. I think even just not allowing it online is gonna make it a little bit more, like you're gonna have to work, put some time in to get it, is what I'm saying.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, I agree. So do we have a second on the motion? I know Alicia had an initial motion.

[Jim Silva]: I second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, Jim Silva, second. Please call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes. Four in the affirmative, none in the negative. The motion is approved. Thank you, Sarah, I appreciate that.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Thank you all.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, next item up for bids, well, sorry, it's not the prices, right? On the agenda is 2026-56, request from Nicole Sullivan representing Dunkin Donuts, or sorry, Dunkin, 34 Salem Street for 15-minute parking sign, space 101, Nicole, let me see where you are. I'm gonna unmute you. Nicole, you have the floor.

[SPEAKER_29]: Hello, everybody. How are you guys? We recently relocated from to Salem Street down to 34 Salem Street until movie theater building. And at our previous location, the parking spaces that are right outside have a 15 minute limit on them. And we were wondering if it would be possible to move that down to where we are.

[Charlie Hartnett]: So it would be to have is it to remove the 15 minute parking from the other space and then move it over there? Or is it just to add one?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: I just had it as adding

[SPEAKER_29]: I don't know when to Salem is gonna be rented. He's gonna have a very hard time renting that space, because it's not ADA compliant, but that's a conversation for somebody else to have. That's why we moved out. If I would be open to moving it, I'd be open to adding one. The problem we're having now is people, and it's not my employees, because we have one spot in the back and the rest of my employees don't drive, but people are parking in the spot outside all day.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, here's the floor.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, I was just gonna I'm glad Nicole offered that because I was going to suggest to not add another one. There's already two near Martin pastry plus the one near the old Dunkin Donuts in this one across the street. So if this were favorable, I think moving it would be the way to go because then it would be revenue neutral in terms of losing another metered space.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And so if we look at what are the businesses next door, they're the one right next door to the old spot. So first of all, I'm in favor of putting a 15 minute in front of Dunkin Donuts. I'm sure that it will cut down on people illegally double parking in that area. But I think in terms of down by the corner, there's a barbershop next door. How often do people park in a 15-minute spot intentionally to go to a barbershop, right? It doesn't happen. Yeah. Then next to it is a little market.

My instinct here is that the 15-minute spot would better serve the city further up. I'm curious if it's getting used now that Duncan isn't down there.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah. And again, there are two here near the, near the men's room and pastry shop. So there's two plus that. Yeah. So, so even if you move the one from the corner and someone used it to go to the, they still have the one, two spaces away at the pastry shop to utilize.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Right. Sarah. How hard would it be to transition the corner spot to a 15 minute meter? No, take away the 50. Oh, take away the 15 minute meter.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: I don't think I don't know that there's a meter of like, 1 of the timing.

[Todd Blake]: I think it's just a double error on this sign. Take this away and put a 2nd error right here.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: There are timing meters by. Modern pastry, I believe in those 2 spots, I think we have. An extra 1, but even if we didn't, we have. Electronic shocking people talking so we can still use it. We can still make it 15 if we don't have 1 of the camera meters.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Todd, you're not sharing your screen. You keep seeing right here, but we can't see.

[Todd Blake]: My bad, yeah, sorry.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Move the 15 minute meter, the 15 minute sign from the corner and we move it down there. Can you put a meter in where those two spots are that would be previously 15 minutes?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yeah, we can just swap the mechanism from the meter that is by Duncan right now.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Right.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: It's essentially just taking that whole housing off the pole, moving it to just flip flopping them and everything. Yeah, and then we tell the vendor, like, this 1's now here and this 1's now here and this it's that's not a big thing. They can do that in a day. The signage is a different story. We don't do that, but the, um, the meters themselves, we could swap out really easily.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Does anyone have any other comments? Does anyone want to make a motion? Well, where would the spot be?

[Chair Jack Buckley]: There's an HP spot out there, I believe.

[Todd Blake]: So it would be, the HP is here, right next to the driveway, and then it would be this next one in front of the HP, I believe.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Can you go ground level on that?

[Todd Blake]: Yeah. Let's see. Yeah. So it would be this one right here.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay.

[Todd Blake]: Right there. So that's...

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, so right in front. Any other comments or concerns or emotions? Would anyone like to make a motion to remove 15 minute parking from the corner of Salem street? make that a mated spot and move the 15 minutes to in front of 34 Salem Street, Tucker Donuts.

[Tim McGivern]: So moved, Charlie.

[Charlie Hartnett]: What's that? So moved. You motion it? Yep. All right. We have a motion from Tim McGibbon. Does anyone have a second?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I second it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Alva, please call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Chief Buckley. Uh, yes. All right. For the affirmative. None of the negative. The motion is one side. One side. Yes. One side is approved. All right, Nicole. Thank you. Wait for this to be put up the side. Okay.

[SPEAKER_29]: All right. Thanks so much. Have a great night.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, you too. Next up on the agenda 2026 dash five seven request for stop sign on Elliott Street a trout app from Renata McFarland 26 Elliott Street rain nada me.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: I don't believe she's in attendance. She sent a letter, and I sent a letter to all the commissioners explaining why she wanted it, but that she was unable to be in attendance.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay. Commissioners, since she was not able to be in attendance, I don't know if you've been able to review, or if you'd like to table.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Why don't we take a look at her letter since she said she couldn't come. I haven't read it yet, but I have it. And so this is a request for a stop sign. So my very first question is, has Todd looked at it and does he have an opinion?

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, thank you. I do.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes, tell us your opinion, Todd.

[Todd Blake]: So yeah, I agree with the residents. It's a little unclear who has right-of-way, Kenway, Trout or Elliott. So in this case, the request, I agree with the request concurred that it should be an all-way stop.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Do we want to look at it? Because honestly, I, I personally believe stop signs are a good idea. And if you feel that it is the right place or an appropriate place for one, that's typically good enough for me.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, so here's Kenway and Trout kind of act as the same street, and then Elliott crisscrossed it. They're roughly about equal, probably roughly handle about similar volume. Elliott is a one-way, so it would be a three-way stop, but it's still an all-way stop. Look at it at ground level. So here's his trout and Kenway, here's his Elliot, sorry. His trout is Kenway.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, does anyone have any other comments regarding this?

[Jim Silva]: Commissioner, motion. Quick question.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Commissioner Silva.

[Jim Silva]: Yes, so Elliot currently does not have a stop sign, is that correct? Correct. The other two do already.

[Todd Blake]: Yes, so we'd be adding 1 to the 1 way portion coming from Main Street.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, is there a motion?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'll move approval unless Jim wants this 1.

[Jim Silva]: I make a motion to approve.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Jim Silva motion to approve. Is there a 2nd? I'm assuming. Yes, Alicia, please call the role.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: And we should know we given.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt. Yes. Commissioner Silva.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Four in the affirmative, none on the negative. The motion is approved. Next item is 2026-58. I apologize if I say this incorrectly. Pachyderm or pachyderm place project. What is that? Pachyderm. Pachyderm. No. Do you know what a pachyderm is? I do. uh, 401. We'll get back to the, uh, 401 slash 403 Boston Avenue, Tufts University and Todd Blake. Mr. Blake, you have the floor.

[Todd Blake]: No, that should be amended. It's, it's tough. So I think they're going to go in and I'll help explain, I think.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay. Mr. Dorico. Uh, let me get you over here and unmute you. There you go.

[Rocco DiRico]: Thank you, Lieutenant Hartnett. Can I also share a screen?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Sure, do you want anyone else to be unmuted from your team?

[Rocco DiRico]: Yes, I would like Jeff Bandini and Dan Beathers to be unmuted as well.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Sure, okay, they are, well, I requested them to be unmuted. You can absolutely, here we go, allow. Okay, I think you have access now.

[Rocco DiRico]: Okay and Charlie can you see that?

[Charlie Hartnett]: We can yes.

[Rocco DiRico]: Okay thank you. And thank you to the Medford Traffic Commission for allowing us to present tonight. I am here presenting tonight on behalf of the applicant Capstone Development Partners. My name is Rocco DiRico and I'm joined by representatives from Niche Engineering and Capstone Development Partners that was Dan and Jeff. Capstone is here to share their plans for improving Boston Avenue. These improvements are part of the community benefits associated with the Pachyderm Place project and some are required by conditions of approval. The Packeter in Place project will provide on-campus housing for 664 students. Capstone is planning to complete the project, including improvements to Boston Avenue this summer, so that students can move in in August of 2027. And construction on the project, as you can see from the timeline, began in April of 2025. Since then, we have hosted 20 community meetings and four community advisory group meetings on the project. At these meetings, Capstone and others provide updates on the project and solicit feedback from our Medford Hillside neighbors. The project submitted their original plans for Boston Avenue to the city in June. These plans showed protected bike lanes, but due to the width of Boston Avenue, adding protected bike lanes necessitated removing on-site parking. In August, the city provided feedback to Capstone, including directing the project team to preserve on-street parking while implementing the other measures that we'll present here this evening. Capstone incorporated that feedback into their plans and shared it with our Medford Hillside neighbors at our September community meeting. On October 1st, Capstone again shared their plans at another community meeting. And then at that meeting, we were asked to share the plan with the community advisory group that is working on a Boston Avenue planning study. So we did that on October 27th, 2026.

And then again, on November 5th, 2026, we had another Tufts community meeting and shared our plans for Boston Avenue. Tufts has also committed to fund up to $500,000 for a design study of potential improvements to Boston Avenue. from Winthrop Street to College Avenue. This study and the conversations with neighbors and interested parties is ongoing and the improvements that we're proposing here tonight will not prevent future changes to Boston Avenue should the design study identify additional desired improvements in Boston Avenue and obviously provided that those improvements are approved by the city of Medford.

I'm joined here tonight, as I said, by Jeff Bandini from Niche Engineering, who will present next, and Dan Beathers from Capstone Development Partners is also here to answer your questions. I'm going to stop the share and allow Jeff to go next.

[SPEAKER_11]: All right, Jeff. Got it. Appreciate it. Do you mind if I share? Sure. Absolutely.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: you see that okay excellent thank you again for having me this evening and thank you Rocco for outlining sort of the steps that got us to this process as you mentioned a lot of improvements that we've sort of gone as we've gone throughout this process in this first slide is basically a summary of the improvements that we're presenting for you this evening Including modifications to the Boston Avenue cross section, including. Approximately 5 foot bicycle lanes on both the North and the South sides of Boston Avenue, which represents a slight increase in the amount of infrastructure for bicyclists. 2 new pedestrian ramp locations 1.

Proximate to the University Avenue street side. And the darling garage implementing record rectangular rapid flashing beacons. Uh, the graphic, you can see to the right at the darling garage location. Implementing flex posts and daylight for both enhanced visibility for pedestrians. Installing an 11 dot blue bike station near the darling garage and once all that, those improvements have been implemented, furnishing a new roadway surface with new signage and landscaping. And as Rocco mentioned, maintaining a majority of the on street parking on both the North and the South sides, and the parking that is being removed is going to be transition to other uses to enhance mobility within the study area. So, this is a representation of the existing and proposed cross section the existing on the top. Showing the existing parking lane on both sides, the vehicle travel lanes in the middle flank by the 4 foot bicycle lanes on both sides. Under the proposed condition, we're maintaining the parking lane on the North side of Boston out up against the. Widening the bicycle lane from 4 feet to approximately 5 feet. Reducing the drive lane to enhance that additional bicycle with. And then maintaining the parking on the packet or in place side. Where feasible and where we've received comments from the city, we would be maintaining. Existing parking and transitioning a few spaces for the pickup drop off locations. As well as removing a few spaces to install exist, curb extensions to enhance that pedestrian mobility. So, here's a representation of the overall parking summary, 97 spaces between University of and McDonald garage. The proposed spaces that I mentioned would be removing 2. On the North side, and 3 on the South side, and then including the transition for the pickup and drop off. So this is the representation of the engineering plan. Which I can share in greater detail if that is the pleasure of the commission. I also have a slide here that is a little bit more of a graphical representation. Of the parking that is to be maintained and transition within the study area. And you can see the parking to be removed on the North side is for the enhanced visibility for the pedestrians leading up to the crosswalk locations. And then on the South side, the 2 spaces in orange here, which you can see for pickup drop off near the new packet in place. In a few spaces that we're showing as transitioning to maintain to propose the existing the curve extensions and then the location of the blue. Blue bikes rack in coordination with with Todd and his team. So, that's what I have for you this evening. Happy to answer any questions. Or look closer at the engineering plan, but again, this is a representation. Of different levels of feedback that we've received throughout the timeframe that Rocco. Outlined for you before I started sharing my presentation.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, before we move on, I just wanted to add, this is a good graphic, but I think it overstates some of the loss. So the parking near the crosswalk in front of the garage that says two removed and three on, it's actually less than that because there are existing parking restrictions in advance of that crosswalk on each side. So I think it's even a little less loss than what is proposed in the other diagram. Yeah, thank you. So, yeah, we were careful to keep the parking loss to a minimum. Even for the safety things, just where we absolutely need it. Thanks. Thank you. Todd.

[Charlie Hartnett]: For the commission, does anyone have any questions or comments?

[Jim Silva]: I have a question for commissioner Blake. Was there any consideration for sidewalk level bike lane? versus parallel to the traffic.

[Todd Blake]: But this particular submission, I think the question was asked, but you would need to widen things to fit some of these elements, some of these ideas from other folks of like swapping the park and the bike lane or putting bike lanes on sidewalks, the certain width that is required and that doesn't currently exist. So no, not for this particular project, even though it was asked at some point, but yet there's no wide, it's maintaining the existing curb-to-curb width here.

[Jim Silva]: Thank you.

[Todd Blake]: Did Jeff, did you?

[SPEAKER_11]: Oh, no, sorry, I was just motioning. Sorry, go ahead.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Any other commissioners have any questions or comments?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I want to make sure that I understood that answer that in order to put the bike lane on the sidewalk, the way that would actually work, you would need to lose a parking lane basically right? Because the, the drive, the 2 drive lanes can't be any smaller than they are. And so is that what you're saying that the that yes, you did look at whether or not you could put a. But the bike lanes up on the sidewalk, but the problem is not with not with on this road, because it's not there's not enough with of the road in the sidewalks that currently exist to make that happen.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, I didn't look at it in detail, but you can see on this plan, there's tree wells as well. So usually, sometimes people think you could swap one for one. So if you put that five foot bike lane onto the sidewalk and made the sidewalk five feet wider, then you know, to some it may seem that that would work, but when you put a bike lane on a sidewalk, usually in addition to that, there's a buffer zone for street furniture. So usually it's like five plus another two or even three. So if you took the five foot bike lane off the street and put it on the sidewalk and think that will work, usually you need another two or three feet. And then that two or three feet, where would it come from? And that gets to your question about parking or something else.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And then I have another sort of higher level question, is that I'd really like some clarity. I know that when Packeter in place came through site plan review, we asked about getting a, you know, that there should be some pickup drop off spots because we firmly believed in the CD board believed that there will be a lot of Uber and Lyft and Uber Eats and Amazon and all of that at a dorm. And there should be sufficient space for that. I know that also there was this, it was a separate agreement with the residents to do a study of Boston Ave and the university extended that. And they hired a consulting firm to do all of that and what all of that should look like, but that I don't feel like that's what we're getting the results of is that the results of that are not coming to later. I'm just and I do know that the goal is to open the door by September. and actually late August, and so you have to have stuff done in a certain timely way in order to be able to open it and get your occupancy permits. So you need permissions to how you're going to restore the road. But I'm sort of missing this disconnect between what's the study, where is the study, when is that coming, and is that going to tell us to do different stuff here? Um, or like, I, I'm kind of confused about that. Is that question for me or no, it's for rockets for the university. Cause I appreciate your advice, but this is their project, not the city's project.

[Rocco DiRico]: Correct. Yeah. Well, I'll let Todd, I will let Todd speak to the four places for spaces to two. Cause that was a, um, recommendation made by the city.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, so there's, you know, when we look at these types of things, you know, the planning board may have approved something, but it's subject to traffic commission. That's why we're here today. And then in terms of 4 versus 2, it's, it seems like a. It seems like a practical consideration when you factor in all the variables such as revenue that's lost when you transition from a metered space to a non-metered space. Considering the area, there could have been opinions to start with none and see how the two-hour works for say the restaurant use. There could be consideration to start with four. Two seem reasonable, two seem comparable to other scenarios where business or restaurant wanted some higher turnover. Simolina, I think that's how you pronounce it on Boston Ave. They still only have the meter two hour and they don't have any short-term parking. I'm not aware of any requests or issues with that one. So two seems like a reasonable amount to consider at this time versus the four because the loss of revenue and not knowing if it was truly needed or not yet.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right, so that's a separate question from the high level. And I do not compare this at all to a restaurant. Those spots were not intended by the CD board because there was going to be some little businesses there, maybe a little bit. But really, 600 people are going to have a lot of drop-off pickups going on. And what I don't want to see is double parking. And if we start to see double parking and the police starts to see that, then I want this back in front of us to add additional drop-off pickup spots. Because I think that's how you solve double parking in the city.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, I don't I don't think anything in Tufts proposal here has rock or someone on his team mentioned. It doesn't seem like any of this precludes what you just said, or. Or, like, you know, some future long term plan for the quarter. It doesn't look like any of this stuff precludes any of that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right.

[Rocco DiRico]: uh, in relation to the Boston Avenue, um, uh, planning study, that plan is for the entire corridor. So from, uh, so zooming out from this, it's from Winthrop Street to, um, College Avenue and actually takes it, you know, we're even looking at taking the turn and going to the Somerville border as part of that study. So that project is ongoing and will probably won't be completed until next year.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, I would add that I've mentioned this to Rocco, that usually the normal order of some long-term, you know, bigger picture exercise is planning first to look at options, that planning, you know, considers all the factors, and then it might produce a recommended design, and then you would design something, then you construct something. And that timeline for something like this doesn't necessarily, in my opinion, the planning study align with the approval and the proposal tonight, because that planning study isn't done yet. So, like, to apply anything that may come out of that to this, the timing doesn't seem to line up right. like for instance there's no parking utilization yet for this whole corridor and that's usually whenever the city in the past has considered changes of roadway cross-section that was a major component to some of these decisions when there's mixed input on both sides of that equation. So I don't think the two have to be in conflict. I think this could go ahead tonight in my opinion and the planning study could still play out for the long term.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Any of the other commissioners have anything to say? If not, we can move on to public comment. All right. Seeing that there's no other questions from the commissioners, I'm going to move on to public comment. I'm going to one at a time. Mr. Kulik.

[SPEAKER_18]: Sorry, let me find, where'd you go? I don't know where he went.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Oh, there we go, okay. All right, Mr. Cooley.

[Bruce Kulik]: Oh, there we go. Thank you. Yes, so I have several concerns about this. My name is Bruce. Cool. Look, I'm currently secretary of the massive of the Medford bicycle advisory commission and I'm here with a handful of other members as well as the vice chair of the of the commission. We have some concerns about this on a number of points. Some of them have already been brought up by Alicia about whether there would be protected bike lanes of any sort and what we would do about parking. But the one thing that really stands out to me, and if we could go to the cross sections, I would like to confirm that I understand where we are now, what this is proposing, and what the long-term concepts are likely to be. We're showing 13-foot sidewalks, as I understand, on one side and 10-foot on the other side. Was there any attempt or consideration to reduce the width of the sidewalks in order to gain more curb-to-curb space that would allow for a more optimum arrangement of lanes?

And I don't know if that's to Rocco or to the consultant.

[Rocco DiRico]: I think if Jeff, if you could take that question.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, that's a great question. And certainly, you know, as we keep talking about the planning study, not precluding any future development, right? Well, our design was predicated on maintaining the existing curb to curb width. Certainly we understand the concern with, you know, the bicyclists and all of that. And certainly out of the planning study could come a recommendation to implement Future study, but certainly given the timeline of. The construction of place versus. Where we are in the design versus the planning study. This is our recommended improvement plan at this point.

[Bruce Kulik]: Okay, so are the sidewalks going to be reconstructed and are the curbs going to be re, basically reconstructed as well?

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Not as part of this, we're maintaining the existing curb to curb.

[Bruce Kulik]: Okay, does that include the large cement blocks that make up the north side on the sidewalk between the roadway and the sidewalk? Or are those going to be replaced?

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: I believe those are being maintained. You're talking about these, right?

[Bruce Kulik]: Okay, I'm not sure if that's exactly what those are. I thought those might have been street wells. but it wasn't clear to me what those were from the diagram.

[Todd Blake]: I think Jeff and Rocco, I mean, I believe you guys reconstruct on the side again, putting standard granite curb in, I think. It's my recollection.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Oh, along this side?

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, to eliminate that concrete kind of knee wall situation, at least from university to crosswalk and possibly a little beyond.

[Bruce Kulik]: My point is, if the sidewalks are being reconstructed as well as resetting the granite curbs, there really isn't any excuse not to increase the curb to curb width, which makes this plan premature for sure. Could I get a clarification on that?

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, we could certainly look into that and again, you know. Improvements may reduce the sidewalk with on on that side as a result of that. Any potential resetting the curve on the side.

[Bruce Kulik]: Just want to make sure that even an additional foot on either side. Would come up to my next concern, which is that the bicycle commission has come to the conclusion that. The absolute minimum required, and this is only under extraordinary circumstances, which can be improved would be the 7 foot 5 foot 10 foot. On each side configuration. That is the absolute minimum that we think is necessary for full bicycle lanes to be put in. And by having the sidewalk slightly smaller, that could possibly give an additional foot, which means the parking lane of seven feet, which is barely the width of a car, would be able to be increased perhaps to eight feet and provide a lot, basically more space. So that's something which I think I would like to see more serious consideration given in that regard. The second thing is that I see that there are trees being planned as part of this plan and that again seems premature if there is a ongoing future plan for this corridor because once trees go in That's a big deal. You can't really move the trees. You know, I mean, you can always cut them down, but that seems like a real waste. So, again, I question whether whether that makes sense at this point in the plan, particularly if there's a thought given to a slightly wider curve to curve situation. So, finally. The one thing that I do see missing which absolutely needs to be part of this plan is the fact that the bike lane is disappearing westbound on Boston Avenue. When we get out of this particular section of the quarter. I see a lot of science here regarding parking and drop off and that sort of thing. but nothing indicating that there is a bike lane or that the bike lane will be ending as you turn westbound. I think that's a very important feature both for bicyclists and for motorists to understand that any bicycle traffic is going to be merging with motor vehicle traffic at that point. Of course I don't see anything to the west of here which I understand is a separate consideration so I can't see how that really dovetails but at a minimum I would like to see bike lane end signs right there at that where the bike lane stops heading westbound.

[Rocco DiRico]: Thank you, Bruce. I want to point out two things really quickly. Number one, the trees were a big part of the conversation with the neighborhood, and a lot of our neighbors asked for trees on both sides of Boston Avenue. And secondarily, Dan Beathers, who is part of the project team and is actually the applicant himself, Um, from capstone has been trying to speak so if someone could unmute Dan feathers.

[Bruce Kulik]: So, he can answer some of Bruce's and then I have 1, 1, final question after. Yeah, maybe I should give that 1st in case he wants to address that. I did have a slight concern about the bump out. and whether or not they protrude into the bike lanes. There have been situations where bump-outs have been put in place and it makes it an obstacle for a bicyclist going past, particularly one who has a five-foot bike lane, and then suddenly the bump-out intrudes. One example is not a city project, but one on the Fellsway where DCR put bike lanes in. which are greatly appreciated. However, the bump-outs stick right into the bike lane space requiring not quite a merge, but definitely a maneuver towards the main traffic lane, which is a little bit uncomfortable for some cyclists. I wanted to make sure that that wasn't going to be the case here where the bump-outs extend into the bike lane.

That's my final question. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Bruce. I want to move on to more public opinion on this.

[Rocco DiRico]: Well, I was just saying, Lieutenant, if we could unmute Dan Beathers, because I was going to answer one of the questions and just he hasn't been able to unmute and been allowed to.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I just hit him to unmute.

[Rocco DiRico]: OK, thank you.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: We can't hear you, Dan.

[SPEAKER_02]: Can you hear me now? Yes. Yes. Okay. No, I appreciate the question and Rocco pointed out with the, with the trees was part of the privacy and the coordination with the community on the side and then along in front of our building. We have the wider sidewalk in front of the project. In part with the restaurants, we've got two tenants that we'll be building out having some restaurants. We have some patio space for them on the front side and along with students moving in, that's our unload loading area. So we can't block the entire sidewalk with students and parents holding luggage as they're trying to move into the apartments. We don't have any space behind the building. So we carefully studied at the beginning and shared with our community meetings and part of the initial discussion well over a year ago. with the community and the team, the city, on the purposes of that width. But it is important to note we are maintaining the curb-to-curb dimension. And I think the work that Niche and Todd have done at the pinch points that you just brought up, Bruce, have been protected to where that's not constricting the bike lanes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Dan. Jeremy, you're next up. I will unmute you. Jeremy, you have the floor.

[Jeremy Martin]: Thank you. Thanks for the opportunity to comment on this. This is an important project. It's a big development. It's got a big impact, and it's a great opportunity to improve the public realm with it. I want to note that I'm a neighbor of the project and also a member of the community advisory group for the Boston Avenue study that was referenced earlier. I think many of you know that once a community development board review process concluded for this project, several members of our neighborhood continued to work with Tufts to ensure that the conditions on the avenue were rebuilt better than they were before the project, including the implementation of a protected bike lane, bike lanes in both directions. Now we understand the traffic commission doesn't support that original design. And I want to thank Todd especially for joining our last community advisory group meeting. and clarifying the city's position on that original proposal. I understand that there's a process for making those kinds of modifications that requires broader community input, and I hope we can keep the dialogue going with the city about how to advance that to the next step. The discussion with Todd in our last community advisory group meeting yielded a couple of alternatives that would achieve what the city has prioritized while also improving conditions for cyclists and other users of bike lanes without widening the curbs. That looks like a parking protected lane on one side of the street and a shared lane on the opposite side of the street, not even a sidewalk level bike lane, which we understand there are complexities with. Now, tonight Tufts has made a point to tell you about all of the meetings they've had with the community, but what they haven't told you is that since they presented these revised plans to us, we repeatedly asked to consider alternatives and they have chosen not to include those alternatives in their proposal.

I also wanna note that the draft recommendations of the Boston Avenue study that were presented just a few weeks ago, only incorporate this current proposal they don't anticipate anything beyond that and that's currently what we think is a maybe a shortcoming of that study so to count on it at this point is a little bit flimsy for us in terms of improving this. street for the long term. So I hope you will show your support tonight for the community by moving to continue this hearing so that the alternatives that were raised in our community advisory group and even that are being discussed tonight can be fully evaluated. This is important not just for the residents but for those 660 students who are going to be living here All of which we just heard tonight won't have parking on campus, they're going to be using bikes and scooters and let's make sure that we're improving conditions and not just returning to the status quo on the street. One more month to do that and to do it right won't impact us ability to build this project. And then beyond the design of the lanes on the street. It would really benefit from other improvements to calm traffic drivers often speed through here. I've seen many times personally where the crosswalks get ignored, even with the flashing beacons. So tools like speed humps and increased enforcement would really make a big difference for both the Medford and test communities. So I think there's more work to do here. I'd look forward to doing it together with the commission and with Tufts. And I thank you again for considering these comments.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Jeremy. Jared, you're next up.

[Jared Powell]: Okay, thank you all very much for letting me speak. My name is Jared Powell. I'm a member along with Bruce Kulik of the Medford Bicycle Advisory Commission, and I'm a neighbor here. I live in the neighborhood within sight of the new buildings. I live here with my family, and I'm glad and I very much appreciate that this group's thinking through ways to improve both the safety and the vibrancy of Boston Avenue, which I think is sorely needed. Um, one of my jobs on the commission is to talk to residents and I hear all the time that people want to bike on Boston Avenue. You know, it's direct it's convenience. It goes where they want to go, but many people just don't feel safe riding there today. Even with the existing bike lanes that are there, they're just too close to the speeding cars. And so it's really only the more aggressive cyclist among us who tend to feel comfortable doing that on those sorts of lanes. And that's really not an inclusive design. Which I think should be our goal here, so I'd encourage us to be far more ambitious and make this a flagship safety infrastructure project for Medford with truly protected. Separated by claims, even if that is. More complicated or require shifting the road layout more or just spit balling might even require tough to absorb some parking into the downing hall garage. I think creativity is called for and I think we must also design for what we know is coming as. Commissioner hunt noted more deliveries, more pickups and more drop offs that are not happening now. So, if we build an unprotected bike lane, that's more or less similar to what's there now. That will absolutely will become a de facto loading zone. that is full of illegally double-parked cars, and that's going to create a huge safety conflict from day one. A few drop-off spaces just won't prevent that, unfortunately. We've seen that in too many communities in our area. So, just lastly, I really want to make sure that the new design prioritizes. Safety, and that it does so in a way that would actually attract new, more conservative and timid cyclists and families to be able to bike down this corridor. And that we really think creatively so that we can make this as impressive a project as I really believe that it can be. So I second all the comments that Bruce made earlier. I'd like us to keep working on this rather than making lasting generational decisions too quickly, particularly in light of entirely foreseeable conflicts that we can see here. So thank you very much for your consideration. I very much appreciate it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Jared.

[SPEAKER_18]: Emily, you have the floor.

[Emily O'Brien]: I think I'm unmuted. Thanks very much. I'm Emily O'Brien. I'm a member of the Medford Bicycle Advisory Commission as well as the Community Advisory Group. If you don't mind to go look back at the cross-section image that you had up there a second ago. My concern here is that this cross-section looks nice on paper, but in real life, it is fundamentally unsafe. And it puts bicyclists in the position of having to choose whether to stay to the right and possibly get doored by somebody opening the door of a parked car, or to stay to the left and possibly get sideswiped. And this image shows relatively small cars parked in both parking spaces on both sides, and also relatively small cars in the travel lane. We know that Boston Ave has city buses, which are 10 feet wide. It has a lot of truck traffic. It has a lot of vans, facilities, vehicles. These are all 8 to 10 feet wide. And it's not uncommon to have two 10-foot wide vehicles passing each other at the same time. So if you're trying to use that bike lane, now you have a 10-foot wide bus going past your left side and a bunch of parked cars that could be opening their doors at any time on your right. And you're between a rock and a hard place. There's nothing you can do as a cyclist to make that a safe place to be. And because of the timeline in which we've seen a version of this that was actually finalized enough to present here, I don't think the cycling community has even had enough chance to adequately Look for alternatives, even within this curb to curb measurement. I would suggest that I know parking is important, but we've had all of this discussion on this meeting. Because cars take up a lot of space and you can put 10 bikes in the space of one car. There are thousands of people who live within a 5 or 10 minute bike ride of this T station and there will be 660 students who move in here who will see that bike lane and think it's where they're supposed to be and think that it must be safe because they wouldn't have put it on the ground that way if it wasn't. And to me, this is just asking for a tragedy to happen. It is a known hazard that cyclists get hit by a car door or swerve to avoid a car door and end up under moving vehicles. And so I find it just really irresponsible when we have this opportunity to Think harder and to redesign this to continue doubling down on this on this cross section that is really not safe to use at face value in order to adequately pass the cyclist by the state for feet that's required by state law. A bus would have to cross the center line by around four feet, and they don't do that. If there's nobody coming, maybe they do it. Ideally, they should slow down and wait until nobody's coming, but there's nothing about this road design that tells them that that's something that they might have to think about. I have personally had a number of close calls. Biking down the street. I've seen other people have close calls. I have a gallery of photos about what it really looks like in practice to have bike lanes of this configuration, adding a handful of inches. to the 4.75 feet instead of four feet is really not enough. A bicyclist is two feet wide, a car door is about three feet, and that's assuming they parked all the way out of the bike lane. So I think we need to reconsider this plan. I think we should be looking for other alternatives. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Emily. Elizabeth, you have the floor.

[Elizabeth Bayle]: Thank you. I just want to represent another point of view. I don't know how it can be reconciled with people who are bike riders, and I know that there's a very organized group of people that represent bike riders, but Not everybody can ride bikes or walk to this T station. My partner and I worked for over 12 years, very, very hard to advocate for this T station and we wanted the Green Line extension to go to Route 16 and wanted a lot more improvements on Boston Ave in general and things that would have benefited the city if that had been possible. But at least we got this one. But it's not just for tough students. And it's not just for people who are able to walk and bike there. A lot of us aren't, partly because we waited so long to get this T Station, which started, there was discussion about it in the 70s and it, you know, you know when it happened, it's very late from when it was conceived. So I just want to represent the people who can't walk or bike to this T station and who need to have some parking spaces there, or they won't be able to use this incredible, valuable amenity of the T station that we've waited so many years for. And I just hope you'll take that into consideration. There's a lot of people even who can walk and bike who still need to park at the T station sometimes when they want to take their whole family to an event or have kids in strollers or lots of other things that just it's not really practical to just walk or bike to this station. So I just want to.

Say, you know, also the other thing is the T station is in operation all day, every day, all year and bikes. are very useful when the weather is good and they're less useful and less people use them when the weather isn't good and especially when there's snow and ice. And there's a lot more of Boston Ave that doesn't have great bike infrastructure and taking away the parking spaces in front of the incredibly valuable resource of the T. Um, when that, that kind of infrastructure can't be extended further down Boston Ave doesn't, it just seems to disenfranchise one group of people for another group of people. And I just want you to take into consideration those points. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Elizabeth.

[SPEAKER_18]: Uh, Laura, you have the floor.

[Laura Jasinski]: Hi everybody, thanks again for hearing these issues and for listening to the community on this. I'm also someone that's a hillside neighbor and has been involved with conversations around this residence for a long time. And I also, I hear what Elizabeth is saying and the importance of parking near the T. I think, and what I hope you're hearing tonight is a request for more time to develop alternatives that don't actually remove that parking so that people that need it can access that T station. but to create much safer conditions for those that are using bikes and walking to the T and that are reducing the number of people in cars that would also take those spots. I think what we're saying is there's an opportunity now to really set the tone of Boston Ave with this project to create a safer condition for the community and for the tough students. I also just wanted to echo what Director Hunt said about the change in four spaces to to temporary parking spaces as someone who I would consider myself a much more conservative year round biker I bike to get my daughter around Medford.

I'd say are the most unsafe part of our commute from hillside across campus. is in front of the coming center where there is no place for a car to pull over. I mean, that's not even for deliveries and other things, and that's not even a residence hall. We have to come out into the middle of traffic to get around that, and that's a really dangerous condition. We're gonna see a lot more deliveries. I think we should be designing for what this building will be creating in that condition and what the students in that building will need, and that's deliveries. And so I think by having more spaces there, that can also help create a safer condition.

Thank you again. I hope you hear that what we're asking for is more time to create a better design for everybody and think that we have the opportunity to do so.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay. Thank you, Laura. I'm going to move it back to the commissioners for their final thoughts or emotions.

[Tim McGivern]: I got a question. It has to do with our purview. So we're looking at a plan that's proposing to remove some parking spaces and it looks change some lane widths. Is that our purview in this plan here? That's my 1st question. Then my 2nd question is if we are rebuilding sidewalks here and we're at 4.75 feet for a bike lane and the recommended width is 5, why aren't we moving curb? That's my 2nd question. And then my 3rd is what is the timeline of that corridor study that we're talking about and what has already been discussed as some conceptual cross sections that could work for the corridor? Thanks.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Any other commissioners?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I guess I want to know if Rocco or somebody from his team wants to address some of those because 1 thing that I heard loud and clear from the residents is that they would like. More time for there to be more study and to identify a solution and what I thought I heard from. I know that there's been this has been going on for a very long time. I have been hearing rumors and variations of this for like. six months, almost a year now.

And who is going to do that study? Who would be figuring that out? Like, if this got continued for till December, who's looking into it? But I also, right, I see this whole, well, if there's gonna be a bigger study, let's stick to just paint and lines for now. And then we can do construction later. But if we're doing the construction on the sidewalk, then I kind of echo Tim, like, Why aren't we just moving the sidewalk? I would like to see the alternatives. And what I kept hearing was the city said we are going to do this. And I'll tell you that it wasn't the traffic commission that said, here's the plan to present. It might be People from the city, but I, like, I would like to see what are the alternatives that involve moving the sidewalk curb because that sidewalk is getting rebuilt.

Only either or either parking or protected bike lanes or not like.

[Rocco DiRico]: Right. Yeah, I will say the community advisory group for the Boston Avenue study is ongoing. To answer your question, Alicia, as to who is doing that study, it's two firms, Sazaki and BHB. And in addition to Elizabeth, we've heard from people on that committee of the importance of parking. We've heard from neighbors who live on University Avenue. We've also heard from small business owners about the importance of preserving parking on Boston Avenue. And then I'll turn it over to Jeff. I think Jeff has considered some alternatives and he can probably talk to some of the alternatives that were proposed tonight.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, thank you Rocco and thank you everyone for the feedback. Yeah, we did certainly look at alternatives. You know, some of them included removing parking, which was sort of the ongoing discussion that we were having with the city and that we heard. Concerns about tonight, so 1 thing I did want to mention. That didn't come up specifically in. My presentation. was the proposing of the curb extensions on the South side, which is the construction of the proposed dorm on the South side. So on the North side, we aren't proposing any curb extension. And that's intentional because as Rocco mentioned, we don't want to preclude ourselves from potentially implementing future alternatives to what's happening on the North side. Right? Like, we were to construct a curve extension here. And then the planning study dictates that we might want to implement additional improvements. Then we have to go out and remove those curb extensions and that's additional money that. And time that no 1 wants to spend, so by implementing the solutions that highlight some of the. Striping and the daylighting that we're proposing on the North side. That does give us flexibility in the future to make future changes. Be that transitioning that parking on the north side or some sort of long term solution. That involves some sort of separated bike lane, but the results of that from the ongoing planning study would dictate what those solutions might be.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think some of my question, though, was residents tonight said, can we have a little bit more time to figure this out that the bike commission only got to see this extremely recently? So when. So who would come up with another idea for, say, December? And I do just want to comment on, I noticed somebody just posted in the chat about there's this big parking garage next door. The parking garage is Tufts. staff park there. Tufts students will park on campus. Residents of the storm can park on campus. The parking is public parking and that's not typically used by like Tufts staff and Tufts residents, right? This public parking is people who are coming to use the T or visitors to campus. I mean, I know I park along there. when I'm coming to visit campus and I don't have a pass for the garage that day. So we're talking about the public parking here and that your garage is not public parking.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Alicia.

[Todd Blake]: Lieutenant can I mention something the cross sections that showed like the 4.75 and all that. You know, that could have been rounding errors when they were measuring because this plan that was just on the screen proposed shows. 7, 5 and 10, and I opened up the 2017 plans from environmental partners when the complete streets project added this. And it called out for 7, 5, 10. So the 7510 was what the city's consultants did back in 2017 in this block, and that's what it's shown here. So the other cross sections that show 4.75, I question those. And then one other minor thing, just for people's knowledge, not saying one way or the other, the cross section that shows the 13 feet, that's, The sidewalk that's only along the new building. None of the other quarter has that extra with. So, like, when we think of what something could look like, we have to think of what it could look like for the whole thing. I'm just pointing that out as a clarification because it might have been not clear.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, thank you. Todd. That was a. The update to the cross section here was based on some feedback that we received at the Tufts community meeting. That illustrated that some of our numbers didn't. Add correctly, and for full disclosure, we, you know, there's some areas of Boston now. You know, when it was constructed that are slightly less than 44 feet. So, not wanting to say, okay, we're going to have less than 10 foot traveling that width has to come somewhere. So, when we, when this goes to get constructed, there will be some sections that are 5 feet. But in actuality, if the, if the curve isn't moving. On the South side, it's going to be, you know, we need to make sure that when it's constructed that we provide as much with as we can. But we just want to make sure that we're saying, okay, we don't want to propose a drive lane. That's less than 10 feet because that's just not permissible. But some sections of Boston Avenue are between 3043 and a half and 4014. so that there will be some sections that show that 5 foot width that's shown consistently on the plan. So, thank you for pointing that out.

[Todd Blake]: Yeah, if it's off by half a foot, it should be. The opportunity should be there to correct it and make sure it's a consistent with.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yeah, 7, 5, 10, I think I got you there.

[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you with that.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yep.

[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you. Can you hear me?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yep.

[SPEAKER_02]: I was just going to make the comment I hear everyone's concerns and appreciate them. and I would point out that that study, the $500,000 that Tufts has put forward will help the entire corridor, not just here in front. We have permits with the MBTA. There are restrictions on the far side of Boston Avenue. The MBTA is very critical with their soil mills, with the train tracks down there. We cannot arbitrarily widen the curb or the sidewalk. We looked at all that at the beginning and working with the MBTA was very long. And they're very good, but they're very thorough. So I saw a couple of comments that stated that we could widen the curbs, and you can't arbitrarily widen the right-of-way or find space. So I think we are confined from curb to curb, and the study will help fix the whole corridor. And I don't see that being, if we try to wait a month, unfortunately, I don't think we're going to be able to come up with sufficient ideas or replacements that would affect the curb to curb. It would affect the paint striping, which we could always do. And I think that would behoove the group to wait for the study, reconvene and discuss that. But that is a separate issue from what we were going for tonight. Thank you.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Thank you, Dan. Any other commissioners? Any thoughts or emotions?

[Tim McGivern]: I didn't really get an answer to the question of why we're not moving curb. So if we're reconstructing sidewalks and we have an inconsistent width and we can push a curb six inches here or there, I don't see why we don't do that. I very much want to understand that. And I also didn't really hear the answer to my question of what's the timeline to the study. $500,000 is a lot of money. Um, and it's a relatively short length of road and there's not a lot of options. Um, so, you know, that's a lot of money to spend on a study. So, you know, what's the timeline of that study? What are we hoping to get from it? And is there a real project there? Or is it a little bit of a. A dream so that I didn't really hear any answers to those questions and we can talk about it too, but also the purview of the commission. I mean, we kind of have a narrow purview from the regulatory standpoint. So a lot of people are here to hear more about the design than necessarily the regulatory standpoint. So I would like to hear some answers to my questions. Thanks.

[Rocco DiRico]: Thank you, Commissioner. And yes, the studies being done by Sazaki and BHB, it is not just for the area in front of Pachyderm Place. It's for the entire corridor. It's ongoing. I don't think it'll be done by December. And I think based on the way the conversations have been going, my assumption is it's just going to result in a variety of options for the entire corridor. It's not going to say, like, this is the one true end-all, be-all. I think as you've seen tonight, there are a lot of different opinions on what's best for the entire avenue.

[Tim McGivern]: What's the target completion date?

[Rocco DiRico]: January.

[Tim McGivern]: Okay.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: So commissioner would give it just because we talked about the purview of the traffic commission. You're correct. It's a regulatory body and we have the authority to approve a plan that is put before us. And it's my understanding Tufts University put a lot of work into this plan and they met with groups within the city, but also members of this city, the traffic engineer himself has approved this plan. That's my understanding. And that would be, you know, Director Blake. And so as it comes forward, it really is our purview to vote and accept the plan so that the project, our neighbors like Tufts can move forward with the project. It doesn't preclude us from considering bike safety in the future or some of these other issues, because we do have a sort of a diverse group. Some people want, you know, to remove parking to create bike safety, but parking is definitely necessary. It is a public transport area. HAB-Michael Leccesereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee that we could vote on this and there's time to modify things in the future. If there needs for drop off pickup spots sometime down the line when we have occupancy there and there's a need for it, we can adjust. At the same time, the police department could do their job and do some enforcement out in that area to make sure that those things don't occur. I don't wanna sort of push, we have ourselves as the city push this off the agenda think long enough that we should actually give this a serious consideration and a vote.

So I would actually move that we sort of approve it with the conditions that we look forward to with the understanding that our traffic engineer has approved the current plans before us also.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Sorry, I was told last May that this was coming on the agenda by residents. And as far as I'm aware, this was never put on the agenda. If somebody asked to have it on the agenda, that wasn't a decision by the board. Like, Tim and Jim and I did not vote to not hear this six months ago.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: I'm not saying that was put on the agenda. I'd say that was, has been discussed, but we were like, originally there was a loss of some 40 something parking spaces. That's not something that should be just thrown out there and debated. It has to be like the city should have a say in those matters. And that's what sort of took time to get that far and to the development.

[Todd Blake]: I believe Tufts may have at one point asked to be on the agenda and then retracted it. I will say this for this discussion. This doesn't discount any desires to improve things throughout the city, which we all try to do on a daily basis. I will point out that these bike lanes were installed in 2017 as part of a Complete Streets project, a year before I got here, and I have crash data for this whole, you know, all of Boston Ave, and this particular corridor from Winter Street to College Ave, there are zero documented door zone issues. And I know some people say they're not always reported, but that's the data we have in front of us. There are some reported door zone injuries in the uphill section of the corridor, but even those are a few that wouldn't rise to the level that sticks out. So I just wanted to add that. That's not to say that know other bicycle facilities are not necessarily more desirable it's just to point out that it's at least the data shows it's not necessarily unsafe as is and five-foot bike lanes are allowed next to and in some other communities do have them and we have them so like we could go by what we know today what Tufts is proposing is is some cross new crosswalk a brand new crosswalk upgrade an existing one, both with RFP is the pickup drop off. That's pretty much the extent of what they're proposing today.

Any like bigger picture. parking impacts type thing should be studied you know collected parking utilization data like I've said before usually that's been like a key component in any decisions about trading bike versus parking but right now the study is as far as I know is unable to collect the utilization because they're all restricting the parking for the construction right now so it's kind of hard to know if that's fully utilized or not in the past with on High Street and some other places, if it's been determined that the spaces are utilized less than 50%, it shows that parking can be absorbed on one side, things like that, whenever there's a choice between these things. And again, I'd point out that there is a desire to improve things, but at the same time, like the project in front of us, is really like one, it's like 500 feet out of a 2000 foot area. So you can't necessarily apply the cross section at 500 feet and apply it to either side on, you know, because those may not be changing. So that's a factor as well. So just wanted to throw that out there.

[Tim McGivern]: What I was getting at with some of my questions really was that this is part of a building project. We get some mitigation that's happening as part of a building project in the traffic. This is not the future of Boston Avenue. From what I understand, what I'm hearing, that $500,000 is supposed to show us ideas of what it could be. I also asked that question about why aren't we moving curb. I'm not talking about huge movements here. The reason I ask that is because if we're building new sidewalks that we can get 5 feet instead of 4.75 feet for a bike lane. We should be doing that. Small adjustments is what I'm talking about. And then I think understanding the timeline is important because the idea that 1 building project is going to transform Boston Avenue is not realistic in this world that we're working in here, but working with tops as a partner to look at the entire corridor is something that is very real and it may take longer. I understand the desire to see this as an opportunity to make a chunk of Boston Avenue saver for cyclists. I can completely understand that. You guys know that. But what we're talking about here is almost very close to status quo, planting a bunch of trees, doing some bump outs for safety when we lose a couple of spaces. And so what I really see us voting on tonight is the loss of a few spaces and some crosswalks, and then basically rebuilding Boston Avenue the way it is without, I think that seat wall is going away as well. And then I'm hoping that we see some, real improvements that may include changes in the actual right of way for $500,000 and getting creative during that process. I think that's the process that calls for the creativity that we're all yearning for. Those are my comments on the matter. Appreciate everybody coming in and presenting. Thanks.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Commissioner McGibbon, I actually agree with that and we could prove tonight in theory and not really affect the future. We can still look at things and we have big study that's coming on. So it's not changing anything that's not, that we don't have right now. And with that, I mean, I motion to approve.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Chief Buckley has a motion on the floor to approve. Is there a second?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I still have a question outstanding that I don't think was fully understood. And that is that there was some thought that, so there's confusion between studies, right? There is a big study being done by VHB and Sasaki. I'm not talking about that. There is a traffic consultant who is working as part of this project for Pachyderm Place, who put forward this proposal tonight, that's Niche Engineering, has been working on this, the site civil work. If this was continued to December, would there be like, what kind of could they look at over the next three or four weeks to improve this? Or is that delay it for people to look at really a delaying that would need six months to do anything? Because there is not six months here. but a month, like, but who would look at that, right? And I actually almost look at Bruce and Jared and Emily and say, you all said, give us like a little bit more time. And I heard that from Jeremy. And I think I heard that from Jeremy and Laura as well. Who is going to actually do that and come up with a different or any changes in December? Because we're not waiting for the Sasaki study is what I heard clearly.

Is there an answer to that?

[Rocco DiRico]: Oh, Lisa, just to be clear, you're not asking that to me, right?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: You're asking to others. Could Jeff at Niche Engineering, would they have?

[Rocco DiRico]: Oh, sorry. I'll allow, I'd like to allow Dan to talk about what the impact that would be on the project schedule. And then if Jeff wants to comment on, you know, how long it would take to truly do full alternatives.

[SPEAKER_02]: Right. No, thank you. So, if the question is, can we, who would revise and try to get permissions to extend the right of way? I don't think that can be done in 30 days.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Um, I heard him side, it would have to be on the tough side.

[SPEAKER_02]: And with the tough sides, we've got a building there. We've got some retail space that is out there for the retail tenants. So we were very constricted with space. I think we could make the improvement for a couple inches. As Commissioner McGibbon was saying, to even it out, make sure we got the five foot. I think that is in the current plan. As we're running through and taking up the granite, we should be able to get that to maintain the curb to curb so we hit the dimensions. That we can do. I do not see us being able to get any more. And if we wait 30 days, I think we're just kicking a can down the street and not getting any answers, which affects the timeline for us as the developer and the contractor on the project to be able to phase and sequence and get everything set up for when the moratorium is lifted and we can begin to work on the sidewalks. Because that will need to be phased. We'll need to finish one side as a section and the next. in order to leave one sidewalk open at all times. So we're on a very tight timeline, but we can commit to catch what Commissioner McGivern had stated.

[Tim McGivern]: Alicia may just be asking, though, for just general review time, maybe not even substantial changes to the plan, just giving folks an opportunity to look at it. And if there are tweaks or changes that can be made, I don't want to speak for Alicia, but I think that's kind of what she's talking about. So I think I want to help Alicia out with her question a little bit. When does the project plan to break ground on this particular plan? When are you pouring sidewalks? When are you putting curbing in and bump outs? What is your schedule for that?

[SPEAKER_02]: So, we are ordering the curb now. There's a lead time on the curbing, but we will be unable to do any of the work until the moratorium is lifted in the spring.

[Tim McGivern]: Sure, and if I with Alicia, if she could just if I was writing in her characterization of her description.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right, I think that's basically it is that I don't think we're going to get a dramatic change. Um, but I also heard many residents say, can we look at this little more? And that's where I'm trying to understand, like, because if it's there, if they want to look at it. Okay, that's 1 question if they want toughs to look at it, then toughs us to say, yeah, actually, there's some things we can we can look at and do right? Like. I've tried to hit like where, how can we get the best that we can get in this time frame?

I am very interested in seeing the storm open on time. Don't get me wrong.

[Rocco DiRico]: That is our priority as well. We have 664 students that are going to be moving in. And I don't want to sound like a broken record, but I think Jeff has said this and would appreciate him jumping in here. But what we're proposing tonight doesn't preclude future changes. And so if the results of the Boston Avenue study produce things that could be recommended. And again, as Todd said, we're given time to do parking utilization studies when there's actually people in the dorms and the parking spots are back open, we can do things in the future. But Jeff, I know you've been looking at alternatives on this, you know, since August. And so if you could speak to that a little bit.

[KaEkSOLEwkQ_SPEAKER_05]: I'm just trying to unmute. Yeah, I mean, certainly. Yeah, I mean, there's certainly. Slight tweaks that we could do, like Dan mentioned about the potential discrepancy in the. The roadway with, and as Todd mentioned, you know, our, our plan show the, the 5 foot. Bicycle lane, so making sure that when we're setting that curve, when we're putting back what we're saying that we're going to design. Is, you know, what we would plan on putting together as part of any sort of revised proposal, but I don't I don't necessarily think. That going and putting together additional plans, I think would be would be necessary under the guys that. We could that future study could indicate that there could be other things here. So, I would suggest that, you know, making sure that there's consistent with throughout here would be. Part of the revised plan again, we're talking about a 500 foot section. So, when it was constructed, it's possible that. You know, our survey showed, like I said, 43 points, something would want to make sure that when we're resetting that sidewalk that we're, we're getting what we're saying that we're putting in.

[Todd Blake]: Dan, can I ask you a question? Hopefully you know the answers. When, in your best estimation and perfect world for your project, when do you foresee repaving Boston Ave?

[SPEAKER_02]: Like this summer, a summer of 27, once we finished the curb and sidewalk.

[Todd Blake]: So that's 6, 7 months. So.

[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, sir, I would, I would say closer to 7. so, I guess the reason I asked that is I'm saying, like.

[Todd Blake]: There was 1 option that I heard folks say before and tonight. With that doesn't involve curbing beyond what was just described. So like, I'm just, I'm just playing this out, speaking out loud I'm not saying this is what should be done. But if the bike commission had met and said they prefer one better bike lane one direction and share on the other versus the two bike lanes. that's not going to be painted until the summer so there's x months that you know someone could propose that and it's only a painting change on a plan for this project so it's not even money so yeah because right now I really see this plan as proposed as You know, some bump out some improvements, some some pick up drop off. It's. It's not really proposing anything cross section, but but if it's just just a paint change. It seems like there may be time for it to drop that scenario.

If they so desire.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I just want to remind we still have a motion on the floor to approve by chief Buckley is very 2nd. Is there a motion to deny our table?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think I would make a motion to table for one month if we thought that there might be some edits that would make people if that's a chance.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Didn't they just say there wouldn't be?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: If there was a chance that there would be some edits that we could see, I honestly, what I don't think that's going to change is which parking spots are eliminated and how many parking spots and that's our regulatory oversight. But I also feel like if we want to make sure that the. The lanes are wide enough and this, this, this stuff is being handled, right? This is also our point of leverage where we can. Do and say that, you know, we could approve it and they'll say, okay, we're going to go do that. And then there's no way we, we can ever follow up and make sure that happened.

Right. I think that our regulatory oversight here is literally just. Removing parking spots, or the change to the 15 minute parking spots. Do we even have regulatory oversight over the crosswalks?

[Todd Blake]: The new crosswalk at university?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: We do.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I don't think that's right. There's a motion to approve. There was no second. There is a motion to table for a month. Is there a second on that motion?

[Tim McGivern]: I'm going to second the motion to table for a month. I think the project can handle that based on the construction schedule. And the primary reason that I'm doing this is because I want to try to help people understand that are here, where the line is between this is a building project that's improving some crosswalks, adding some bump outs, and losing some spots, and basically putting the road back to status quo until, and I understand status quo is not optimal, I understand that until we see the results of a study and I want the traffic commission to think about conditioning that study the timeline. I'd love to see it done in January and that we have an issue with funding. So, whatever concepts come from a study. We're going to need funding, so the city's going to need funding to do that. So, you know, what does that look like for project? It's a longer term project. So, we just got to get ready for that ride. But I think the project can afford a month and that will give folks like the bike commission and other folks to sort of digest this plan and try to understand. the situation between this is one building project with a block of Boston Avenue that is getting some relatively minor improvements versus a longer term, very expensive study that should yield a bigger, better project that could include things that we all want to see. So I'll second the motion to table this in December, and then I would be in support of a plan like this with just some minor tweaks. Thank you.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Now, can you please call the roll?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: There's no need for roll call, it's tabled.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon. I think we have to vote to table it. Oh, okay. Alicia made the table, right? Good. Commissioner McGibbon.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt. Yes. Commissioner Silva.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley. Absolutely not. be in the affirmative, one in the negative.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, the motion is tabled. For one month. Three to one.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, for one month, right?

[Charlie Hartnett]: For one month, yep. I'm gonna request that the, I'm gonna see if there would be a motion out there to have, to take 2026-62 out of order So we can take the three HP requests at one time. Is there a motion for that?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Motion to take them out of order.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Motion to take them out of order. Is there a second?

[SPEAKER_16]: Second.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley? Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: On the affirmative, none on the negative. The motion is approved. Okay, so 2026-62HP sign Edward Serino, 49 Bradshaw Street. Let me see. Is he on this?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, but there's three others in front of him for handicap if we're doing that. 2026-59. Oh, I'm sorry. Yes, yes, yes, yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I'm sorry. My apologies. 2026-59HP sign. Courtney Crump, 132 Monument Street. Let me see. Alyssa Scott. I'm sorry, Alyssa Scott. Alyssa, go ahead. Are you on behalf of Courtney Crump?

[SPEAKER_20]: Yes, I am. Yeah. homeowner of 132 Monument Street, and I'm also Courtney Crump's fiance and power of attorney. We've owned the house, or I've owned the house for 11 years. We do park in the driveway. He became a quad amputee this year, and I cannot load him in the car unless I have a sidewalk to assist me. So I'm requesting a disabled space in front of the house so that I can park my car next to the sidewalk because he has to transfer with no hands, no legs on a slide board, which I have to place him on. And I can't do that uphill. So the sidewalk gives me enough of a straight angle that I can get him into my SUV.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: That was very clear to me. So I would move approval of this. We should check, like, are there other handiclips spots nearby? But I can see very clearly why they need one in front of their house regardless.

[SPEAKER_20]: There's none on the street either. Okay.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Then a move approval.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Alva, is the paperwork in order?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yes, paperwork is in order.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, paperwork's in order. Is there a second?

[SPEAKER_16]: Second.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Alva, call the roll. Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Deputy Chief Covino? Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right, four on the affirmative, none on the negative. The motion is approved. Thank you. So we'll be getting the sign up as soon as the DPW is available too. 2026-60, HP sign, Harold T. Bruning, 48 Chipman Street. Is Harold here?

[SPEAKER_18]: Anyone acting on behalf of Harold.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: I'm surprised he's not here. He was calling. Oh, wow.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I wonder if he left, um, do we have like an email or something explaining this 1 answering our typical questions.

[SPEAKER_18]: If they have the paperwork or anything like that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I see the paperwork, but I don't see a, um, like, sometimes, like, we like to ask is it. Why can't you use your driveway? Do you have a driveway? Actually? Can we check, like, from street view? Like, if there's no driveway. Well, we like to confirm that it is. In fact, I'm, I'm reminiscent of the time that they wanted somebody wanted a handicap spot for the ride to pick up and drop off, for example, and that wouldn't be an appropriate use.

[SPEAKER_18]: Just like to check you have an email from do you have an email from him?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: I got tons of tons of paperwork from him with his email address. Yes, I have been emailing back and forth with him to. Complete all his paperwork over and above everything that I needed a letter from the owner of the property.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Is that in our packet?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yes, I'm not in your packet and no, I didn't. All I did was the basically quest for the for the application for the handicap sign.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: I don't believe he has access to the driveway. 100% disabled veteran. Letter from the doctor, which is not given out.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there a motion on the floor?

[Unidentified]: I don't know why it's not in the sentence.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right, when I look at it from street view, there's a very clear driveway right next to his door and so I just want to understand why. He wouldn't be using that like the previous applicant had in their letter a very clear explanation of why they needed the street and not the drive by.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Just going over the question. He doesn't specifically say he has the use of the driveway, but he does say by the time he gets home from work, parking directly in front or near his home is always unavailable, forcing him to walk a great length of distance to get to his house. Yeah, that's above all.

[Tim McGivern]: Does it safe to assume he doesn't have access to his driveway?

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Yes. He doesn't specifically say that, but reading his request in the application, I don't think he does.

[Tim McGivern]: Are there any other handicapped signs on the street?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: If not, I mean, I don't see any, Tim.

[Tim McGivern]: I would move to approve.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Second. All right. Alva, please call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGiven?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes, please.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Deputy Chief Covino?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes. Before any affirmative, none on the negative. The motion has been approved. 26-62 HP sign, Edward Serino, 49 Bradshaw Street. Is Edward in attendance?

[SPEAKER_20]: I don't think so.

[Unidentified]: Any paperwork on? I have his paperwork.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: This paperwork is all in order. I don't know. Doesn't say anything here about not having a driveway available.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I did just, I wanted to, I was looking if the previous one was a two family and it was, which would also, and the person who was the applicant was not the owner of the property. I will say that this is a single family house and the owner, the applicant is the owner of the property per our assessors, our public assessors database. So that again brings me to ask, why would they not use their driveway?

I know sometimes one of the sergeants is able to go out and visit and find out, get the story. I assume we haven't had that opportunity in this one.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: He doesn't make mention of anything of that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right. And we do like to confirm that the spot is for the resident and not like a guest or whatever. Although we do also, I believe Tim has advised us that a certain number of handicapped spots sprinkled throughout residential neighborhoods is a good thing to have. But this is a single family house. There is a driveway, there's a car parked in the driveway in this image. I'd like to just understand And it's for Bradshaw Street, right? It's a corner house.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: The corner of Honeywell and 49 Bradshaw Street. That is a little bit confusing.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, I was looking to see if might be there was like a rear entrance. He was trying to use because of, but there is not the back is all fenced off. So I was just trying to understand why. Can we table this 1? Unless you have any more information on it.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Sure, if someone wants to make a motion. Yeah.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I would motion to table this and advise the applicant to that. We need an explanation of. Is need unless 1 of the commissioners feels differently.

[Tim McGivern]: How's this 1 different last 1? We have 0 information on whether or not he can use the driveway. Is that is that what I'm the last?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: The last 1 was a 2 family. He's a renter and I believe that Alva just said that in his email, he said he couldn't use the driveway.

[Tim McGivern]: Yeah. Yeah, that was a difference I was looking for.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So this one, this is a single family home. This is the owner of the home. Oh, and it has a driveway. So I'd like to understand why the owner is looking for a handicapped spot in front of the house rather than using his driveway.

[Tim McGivern]: Got it. I see. I'm fine with that. I mean, I'd second that.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, so we have a motion to the table on the floor from Alicia Hunt, is there a second? Tim.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Oh, Tim, I'm sorry. Commissioner McGibbon?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Chief Buckley? Yes. All right, four in the affirmative, none in the negative. The motion has been tabled. Now just the next one down. Yep. Okay. 26-61, correct? Oh, no. 19 handicap 19 yeah that's from table biz sorry right okay uh the next is 20 26-19 hp sign marie carmel grant uh grenois i believe i apologize if i said that wrong 36 evan street marie i think you i am gonna unmute you Mary?

[SPEAKER_23]: Yes.

[Charlie Hartnett]: I appreciate you waiting so long for this.

[SPEAKER_23]: Yes, hi. It's not Mary Carmel talking right now. It's me, Mary Ellen, her sister. On behalf of my sister, I'm talking for her. And the reason I'm asking for this spot is just like, we do have a driveway, but unfortunately, when people park near the driveway, I have trouble to back up my car to bring her an appointment. My sister is suffering from a disease called Parkinson's, and she cannot walk too long, neither stand too long, and she has several doctor's appointments to go in a week.

So I was asking if you guys can allow me to have a spot on the street in front of my house so she can park her car. And when I need to go to the doctor's office with her so that will be accessible to her more quickly. That's the reasons that Asking for the spot, and I hope you guys consider that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And to clarify, your sister lives there with you? Yeah. Okay. Or in that building with you? Yeah, sure. And so this is one where I see that they do have a driveway, but you have to back into the driveway in order to get there.

[SPEAKER_23]: Yeah, because it's like sometimes people kind of like block the driveway. And the way they park the car, it's really hard for me to back up and then to take her to the appointment, not to be late for the appointment. weekly appointments, those very often. So sometimes any day she probably has two appointments to go to. And during snow time to back, you know, so that really difficult for me. That's the reasons that I'm asking for that spot, please.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I'm taking a look at this spot, and one of the things that I'd like to understand is like in the image on Street View, there are two cars that are practically touching each other, squeezed in there. Is there actually room for two spots there? Or is the problem that this is really only enough space for one parking spot in front of your house, and people are squeezing two vehicles in? They have room for two spots.

[SPEAKER_23]: It's just like this, the way they park.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Okay, Alva, is the paperwork in order? Yes, yes. Is there any other comments from the commissioners? Is there a motion from the commissioners?

[SPEAKER_11]: Motion approved.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Motion approved by Commissioner McGibbon. Is there a second on the floor?

[SPEAKER_11]: I second.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Commissioner Silva, second. Alva, please call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner McGibbon?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner Hunt? Yes. Commissioner Silva?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley?

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes. 4 in the affirmative, another negative. The motion is approved. Just wait for DPW to be able to go by there and put the sign up. Marie, thank you very much. I appreciate it.

[SPEAKER_23]: Thank you so much. All right.

[Charlie Hartnett]: 2026-61, reaffirming parking violations and schedule of fines, Sarah McDermott, parking director. Director McDermott, you have the floor.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Hi there. As some of you might know, I've been working with Lieutenant Hartnett, Todd Blake, and Tim McGivern to redo update the traffic and parking regulations for Medford that were last ratified by traffic commission in 1973. While we do that, there are some concerns I have after looking through the 1973 document a little bit more carefully and. Dealing with the recent appeal that we have for a parking citation, I've realized that I do not have reference from a traffic commission decision to issue parking citations for certain violations. Um, that we have been issuing that we not just we have not just the parking department, but the city of Medford police and the parking entity have been issuing these violations for over a decade. Um, but when faced with. The, um, with a challenge. Whether we could issue a parking citation for an inspection sticker, I was unable to produce any documentation that traffic commission ever approved that. Parking violation, so it's obviously that you're not allowed to operate your vehicle with a bad inspection sticker, but parking it on a public street.

Is not something that I can refer to a state law to show that it's enforceable. So I'm just looking for. The traffic commission to approve the issuance of this type of violation so that when and if they are appealed in the future and a. my department's authority to issue that type of citation, I can refer back to the traffic commission's authority to allow us to issue that type of violation. The expired or no valid inspection sticker, expired or no valid registration. The overtime parking, as it's written, does not include 15-minute, one-hour, two-hour zones. It only refers to meter zones and time limits at meters. I'd like to add That in there as well, and then in looking at this, I realized we have odd, even parking, impeding snow removal and snow emergency, which. I don't know why we have all 3 of those. So if we can consolidate those great that when I'm less concerned about consolidating the 3, we've been here for quite a while. Now, I really just want. Something in writing that says our department and the police can write parking tickets on public streets for expired inspection stickers, aspired registrations and the overtime parking.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: This all makes sense to me. Do we have the exact language to vote on? Should we write it down? I mean, usually don't we, when we've done regulations, it's been a long time. We have like, here's the regulation. Yes, that language looks good. Sorry, I didn't read my packet in advance.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: No, and also I included the schedule of fees because the most The schedule fees in the 1973 document is wildly outdated. So that's the other half of what. I was hoping to get approved, but no, we should don't have any. Language other than can't park on a public street with a expired inspection sticker and you can park on public street with. A expired registration or no registration. So, you know, if you don't have a plate at all on your car.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: All right, you sort of mean the Medford parking or the city of Medford is authorized to ticket vehicles for being parked with no, without a valid registration. And I can attest, you do give out that parking ticket.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yes, we do. So with the police, it's not just us.

[Tim McGivern]: Is there a mass general law or something that we can reference that's already written?

[Director Sarah McDermod]: There is about operating a vehicle, but presumably you're operating your vehicle on the public streets to get to the public street you parked on. With your bad inspection sticker, so I think that's kind of the argument there. I doubt everybody's getting towed from the inspection station back to their street when they're either. It's not even just the our stickers. It's, it's just expired people who don't keep up with their inspections or registrations.

[Tim McGivern]: Yeah, I'm in support of filling this gap, but I think, yeah, we need something to vote on so we can incorporate it.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Should we just write it down right now?

[Tim McGivern]: Maybe.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And on the other regulations in there, is it the city of Medford is authorized, the police, the parking department, like, I don't want to be too specific. Like, I don't want you to, your department to change its name and no longer, and it's no longer covered.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: I understand. I'm just going to, See what see what they wrote 1973, I reckon and. In the meantime, can be look, can you look at the schedule of fees while I maybe come up with some wording here?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And this is the schedule that you've been using, right? That's correct.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: There's no changes to anything. Um. Since I started in December 2024, none of those, that's how much the tickets have been. At least in my 10 year, presumably before that for a substantial period of time, because I look at Park Medford tickets, they're similarly priced. I don't know, but that's also a traffic commission decision that I can't find. Or, well, I take that back that when I haven't really asked for a decision on, I asked for a decision on. The inspection sticker and the registration and none could be produced.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: My instinct on this table of fees would be to ratify it as it stands with the caveat, like, if there was a reason to change them, I would expect that to come with a proposal, why we're changing it, an explanation or whatever, comparison to other communities or whatever. As long as the question is we just need the authority to keep giving out the current tickets, then

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yeah, yeah, it may be a redundancy. All of this might be redundant, but I don't have anything. To reference when somebody appeals a ticket and challenges. Our ability to even write this kind of ticket, that's all I'm seeking. So I'm looking at the 1973 regulations and many of the, so parking. No, all night parking, for example, and a lot of these just say, no person shall. It shall be unlawful for a person to park upon a street or highway with a vehicle display for sale. So it could be as simple as it is illegal. It shall be unlawful for any person to park upon a street or highway. Any vehicle display, or, you know, displaying and it's expired inspection sticker. And that at least is see, that's more of a rule. That's not really saying that I can write this ticket, but if there's a rule out there that I can refer to that rule. When we issue the ticket, I think you just is that the rule you want.

[Tim McGivern]: It's a no car shall be parked on the street.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Without dealing a ticket with an expired inspection sticker and saying who said you can write this and then me not being able to give them in the form of a rule that I can refer to that traffic commission has approved. then I can refer to that ruling as.

[Jim Silva]: I mean, these are state laws for, you know, expiration. I mean, to look at the cars, to inspection, et cetera.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: They all refer to operating the vehicle though, Jim. And that's what people point out. Or I say people, one person was kind of the catalyst for this.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: I just need to add something. We didn't suddenly just make this up as a police department and put it into a manual in 1973 and adjust the charges. The issue here is that the records of the traffic commission are mostly handwritten, and it will take us forever to go back and track all of these changes. There is a history and a basis for where these fines come from. What we should be doing is voting on a regular basis to adhere to the schedule of fees, et cetera.

The idea of the premise of the conversation that, hey, we never did this before. It's not necessarily true. It appeared on a citation. Inspection stickers came into Massachusetts somewhere around 1960, and the traffic commission probably voted it there. I could go down there in the basement and look for all these files, which I'm sure we have, and it'll take us about seven months, or we could just reaffirm the schedule of fees.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, and that's what I said, we should just affirm it. And then if you want to change something later, come back with a reason. I just put two drafts in the chat there. It shall be unlawful to park a vehicle with no or expired registration, no S on that, registration on the streets in the city of Medford. It shall be unlawful to park a vehicle with no or expired inspections on the streets in the city of Medford.

I assume that would be enough for whoever is then the authority to give tickets under the parking thing that that document to then give tickets for those things.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yeah. And you know, what's so silly is that I did write out like something for overtime parking to add to overtime parking, because in the 1973 document, it only covers meter zones. I don't know why I didn't think to do that for these two. So thank you, Alicia. That essentially is what I need. so I can refer to a decision from the traffic commission. Can we add, it shall be unlawful for a vehicle to remain in a parking space beyond the maximum period of time designated by approved posted signs to the overtime parking rules? Because it only covers meter zones.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'm rewriting what's in your document. Gotcha. So that for vehicle to If we were by the way, if we were doing something new, I think that it would be proper for this language to show up on the agenda because this is not new. This is like just. Fixing something that should exist that we assumed exists. I don't think it's a big deal.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yeah, I mean, it's like I said, it's likely redundant like the chief said this. I believe there's record somewhere. I just need to have it. On hand for when I get an appeal in the person. Challenges our authority.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there any other commissions or is there a motion?

[Tim McGivern]: I'd motion to approve Alicia's language that she wrote. I just read it. I think it's fine. I think it does what Sarah needs and the police need. And it's on record.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: I'm going to copy paste it into something so that it's. Not just in a chat.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes, I agree. And you can email it to Alva.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: We'll do. I'll just, yeah, I'll resend my original email with this added text to, you know, follow up. Sorry, y'all, I'm losing my mind here. But I am glad you took that other fellow before me because those poor HP people were waiting all night. Okay.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Okay, just make a recommendation that the entire schedule and fees be put into the minutes of the traffic commission.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So, Sarah is going to resend her email with these 3, 3 rules and the traffic schedule fees to Alva and then Alva should include all of that in the minutes. So we have it on the record.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And I think that if it's some other point, especially if there's a light meeting, you wanted to take those other 3 things and. Give us language we can vote on them. Yeah, we're still working. Somebody's working on the updated traffic rules. Right.

[Director Sarah McDermod]: Yeah, and that's a, that's a great opportunity for me to have a lovely document to refer to all of our rules and regs and people appeal tickets. But I just needed these in the meantime, until we get that taken care of finally. So.

[Charlie Hartnett]: So, we have a motion on the floor from commissioner given. Is there a 2nd. The 2nd from commissioner Silva, Alva, please call the role commissioner given.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes, yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Commissioner silver.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Chief Buckley. Yes. Morning affirmative adjourn.

[Charlie Hartnett]: None negative. The motion has been approved. Is there a motion to adjourn?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Motion to adjourn. I have another meeting to go to.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Is there a second? Second. Alva, call the roll.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Mission to McKibbin.

[Charlie Hartnett]: Yes.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Mission to Hunt. Yes. Mission to Silva.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Yes. Chief Buckley. For the final time in my career, yes.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: You won't be with us in December?

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Not in December. I'm leaving. I'm retiring.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I thought you were retiring the end of the month.

[Chair Jack Buckley]: Yeah. Mid-month. Probably tomorrow.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: December 19th.

[Charlie Hartnett]: All right. Thank you, everyone.

[MCM00001607_SPEAKER_07]: Have a good night.

Bruce Kulik

total time: 5.52 minutes
total words: 885


Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Traffic Commission