The Medford Community Development Board reviewed draft amendments to standardize and clean up the city's zoning ordinance. The board also discussed future zoning priorities and voted to advise the City Council to take up Tufts institutional zoning next.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Good evening, welcome to tonight's meeting of the Medford Community Development Board. It's Wednesday, November 4th, 2026. The time is 6.33. I'll call the meeting to order shortly. Please know that the project materials for all projects before the board can be viewed on the city's Medford website, medfordmass.org, forward slash boards dash commissions, forward slash community development board, and by clicking on current CD board filings. For those on Zoom, you can also find the link in the chat. All right, roll call attendance. John Anderson. Present. Thank you. Sean Began. Present. Page Buldini.
[Dina Caloggero]: Present.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Vice Chair, Dina Colagaro.
[Dina Caloggero]: Present.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman is absent. And myself, Doug Carr, Chair, is present. Danielle, can you introduce any staff at the meeting or on the call?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Myself, Danielle Evans, Senior Planner. Um, director Alicia hunt of office of planning, development, sustainability, and we have 1 of our graduate student interns, Natalie Rodman with us. I believe that is everybody.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. Thank you Danielle. I'll briefly summarize tonight's agenda. It's, it's brief compared to previous meetings. We're going to start with the discussion development of items, including the zoning upcoming zoning cleanup draft amendment. We'll talk about zoning updates generally and other administrative updates, and then we'll look at the meeting minutes for our last two meetings as well. The first item is the discussion of the Zoning Cleanup Draft Amendment. Could you please, maybe Danielle, Alicia, give some context about what we're doing here? Because if someone hasn't been here before, it might be a little dense when we get into it.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: So, this is the 3rd meeting 3rd session that we've been talking about this and looking at this, you know, some of it is formatting just consistency. Of the entire ordinance, because it's been a. The zoning changes have been in phases, so it's starting to kind of be like a Frankenstein document. And so we need to make it all consistent. And then there's some. Some things that. Came to light, you know, as we've gone through the process, as you're aware, like, in the incentives, some. You know, different provisions that we've. Developed in the subsequent phases of it. Of the zoning and we would like to. Roll those into the other districts as well. So that's another type of change we're looking at.
Our graduate student interns have been working on combining all the incentive. Um, bonus tables to be 1 kind of standalone section that could be referenced instead of 1 in each section. And I believe they have. Something that they can update you all tonight on. I think that's like, kind of the bulk of. Yeah, we're looking at you here, so nothing that's really like, changing any meaning nothing controversial. just real clean up kind of stuff. And anything bigger would be, I think, taking another time.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So that's fine, Danielle. Go ahead, Dina, why don't you go ahead.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, just a point of clarification, Danielle. So we won't be doing any changes in definitions or any major changes like that, just basically logistical issues to make the document.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Like clarifying things, like not changing meaning. So and just like reaffirming some of the changes, like making clear was Or like throughout the whole ordinance, for example, like the definition of building height and height. Right. The definition of height should have been deleted. Because the definition of building height, the new 1 was to replace that. Yep. Yep.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So, you know, I received a, a document from city council president Zack bears in the last meeting. And I think it came from the, the, the planning committee subcommittee that, that he and that council are on, I believe. They had 3 different tiers of changes, right? And we kind of talked about that. I think I'm not sure if we gave it that you kind of walked us through that. I think. But are we just talking tonight about tier 1 in terms of because tier 3 feels to me, like, it's a more substantial change, like. the Historical Commission, like other things that are really substantial policy changes versus what they described as a Tier 1 as a Scrivener errors, which is some minor things. Maybe, is it worth talking about in general terms or you just want to dive in?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Um, I would so I would say we're doing, like, tier 1 tier 2. like, I think tier 3 are policy discussions, you know, that. Are bigger, like, the historic preservation, like, tweaks to that, like, I don't feel that that's a tier 3 kind of thing. I think that's fixing. A tier 2 item, the intent and the language was put into. You know, the Medford square ordinance, I don't think that went into the boss and have, or maybe it did. Yeah, I think it did. It did, but we just wanted to make those tweaks from the input of the historical commission.
[Jeremy Martin]: Right?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I don't think that that bubbles up to something that's major. I think that that's. Just kind of cleaning it up and just changing some words. so that it makes sense in the existing framework that we have. I don't know if that makes sense.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So how do you want to structure this evening in terms of going through these changes? I assume you have a document you're going to put on screen.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I thought we presented these to the board in our last meeting. I thought we actually did that, and my memory was that the board said, thank you, we need to digest these and think about this a little, and let's come back and readdress. Um, so we don't have major changes from that the 1 that was complex. So there's 1 that some people might call tier 3 and I have to say, I've not seen the document you're referring to. I mean, maybe I produced it in the 1st place, but I don't know that because I don't. I, like, if he sent it to you, and it came from me originally, I'm not sure which document you're referring to.
But the one where we clear up development incentives, we did want to change some stuff in there, right? That might be meaningful to a developer who wanted an easy way out. But I think it's all stuff that we talked about and didn't have time to clean up, and that there is this piece where we want to say that the Mystic Ave, the Salem Street, the Medford Square, all those development incentives should be in alignment as much as is reasonable. And that this would be that partially be that effort.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, no, I, you're correct. I, we did review that. I think it's worth. Taking a fresh look at it to see if anyone has any comments or corrections. I will say that just from putting on my historical commission had for a moment, Ryan Hayward, the chair there has. drafted some language that he will be sharing with Danielle and Alicia, you soon to try to align things. We're going to need your input. We're going to need probably a legal mind to look at it as well for language. So I feel like that one is actually pretty complicated. One of the most complicated, I think, compared to the other ones, like definitions of building height that Danielle mentioned and a few others that I think are pretty straightforward.
So I think it's worth putting them again on screen. Just a brief summary. I don't know if Natalie or someone on the team is going to just kind of briefly go through them and we can open it up for questions from the board. That's what I would recommend, how we proceed.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Natalie, did you want to do it?
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: I'm certainly happy to talk through them. Do you mind just sharing your screen, though, if that's possible?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So why don't I do that? I know. I'm more than happy to. And should we go through them, just start with A, then go to B, then go to C. And I will say that as a process, if the board is conceptually, and I don't mean the details of all the words, but conceptually okay with this process, I'd like to also send it to the city Councilors so they can see what we're working on specifically. And then with the idea that then this board will finish wordsmithing, and then officially send it to the city council who would then officially refer it back here. But I'd like to sort of get their take whether they think it needs to go to a planning and permitting committee or whether it's something that they could just get the final language and be comfortable with.
[Unidentified]: Sounds good.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So here I'm gonna share screen. I'm starting with A.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: So today there's four different amendments to look through A through D. A is definitely the most simple in terms of change. It's standardizing the formatting throughout the ordinance, so we wanted to make sure that everything was as consistent as possible within the text. And as you can see on the screen, there's these example section headings, and so that would be applied. Throughout the ordinance right now, there are some funky things that I think can make it a little bit challenging to understand if something is a header or subsection. So.
Yeah, feel free to take a look. There's different specifications of what the font would be again, so that everything would be consistent. So any questions with that 1.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, it's just formatting.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: Okay. Yeah. Sounds good. Happy to move to the next one.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Looks good. Thank you.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And sorry, I went, there it is. Lost my stop share button. Oops. Second. Sorry. Hmm.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: Right, thanks, Alicia. So, amendment be also kind of on that formatting standardization idea. And so throughout the ordinance, there are sections where tables, for example, aren't captioned. And so we provided an example for how that could be, for example, like table 2.1, Medford zoning district. And then throughout the ordinance, there are currently some inconsistencies with how the numbers and percents or dollars are written. So. the more updated version like Boston Ave will say 10 written out and then in parentheses, the numerical value. Some of the earlier districts, it's maybe just has the number. I think for the Salem I was looking through recently and one had a really funky system. Again, just formatting all of that for consistency, but pretty straightforward as well.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Any questions from anyone on the board about Amendment B? Okay, seeing none, let's go on and see.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: All righty, so amendment C, this is when it gets a little bit more interesting, but again, nothing too, too crazy. In short, currently there are two definitions in the ordinance. There's one for height and one for building height. These are different definitions. The old definition is height, and that's talking about measuring from the curb. And so during the Medford Square rezoning, the new building height definition was added. And that describes measuring from the ground. So. As you can see below, the height definition is struck out and then that building height definition is new. And again, instead, it measures from the ground, which is consistent with how other communities measure. So this is. You know, standard and I believe Alicia, right? The building commissioner had input. So this will happen during the Medford square rezoning, but accidentally both the old height definition and the new building height definition. We're kept in the ordinance and so that creates some contradiction and so. We were trying to think through the best way to go about this. So instead of just removing height and then having to make every little individual change throughout the ordinance that changes it from height to building height to match this new definition, we thought that it would be the most straightforward option to actually change the building height definition to be building height slash height. So that way in the ordinance, if there's reference say the term height is used or the term building height, they would be interchangeable, but that way we would just have that one definition. So again, happy to kind of walk through that a little bit more.
Let's see chair card looks like we have a question do you know you have one go ahead.
[Dina Caloggero]: So, this definition of building height slash height right? This applies to all the will apply to all the zoning districts, not just method square. It will be everywhere.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: Is that correct? Yes, yes, absolutely, yes. So that would be in section 94-12-0 definitions. So, yes, that applies to the whole ordinance, correct? Yeah, thank you.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Natalie, if I might interrupt, what I want people to be really clear on is this is what was voted on during the Medford square with the minor modification that during Medford square the words building height were put there with this definition to and added to section 12 definitions. But because that's literally different from the word height, which is what was previously in our definitions, it didn't replace and nowhere did it say replace height with building height. It just said the definition of building height. On all the slides that were put, and even the document just said, alter section 12 and from that meeting, they're actually 4 or 5 definitions that were added. I may actually still have that file open on my computer that I, I think I'd like to share and show you sort of what. the city council actually voted on that night. And because it didn't say height, it said building height, it was literally and legally a new definition, not altering the old one. But when it was presented to the city council and the CD board in the public hearings, the words that the consultants and I used was we're replacing height with building height. But that's not what the actual document said.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, are you going to share your screen with the other terms?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I was just finding it before I change my screen share, whether it's still open.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And we'll go to you Paige next after after Dina is done.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And say if they want to, if they have any other clarifying questions or whatever before I find it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina, do you have any other additional questions before I move on to Paige?
[Dina Caloggero]: No, I think that's an important point of clarification though, is that the definition supply.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes, and so that was a piece that sort of. I will say that Emily Innes and I thought was just clear was that when you change a definition, you change it for the whole thing unless there's some reason why you wouldn't. But it makes zoning very awkward if you have different definitions depending on which section you're in. Exactly. I feel like it never occurred to us that we had to say that in so many words. Because it just, sorry, it was just obvious to us as planners that, of course, one would do it that way. Okay.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And also the legal public hearing notice did reference that section 12, which is the entire definition section, which applies to the ordinance was being amended. But you don't list everything out in the public hearing notice. You refer to the document that's available. and City Hall are online.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Okay, so actually what I'll do is this is literally the City Council agenda and this is the document that was attached. So you can see here the Medford Square zoning that definitions was page 16. So when we scroll down to page 16, I thought it was six, did I miss it? Here we go, sorry. This is amend. It says this, and it says building height here. And it doesn't say height. And when we went back to make the edits after all the votes, we realized that it actually says height in our current definitions, not building height. So this is exactly what Natalie just showed you. The only edit we made was this adding this to be a slash height. Like as she just said, right, so Medford Square and Boston Ave both refer to building height, but the rest of the zoning refers to height. So rather than trying to make edits throughout the entire document, we thought that if we just called height or building height one definition, but then you also have to say remove the other, the old one. And this doesn't say that. But these other definitions for the record, historic conversion, multiplex, pervious surface, and open space landscape, were added to the definitions of Medford zoning as well with that. And I think people just assume, of course, if you have a definition of pervious surface, it's the same definition regardless of where you are in the zoning.
[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, uh, Alicia, if you don't mind keeping that page up, I want to, uh, yeah. Definition page. I think that's important. Uh, page we'll do any, why don't you go ahead and ask your question.
[Page Buldini]: Thanks real quick in this. I don't know if this is even a question for Sean, but is there any way that having the slash height would be confusing to somebody that wants to like a developer or is that straightforward? I know it seems silly, but I think just wanting to make sure that it's super clear and that that wouldn't be something that would come back.
[Sean Beagan]: You're asking for my opinion on it, Paige?
[Page Buldini]: Yes. I know that you handle this just with the slash and the height.
[Sean Beagan]: That's all. It's not ideal, but I almost think practically it's a better solution than trying to go through the document and making sure that you've hit every reference to the word height and change it to building height. So I think practically it's probably the best solution for a you know, a very lengthy and dense document to do it the way it's being proposed. But yeah, I mean, in a perfect world, you would just have either building height or height, not both, but there's only going to be one definition. So I think it's clear enough.
[Page Buldini]: Perfect. Thank you for weighing in on that. And thank you for Director Hunt for coming up in your team with a creative way. Right.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And I will say we debated whether it should be or height or if it should be with height in parentheses. We kind of and there were several other definitions that start with the word building and we thought it made sense for them to be grouped together alphabetically in the definition section. So that's why we did it that way rather than height slash building height because of the alphabetical. But if particularly Sean and Doug who work with zonings from other communities, if you think that one or another is going to be easier for people, experts who are reading zoning to understand, we were just, we took our best stab at it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And I think that's fine. Can you, first, can you look at the term uniform finish grade? That's actually a term on building height that I don't see a lot when I look at the communities and zoning. I see average grade a lot. I see other, but that one is a term that I think can be a little confusing. What's your understanding of what that exactly means? Make sure we're talking about the same thing.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: That terminology came to us from the building commissioner, who was Scott VanderWaal at the time. So, I mean, this would be the appropriate time to have somebody weigh in. By the way, after Scott left, Bill Forti, our former building commissioner, came back. He has now left. He is now the He was the assistant building commissioner in Brockton and he's now the, the building commissioner. So, we now have the Winchester building commissioner as an on call interim building commissioner. Until we hire someone, but the city is doing interviews. So. Okay, that's helpful because I would want to building commissioner to tell me, because they're the ones I'd be happy to pull members of the building department downstairs.
[Chair Doug Carr]: But you understand what I'm saying. This came up in Medford Square, and I know this is now citywide, which is good. I think we're all in agreement that we want this to be across the city, but we did change the definition of height from a curb, you know, at the street, basically at the front of the building, which it's been probably for my entire life, if not longer, to something that's different. And it's different in a way that I'm not sure is clear.
I want it to be clear, obviously, but if you have a slope site, it's not uniform. It's sloped. What if it's unevenly sloped? What does that mean? What does uniform finish grade mean?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It does say, if you follow the next line, where a building is located on sloping terrain, The height shall be measured from the average ground level of the grade at the building wall. Average ground level shall be determined by locating the mean between the extreme upper and lower finished grades per building elevation. Now, I'm not a contractor, but okay, but isn't that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I agree with what you said makes complete sense, but that to me is a definition of average grade, not uniform Finnish grade. Like, I don't know why. One seems unclear. The blow seems clear to me. But again, I mean, again, Sean and others.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Should these words be average ground level? Because then we have an explanation of how to get the ground level.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I, I, I, I guess my initial answer is yes, but I, again, I would like, you know, maybe the bring in the, the, uh, the city commission because it doesn't seem clear to me. The definition below is clearer than the 1st sentence, in my opinion. So. Um, but 1 of the point about this, um, is that I think, like, this, I know we voted on this back in what? May or June we did method square. It was advertised as you noted for a change, but I think in the scale of what we were doing, I think it was not on a lot of people's radar. And I think it's worth kind of when we go to the final version of this, I would be, I want to be very explicit that the building height definition has been changed citywide with these proposals. This is not a Scrivener's error. This is This is significant, it's clarifying things, but it's a change and I want to make sure that nobody who may have been building, you know, for their whole lives for decades and efforts suddenly, you know, they're not aware that the curb measuring for the curb no longer applies. They have to look at if they have an average grade if they're building drops off like. All the buildings in High Street, for example, on Medford Square dropped down two stories. That's a dramatic change. I want to make sure that nobody is caught off guard and some of their projects coming in the next few years don't get sandbagged by this and have to go to zoning and get relief or whatever. It's just a concern of mine because it stuck up on me. I don't recall it being as big as I think it now is.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And so let me just go back to sharing the version that we were talking about circulating. Because, so wait, this was C, right? Yeah. That was C. I can see the letters in the little. So I did highlight that and say, like, I wanted to add that. So this would be what would be circulated. And we do use the word affirm because I want to be careful that we are clear that it did change legally, but because it wasn't clear to people, we're basically kind of reopening that question.
And it could be that people say, Like, like, it would be legal for us to put this up and then for people to argue against it. And for the board, the city council to say, actually, let's go back to the old definition. Right. But it would be done through the public hearing process.
[Jeremy Martin]: Yes.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And not because somebody goes, wait, I didn't understand. Right.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Right, but what we're in what we're in right now is not a public hearing. We're brainstorming topics and issues. We're not voting on anything. So. We need to have that when we get a document that is. As you said, process you mentioned earlier.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Recommend to the city council that I'm proposing is this could be that document. Agreed I would propose to send something and this is the other thing I'd like to hear from the board. That includes a reason, an explanation of what we're doing, very clearly proposed language, and then very clearly remove this. And so this is the actual strikeout. And then revise this. So this would be what would be revised the definition to apply. And actually, I'm wondering if we insert the following. Oh, right. So this is actually revised. If this was new, we would say insert the following. but this is revised the existing building height definition. Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Are there any other comments from the city board members about this topic? Go ahead, Sean.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, just going back to the verbiage building height slash height. So it's not going to read, if I'm reading this ordinance, if I'm working with this ordinance, I'm either going to be seeing building height or I'm going to be seeing height. I'm not going to be seeing building height slash height. Is that right? Everywhere else in the document. Everywhere else in the document. So I think then it should probably be building height or height. And then maybe a sentence at the end of the paragraph that says the terms building height and height are used interchangeably throughout this ordinance.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Because we measure other things that aren't buildings. So how would we, like fences, like how are those measured then if you just have a building height definition?
[Sean Beagan]: That was my other question is how else? That might be, I don't know.
[Page Buldini]: That's kind of what I was trying to get at, too. If there would be an innocuous thing, that height, that was what I was trying to get to, too. Thank you.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So what's interesting here, though, is that this definition, the old version, was very clearly only for buildings, because it talks about a ground level and ceiling joints, ridge of roof. It doesn't talk about top of any other things. The other thing I can think of easily is a fence. We measure fences. There are zoning about fences. If your fence is over six foot tall and it's within 15 feet of your property line, you need a zoning variance to do it. I have seen zoning meetings go on for months over fence.
in Medford.
[Chair Doug Carr]: What else? Why don't we go on to item amendment D?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: You saw that I made those changes on the fly there. I did. At some point, I'd love this to actually, and if people don't like the format or the layout or how we're doing this, They should say so, so that we can reflect what works best for the committee. I will say that when I did meet with the city council about this six months ago or so, they asked for having some kind of explanation like that in the document. So that's where that came from. All right, Natalie.
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: All right, so amendment D, the final 1 tonight. So previously, I think we discussed how in the different districts, so Mystic Ave, Salem Street, Medford Square, et cetera. Currently, there's different incentive tables for each district. And so as we're working on the Boston Ave zoning, and then kind of fix that affordability loophole, We started to also look at the other incentives, and then Amendment D is really getting at, okay, now that we've kind of sort of fixed that loophole, figured out some of these incentives, we're gonna have one centralized developer incentive table, and then in each of those district sections in the ordinance, it's going to refer to that table. That way, it's just easy central location, and then if there's future iterations or changes, It can just change that 1 table instead of having to go back to each and every district. And so I mentioned that we kind of looked at those other incentives in the table and really used that affordability incentive as. A benchmark to try to figure out whether or not the different incentives were proportional both to the community benefit and then what a developer would have to provide. So, Alicia, if you don't mind scrolling all the way to the bottom, there's an example. Development incentive perfect. Yeah, and then just scoot up a little more.
Okay, yeah, so here's an example of some of the proposed edits that we made to the development. Incentives, nothing major was added. It was more so removing certain incentives that maybe developers would already have to provide. So, like, community amenities, for example, a lot of that would already be provided through site plan review. We also made some formatting changes, so previously all the incentives were just listed in the table, but we added numbers such as incentive 3, 3A, 3B, just so it's a little bit easier to refer to each incentive.
We didn't change the number of stories too much. There were a couple where we maybe changed it from a full story to a half story, just again, with the proportionality in mind, and then a couple of clarifying issues. But happy to talk through any specific incentives if anything jumps out to people. But again, it was mostly cleaning up and trying to think about proportionality and what makes sense for developers to provide.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Natalie. Are there any questions? Go ahead, John Anderson. Go ahead and unmute yourself.
[John Anderson]: Thank you. I just wanted to ask a question about below grade. In the case of when you have a building which say, but it's two different streets at two different levels. The parking might be below grade from one street, but at grade on another street. You follow me?
[Jeremy Martin]: I do.
[John Anderson]: So is it above grade or below grade if it's below grade from one street and at grade on another street?
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: I'll take a first pass at that and then Danielle, Alicia, if you have any thoughts. That must be for incentive 3, 3A, the concealed parking. Is that what you're referring to? Yes. I think the idea here is that we don't want parking that's really visible to the public, just large swaths of parking. That concealed is really the key word there. Whether it's maybe like a below ground parking garage or sometimes with parking garages they have Nice structure, so that's why that within building would be concealed. So, um. Yeah, let me know if that if that answers your question.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, because it doesn't hinge on, like, the incentive doesn't hinge on whether it's below grade. Just. It could be within the structure below grade, but that it's concealed. So, if it was a sloping law and so partially below grade, but you could see it where. you know, the topography revealed it all, then I wouldn't consider that concealed and eligible.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I can give you an example. I did a building once where the 12 foot high parking garage was 6 feet down, 6 feet up. Above the average grade around that building, but it so it was below grade partially, but it was all concealed. You could not see in the car. I think that's to Natalie's point is that's what this incentive is really about because you're right. John is going to be with different grades on different sites. You could have a garage come out at 1 level and the other. But if it's all contained, that gets you, I think, the additional half story that Natalie referred to. That's how I would read it. I don't know if Alicia or Danielle have any additional thoughts on that. Go ahead, John.
[John Anderson]: If something is concealed below grade, isn't it automatically within the building structure?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Uh, well, some crosses are open right for air requirements. So, sometimes they could be actually, they could be below grade, but you could see them if they were right next to the sidewalk. So, it really depends on the design, John, in my opinion. And within a building structure, it could be quite visible. It could be, and the intent here is the concealed part. I think that's what we're saying is that we don't want to see the cars activate the streetscape. That's the concept we're trying to do here.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I think it's also just to, through the chair, not concealed by a fence or concealed by vegetation, but concealed these ways.
[John Anderson]: So my old mathematical logic is clicking in here. It depends whether you mean it's concealed either below grade or within the building structure, or if you mean it's concealed below grade or within a British building structure. You follow me? I just think it needs to be clearer. What would make it clearer?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: The header says concealed parking.
[John Anderson]: Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Can you think of anything John?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: You said parking is concealed either below grade or within a building structure. Works for me.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. That seems reasonable.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: You all don't mind this working document?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sure. Did you have a comment on that, Shona?
[Sean Beagan]: I was going to say the same thing. If you could insert the word, parking is concealed either below grade. And if you want to really make it clear or concealed within a building structure.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I see he was concealed twice. Oh, that's pretty clear.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And honestly, I appreciate it because what happens is we get too close to this and then we know what it means and then we are not reading it other ways. So I'm not like, we're not offended by edits to this.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Other comments or questions on is now, did you finish your talk on this piece?
[vIXAnO_MxfQ_SPEAKER_04]: If there were any specific ones that folks wanted to talk about a little more happy to give some more details, but, um. Yeah, most of them are the same, just a couple of tweaks here and there to try to make things a little clearer. And then, again, the biggest change is this affordability incentive, which over the summer we talked about in depth, so that's all squared away, but that was really, I think, the most crucial one to change.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Natalie. Go ahead, Paige.
[Page Buldini]: Real quick, I just have, it's more, I'm curious on the community incentives, incentive two, but I've seen it a couple of times where it says low income shared community solar incentive to be confirmed. What is, what does that mean? I'm just curious.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I'll answer it two ways. So just to be clear, that first part I skimmed through very quickly just now. Those were all just saying delete this table from, delete this table from, delete this table. And the table that's deleted is there in each case. So this is the table we're suggesting putting it in there. So this is the only language going forward that would matter. I will tell you that conceptually, that idea came through the city council. And it's an idea that came from the Energy and Environment Committee with this idea of community solar is a public benefit. It's stuff that people who can't put solar on their own homes can buy into and get the benefit of an actual solar array. And there is both a technical benefit to having it be local and an emotional benefit to it being a local building that you can point to. So this is the current version of the language. I almost do wonder if we want to run it by the Energy Committee too and see if this is making sense. I believe this language in the end came from Councilor Bears, Council President Bears, and I'm not sure where he got it from. I'd almost want to run it more by the state, the Department of Energy Resources to see if like, These are things when you build a solar array and the electricity from that array is being used by certain entities, you get extra benefits, financial benefits from the state. And those entities, I'm certain include low income programs. Municipal people are always trying to sell us solar credits because they get more money if a municipality buys them.
[Page Buldini]: That's what I found really interesting, so thank you for looking to that, because that could be an extra extra benefit. So, and I love that idea. I just wanted to be clear that I was understanding that they can sell it back.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So, originally, the idea was that they wanted to just say community solar, but that can be limiting because it's harder to do and it's unclear that they could get all that legal arrangement set up. before they build their building and how can they guarantee that they will find like a correct off taker? I mean, in theory, maybe the city might agree to buy the electricity before the building is built. So I haven't seen it actually done in practice, particularly the community solar yet, but I do understand they're out there. Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And when we're done tonight, I assume we'll be circulating this document to us. But as you send it to the city council, we obviously have another bite at the apple, I guess, for any last fine tuning. But I think that would be helpful because we're making changes. And I agree getting to the council is important to keep the ball moving. Go ahead, John Anderson.
[John Anderson]: I think I raised this once before at another meeting. Outdoor pedestrian plaza. I've seen two situations where the developer put a pedestrian plaza on top of a parking garage and it was plenty big and it was accessible to the public during business hours by walking up several flights of stairs. But I can tell you that no one ever used it. I mean, I had a view of the, And it was very pretty, but.
[Chair Doug Carr]: How does the plaza up in the air become a plaza? Isn't that a roof deck? Isn't that a different term? Can we clarify that? Meaning at grade or near it?
[John Anderson]: Well, okay. Yeah, that would be very helpful.
[Chair Doug Carr]: What do you think, Alicia and Danielle, can we just say, we don't want it to be four stories in the air. That's not really accessible, honestly. John's right about that. But we mean that the intent of this is clearly to be at street level, to activate the pedestrian environment, not be up in the air, two, five, 10, eight stories, whatever it is.
[John Anderson]: It wasn't quite that bad, but it was good enough.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, but if no one could get there, it's not really.
[John Anderson]: Yeah, yeah.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That's your point, I think, right, John?
[John Anderson]: Yeah.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I think accessible to street level, I think is, and I guess we, it can't be an elevator. It has to be something that you can, it's, I don't know.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I thought the whole thing was that unless you, um, We had the minimum or the maximum setbacks. And you could only go deeper if you had a pedestrian plaza in the front. Yeah, I feel.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I lost a word, but are you suggesting Danielle that maybe this shouldn't be an incentive?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Well, no, I mean, because it didn't have to be active. You know, or it didn't have to be open to the public. But I'm just, I'm wondering if, have we defined like a plaza somewhere else or. That's a good question. I mean, do we care if it's visible to the public? Do like, I guess. Well, then that's right. Yeah, it would be visible to the public. Yeah, I mean, well, I mean, like, could it be tucked away? Like, could you walk down. You know, like an alley and there could be like this beautiful garden in the back that's tranquil and you can go enjoy it like. I would rather have that than something right up against Mystic Ave, personally. I wouldn't want to foreclose that option.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah. I think this board wants flexibility too. If we see intent being, we don't want to. I think this board would do that. If somebody did create one down an alley, they had a public sign saying, courtyard open to the public, that seems perfectly reasonable. But to John's point, if it's three stories in the air, or 20 feet in the air, and it's not well signed, and it's not really visible, that's not really the intent. It's the public realm. I'm sure there's language in here somewhere we can draw upon.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I did just quickly check our definitions, and we don't have a definition for plaza or public plaza. So what is it could be an example. So there are a number of things that we don't have. So there's another category that I think we should consider through this cleanup is that there are words there are uses in our zoning table that do not have definitions. There are also definitions in our zoning that are not in the use table, which is sort of weird. We do have a list of both of that. I'd actually love to copy that into your folder and then circulate those as things that anywhere where they're non-controversial, it would be good if we actually added those defs. So I'm not saying come up with something new and start updating use tables, but rather particularly the ones that exist in the use table with no definition feels nervous. And there are a few definitions that we feel like need to get cleaned up.
Do we want to, let me hold that thought because I had some examples. I went down a rabbit hole today, but let's finish on this. And actually, Natalie, are you able to like, do you know where that list is? I can find it pretty quickly. I just wanted people to look at all of this before we moved on.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I Daniel, I remember 1 of the intent of this is you felt and I think you were speaking on behalf of the PDF staff that some of these incentives were so. Going to be required by this for a site plan review that they really want incentives that wasn't going above and beyond. They already were getting it. That's not part of this.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, we definitely want. There we don't want to be just giving things away that they would ordinarily already do. Yeah, they are meant to be above and beyond. But it's tough to kind of like, where is where is that line? Because sometimes. A condition where you require a developer to do something is because it's mitigating some. Possible detriment of the development, so you have this nexus, like, you wouldn't have required it for a different project. Because of whatever, like, it doesn't have the same impact. So. I guess there's some kind of gray area there, but I mean, like, engineering has their requirements. Like, you rebuild the sidewalk and.
To their to their standards and. There's other things that could trigger other things that they would require in the public way or not. But I don't think that they require any street furniture or anything like that. And I'm not sure. Yeah, so the tree planting, we have a street tree ordinance or it's written somewhere where they have to replace them or contribute to the fund. Yes, we do want to make sure that we're not giving bonuses for things that they would have to do anyways.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yep. Alicia, do you have any other examples you want to share?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I so I just wanted people to have looked at these because I feel like when you're in the meeting together, this is when we get like the best synergy where people bounce ideas off of each other to read through what these are. This is obviously not by any chance your last, you can go read this tonight and send us edits or whatever. I think that I would like, I think that this isn't a solid enough position that it would make sense for us to send it to Councilor Leming as chair of the planning and permitting committee and Councilor Bears and say, These are the ones that we're working at on. Do you want this to go through planning and permitting to be workshopped?
Or do you wanna just refer to the council to go through the public hearing process? But people, we can still be, we don't have to say this is the final version, just as this is a working draft. We wanted to share our working draft. Because I feel the first three we looked at, A, B, and C, I feel like they're good. I don't know what other edits we'll make. All right. So if we've looked at this, I don't see any more hands. I actually have that table of definitions that I'd like to just show you where that stands right now and have a conversation as to whether people think that's something that we could be working on. or is that like a harder thing that needs to wait?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Let me go to John Anderson first.
[John Anderson]: Go ahead, John. How do we validate that these incentives make sense? What I'm getting at is, What I'm getting at is there might be an incentive that is so inexpensive that any developer is always going to do it, in which case it's kind of a giveaway. Or there might be one that's so expensive, nobody would do it. I mean, is there any way to put an economic value on these things to see if they make sense?
I mean, it's certainly not something I could do. It's something that a developer would figure out for themselves.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That's a fair question. Danielle or Alicia, do you have any thoughts on that? I have my own, but I would like you guys to go first.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Well, I think that's what we're trying to figure out here. Of course, costs aren't fixed. Sometimes something will cost more. And then, you know, one year and then, you know, another year, it's less. It's not an exact science. I think we've tried to kind of balance it. I think because we can change this, we can see what works if there's What appears to be kind of like a giveaway loophole, like, I feel like that will become apparent. Pretty quickly 1 thing we'd like to do is track the incentives that are being taken and kind of see if things need to be adjusted and whether. It matches our priorities of what we're trying to get.
[John Anderson]: Have we compared this with incentives offered in other communities? Yes, that's what I was going to ask. Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Danielle, I mean, every city is different, obviously, but any thoughts there?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I have not, I don't know what work Natalie and Izzy did. I know you were trying to calibrate these. That's what you had talked about at the beginning, but I didn't actually question you as to what exactly you did.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I don't know. So the original tables were developed by the consultant team too. So I'm not sure like where, you know, they were pulling things. But I mean, like, I guess it, you know, it's all kind of like relatives, like you're not going to be necessarily comparing apples to apples. Like if you're. If your, your base heights and base allowances are pretty low and there's an expectation that they'll want to do more than that. And here's your menu of things to do, then maybe it would feel like it's more permissive. Um, but in maybe another community where.
They're really supposed to be like, real reaches because they already allow so much. It could look different over there. Like, I think it's could be really difficult to. Really have a comparison.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I, I think I agree with that. I have some additional thoughts, but Dina, do you have any other thoughts?
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, I'm just I was just trying to figure out the origin of these. So they, they, they came from consulting right? Were they also some of these implemented or suggest or recommended as part of the planning and development committee, the planning and permitting committee to. And I think your point about what works in one community might not work in another. I think that's a very one. So, you know, the origin of these were originated from another community would be very, very helpful, you know, but they're already there. I think it's important also to consider how we're going to maintain these as well. You know, method does a good job of introducing things sometimes, but perhaps that's not such a good job of maintaining thing and to ensure the incentives remain intact.
That's all.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Dina. I do have a couple of thoughts. I actually think Danielle hit it right on the beginning when she said, we are writing zoning that is written in pencil, not stone. We are going to test this, and when we see things that work, that are good, we're going to note it. When we see things that we don't want, we're probably going to change that zoning. I think Council President Bears and Matt Leming, to their credit, have agreed to that. They want to move fast, but they also realize that this is something that is going to be fluid, that is going to evolve, and I think that's the key part here. I'll give you a new example though the gentleman who's going to be proposing Titan gas site on 590 Boston Ave. He is preparing his proposal now, but he's not taking the full height that is allowed on that site that we passed just recently, just in September. And I'll be speaking to them shortly because he likes the simple five-story building. He's got four stories over one story of parking with an entrance. That works for his economic model to go two stories higher, which he could have.
with some of the restrictions, maybe additional affordable, maybe the step backs we talked about. He has chosen and his developers have chosen to stick with what they have. rather than try to go to more stories. And I'm going to ask him why and try to get that data. Tracking it is critical. I think Danielle and Alicia are spot on there. We need to understand the motives behind developers, the decisions they're making so that it informs us better.
[Dina Caloggero]: That makes good sense to me. Thank you, Doug.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sure thing. Any other comments or questions before I turn it back to Alicia to continue moving forward? All right, go ahead, Alicia. You were about to move on, I think.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, I think that I would like to. So this wasn't in your packet until maybe five minutes ago. But in the interest of sort of working on these things, I'd like to share it and get a take on people's thoughts on this one. So this does not have the description up at the top. But what this does have is So as you can see, everything that's in orange, oh my gosh, I just turned my screen so you could see it better.
Everything in orange is a language that does not technically have a definition in our zoning, which is fascinating. There is some sort of definition that I think is pretending. So detached single family dwelling is what used to be called a single family house. And I thought we had something, but I'll sort of scroll through these so you have these. So we have dwelling, dwelling multiple, dwelling one unit attached in our zoning, dwelling one unit detached, dwelling two units, and we have dwelling unit as definitions, but we don't have it framed these way. And I'm going to tell you that I have run into situations where people say, what is this? Is this an attached single family dwelling? Is this a two family? Is this like, what is this? Is this a townhouse?
But then let's go down to some of the others. Um, so historic conversion, so, but we now have that that was in that last group that we just saw and multiplex. We just added that in in that the Medford square one. Yep. These are other things that there's no actual definition and it's sort of like, the use is supposed to be the definition. We don't have definitions for public fire station or library. Maybe we don't need them. We don't actually have a definition for essential services. We don't know what that means.
And it's actually come up, Cataldo Ambulance is looking for a location in Medford. Are they a private medical use or are they an essential service or an other municipal use? Because the reason they're looking for a location is they are our contracted ambulance provider and they need to be located in the city of Medford to be doing a good job. just flagging that as an example. We come further down, trade professional or other school operated for profit. Some of these might be Z. Laboratory office, clinic not affiliated with any other institution. So these definitions are different than the ones that we use neighborhood medical office.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, also I noticed when, sorry to interrupt, I had someone inquiring about a use and what they would be qualified under the office use. And that's when it became apparent to me that there's a, yeah, so there's business, professional, or government office. So there's office, business, professional, or government. And none of that has kind of like medical kind of uses in it, but then there's professional office. which repeats the word professional, but is different. It has another kind of mishmash of uses that do include some kind of medical uses like lawyers, dentists. And in the definition section, I noticed that there's like office comma medical, and then there's actually a medical office definition elsewhere. So they're like, which one is it? So that's another example. And I don't think I added it to our running list because I couldn't find it at the time, but I wanted to flag that.
And it's one of those things that you don't even realize is an issue Until you're looking something up and you're like, oh.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, so and then actually, I really, really have a pet peeve right now with the. The auto uses, but I will say that some of the adult, the marijuana establishment definitions, I know the delivery definition changed at the state level, but it's not 1 of these. So eating places.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sean, did you have a comment about that?
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, no, I was just going to come. I'm just going to agree with what Alicia and Danielle is saying, and that when someone's using this ordinance, they're starting oftentimes or frequently referring back to these definitions. And if the definitions aren't clear, It becomes very frustrating for someone who's trying to use the ordinance. I've had personal experience where I've actually taken. I think if you scroll back up to the beginning, some of those descriptions of single family type structures, I've thrown those into Google just to see what Google describes them as because it's unclear what exactly they are. If you don't, you know, if you're using it all the time and you're familiar with the building department, you probably know what they are. But if you're coming to this from another town, if you're an attorney who works in another town a lot, and you're not used to Medford or you're someone in Medford who is using this one time, it's really some of these definitions are not, without a proper definition, the terminology is not clear. And I've run into that myself with Medford zoning. So I think they do need, all those blanks do need some definition.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And we've run into people making assumptions. We recently had somebody assuming their use was a warehouse use. And we're like, actually, that's like co-house. It was just like the one that we did the site plan review for, the co-warehouse, the co-making space. Another company wants to come do that in Medford. And they thought they had an as of right use. And we're like, hold on, no, you don't. And we know you don't because we just made this other group go through it. And by the way, it's definitely a special permit. I wanted to stop at the automotive ones. And I just have to say that that's where I realized that we changed them during the recodification. So today I went down the rabbit hole and I checked and the recodification zoning has these motor vehicle, these terms, and the version immediately before that, that we were using through 2020 did not define basically any of these. And our use table said gas station or gasoline station. And this motor vehicle light service station, I'm telling you, That's a gas station.
And the reason it is is because a building or premises used for the dispensing, sales, or offering for sale of motor fuels directly to users of motor vehicles. That's a gas station. Other sales activities and any repairs shall be activities minor in scope and clearly subordinate to the sale of motor fuels, oils, and lubricants. No drive-through facilities are permitted without further zoning relief. Which I went, wait, what? Although I will tell you that in our site plan review, right, Danielle? It says that gas stations are required to go through site plan review.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I'm saying that I think so. I know that convenience stores do.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia, it doesn't say fuel in the actual use, right? It says motor vehicle, right? Wouldn't it? No, I know.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, not in the use term. Yes. You got to add fuel, right? I mean, it should be like a fueling station, right? But I had someone when they were looking to site a remote What was it like a autonomous vehicle, like charging area, or like, it's not a parking lot, but it was like a facility. And they were saying, well, we're a light service station. And they were trying to say that that's what they were. And I'm like, well, this, I mean, like fuel, I guess electricity is fuel, but
[Director Alicia Hunt]: My definition doesn't contemplate EVs. I think actually, Danielle, we were wrong. And what I'll say now is that now that I realize that this definition was added in the recodification, my theory is that, in fact, this was crafted in a way to contemplate EVs and charging high-speed charging banks. in addition to gas stations. I think that was the suggestion and it went so quickly by in that whole multi-year process that I don't remember that occurring. But it's the only thing that makes sense because the version before doesn't have this in it and the use table in the version before says gasoline station. So I did just site plan review, says that site plan review shall be required for a major project for the purposes of the SERP section, the term major project shall mean, and number 8 is gasoline service station. Which by the way, not defined, and unless you want to say this is it, is not in our use table.
[Sean Beagan]: Most towns have an additional requirement, whether it be special permit for gas stations and then also fire department inspection and permit.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I do know they need some tank, fuel tank permit because we permitted when we went through the BJ's gas station. The BJ's gas station went through site plan review, Nobody argued with that. But then they needed their fuel tank permit from the city council, and they denied that, but they got appealed in court, and the court basically said you did not deny it for a nexus.
[Sean Beagan]: I remember that.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah. But they also added a bank of charging stations. but during site plan review, we said, we think you should add charging stations to your property because you're adding a gas station and you're a big store. We think it makes sense. And they said, okay, they might've actually done that. They said, maybe I think during site plan review, I can't remember if that was ended up being a requirement, but they came back during the fuel tank permit and said, we're also adding charging stations. And we thought they were putting in level two charging stations and they put in eight high-speed charging stations.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That's an immense investment.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: We were thrilled. Yeah. Wasn't what I meant, but it's better.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Take the win.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I thought that we couldn't, like, that's something that big would be, we couldn't require of them, but they did it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Harmon Zuckerman, PB — He, him, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, his, Okay. I think there's so many here. I don't think we can do it like live editing.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Definitions that we couldn't.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Right.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: But I'm, and I will say there is an option here that if we filled in 10 of the definitions and move that through, we could do that without doing all of them. Right. We could do, maybe there's low hanging fruit in here. Um, I think it's something we need to start picking at.
[Dina Caloggero]: Could we could we look at other cities and towns and see what they've come up with? I mean, obviously there must be other definitions that are out there for motor vehicle repair establishment, right? Or light service stations. I mean, we could look. Right and so I mean, I'm surprised and this didn't do this since. They have more they've done zoning and other cities and towns and communities.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It is that I don't think they really update them. Looking at tables and other communities is fascinating and we can make that an exercise for the students.
[Dina Caloggero]: I can't, I just like to see, I mean, you know, perhaps we could glean some, some more favorable definitions or assistance with these, you know, especially where in other cities, towns where those ordinances have been in place for a long time too. So they've been, you know, tested.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Well, what we find is that people just kind of make things fit. I remember looking at Molden and I feel like they have, Retail and they have like, I felt like they had 10 definitions for you.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: The less I've worked in 3 other municipalities, so. Everyone does a little bit different, but there's a lot of borrowing and a lot of the sameness.
[Sean Beagan]: The less clear the definitions are, the more at the mercy. The developer or the representative is. to the building commissioner. And depending on the type of building commissioner you have, you may want a very loose, vague definition, or you may want a very tight definition. But I prefer a very clear, tight definition.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And it's changed three times, as you noted before, in the last five years. So it's like there's no continuity here.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah. So I feel like I'm hearing that one of the next steps Would it be if we could ask Natalie and Izzy if they could start. Like, 1 of the projects on their plate is starting to research some of these and come up with suggested definitions. That we could look at, and it sounded like. I feel like we want to talk about what are the most urgent ones, which maybe are the 1st 3. Up there and then come back to these.
So like these are uses, but not found in the use table. Oh, so this is also a list of definitions that he found in our definitions section, but are never listed in the uses. So just flagging that.
[Unidentified]: OK.
[Dina Caloggero]: So these documents are on the shared drive, right?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Is it on the shared drive, this document? It's in, right. If you went back to your meeting packet for tonight, this copy is there now.
[Dina Caloggero]: Very good. Thank you. Thank you.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It was not there in advance.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yep. Go ahead, John.
[John Anderson]: John, you're muted. Yep. Could you go back to gas stations for a minute? My favorite thing. Where are we?
[SPEAKER_08]: Sorry, I searched on auto and I ended on autopsies. Okay.
[John Anderson]: Here we go.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: No, this is not it.
[John Anderson]: This is good. Light service station. I mean, I recently took my car to a place that sold gasoline, but they also did inspections and they had cars up on a lift. They're doing brake jobs and buffer repair and stuff like that. So they're more than a light service station, but a motor vehicle repair establishment doesn't say they get to sell gasoline and stuff like that.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: We've always said you could have two uses in one building.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, okay. I think so, yeah, that and this raises another things like, when is something like considered. Like, accessory to it, like, if they're not both kind of like, equal weighted uses. And 1 thing I think that has come up before is like, whether, you know, the charging electric vehicle charging stations, you know, where you're allowed to put those. I feel like it's sort of just been silent on that. And as long as it didn't remove a parking spot, then it was okay.
But that is sort of like an accessory use, especially if we're defining the motor vehicle light service station as being any kind of fuel. And is that inadvertently creating a hurdle for EV charging? Kind of like a bank of EV chargers, like they're all sudden, well, that's a light service station. I just feel like there should be more.
[Chair Doug Carr]: It's primary use, right? If it's 10 of those level three chargers, right? And that they also happen to have a little repair. Isn't that primary and tertiary or secondary use?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Well, I'd like to put my sustainability hat on. I actually think we should have separate definitions. And one is a gas station and you regulate it one way. And the other is whether and then actually, maybe it's. Electric vehicle, high charging stations accessory to a primary use. And the other is as a standalone use, right? Because if you had target, say, I want to put charging stations, a bank of them in my parking lot. Would we that that should be an easy thing for them to do. And if you, but if you had a company come in and say. We just want to set up private charging a building where we're going to store our vehicles, park our vehicles and charge them. And it's for us for privately. I don't know if we want that to be easy for them to just do. I'm not sure. I'd want to think about that some more.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And what about places where they're like, it's really tight parking and. Like, they just barely meet their parking minimums and then they, set up some desirable rapid charging stations, and then they're open to the public. And so is that somehow removing one of their parking spaces if it's not always available? Or does that have to be expressly permitted as shared parking? If it's just customers only, I feel like that's just a parking space where you conveniently can charge your car.
At some point, like, cross over into. Like, uh, an charging. Station you sets. Just happens to be in that line.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sure, go ahead.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I mean, it sounds like. I'm just thinking about different areas in Medford where there are EV charging stations, and I'm thinking about one that comes to mind is right next to the Ocean State job lot, and that there's just a bunch of charging stations. I have no idea who they actually belong to, but it's certainly not part of any larger business. It's just a set of charging stations. Somehow, you know, someone owns them. Someone got a permit to put them there.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And they're only Teslas, I think, so it's like, I can't use them.
[Sean Beagan]: Right, it wasn't under a motor vehicle light service station use.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And interestingly, I'll tell you that I'm pretty sure that they just got an electrical permit. I never saw a building permit come through.
[Sean Beagan]: I'm sure they did. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. So I guess we have to, maybe that's another question for the building commissioner is how are you approving EV charging stations?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: He doesn't work here anymore.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Right, but let's think about this. Because, I mean, as someone who owns two EVs, I've really been dealing with this for about eight or nine years now. EV charging stations are different than gas stations because they're basically just an outlet somewhere. You can have them anywhere. Right in your garage on your house. It's not the same. I don't have a gas pump in my garage or or didn't but I can have an EV charger anywhere and they're going to become ubiquitous like at metered spots on the city of Medford streets are that's we've already seen a few of those per Alicia's efforts and others and the sustainability. We it's going to be just a different animal than then gas stations and gas charging because it's going to be All over the place, you know, and I think I agree with Alicia thinking about it that we probably want to have a little bit more of a definition, not just fuel, but say, you know, and try to expand it. Exactly. Try to expand, try to give a lot of leeway because they're going to be everywhere. They already are.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: This is an interesting question. When we installed curbside charging in a couple locations in the city, it didn't occur to anybody that we needed permission from anybody except the city and DPW to be saying this is public right away spaces we want to use. We got a question in the last week from a private party who owns two multifamily buildings in Medford, and he wants to know if he can install curbside charging stations that he would own and operate and people would pay to use.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Wow. That's interesting.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And I asked for the addresses because I said to him, the answer may be different if you're talking about a private way, a public way, or a state road. And in my mind, I was thinking state road is a non-starter. No. Definitely not. But I will just say that the locations he's looking at are public ways. So I feel like this is now, this is an interesting question, right? It's a benefit to the city. It would be a heck of a lot easier on me and my department if someone else owned and managed them.
[Sean Beagan]: But- Is it in a residential neighborhood?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes, in front of multifamily houses.
[Sean Beagan]: So you're running a business in a residential neighborhood.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right, and the curb space is not theirs. The city owns it. And he acknowledged that, which is why he's reaching out and having a conversation. but it would make it easier for the city. Sure.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, Paige.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: We would have to get a cut, I think.
[Chair Doug Carr]: One word at a time.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah. And just full disclosure, like I also drive an EV and I want the proliferation of charging. EV chargers wrap it in just regular level two ones, but make We need to address it. It has to be addressed in your ordinance.
[Sean Beagan]: It sounds like it, yeah. Paige, did you have a thought?
[Page Buldini]: Yes, I appreciate this conversation because I know that, I don't know how far it's gone on, but in the hillside specifically, residents are interested in learning about, like, I have an EV, we have a charger on our house too. We have two EVs, actually, like you, Doug. But it would be for renters. So I think getting really clear about what that could look like. And there was discussion about how that would go over sidewalks and accessibility. So it is a conversation that's happening. So I hope that this could be clear so that we can have guidelines for potential ordinances that could come as well.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Paige. All right. Alicia, what's what's next here? I've kind of lost where we are going to try to go through to try to low hanging fruit approach.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So my thought here's here's what I would suggest. I take A, B, C and D. And send them to the Councilors bear and Leming and just say, like, here's what we're thinking about and talking about to keep you in the loop. Would you would you want something like this refer direct to city council? Would you want to also take a look at planning and permitting? Let's have a conversation. I would also like to send an email to the CD board.
Number D, which was the, the table, the. the complicated one, and then this one, let's start to call it E, the table of uses, and send it to you all to just mull over, think about, put your own notes on, start to have opinions outside of the meeting, which you could then send to us or bring to the meeting, depending on your preference. Well, I'm also gonna ask Natalie and Izzy to look at their workload around start, first priority is that table of the incentive tables. What else can we figure out on that? What research? I think they need to meet with Danielle and myself to sort of talk about how do we attack that. And then the second on their list would be to start working on some definitions Bring us example definitions, or this is what everybody says, or this is what the dictionary says, or whatever, but start to think about that for a future meeting. To look at and to start, like, as conversation starters.
And honestly, if you all have suggested or strong opinions, just send them over and that can inform Natalie and Izzy as well.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That sounds like a good plan.
[Dina Caloggero]: I think we're good.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So let's close out the zoning cleanup section of this meeting and proceed accordingly. I think that's good. I would like people to send their comments to Alicia and Danielle and the staff in advance of our next meeting, just so we can have maybe a consensus document that would be available, you know, maybe with a packet, which would help
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Oh, 1 comment I noticed that there's a member of the public who wants to comment. But what I realized is I didn't put it. To the public files, I just put it in your packets. So, I do think that maybe I should, we should update any of these documents that we edited during the meeting and this document and put it in the public repository. So the public could send us opinions. Sure. Yeah, that's a good idea.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And I know this is not a public hearing, but there are a few people who have been here and someone who's applied to this board. Jeremy Martin is also raising his hand. I'd like to acknowledge him. Go ahead, Jeremy. Give us your thoughts.
[Jeremy Martin]: Thanks, everyone. And Alicia, on that last point you made, that would be appreciated. I always like to try and read up on these things when I can. I'm Jeremy Martin. I live in the Hillside neighborhood. Just wanted to share a couple comments on the discussion tonight. These are coming from my experience working as a landscape architect with developers on projects where we're evaluating zoning and different zoning implications. One is on the discussion around uniform finish grade versus average finish grade. I almost always see average finish grade as the definition there, because that allows both flat and sloped sites to be considered. So that seems like the right Definition there to me from experience and then the other is around the conversation on the incentive on public plazas as a, as a potential incentive.
I do think that the notion of giving some flexibility to a developer to think about where that public amenity space is located is good, but we often hear from the community when we are working for, let's say, like a university on a project or even a private developer that when public spaces are set back or are concealed, even though there might be a sign that says they're public or people might know about it, the perception is that they're not welcome in that space. The public are not welcome in that space. And so in that incentive, it seems like the biggest value for the community that this is meant to support is having space that feels public, that appears public. And so associating a public plaza or a public pocket park or whatever with the public way and the urban realm, the public realm would really make that the most effective version of that incentive. I hope you all will consider that as you are refining these definitions. That's all I had to add. Thank you very much.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thanks, Jeremy. I appreciate it. Is there any other member of the public who'd like to comment on some of the conversation we've had over the past hour plus on the zoning definitions, etc? If you do, please raise your hand. If not, we're going to move on to the next agenda item. Okay, seeing none, let's move on. I believe the next one is really talking about the overall zoning update project and other admin updates. And Alicia and Danielle, I thought it might be worth just updating people to talk about where we are with the zoning consultant, the communications consultant for zoning, and a couple other things. And the schedule that we're still talking about for the next one to two years, if it's worth reiterating that, if you don't mind.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Do you want me to go, Danielle? I've been managing the RFP, so I believe the RFP is out. The procurement office told me they were putting it out. I saw they sent me an email that it was out. And we're looking for proposals back in like mid to late December. The goal would be to do interviews and make decisions in January. to hire somebody in February. I think the idea is to do sort of startup light lift things on the zoning during this spring. There was some concern, not so much concern as sort of an acknowledgement that the city is going to be working on the override for the high school. And so we didn't want to be doing something highly controversial at the same time. We kind of wanted to have that be you know, the focus, the high school override. So if we were doing some lighter lift stuff, uh, one thing that we were recommending from our office to do first is to maybe look at the Wellington area because we did that transformation study. We did a lot of outreach to residents there, um, and property owners. And so it's, we'd like to do that zoning while it's still fresh in people's minds that the people who participated in the study, um, But how that actually plays out, I think we still need to see how the winter and stuff goes.
We are putting it out as a three year RFP. That way, if things take three years, we don't have to be doing all these extensions. And if it doesn't take three years, you can finish when you finish. So that is the RFP. We also did interviews for a communications consultant. We have to make a final decision and then negotiate with the preferred company for that. The goal would be to get that decided and that information out as part of the RFP so that the people who are bidding can take that into account as part of their bidding.
I think that covers that piece. Any questions on our piece?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Just one question on that. If we have the cleanup zoning for this fall, the high school becomes a big focus. Wellington would be in the spring of next year. When would, do you think that we could complete Wellington next year in the midst of all what's going on?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think it depends how controversial it is and how straightforward it is. Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm just thinking about when does Taos happen? When does West method happen? Now, those are the next two dominoes, if you will, to fall.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And are there general feeling was that those would become much more heated and people would have much more passion about, and that's why waiting for the fall for them. But. Nothing set in stone.
[Chair Doug Carr]: OK, but so go ahead, Paige, and then I'll have Dina go next after pitch.
[Page Buldini]: Thank you. Just to be clear, because I guess I'm confused from the last meeting that we kind of talked about this and up to definitely discuss. I know we had talked about actually doing Wellington, and then we decided maybe we'd go back to Tufts Institutional Zoning. And I do appreciate that. But I think one of the reasons was is because the community was engaged on Boston Ave. And that's why we thought we would have that good community engagement. I do appreciate that there is a lot on everybody's plate, but I just want to make sure I didn't misunderstand. Is this something, has something changed to bring us back to Wellington?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It may be that I never internalized that conversation and I think that different people have different opinions on what would be the right thing to do. So I'm, I don't feel strongly about it. I feel strongly that I agree with the idea that we don't want to do something that's going to get people in an uproar during the spring.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. Dina, go ahead please.
[Dina Caloggero]: I want to echo what Paige said. My understanding was that we were going to move with Tufts Institutional since there's a lot of development that's happening with Tufts right now. There are major concerns from the residents in the College Avenue area as well as parts of South Medford on what's going to happen with certain properties that Tufts has. I think that's also in line with discussions on you know, finalizing some type of pilot program and all that. I would urge to move forward with the Tufts Institutional over Wellington.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Dina. John Anderson, please unmute yourself.
[John Anderson]: Got it. I'm sorry, what's supposed to follow Tufts? Wellington. Well, no, Wellington was going to be before Tufts.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Well, that's kind of a dispute from that conversation.
[John Anderson]: But after Wellington and Tufts, what's next?
[Chair Doug Carr]: West Medford.
[John Anderson]: Okay. Well, one thing about Tufts is it's going to be very different from, I think, the way we do other rezoning. I really recommend folks read Christian's thesis on the Dover Amendment. You don't have to read the whole thing. It's pretty heavy going. I read the first couple of chapters and then skipped to the end. And it's really unclear, well, because the end is sort of the current situation. And it's clear to me that there's a whole lot of legal considerations. Basically, the legislature, when they passed the Dover Amendment, it's just a few words. And it's been left totally up to the courts to interpret it. So what we can regulate and what we can't regulate is, it's very unclear.
So I think we need an approach for that that's kind of grounded in reality, or we could spend a lot of time talking about what we'd like and what the people who live in the neighborhood would like. And you'd like to support them in that, but what we can do might be very limited. So I would think that we might wanna postpone Tufts Institutional until we have a better sense of what we can actually do there.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, thank you, John. Back to you, Dina.
[Dina Caloggero]: I mean, we know that Tufts Institutional is part of the project, especially where the consultant will be hired for a three year period. So, you know, part of the assessment of the consultant at that point would be the ability to deal with those special issues surrounding Tufts Institutional regarding the Dover Amendment.
[Chair Doug Carr]: You're saying it's a requirement of hiring them.
[Dina Caloggero]: It's already a requirement in what we're asking them to do.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Fair enough. I'll keep reminding people that we did ask, and I believe Alicia Rocco has agreed that we would get an annual update for what Tufts is going to do. I think we're owed that by the end of this calendar year for what the next 12 to 18 months is. I think we should insist on that. Go ahead, Paige.
[Page Buldini]: There's actually a meeting, I don't know if the office is able to listen in tomorrow for the hillside neighborhood from Tufts. It's like their update that they do monthly. But on that agenda is packet or in place their Boston have study, but the aquatic center as well. So I don't know. I've been sharing it with people that I know are up here. I'm happy to share it with whomever. But I think those updates are great because we definitely do need to know what they're thinking for the future.
[Chair Doug Carr]: But those are construction updates, right? Not planning updates. We want all of it.
[Page Buldini]: Oh, correct. But this is what they're sharing. So I feel like it's an easy ask to ask again.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Fair enough. Thank you. Are there any other thoughts about schedule and priorities? Tufts, Wellington, you know, we have to decide. We're not going to decide, we don't need to decide tonight, but we do need to start planning for it. Sean, why don't you go first, and then I'll go back to John.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I guess my question is, who is deciding what order we're going to take this in? If the City Council is deciding because it's going to start with them, then We're going to do whatever they send us first. So I guess if they already decided, it sounds to me like there's amongst the politicians in the city, they'd like to do as their next zoning, the least confrontational, least argumentative Area they can think of and I guess that's what I guess that's Wellington. Is that correct Alicia? Is that what I'm hearing that we're going to be starting with Wellington?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I feel like they would take advice and input. And I think the question is, could one want to make the argument that Tufts is not gonna be controversial and getting people all up inflamed? Because I do know people are nervous about it, but we also have zoning in place where the Elliott Pearson School is. And that current zoning says two and a half stories and 35 feet.
[Sean Beagan]: I thought, yeah, I agree with Paige and Dina that my memory of the conversations we had whichever meeting it was in the recent past that we were discussing it, was that we would just continue with the Boston Ave area, which meant continuing with Tufts because everyone was kind of thinking about that area and the public was engaged there. For some reason in my mind, I thought we were going to start kind of sooner than next spring.
I don't know if the delay of, now we're talking about maybe a five month delay before we pick anything up again. I guess maybe that'll change, maybe that changes my opinion a little, because I think a lot of people will have forgotten about what we were doing back in the summer. But I definitely remember Dina and Paige, that conversation that we had, and that was the, I think that was the desire of the majority of the board to do that next.
So I agree with you on that. But I guess I go back to my position of, I think we're just gonna be told what we're gonna do next. And if that's the situation, then I'm fine with that as well. I'm not an elected official.
[John Anderson]: John Anderson. I guess one comment I would make was my reading of Christian's thesis was, that whatever height restrictions we put on a Tufts educational building, they might well be able to go well beyond that, saying if it's vital to their educational purpose. But you know, I'm not a lawyer, but that's how I read it. And I think it would be a mistake to make too many assumptions about what power the city has versus Tufts. We have a sort of moral suasion but that probably only goes so far.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: John, let me just address that for a second. Sure. If there is no limit, if say we tell them there's no zoning limit in their area, then they can go as high as they want. If we tell them that the limit is two and a half stories, then they have to make an argument for why they should go higher than that.
[John Anderson]: Yes, I understand that.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: That's where it's important for us to be thinking about it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, I mean, 1 of the things I'll get to in a 2nd. I mean, I believe the place, you know, it was zone for 125 feet for 5060 years and nobody thought twice about it. And then when they asked for 110, even though it was a monster, they had such an easy case to win that because our zoning allowed it. If our zoning was 45 feet or something equivalent, I think to Alicia's point, we might have had some more leverage. We had no leverage. I don't disagree with you, John. I don't understand the ins and outs of the Dover. We all need to educate ourselves on that clearly going forward whenever we start Tufts.
Go ahead, Dina and then Danielle afterwards.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, I mean, I think Sean's point is is excellent is that I guess it's up to the city council to determine what comes next for us. Um, but I, you know, I do find it curious because we were discussing Medford square and also Boston Avenue zoning. During the whole time with it was intense discussions from the school committee on the cost of the high school. So, you know, you had those 2 different things happening at the same time as well. And I know lots of. residents were trying to attend both meetings and found it difficult. So perhaps the city council wants to do something easier to avoid that scenario again. But I do feel in the light of all the development with Tufts University that's happening, along with the city council's recent discussion about developing a pilot program, that Tufts institutional zoning would fit very nicely under the intended schedule of dealing with the pilot program and some of the development that Tufts plans to do over the next couple of years.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Danielle?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so a couple of things. I also agree that I think that the Tufts institutional zoning needs to happen sooner in the process. Because I think that the Dover amendment Like, the arguments for them to get exceptions are easier to make, right? Because the zoning is ridiculous. They're like, you can't be like, you're in a district and it's a university. Like, why would, why did the city zone at GR? The university was there before the zoning. So it doesn't make sense. Like, why would we do that? That that makes no sense. And so I feel like right there, we set ourselves up for. Failure there and losing any challenge be like, well, you zoned us to family and we're clearly a university. And. So, I feel like we should at least match what. Is reasonable for a university there and 2nd, as far as other areas, I think we need to go with where we have studies that have looked further. So that's why the Wellington 1 as Alicia brought up. Makes sense. We just completed a study. And we just got our contract for a grant signed with the state to do a climate impact study for the residential neighborhoods. So we'll hopefully be getting an RFP out together for that and try to get someone under contract in the new year to study that and make recommendations for the kind of zoning that would not be counter to our climate resiliency goals and also be able to have some housing production in a smart way that didn't treat all of the residential areas as kind of like a one size fits all to respect that there are areas that are more prone to flooding and areas that you know, have topography challenges and others that, you know, just have their own like sets of issues. So, um, I would want, so we're hoping to T that, that study to be complete by the time we would ever get to those neighborhoods. So just finding like, you know, filling in the gaps with actually more in depth study. And I know West Medford had that economic, um, study of some sort. I don't know how informative it is for zoning recs, but at least it's been looked at. Yeah, so because the comprehensive plan is kind of like the big picture, but you really need to drill down at the kind of more of a localized viewpoint.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Paige, go ahead.
[Page Buldini]: Just real quick for me too, just so I'm clear as well. So would we, Wellington, Tufts Institutional Zoning, whatever kind of is decided or shared with us or what we do, would that be something that we wait for the consultant? Because maybe I misunderstood too, but was there discussion about inquiring if Innis could help out? And when we were talking about Tufts Institutional Zoning to keep it going, In the interim, I think we would need guidance if we are doing this.
Maybe I'm wrong.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia, Danielle, Ines, are they done?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I agree. If we were to do something in the interim, we would absolutely need guidance. And we could ask Ines to do it. We need funding. They did give me a quote. It was something like $30,000, and I would need to go ask Mayor and the City Council to come up with funding or to tell me to spend down my budget on it. Wouldn't it have a hard stop in January or February? I think so, because that would be the three months from when their original contract was signed.
[Chair Doug Carr]: But we only have a handful of meetings between now and then.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I don't know that this board has the time to do it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I don't think we do actually. But I'd like to address something that a couple of people have brought up. You know, one of the things that we said in our collective response to the city council was that we want to be partners in this, not getting a baked cake delivered to us that's already far down the line. We need to get ahead of things and educate ourselves and try to think about what's appropriate boundaries like look at not necessarily create our own maps, but I think we need to start not reacting as much as trying to get ahead. We have a couple of iterations now where I feel like When we're far from the experts in zoning, but we there's we can start thinking about things. I think intelligently and not wait for something to be handed to us. I no matter what we take, I think that's the case. And in Tufts institutional zoning, we also have Somerville zoning, which is half the campus. Like there's a precedent there that might be of some use for us to look at. Because it's very different than Medford's, obviously, and and it might behoove us to think about that. So.
Should we think about a potential motion, an intent of the board to choose a direction for the next zoning? I think that's worth thinking about and taking a vote on, and I'll entertain a motion for such a thing.
[John Anderson]: Go ahead, John. Can I just comment that I agree with you completely, Doug, and if you read the what the law says about what a planning board can do or community development board, we don't have to wait for the city council to propose anything. We can propose our own changes to zoning. I mean, they can just turn us down, but there's nothing to stop us from doing it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That's correct. We just never have.
[John Anderson]: Yeah. It's just a habit we're in.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sorry. Go ahead, John. Do you have another comment?
[John Anderson]: Um, so, yeah, so. What's the status, by the way, of the Boston Avenue zoning at this point? Is it a done deal? It's done. All done. Done. It's done. Okay. Yes. That's it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay.
[Sean Beagan]: Go ahead, John. Yeah, no, I agree with John that our board can propose zoning, but without the assistance of a BNS or some other entity, it's not gonna happen realistically at that scale. I mean, we can propose minor amendments, sure, but we're not gonna propose an entire new district worth of zoning on our own. I wouldn't propose that we start to do that, but I would propose that I think what you were getting at, Doug, is maybe a motion to advise, you know, that this council makes a motion to advise the city council that our intention is to deal with Boston Avenue, Tufts rather, as our next
[Chair Doug Carr]: zoning district is that what you is that what you were suggesting yes that's the intention yeah yeah that this is a broad direction of where we want to go next yeah i would yeah i would support that yeah all right can i um have a motion somehow i'm not sure what we moved a motion for this cd board to begin study, investigation, interrogation into Tufts institutional zoning as our next area of inquiry.
[Sean Beagan]: Exactly. And I would just like to amend that just to, that we'd like to advise the city council that that is where we would like to go.
[John Anderson]: I second that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Second. I'll call the roll. John Anderson.
[John Anderson]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: John Began. Yes. Page Buldini. Yes.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I got my fishman is absent and myself. Yes. The motion passes five to zero. Thank you. Very good. Um, are there any other, I guess that we covered a lot of it there. Um, so that's really the outline for schedule. We talked about that. Um, Are there any upcoming projects that you want to just tell us that you think that between now and the end of the year, that's something we can anticipate seeing? Like transit, is transit, is it a done deal? You think we'll get it before the new year or is that still a work in progress?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I don't, I don't know how we would get it before. Okay, we haven't gotten anything. Yeah.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I sure hope they're going to apply before then. I don't know. Yeah, apply, but I don't. I think opening a public hearing. Yeah, I'm I have advised them that engineering and traffic has suggested that they reach out to them and talk to them. And I should check and see if they've heard from them.
[Unidentified]: Okay.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Okay, I think I mentioned maybe I didn't that there's another 1 of those 2 single family houses on 1 parcel. They went through ZBA, they need a special permit. I expect that to come through and I expect that to be pretty straightforward. It looks on the surface just like the other one. We've had the staff to the ZBA reaching out to them again, making sure they understand they need that special permit from this board.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And then there's a self storage with ground floor. Retail commercial space that are looking to get this is on mystic out of where self storage is not allowed. So they're, they have a nonconforming use. So they're going to the zoning board to change from 1 nonconforming use to another nonconforming use. Which is just by a special permit finding and the bar there's is a substantially more detrimental in the existing nonconforming use. And right now it's a. I think it's is it a car sales or it's a motor vehicle use and then there's.
Like, a house on there, that's being used office. It's really in bad shape. So we met with them and they agreed to do things like ground floor. Commercial activate that. Space and so it will be coming to you all so. Although it's self-storage and wasn't our first choice, not necessarily opposed to it. I think they're going to do it in an interesting way that I haven't seen. So we'll see how it goes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, the design drawings I saw looked a little odd, but I think there's a path forward there.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, I did comment that I didn't like the fake The, the fake windows to the fake storage units behind, but let's, let's stop being so fake. I was very, very forthright with them, but yeah, really. I met with them yesterday.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm shocked. All right. Are there any other administrative updates Alicia or Danielle that we need to know about? Otherwise, we'll move on to the meeting minutes.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Nope, just minutes. We have a new staff person starting November. Oh. So I guess who? We hired an economic development planner. We hired Christian back.
[Unidentified]: My God, what a deal.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Natalie and Izzy are still working on the zoning. He's not going to spend all of his time here doing zoning, but he will be available as a resource, particularly around economic development pieces.
[Dina Caloggero]: We need the economic development.
[Page Buldini]: Can I make a quick plug? The newsletter I received from your office was exceptional. I don't know who put that out, but it was really great. I've shared it to a bunch of neighbors and business owners and there are so many great clickable links now, so I don't know who put that together, but well done. It was really awesome and it was really helpful because it's linking now to upcoming zoning, which I know will get updated. Could we have the Dover information? I know it's Christian, so I don't know if that's appropriate, But I think if there's resources like that, that would be really helpful.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Do you mean, put that on the zoning page or email it to you? I thought I emailed it to you. No, for the public that would be appropriate. I think if he's okay with that, I think we can. Because it was really great. And I just wanted to clarify, because we did make some changes to the newsletter, and it looks like you noticed them, that we went to try and shorten everything. Fewer words, but linked through to stuff. Is that what you were particularly saying you liked?
[Page Buldini]: It was great, but even just it was really clickable. It was really user-friendly. And then the affordable units, I thought was really cool, too, seeing that.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right and I appreciate that because so Emily in our office, Emily is 1 of our interns. She did it. She made worked on that a lot. And then Kayla, our economic development planner is a background in design and she actually helped craft sort of the new design that Emily implemented. Well, it's great. So please let them know.
[Sean Beagan]: If we have Christian back, even more reason to do Tufts next then. Before someone else scoops them away from us.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, really. Let's go with that.
[John Anderson]: Go ahead, John Anderson. Just quick question. Doug, have you and Sean had any more meetings? What do you call them? Oh, the working group meetings.
[Chair Doug Carr]: No, hasn't been one in some time.
[John Anderson]: Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay.
[John Anderson]: That might be a place to bring up some of these questions about you know, how we propose these minor cleanup projects to them, but it's up to you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, they are and I think Alicia's and Danielle have been communicating that they know that we're kind of working on this in parallel trains and that there's going to, we're going to try to keep that information exchange going. Zach gave me a list of his tier of his comments from a previous meeting. I know Alicia and Danielle have been kind of platooning back and forth between them trying to get consensus here. So I feel like I feel like the cleanup process is actually heading in a reasonable direction right now. I don't expect anything there to be controversial.
All right. I'm going to take a motion to accept the 9-16-26 and 10-7-26 city board draft minutes. So moved. Second. Second. All right. I'll call the roll. John Anderson. Yes. John Began. Yes. Page Buldini. Yes.
[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Fishman is absence myself. Yes. Motion passes to zero. Motion to adjourn.
[Dina Caloggero]: Second. All right.
[Chair Doug Carr]: This is a little longer than I thought, but it's good. John Anderson. About. Doesn't matter. Sean Bacon?
[Chair Doug Carr]: I got two yeses. Page Buldini?
[Page Buldini]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Colagaro?
[Page Buldini]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Igoff and Fishman absent, and myself, Doug Carr. Yes. Thank you all. We'll see you at the next meeting in a couple of weeks.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Appreciate your time.
|
total time: 4.12 minutes total words: 788 |
|||