Zoning Board of Appeals 10/29/26

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3.6-flash from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The Medford Zoning Board of Appeals met to hear multiple residential requests, including administrative appeals regarding state-protected accessory dwelling units (ADUs), dimensional variances, and special permits. The board approved a permit extension for a mixed-use project at 590 Boston Avenue, granted dimensional relief and special permits for proposals on Vassar Street, Wellesley Street, and Albion Street, and approved the reconstruction of a three-family dwelling on South Street.

  1. 2:45 226 Main Street — The board granted the applicant's request to continue the hearing for a proposed three-story, three-unit townhouse dwelling to December 3, 2026.
  2. 4:33 590 Boston Avenue — The board approved a two-year extension for a variance and special permit for the demolition of a gas station and car wash to construct a five-story mixed-use building with 45 units and commercial space.
  3. 10:16 1-3 Vassar Street — The board granted dimensional relief for a reduced 780-square-foot protected accessory dwelling unit and approved a special permit to extend an existing nonconforming side yard setback vertically.
  4. 1:48:46 12 Wellesley Street — The board granted dimensional relief allowing the applicant to construct two shed dormers for a 769-square-foot third-story protected accessory dwelling unit.
  5. 2:15:38 11 Albion Street — The board approved a variance for third-floor square footage and a special permit to extend a side setback nonconformity vertically to expand living space in a single-family home.
  6. 2:35:41 75 South Street — The board approved a special permit to demolish an existing dilapidated three-family home and construct a new three-story, three-unit residential building.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Zoning Board of Appeals

[SPEAKER_01]: Hi, everybody. Hey, everyone. How's everyone going? How's everyone doing? Very good. Awesome. So I guess I was, I was 226 Main Street. I think I was first on.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Oh, yes. Yeah. We're going to, we'll let us, uh, we'll open the meeting officially and take a roll call and then we will, uh, we will get right to that. Thanks for, sorry. We're starting a few minutes late. I appreciate you. Thank you.

[Unidentified]: All right, let me just rename myself here.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, good evening everybody. Welcome to the October 29th meeting of the Medford Zoning Board of Appeals. My name is Andre LaRue. I'm the chair. Dennis, could you kind of officially open us?

[Denis MacDougall]: Yeah, so hello everyone and thank you for your patience. This is the October 29th meeting of the Medford Zoning Board of Appeals. We have a number of items on the agenda, so all we ask is that if we ask for a public comment that you just raise your hand either on the screen or on the little raise hand app there like that. And we will call on you to speak. And all we ask is for you to provide us with your name and your address for the public record. Sorry, we're gonna, if you can't, just gonna mute folks, sorry.

And we're, thank you. So we're actually gonna be taking a few items right at the beginning of the meeting. And actually the first one is 226 Main Street. The applicant is to construct a proposed three-story, three-unit townhouse-style multiple dwelling at 226 Main Street, requiring variances for insufficient lot area, lot width, left and right yard setbacks, and sufficient usable open space.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Dennis, I'm just going to do a roll call first.

[Denis MacDougall]: I'm sorry.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right. I know member Mark Crowley is not available this evening. He won't be here. He will be replaced by associate member Chris DeVetta. Roll call. Chris. Present. Yvette.

[Yvette Velez]: Present.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Mary Lee. Present. Jim Tirani. Present. Okay, I saw you say that, but me, okay. Just give me a thumbs up. All right, thanks, Jim. And Andre LaRue, Chair, present. All right, Dennis, over to the first continuance there.

[Denis MacDougall]: So as I sort of said, 226 Main Street, the applicant is asking for continuance until our next hearing. That hearing will be heard on Thursday, December 3rd at 630 PM using the exact same zoom information to log in. So. We received a email from the applicant asking for the continuance and it's, you know. That's basically, I think all we just need is a motion from the board for.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, and just just a note on this everyone. So, in the past, uh, you know, extension or no, well, continuances. Um, or just so Dennis, we're not doing the November 1. we're going right to into the December. Sorry.

[Denis MacDougall]: I didn't I didn't make that clear. So the November hearing would be on Thanksgiving. So we're pushing it forward week to December 3rd.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Yeah.

[Denis MacDougall]: Thank you.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right.

[Denis MacDougall]: Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So, board members, we're just going to take a quick roll call vote on whether to approve the continuance. Chris? Yes. Yvette?

[Yvette Velez]: Yes.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Mary? Yes. Jim? I see a yes there. And myself is a yes.

[Unidentified]: Now you're being muted. It says on the other end.

[Denis MacDougall]: Oh, wait a minute. Let me. You should be all set now.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. Thanks, Jim. All right. So 226 Main Street is continued. Thank you very much Dennis. We're also taking 1 other item out of order.

[Denis MacDougall]: Yes. 590 Boston Ave. Applicant and owner Aniletto brothers are requesting a 2 year extension on a variance special permit granted by the board of appeals with the decision expiring on January 30th, 2027. for the demolition of the existing gas station, car wash, and construction of five-story mixed-use building with 45 units, approximately 1,464 gross square feet of commercial space, and 41,306 gross square feet overall. We have an attorney on the call.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Attorney Barnarski, is that you? Yes.

[Adam Barnosky]: Good evening.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Would you like to just say a few words briefly? Sure, sure.

[Adam Barnosky]: Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the board, Adam Barnowski from law firm Roberto Israel and Weiner in Boston. On behalf of the applicant and owner, Antelato Brothers Inc. Thank you for putting us at the top. I will try to make it brief. And with me tonight, if there are any questions beyond what I present, is Joe Antelato. He is the principal of Antelato Brothers. The applicant's development partners David Hunt and Matt Brown of 685 Development Partners. So for those on the board, some may be familiar with this project, some might not be. The project is a five-story mixed-use building on the corner of Boston Avenue and Harvard. It's where Titan Car Wash and Gas is currently located. There'll be 45 units, just under 1,500 square feet of ground floor retail and accurate parking. This project was first approved in 2020. There was an issue with the, a question about the use variance, which was ironed out and it had full and final approval in 2021. The city extended it. The project was then amended in 2022 and the city approved the amendment was reduced and more compliant dimensionally, went up from 45 or 40 to 45 units at that point in time. And then in 2024, the economic development bill of the state extended all permits that were valid during a certain period of time, which this permit was part of. And so currently, it has an expiration date of January 30, 2027.

And so we're here tonight asking for an extension. You know, this project is very similar to a lot. It mirrors the market conditions over the past five years. And it remains a good project. We think that with the recent zoning and even more consistent, really, than anything that was approved at the time and when it first went through permitting. David and Matt from 675 bring a lot of skill and talent to this project. Joe Anoletto, many people on the board know Joe, and he has a rich history with the community, rich history with the site and the project. And we are now at a point, I'm happy to say, there are plans to break ground. And so we're here before the board not asking for any modifications or changes to the underlying project, but really just a continuation of time in order to actually finally do what we've been excited to do for a long time. And so that's really it. I have a lot more information I can provide if there are any questions of the board. I did want to reiterate that we want the vote, if it is approved by this board, to mirror what Dennis had said at the top of the hour. We don't anticipate needing two years. The state now allows a two-year extension. We probably need less than a year, but crazier things have happened, and what we want to avoid is having to rush to come back before this board in the event an extension is needed, but do anticipate breaking ground in the first half of 27.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great, thank you, Attorney Barnoski. So members, this is fairly straightforward. No changes to the project. The state law has changed. So generally we have done six month permit extensions in the past. State's really extended that to two years now. And so this is just a vote to approve that two year extension so that the project can be completed. Are there any questions for Attorney Bernofsky at this time by the ZBA members? Okay, seeing none, is there a motion on the floor to extend the permits for 590 Boston Avenue for a two-year extension?

So moved. Thank you, Jim. Is there a second? Second. Thank you, Mary. All right, we'll have a roll call vote now. Chris DeVetta. Aye. Yvette Velez. Aye. Thank you. Mary Lee. Aye. Jim Turani. Aye. And I'm an aye as well. So, thank you to the proponents of the project. Best of luck and we hope That you're able to get going soon. Thank you all for your time. Thank you. All right. Have a good evening. Dennis, what's the next item on the agenda?

[Denis MacDougall]: 1-3 Vassar Street, continued from September 24th. Applicant Christian Austin to construct two shed dormers and expand the existing attic space to create a full third story for purposes of protected ADU at 1-3 Vassar Street, which is in general residence zoning distance, requiring a variance in door finding. Pursuant to Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 48A-3.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great, thank you. Attorney Desmond, I know we've been talking about this project now for, I don't know, two, three meetings, and we had a thorough conversation last time, I know, and I'm wondering if you could update us on where the project stands. And Dennis, can you unmute? There you go. Taking care of, thank you very much.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Yeah, I believe when we, Kathleen Desmond, stone him as I'm here with, uh, Christian Austin, uh, the owner of the property, I believe where we left off at this point, was there a deliberation and the board, uh, was looking, um, for us to present, uh, plans that may reduce, uh, the size of the, uh, AD unit ADU units as proposed, at least that was part of the, um, discussion. Uh, you know, my position is, and it still remains that I believe the statute and the 900 square feet is what it is. But I understand that the courts haven't ruled one way or another, and the courts haven't determined what the regulations or the statute indicate. But I do believe that it's simply a math problem, either half or 900 square feet, whichever is lesser. And I did speak with Attorney Nick Shapiro from Phillips in Angley. He's done some of the MLC classes, and he did agree with that. position. But again, I understand that this is new. I understand that the courts haven't regulated it, but that would be my client's position. Having said that, we did provide the board with two plans. And Dennis, if I, I'll start with Vassar, if I could share my screen.

So I believe this is the Vassar. Are you able to see that?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Uh, not yet.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Okay. Hold on. You just go. Is that sharing now?

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Okay. Um, so in terms of the Vassar street project, um, again, this, this one needs, um, this one needs a special permit in addition to, um, anything related to, of the ADU and the finding under 40A as there is a violation of the side yard setback. And in order to go up, increase the plane height, we would need a special permit to do that, to just go up and create the dormer. But what this plan does is it reduces the square footage of the unit to 780 square feet.

As you may recall, the original proposal was to utilize the entire space of the third floor, which was 899 square feet. And let me just get that over. Let me reduce the size. I can pull it over. So that was the original proposal was 899. square feet, the dormer was 31.4 feet. We would be reducing the dormer on the left side of the property to 26.4 feet. In terms of the overall square footage, the second floor of the property is 1136 square feet, so half of that would be and 68 square feet. So what we're looking for is an additional 212 square feet for purposes of the ADU. So it's probably a two and three quarter story. It does preserve the two bedrooms. I think it's clear from the statute and the regulations and the fact sheets and all that's been put out that the number of bedrooms cannot be that municipality can't regulate the number of bedrooms. In terms of the bedroom space, it just really gives someone a private area so that even if you were a single person who rented this space, you would have another room for an office or for a guest bedroom if someone were to come and be a guest. It also allows for two individuals to occupy the space, which helps with the costs associated with the unit. As you can see, the common area is rather limited in that regard. You have a kitchen, you have a dining slash living room. It's not as ideal as it was previously in terms of space, but it does accomplish the purpose of creating a living space that has a kitchen, a bathroom, a living area, and then the two bedrooms, which could be used either as a bedroom or as an office or as a guest room. Um, so we, we have reduced it significantly. It's 212 square feet over what the, uh, second story, um, half story requirement would be. Um, and I think I mentioned at the last meeting that the whole half story concept is, is, is somewhat, um, arbitrary and based on what you have for, um, a second floor. So in this instance, the second floor is only 1136 square feet. So you're only entitled to half of that in terms of the half story, whereas in some, you know, some homes, you're going to have a 1500 1600 square foot second floor that then increases the area of the half story on the third floor. So, you know, my client's willing, he doesn't love this idea, obviously, but he's willing to reduce it to that size for purposes of an ADU. And I think it's also important to point out that in terms of, I know we had a lot of conversations about density and about people and overcrowdedness, even if this were a half story, he would still be entitled to or he could place two bedrooms in it and you just have a larger, um, second story unit, which isn't really something that he was interested in, in doing. Um, again, because from an owner perspective, and I think I indicated, uh, he owned one of these will be owner occupied. He's lived in the neighborhood for over 13 years. Um, so it's much more manageable, um, in terms of, of tenants. when you have, you know, less bedrooms and less, you know, four bedrooms with a tenant, it gets somewhat unmanageable. There's more roommates, obviously. And this breaks it down to a unit where you have two, two, and two, which is what he has. And with respect to Wellesley, which is another project, he was actually intending to possibly occupy that space. Because again, he does live at one of the properties. 12 Vassar and 12 Wesley and 3 Vassar. So that's essentially the changes that have been made. Vassar is unique in the sense too that it abuts a vacant land and it's on the corner, so there aren't any neighbors to speak of that would be impacted by the dormers in terms of direct effect of light, shadow, and closeness, proximity to the other structures.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you attorney Desmond. Members, any questions regarding these changes? Or attorney Desmond's comments? All right, I don't hear anybody or see any hands.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah, I'm sure I do. Actually, if I just could ask the applicant, we are looking at a plan that says 840 square feet. And she was stating 780 square feet, right?

[Kathleen Desmond]: So I asked that same question of the architect when I received it. This is a gross square footage, the arterial walls, the actual living space of the ad unit will be 780 square feet. Um, because I saw the difference in that as well. Um, but he assured me that the 7 80 is accurate and the 8 40 just relates to the outside areas. Probably these areas here, which are included within, but are not part of the space.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Okay. So that's a building commissioner question, I guess, how he calculates that because we will go by what he right.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Understood.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Mr. chair. Yes, I believe that the square footage should be written into the order. So then it's directed as to do so, and then it could be verified during the plans exam.

[Unidentified]: OK.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Thank you.

[Kathleen Desmond]: One other item which I neglected to mention, just to refresh everyone's recollection, he is intending on installing heat pumps and making this a green building. And that's part of the whole construction costs and the, you know, Um, what goes into this? In addition to that, this will also be sprinkled the entire building. Um, and if it were simply a 22 dwelling unit with four bedrooms, that wouldn't be a requirement. So there are some safety enhancements that are being made by virtue of the A. D. U. That you wouldn't have in the instance where it was just a two family with four bedrooms to in the attic space.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you. Members, any other questions?

[Chris D'Aveta]: Mr. Chair, sorry, I have two questions. The second is, is this technically an as-of-right ADU based on the fact that we'll be granting what I assume is a variance for the extra square footage?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: We are going to be addressing this as an administrative appeal and really looking at the reasonableness of the city's regulations that we are evaluating here. We've had some back and forth with the city's attorney on this and that is their recommendation.

[Chris D'Aveta]: How will we hear about that, like what those recommendations are?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So when we get enter into discussion, you know, deliberation, then I can, I'll go into that a little bit more. Okay. Thank you.

[Kathleen Desmond]: So this would be labeled also as a protected ADU, which would be, you know, would be limited to, to that particular type of an ADU. And it's under 48 section three that, that, you know, the relief is, is sought through.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, other clarifying questions before we open the public comment period? Okay, I don't see any. Then maybe Attorney Desmond, could you stop sharing your screen for a moment? Great. Let's open the public comment session of this hearing. Is there any member of the public who would like to weigh in on this proposal? And you can use the little Zoom, raise your hand. You can put something into the chat if you're having trouble unmuting. Dennis, have we gotten any new comments on this project since the last month?

We have not. All right. I don't see any members of the public weighing in at this point. Is there a motion to close the public hearing portion of the meeting? Motion to close. Thank you, Mary. Is there a second? Second. Thank you, Jim. All right, roll call vote. Chris. Aye. Jim. Aye. Mary.

[Mary Lee]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And Yvette. Aye. And I'm an I as well. Thank you. So the public hearing portion is closed. Members, we enter into deliberation. What are your thoughts? So we've been talking about this for a couple of months now. I think you're familiar with the concepts, but if you do have questions, please feel free to raise them. Just getting back to Chris's question about what we're specifically going to be voting on, whether it's a variance. So one of the properties, and Attorney Desmond, is it the Vassar property that's also looking for a special permit?

[Kathleen Desmond]: That's correct. On the side yard to go vertically, to build vertically. The property already encroaches in the side yard. We're not increasing the encroachment. It's just extending the vertical plane.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right, so we may need to take that the special permit vote separately, but I think the rest of it, we're going to treat as an administrative appeal. So. Because this is, it's a protected use 80 you under state law as attorney Desmond has mentioned, then we need to evaluate it as such. And what we are. Let's just take Vassar Street. We're just going to do Vassar Street first. The Vassar Street proposes a protected use accessory dwelling unit or ADU that will create a new non-conformity by constructing a third story that's not otherwise allowed because it exceeds the 50 percent of the gross floor area. Our City's attorney, and I think where the board was as well last month, is that although these ADUs are legally protected under state law, it does not mean that the ADU can create a new nonconformity by right, even though the use itself is by right, the nonconformities are not by right.

There is language that says, no zoning ordinance or bylaws shall prohibit, unreasonably restrict, or require a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single accessory dwelling unit or the rental thereof in a single-family residential zoning district, provided that the use of land or structures for such accessory dwelling unit under this paragraph may be subject to reasonable regulations. And so, if applicable, site plan review regulations concerning dimensional setbacks and the bulk and height of structures may be subject to restrictions and prohibitions on short term rental as defined in Section 1, Chapter 64G.

So, ordinarily, a dimensional variance would be required to allow that new dimensional nonconformity here. But since this is a protected use, city, the council's opinion is that the city may not require the applicant to obtain a variance for the ADU, but that the city, us, the ZBA, may still reasonably regulate the use. And so what we're looking at then is what constitutes reasonable or unreasonable regulation. And those, regulations. So, basically, a municipality may reasonably regulate and restrict protected use ADUs provided that any restriction or regulation imposed by a municipality shall be unreasonable if the regulation or restriction when applicable to a protected use ADU. So, essentially, if the following occur, then these would be unreasonable regulation. So if it, if you know, our attempts to regulate do not serve a legitimate public municipal interest sought to be achieved by local zoning. If it does serve a legitimate municipal interest, but its application to the protected use ADU does not rationally relate to that municipal interest, or if it serves a legitimate municipal interest, but compliance will result in the complete nullification of the use or development of a protected use ADU, or impose excessive costs on the use or development of a protected use ADU, or substantially diminish or interfere with the use or development of a protected use ADU. So, again, this is all very brand new. There's not a lot of guidance about how the court will apply all of these factors.

But what we should do is we're going to treat this as an administrative appeal because the reason why this is before us is because the building department rejected or denied the protected use ADU on its dimensions for the dimensional reasons. So we need to, I think, address findings. We need to kind of find, through findings, establish some of these factors and then make a vote as to whether this was an appropriately done decision. And we have some, I think, As we usually do, I think we do have some ability to maybe waive some of the dimensional requirements if the board so chooses and finds that it's in the best interest of the municipal interest as embodied in our zoning regulations. So that was a lot, I know. Do the board members have questions about that?

[Mary Lee]: So it sounds like the municipal interest is the interest of the building department regulation.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Is that correct? Well, it's really the zoning rules of the city of Medford. That's what I would say. So because the dimensional requirement about the half story, right, this zone is a two and a half story Zoning district and so the half story on the 3rd floor, you know, the 80 you proposed exceeds the half story. And so the question is, what is, I think, the municipal interest in that half story and having a district that's 2 and a half stories and.

We would probably have to make a finding about that municipal interest and then. We could vote on the project. kind of itself and what we want to do about it, whether we kind of approve what's being asked by the proponent, whether we kind of approve it to a certain degree with some conditions, or we uphold the building department's interpretation of our zoning law and completely deny it.

[Mary Lee]: So, sorry, but I mean, so we are put the board is being placed in a position of defining what the municipal interest is. That's what it sounds like because I, I think I had the same question last time. Yeah. You know, what, what is that municipal interest or is there any guidance in terms of. How we should. proceed or how we how we should analyze what that municipal interest is because it sounds like there's not much guidance on that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: That's correct and that's a good question Mary and so we are kind of in kind of uncharted territory a little bit but I think that we have enough familiarity with our the zoning code here in Medford to be able to try to make a stab at that. And I see Alicia, you have your hand raised. So why don't we go to you on that?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. As the city's planners, senior planner Evans and I are here who can speak to the municipal interest, like why zoning, this zoning exists. And I know planner Evans has to leave in a minute. And so I don't know if you wanted, she wanted to state about the, um, that some of the things that we discussed earlier to provide that as information for the board, because that's what we do is zoning for the city. Or if you run out of time, let me know and I can speak to it.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. That would be great. Planner Evans, would you have time to do that?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Daniel Evans, senior planner. In the GR zone, two and a half stories is the maximum height. As you understand, it's number of stories and height. So even though this wouldn't be exceeding the ridge and that kind of way of exceeding height, it's the story. So basically, it needs to be a pitched roof. or small enough dormers that it doesn't trigger this third story. And so the reasons for that are, you know, for a variety of reasons, like the lots are smaller, the setbacks are very modest. So adding, you know, full length dormers or large dormers with an additional story of windows looking out, you know, can create privacy issues with neighbors creates a looming effect. It can interfere with sunlight, views, airflow, things like that are reasons for having the pitched roof with modest dormers.

Also, you know, the architectural rhythm of the street, the historical development pattern in that neighborhood, and of that, the age of the housing stock there is that, you know, those gable roofs. And when you add large dormers, especially if the pitch is very shallow and there isn't appropriate setbacks from the front or the eaves, then it just becomes overwhelming. And then dormers by nature are supposed to be very subordinate to the structure. So if the dormers are so long and large, that they're no longer subordinate. It's really just why we call it a third story and why it's defined as such.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Thank you. Director Hunt. I feel like there are two other things that I just feel are useful to the public interest. So overall, our housing production plan found that the city of Medford does need additional housing. We need additional housing that is affordable to our residents and we need more 1 bedroom housing that we have a plethora of units that people are overcrowded into and are sharing and that that the plan. So the bet the public interest for the city of Medford is more 1 units apartments. So, just to take that into account, as part of yes, there is a need in Medford for more housing. Additional provide more housing, but there's not necessarily a need for larger 2 bedroom units. So, one would be to the public interest. The other is I would perhaps say neutral to the public interest or if one was to argue that it would be more likely to add a roommate situation would add to the crowding as opposed to providing more suitable apartments for people. So, we're providing that information as the city's planning staff.

[Unidentified]: Great. Thank you, Director Hunt.

[Mary Lee]: So the municipal interest is to increase the availability of housing. Is that the interest?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I think my interpretation of what we just heard was all of the elements that Planner Evans and Director Hunt mentioned are in our municipal interest. So there's multiple municipal interests in the zoning code. Setbacks, for example, allow adequate sunlight and fresh air to all units. That's why we don't have tenement buildings anymore. I think in a district like this where all of the properties are two and a half stories, there's sort of a consistency that prevents any one property from looming over the other properties.

So, you know, I think we've just heard a bunch of different things, Mary. And I think, you know, we would, it's up to us as a board to make a finding and basically say what we, you know, what we affirm to be the municipal interest in the regulations that we are upholding in our decision.

[Mary Lee]: So I just want to clarify, so we are affirming the stated municipal interest because I think our decision will impact future applications. And since this is so new, I think somehow what our decision may be on this matter may be a precedent for future cases. That's why I want to make sure that we have a clear definition of guidance in terms of what that municipal interest is.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, unfortunately, we have to create it, so it's not necessarily something we're going to get from anybody else. But yes, I agree absolutely with all your points. That's definitely why it's important, and we should kind of state it in our finding. Yvette?

[Yvette Velez]: Thinking about the municipal interest, can we look at the plans again with those thoughts? So where is the property located in relation to its neighbors? Would that impede, is it too close? Are you looking into other people's spaces and things of that nature? And then is there no other Up right can it can't be built in the surrounding lot. Obviously that's why we're going up. We're not doing, you know, like, can we can we look at it through that lens of. The event, you know, it is a two bedroom. I'm happy it's smaller two bedroom. And to be honest, I, I, while I hear that municipal interest is saying like at least one bedrooms, those are like the more coveted spots, but like, this is now a small two bedroom and it's nice to have two spaces. So I'd be more lenient on that, but could we look at it in that way? Like re-review and then go just through it as a group? I don't know.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, I think that makes sense of that. And again, this is sort of balancing a little bit, just in that we can state what the municipal interest is. Some things are not allowed, like we're not allowed to say. are in the municipal interest because of the state law around ADUs, right? So we cannot, we can't regulate number of bedrooms, as Attorney Desmond mentioned. We can't regulate on parking spaces for an ADU. So we cannot say that there's too many people. It's too dense. So we have to identify what we can say and base our decision on those items.

[Yvette Velez]: But we could also again, because we're looking at each individual property on his own. So. To counter Mary's thoughts on, like, we're setting precedent because I don't think we are to some extent, because each we're reviewing every. Uh, everything that's brought to us, we should be reviewing on its individual basis. Um, but I would consider, like, in this neighborhood, for example, are there. If, you know, to review, like, the parking on it, right? Is it. One side of the street, does it not allow parking or is there part of street parking everywhere? Right? Because while we can't take into consideration those things, I think we can talk about quality of life for neighbors, right? And whether or not, just as we would for any other space, if it's not detrimental to the neighborhood, I think we can bring it in from that lens, if you will, not necessarily saying like, oh, Two bedrooms means overcrowding, and there's two people. No. It could be one person, but it's nice to have two different spaces. And we're not looking at that. I get that. But we can talk about if we are adding one more car, and the street doesn't have a lot of parking, that's a detriment. And then you're taking away spaces that are existing. So I think we could look at it through that side.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, we'll have to we'll have to be careful about that. I think, but I understand your point that there's a bit of a distinction between. Regulating on the number of units and the number of people itself versus kind of. The neighborhood context, right? And I do think that. Where we were coming down as a board after the last couple of conversations is that, you know, this is a very, it is a very crowded, congested neighborhood. This board and the city as a whole has been very supportive of adding new housing units.

But also trying to be. Trying to be sensible about fitting them into the city and kind of adding the density and changing the zoning to by right uses where that makes sense. So this proposal puts us in a bit of a conundrum. I think that Attorney Desmond, I appreciate the effort to come back and kind of reconfigure a bit the The units certainly we appreciate the, the sprinkler ring of the units and everything, but, you know, knowing that. There is no additional parking proposed and that we cannot regulate on it, knowing that it is a very congested neighborhood near Tufts University and that we cannot regulate on the bedrooms. You know, it was. I think we as a board felt that we would like these ADUs to really be ADUs and not a third unit, full unit. I would personally, at least speaking for myself, not for the whole board, but I was hopeful that maybe we'd see an even more modest accessory dwelling unit proposal. I think it's challenging for us to address this. Chris, you have your hand raised.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Good points by the other board members, too. I hadn't thought of some of that. But my point, and I wanted to just state for the record that I don't think this is a protected use ADU. I think it is a third unit and an existing two-unit structure, so I don't see how this is a protected-use ADU because it does not comply with the statute, which would be 568 square feet based on the square footage of the other apartment. So I have a fundamental problem with approving something that's called a protected-use ADU that I don't see as a protected use. We could grant a variance, I suppose, or I don't know if it would be a variance, maybe it'd be a special permit, but to allow for a larger third unit. But as this statute is written, and I've been to a number of meetings on this, this does not seem to be a protected use ADU unless Medford in its zoning had a larger, Protected use 80 allowed.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Um, yeah, this is what this is 1 of those instances, Chris, where the kind of state law has superseded. Medford's ordinance and so. We. you know, the state defines it as a protected use ADU and, uh, kind of allows it. And what are the, all that we're allowed to do is really, um, regulate the nonconformities, right?

[Chris D'Aveta]: I don't think I, well, this is where the fundamental disagreement becomes because the protected use ADU would be half of the square footage or 900 square feet. And I believe we've been through this, but I don't think you can count the whole structure as one unit to calculate the additional ADU square footage. I think it's only one and that we're back down to the, is it a third unit or is it an ADU? And I think it's a third unit, which And I want to emphasize this. I'm not opposed to third unit. I'm opposed to the way this is being presented to us as an ADU.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, my, my understanding, Chris, I know that that's, it's been sort of a, it has been a point of contention, what you're talking about. My understanding is that the executive office of housing and local communities has kind of issued guidelines and answered that question. saying that it is for like a two or three story, you know, a family building, that it is the entire building, half of the entire building or 900 square feet is the maximum, right?

[Chris D'Aveta]: That's, that's where I think we, we, I need, you know, legal guidance as a board member that's voting on this because I, I, I don't believe that. I haven't, that's what I have not heard. I have not heard that exact, statement from someone from HLC say that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I can find that for you. That would be great. Bill or Alicia, can you address this issue?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: I'll go first, Mr. Chair. I did look that up the last time and it says the combination of all the living space within within a building. And it doesn't define or discern between both a single or two family. So it is the living space of all the floors of a building, whether that's a one or two family. In addition to that, Chris, I just wanted to say that if this permit had come to us and it had the allowable roof limit that would allow for habitable space to be in, it wouldn't be before this board. It would only be, it would have been issued by right because of the, you know, the volume of the roof might've been a little bit higher to accommodate the living space. So we had very similar cases like this in Brockton and they were actually denied because we have a requirement that says that an ADU must meet the required setbacks for the district, which is 15 side 30 rear, which is impossible. But someone had an existing accessory dwelling unit that was not legal, and it was four feet from the property line, and the zoning board denied it. So, you know, it is very complex. It hasn't been challenged in the courts yet. But I will tell you that Again, if this were by right, then it would be kind of a slam dunk. It would be allowed to exist. So the use is protected. The dimensional increases are what the board's considering. But that square footage does include all living space. In addition to that, if they had space down in the basement. And let's just say that that first floor unit had livable space that could be used toward the calculation, they would meet or exceed it, provided that that height is more than six feet, eight inches. So it would be the same as a dwelling unit that was detached, okay? If you have an ADU, a single story ADU that's detached in your backyard, you cannot have a fully habitable size basement, okay? So that you couldn't add living space to that after. Any square footage that is either finished or can be finished, it can be used toward the credit for an accessory dwelling unit. So if that basement is 6'8", even if it's not finished, it still counts against their credit for their ADU. But again, in the CMR, it says all living space of all floors, and it doesn't turn the number of units. So if you've got 1,800 square foot of finished floor space, and you have an additional 800 square feet of space that can be finished in the basement, that would also count toward the credit. So they are probably entitled, if they calculated it that way, to the full 900 square foot. And I see that they've reduced the size of that ADU to 750. And so I just wanted to bring that to you.

[Chris D'Aveta]: I think I just follow up with the line of reasoning here. So if that building that we're discussing now were to be condoized, would one of the other units be able to put an ADU on?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: No, it's one ADU per single family lot. So it's only one ADU per single family lot. It doesn't allow you to have an ADU for each unit. okay but we're calculating based on the shell of the whole structure correct yeah it is yeah there's nothing that concerns it from separate units so if you had a if you had a six family and you wanted to add one you can have one adu for one six family and you would use the square foot calculation for all of those units combined even if they were 500 each or something yes that's correct yep that's correct But you can only have one and you would be able to build to the maximum. And again, this is the state's way of pushing down our throats and making us add units.

[Chris D'Aveta]: I ask because I know that the condo situation is becoming a condo. Each would each be allowed because it's a protected use.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: No, no, it wouldn't be. And that hasn't gone that far in the court yet. But I would tell you that the condominiums are a separate they are a separate issue that would probably be worked out more in the land court than anything else. And that's still miles away. I don't, I don't see that happening. I do see that right now that single family homes have being sold with ADUs attached to them, but I have not seen them come in with separate ownership. You can condoize an accessory dwelling unit because it's a, it's a living unit. It just is a subordinate to the principal dwelling. It doesn't mean you can't sell it. So.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: André, may I add just one thing?

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I added a link in the chat to the FAQ, and essentially all of these questions are actually on that FAQ. They address the question about what if it's a multi-unit structure? What if it's condoized? How many ADUs are they allowed to? What if there are multiple things? What is the square footage? It's all in line with what Commissioner Fordy just explained, but it is written out by the state, those several of those specific questions. So I just wanted people to realize that that was there.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Chris, does that answer your questions? I know you might want to take a look at that document, but I think at least for the particular question about the protected use ADU, it's for the full structure of the calculation.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah. Well, with the situations that I've heard that are, you know, the possibilities that would arise is that the condoization of a structure, which that person is totally allowed to do, would then trigger a protected use ADU for the homeowner who is buying that unit. I guess, you know, like Bill is saying, it hasn't been tested in the courts yet.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, but I do think as, you know, I think as has been affirmed, um, there's only really one allowed per principle structure. And in the, in the case of a condo is Asian, then I think, you know, these are small lots without any dimensional capacity to kind of incorporate that. So I don't think that would be a situation. This is, again, we can, I think, uphold, we can regulate the non-conformities that are proposed by a protected use ADU. We cannot regulate certain other aspects of the protected ADU itself.

So they want to build a protected, they have the right to build a protected use ADU in the half story That's allowed under Medford zoning law. They would like to build a bigger 1. And so we can regulate that. We have some ability to do that. Does that make sense to everyone? But we have to, you know, we have to basically. find we have to kind of articulate what the municipal interest is in regulating that non-conformity like what's if we are going to limit the dormer size for example because it's a non-conforming dormer then what is the municipal interest in doing so and make a finding about that.

[Mary Lee]: Can I ask a question? Attorney Desmond, what do you think the municipal interest is in your case?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Uno reverse. You're muted, Kathy.

[Kathleen Desmond]: I mean, there is the public interest for housing, which is what this statute sets out to do. And, you know, previously you had a variant standard, which was much more difficult. to navigate in terms of housing, but they have now under the state statute allowed for use variances specifically for those municipalities that don't have a use variance for purposes of residential housing. So, you know, in terms of, and you shouldn't be asking me this question, but I mean, I think that the state statute sets out to provide for housing. And I do disagree with respect to the 900 square feet and um I know that's something that that's in contention but that fact sheet clearly says that that an ordinance could limit it to beyond to less than 900 square feet so I I don't know where that goes but you know and that's why we have reduced this in an attempt to to to compromise and you know get the protected adu recognize that um you know this the city has asked for a smaller smaller unit right

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So, board members, thank you Kathy again, you did not have to respond to that, but board members, I think what our job here is to balance the kind of what is required by state law. with what we are allowed to do in terms of upholding the municipal interest of our zoning code and find a balance there. I think in the past with certain projects, we have allowed dormers, for example, of modest size in two and a half story districts. That would not be something that I would be opposed to.

I think, you know, all of you need to kind of come down on, on, on it, but you know, this, some of this stuff has never been figured out in court. We don't have a lot of real clarity around, you know, the edges of it. So there is, you know, municipal interest in more housing units, there is a state interest in more housing units, and we need to balance that with regulating If there's another municipal interest that counterbalances that, we need to articulate that and make a finding.

[Mary Lee]: Well, I tend to agree with with Chris, because I'm not sure if I can make a decision 1 way or another, particularly that if we are charged to the to the board members are charged with defining what that municipal interest is, because it's just so so broad and so fast and I would hate to be. to be put in this position where, you know, we don't have, we, you know, frankly, not much guidance in terms of what is that municipal interest, because the term is municipal. And that interest is specifically that the interest of Medford. So, so having more housing, yes, that's very broad all over the state, maybe even all over the country. But I think it's just, I'm not sure it's practical or possible for us to make a decision and primarily relying on that, what that municipal interest is.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, that's our job. So I think we need to try, um, if we do say, I mean, you know, if members don't agree and they believe that this is not in the municipal interest and can, you know, make a finding and justify that, then, you know, that will be put to a vote. That may go to court, you know, and I think, you know, our job is to try to resolve it here if we can.

[Mary Lee]: Um, with all due respect, but what is the municipal interest? I mean, I, so far the municipal interest I've heard about is that that's clear. It's that we needed more housing. I mean, can we have a guidance in terms of making this decision or voting? What are the municipal interest that we should be basing on? And what would be the source of these interests?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All we are really doing, we're not talking about whether or not there should be a unit, we are just talking about whether to allow this unit to have some non conformities, you know, that are go beyond what the property currently has right now. So, If we say yes to that, then we need to express what the municipal interest is in that. If we say no to that, we need to express the municipal interest in that. So Mary, I would ask you, I don't, I'm not sure entirely where you land on this, but what is it that you would like to see as an outcome? And what do you think the municipal interest is in that?

[Mary Lee]: Well, so far, I mean, I think I would rely on what the city's municipal interest is, and I need to have an understanding what that interest is in order to facilitate myself in terms of making the decision one way or the other. But so far, I don't have a clear picture of what that municipal interest is. I mean, if we have a definition or clear definition of what the city's municipal interest is, and I think that would be very helpful in terms of making the decision either one way or the other. I think that's my point. I mean, I can't define what that municipal interest is, because obviously that interest embodies Multiple people, or every, every individual who lives in method or collectively, right? The majority. So, in terms of making this decision, I just need some guy. I think it'll be helpful for me to have some guidance in terms of what that municipal interest interest or interests are.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I agree that it's a difficult question, but that is our job we are the zone, the Medford zoning board of appeals so we are the ones who are supposed to be defining that and upholding it. So, PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. PB, Harmon Zuckerman. Alicia or Danielle, do you want to try to maybe kind of. Restate a little bit of the high points.

[Mary Lee]: So, so, so is commissioner 4 days statement is that also can we configure that into the municipal interest as well?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Which statement are you referring to?

[Mary Lee]: I think he said that the, uh. the overall footage will not have complied with the building.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I think he was just making an evaluation of facts, what his job is in this situation, which is that because our zoning says you can only have a third floor, with 50% of the habitable space of the floor underneath it, then he made that calculation or his department made that calculation and basically said, this is not allowed. You need to go to the ZBA. And that's where we are now. I don't think he wasn't interpreting the municipal interest. He was basically just interpreting the rule, the ordinance itself.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Mister chair. So so yes, just to clarify what what I what I stated was that if the roof line was high enough we wouldn't be here with this because I would have issued that permit as of right provided that it met the building code requirements for minimum height inhabitable space. They wouldn't have to come here for the variance for the dormers which is what's going to accommodate the space. to you to use the building as they have a right to use the building so that the uses again the use is allowed the dimensional variance to allow the use is really the only question uh in front of the in front of the board so okay so so what is in front of the board is the the use it's not in front of the board nope the the use is not in front of the board what's in front of the board is the dimensional requirements needed to allow to allow the third floor to accommodate a by right use. And in essence, it would be the extension of a nonconformity. But here, because you're only allowed two and a half stories, it's a dimensional variance that would allow a buy right use. So again, if the applicant had come to us for a buy right ADU, I would first allow the 900 square feet because that would not exceed the total living space in the principal building. So when the principal building adds up to 1,800 square feet, they would be allowed that 900 square feet. Let's just say it was in the basement. That same thing, it would be allowed by right because it doesn't supersede the entire allowed living space of the principal building, which doesn't matter, again, how many units are there.

[Mary Lee]: So, so it's before the board, because you need it. They need it by right.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Yeah, they need the extra dimensional accommodation to fit the up there.

[Mary Lee]: Okay, that clarifies it. Thank you.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Danielle yes, thank you. I just kind of wanted to direct the conversation back to it's. what is the municipal interest in enforcing our ordinance's requirement for two and a half stories? Just trying to kind of get back there. Yeah, so I can recount those again. And also we've been counseled by our legal counsel that the use is protected and by right But if you can fit it there, like, so if this was like a five story building and they're like, well, we want to add an ADU because we're entitled to one. No, you can't add a six story. I mean, it's just, where is, I mean, I can't wait for some judges to opine on this because the one size fits all regulation just does not make sense in application. and there was an article in the Globe last week about how some of it is so ridiculous.

It's by right if you can fit it into the dimensional controls, but there is that exception that for this reasonable test, so maybe in certain situations, it would be reasonable to relax that requirement if the municipal interest for that zoning regulation you know, is that purpose is still served there. And that would be, you know, the neighboring context, maybe the corner lot, it's different, it wouldn't have this looming effect if it's on the corner, but another lot that's, you know, more is undersized and has non-conforming setbacks, it wouldn't be reasonable to allow it there. These are just like, I'm just kind of trying to thought here of like where the thought process, I don't know if that helps.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, thank you, Daniel. Can you just restate your original sentence? What you said? I think that was very helpful. So redirect us back to yes, so.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: What the the zoning board needs to be considering? And discussing is is. Enforcing the two and a half story limitation for the GR district. Is that a reasonable regulation that serves the municipal interest for why those are there? And the reason why you have that is because, you know, the privacy, the looming effect, the shadow, the light and air, things like that. because there's a de facto third story. And in the zoning district, we've said two and a half stories is appropriate because having windows and all this living space on the side yards or the side of the gable wasn't an appropriate architectural pattern in that zone.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Do all the board members understand like what it is that we're doing. We are. Enforcing or not, we're basically saying what is the municipal interest in having the two and a half story requirement, and we would need to make a finding. If we uphold that to the detriment of the proposal here, we would need to make a finding that states what the municipal interest is. I think Yvette made a good Suggestion earlier, which was to let's look at the project. Let's consider its context. And then let's identify whether we can state a municipal interest. In upholding or not. The 2 and a half story zoning requirement.

Let's go back to that. Attorney Desmond, would you mind sharing the visuals of Vassar Street? Not necessarily the interior plan, but the exterior as well. Let's start there. I know it's changed a little bit, but if we could give everybody a visual of the neighborhood and the parcel itself. Great, thank you. So 102 Vassar Street, it's on a corner lot. It's not very close to the adjacent buildings. And can you show us, is this the rendering or is this the existing?

[Kathleen Desmond]: That's the rendering.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. This is the dormer that was initially proposed. Is that correct? Or is it on the other side?

[Kathleen Desmond]: Right. And that's the original picture, I believe.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. So this is the dormer. And is the dormer only on this side?

[Kathleen Desmond]: No, the dormer's on both sides. I don't know if there's a straightaway on this particular one that we had. I don't think I had a straightaway on this one for some reason. But it's an identical dormer on the other side adjacent to a vacant lot. So that is not the rendering, but that's what it would appear from the front right there. Now that dorm is reduced on one side, on the left-hand side of the building.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay, on this side.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Correct, on this side. It's reduced in the back, not in the front because of the need to put the kitchen in to be able to stack your services. But there's a vacant lot adjacent to it.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. So members seeing kind of this, remembering like what's being proposed, is there, can you express a municipal interest in enforcing the dimensional requirements of the city zoning ordinance here? And do you, do you want to do that?

[Yvette Velez]: Can we also talk about it in the context of. Again, overcrowding in the streets, right? We can't say. Because parking is not part of this, but like. Because of the way this is situated. Right I mean, it is going to impact the larger community. So. Speaking on that, so I, because I think a corner lot would be good, right? Like, that's great. Like, that to me is fine like that. If if we were to approve something like this, a corner lot would be ideal because it's not. Impacting as many people, right?

but does that impact more people in that way? Like, is this gonna be a detriment to the neighborhood in that way? And then I guess I would lean towards this isn't gonna work because it is an overcrowded neighborhood, right? We've already discussed it. But tell me it differently. If somebody can tell me differently then, I would lean towards no.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And here is, let me share my screen too.

[Unidentified]: Okay, so this is just the Google Street view of the property.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Wellesley Street here on this side is pretty narrow. You have, there's this driveway which looks like it only accommodates two cars in tandem. Maybe, I don't know if there's two side-by-side, but there's no off-street parking for this unit being proposed. Again, we cannot regulate on that.

[Unidentified]: This is Main Street right here.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So this is where the dormer is going to be on that side.

[Unidentified]: And then on this side, would be another dormer here.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And neither one is adjacent to properties. And there's a butter on this side is pretty far away. The streets are very narrow. It is a very congested neighborhood. I've been over there quite a bit. You know, you can see some of these like streets that all come off of main street or like don't have enough room for cars to go. This is a two-way street. So it is very congested. We did hear from some neighbors their concerns about that.

Other board members have an opinion. I don't know, Jim, do you have any thoughts about this?

[Unidentified]: I've been out for the last two months, but I've been trying to follow up on it. I do believe that it's overcrowded in that area and that the street is very narrow. I know it very well. So I'm trying to process everything currently. So it will remain a two and a half story, but it will have two bedrooms in each unit. This is just for the third floor, the top floor where the dormers are going. Right. But is it considered a two and a half story?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, it's not changing the overall zoning of the district.

[Chris D'Aveta]: So yes, Chris. I guess if the floor area exceeds 50% of the lower floor, then it is a third floor, correct? So it's become a three story structure.

[Unidentified]: If I may, that's my only dilemma. Is it a two and a half, or does it now become a three story?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: No, I mean, we're basically providing zoning relief and they're not using the full three stories, so no. Did I get what you were gonna say, Attorney Desmond?

[Unidentified]: Yes, Danielle.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: What was the question again? Is this a third story?

[Unidentified]: Is it considered a third story? three-story now where you've expanded that top floor?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: As proposed, yes. That's a third story. If it's either a half story or it's a full story, there's no in between.

[Unidentified]: We keep saying two and a half stories, but is it a three-story?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: PB, Harmon Zuckerman. No, I mean, but Danielle, let's not muddy the waters here, please. We're not saying that you can max out on the third story, the building of the habitable unit of the unit. So like, this is not a, this is not an important part of the conversation.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I just, I thought I heard something. Yeah. Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So it's already, do you want to, do you want to chip in, chime in on that at all?

[Kathleen Desmond]: No, I guess that was my point that it would be limited to the size of the ADU, which we've reduced from what would have been actually close to a full story. I don't think it was quite a full story to something less than that based on the square footage of the ADU. And that's what it would be. You couldn't then, you wouldn't then have the right to call it nonconforming and exceed that. It is what it is once you set the ADU and the limits for the plan. And what we're looking at in this specific is adding 212 square feet to what the half story would be.

If you calculate it, the 568 is what the half story is. This adds 212 square feet.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, so members who have expressed skepticism about this, I need you to articulate a municipal interest in upholding the two and a half story, the city's two and a half story zoning ordinance based on everything you've heard so far and what you've seen from the neighborhood. My personal take on this, if if it helps is that. You know, I think we've given some dimensional relief for dormers in the past modestly sized dormers that do not convert the building from what looks like a 2 and a half story that. fits in with the rest of the neighborhood to a full-fledged three-story building. I think the proponent has reduced the size of the dormers for Vassar Street, which is what we're considering right now. There are no abutters on either side where the dormers are. I do not believe that the municipal Kind of interest is outweighs the housing piece. I would like to be able to regulate about the bedrooms and the parking, but we cannot do either of those things. And so. I would make. A finding that the modest. Dimensional relief, um. that would preserve the spirit of Medford's two and a half story zoning district would accommodate this project and we could move on.

That's not what I'm hearing from all of you, so I need you to articulate something different.

[Yvette Velez]: I just want to be clear that it's only 200 and what did you say?

[Kathleen Desmond]: Kathleen, it was 212 because if you do the math, 568 is the half story limit and and to get to the 780, it's 5. 212 square feet additional.

[Yvette Velez]: So, when I hear it from that, I mean, that's pretty small. So I feel I feel like that would be. And it's a much comfortable space. So. I guess I would be, you know, to your point, my main thought is like, oh, it's impeding the neighborhood, right, overcrowding all the things, right? But if it was, but I do think the location of a corner lot, like, does supersede that to some extent, like, not every place would take this granted, but like, This is actually situated in a decent spot, so. I think I would I could see. Moving forward with it.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you. And it does have twice as much frontage as being a corner lot as your typical unit does. So in terms of street frontage for if cars are parked, it's not an ideal situation. I know it. But this is where we're at. This is kind of where the state law has put us in this position. So I don't know, Chris, Mary, Jim.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah, I mean, from my perspective, you know, and we did this a couple of meetings ago, which we, you know, we showed the illustrated the other houses around this particular house and some of them are much larger. It's not that the massing of the house that we would allow, you know, the alterations would then be the biggest around. In fact, it'll still be one of the smaller ones if you look at the additional houses. My confusion and consternation was that the ADU was being put forward as a reason to create a third unit in a two and a half story district, which you know, if we now understand that you can count the whole house, which I hadn't been, um, apprised of, you know, you can count multiple units to calculate the square footage of an additional protected use ADU, then, uh, I'm okay with that. I think the remaining question is what the one, uh, that, um, uh, member, uh, Lee brings up, which is that, you know, what is the municipal interest? And if, and I think this bears some discussion, not necessarily here, but in the future and with the, you know, legal council, which is what is the municipal interest, of course, Medford as a city doesn't have any municipal interests other than the interests of its residents. It's not a body unto itself, except it's made up of residents, correct? So its municipal interests are dictated by those of its residents. And so if this addition was detrimental to the other residents, then it would be against municipal interests in my opinion. But I don't think that's the case here.

However, There are issues with the parking, with the overcrowding. We're creating more units. And then there could be more of these ADUs in this street. Because remember, this is right next to a university. And enrollment keeps increasing. And so therefore, the need for bedrooms keeps increasing.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And all of those things are things that we cannot regulate, unfortunately, because of the state law and guidelines. So it does put our hands in a bind. I agree. Mary, what's your thinking after hearing all of the discussion?

[Mary Lee]: Yeah, I mean, I understand that we're not regulating parking, but I think parking is part of a consideration for municipal interests. And I think if we solely evaluate this based on municipal interests, then it really granting this would not really serve the municipal interest, because I would hate to. to set a precedent about at least leaning or give any indication about what the main municipal interest is. And I don't want to define that and the fact that if we make a decision on this, it will reflect on our definition of the municipal interest. But I think we're not regulating the parking. But I think it does contribute to the, to the definition of municipal interest.

So, and I, and I don't think we have enough information to, or at least for me, I don't have enough information just to based a decision or setting a precedent for future applicants about what that municipal interest should be.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, I mean, Mary, I feel like if we don't articulate a municipal interest, if this board does not do that, then the basically the state law and the state interest will. Kind of prevail because it is. To protect 80 years and get more of them built across the state and build more housing. So so I think the option is. I know you don't want to create a precedent, but the that's. the answer would be to articulate a municipal interest for not doing it. If we cannot do that, then I don't see what our option is other than to approve the project.

[Mary Lee]: Well, as I said before, I think parking, it's a contributing factor to municipal interest. And I do think that, yes, there is a state interest, but the statute particularly said municipal interest. So that definition specifically applies to the City of Medford. And I think it calls for what the municipal interest for Medford is. So in considering the constructions for the parking, and I would think that that would be a part of the municipal interest.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right, but that also gets into the other concept of reasonable regulation. So we are allowed to reasonably regulate, you know, And there are certain things that the state says, by definition, are unreasonable. And parking, regulating on parking, regulating on number of bedrooms, those are two of what the state defines as unreasonable regulations.

[Mary Lee]: but we're not regulating on parking. I'm just saying that it's a high contributing, major contributing factor to the interests of the residents. So, I mean, that's why in the very beginning, I said that we need a clear definition or more guidance in terms of what the municipal interests are or is. And I hear bits and pieces of that, but I still don't have a coherent idea of what that interest is or what those interests are. So, it's not about regulations, it's about all these combined factors that contributes to that municipal interest or interests.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right, but what we are doing, we are a regulatory body and we have to articulate what our decision is based on, which we need to provide. So anyways, Yvette, I see your hand raised.

[Yvette Velez]: So I, Mary, have changed my original thought of no to yes, because not only is the location, I think, decent for this type of ADU also and it's not detrimental to the neighborhood. Also the neighborhood itself, while it is dense, it is very close to the public transportation. So I don't think the parking now would be detrimental to the neighborhood because I think what you're saying, what I understand you to say is the municipal interest is the neighborhood and the neighborhood has a few people have articulated that it's overcrowding and There's not enough parking, and I'm saying I'm disagreeing with that, that it's not a detriment.

And so that's how I came to view it and to change my mind in regards to like, and again, it was a 250, right, number. So that's pretty small for a decent accommodations for an ADU. So I think it's reasonable. And then we are supposed to look at each property and project individually. So I'm going to counter the whole we are setting precedent. This is not precedent to that extent, because again, where it is located, what it is surrounding, how the, you know, when I hear how things should be affected in the greater, the neighborhood, I don't see that. So maybe Mary, look, if you could try to look at it through that lens, or tell me if I'm wrong in what you're trying to articulate.

[Mary Lee]: So, if in our decision, we can specify that this is not a precedent, but it's only. It's only a particular to this specific location and this project. I think. I will be okay with that, but it would have to be clearly stated in the decision.

[Denis MacDougall]: And sorry, let me just jump in here. We've done that in the past. We've had cases on the same street where we've had allowed. You know, a conversion, you know, from a single family to a 2 family, and then 5 houses down, we haven't. So, there's just because we're doing it at this 1 property doesn't mean we have to do it for another.

[Mary Lee]: So, it will be in the decision, right? This is on. Yeah. Okay.

[Denis MacDougall]: Thank you for this property.

[Unidentified]: Yeah, Jim. Could an interest be that we're making more space available for. People to. you know, live in our community or to live in that area where it might be closer to school, closer to, let's say, transportation where they can go into Boston and get around, wouldn't that be considered an interest?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, absolutely. That's an interest. If I'm interpreting what you're saying correctly, it's an interest in favor of the proposal.

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes. So, there's 2 ways we can go about doing this. I mean, 1 is we can. find that the proposal is reasonable given its location and that a reasonable application of the two and a half story Medford zoning ordinance would allow the more modest dormers that have been now proposed by Attorney Desmond's client. I agree. That would be something we can put on the table that would would also kind of wrap the variance kind of request into that, because this is not what we've we've heard from the city council is that. You know, a variance, they do not believe that a variance is really the way to go, but. The proponent has asked for a variant, so we sort of just need to wrap it all into the decision of the board. and that that would be taken care of. Now the special permit, which I think is also for faster street, we would need to address, have a separate vote on that special permit, which we would do after this. Okay. So that's one way that's sort of how I'm proposing. We, we go now there is another way we could go, which would be to find that the proposal, um, It's not in the interest of the city because the two and a half story Medford zoning ordinance is reasonable and the municipal interest is that it provides a good quality of life for everybody in the neighborhood.

And as a result, we deny the dimensional relief that's sought. I propose for Vassar Street for this one at least. I think because there's not abutters on either side, because it has double street frontage on the corner, I find that it would be reasonable for us to accept this. I think a court might interpret it as unreasonable if we were to deny it, but we can do either one of those things.

[Unidentified]: No, I'm in favor. I tend to feel it is, uh, reasonable. After hearing, you know, everyone.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And because this is, uh, you know, being treated as, uh, essentially on appeal of the building department decision. that we do need a super majority vote to pass it. So that's four out of five members need to vote yes. So let me try to put a motion on the table here, which is what I just said. So I would find that it would be reasonable and in the interest of the city's zoning ordinance to allow the reasonable zoning dimensional relief through the dormers as newly proposed by Attorney Desmond's client for 1-2 Vassar Street and allow the project to go forward, addressing the variance, request is not needed, and dealing with the special permit separately.

[Unidentified]: Is there, so I would. I would also move on that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And attorney doesn't mean, can you just for the state for us exactly what the square footage is that's going to be in the. That would be in the order to be 7, is that correct?

[Kathleen Desmond]: Yes, I believe let me just 7, 780.

[Unidentified]: I believe if I could just.

[Kathleen Desmond]: share my screen so I can just confirm it. Or I can try and pull it up on my other screen. I just don't want to lose.

[Unidentified]: Absolutely. Yep.

[Kathleen Desmond]: All right.

[Unidentified]: It was 568 and 212. So 780 square feet.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Great, thank you. So, Jim has moved. So moved. Is there a second?

[Mary Lee]: Um, 2nd, but I would add that. The decision, it's only applicable to this. Project this proposal to this house, it doesn't mean that the decision does not reflect that the board has defined. What the municipal interest is, even though we try to. Conform our decision to what was proposed by the. The office of planning and development, but it doesn't mean that we define what that those municipal interests are.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So, Mary, can I try to put that into a friendly amendment that we just we state that. This is limited to the case of 1 to 2 Vassar street.

[Unidentified]: Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So, Jim, is that all right? Are you all right with that friendly amendment to your motion? I am. So, Mary, did you want a 2nd. The motion with that yes.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Okay, thank you. Uh, let's clarification. This is the finding for correct.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So. We're basically rolling a couple of things all into one vote. A finding and a ruling on the variance, ruling that the variance is not, the request that is not required. And that's been advised by city council. Okay. The finding, the only thing it doesn't include is the special permit, which we will then vote on after this.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Okay. Okay. So that will be included. Dennis will draft that up into the. Yeah. Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. Uh, let's go to a roll call vote. Uh, Yvette Velez. Hi, Jim Tarani. Hi, Chris. Hi, Mary Lee.

[Mary Lee]: Yeah, I, but provided that we also in the decision to include that the board did not define or clearly define what the municipal interest or interest are.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, it is included that as a friendly amendment to the motion. Yes. Yes. And I'm an eye as well. So. Uh, attorney Desmond, the for 1 to 2 Vassar street that, uh, we've. We've issued a finding we do not need to deal with the variance and we've granted a degree of dimensional relief for your client.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Thank you. And then we still have the special permit issue. Correct on on master, which would be needed even if this was not. You know, if we weren't seeking more than that, they have story because. It's nonconforming. We're not changing the nonconformity, but the, um, plane of the left side of the house sits in the, um, in the side yard set back by one and a half feet, I believe, or thereabouts. Um, and we're moving vertically up from that. So it's not encroaching further into the side yard, but it's being verdict. The plane, the vertical plane is being increased. Um, and that requires a special permit under the, under the code.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, so do all board members understand that? So we would now be voting on a special permit. So the dormer, which, as we've seen in the diagrams, are on both sides of the roof plane. So if you're facing the house on the left side, that dormer does not go out further than what the existing house kind of wall does, but it goes up. So that means we're extending an existing nonconformity and we have to issue a special permit to allow that to happen.

[Denis MacDougall]: PB, David Ensign – He, Him, His PB, David Ensign – He, Him, His PB, David Ensign – He, Him, His

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, so yeah, Dennis, I, that was I rolled that into the roll.

[Denis MacDougall]: Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Sorry.

[Denis MacDougall]: Sorry. Sorry. I'm trying to do 4 different things here.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, no, I appreciate it. Yep. Thank you. All right, so any questions about the special permit before we go to a motion? Is there a motion to approve the special permit to extend the existing non-conformity for the left dormer?

[Mary Lee]: Motion.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you, Mary. Is there a second? Jim, thank you. Okay. Roll call vote. Yvette Villes?

[Yvette Velez]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tarani? Aye. Chris DiVetta? Aye. Mary Lee?

[Mary Lee]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And I'm an I as well. The special permit has been approved for one to two Vassar Street. Thank you. Thank you, Attorney Desmond. All right, hopefully, this one will be a little quicker. We'll see. Moving on to Dennis, next item on the agenda.

[Denis MacDougall]: Wellesley Street, continuing from September 2026, applicant Christian Austin constructs two shed dormers and expand the existing attic space to create a full third story at 12 Wellesley Street for purposes of a protected ADU, which is in the general residence zoning district, requiring a variance and refining pursuant to Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 48, Section 3.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, and Attorney Desmond, do you want to share your screen and just kind of bring us up to speed? You know, we don't have to go into a lot of the issues, but just so people can see where the property is and what the... Right.

[Yvette Velez]: And can I just add, Attorney Desmond, as you go through it, can you look at it through the lens of what we would think about for the greater good?

[Kathleen Desmond]: If I could just, I'm just going to try, because I'm not finding it when I go to share, but it's here. So let me just X out of one and see if I can't. All right. Here it is. Oh, good. And you can see that on your screen. I assume, um, yes. So in this particular instance, um, the second floor level is 1206 square feet. Um, if you looked at it from, um, what would be permitted on a half story, the square feet, the square footage that would be permitted would be 603 square feet 603 square feet.

[Unidentified]: Hold on just one moment. Sorry, Jim. Do you have an urgent question? Yeah. Attorney Desmond, could you make that a little larger if that's possible? Thank you. Great. Thanks.

[Kathleen Desmond]: I haven't lost it. So we're, we're good. Um, so, so 603 square feet would be permitted. Um, we have reduced on, on this one. If you look at what the prior was, uh, level three was 870. 5 square feet, which is smaller than the other unit to begin with. This is being reduced to 769 square feet, which is a difference of 166 square feet from what you would have on a second story level. It also reduced the dormers to 26.4 on one side.

The other dormer is still 31, so they're a little bit off keel based on the square footage and trying to get in the living space on this. As you can see, it's a two-bedroom unit with a kitchen and just a small living dining area in the front of the property. So it's very similar in terms of layout. Let me see if I could just get down to, in terms of what it looks like, that would be the front. We have the, so that's the visual on the dormers on 12 Wellesley. It is significant to note that there's a lot more space on the side, which has the dormer, which will now move forward, which will remain at 30 feet. This distance is even though both meet the 7 and a half requirement. There's much more space on the Wellesley side of the property. It also kind of balances out. I don't know if I have a front. Yeah, so that that's what the property looks like from the front. It's kind of an unattractive front to the property. The dormers kind of balance it out. I think anyway, in terms of in terms of the space.

And so basically, that's the difference. It's on the same street. You can see that there are large houses next door. It looks like there's probably a full third story in the Brown House located next door. So it is a situation where you have larger units. Again, there's two bedrooms, and one can function as an office or as a guest bedroom. And I just want to kind of raise this point because the two bedrooms, you know, gives the opportunity to share the costs of living. And I think all of us who are parents who have been in situations where you have a roommate and suddenly that roommate leaves and the space is expensive and you haven't got anywhere to put anybody else to share that space. And I think we talked about that at the last meetings too, that there's a price point where it doesn't, singles don't necessarily, work that they're they're difficult for people to carry so the two-bedroom even if you're even if you go into it as a single it gives you the option of bringing someone on um to to help with expenses um and again uh we're asking for an increase of 166 square feet over what would be allowed um as i've said before that the whole second story half story is is rather subjective because it all depends on what you have in terms of your second story level. If you have more space on your second story level, then your half story is much bigger. I've had situations too before this board where it becomes a diminishing violation because if you added on, if you had space to add on, you would, by virtue of adding space to the first and second floor, you know, diminish or negate your half story issues. So it, the half story is, is somewhat subjective, I guess is my point. Um, and I, I think that's, I don't want to belabor the point. I think we've been over the, the, um, factual aspects of this for, for quite some time. Um, but, but that, that would be the difference. It would be 166 square feet. Um, and seven 69 would be the total square footage.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks and attorney Desmond, I know that this, so this is a rendering of, you know, that was submitted with the. Original is, and it looks like the dormers here are very to the front of the, like, towards the street line. The facade is that actually the case, or is it going to be set back. Further, like, the brown house next to it.

[Kathleen Desmond]: We have the. So I don't have a measure on it.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Um, but it is set back. Right.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Thank you.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Do you want me to stop sharing or do you want it shared?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Uh, let's stop sharing so we can. Okay. Thank you. All right. Any, any questions by board members, uh, about this proposal? And then we'll still do the public hearing and go into deliberation. So.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah, Chris, just a clarification. So we're comparing apples to apples. I think. As I said on the prior application about the gross square footage versus the livable area. I think we're not. Voting on the smaller number voting on the larger number because. That's how a house square footage is calculated. And. I know it seems like we're voting on the lesser number because that's where you live. But if you look at the other floors, the architect knows what he or she is doing and is calculating all of the floors in the same manner. So I just want to compare apples to apples. So I don't think it's just an increase of whatever it was, the square footage that's a livable area. I believe it's this increase to the gross square footage just as the other floors of that building are calculated similarly to the way the third floor is calculated.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I'm going to take a stab at this. Let's see. I don't know if Bill 40 is still here, but maybe he could explain it better. I guess my interpretation is that the square footage, and we're putting this in the order itself of the board, that the smaller one like we did, for example, for the previous item is going into our order. I understand what you're saying, Chris, maybe a stairwell would add a little bit. to that because if you want to consider it habitable space, but it doesn't necessarily qualify as habitable space for purposes of the unit itself. The floor plan of the third floor is 1,100 square feet, so it doesn't change that. I don't think, in my opinion, it matters too much.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Well, I think for the record, it would banner because, you know, we're, we're, if you look at the plan that was just illustrated, they're all calculated in the same manner. So it's not like the third floor is somehow different than the first or the second floor of that building. They're the exact. Same calculation. So the calculator from the exterior wall, which I agree is not where you live, but, um, when you, you know, you build a new house or anything. It's always that way. So I'm not sure why we're looking now at livable area versus gross square footage just to make the number look smaller. I don't, I'm not, maybe the building commissioner can comment on that, but I just, that's a little bit annoying that they were talking about a different number when the architect has clearly defined what that number is at the bottom?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Just to be clear, again, regardless of how many units the building is, the livable square footage that exists right now, and including square footage that could be utilized and finished, would be the total calculation that could be used to allow for the ADU, the by-right ADU. So if you have 2,000 square feet, if you have 1,000 square feet in each unit, that 2,000 square feet, half of that or the maximum of 900 square feet can be used. At your discretion, if an ADU is reduced to that 750 because it otherwise can make it more, you know, more appropriate for the neighborhood, whether that be a cutting down of the dormers or a little bit less square footage on the very top floor rather than what's on the first and second floor, then certainly that's the discretion of the board. But the gross square foot calculation is all of the floors of a single, two, or even three family. If it were a three-family, it would be the same thing. So the finished gross floor area, and again, only one ADU is allowed per lot. That's it. It doesn't multiply itself by saying each unit gets to have an ADU, even if those are condoized. You know what I mean? Even if they're in separate ownership, they still, there's only one ADU that can be produced. So obviously, you know, it would have to be by by covenant, if you were going to divide that up into two, you would not be able to replicate that. You only allow by one ADU by right, and that's it.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah, in fact, if I could follow up, Mr. Commissioner, that's exactly, I wasn't going to revisit that whole question from the last application, but I was just wondering, based on what the architect has rendered there, what are we supposed to put in as the proper square footage that we're approving, not outside of whether or not we, you know, like we've established that they can they can count the whole building as in their calculation.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Right. So if the architect reports only a thousand square feet, I wasn't sure I didn't see the calculation. I was just busy with something else.

[Kathleen Desmond]: But I could give you the note that he wrote to me and then maybe that will clarify as to why there are differences between So I asked that question this afternoon and what I received back from the architect was that ADU square footage is measured to the interior face of exterior walls while gross square footage of floors in the overall building is measured to the exterior face in the building walls. So what he's calculating the area on is the interior of the walls that will be the ADU.

[Chris D'Aveta]: We're approving, just to the commissioner if I may, we're approving

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: the livable area and not the gross square footage of... Yeah, the outside to outside gross square footage of the building is different from the livable net square feet of the interior of the ADU. And other things that are excluded from the ADU are also stairs. If they are not part of... If the stairs are common area, okay, and let's just say that the staircase is When you when you get to the top floor. Okay, that does a door that closes and that common area starts that part of the common area does not count against your square footage. However, if the doors at the very bottom, then that staircases included in your square footage. Okay, so so it kind of, it's a little complex, but it but it does. uh, what, what, uh, attorney Desmond said is correct. That's how the CMR is worded. And that, that's how they're allowed to, to get a little extra square footage. That's, that's kind of what it gives you, um, in the CMR, which is the code of mass regulation regarding, um, you know, um, accessory dwelling units. Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks Chris. Any other clarifying questions? All right, let's open the public hearing portion of this meeting. Are there any members of the public who would like to weigh in on this matter? For 12 Wellesley Street. Okay, Dennis, have we received any additional comments on this project?

[Denis MacDougall]: Nothing since the last year.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay, thank you. All right, is there a motion to close the public hearing portion? Or the public input portion of the hearing? So moved. Second. Is that you, Jim? Yeah, so moved. All right, thank you. Roll call vote. Yvette Velez.

[Yvette Velez]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tirani. Aye. Chris Stavena. Aye. Mary Lee. Aye. And I'm an eye as well, so the public participation. Period is closed and now board members, we move into deliberation. What are your thoughts about 12 Wesley? And I guess, since we just had a long conversation about 1 to 2 Vassar, are there. Any reasons to kind of deviate from what we did there.

[Yvette Velez]: Can someone remind me of the abutting neighbors spoken about this project? The direct neighbors.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I don't know if Dennis, you have that, if you're able to find it. And in the meantime, I can just share my screen here. Okay, so this is 12 Wellesley right here. That's the brown house with the dormers right next to it. This house looks like it's on Main Street. Main Street has a lot of homes that are denser, larger, like three stories.

[Unidentified]: Going this way, smaller.

[Denis MacDougall]: So the letter writer was at 20, so two houses over. And mostly their concern was traffic on the letter.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right. It wasn't necessarily about size, just traffic.

[Denis MacDougall]: Yeah, it wasn't about the massing, per se.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right. As you can see, there's a lot of curb cuts, so not a ton of on-street parking here. As you get closer to Main Street, I know people do park near Main Street if they are going to Main Street.

[Unidentified]: They park on all these side streets.

[Yvette Velez]: I think I'd be inclined to say that these dormers are not detrimental to the neighborhood. They would echo, and I didn't hear any huge, I didn't hear any complaints in regards to the neighbors, like, about the massing of the building itself. So, I mean, I would be inclined you know, to make this ADU, you know, if they were going to do, just add extra bedrooms up there with the dormers, you know, you're still adding people if you, right, to a different household. But I think this is a quality of life. And when we talk about, you know, The larger community and housing, you know, I don't I think this would be a still an okay project to add it on the top floor.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks a bit. Other members have thoughts. Again, very similar to our last project, wish we could regulate a number of bedrooms, wish we could regulate parking and accommodate that. We're not really able to do that. I don't think this street is permit parking only. or we could ask the proponent to make sure that they don't have a vehicle or that they would not be applying for that on-street parking. But again, in this case, I don't think possible.

I'm glad that the dormers are set a little further back than they appear to be in the rendering to match the brown house next door. Um, so I would say that I would be inclined to kind of do a similar finding and motion as the 1st project.

[Unidentified]: I would agree.

[Mary Lee]: I would also agree, but I would put in the same conditions that we that we propose in the Vassar street project. with respect to the municipal interests, and also that it's not a precedent and only applicable to this particular project.

[Unidentified]: Yeah. Yeah.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Chris, do you have thoughts? No, I just wanted to clarify the square footage question that I had and the commissioner has, so I'm satisfied with that. I think it is much like the other project. spent a couple of hours discussing, so I don't see it as, you know, impeding, well, we didn't ask for, you know, front sunlight studies or something like that, but I don't think it would be, you know, directing any shadow to the neighboring buildings.

So I, don't really have an issue with it. I do agree with you, essentially, that the parking, we are adding to that load on the street. And does that count as a municipal interest in the larger scheme of things? So we should have some discussion regarding that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, I mean, I think the neighbors could potentially pursue, you know, resident parking only policy. That's where we're at right now. You know, unless the state comes out in the future with some additional guidelines, refinements about, you know, what municipalities can do to kind of regulate these, then I think this is where we're at at the moment. Given the fact that it is very similar to the building, the brown house right next door, the dormers will match it. I don't think it's out of character from a design standpoint.

Let me try to make a similar motion here. For the case of 12 Wellesley Street, the board would make a finding that reasonable dimensional relief as proposed by the client, Attorney Desmond's client, for a dormer would be reasonable and would not violate the city's sort of two and a half story zoning ordinance in a way that's seriously detrimental to the zoning ordinance. As Mary said, you know, we're really focused. This is just for this property. So we'd like to put some language in there about that. We'll clarify that the variance request is not needed. That'll be part of this decision. And I think that covers it, no special permit on this one, so.

Would someone, is there a board member who would make that motion? So moved. Thanks, Jim. Is there a second? Second. Thanks, Mary. Roll call vote. Yvette Velez.

[Yvette Velez]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tarani. Aye. Chris De Vetta. Aye. Mary Lee.

[Mary Lee]: Aye. Again, I just want to stress that we, the board or I myself, we did not define what that municipal interest is in this decision.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you. And I'm an aye as well. So the The finding for modest is made for the modest dimensional relief for the nonconformity proposed and you have the proponent can move forward with a protected ADU.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Thank you. And I'd like to thank the board for taking all the time. I know this has been a difficult and complicated situation because the statute is complicated and there isn't any case law at this point and then throw in what happened with the variances. that it's been a lot, and we do appreciate your time and review. And we did throw it all at you, the dormers and the protected use, just so that you would know that that's what was intended. Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, thank you. Thank you. It was important for us to work through all of this one at some point. So I guess this prepares us better for the future to deal with these items.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Christian, did you want to say something? This is Christian Austin, my client. I don't know. He's muted. Thumbs up. Right. Thank you.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Right. Thank you. Christian. Thank you for being an owner investor in the neighborhood and good luck with the project. Dennis, any next steps that you want to mention before we move on?

[Denis MacDougall]: Just for attorney Desmond, if you want to expedite this, if you want to help draft vaccine findings, I would be much appreciated.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay, Dennis, next item on the agenda.

[Denis MacDougall]: 11 Albion Street. Applicant Sam Collins to increase the third floor area at 11 Albion Street beyond the maximum of 50% of the story below in reference to the dimensional requirements of Table B of Section 94 and this term story half is defined in Section 94-12.0 definitions requiring a variance and a special permit.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, another third floor. Thank you. Yes, sir. Would you be able to walk us through, Mr. Collins, what you're proposing?

[SPEAKER_02]: Sure. Good evening, everybody, members of the board and planners. Thanks for being here. So this is a single-family home. It's going to stay a single-family home. The owners are trying to do their best to maximize the property within their, their budget for a long term livability dream home status, looking to eventually have their child move back in or move in with them. So the idea is to finish the third floor. which is currently already livable square footage, but expanding it. And because of the ridgeline that requires dormers to do so. It will be one bedroom on the third floor, but again, not adding any units.

So let me, is it okay if I start with a screen share just to give a perspective? Yes. So screen share, here we go. All right. Let me know when you can see it. Yep. So this is actually the backyard view and it's a pretty unique property. And I just wanted to call your attention to this right away. The second floor for reasons unbeknownst to us was not filled out with the rest of the property. And in fact, the first floor only has a sunroom on the back part of the foundation. So it's a way underutilized footprint. So we are exceeding the 50%. Currently, the third floor would be 640 livable.

and the floors below are seven, I think the first floor is like 795. And so if, and I understand that that may not come into play here, but it's just, we're under already tight constraints for that limit. If it were the full, if the second floor were the full size of the first floor, we'd only be talking about 149 square foot area relief. Since it's not, we're looking for 240 square foot over the 50%, again, for a total LSF of 640 square feet.

Also, in terms of appropriateness in the neighborhood, you are now looking at, on the right, that is 11 Albion, on the left, that is their immediate next-door neighbor. There is a special permit.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Sorry, Mr. Collins, the screen didn't change, so we're just still looking at it. Oh, how do I do?

[SPEAKER_02]: I have to share a different screen? If it's on a different tab, you might have to. Yes, I think I have to. Let me see if I can do that. Oh, boy. Here I was thinking I was good at this. You might have to kind of stop sharing. Any questions just on the perspective? And I can take us through the rest of the drawing since we're up.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: One basic question, which is, is there any reason why not expand the second floor kind of over the foundation?

[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, cost prohibitive and cost restrictive. And it doesn't create another sort of area, if you will, if you were going to make this, consider this an in-law suite on the third floor for the current owners who are also on the call, if you have any questions for them. It would add some square footage, but not enough, like we're adding a bathroom and basically a separate adult living space within the family for the third floor. Okay. That's a good question. Yeah. We did look into that, but it is a lot more expensive than I wanted it to be to just to open up that corner of the house and fill it out. Yeah. So I'll take you to the plans real quick before I try to change tabs. here's the existing. As you can see, the first floor fills out and encloses the porch, but does not make that livable space. And the second floor, that's all cut out below. And in fact, if we were going to encapsulate the whole property, it would be almost compliant and might not need to request it at all.

And there's the ticket to the third floor plan, single bedroom, which, you know, if somebody in the future wants to make this a separate unit, it's ideal for what the city wants. Nice, his and hers closet, big bathroom, single bedroom, lots of storage. And that's it, that's the third floor. Here's the view from the front. These are set back four feet, an inch from the roof and three feet in from the front wall. A little setback. And as you can see, we're splitting into two roofs to further reduce the sort of encumbrance, the visual weight of it, right? So we break it up with like a little dormer, another dormer in the back.

And this side is already much smaller because of the missing bite, if you will, from the frame of the house. Let me try to change tabs. I will stop sharing. and go to a picture of the house. Share again. Here we go. Yes, thank you for that advice, whoever gave it, that was correct. Move my windows around here. Okay, so we're looking at the backside. There's a better picture. So can everybody see the two houses now? Is that correct? Yes. All right, so on the right, that's 11 Albion. And their left-hand neighbor already has oversized dormers. And this is the, There's also a special permit application to extend vertically a non-conforming side, just like your other project there. And that is the side that already shares that dormer with the neighbor.

So there's still some space, but it is non-conforming. It's too close to the property line. And again, that's just the same perspective from the other side. Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: What's the distance between the two homes?

[SPEAKER_02]: Matt is on the call. He is the architect. I wonder if he can answer that. That is not on the plans. I can quickly dig up the plot. You can come back to that. You can continue. Okay. Yeah. If you see Matt Carlson there, if he could be unmuted, that is the architect for this project. I suppose you guys get the idea with the house. Okay, to stop sharing or do you have the other side of the house as well? The other butter? I do. I didn't load it up here because that is the side that there is plenty of room. Okay. If can that be muted? Do you see Matt Carlson? Yeah, he's here. His camera's on.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And actually, Sam, could you stop sharing for a moment? I can, of course. Thank you for that. Dennis, if you could get Matt to unmuted. Hey, everybody. Hey, Matt.

[SPEAKER_06]: Can everyone hear me OK? Yes. So yeah, just to jump in and help out. We don't have specific dimensions of the adjacent property, how wide specifically that driveway is. Trying to pull up the survey plan that we do have for our project. There it is. So we are just over two feet from the property line on that left side. And then as you can see in the picture, it's a, it's a full width driveway. So, you know, we can sort of guess to what that exact dimension is somewhere in the realm of 12 feet or so, but we don't, we don't have that exact dimension.

Okay. Thank you.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Sure. And I'll just share my screen so we can look at Google maps real quickly. So this is 11 Albion. Is this correct? Is this right?

[SPEAKER_02]: No, no, it's not.

[SPEAKER_06]: Turn around. Yeah.

[Unidentified]: Okay.

[SPEAKER_06]: You're in Somerville. All right.

[Unidentified]: Let me get out of that.

[SPEAKER_02]: For some reason, if you put in east LB on street, it will more easily find it.

[Unidentified]: Yeah, I got it here. Let me just share again.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, this is the correct property, right? There we are. Okay. So there's the house on the left side. As you mentioned, the house on the right side, you've got a double driveway here separating them.

[Unidentified]: Oops, this side is a little tighter. OK.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Anything else to present or as far as appropriate if there's.

[SPEAKER_02]: I can always go on as far as appropriateness for the neighborhood. Yeah, there are definitely examples right in that immediate area of both full 3rd floor build outs and not conforming. Dormers and vertical faces. Bow Street, which is literally right across the street, 519 Bow Street, if you want to look at that monster. And that's like right around the corner that's on this area. uh, Willard Ave, the owners have said, uh, inside the same zoning district, there's a row of three stories, three families, full third floors. And, uh, again, I think given the constrained size of the property, it's, it's a, they're, they're modest dormers. They're, they are large compared to the second floor. I understand that. But, uh, given the size of the property, um, I, I think it's, I, my personal opinion is it's appropriate, but that's, that's all I can offer to that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you. Mr. Collins. All right. Um, are there any members of the let's let's enter the public participation portion of the, uh, of the hearing? Are there any members of the public who wish to speak on this matter? And I think I see these, the owners, did you just, okay. Would you like to say anything before we go into the public participation? You don't have to. Okay, thank you. Any members of the public wish to speak on this? And Dennis, have we received any emails or phone calls about it? We have not. Okay, thank you.

All right, seeing nobody wishing to speak, is there a motion to close the public participation portion of the hearing? So I'll move. Thanks, Jim. Okay. Thank you. Get Chris first roll call vote. Yvette Velez.

[SPEAKER_10]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tirani. Aye. Chris DeVetta. Aye. Mary Lee.

[Unidentified]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And I'm an aye as well. The public participation portion of the hearing closed. We go into deliberations now. Members, what are your, what are your thoughts? Got a lot of dormers on our minds.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Yeah, the massing of this and everything, and the way the structure was originally built, it's just less somewhat intrusive than a lot of others. The high-pitched roof lends to the expansion of the third floor. Lucky for the owners, they've got that high picture, I guess.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: What's that? Can you remind me, Mr. Collins? What's the or the Mr. Carlson? What the total square footage is the livable square footage of the floor is 640. Proposed thanks.

[Chris D'Aveta]: What would it be if.

[SPEAKER_02]: What was the calculation if, um, if, if, if it, if it, if the full plate was built out, I have that here at the bottom floor is nine 82. So that would be half of that four 91. Okay. And so if this were a full plate, uh, we would be 149 square feet over 50%. Okay.

[Chris D'Aveta]: So that's relatively modest in my mind.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Good question for the owners. Have you talked to your neighbors at all about this and any, what are their reactions? You'll have to unmute them. Dennis is working on that.

[SPEAKER_18]: We're unmuted. We have met our neighbors, some of the neighbors, not all of them yet, but we have not discussed the plans, but uh, you know, we have told them that we are going to be doing some work, um, and that we would be putting dormers on. Um, and, you know, people sort of shrug and say, good for you kind of thing. Right. You know, you, uh, welcome to the neighborhood, but I'd say we've had that conversation with three people.

Thank you.

[Unidentified]: Uh, Mary.

[Yvette Velez]: I would say. This seems appropriate for the neighborhood and it looks appropriate for the building. And it sounds appropriate for the individuals and it's not a detriment to anyone. I would be inclined to say this is a good project. We want people to stay in the community and be happy.

[Mary Lee]: I agree with you, but.

[Unidentified]: All right, I'm also in agreement with my colleagues. Great Thank you.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, I, I kind of wish the dormers were set back a little bit, but I understand that's such a small footprint on the 2nd floor. You know, it would be nice if the 2nd floor could be built out and then the 3rd floor dormers kind of set back more. But, you know, we have to. We have to deal with reality, so I. I want that too, but.

[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah. Nice change order for me, but no, it's not that we can't.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. So is there, let's see, I hear a lot of kind of support for this. So we have a variance and then we'll vote on the special permit. So the variance is to allow more than the half floor square footage for this project. And is there a motion to approve the variance allowing the, sorry, you have to remind me of the square footage again. 640, 640 square feet of livable space on the third floor for this property, for 11 Albion Street.

[Mary Lee]: Is there a motion to approve?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you, Mary. Is there a second? I'll second. Thanks, Jim. Roll call vote. Yvette Velez?

[SPEAKER_10]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tirani? Aye. Chris DeVetta? Aye. Mary Lee? Aye. I'm an aye as well. 5-0, the variance is approved. Next we'll discuss the special permit. So the special permit again is for the dormer on the left hand side. There is an existing nonconformity because it's only two feet away from the property line. There is a driveway on the other side, but It's an existing nonconformity and because it's going up vertically, we have to approve by special permit the extension of that nonconformity and. You know, that our basic threshold for finding is essentially that there'll be the public will. benefit outweighs the detriment to the neighborhood. And in terms of providing adequate housing, I would say that it meets that standard. Is there a motion to approve the special permit for 11 Albion?

Motion to approve. Thanks, Jim. Special permit. Second. Thank you, Mary. All right, roll call vote. Yvette Velez?

[SPEAKER_16]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Jim Tarani? Aye. Chris DiVetta? Aye. Mary Lee, I, and I'm an eye as well. 5, 0, the special permit is also approved. Awesome. Thank you, Dennis next steps.

[Denis MacDougall]: Yep, so I will be writing up the decision. And, you know, it takes me a little bit of time to get through and then it'll get reviewed by legal counsel and then completion of that. it'll go up for signatures. Once that happens, which nowadays has been about like a few weeks, then it gets filed in the city clerk's office and that starts a 20 days appeals period. So until that 20 days appeals period is over, you know, you can't get the permit. So, but I'll let you know when that is. And then once that appeals period is over, I can give you a copy of letters saying there's been no appeal and the decision, and you can just have to come in here to city hall to pick it up. Sure, but for the hard copy, and then you take that and file it at the registry and then you can go to the building department and get the permit.

[SPEAKER_02]: So that's that's great.

[Denis MacDougall]: So, awesome.

[SPEAKER_02]: All right.

[Denis MacDougall]: If you have any questions about this process anywhere throughout, just give me a call.

[SPEAKER_02]: You know, I will, you know, I appreciate everyone's time and hanging in there for this meeting. Thanks.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, no, thanks. And sorry for the long wait, but we appreciate your investing in the neighborhood. No, no, we're all volunteers here, right?

[SPEAKER_02]: All right, thanks everyone.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Best of luck.

[SPEAKER_02]: Good luck with the rest of your meeting.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Cheers. Thank you. Dennis, next item on the agenda.

[Denis MacDougall]: 75 South Street. Applicant Kelly Morrissey to demolish an unperforming three-family dwelling and reconstruct a three-family dwelling at 75 South Street, which is in a general residence zone district requiring a special permit. I just want to say this is more just, sorry, just to jump on you, Attorney Desmond. 1 of the requirements is to post notice on the building and this had a link. The rest of the notice was fine. The link actually went to the wrong part of the city of Medford website. We fixed it. We didn't realize that the old link used to say just boards and it would go to the boards and commissions website. That was changed, but it still took you to the city of Medford website and I checked with you know, the folks responsible, and they said that that's just a city thing that doesn't affect this. So we can still continue forward as, you know, notification was sent out to the abutters, the legal ad was put in the paper. So I just want to say that before. And I think actually the person who sent it, I just, I'm sure it's on the call. So I appreciate the email letting us know, because we didn't know that that link was not going to exactly the right place. But thank you for that.

So that's my.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you. Uh, attorney Desmond, uh, you're representing the client, I believe.

[Kathleen Desmond]: And the good news for you is that Jacob Levine is here with me. So you don't have to listen to me the entire, the entire hearing. Um, with me tonight, uh, chairman LaRue and board members is the owner of the property, Kelly, Kelly Morrissey, also, um, Jim Sheehan of Caruso McGovern construction. Who's the project manager. and Jacob Levine of SNL Housing Group. Before you is a petition to demolish an existing three-family dwelling and reconstruct the three-family dwelling on the site, which extends and slightly varies the current footprint of the existing structure requiring a special permit under Section 5-7 of the Chapter 94. As proposed, the structure will be comprised of three two-bedroom units with an approximate living area varying between 1,600 and 1800 square feet per unit. If I can share my screen, Dennis, am I good to go?

You're still all set. Okay. I'm good. Okay. I believe it's this one. Yes. Okay. Um, sharing, but by way of background, the property is a 6,170 square foot parcel of land situated in the general residence district. on which the non-conforming three-family sits. The property is, and you can see from, it is largely- Sorry, Attorney Desmond, could you just make that a little larger if you could? Yes, absolutely. The property itself is largely non-conforming. It doesn't conform to lot area width, depth, open and usable space, setbacks, and lot coverage. According to the city assessor's records, the current structure contains approximately 14 rooms. I'm sorry if that's popping up. 14 rooms and has a growth flurry of approximately 6029 square feet. The property has been in the Morrissey family for over 60 years. The property was originally owned by Ms. Morrissey's grandmother. It was then passed down to her parents. And then when her parents passed away, Ms. Morrissey purchased her sibling's interest in the property and mortgage the property to do so.

The proposed three-family dwelling does not create any additional violations. The new structure will bring the property into compliance with respect to the front yard setback. You can see here, let me see if I can move this. I'm sorry, I'm having trouble moving the screen. Okay. Did I click out?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: No, it shifted a little bit.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Okay, yeah, so where it was 9.8, the front setback, we're now 17.6, so that brings the front yard violation into compliance. We're minimally improving the side yard requirement. It's 3.9. It will now go to 4.2. There isn't, even in demolishing the property, there isn't really any way to shift the building more to the right because there's conservation land. It's on the Mystic River. And so we've already been through conservation. So where we sit, the property actually keeps it out of the floodplain for the most part. And so there isn't any room to make that any less nonconforming or we would have done that. The percentage of open space increases from 18% to 23.3%. And you'll see too that the project as completed will also increase landscape area to 30.7%. So, in some respects, we're improving the nonconformities that exist now. Conversely, the structure does slightly increase the nonconformities as to lot coverage. Presently, it is nonconforming. It's 30.5%. We're increasing that by 0.9%, the lot coverage. I will mention, because I think it's worth note anyway, that with respect to multi-families, the requirement of lot coverage is more strict than it is with singles and twos. This is in a general residence district, so if this were a two-family, the lot coverage maximum amount would be 35%. If it were a single, it would be 40%. So while it is a violation, per se, for three families, within the district, it's within what would be anticipated. In addition to that, the rear yard setback is increasing by about two feet. And the reason for that is not the building structure itself. You'll see here that 9.1 is where the building hits the rear yard setback, rear yard line. But because we have open porches and because those porches are stacked one on top of the other, You have a covered porch, so you now have to measure from the open porches rather than from the building itself, creating the increase in the violation. The other increase is in usable open space.

And I'm quite happy to say that there is some, because usually that's a very difficult number to achieve. Usable open space, you have to have a horizontal area. Both horizontal lines have to be 15 feet, There's a certain grade that has to apply and it can include where clotheslines are. Not that those are in existence anymore, but, um, but that's, that's, it's difficult to meet the usable space, um, requirement under any circumstance. I will say overall though, we are increasing the landscape in the open space, which kind of offsets, um, the, the dimensional issues, uh, there in terms of, just so I can show you, we went to conservation, Um, and so we've got the engineering sort of done, but this is the overlay of the, um, is that too big? Do I need to shrink it a little bit?

Yeah. Um, that's good. Okay. So you can see, although, um, we're in, we're increasing essentially squaring the property off, um, there's certain portions of it that, that the existing dwelling extends beyond. So basically we're just trying to, to create a clean building. Um, the footprint itself, if we kept it this way, it would be kind of awkward. Um, and, and this, um, achieves the result you're looking for, um, increases the footprint somewhat. Um, but it also gets the property out of the, um, out of the, the floodplain in some spots based on where we positioned it or help to get it as much out as we could. Um, as I said, we've been to conservation. Um, they have approved the location of the plan and there's been a notice of condition that, that they have issued. We did that first so that if there was any issue with the structure, um, we could take care of that before coming to you and seeking, uh, relief. And with that, I will turn the presentation over to Jacob Levine. uh, for the architectural portion. And if you want me to still share my screen, Jacob, just let me know.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Um, I'll take, uh, well, good evening board. My name is Jacob Levine, uh, from the architect from SL Haas group at 27 Congress street. And if you don't mind attorney Desmond, I will share my screen. I have the presentation as well. That's fine. Okay. Terrific. I'll just run through, uh, my part.

[Unidentified]: Great.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Again, good evening board and thank you for the late evening. We're really excited about this project. We've been working on it for such some time at this point and it's an amazing property. I've worked in Medford for a while now and lived in Medford for a while. I think we've all know this area and driven around here, been stuck at that traffic light at the end of South Street. This house, When we first saw the project, we were hired to do an evaluation on it and see what can be saved and just the amount of work that would go into trying to save it. The original layout is really bizarre with additions on additions, so it really makes the most sense financially, structurally, and architecturally to tear it down and do something really nice with this property. We went through the Medford historic, meetings and they actually worked with me on the design of it. They wanted something that had a Greek revival look to it and not just another triple decker. That's how we landed on this design with these open porches in the front with some decorated columns and a really celebrated farmer's porch entryway. We're only dormering one side of the property to the left, which if you could see my pointer here, this is where the neighboring property is, which is this yellow house that was developed recently.

We thought it was best to put the dormer on this side and not Come closer to this, so it's only dormant on 1 side. It's 2, 4, 4 plates. And as we mentioned, we have decks on the back here to capture the amazing views of the mystic and take advantage of where the property really is. I'm going to go through the architectural plans. My blue beam, so these are the plot plans that. we just went through. Essentially, we're calling out for three units, as we said, and we're trying to have a cleaner massing on the site. Thinking about the best way to maximize the outdoor space, provide decks, provide safe egress, provide parking, and have a really clean way to navigate through the building. They're both two bedrooms. One is an en suite, one has a shared bath. It's a two bed, two bath, but an open living style.

The first floor is about 1600 square feet. And then as you move your way up to the second floor, it's a very similar floor plan. You're about 1700 square feet on this one. And then when you work your way up to the 3rd floor. depending on, you guys had an interesting conversation of gross versus net square feet. I am 1,800 square feet gross. So that includes, in my view, the floor plate itself down here, not including the knee wall. So I'm calling out this gray wall is 1,800 square feet. The net square footage on that would be about 1,200 to 1,300. But I'm calling out gross square footage. Each unit, again, gets their private decks. And then working really hard and thinking about the elevations that we mentioned we went through the historical board and presented these and they worked with us on it. So trying to create something that's a little more historic in nature, something that looks like it might have been there for longer than just. Plop down with new vinyl siding on it. We're working with a really excellent building team who've done some fabulous work in detail. So we're trying to do something that's going to be really nice to the neighborhood really nice for the street and really keep a low profile as much as possible. I want the absolute absolute peak will stay below methods. 35 foot height limit. Um, but again, that that's a low slope dormer, so it's not your typical, which you guys have seen today, like a 2 pitch dormer. This is a much gentler slope. And if you see, it's just like a typical pitch on the roof. So, it's not this really tall 3rd story that that feels heavy. Uh, that was kind of the idea is to really keep the massing on the 1st, 2 floors and have it read such as.

On the sides, this is the side neighboring the house. We wanted to keep as little fenestration as possible, so we're not peeping in. But this is the living room side, so obviously, we want some windows on there. But most of the action happens in the back of the house, where you have sliders that would lead out to the deck overlooking the Mystic River. The other side that isn't so close to the neighbors, we put the bedrooms on. So that has a little bit more fenestration on there with the dormer.

Um, these maps we included with attorney Desmond, do you want me to discuss these or would you like to take these?

[Kathleen Desmond]: Muted sure, I can discuss that if you're finished with the architectural piece of it. So, in terms of the neighborhood, let me just see if I can share. Can I share again? Yeah, let me see. Okay. I am sharing, right?

[Unidentified]: Yeah.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Um, so in, in, in terms of the neighborhood, what I did, um, and I do this sometimes to show that, that there are a number of three families which are existing in that area, in that area already on South street in the general vicinity. And I've highlighted them, um, with the yellow dots so that you can see, you know, where they're located. So directly across the street, you have three, three families, um, There's another three family on Manning and there's a few more on on taro street. Um, so there's really in a lot of what's not three families in that general vicinity are mostly two families. Um, I also took, um, a, took some photographs of the existing neighborhoods. So this is the house that's immediately to the, um, Right and Andre, I need to learn how to use my Google map because I don't know how to do that. But, but yeah, it's my share screen.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, you got to just click out of that update. Yeah, let me see X in the right hand corner of that box.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Yeah, I can't get to it. Oh, all right. There we go. Okay, so this is the house, which is immediately next door to the left of the property. And as you can see, that's the full 3 stories. It is a single. But it is quite tall in terms of the surrounding neighborhood. And that is consistent with what is surrounding on the other side of the street as well. You have these three family homes. And then this is the other side of the property that we're looking at, which again, is a very, large, tall building, three stories tall. So what we're doing in terms of changing the nature of it, because this building is kind of really run down, is to bring it back. As Jacob said, it's a very exciting project because it will restore the property. Right now it's in rough shape. There'll be more landscaping and open spaces that will improve the lot. It will retain the existing housing stock. This is a three-family. We're not asking to put on any additional units, but seeking to retain the three-family unit as it is. And it will also, importantly, in terms of my client, allow her to maintain the property. You know, as for one person, she bought out her siblings. She wants to stay on the property. This will enable her to condo two of the floors and then be able to share the expenses, attributable real estate taxes, exterior maintenance, all of that with the other parties who purchased the property. At this point, you know, it's all on her in terms of exterior maintenance. She has an existing mortgage to buy out her family members. And so this would be really a good project for her. She could cover the construction costs with the potential sale of two of the units and then be able to share expenses with the other owners rather than have all the maintenance of the property solely on her. And she would love to keep this property in the family and improve it. And so that's why we're here before you tonight. Under chapter 94, section 5.71, the board has the power to grant a special permit to reconstruct a non-conforming structure based on a finding of no substantial detriment to the neighborhood. And that's the section on which we've applied.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. Thank you, Attorney Desmond. And thank you, Mr. Levine and the proponents. Yes, sir, Commissioner Forty.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Yeah, hi, Mr. chair, just a couple of questions for the architect. If you don't mind me addressing them directly, did you consider the full foot setback from the property line and the fire rating on the wall?

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, so we are looking at doing that wall with a 1 hour rating on it, but correct me if I'm wrong. I have the builder on here as well. Jim, we're looking at the sprinkler system as well on the building. could give me a thumbs up, Mr. Sheehan.

[Kathleen Desmond]: I don't think he's able to talk, Dennis, Jim Sheehan. I don't know.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: I mean, the sprinkle system is required anyways, and it does give you some reduction. However, because you're building within that five foot setback, I don't know how much relief you're going to get. In addition to that, I would be concerned about the number of openings I saw on that wall. I don't know that you're allowed to have that many openings when you're that close to the property line. And so I just wanted to kind of give the board a heads up on that, that you may not see as many window openings there. You might, you know, you might be having less windows than what's on the diagram. So you may not, it may not be completely accurate. That'll be something that our inspectors look at when they're, when they're doing the plans exam. I think you can have more than 25% openings and I'm not exactly sure how much is on there but I just wanted to bring that to your attention. In addition to that, I see that there are two means of egress, and one is located on the outside of the building that that third floor has to be covered. You can't run three stories of egress off of a third floor without that first floor staircase being covered. So that's gonna create additional impact when we go to do the plans exam, we're gonna require that. And the reason for that is for snow. You don't necessarily need two means of egress from each dwelling unit. And that back staircase can almost be eliminated with the proper sprinklers, which would be a 13 hour system. So that might be something that you may want to take a look at as well. But what I saw from a building code perspective concerns me. That four feet is, I mean, the building is being rebuilt. And with it that close to the property line, it does pose a fire risk. And most side setbacks are a minimum of five feet, and to avoid any of that, including the overhang on the top. I saw that your overhang was, it looks nice, but it may not, you're only allowed a certain number of inches per foot. So that would create some complications. And I'm not exactly sure that the siding has to be non-combustible either. So there are some considerations there, and I have some concerns as the building official and as the you know, as we're doing the plans exam that might change the character of what you showed us for rendering. So that's all I wanted to say to the to the commission to the board. And I just want to make sure that everybody understood that there are a little bit of complexities with the design and where it's located on the lot. Okay.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you, Commissioner 40. Mr. Levine, do you want to respond to any of that or

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: It's all very great feedback. The only thing I would say is just on the facade that we were looking at there on that one facade where he said that 25 percent that is on this side. So we're doing our best to stay under that threshold. Everything you said is definitely something we want to look at, especially this back stair. So thank you.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Yeah, of course.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, well, thank you. Thank you. Commissioner for it. I appreciate that. I know you've been through, it sounds like you've been through a big process already with the historic and with the conservation commission. So we appreciate that. You kind of navigated that already. Um, so, uh, let's see board members, any, any clarifying questions do you have based on the presentation?

[Chris D'Aveta]: Good to hear from the building commissioner on that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. Yeah, and we don't obviously as a board, we don't have to rule on that. That's going to be something that as they go through the process, the. The building department will be dealing with those those items. The code items really what we're what we're doing here is we are. Are evaluating whether to issue a special permit. that would allow the proponent to demolish the existing house and to build this house, this proposed three-story home. Again, the threshold, as Attorney Desmond said, would be, it's getting late, so I'm forgetting. It's not detrimental to the public interest basically.

No significant detriment to the public interest or substantial. Let's open the public comment period. Is there any members of the public who wish to comment on this project? Please raise your hand in the Zoom. Yes, Mr. Lamb. Name, could you please state your name and address for the record before your comments?

[eQfu2R5n4yE_SPEAKER_01]: Hi, can you hear me?

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yes, we can. Thank you. Okay.

[eQfu2R5n4yE_SPEAKER_01]: My name is Chris Lamb. I live at 69 South Street, so I'm two houses down from the proposed area. I'm in favor of this project. I'm wondering if there's an issue with the historical preservation. If they've been through the historical board and it's approved from that regard, I'm happy. Um, the, the house is in shambles, it has raccoons living in the, in the attic, and it needs to be torn down. I'd be very happy to see it renovated and not renovated but have a new set of condos there. I think what would be.

to the community is to not approve this proposal because the state of the house is terrible right now. It's a shambles and it's kind of an eyesore. And if you did not approve this project, I'm pretty certain I've been in this house for eight years. I think this particular house has been unoccupied for 10 or so. If you don't approve this project, it'll probably just remain the way it is for another extended period of time. And that's terrible. but there needs to be some forward progress on this property. And I'd be very happy to see that. I'm also very happy to see that the floor plan, there was a proposal several years ago that actually extended the floor plan to the right, to the east a little bit in the back and got quite close to the neighbor's yard. And I'm very happy to see that this is a much more staying within the exact, very close to the current footprint and not doing that. So I'm happy to see this change and I'm fully in favor of of moving forward here.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. Thank you, Mr. Lam. Appreciate it. Naomi Altman. Again, name and address for the record. And you just need to be unmuted.

[SPEAKER_16]: Hi, I'm Naomi Altman. I live at 71 South Street. I'm that White House that was shown. My name, Well, I have two main concerns, and actually something that I really didn't understand in the presentation, which is related to that. So it is true almost all the other houses on that block are three stories, but this house is significantly wider. I mean, I guess using the dormer does somewhat mitigate this sort of bulky feeling that I fear it would have, Anyway, so that's one concern. Before I go on, I should second Mr. Lamb's vote that something be done, something be approved if possible for similar reasons. I think it's time to have a new structure on that site. That being said, the one thing that really does concerned me, I didn't really understand how it was said that more open space was being created. And that's because of the open porch at the back, which seems to take up almost the most of the backyard that belongs to the property as opposed to the riparian way that belongs to the state.

So, I mean, I just wondered how much whether that was completely necessary and whether it really does take up as much of the property as it seems. Maybe you could talk a little bit more about how the open space is getting improved. Maybe we're talking about landscaping, but my understanding from the presentation was that there was somehow going to be more open space.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. Thank you, Ms. Ullman. Appreciate it. Would the proponents like to address that question? I don't know if Mr. Levine would be in your wheelhouse.

[Kathleen Desmond]: You know, it may better be served by Jacob and actually the engineering department. The engineers are the ones who calculate the actual open space, but we are reducing overall the the impervious areas within the property. Um, and also, um, as part of the conservation, um, committee it's work, we, um, are required to provide landscaping for them. So we're reducing what's there now, whereas some, a lot of it currently is, is, um, pavement on that driveway. Um, and that will be, uh, removed and there'll be impervious pavers per the, um, conservation commission requirements. And more landscaping, so that's how that gets calculated. Jacob, if you want to add and as well, that would probably be better than listening to me.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, no problem. Well, thank you for the comments. I think. Overall, when you see what the existing building that's there with the current driveway here, that shown dotted with the rear edition of the existing cottage, if you want to call it that that was there and then all there. sort of. staircases and patios and then our massing that does pull it back further from the setbacks. You do get a larger front yard, which is a big change. Our driveway is significantly less wide than what was there before. We're buying more real estate that's essentially back here. The open porches do provide the tenants. If you're on the second floor, you get what we would consider outdoor space being uncovered back there. But the overall actual usable landscape, this would be permeable as we went through a conservation. The building footprint itself, it's when you add up all these jogs and how close things are and the asphalt here, this is a worse condition than what we're proposing here. So, I mean, that overlay plan, which I was looking for, did a pretty good job kind of showing that as well of where the old footprint was versus where we are, even with the decks and then the driveway, how it came all the way out versus where we are now. You do get some. Some nicer actually usable space and then, you know, it's all going to be done new. It's better materials for the environment. We're conscious to that and we want to, we want to provide light and air to the, to the units. So that's kind of our, our just for open space.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great, thank you for addressing that question. All right, are there any other members of the public who wish to speak? And Dennis, have we received anything in writing or phone calls?

[Denis MacDougall]: Apart from the letter from Ms. Altman about the notice now.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Thank you very much. Is there a motion to close the public participation portion of the hearing? Motion. Thank you, Mary. Is there a second? Second. Thank you, Jim. Roll call vote, Jim Tirani. Aye. Chris DiVetta. Aye. Mary Lee. Aye. Yvette Velez.

[Yvette Velez]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And I'm an aye as well. The public comment portion of the hearing is closed. Now we move into deliberations. Members, what are your thoughts? Again, our Just to reiterate, we are voting on a special permit, whether to allow the demolition of the existing property, which is very substandard and can't really be built, and to allow the construction of this new three-story property proposal.

[Unidentified]: I can just share really quickly again that just from the Google Maps, just to see the context.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: So there's the next door neighbor property. This is a single family, but it's three and a half stories. This is the property that's being demolished. You can see it's very deteriorated.

[Unidentified]: This is the home next door here. Let's see, extension in the back. Across the street, you have three family properties, three-story, three-family properties.

[Chris D'Aveta]: I have a clarifying question, if I could, through the chair. Yes. Building Commissioner, may have mentioned five foot setback, but I believe it's seven and a half foot setback on the side for the GR. Is that correct?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Yeah, so that wouldn't be a zoning setback, that's a building code setback. So building separation of five feet from the property line is a standard. When you are less than five feet, and let's just say that there was a substantial improvement of the property, and it was going to exist to remain, they would still have to make that a one-aisle fire rated wall on that exterior and they would be limited by the number of openings that they would be able to have. Here, because they actually do have the room, if they didn't want to go through the trouble of making that a fire rated wall, they could move it a foot over and that would that would subjugate the need for fire protection. And so that would be my only recommendation is to shift it over a foot.

Only because they've got the room and I know it would squeeze the parking a little bit, but you're talking about one foot, you're not talking about five or six feet. So, by having the building shift away to that five feet you get away from all that requirement in the building code to have that be a regulated firewall because it presents difficulty and and a lot of times the builder. It doesn't exactly get the message and I've had trouble with these when they are less than five feet off the property line because sometimes you have to educate the builder on what's required. And, you know, there's a little bit of back and forth with how the wall is designed. And, you know, I mean, I'm sure if you're an architect or engineer, you have no problem with the plans being drawn up. you know, the number of openings. But, you know, again, it becomes problematic. That's all. It's not something that can't be overcome. And I'm certainly sure that the architect has designed it properly, but it doesn't always get constructed that way. The first thing that happens is the sheathing goes on and it's not fire rated sheathing, you know, right away. We're already in trouble, you know, so.

[Chris D'Aveta]: My follow up question, I guess, too, is that once you raise a property, they're going to lose their setbacks, correct? They're going to be subject to a seven and a half foot setback?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: No, no. A special permit will grant them wherever they want to set the building. So a special permit will allow that setback to be less because it's a non-conforming lot. So you're saying by special permit or a finding that it's not, a variance isn't required, it would be that they, you know, that they're seeking a special permit to increase a non-conformity, if you will, so. Even with the complete demolition? Yep, yep. It's it's the new you know whatever the whatever the board decides is the new controlling zoning for that particular property. It doesn't carry through it doesn't have any precedents, it is the standing order. in which the zoning, it takes it out of the zoning ordinance and puts it in a special order, which is then recorded at the registry of deeds and becomes a zoning for that property. So it's not, there's nothing to do with zoning after you've approved it, it becomes a standing order, which is different from the zoning ordinance.

[Chris D'Aveta]: Okay, I was under the impression that they had to leave some part of the existing property in order for that to be the case.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: No, no, there isn't you. Yeah, you can you can stay within that special permit guideline and still be outside of the required setbacks because of a lot shape, size and other unusual circumstances. So it's perfectly, it's perfectly fine with Sony.

[Unidentified]: Okay.

[Kathleen Desmond]: We'd be more than happy to move that line, the foot, if provided we're not, I think we'd have to go back to conservation or at least check with conservation because part of where the building is placed is based on that flood line. So that, you know, happy to make that change if we can make that change and not create issues with conservation.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Well, again, it's really it's a design question and it's certainly up to the builder if they want to concede that and take that concern away and it would help you make an easier determination and again I'm not I'm only suggesting it. I just, I just do know that when when a property is built when a when a building is built less than five feet from a property line. It presents problems and it can be, it can be problematic throughout construction and obviously, you know, you'd want this to be as smooth as possible I'm just not sure why they would set it at four feet, and for all the amount of trouble. If it was shifted over by one foot it would have avoided all of that, you know what I mean.

just a thought. And again, I have no skin in the game, but I think obviously, it's something that the ZBA, the board may wanna take a look at.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Well, Commissioner Fordy, if we approve a special permit for the current proposal and then down the road, they decide it's in their best interest to shift it, they have to come back to us?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Well, no, not if they're decreasing, if it's a de minimis move, right? Let's just say that you approve it at four feet and they say, you know what? This is a pain in the neck. Let's go to five feet. I believe that it would still be allowed to be issued because it's a de minimis move. It's not increasing the nonconformity, it's decreasing it. And I would say that that historically, whenever I've gotten a ZBA order, and let's just say that the ZBA order included a garage, and now they're not going to do the garage or they're going to wait a couple of years. That's a de minimis thing where they're actually putting less and that would still be okay, you know? Okay, thank you. Yes, Dennis.

[Denis MacDougall]: There we go. All right, it's not often I actually get to put on my environmental agent hat in these meetings, but I can. So just because I have all the plans for when they came for the ComCom earlier this summer. So there's like sort of two issues. It's basically, there's a floodplain that kind of runs, I can actually, let me share my screen. Let me show you. Okay, so there's, This is sort of the property, and this is the proposed. So there's the 100-year floodplain runs from here to here. And if they moved it so that it was still out of that floodplain, because floodplain is basically L points north of there. So if they moved it over a foot, looking at it now, I think it would probably be fine. And so as long as they don't chain, as long as they don't add anything new to this, so as long as things like that don't change, you know, it could actually, it could be just done administratively with myself. It wouldn't need a new COMCOM filing. So just, I mean, but it's a really tight line there. And I mean, the minute they go over it, then it would involve reopening up to the COMCOM or another filing. So, and that is, you know, where they've kind of got it, it's sort of almost in a sweet spot between a couple of the resource areas.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: And if I could just add to what Dennis is saying, I absolutely agree that, and I'll put on my conservation commission hat, I was Hong Kong chairman for 20 years in my town. there is provided that they don't go into the flood zone, there is no additional compensatory storage requirement for cut and fill. So I would say that, again, that move on a conservation commission level would be de minimis as well, but it would be a notification to the commission that the building has shifted a foot, probably without any consequence.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great. Thank you, Dennis and Bill.

[Denis MacDougall]: Figure out how to stop my screen share. Hold on. Nope.

[Unidentified]: What the heck?

[Denis MacDougall]: All right. Oh, there we go. Nevermind. Sorry. I'm good.

[Unidentified]: All right. Thanks.

[Denis MacDougall]: Slowly approaching my mother in every possible way.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: All right, everybody, so. Again, the special permit standard is we need to find that the proposal is not substantially more detrimental than. Then what currently exists. I think what I've heard is that there are a lot of reasons given the current conditions of the property to move forward with this. I think we've had some good conversation about design, about code issues. I think we could vote, my recommendation would be to vote on the existing proposal and let the proponent decide whether they want to shift the you know, to the East by a foot to get out of that, the fire code requirements. But I think that's something that can be dealt with, with the building department and the architects and the engineers and the proponent. So based on what I've heard, what's your thinking? We're in the deliberation phase now, members.

[Chris D'Aveta]: If no one else is gonna go, I'll go. Yeah, I think it is, I think the building is oversized and therefore it is a detriment to the neighborhood. There's no prohibition on redeveloping this building and it would be a good option to do so. But it does not mean that you can just put, maximize the size of the, three units, you know, that are there. And I, I guess the three units carries over from, yeah, I'm still not sure of that, you know, from complete raising of the building, uh, of a three unit building to creating another three unit building. When you do that, I guess still a question in my mind, whether or not we can, you know, approve that in the GR there? Because it's, I believe it's two units, correct? So once they raise that structure, Are they allowed to continue with three units? But putting that aside for the moment, even if it's three units, these are rather large units. And this is a self-created problem where they're bumping up against the floodplain district. And they're almost half of the setback on the one side of the property there.

So I can't support this as I see it right here. I don't think this is a good development for, I think it's detrimental to the neighborhood just based on the size, not the use.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks, Chris. Other members of that? I saw you had your hand up at one point.

[Yvette Velez]: I did, I'm actually I'm actually going to agree with Chris when I initially saw this and I understand the street and I know that there are across the street already existing large. But to go from the single to the 3 and I guess I want to hear more about, like. You know, what are the other reasons? Right? I think I heard maybe there was cost related to this, but. You know, show me that I guess. You know, now you're adding three families.

You know, my thoughtful question of like, where's the trash going, right? Because you cut the backyard, now you're talking about cutting the side, but you need to park cars, you can't put it there, so does that mean it's going in front of the house? Like, that doesn't always look great, and it just adds to the like, it looks big, and you're adding so much more. Like, why do we have to keep I, I would somewhat agree, like, why did it have to be a 3? Why couldn't it be a 2 and be comfortable in the space that. Abutting the marsh and the wetlands, I mean, and accommodating the neighbors and the fire and the things right. So, I guess I think I want to hear more on why this would be.

And of course, the house has to be demolished. Yes, a big improvement. All of that, but I, I'm leaning with Chris that it would.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: It seems oversized with the proponents like to comment. I'll let you guys go in there since nobody else can respond to that concern.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Well, you know. we could put together for you what the cost would be. We don't have that in terms of how that affects the impact generally, but it is a three family, uh, now and under five, seven, one of, of the, of chapter 94. Um, you know, you, you do have this right to voluntarily demolish and, and rebuild because I think there's probably a recognition that, you know, sometimes you're in a situation where renovation doesn't work and the, and that's why it's in the code so that you have that, ability to do that. In terms of the need, this has always been in my client's family for over 70 years. So in terms of the self-created portion of this, they've owned it. It's been in the family since at least 1950 somewhere. I couldn't go all the way back, and maybe Kelly can answer this, but it's well beyond a situation where it would be self-created. And, you know, she wants to keep it in her family. I mean, she does have an existing mortgage on the property. You know, the face value of the property to buy out her brothers and sisters was $300,000. I think we talked about it. I think she's taken maybe $40,000 off of that mortgage to date. But to do the type of renovations or the remodel that's required here, you know, you're in a situation where you have to have sufficient capital and the two units would give her that capital and you know would also so that she's not in this situation again you know as a single owner it gives her the ability to share costs and expenses with the other owners as to exterior and you know utilities property tax all of that that comes with it so it allows her to maintain the property in the family. So that's a big piece of it for my client. And, you know, if there's an issue with size, we're certainly willing to discuss that. You know, maybe there's something that we could do. I think the other structures around are the same, you know, roughly the same size or larger in some institutions and taller. So, you know, from that perspective, From that perspective, it's difficult. It's also a unique property in the sense that it's right on the water. So there's the whole enjoyability piece of it, which is part of the reason why she wants to keep the property in her family rather than sell it to a developer who she's had offers from to do that. But that's not what she wants to do. And she'd like to keep it within her family. And this is a way to do that.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks, Attorney Desmond. Ms. Morris, did you want to weigh in on this at all or you do not have to?

[SPEAKER_10]: Hello, thank you everybody. I know it's a late night. Thanks everyone for showing up. Actually, My grandmother purchased this home in the 30s. And my father, her son, purchased it from her in the 70s. So I've been there my entire life, part of the community. And I'd like to keep it. I think it's a great place. I grew up there. So I'm trying to do everything I can to restore the home and make it livable. It's very difficult right now.

[Unidentified]: Thank you.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: I mean, from my perspective on this question, I think it's actually a benefit. It's going to be 3 nice condo units, so we'll have 3 homeowners there. You know, being able to enjoy owning a property right on the river. I. I think that all of the properties around it are three stories, so I don't feel that it's overwhelmingly large compared to those. I think it might be shorter than the yellow single-family home next to it. I guess I don't have the same concerns, I guess, about it being oversized in that way. I am familiar with construction costs and that you have to, uh, you know, tear down, uh, you got to demolish an entire existing structure that's there and re like prepare the site and then rebuild and construction costs are very expensive. Um, so, you know, I think the fact that there are nice units there is a, is a plus, uh, attorney Desmond, would you'd like to say something important here? Yeah. You're muted.

Attorney Desmond, you're muted.

[Kathleen Desmond]: I'm not sure whether this addresses all of the concerns or some of the concerns, but we have brought the front yard set back in and Jacob chime in if you like to 17 feet, which is is in conformity with the code. Because we were doing that, I didn't do or take a survey of the existing houses and how close they were to, um, to the street level, and you can take the average of those within the street level to come up within 150 feet to get it. So it's possible that we could shift it towards the street and over if the side set back is what some of the members' overwhelming concerns are, that that might be possible. We'd have to go back and take a look at that, but we may be able to move it closer to the street rather than back, but then you'd have to deal with conservation. as well, so that, you know, it's, there are things we could try and do to shift that side setback, but, but, you know, and I think it's important to say that as of right, you could put it on the same footprint, which is closer. So we've improved the, um, the proximity to the, to that left side yard line. Um, and we've improved some other nonconforming matters. We just couldn't, you know, make it conform totally because you've got the, you've got the rear yard, um, issue with, with the, the, uh, the river and the floodplain. So you've only got a limited area that you can actually place the structure.

But if we were on the same footprint, it could be as of right. Um, and we're not extending it significantly, um, because there are some pieces that pull out and some pieces that, um, which is kind of straightening it off. But, um, you know, My client wants to do this project. So if there's something that needs to be reworked, we'll work with the board rather than have the project denied, obviously.

[Unidentified]: Jim and Mary, what are your thoughts? My thoughts are the same as yours, Andre. I know the area very well. I know the house very well. And I'm actually in favor of this project. I think it's going to compliment the area very much. I think financially, those other units are really needed to make this project work. I would say that I really like the idea of what their plans are. Thanks, Jim. Mary?

[Mary Lee]: Yeah, I echo the same sentiment as you and Jim, and I think it would tremendously improve the neighborhood and also preserve that new house, a new building. I think it would be great for that building, for the street.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks, Mary. So, for a special permit vote, we do need a super majority. That's 4 out of 5. so that increase since you've expressed both expressed concerns here. Is there anything that would be helpful to. Kind of winning your support or answering questions that you have. Yeah, let's go to Mr. our particular being 1st.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Well, thank you again. I just wanted to. show and say the building is about 35 by 50. So if you think of the floor plate for each unit, they're not top and down units. It's not like Philly style. We're not using the basement. So each unit is about 1,700 square feet. And just the cost of things, it's really hard to build when we have an opportunity to build. We're not trying to be greedy and build 2,000 plus square foot units, but we have to make them nice and livable. They're only two bedrooms, trying to keep it open. There's a lot of thought that went through that 35 number, and that's what we were trying to do with the massing. I'm just going to share my screen one more time here, because I have this nice model open. This is like that 35 again on the east to west side, and then the 50 on the north to south. And I was trying to not have it look so vertical like some of the other buildings and actually kind of have that width to it and use it for the front facade to create opportunity for more windows and more light and actually have the building sit proud on the site and hold its ground there. And I think one of the things I don't actually like a lot about Some of the neighboring South Street buildings is how narrow everything looks and I thought this was an opportunity, but it still feels to scale. At least in my opinion, only being 35 feet and at that 1700 square foot kind of magic number. You know, we're really able to get nice nice sellable units in here that that I think are really going to help that neighborhood. So. There was a lot of thought and we've got, we've had other ideas, but, you know, we really landed on this one working really well for the homeowner and for the builder. So just some food for thought.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah, thank you. Could you just speak to. I don't know you're familiar. I don't know that, you know, obviously the widths of the other buildings that are in that neighborhood, but. typically for a two or three family home, what is a typical?

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Sure. Your typical Medford houses that I work on are usually the load-bearing wall is somewhere between 12 and 15 feet. You're usually about 24-30 feet wide, somewhere in that ballpark for the really dense part, like over by Tufts, over by Magoon, up by the Highlands. Those are the really, really narrow parts of Medford. 24 to 30, because back then they used lumber that can only span 10 to 12 feet, so you have your load-bearing wall in the middle. Then the newer developments that we're seeing that are built over on, I'm doing a big project on Salem Street, those are more in the 35 to even 40 sometimes using TGIs to span across. It is wider than your old, old traditional Medford two-family. dwelling, but not substantially, right? It's five to eight feet-ish over what you're typically seeing.

Thank you. I hope I helped there.

[Yvette Velez]: Thank you for the thoughtful recap on the layout. I think I've, you know, I've, I would say I've changed my mind when I think about the cost and, um, and a better understanding of three versus a two unit. Um, so I, I would, I guess I'm changing my mind.

[Unidentified]: Thanks. Chris, did you want to add anything or.

[Chris D'Aveta]: No, I mean, I, I really have not changed my mind because, um. It's not the three units that that is the issue for me. It's, it's the size. And I, I understand you increase your square footage, you increase your profit and I get it. Um, but, um, you know, I don't think our role is to help, you know, folks make the most profit they can. I think our role is to get the best development and the most appropriate development for The particular neighborhood that that development is in. So, I'm still a Nova.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks, Chris architect. Have you guys did you ever consider, like, making it slightly narrower, but maybe pulling it forward, like, having less of a front yard setback.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, if we went narrower, it ended up being almost like a full triple-decker, very similar to what's right across the street. I'm not sure if you still have your Google images or your Google Maps open, but I can pull that open really quick. Sorry, I can do it. Okay. My eyes are starting to go at this point. I've been sitting in front of the computer for a long time today. Again, here's our house. When we narrowed things out, it started filling in with that full third story because when I start really getting narrow, this is about 30 feet in width. If you think about a load-bearing wall in the middle and 15 and 15 with the Boston bump, It starts asking for that 3rd floor to really make the numbers work and make the building viable to be honest with you. So that's kind of 1 of the reasons why the commission sent us down this route where they really like the historical commission really like the look of this and less of the narrow and tall and they like this look of the wide and. and squat. So that was kind of our inspiration on the project, was looking at this style versus this style. And there is a rendition of this project that follows very closely to something like this or something even like this yellow house. We mimicked that at one point and tried to go a little bit longer in it to make it work. It just stands so tall and it looks really not right with this building right next to it and just another massing up here. It just didn't look right. Yes, we did explore those options and it landed us having a full third floor, which we didn't feel was right and respectable for this little street.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thanks. That was really helpful, I think. For me, it gives me a lot of confidence. The Conservation Commission has already seen and approved this. The historic has already seen and approved it and they've weighed in. made their design suggestions and all. So I feel comfortable moving forward with the vote. And I don't know, Chris, where you'll land on it, but I think at this point, I think we can go forward with a motion at any rate.

[Chris D'Aveta]: One more question, if I may. Given the fact that you're trying to mimic a more Gable, typical Rick Revival sort of thing, Why not push it closer to the sidewalk? What was the rationale?

[Kathleen Desmond]: You want me to answer that, Attorney Desmond, or well, you know, I mean, other than then, you know, to bring it into conformity with, you know, you always try in these projects where you have nonconformity is to bring what you can into conformity. And and so in terms of, you know, trying to bring the project so that you're creating some conformities where you can. That's what you attempt to do. As I said, I haven't done the 150-foot square between the two properties adjacent to see what the actual setback would, because sometimes it's less if it's less. If you have two properties on the other side within 150 feet that are 10 feet closer to the lot line, then you can use that as the setback. Requirement I didn't do that calculation because we weren't in a situation where we needed to do it. But that, you know, essentially, it was something that we could do. That we could make conform and so I think unless and you may have other additional points on that Jacob, but but that I know from my perspective, that was 1 of the thoughts at the time.

[Unidentified]: Thank you well.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Again, we have a special permit application. The standard is that we find no substantial detriment to the neighborhood.

[O1CMBj7JDes_SPEAKER_04]: Can I share 1 last 1 last thing and then and then that that's it for me. I just wanted to share because I think, I mean, you guys all love this stuff as much as I do. This was when we're working with Peter. These are kind of the precedents that he sent me that we were looking at. for character of what he really liked and what the historical board kind of liked around the area that we were working at. And they all kind of have that very similar squat tall look. And we were actually met and sketched and drew. And there was a lot of thought that went into kind of how it ended up the way it did. So I just also wanted to kind of share those. And that's it.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: PB, Harmon Zuckerman, he, him, his.: : Thank you appreciate it yeah I mean like knowing that street I agree, some of those like tall narrow ones I don't particularly love so. PB, Harmon Zuckerman, he, him, his.: : i'm fine with this design I don't feel like it's it's overdone I appreciate understanding the you know, the history behind it in terms of the different iterations and. The fact that historic weighed in asking for more of that. So, again, we have a special permit application. Our threshold is that it be not substantially more detrimental than what's there right now. I think it's improving vastly a property that's very deteriorated. I think it meets that standard pretty easily. I think it would create three homeownership opportunities. I think it respects the river. It's been through conservation commission, it's been through historic, looks like a beautifully designed proposal. I'm prepared to go forward and vote on this. Is there a motion on the floor to approve the special permit for 75 South Street?

From a member of the board. So move. Thank you, Jim. Is there a second? Second. Thank you, Mary. Roll call vote. Jim?

[Unidentified]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Chris? No. Yvette?

[SPEAKER_16]: Aye.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Mary? Aye. And I'm an aye as well. So by a vote of four to one, the special permit is approved for the proposal.

[Mary Lee]: Thank you very much.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Thank you very much for your patience, for hanging in there for a very, very long meeting, and appreciate your responding to all of our questions.

[Kathleen Desmond]: And I can't believe I'm saying this, but I'm wishing you all a happy Thanksgiving. I can't believe we're in November again, but enjoy your Thanksgiving holiday.

[Unidentified]: Thank you.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Same to all of you.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Thank you. Yeah, this will be my last appearance in Medford now, so you're just going to have to admire me from afar.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Then the turkeys to somewhere else, Bill?

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Merry Christmas, Scott, to 45 School Street, Brockton, Mass. To you all. Thank you. Well, Bill, thank you so much for your service.

[Unidentified]: Yeah, of course.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: It's been a pleasure reconnecting with you all, and best of luck, and happy holidays to you all.

[Unidentified]: Thank you. All right.

[Interim Building Commissioner Bill Forte]: Thank you.

[Denis MacDougall]: Have a good night.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Yeah. Dennis, do you want to say say anything to about the next steps?

[Denis MacDougall]: And just well, I mean, kind of just whether it's repeat from earlier with attorney Desmond, but the findings that will. You know, expedite the decision and then, you know, attorney Desmond kind of walk you through the next steps, but it'll be. Decision will be written, it'll be reviewed, it'll be signed by the members, then it's filed in the clerk's office. That'll start a 20-day period where it can be appealed. Once that period is over with no appeal, then you can file and get your permit. So we've been doing pretty good with turnaround here of late. So it's usually about a month and change from this meeting to the next one. So I would say by early December, you should be able to file and get your permit.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Great, thank you very much.

[Kathleen Desmond]: Have a good evening.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Dennis, my suggestion, unless there's something important that we table the remainder of the miscellaneous items, we don't really have much anything else anyway.

[Denis MacDougall]: So, yeah, it's just meeting minutes, which we can do. We have a bunch that we can do all next next meeting. Although I think we have a few items in the next item next month's meeting as well. So I would recommend eating a big meal beforehand. Cause I'm just sort of saying the, the one that we talked about with attorney Stein that has been brought back before us. So we're going to be hearing that again. That's been remanded and back to us. So we're going to have that next month and a few others.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Plus the main street one.

[Denis MacDougall]: Yeah.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: Okay. Well, all righty. Let's thank you everybody. Is there, is there a motion to adjourn? Okay. All right. Thank you, Mary. And seconded by Jim roll call vote, Jim. Hi, Chris. Hi, Yvette. Hi, Mary.

[SPEAKER_10]: Hi.

[Chair Andre Leroux]: And I'm an eye as well. So meeting is adjourned. Thank you so much, everybody. Appreciate it.

[Denis MacDougall]: And actually is having a Thanksgiving. Well, I'll talk to you. Yeah. Thanksgiving. I'll see you in December.



Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Zoning Board of Appeals