Community Development Board 2/4/26

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3.6-flash from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The Medford Community Development Board endorsed a lot-line adjustment plan, approved a mixed-use site plan review for 255-257 Main Street, and continued site plan review public hearings for 360 Salem Street and 400 Riverside Avenue. The board also conducted a working discussion on proposed Medford Square zoning amendments and approved prior meeting minutes.

  1. 2:56 ANR Plan Endorsement for Bridle Path Lots 4 & 5 — Endorsed an Approval Not Required (ANR) plan transferring 1,100 square feet from lot four to lot five within the Bridle Path subdivision.
  2. 8:48 Site Plan Review for 255-257 Main Street — Approved the site plan review for an eight-unit condominium building with ground-floor commercial space, subject to conditions including tree replacement funding, twice-weekly trash collection, and economic development coordination.
  3. 1:27:07 Continued Site Plan Review for 360 Salem Street — Continued the public hearing to March 4, 2026, requesting the applicant revise massing and parking concepts to address abutter shadow impacts, parking stacker concerns, and affordable unit preservation.
  4. 3:09:19 Site Plan Review for 400 Riverside Avenue — Continued the public hearing to February 18, 2026 to allow the applicant time to address department feedback on parking, accessibility, and fire department access for a proposed co-working and maker space retrofit.
  5. 3:48:00 Discussion on Medford Square Zoning Amendments — Discussed feedback for upcoming zoning consultant sessions, emphasizing sub-district boundaries, accelerating development on city-owned parcels, standalone parking garage permissions, and historic preservation tools.
  6. 4:18:02 Approval of Minutes — Approved the board meeting minutes for October and November.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Community Development Board

[Chair Doug Carr]: Welcome to tonight's meeting of the Medford Community Development Board. I'll call the meeting to order. Let's begin with some obligatory procedural matters. This hearing of the Medford Community Development Board is being conducted via remote means. No in-person attendance of members of the public will be permitted, but every effort will be made to ensure that the public can adequately access the proceedings. Anyone who would like to listen to or view this meeting while in progress may do so by accessing the link that was included on the meeting agenda posted on the City of Medford website. A recording of this meeting will be posted on Medford Community Media website as soon as possible. A reminder that given the remote nature of this meeting, tonight all votes in the board will be made by roll call.

Please know that project materials for all projects before the board can be reviewed on the city's website, medfordmass.org, forward slash boards dash commissions, forward slash community development board, and by clicking on current CD board filings. For those on Zoom, you can also find the link in the chat. So I'll give the roll call for attendance. John Anderson. Here. John Began. Present. Page Buldini.

[Page Buldini]: Present.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Colagaro.

[Page Buldini]: I am here.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman. Are you there? Oh, she's there, okay.

[Ari Fishman]: She's waving, she's muted. Yeah, she's waving, she's muted. Yeah, come and unmute for whatever reason. I'm here. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, I appreciate it. And myself, yes. Danielle, can you introduce any staff? The meeting are on the call.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, myself, Danielle Evans, Senior Planner in the Office of Planning, Development and Sustainability, also Director Alicia Hunt, the Director of PDS. I see Kayla Mieros is here, our Economic Development Planner, and as well as Christian Zapata-Lepofsky, who is our Graduate Student Intern.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good, thank you. I'm just going to outline what we're going to cover tonight before we dive in. The 1st item on the agenda is an A&R approval not required for the bridle pass lot 4 and 5 behind Medford High School. We'll get to that in a few minutes. Then we'll continue with 2 public hearings from our previous meetings, not the last one with the ones before at 255 and 257 Main Street. That will be The second item, and then we'll go on to 360 Salem Street, another continued public hearing.

Next up, the fourth item will be a site plan review for 400 Riverside Ave. And the last piece will be a board discussion, not an hearing, not an open hearing, public hearing of the Medford Square District proposed zoning amendments. So we'll just be talking internally about that. Nothing will be decided tonight. It's not a public hearing. So with that said, we'll jump into the first one, which is the ANR, Endorsement of Approval of Not Required Plan Bridal Path Lots 4 and 5. And I'm going to ask Danielle to introduce the team and explain the ANR for people who may not know what they are.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, so the Bridal Path subdivision is an eight lot subdivision that was approved by this board back in February 2025. They are now getting ready to pull building permits, I believe, for this subdivision, but they're now seeking to adjust the lot sizes for two of the lots by taking 1,100 square feet from lot four and adding it to lot five. We did check with legal counsel that confirmed that The approval not required process. Can be done for this, so that is why it's for your board to be endorsed. They. It meets the criteria for endorsement of an plan as the.

They're on a right away, which was approved under the subdivision control law. They meet the minimum frontage, which in the 1 is 35 feet. They have adequate access. And, um, yeah, those are the main, the main, um, items.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Can we have Christian or someone put the, uh, the site, the kind of site plan on screens that I'll see it just to just for reference, because not everyone, I kind of knew where it was, but not to actually saw the actual site plan. If you don't have it, I can do it.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And we also have Ron Lopez, who is the developer who is here with us tonight.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I see Mr. Lopez. So are you going to share, Danielle, or do you want me to?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, I don't have it teed up.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Let's see.

[SPEAKER_17]: Let's see if I can find it.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I made Mr. Lopez the co-host, because often now he will do the sharing.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, let's do that.

[Jack Sullivan]: Go ahead, Mr. Lopez. Why don't you introduce yourself? I'm actually Jack Sullivan. I'm here with Mr. Lopez. I'm the project engineer. I don't have the plan up available for sharing. I just was unmuted. But I think Danielle covered it well. I don't know if someone there is able to share it. I can do it. Okay. If you're able to do it. Um, but I think Danielle covered, covered everything.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I just wanted to share the general site plan for us before we get into the actual plan. Um, just to give people the context, you know, it's, uh, off of Franklin and Headland way. It's behind the athletic fields behind the high school, the enlarged map that we'll be showing shortly is of this site that's outlined in red, roughly on screen to serve. Everyone gives a little bit of context. If that's okay. In terms of the PDF, you don't have that.

[Jack Sullivan]: We could try to find it in a file. I don't have it readily available.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I have that. Are you looking for the PDF of the?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes, the actual. Yes, the NR plan. Can you put that on screen, Danielle?

[Cheryl Rodriguez]: Yeah, let me.

[SPEAKER_17]: Medford.

[Jack Sullivan]: There it is. They got it. Oh, thank you, Danielle.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah.

[Jack Sullivan]: So I think you can see from this, there's a little triangular piece that will be taken from lot 4 and given to lot 5. No change in the lot frontage on lot 4 and lot 5, and we still have sufficient area for the remainder of lot 4A and lot 5A to meet the zoning. And Danielle's correct, Mr. Lopez has recently submitted for building permits for lot 1 and lot 2.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: So this is the triangular portion that's being taken from this lot and being added to this one.

[SPEAKER_17]: Correct.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Does anyone on the board have any questions about this? We've had a few ANRs over the last few months. They're obviously fairly procedural, but if anyone has any questions, please raise your hand or speak up, please.

[Dina Caloggero]: straightforward.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think so. Yep. If there are no questions, I'm going to ask for a motion to endorse the plan and I'll take a roll call vote.

[Dina Caloggero]: I make a motion to endorse. Seconded.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Dina. Thank you, John. The roll call. John Anderson? Yes. Sean Began? Yes. Page Buldini?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Calagaro?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, yes, the motion passes six to nothing. Thank you, sir. Appreciate your time. Yep. Thank you. Thank you board members. Thank you. Thank you. All right. That's the ANR. We're going to move on now to the public hearing. for 255-257 Main Street. This is file number SPR-2025-3. So this public hearing was continued from the meeting on December 3rd, 2025. And the applicant ESG will present any new information they have in response to city staff and board member comments from the last meeting, which again was not two weeks ago, but four weeks ago. I'll ask Alicia or Danielle to give any introductory comments before we move into the revised presentation from ESG Group.

Alicia or Danielle?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I don't think I have anything to add.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. All right. Then let's get Mr. Messina, if you could give just your name and address for the record, sir.

[SPEAKER_07]: Hi, everyone. I'm Mike Messina with ESG Group. Our address is 24 Roland Street, Boston, Massachusetts.

[Ralph Klein]: Thank you, Mike.

[SPEAKER_07]: Let me pull the presentation up very quickly. just confirm you guys can see that?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes, sir.

[SPEAKER_07]: Great. All right. Again, Mike Messina with the ESG group. I'm representing the project for 255 Main Street tonight. Just want to start by thanking all members of the Community Development Board and members of the public for being here tonight. We really appreciate the collaboration and work on this project so far. Tonight, I have James and Buddy Christopher with me. They're the lead architects at 686 Architects. for the project they'll be presenting with me tonight. Just to highlight some of the other team members that aren't here, we have Boston Civil. They were our civil engineer for the project. Zaid Engineering is our mechanical, electrical, and plumbing engineer. And Hussaini Design Group did the transportation study that was included in our site plan review application. Some of this might be repeat from the last meeting, but just quickly, this is an aerial view of our site along Main Street, and then the two photos on the right are street views, you'll see the building head on, it's a single story retail building with four units that are all vacant at this point, and then the view bottom right is looking north along Main Street with our building featured on the left. The proposal, the lot is 7,600 square feet. Lot coverage is proposed at 77%. Gross square footage is 11,700 square feet. A building's being proposed at 35 feet, three stories. There's eight condominium units, all two bedroom, two bathroom units. There's an 1,100 square foot retail unit proposed on the ground floor. We did obtain a variance from the zoning board for that to be an eating place without a drive through. And so that's sort of how we're thinking about that space, but the end user is still to be determined. And we've agreed to work with the city of Medford to try to collaborate on who that end user might be. And then we're also providing eight off street parking spots, one for each condominium unit.

[Unidentified]: Great.

[SPEAKER_07]: Summarizing some work to date on this project, we have been working on this for about a year, a little over a year, but we notably had a pre-file meeting before we went to the zoning board with community development staff just to make sure that our project was heading in the right direction. And from there, we made some tweaks and shared the proposal with the neighborhood residents. And we did get over 75 signatures in support of the project. From there, we went to the zoning board to request the variances that are required for our project and that did pass in May of last year. From there, we applied or submitted our site plan review application, received department comments on December 2nd. A lot of that was discussed at our last meeting in December, which was really helpful for our team just to make sure that we had direction as to how to move this project forward. And so we spent the month of December and January collaborating and coordinating with those city departments and responding and closing out each comment that we received from our application. And then we submitted revised plans last week to the board.

I know you guys probably can't read this, but just illustrating, we wanted to make sure that we were diligently tracking and closing out all of those items. And so this was an internal tracking matrix that we put together and we did share with Danielle and her team, but just trying to make sure that each comment and request was addressed, accepted, and closed out. And so this was shared along with the Community Development Board's checklist with Danielle as well. Just to highlight some of the major revisions that we did make. I'll let Buddy Christopher walk through some of the more like detailed design revisions, but one of the biggest changes we made was the removal of the wing wall and north side of our site. The fire department and the city engineer requested that a minimum of four foot setback for fire access was provided on the north side of the site. And so by removing that wing wall, we were able to create a 10 foot, just a little over 10 foot setback over here. We did add some windows to bathrooms and change sort of the way that the design language reads along the really all the elevations of the building. And then we did add some brick veneer and I'll let Buddy get into that in a second. We did agree to do all the required roadway restoration that the engineering department required. So that's not shown here, but that is captured in the civil plans that we submitted. And then we added some pedestrian and vehicle safety provisions as well. One thing that was discussed at our last meeting was the two street trees that were out front. The Medford tree warden did inform us that both of those trees need to and will be removed. So with that, we do now have adequate access to our garage space on the ground floor. I will pass it to Buddy to walk through in a bit more detail some of the design revisions that we made since our last meeting.

Buddy, are you there? Buddy, you might be on mute.

[SPEAKER_15]: Yeah, OK. There we go. Thank you very much. Yeah. plan of a building that's a very efficient building. We've, we've minimized, um, you know, any, uh, extraneous spaces that we go forward. The building is organized quite simply. We have the middle of the building will be the main entrance to the residential area upstairs. Um, the double set of doors there will allow you into a lobby, uh, that'll, uh, have access to the elevator. The retail space will have its own entrance, uh, shown here with the vestibule. Uh, on the top of the sheet is the entrance to the parking, which will, um, we'll have an overhead door. Can we have the next slide? The elevation. Okay. Well, we go through the plan. If you want the plans fine. This is the second and third first floor plan. Again, very simply organized. Um, we have, uh, a trash storage space, uh, in the back of the building. Um, that'll be in a two hour fire rated zone so that it's totally protected. Um, For the retail space, we do have 257 square feet of support space for that. That'll be trash and whatever supplies and whatever else needs to be done. We have provided a sprinkler and electric room. This building will also require a transformer, which is shown on the site plan. We have bicycle storage here for six bikes. It could be nine bikes if we use the tandem wall mounted Uh, bikes, but we think six, six should be enough to get going, but we can work that issue out. Um, next slide.

This is the second floor. You can see the stair in the middle, uh, opens up to it's called room, but it should be a common area. Uh, all four units are entranced off of that. They're all two bedrooms, um, with two baths. Um, uh, pretty standard, pretty straightforward. There will be Juliet balconies for each unit so that each unit will have a space so that they can appreciate some of the outdoor during good weather, not this weather, but good weather. Next slide.

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, and buddy, just before we move on, I wanted to, and you'll see it in the elevations, but for all the bathrooms that are touching an exterior wall, we did add a window. And so that was a request that we did accommodate. I know you'll get to that in the elevations, but just wanted to note it there.

[SPEAKER_15]: Yeah, we've pretty much, I think, been answering positively to all the elevations. This is the roof. It's a minimally sloped roof. And there is an area provided for a solar array. What you see here is there is a roof hatch so that we have access to the mechanical equipment on the roof and the elevator penthouse, which will not have an entrance here. But that's just the penthouse coming up four feet above the roof. There are downspouts on the front and back. go to the front of the building. As you can see here, the slope of the site goes from left to right, it goes down. So we've taken advantage of that so that we can do that. There was a recommendation to add transoms over some of the shorter windows that we had in there. And we were able to do that, which is a very good thing. We're gonna be providing a pedestrian vehicular conflict warning system on the building here. We've just diagrammatically noted that there'll be an exterior warning signal, both audible and visual, so that everybody has the benefit of that. And again, the building is pretty clean and simple. The first floor on this elevation is all brick with hardy plank up above as we go along. There'll also be one by five trim boards on all this. And we have a somewhat exaggerated roof line so that we can put a cap on top of this building. Next slide.

This is the side entrance. This is the vehicular entrance. As you come in, you can see, we have the bicycle rack shown right there, there in front of two other, three other racks that are behind that, that'll be wall mounted. We have down lighting all along the ceiling here so that it'll directly illuminate the site from directly above. On the rear of the building, we have, we put two shoe box lights. so that the parking spaces that are off to the right hand in the back of the site, but the beauty of these shoe boxes is you can control the lens so that you can make sure that the light does not spill onto any of our abutters as we go forward. Next slide.

This is the rear of the building here. You can see the two shoe box lights that again, mounted on the bottom to face back. These retaining walls are required so that we can maintain grade so that we do not disturb any of our abutters, but we're able to control what's going on on our site. There's one more elevation. You can see here in the front, that row of storefront windows are all nestled into bricks so that we've carried the brick a third of the way back around the building. These two doors are the doors to the electric room and to the sprinkler room. On the second and third floors, you can see the smaller two-by-two windows, the windows Mike had talked about that were a suggestion from the committee, and we think it's a good idea, so we added those windows into the building. This is a view looking, I believe, at South, with our building inserted in this on the right. We're trying to match and complement the existing fabric of the housing. of the buildings in the area. And then the next slide is looking north. And again, just to show the character and fabric of what was into the community. And I think that's the presentation.

[SPEAKER_07]: Happy to answer any questions. Thank you very much. So I think with that, we can open it up for any questions and discussion. We appreciate the time.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Thank you, Mike. Thank you, Mr. Christopher. I appreciate it. Are there any comments, questions from the board?

[John Anderson]: I have a question if I may. Thank you. I'm trying to understand the parking plan on the ground floor. Am I correct in seeing that the cars are actually parked outside of the building?

[SPEAKER_15]: Six of the cars are. The parking spaces one and two will be under the building. Those are actually the two spots that'll be prepped for EV charging as well. But the rest of the buildings, yes, the building will be up on stilts so that we have the ability to park underneath.

[John Anderson]: And I'm just wondering, I'm very conscious of this question because a lot of people in my neighborhood have been having a problem backing in and out of their driveways and with all the snow banks and stuff. And I'm just wondering if you feel that Some of these parking spots might be a little hard to get in and out of, turn around and so forth.

[SPEAKER_15]: I'm not an expert on this by any means. It's a good question. It really is because it was a challenging site due to the area and geometry. But the one spot, spot number six is a bit of a challenge. And that spot six is in the top left-hand corner. And that parking space is double depth. so that people can slide in and also be able to back out. Parking spaces seven and eight are both 25 foot deep, which is the industry standard for all parallel parking. And the remainder of the parking spaces are direct pull in pulls outs. We have 20 feet face of the building to the inside face of the columns that are supporting right by parking space number seven and eight. So we have a 20-foot clear area there, which is more than ample for a car to be able to do a three-point trip. Okay, thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, Ari.

[Ari Fishman]: Thank you and thank you to the applicant for the presentation. I think this overall looks to be in really nice shape and I'm excited to see it coming together a few kind of mostly small questions and apologies if I miss this during your presentation. There were comments from I believe Todd Blake about impervious surface for the driveway and increased impervious surfaces. Is any of this going to be more porous to account for stormwater? I'll just ask all my questions at once. I believe there's a tree or two that the tree warden has approved taking down. Are there plans to replant it and if so, Can it be with a native plant? And the third one is there had also been a comment, I believe from Todd about eligibility of residents to receive an on-street parking permit. And I think I would feel better if they were not eligible to receive on-street parking permits.

[SPEAKER_15]: All right, let's start with the first question. There is a total onsite stormwater management system. So all water that is pouring onto the site currently will be put into a contact system, below grade, retained, and then released at off peak hours. We will be using the previous paving for the parking area. There is a planting schedule. If you can go to the L1 drawing, You'll see, we have a pretty extensive planting schedule for this. There are four trees coming back. There are two major planting beds on the left-hand side of the lower side of the building. And then anywhere there's open space, we're going to be doing some, some planting. We'll be putting some annuals and some perennials so that this should be a robust, uh, you know, a lively site all along. In the front, if you look at the lower right-hand corner of this where the three yellow trees are, that gray box behind there is the transformer that we are required to do.

[Ari Fishman]: Great. And can you commit to doing primarily or exclusively native plants?

[SPEAKER_15]: Yes, absolutely.

[Ari Fishman]: Fantastic. Thank you.

[SPEAKER_15]: Mike, can you answer the last question about the eligibility for the resident parking?

[SPEAKER_07]: Yes, yes, I can. I believe that came up in our last meeting and I had agreed that we can accept that provision if that's what the city wants to see, then we provided a spot for each of our, we won't call them tenants because these are for sale, but each resident will have a spot and so we're comfortable with that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, thank you, Mike. That has been the standard that this board has adapted for the products in the last, every project for the last four or five months. So this is consistent with that. So that's going to be a requirement for all these products going forward. So I'll go next to Page Buldini and then we'll do Dina right after.

[Page Buldini]: exciting to see this from the last presentation, so I really appreciate that. Seeing the checklist was super helpful as well. There actually might be a resident who had asked this question before on this call, but as somebody that walks my child to school, not right now, but past the snow, it is a significant slope that's coming into that garage. So I am grateful that that is something that we had discussed. And I do appreciate that large tree that's on the corner where the dental office is. But I just want to be mindful that as we walk by and or the future of snow, with that slope, are the cars going to actually be able to turn in and out that way? Because obviously this, if you walk by right now, I appreciate the snow is currently removed. but the block up isn't. So I just want to be really mindful, especially with that retail space, if it's Eden, which is very exciting. Um, and that was another vision question that I had asked before. I just want to make sure that the accessibility from the sidewalk and, or pulling into the garage, um, that we're really mindful of that.

[SPEAKER_15]: I appreciate that part of that. Um, not all of it. Um, the layout, the answer is yes. The cars can get in and out. And with the warning system, we're very, very comfortable that it'll prevent any conflicts between pedestrians and the vehicle. As far as the snow removal, I can't answer that question. Uh, I would, I would hope that, you know, everything would be clear, but, um, we'd be willing very much to, to work with the city to make sure things happen the right way.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His): yeah I mean you're responsible for your own snow removal that that's obviously part of the condo board, you know the. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : Right so the building i'm not I think you guys will need to do that as just a you know I don't think the city's gonna get too involved in that obviously.

[SPEAKER_07]: David Ensign, PB – He, Him, His.: : will be responsible for snow removal, yes. David Ensign, PB – He, Him, His.: : I appreciate that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : Anything else you're all set page okay do you know once you go next.

[Dina Caloggero]: yeah i'm. Alicia.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia Hyatt, PB – She, Her, Hers.

[Dina Caloggero]: I'm excited to see this project finally come to fruition. It's right up the street from me. So I live right down the street. So I walk past it every day. So one of the questions I have is, I'm going to piggyback on John a little bit of page here, is that on the street in Main Street, there's a bus stop in front of the dentist's office. And then on the top, between Main Street and Stanley Avenue, it jets out. So there is a provision there that the cars cannot park from the corner. I know there's not going to be any residential parking, I heard, permitting. And they'll all have to use the spots. And I'd love to see how the snow is going to be removed with all those cars parked there. But I'll leave that up to the condo board. But my question is that the retail space in front of it, That's going to be difficult to do maybe one or two spaces with the retail in front in ensuring that they don't park too close to the corner of Stanley because you won't be able to see coming out on that. And then the other question is, where's the trash located and how is the contractor going to commit and move the trash out?

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, so we will the trash is located on the inside. I believe that's right here under the stairs, which is allowed per code will be using a private hauler. I'm thinking because I think we're gonna need probably two pickups a week for this building. So that's sort of what the plan is right now. Either our property manager or the private trash contractor will come and wheel the barrels out this door here and out to the street really on the day of pickup. They won't be sitting there for days. We'll try to make sure that it gets wheeled out the morning before pickup or maybe the night before, depending on what time it gets picked up in the morning. Yeah, and then in terms of the vehicle parking in front in front. I think that will work with Todd and his team on that I don't have. ultimately like the city can do what they want with their street, right? But we wanna be cooperative and collaborative there with Todd, but we'll probably have to work with him, but I totally understand your comment and we'll keep that in mind as we move forward. There's still a lot of the engineering details that needs to get flushed out when we apply for a building permit. And so we'll keep that in mind when we get there.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, and just as Paige pointed out, I think the snow, like if we get an extreme amount of snow like we did this past couple of weeks, it's going to be extremely difficult for those cars to get in there. Main Street's very congested right now, just trying to get down with the car, not trying to make that swing into the garage.

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, understood.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yep.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All set, Dina?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yep, I'm good, thanks.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His): All right, Lisa, you were next. I just unmuted you and then we'll go to talk to Sean afterwards. Go ahead, Lisa.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, Hers. Lisa Spiro, PB – She, Her, And that might be an impact, like you do have to have drainage there because it's open and water and rain will come in. But I do the, you'll need to discuss this with the engineering office, who unfortunately, they didn't notice this until this evening, but we'll need to check in. But the area that's under the roofed area, definitely building code cannot be pervious. Even though the board would like it.

[SPEAKER_07]: Well, I appreciate that. And buddy, I can take this one. I think our original design and it was asphalt. And so we we were going to explore, I like the idea of more pervious pavers as well. But that was something that we were going to have to review with engineering when it came time to submit for building permits. So I'm agreeing with the board, like the more pervious area we can have on site, the better for everyone and you know, including our project, but there's some nuance and some details that we're going to have to work through with Owen and his team. So I appreciate you flagging that, Felicia.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And I just want to be clear, because if it's on the site plan and the site plan is the controlling document, then you might have to come back here for an amendment. And if we find that this evening and then we state something, we can have something that says that pervious pavement to the amount allowed by building code and Medford's engineering and stormwater regulations, then I think that would allow this and the board would, then I'm asking them now to understand that it is not because you don't want to do it, it's because there are code issues here.

[Chair Doug Carr]: We can put that in the conditions, can't we, Alicia, if we get to that point?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, and that you'll need the building drain needs to have a grease trap if it's under the building. So I just wanted to flag these things, because I don't want you to have to come back for an amendment when it's something that I could raise this evening and you could have it now.

[SPEAKER_15]: Yeah, the drainage system, which we are working on, does have an oil grease. There it is right there. There are separators, and then the galleys are below the building down below. But you can see we've got catch basins. So we'll be able to capture all of the stormwater, whether it's under the roof or not under the roof. In the whole driveway, that's part of the reason for the retaining walls is we're pitching everything internally to these catch bases.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, there's a clean line between those different type of pavements. That's clearly the footprint of the building and the dark and the lighter gray there. So I think that's a pretty straightforward thought. Anything else, Alicia?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Nope, that's it. Sorry, I usually try to keep my mouth shut, but.

[SPEAKER_07]: No, I appreciate that, Alicia. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: We do not want you to keep your mouth shut. We want to solve as many problems as we can. Go ahead, Sean.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, thank you. For the applicant, in regards to the retail location, are you planning to keep ownership of that location, or are you going to sell that along with the other units?

[SPEAKER_07]: I think our intent, That's a tough one to answer, Sean. I think that our intent would be to own it and have, you know, rent it out to a tenant. But I can't, I can't really make any commitments here or there to that, like if there was the right opportunity to sell it to the right tenant, we would explore that. But I think we'll we're trying to keep ownership ownership of it.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I I don't have, I don't really care either way. I prefer that you own it for a little while so that you're still involved in the building and we can make sure that everything that ultimately is agreed to, you know, is kind of adhered to. I'm specifically thinking about the trash. You know, you had mentioned probably needing two times a week trash removal. That's something, unless it's written into the, are the agreement with this board or into the condo docks could get lost along the way when a different unit owners are owning this building and it's not yourself anymore. So yeah, that's where my mind was going with that.

[SPEAKER_07]: I appreciate that. And I think just given the size of this building and the trash we have, like whether it's a requirement or it's the future HOA, I think that they would come to that conclusion on their own as well. So I understand that. OK, thanks.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Mike, could you bring up the exterior renderings? And I do want to compliment you and your design team for the improvements that you've made. I think they're significant for not only the additional windows and the the transoms over the slider doors and the additional brick, which I think was Danielle's initial thought. I think it's an improvement. Could you go to the other, looking the other way, the other rendering, street rendering two. This seems to imply, maybe I'm not reading it correctly, but it looks like the trees in front are staying in this rendering. And I was trying to figure out, and I spoke to Danielle earlier today, and we were saying, okay, well, you've added some trees. I see that, and that's a great thing, but the two trees that are gone, isn't the city standard to be required to replace those trees, not to have them just shifted?

[SPEAKER_07]: Well, yeah. I think just starting with, I think the point of this rendering was to address the comment we heard in the last meeting that you wanted to see the size and scale of the building in the relationship of the neighborhood context. I think in the matters of the trees, I believe that the tree warden had let me know that they were going to be removing those trees kind of regardless of this proposal or not. Maybe I'm misunderstanding, but I was sort of informed by Aggie that the trees were being removed. So I don't know if that puts us in a different category. I think, you know, our intent is we have, I think, you know, four or five trees, buddy, I'm not sure how many, but we wanted to replant some trees, but in terms of replacing those two specific trees, I'm not sure where we stand, to be honest on that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Let me kick it to Danielle, since I think she talks to Aggie all the time and is familiar with this process. Go ahead, Danielle.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. My understanding is that Um, Aggie waved the tree hearing, um. Because the trees were in decline, but most urban street trees are not, you know. The healthiest specimens, um. We definitely need to have some replacement trees. I don't. You know, back of the sidewalk trees are great and I don't think these those should, um. You do not go forward. I think we need both those. Street trees that were there before were large and had a large tree canopy provide shade.

So, I, I would recommend and I had wrote into the draft conditions that. You know, in accordance with the city's policy, that 3 inch caliber trees. be planted in the, you know, adding up to what was lost of the removed tree. So if it's a 10-inch caliper tree, then you would need, you know, four.

[Chair Doug Carr]: That's four new trees, right, Danielle?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, four new 3-inch caliper trees. And it doesn't have to be along your frontage. I mean, it could, I mean, I believe you should have 1, but it could be further along main street. So, I'm recommending that as a condition, the idea that you would move both trees and then. Just replace a sidewalk and not have anything there doesn't seem like a great idea.

[SPEAKER_07]: I agree. And I didn't mean to seem like I was pushing back on that at all. I just didn't know in terms of what was required or not. We're happy to accept that condition, Danielle. Just to be clear.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: The board can impose conditions beyond what the tree warden's policies are. Sure.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, thank you, Mike. I really appreciate that, because I think there's a lot of people in Medford who are passionate about the trees, and we want to obviously increase the tree canopy, not decrease. And I think it would help this project and help Main Street as overall if we could just get a little bit more green space, a little bit more shade canopy. It doesn't have to, as Danielle said, it doesn't have to be within the limited frontage you have, but I think we can sort that out. And I appreciate you being flexible on that.

[SPEAKER_07]: Absolutely.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I had one other question. I think it went to the fire department comments. I think the checklist you had mentioned that the fire department had given you feedback, and I know you had from the wing wall removal and other things, but was there an actual letter or email? Because I could not find it myself.

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, there was some email exchange that went back and forth. deputy chief Shea, and it was specific to that wing wall comment. They wanted to make sure that we had adequate fire access on that north side of the site. And so we had submitted a letter with an updated elevation that reflects what we presented and what we submitted to the board. But there was just some coordination there before we went ahead and revised the design. We wanted to make sure that we were headed in the right direction. And so he was able to confirm that that solution was acceptable. And then it also did satisfy Um, the city engineers comment they were requiring a minimum of four foot setback. And so we've, um, we've now, we now have over 10 feet.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Daniel, do you have anything in the conditions that at least, uh, codify that and say, you can, so we can make sure that that's not an impediment here.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Um, so there, because his, the fire department's, um, conditions are, or their requirements are, are shown on the, um, On the control plans and there wasn't anything above and beyond what would be required by all their other regulations. I didn't have any specific conditions to add. One thing that I've been trying to do is not just reiterate requirements that. You know. Makes our list of conditions like unreasonably long because that's they're not actually. conditions that are being imposed on by the board, the requirements that they would have to do anyways once they file for building permits.

So I didn't have anything additional here, but I believe I do have an email saying that he was okay with it. I can go find it.

[Chair Doug Carr]: No, no, as long as you're comfortable with the resolution, I think that's fine. John Anderson, you have a question.

[John Anderson]: I know this came up at some other site plan review. I can't remember if it was this review or not, but the audible pedestrian warning, is that an issue at two in the morning when somebody comes home late?

[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm afraid it's required no matter what time, John. It is a condition that we have, that the city, I think it's Todd, who required that. And the best you can do is to not have it too loud, you know, like 80 decibels, but there's a requirement for both audio and visual that has to be there. There's really no choice, unfortunately, that I can see.

[John Anderson]: Okay. I'd think twice before I got the, the unit right above the entrance.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Maybe that unit comes with a white noise machine, John.

[John Anderson]: Right. And one other thing, and maybe it's not a problem, once you scale the parking to the spaces, the size of cars that the space provided, but where would people pile the snow? If you look at the L1 drawing, there are two areas.

[SPEAKER_07]: L1. Give me one second. My apologies.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Let's just put it on screen, John. There it is.

[SPEAKER_15]: You'll see that there are two spots immediately below parking spaces one and two. We have an area there. And then along parking spaces six, five, four, three, we also have area back there.

[John Anderson]: That's what those little circles are. No, little circles are actually shrubs and bushes. Okay.

[SPEAKER_15]: But there is an area there that's beyond the retaining wall that we could offload some of the snow.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So, Mr. Christopher, are you saying those spaces are longer than 18 feet?

[SPEAKER_15]: No, they are 18 feet, but there's a retaining wall, and then there's another, I think it's six feet, beyond the retaining wall to the property line.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So you'll be burying some of those plants in snow, essentially?

[SPEAKER_15]: If they're perennials, I'm not too worried.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. Well, I think there is a reasonable accommodation for some snow here. I mean, when you get three feet, all bets are off, obviously. All right. Are there any other board questions before I open it up to the public? All right, I'm going to open up to the public. So I'll now open the public comment period. Those who wish to provide comments can use the raise hand feature, which may be under reactions on your Zoom, or if you're dialed in on the phone, you can use the star nine to raise your hand. You can message Alicia. In the chat, if you're having technical difficulties before providing your comments, please state your name and address for the record, a reminder that all meeting participants to please refrain from using the chat function to message any comments to city staff or board members, as it is not part of the public record. However, if a participant is having audio or other technical difficulties, you may message staff for assistance. Each participant will have two minutes to speak, and I recognize Jeremy Martin. Hello, Jeremy.

Jerry, I can't hear you. You're unmuted though.

[Jeremy Martin]: How about now?

[Chair Doug Carr]: That's good. Go ahead, Jeremy. We can hear you. Or at least I could. I can hear you. We can hear you now, Jeremy.

[Jeremy Martin]: Can you hear me now? Yes. All right, sorry about that. 65 Burgett Avenue, Jeremy Martin. Great to see the updates for the project. And as a comment to last time, this is a very welcome addition to Main Street. I want to call attention to two things that have been discussed tonight. I'm one of those people who are passionate about trees, as you can anticipate. This plan here, I see that the landscape plan indicates the existing trees to remain. We obviously just heard that they've already been cut down.

I hope that this board will absolutely condition this project to require replacement of those two street trees on this frontage. They're really important to Main Street, and I think looking at the renderings of the new building, it just makes it even more obvious that those trees are valuable and needed in front of this building. I also want to point out that a couple of the other trees that are proposed here, I'm assuming a red maple on the top right of the plan, is in an incredibly narrow spot between the paving, the sidewalk, and the adjacent property. And then the tree just near the, I think the electrical room doors, seems to be on top of the electrical duct bank. So I just encourage a really critical review of this site plan to make sure that the trees that are being offered and proposed are actually viable in the locations that they're proposed. The other point I wanted to raise, I was glad to see that the new building elevations take into account the slope across the sidewalk. That's really important for some of the reasons Paige noted. Hopefully those entrances are all accessible.

There was a comment earlier that all of the stormwater on the site is being captured in that system, and from what I can tell in the civil grading plan, The portion of the site that has plants out here has about four feet of slope from the back to the front. It does not appear to drain into any kind of storm structure. It looks like it's going to run across the sidewalk, and I think that needs to be alleviated so that there's not a big icy pile of snow and water that comes across it. Thanks.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Jeremy. Appreciate it. You're a regular on this on this particular program. So we appreciate it. Thank you. Are there hold on a second. Are there other people who want to make public comments? I'm not seeing anyone raised hands. Alicia, is that correct?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I'm not seeing anyone. And I have not gotten any messages from anybody.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. All right. I want to get a sense of the board if they're ready to talk about conditions that they think that this project is ready to be approved or not. It's an open question. I would like to kind of do a informal survey, if you will, about how people are feeling about this. Um, maybe, uh, starting with you, John, since you're unmuted.

[John Anderson]: Okay. Um, this seems like a really great project. Um, I do note that there's sort of some loose ends. Uh, some of the, some of the responses reference conversations or discussions with city agencies, uh, which aren't really documented. Uh, Just to avoid any misunderstandings, it would be good if those were documented or if the approval is granted with enough conditions to cover it. I don't want to hold things up for sort of formalities, but it is good to, you know, tidy up all the loose ends.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Appreciate that, John. I think that was my question about the fire department earlier, which I think I have a good answer for. But were there anyone else that you thought was a loose end besides the fire department?

[John Anderson]: Gee, I'd have to go back and look at the, well, there are a number of references. For the city engineer, calculations and documents will be provided when we submit our stormwater permit application. Did the police ever make any comments?

[Chair Doug Carr]: I don't believe so.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: No, and they rarely ever do. And that's okay? Yeah. If you don't get any comments, they have no comments.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It's their purview, John.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Sorry to interrupt you, John, but I did find the email from Dan Shea where he said the access looks good to him. So, yeah, so really, like, city staff, like, so my job and Lisa's job is. To kind of make sure that all the other departments are all set and then. Um, you know, anything that isn't shown on the plans or isn't controlled by some other regulation, like all of own stormwater and. Requirements those are controlled by stormwater rules. Like, so if what you approve doesn't.

Just you, just you all approving a plan, like, even even the pervious pavement, if that is against code, they don't all of a sudden get permission to do it. So there are a lot of other layers of protection.

[John Anderson]: Okay, thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, this is essentially advanced conceptual design. It's not construction documents. Go ahead, Dina.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, so Danielle, could you go over the provision again you were talking about with Aggie, the conditional on the trees? You said four, right? So the design includes four trees that would be replanted, and what the commenter suggested is that an investigation has to be into the viability of where those trees are located. So does the condition right now require the four trees?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: So this would be the board's condition, not the tree board's condition. And this is regarding street trees, so trees that are in the public way, so things that are not trees on their property, which they you know, you have, you know, requirements for site plans. If you want more trees, you can ask for more trees. But so I wrote, I mean, should I, Mr. Chair, should we, should I share the draft conditions document?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, I think so. I'm getting the sense that people want to get into that.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I just want to look at it. It was a lot said. Yes. Yeah. So this is in the folder. It was added today. So I don't expect you to have seen it. Because I know you guys do your homework well in advance.

[Dina Caloggero]: There's a lot to read.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: It's a lot. Yeah.

[Dina Caloggero]: Let me... It should be at least two. Two trees were removed. Two should be replanted. Native trees in viable spots.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But we're adding four total along. Not necessarily in front of the building. That's what Mike and his team agreed to.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so this is, I mean, I had just put in recommended language, but you all are the board and you can add whatever you like. So I just throw something down there to at least get something. Yeah, no, good. Can you guys see this?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, can you zoom in a little bit more just to be bigger on the screen?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, because it's like a molder. Here we go. Okay, yeah, so do we want to focus on this street tree?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah. Yeah, so I put.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so I put as mitigation for the removal of the northerly street tree, which. I had seen references at 10 inch caliber pear tree. If that is not correct, then. Hope the applicants would correct me that for new 3 inch caliber trees. will be planted along Main Street. The applicant shall coordinate with the tree warden on species selection and locations. And this is what I did not know that the Southerly tree was being removed. If the Southerly Street tree is removed, the applicant will be required to plant additional 3-inch caliper replacement trees equal to the caliper size of the removed tree. Because originally only the Northerly tree needed to be removed. That's right, because that's where their entrance was right in the bus stop in the entrance.

[Dina Caloggero]: Right. Yeah.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And then we need to know how big that tree is know how many replacing it. Correct. That's right. It wasn't very healthy. I don't think Well, I think we're going to have to have some flexible language in there to coordinate the caliber with the replacement because we're not going to solve that tonight.

[Dina Caloggero]: Right. But it can be a condition.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think the intent is there. I think the consensus is there from the applicants. I think this will be maybe with a little bit of adaptation for the language here to reflect that it sounds like both trees are going and need to be replaced with equal calipers along Main Street is the essential point.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I agree, but it's 3 inch caliper trees is what the city plants that they found that that is the size that does the best are more likely to survive any bigger. You know, it doesn't work out any smaller doesn't work out, but they found that 3 inches kind of like the magic number. And so if the tree was found to be healthy and needed a tree hearing, then they would have required that they replace it with.

this formula of whatever the removed caliper size is, you know, divided by three inch and then you round up.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So I think the language needs to be slightly edited, Danielle, to reflect that both trees could go away and be replaced with equal calipers, depending on if it's one or both. Just, I think that that would cover us in terms of taking this item off the table, so to speak.

[Dina Caloggero]: I agree with Doug. Okay.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All right. Are there other, do you wanna, Danielle, maybe you could go to the top of this and we can talk about what's here already, because some of this is boilerplate.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so these are the boilerplate, these are, you know, I fill in the control plans, the planned modification boilerplate condition, which gives our office the authority to approve diminished mischanges or like minor modifications without having to come back to the board. Um, you know, for little things that they have to record it. Yep.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Um, there's the audible.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so the, all of the engineering conditions, um, or the actual property are shown on the plans and they address, um, city engineers comments, but this was the one remaining it's, you know, off of the property and could get lost. So we put this in here. about the road restoration, so in accordance with engineering directive number three, the applicant shall perform roadway restoration, pavement restoration limit shall be curb-to-curb milling and paving of two inches along the entire frontage. Usually there's also, they have a condition about replacing the sidewalk, but I did see that noted on the plans, so that potentially could be covered there.

That is also 1 of their requirements, and I saw it on the plan, so I don't know if it needs to be added.

[SPEAKER_17]: I don't think so.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And these were the traffic and transportation conditions that come directly from Director Blake's memo. Yep. Bike racks, yeah.

[Chair Doug Carr]: The audible warning. The one about the dwelling not being eligible for on-street residential, that's probably what Blake got that, obviously.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Trees and then just for the public that. We've been requiring this when they don't. Supply the 1 and a half per unit, so they're not. They're doing, I think it's 1. So, we put that in there, if they're supplying enough parking for their, their residents, and they don't need offsite parking. So this is to. Ensure that they're building what. the residents will actually need, and it won't burden the on-street parking availability for the existing neighborhood. Here we go with the tree one, and then this is flagging that it's subject to linkage fees, and then prior to a building permit, they need to enter into a linkage agreement, which also outlines the amount and the pavement, and if there's any credits.

And then the final 12th one was about, you know, was a recommendation. It's not a requirement by the, that the economic development planner suggested that they, you know, reach out to the tenants that were displaced and connect them to our office for support and resources.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. I'm going to go to Alicia, but then I'm going to ask the board if there are any other conditions that they want to add to this list. Go ahead, Alicia.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right. Sorry. So I apologize for contradicting anything that was just said around the trees, but I happened to be messaging with our city engineer who provided me actually with language from our tree warden. that Danielle might not have seen. I'm not sure why I've asked him to forward us the message, but she specifically has said that, and I can put it into the chat, the two trees and the stumps were removed by forestry, the combined DBH, the diameter of breast height.

was 30 inches divided by three inches caliper of replacement trees equals 10 new trees. Cost per tree for materials, insulation and watering by contractor and warranty for one year is $840 per tree for a cost of $8,400 payable to the city of Medford tree planting account. And according to the city engineer, they would prefer actually to have the money in the account rather than have the rather than coordinating with the contractor in this case to plant the trees because it will be easier for them to locate them in the locations they feel are the most appropriate if they had the money rather than making the contractor plant the trees.

[Chair Doug Carr]: What's the timing on that, Danielle? I'm sorry, Alicia, in terms of the commitment of the $8,400?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: HAB-Charlotte Pitts, Moderator, Secretary for Housing and Urban Development.: : Soon, it would, it would be permanent before the building permit.

[Chair Doug Carr]: HAB-Jacques Juilland, Moderator, Staffing & Management.:

[Director Alicia Hunt]: : For the building permit. Yes. HAB-Jacques Juilland, Moderator, Staffing & Management.: : Like a new okay with that with your, your team.

[Chair Doug Carr]: HAB-Michael Leccese, Moderator, Staffing & Management.: : We agree. Yep. HAB-Jacques Juilland, Moderator, Staffing & Management.: : I didn't think that was a big lift.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, no one communicated that to me at all. This email did not actually go to Daniel Planning, and he's apologizing that they need to resolve the process. There was a process issue here. And so it's convenient that I was messaging him about the other issues, the previous pavement. So he was able to catch this. We'll fix that for future hearings.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And we'll need to revise that condition, obviously. Sean Bacon, go ahead, sir.

[Sean Beagan]: Sure, a couple questions. So point 12 in these conditions, is this building currently occupied by tenants?

[SPEAKER_07]: It is not.

[Sean Beagan]: Okay, so do we really need point 12 if it's a vacant building?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: There were tenants. They moved out since this project, I think, was initiated. There was a dog groomer there and some other ones.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yep. I'm just. Planners in touch with the dog groomer, but I don't know about the others.

[Sean Beagan]: It sounded like they want a restaurant there.

[SPEAKER_07]: We obtained a variance for an eating place without a drive through just because that's how we've been thinking about that space, but I know the. the Office of Economic Development wanted to collaborate with us on that. We haven't signed any leases. We haven't made any commitments. And we understand that if that use does change in the future, we might be required to obtain an additional variance for a different future use. But we want to collaborate with the neighborhood and the city is what I'm saying on that. It might not.

We had done some early feedback that there was a desire for an eating place. And so that's how we've been thinking about it. Um, nothing set in stone at this point.

[Sean Beagan]: Okay. So I guess just sticking on point 12, what, what specifically does the applicant need to do? To me, this is, uh, and I understand Mike wants to be accommodating and I appreciate that. And he's been very, very accommodating. I just am trying to, I just want to make sure that if we give him an assignment to do that he knows what he needs to do to comply with this assignment. So explore opportunities to retain existing tenants.

Does he have to reach out and contact these tenants directly and report back to us? Or does, I mean, is it, I don't want to put something in here that's just a throwaway item to satisfy the, office, you know, the one of the offices in the city, if he's not, if it's not of some substance.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, Elisa, you had a comment.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think that in the spirit of this, we might say work with the economic development office on the tenanting of this space. Because if it's, if it's the right thing to do to bring in an eating place, I mean, we actually hear from businesses that want to come to Medford, right. And so It would be lovely to be able to match a new building with the business that wants to come here. At the same time, if the, you know, there's a question, I don't know if there's a desire to have the former business come back. Of the ones that were there, I know we're in touch with one of them who was actually frustrated, I think it was the prior owner of the property who gave them a notice that their lease was ending.

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, and if I can speak to that I believe I just got a text from someone on my team that all the old tenants now have new homes in different places so there has been some contact there. And just on the condition of working with economic development, we, we want to and we think that that's that's great collaboration I just want to be careful of. boxing us in at, you know, from other opportunities, like our, our intent is to fully collaborate there. But I wouldn't want it to just be like, whatever Economic Development Office says goes kind of thing. But we definitely want that collaboration. I just wanted to throw that out there.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, it seems to be in the spirit of being advisory. I think that's okay for everyone. Go ahead, Paige, you had a comment.

[Page Buldini]: Yep, just totally agree, Mike. Thank you for being so appreciative of the city. Even the Chamber of Commerce works directly with the Office of Economic Development. And I think Kayla actually might even be still on this. So thank you for thinking about that and being mindful of it. But I think especially if it's a walkable space for an eating area, I think that would be really great. So if there are many people I know that are looking to putting in cafes, ice cream shops. So thank you for thinking about people in the area.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. Thank you. Go ahead, Sean, and then we'll get to Kayla after that.

[Sean Beagan]: Yep. Just a couple more points. In regards to the money that the applicant has to pay into the tree fund, is that money specifically earmarked for trees for this location, or does it just go into a general fund? I want to make sure that if the applicant's paying for trees, that he's getting the benefit of the trees at that location. And it doesn't just go into a general fund. And with someday some, he may get a tree or may not. So I just don't, I'm not being facetious. I just don't know how that works at all.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I would think Alicia or Danielle could answer that one. I thought it seemed like it should be a dedicated fund if they're talking about exact dollars.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Um, hold on one second because I see typing. Um, it is my understanding that South Medford is a priority area for us to plant trees. One of our difficulties is getting the permission or not exactly permission, but to plant trees in front of people's houses. Yeah, so very problematic. Um, so that is, um, uh, sometimes an issue. And there are people who asked to have trees removed from in front of theirs. If there is space on the sidewalk in front of this building and that works, I mean, I think DPW would prefer that, but I also am not clear that you could or should put more than two trees in front of this building, right? And if we're paying for 10 trees, they're gonna need to be spread out.

But I can tell you that South Medford is a heat island area. It is a priority location for us to be planting trees. And I'm also just going to flag for you that our economic development planners on call, which I did not realize earlier, or I would not go to her next.

[Sean Beagan]: So it sounds like the answer is no, it's not necessarily dedicated to this location.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Well, you certainly can't put 10 trees in front of this building.

[Sean Beagan]: No, is that what he's paying for? I missed that. Is that how many entries?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yes, the tree warden wants the money for 10 trees at $840, which covers the tree, the planting, and a year of maintenance.

[Sean Beagan]: OK. All right. Thank you. Very good. And then my final comment on these conditions is I would like to add something in about the trash removal. that it be at least two times a week for both the residential units and the retail unit.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think that's fair, Sean. I agree with that. That room is actually pretty small. I think it can only fit about 290 gallons, which could fill up quite fast for eight units. All right, so I'm going to then go to Kayla.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Hi, thank you. Turning back to section 12, I would suggest based on what everyone was saying here, updating these to say, scheduling a meeting with the economic development team to discuss potential tenants. And it would be really great if the development team does have the contact information and where these businesses landed, sharing that would be nice. But I don't think that needs to go into this decision. but offering it as a suggestion to get conversation started and get appointed with one another. Okay.

[SPEAKER_07]: I appreciate that, Kayla. Thank you. I'm happy to share the contact that we have and schedule that meeting, but I appreciate it.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Great. Thank you. So we should- I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I cannot find my raised hand function while I'm sharing and the whole layout has changed. So I'm so sorry for interrupting and not raising my hand. Kayla, could you please text me that language in the chat so I can, in Teams or something, so I can drop that in. And also, I just wanted to add, regarding the location for the trees, you could require that one of those go in front of their frontage. You can do that. That's within your power. You could say, to the greatest extent feasible, that one of the street trees from this spot be along their frontage.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, I would think that would be a good idea. I wouldn't want, I want them on Main Street, obviously they need to be, but I don't want them everywhere else but this property. This property should benefit from those trees and so should the residents and the retail. So let's put that as one of, at least one of the 10, subject to the review of the tree ward in which this all is, and the city, we can add that to the language. Go ahead, Paige.

[Page Buldini]: Super quick, can we just say that they have to stay in South Medford? Is that allowed? I know it is.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think we're saying on Main Street, we're being quite specific.

[Page Buldini]: So we can say that though?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes, I think that's the language that I've heard suggested we should, we don't want them anywhere else in the city for sure.

[Page Buldini]: Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, Daniel, how do we, I think we have a little bit of quick editing here to get some of these conditions. I know you're waiting for some texts from maybe Kayla or others. Are there any other comments or questions from the board members while we start to put together, fine tune these conditions? Okay, hearing none. I don't think we're ready for a motion yet because the language isn't quite there. Go ahead, Alicia.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Mr. Chair, just while Danielle's editing those, because I think that's all you need. Yes. I just wanted to remind the applicants that if they need or want to use the sidewalk space or street or parking or anything during construction, you need to prearrange that with the engineering department. It's not a given, but they will be anticipating that you will be asking for some occupancy, and I do believe sometimes, I do believe there are either charges or work in kind that comes along with that. It's not a condition from the board. I'm just passing along a message from the engineering office.

[SPEAKER_07]: I appreciate that, Alicia. I think that our construction team's already been in contact a little bit with Ellen on that, so understood. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And Mike, can you speak to, if this does go through tonight, what's your general thought on schedule going forward?

[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, I think we've started the permit process, the preliminary, like not full building permit, but demolition and starting to finish our structural design. And so our intent is to start, you know, as soon as really the weather gets better. I mean, I know there'll probably be some time before we get a building permit, but it's probably like this spring, depending on how quick we can go, it could be as soon as April.

[Chair Doug Carr]: That makes sense. And do you strike, is this a six, eight months or more? What are you thinking for approximate timeframe construction?

[SPEAKER_07]: Oh yeah, it's gonna be more than that. I think that we're assuming 14 months of construction, but I think we'll be weather tight. So from the outside of the building, it'll be sooner than that. That's probably about eight to 10 months. And then all the construction will be on the interior after that. But yeah, I think our best case for starting to go out of the ground with this, TAB, Mark McIntyre ): Is April and I know we still have some work to do with the with the building department to get there so but that's kind of like the soonest that it would be.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I appreciate that. TAB, Mark McIntyre ): looks like we're getting there on the. TAB, Mark McIntyre ): The tree language.

[Page Buldini]: Can I just say something quick? Mike, thank you so much for clearing the sidewalk. Seriously, that whole strip is awesome. And even cars can get by. So I just really appreciate that.

[SPEAKER_07]: Thank you. Yep. That wasn't me, but that was our team. So I'll pass it along. Maybe they're listening. Thank you.

[Dina Caloggero]: They did a really good job.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. So I think we're getting close to a motion. I think there's a little bit of language here. I think Sean, the number 12 has been simplified. It looks like a little bit. The economic development team shall schedule a meeting with the economic development planner and director to discuss potential rent attendance. That's pretty straightforward. I think that's satisfactory.

[Sean Beagan]: I think that's good. That gives him some marching orders and he knows when he's had the meeting, he's complied with what he needed to do.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, thank you. So we're still working on the language for number 10 and then go ahead, Kayla.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Hi. Can we just change 12 to say the development team will schedule a meeting with the economic development planner and director?

[Chair Doug Carr]: You mean the construction development team?

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: That's right. So that economics should just be deleted. Yep. Thank you. Thank you, Kayla. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : All right, I think that's it what we added there was. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : At least one tree shall be within the frontage of main street of this project that's the only other. Harmon Zuckerman, PB – He, Him, His.: : caveat or additional text for item number 10 at the end.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: What was Sean's trash condition? I'm still wordsmithing this. Sure.

[Sean Beagan]: I can type something up if you want me to.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oops, here we go.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It was, he said, trash pickup at least twice a week, I believe was what Sean was saying.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I would say at least two times per week for the residential units. And then if the commercial tenant's a restaurant, I would say twice a week for a restaurant, and perhaps less for a non-restaurant use for the commercial tenant, maybe once a week. If it's a different type of use that generates less trash. You might not need two times a week for the commercial trash because that looks like it's a bigger trash room.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Agreed.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Alicia, what is the fund called? Tree fund?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: It's exactly.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, the tree planting. Okay, I see now. Yeah. What if this price changes? What is this due by? This is prior to issuance of the building permit?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, sorry. I thought I put that in the text that I messaged you.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, I haven't. I just cut and paste the one paragraph. OK.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Oh, OK. Before issuance of the building permit.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And then member begin you will. Did you have? The language in the. You could. Message me in the chat. I'm not. I'm not good at multitasking, typing and.

[Sean Beagan]: I'll send it into this meeting. OK, chat that I have here.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. I think we're almost there. That looks good Danielle. I see the text, Michonne, in the chat.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Sorry, I have to stop the chair because the interface, I can't see. OK. Can I ask a question?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, Dina.

[Dina Caloggero]: It says restaurant. Perhaps Meg put a food establishment in there. You might not sit down, right? But you could have a convenience store, sandwiches, things like that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Cafe. Yeah. Did you get that, Danielle? So not restaurant, but?

[Dina Caloggero]: Buddha establishment.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Buddha establishment. Instead, the language for that last piece on the trash. All right, so applicants, this is the new item. Applicants shall set forth in any future condominium documents that the residential trash room shall be emptied twice per week by a private trash removal service and the commercial retail space shall be emptied twice per week for any eating establishment use at least one time per week for other uses. Should applicant decide not to submit this development to the economy statute, then this trash removal requirement shall be a condition of the owner of the building.

Okay, I'm good with that. Any final comments? Otherwise, I'm going to be looking for a motion to accept the project with the following, with the conditions as noted.

[Dina Caloggero]: I make a motion to accept. I second it.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Dina. Thank you, Paige. I'll do the roll call. John Anderson? Yes. Sean Dagan? Yes. Page Buldini?

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Calagari?

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman?

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, yes, the motion passes six to nothing. Congratulations. Thank you, Mike. Thank you, your team for your effort and good luck. We're looking forward to a new piece of Main Street coming online and about this time next year.

[SPEAKER_07]: We are as well. Thank you very much.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It's been a pleasure working with you. Thank you all.

[SPEAKER_07]: Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia, I think it might take a five minute break between the next one. I think that we'll do that right now, and then we'll jump into 360 Salem Street next. Everyone has five minutes, right? Thank you all. Dina and Ari, are you ready to go?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yep.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Ari. Dina, are you there?

[Dina Caloggero]: I'm here.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, very good. All right, let's move on to the next item. This is the item 4 in our agenda, the continued public hearing site plan review for 360 Salem Street. That's SPR 2025-4. This is our 3rd public hearing for this project that was open on December 3rd, 2025, and the applicant, which is 360 Salem LLC will present any new information they have in response to city staff and board member comments from the previous meeting. I'll ask Alicia, Danielle, if you have any introductory comments before we move on to the presentation, please let me know.

You're all good, okay. So I'm gonna ask the applicant 360 Salem to present the new information. They have updated drawings, updated concepts. Please state your name and address record.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Good evening, Guy Manganiello. Hi. Guy Manganiello with Genesis Construction Development on behalf of 360 Salem Street LLC. Tonight I have with me our architect and our civil engineer. So we can go over any of the questions that the board may have. I will go ahead and share the updates for you. One moment here. Okay. Just as a quick refresher, this is a 14-unit residential, one commercial space development in the MX1 district on Salem Street. We have met all of the zoning requirements from the Court of Ordinances with the exception of the parking. And last we spoke, the building commissioner was ruling on our qualification for the high frequency transit, at which time he had deemed that we did not qualify.

Since that point, we had been working on alternative solutions to meet the parking requirements. And what we have come up with is a urban infill solution that is used quite a bit in Boston and other settings and that is stacker parking system. The requirement here for the 14 units, as a reminder, will be 1.5 parking spaces per unit. We have a total of 14 residential units, thus needing 21 spaces. It's actually a bit less, because in the 14, there are two affordables, which qualify at a 0.5, but it rounds up, so 21 parking spaces.

And what we are offering, if I may, 11 full-size spots, 10 of which will have the stacker systems, and we have a plan here identifying that. We've also located parking spaces for bicycles, and I'll show that as well. Flip over to the updated slide. Here it is. Okay, so here we're using the stacker system in spots 1 through 10. We have stacked bike racks and bike ring for bicycle parking as well. This space we had reserved as an accessible option space.

Typically, if there is a request placed to the HOA that one of the residents may need an accessible space, this would be the one that would be able to afford that option to the HOA. So this space is sized to meet that demand, but will be available as a full-size parking space.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Are you saying that that space does not serve as an accessible space unless there is a demand?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Correct, it is a standard space, and then if a space is needed, requested by one of the residents, then the HOA can make this the accessible accommodation, since it is sized appropriately for it.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, thank you.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: You're welcome. Just to give you a bit of understanding on how the units work, they are mounted into the concrete through through bolts. They are a electric system. As you see here, one unit, this lowers, one unit drives on, raises, and then another unit parks below. The system we have elected can accommodate two SUVs. So there's wide range of capability and parking. It does work in conjunction with EV chargers. So we have that option to add it on, as seen in this detail, so we can continue to meet that requirement.

For the bike parking, we have gone with a double-tier system and a post and ring system, and this is an enlargement of the bike space. So, we're able to put the 2 double tier bike rack system for 8 bikes and 1 standard post for 2 additional bikes. So, 10 bikes in total. Beyond that, we had nominated the inclusionary units. I'm not sure if we reviewed that in the last meeting. And I believe we had gone over some of the updates on the facade, so I'll save those for later if we need to review them once again. The other ask was that we complete a solar assessment. And we had that completed. So they took the data, the roof, and they looked at the capacity, leaving enough ample space to meet the requirements for the rooftop mechanicals needed.

And they gave us a range of production on the available size. All the data is listed here. They went forward into giving us some optimization outputs and then the type of system we would need. And they give us a schematic design on the available rooftop based on the optimal direction of the sun. And then leaving us ample space to place rooftop units if needed, while ensuring that they're not visible from sight lines from the sidewalks and street view.

So that is the solar design and assessment. The other ask was for a cut through of the building. We've provided that here. showing the fire ratings, the floor-to-ceiling sandwiches, and the wall separation fire ratings. And I believe we went over the update to the facade where we unlinked the columns so that it was more uniform during our last meeting. But just to recount that, and we had moved the vents to the side of the building, added the windows to the front as requested, a door out to the back, and maintained the same facade on the western exposure, again with the vents and a door out to the side.

I believe those were all the updates we had and we're looking for feedback from the board as it relates to the parking solution. So hoping to hear your thoughts there and any comments you may have on the other updates.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Guy. I appreciate it. Why don't you go first?

[Page Buldini]: Thank you so much. Thank you, Guy, again for listening to some of our feedback and of the residents. I was looking at some of the comments from our Director of Traffic and Transportation and Medford Fire. So some of the questions that I also had when it came to the system, just simply, I think you need a licensed operator to use this. This wouldn't be the residents. Would the residents be trained to load their cars and move it?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yes, they can be trained and certified to use the lifts, yes. And we- So is that- Yep, go ahead.

[Page Buldini]: I'm so sorry, is that a requirement that you will have? Because I feel like if it's 21 cars, that's potentially 21 people that will be required. Is it like a training that you need to pay for or how does that, what does that look like?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, no, great question. It's actually 10 people that will need to be able to operate Well, suppose 10 of the spaces will need registered people to be able to operate them. The manufacturer of the lifts does come in and provide training for the residents. They also provide ongoing maintenance and inspection, and that is all done through contract. So, it's not just the install lifts, you know, have a nice day. They will be there continuously inspecting and training and retraining, you know, should there be a tenant, tenant, I'm sorry, resident turnover. So, yeah, those are trained. We did develop late yesterday a very I'll call it a primitive O&M plan for the stackers and just goes through some regulation And what the model is, who's authorized maintenance and inspection, and then it has a resident acknowledgement agreement form that they must comply with. And then there'll be assignments of the spaces, both the upper and the lower space. on the stackers so that it's not just a first come, first serve, that they're dedicated spots. So, it's programmed usage.

[Page Buldini]: Now, does that change your insurance or your liability when you have cars stacked upon one another?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Not certain, but that would be done through the HOA's policy.

[Page Buldini]: Okay, and then I'm also, thank you. And looking at the sprinklers and the ceiling height, are the two SUVs on top, is there enough clearance for that? Because I know from looking at the sprinklers, that might be a problem with sprinklers on the ceiling. So it looks like it's recommended to put sprinklers on the side. Is this proposal prepared to do that?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, no, yeah, so we would be during our construction documents, we would be ensuring that the design fits and works with the stacker system in place. So, certainly, when we're going in for permitting, the engineer will have to take that into consideration. We do have the full CAD model of the stacker units. So we're able to make sure everything gets sized on the elevation from an elevation standpoint appropriately, and there is ample coverage.

[Page Buldini]: And so that wouldn't change the height of the building then, right?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Would not need to, no. The stack was specifically elected to meet this building height.

[Page Buldini]: Okay, and then with the EV cars, which that's exciting. I like that that's an option. Is that a safety thing that we have to worry about about EV cars as well being stacked?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It's a great question. Like any other parking spot, it's going to have EV cars have their. Potential risk, right? So, with a car being next to it, or above it, it's it's same same similar risk.

[Page Buldini]: Looking at the comments from fire and Todd, like, and then 1, just last simple question, and I'll give it up to the other members of the board as somebody who loves solar and went full electric in my house, we did remove significant pipes. and it did change the building, is that something that this building is looking to do, or is this just an option that you were thinking about adding solar?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Could you ask that question one more time from the beginning?

[Page Buldini]: Yep, so when you mentioned solar on top, does that change your design? Is this a building that will be fully electrified that you're looking to do full solar, or is it just an option that you're looking at?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It's an option that we're looking at right now. We haven't done the full cost analysis because we do need to complete the design of the building to know the full load calcs to see what, you know, savings that true savings that the solar could bring about. So certainly something where we're genuinely entertaining. The last few projects we've built, we've been able to be, although they were single family residences, developments that we had done, we were able to include solar in them. So it's certainly something that we entertain seriously.

[Dina Caloggero]: Okay, thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Hey, it's picking up on that. I believe a lot of this scale building are going all electric to comply with the city of Medford's stretch energy code because it's and Danielle can speak to this or maybe the, the, the environmental folk in planning can speak to it. But I think, I think to comply, you have to not necessarily the solar, but I think electric gets you there more than anything else. The solar is a great addition. I couldn't agree more. I have solar panels on my house. and have for 15 years. They're really wonderful to have no electrical bill for half the year. It's really fantastic. All right, I'm going to move on to Ari. Go ahead, Ari.

[Ari Fishman]: Fantastic. Thank you to the applicant. I am really excited to see this moving ahead. This is not really a question. I was excited about this project. I was very sad That parking was such a hurdle. I think this is a smart solution. There's obviously a lot of details, but this is just a voice of support, encouragement and excitement that this project kind of seems to have a reasonable proposal in the big picture for the biggest hurdle.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Ari. Just to echo that a little bit before I get to Dina, I think, remember, the primary opposition to this project was the parking ratio that people in the neighborhood felt it was too low. But the question, I think, that needs to be addressed is the stackers. All these units that you're proposing, I believe, are two-bedroom units, correct, Guy? Yes. Okay, so that's 14 two-bedroom units, but you have 10 stackers, right? Doesn't that just, the logistics of it, the math of it require that two units may have to share a stacker?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yes, yes, transparently it does. You know, there's going to be some, operational planning that the community is going to have to do, the residents of the building to operate this system appropriately. Certainly.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I guess I have a concern about that, because if it's a roommate or a spouse situation, that's clear. You can coordinate that easier. But when it's two people who might be on different floors or different apartments, that's just not been what I've assumed stackers work like in terms of other projects where I have worked with stackers. I just assumed it was always within a unit, not between units. Can you address that, please?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: And we certainly can make them assigned spots where they're to the unit and not all units will have parking. We've toyed with the idea of making them deeded so that they come with the unit and then just there will be some units without parking. We had in our presentation to the building commissioner with regard to when we were going for the high frequency transit qualification, we had pulled up the study on vehicular usage in the city of Mefford specifically from the last 5 year study to this most recent 5 year study. And the data was pretty surprising, where it showed that there was actually a significant reduction in people that were using vehicles, period, in the stadium effort. And then, moreover, that an even larger reduction in the amount of people that were using them to as their main means of transportation to work. So there's still 48% of your population that doesn't use a primary vehicle as a means of transportation to work, whether it be that they work from home, they don't have a vehicle at all, or they take public transportation. So, you know, we felt strongly about this project at a reduced parking rate. We're looking to build true transit-oriented housing, and we're hoping to do so with this project. Um, aren't, you know, we're amenable to to this design. And perhaps having other discussions if the board is so inclined as to other solutions, but this is what we could propose to meet that largest hurdle. But we do it's not.

We're not, we haven't lost the fact that it can be a bit hinky if not properly organized, certainly.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. I'm going to go to Dina next and then Alicia and then Sean. Go ahead, Dina.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah, this question for Danielle and Alicia first. Have there been any models in the city where the developments have used this stacking solution for parking or was this the very first one?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: To Dana through the chair, I did ask that question to deputy chief from the fire department. If he knew of any stackers that are in use in Medford, he wasn't aware of any. There was 1 that was proposed for a life science building that didn't go forward, but that was for. Yeah, that was a employment place. That was, yeah, but it would have had like a lift attendant. So this would be the first application of stackers. Um, I should add that if these were, um, an accepted, um, you know, solution to mitigating reducing parking, they still don't count as parking spots. So you would have to still grant a waiver to reduce parking. Um, This is akin to tandem parking and like a multi unit situation that you don't box a car and you have to have access to the vehicles like easy and ordinarily. I'm watching what the provision is in the parking requirements, but having to move another car or do something doesn't. means that they don't have that access, but if this was a solution that the board thought mitigated that reduction, you could, but under zoning, they would not count as individual parking spaces, the stacked one, but that could be mitigation for not providing all of the spaces. Just want to make that clear.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Thank you, Danielle. Appreciate that.

[Dina Caloggero]: Wait, wait, wait, wait. So you also mentioned that with the units, these units are going to be condos and they will be owned, but they could be owned and rented. Is that correct?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: That will be up to the HOA on how their board constructs their preferences. But on onset, we will restrict it as much as needed without precluding people's ability to finance their units, right? Because there is a percentage where then it begins to disqualify people from being able to finance their building. So that's how we've handled HOAs that we've done in the past.

[Dina Caloggero]: Okay, so if that's the case, I'm very curious to see how the implementation of the stacking would be implemented to ensure that people were trained properly And we're assessed on the competency to run the stacking units as well. For instance, from a renter, I go in, I'm trained, how do you ensure competency? This seems to open up a can of worms of liability. I'm also very skeptical and curious about how this will be passed down from one owner to the next. And the second point is, you said there was a vehicle reduction study that's like 40% of the people in Medford don't require cars. I'm very curious to see where that data was taken. and where it is from. If it's from South Medford, it would be quite interesting because I live in an area where there's college students, right? So they just walk straight, right, to the dorms and everything else. So I'm a little curious, when that was taken, the data, the study data, and where exactly that sample size of residents was pulled from. But back to the competency, assuring competency, reduce liability on the use of these stackers with multiple owners and multiple people that would be in these units.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Sure. Dean, I thank you for the comment and I shared your thoughts there when we were exploring the solution. It certainly is not as common outside of major metropolises like Boston. So, definitely a nuance here for not only you, but us as well. So, we didn't take that lightly when we were exploring the option. The vendor has assured us that they will properly train and certify the residents who are going to be the operators of these stackers. So, they'll be going through a training program with them. and certifying and then they have to sign a disclosure that they've been trained and then they're responsible. So, it's an added layer for sure. Addressing your comment about the data, it's actually pulled from the ACS report. The U.S. does the census and the last one they had done in 2018 for Medford and the data is right here on the screen.

And I actually pulled some of this information from your 2022 housing production plan that you submitted to the state. But in any case, I then went to the US census and pull the data myself to verify. So. Yeah, in 2018, 68% of the residents of Medford commuted to work with a personal vehicle, 59% alone, 9% carpooling. And then the rest through commuting other means or work from home. And then 5 years later, when they did the update, shifted to 55%, 49% alone, 6% carpooling, and the rest through transit commuting, other means, or working from home. So 40, and I misspoke earlier, it's 44.5%, so it's a 12.5% decline over a five-year period. So there is a trend in, you know, specifically in the City of Medford and other surrounding cities close to Boston, where people are focused on transit-orientated housing and and not the necessity of having to have a car. I know it's not maybe what everybody wants to hear. It doesn't meet the narrative that people, you know, have to believe in, but it's true. Data doesn't lie. The numbers are the numbers of the numbers. So that is, those are the statistics right from the U.S. Census Bureau poll for specifically the city of Medford.

Now, all that aside, we understand the board has to Grant the mitigation, not grant the mitigation or have a discussion with us on some other type of solution. We're also not opposed at looking at the scale of the building and we've begun toying with. other configurations that would also allow for a reduced unit count and thus less burden on parking. I'm not sure if the board is amenable to openly discussing that. I saw the previous project had a one-to-one parking ratio, something of that nature. We may be able to accommodate with the scale down project and eliminate the need for the stackers altogether.

If the board's so inclined, I do have some very preliminary layouts of what that would look like, but I'll leave it to you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Guy. I appreciate it. I'm going to go next to Alicia, because you've had your hand up for a while, and then I'll move to Sean. Alicia.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I actually wanted to get a clarification on the stackers and how they worked. and then actually share something that I've been, I've actually been actively observing how apartment buildings and parking work in my recent travels in Jersey City and Seattle, because I was, so first of all, I wanted, well, let me actually share that first, and then let's, let me ask my question so he can answer the question directly. Both the friend that I happened to stay with in her condo in an apartment building in Jersey City was showing me that when she bought her condo in the condo key bag, that she got was also a car key. And she said, what is this? They said, well, that's the person who parks their car. such that you can't get your car in and out of your spot without moving their car. And their car key comes with your condo so you can move their key. And I was stunned. And I actually used, they actually moved some cars and I parked in their garage. And there were several spots throughout the lot where that was the case. And I was stunned. And then two weeks later, I visited my sister in Seattle. And she also had to move someone's car in order to get her car in and out of her apartment building parking spots. The fact that both of them were people who had to move cars was stunning to me. It said to me that this is the trend where things are going. And I felt that I should share that because while it is not what we see in Medford and have ever seen in Medford or have allowed, I feel like this is the trend where the buildings are going. That said, I didn't understand something. With these stackers, does the bottom car have to move out of the way and then the upper car is lowered straight down? Or does it come out at an angle and lower it into the aisle? So do you have to move the lower car to get the upper car up and down?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes, you do.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Okay.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I've seen them in action. I worked on a few buildings that had stackers. You have to pull the car out, drop it, pull it out, and then go back in. It's not like the bike. The bikes can come off, but not the cars.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And if this was one spot per unit, then that would mean people in other units would have to be moving each other's cars. That would be a requirement for that to work.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I believe that's accurate. All right. Sean, why don't you go next?

[Sean Beagan]: OK. To the applicant, I appreciate your thoughtfulness on this. And I can imagine that the stackers are a pretty sizable investment. How much do they cost per unit?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It's close to a $300,000 investment for the stackers in totality.

[Unidentified]: Recording in progress.

[Sean Beagan]: The building commissioner had issued an opinion. Have you seen his? Did you read his opinion?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: I did, and he also, I don't know, I'm not sure if they shared your email, but he also commented that he would be amenable to the stackers. So, as if there was a An operation for the building, so that the residents weren't complaining to him. So, I appreciated that comment from him. I know that's not as.

[Sean Beagan]: He said that, in his opinion, he said that 1 of the spaces that was shown on your plan blocks the rear elevator exit. Yes, half of the elevator is that spot still in this plan? Or has it been Sean?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: So he left. So this right here is what he was talking about. See this, this, this is just their standard cut for an elevator with an exit on either side. I believe I had asked them to find a way to remove that one second. I'll see if I can bring that up. We had closed that out.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Here, you know, that's not that's not an opening. Sean. That's just a graphic error.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It's just a graphic error. There is no opening there. They only exit from the lobby and and his comment to me was that he can only comment on what he sees and that's fair. So, I let him know that we would update the drawing, but we were certainly not having people exit directly into a car.

[Sean Beagan]: Okay, so we don't have to worry about that issue. Correct. Yeah. Okay. Fair enough. And. You said you were looking at some other designs that might have less units and bring down the needed parking spaces. Have you looked at, you have 14 units right now. Have you considered, is there any plan under which you could have 14, whether they be inside or outside, 14 parking spaces?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: So great question. And there is a solution for that, but it would require us impeding upon the open space and then asking for relief there. So we had toyed with an idea originally, if you can see my highlighted area here, of opening this section of the garage and the back wall. We actually have another building where we did something similar to this, which would then allow parking in this area here. It would remain permeable. But it would take away from the open space requirement, which we're in excess of today, but certainly would not be in excess of and we could fit for additional parking spots back here. So it was a thought that would bring us to 15.

So it's certainly a solution. And with the board's feedback, we can make further alterations, but that would be the trade-off.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, sure. Honestly, me for one, I kind of don't want you to lose units personally.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Appreciate that.

[Sean Beagan]: I think the housing is, and these are going to be condos again. Yes. Okay, yeah. Okay, thank you for that input, Guy. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Guy, before I move on to a few more questions, you mentioned you had some initial concepts, sketches that showed fewer units, I assume either less of a floor before removed or a partial floor. Could you show that on screen? Because I think one of the, if there were two major issues on this project that have been a big focus of discussion, one was the parking, which I think You've addressed to a degree, but there are options there. But the shadows on the adjacent property, the direct abutters next door, I think was the other, what I call major issue. And I think maybe there's a kind of compromise in here that's maybe a little less units or a setback on a floor or something that would kind of ease both.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yeah, we looked at the shadow stuff. Unfortunately, there's really no way without not building a building to. Stop the shadowing and it's slight and it's only at 2 hours in the morning based on the study, right? That we had provided, but and I can pull, let's, let's do that right now. So that we're all on the same page here. But you can see that the shadow only occurs at the 8am during the summer solstice and then shadows on it. And even if we reduce down to 2 floors above the parking, instead of the 3, you're still going to incur that shadow effect.

because their comment was, and I have my notes specifically about their backyard being in the shadow, right? So with the proximity of their yard so close to the building itself, it's very tough to eliminate that or any loss of light into those windows. And again, happens at the 8 a.m. hour. By noon, there is no shadow, and then it ameliorates as the day progresses. But here's the other concept. So, it's a reduction from 14 units to 9 units. In doing so, we're able to increase the square footage of the commercial space a bit, maintain the 11 parking spots, We did shift the stairwell design from this section to the right side, the east side of the building, moved the bike access to the back end of the building, and that's still in play. We have other thoughts where it can go here and other places. We haven't fully flushed it over here.

Let me just zoom in a bit for you here. The units. remain two-bedroom, two-bathroom. But what we were able to do was afford them a larger footprint. So the units are, we'll say, much, they have a better flow. And one of the comments early on was a dining space. So we ensured that in the redesign, hey, let's see if we can afford them that. And we did. So all the units have a dining space now. we were able to give an office space to three of the units on the southern exposure of the building. That was nice. Then we were able to add a half bathroom in all of the units as well, so they become two-and-a-half bath versus a two bath.

We were also able to increase the deck space for the units. All in all, and then this floor plate here replicates as we go up. to the 3rd floor and then again to the 4th floor. They do, however, step in a bit on that 4th floor. As you can see here, the units do shrink in size a bit to allow that 45 degree step back from the 3rd floor plate to the 4th floor plate.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I appreciate this guy this is really it to me this is really interesting because one of the things I saw about your floor plan is that you had a lot of two bedroom units they were quite small, but they were under 900 square feet for two bedrooms right so these larger there might be fewer units but I suspect. that they're gonna go for a hell of a lot more dollars because they are so much more generous, both the living and the bathroom. And I think, I'm not gonna, you're the business guy, it's your money, your investment, but I feel like there's a lot of merit in this scheme. And I think it's worth pursuing, but I wanna hear from the other folks on the board. And I'm gonna start with, I guess I'll do Danielle and then Ari right after. Go ahead, Danielle.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Oh, I just wanted to add when there was discussion about adding parking in the in the rear behind the building, they would not be eligible for a 4th story. It's the maximum height in this sub district is 3 stories. They are eligible for a 4th bonus story because of the parking is totally enclosed. That's in the sales record district. So, if they put parking in the rear. They don't get a 4th story, but you don't need then you wouldn't need the parking in the rear because the parking in the rear is to accommodate the units from the 4 stories. The other option to. I believe there's a few other options and that's with deeper or more affordability, but I just wanted to. State that that the height, the height limit in the sub district is 3 stories unless you get the density bonus.

Personally, I think 3 stories is more palatable. I would like to see a shadow study that shows a difference between the 3 and the 4 stories, not just summer solstice, but other times of the year to see if that would make a meaningful impact or difference. There has to be some tolerance for shadows in the city. You know, this isn't a rural area. We have multiple acre lots, but if it's ever. If there's ever a way to mitigate that, I think it behooves us to try.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Thank you. If I, if I could just 1 moment to thank you and agreed that that was the other reason why we hadn't pursued the parking on the rear end of it, knowing that that was our means of getting the additional story. This is the only other. We. We did a full study on this and play with every model we possibly could have. And the only 2 that work from our standpoint to develop this is either this 14 unit plan or the 9 unit plan. Any less units from that the project's not feasible. and any further reduction. And then from the 14-unit plan with the two affordables included in there, any reduction from there, including the two affordables, then deems the project not feasible. So from our standpoint, in both instances, the building remains a four-story building with parking on the first floor.

Certainly, um, you know, lowering the density has has some. Um, perceived benefits where it's, you know, let's use some resources and not and then has an ample amount of parking, um, in our opinion, and then, you know. based on the board's treatment of other projects, it looks like it would be amenable on a one-to-one or in this case, it'd be greater than one-to-one parking. We would certainly pursue the nine unit further with additional comments from the board if they were so inclined to like that one. I can prepare a full presentation on that one.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, thank you, Guy. I want to go to Ari and then Paige next. Go ahead, Ari.

[Ari Fishman]: Thank you. I would be very disappointed to see this project lose units and affordable units due to this parking issue. I know that it was determined not to be high density with the bus. I believe, although someone correct me if this is not true, you could go to ZBA for approval over that. I think that the density is exactly what we need and I'm in support of kind of working together to find a solution that is palatable to everyone. I think losing that fourth story would, I agree, make this much less feasible.

I have no opposition to a one-to-one ratio, if that makes any difference. And in terms of social patterns, the fact that this is going to be condo, this is going to attract people who know that they won't be using their car every day that this isn't a rotating cast of characters. We're a one-car family. We share a driveway with two of our neighbors in a condo. We bought this place knowing our patterns and that was part of the decision. I think we don't have to be imagining every resident of Medford. The question is, is this housing that can work for some people? The answer is, Absolutely, in my mind, yes. Obviously, there are details we need to work through. This is very early sketches. But there are more than 14 people and many, many more, especially on the affordable units, who would be very happy to work within these constraints.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Great points. Go ahead, Paige. You're next.

[Page Buldini]: Super quick. Two points. Did I miss the accessible parking? Is there specified accessible parking in the parking lot?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Yes, so we had identified that spot 11 would remain the accessible spot.

[Page Buldini]: Okay, is that a stacker too considered or is that?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: No, it wouldn't be a stacker.

[Page Buldini]: Okay, and then with, thank you so much. And then with the nine units, what does that look like for the affordable unit? Is it one?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: There wouldn't be any at that point. We would lose them. Yeah, the, the other issue and we hadn't got into it, but you guys asked the question on the 14 year design, the stackers it. Pretty thin on the project, whether or not it ends up making sense to build them with it. So we're still we're still exploring that, but it took a little bit to get a solution there to find a stacker company that made a product that was usable by a resident because a lot of them to previous points that. Doug had made, they are typically manned by an attendant. It's not ordinary to have residents manning their own stackers, so operating them. So we would...

There's still more to do there. I think from a feasibility standpoint, that being said, if we had to pick one or the other, right now we know the nine has less nuance and would certainly work. So we do have a bit more work to do on that one, but we were eager to get your feedback on the stacker solution to see if it was worth pursuing. So that was, it was important for us to have your feedback.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Sean, and then we'll do John after that. Go ahead, Sean.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I just wanted to echo, I think, what Ari had said. I think if he goes down, if the applicant goes down to nine units, does that take him out of meeting any affordable units, right? I think 10 is the threshold. So now he would have no affordable, not need any affordable units in the nine unit.

[SPEAKER_17]: Daniel, can you listen to that quickly?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, it's 10 units, which triggers the requirement for affordable units. And you round up, so even at 11 units, it triggers needing two. So that cliff is at nine. We are currently working on a fractional payment ordinance to encourage production of units. Without that disincentive to have more years, because of. It's the numbers don't work with the rounding up and that's why you see, you don't see 10 unit projects because why would you build 10? if you lose money on the 10th, you build 9.

Without without some kind of public subsidy, that's just they don't pencil out. but I don't know if that will be ready in time for this. But I also want to point out that the two designated affordable units happen to be the smallest and they're not going to be allowed to do that either. So I don't know if the applicant has also considered that when crunching out their numbers of which ones that they're choosing to designate as affordable because they have to be comparable you know, evenly distributed, they can't pick the two smallest ones, least desirable ones. So that is also going to be squeezing their numbers.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Danielle. John Anderson.

[John Anderson]: Thank you. I just wanted to comment a little bit more on the stackers. And I respect the comments of people who have lived in situations or know of people who live in situations where you have to jog the cars around, tandem parking situations. It seems to me, though, as people pointed out, the stackers are sort of another kettle of fish. And assuming that if there's one stacker per unit, which would sort of solve the jogging around problems because at least it would be a roommate or a spouse.

Then you would have 10 units that had two spots, thanks to the stacker, one unit with one spot, and three units with no parking. And if we applied our usual rule, they would not be allowed to apply for resident parking on the street. That being the case, I think the stackers no longer make sense because I can't imagine they're going to be many people who want to buy one of these condos and have two cars. I mean, that seems like that would eliminate a lot fewer potential buyers than the fact that there are three units with no parking at all.

So it seems to me the stackers, it's a clever solution, but I don't see it really solving the problem here. I would personally prefer to allow, to let the stackers go if the developers are happy with the idea that three units would have no parking at all available. if they don't feel that affects the saleability of the property. About the study that was referenced, it was 55% commute to work and 45% use public transportation or work from home. The real statistic here though, is how many people have a car? Because you can commute to work, but still find the need for a car. For example, going shopping, taking your kids to school, doing things like that. So I'd want to see some more data before we assume that 45% of the people, just because they're working from home, are willing to not have a car. Medford's a very great location if you have a car. If you depend on public transportation, particularly buses, it's not so great.

I commuted to Kendall Square by bus and subway 20 years ago. And since then, it's actually, there are fewer buses now than there were when I was doing it 20 years ago. It's kind of moving in the wrong direction. Anyway, that's kind of my point on the stackers.

[Chair Doug Carr]: John, can I ask if you have a preference between the 14-unit scheme and the alternate nine-unit scheme? Because I think I want to kind of get a sense of that from the board just in general. I think that's what Guy's looking for as well.

[John Anderson]: Yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, the nine-unit thing solves one problem. It also probably mitigates if it's one less story, right? Is that correct?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: No, the story's not.

[John Anderson]: Okay, doesn't change that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: They're just, they're bigger units, right?

[John Anderson]: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know. I'd like to hear from the neighbors too, what they think.

[Chair Doug Carr]: We haven't gotten to the public comments.

[John Anderson]: I know. Okay.

[Chair Doug Carr]: There's a lot to unpack here. All right. Anything else, John? Nope. Okay. I'm going to go to Dina.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yep, so I was trying to step back a little bit just so I can understand this. So it can't go to 11 units, right? Because that would still be four store. Why can't it be 11 units and scale it back and make the parking ratio one spot per unit?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It just no longer works from an economic standpoint.

[Dina Caloggero]: But nine does?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Nine does.

[Dina Caloggero]: Because?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: There's a significant loss on the affordable units.

[Dina Caloggero]: But if you had 11 units, then it would need to have two affordable, is that correct?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Correct. So at nine, we're essentially just adding two units at a loss.

[Dina Caloggero]: Because they're affordable.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Correct.

[Dina Caloggero]: Right. So because they were affordable, we can't go 11. We have to go nine. Yeah.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: The other three units at 14 allow us to offset those two.

[Dina Caloggero]: So it's a cost.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: It's a cost.

[Dina Caloggero]: Thank you.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: You're welcome.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All right. I think I want to open it up to public comments. I do want to come back to folks here, the board before, because obviously I want people to think about the two options. They are different. There's pluses and minus for both of them, obviously. And I think there'll be a variety of opinions about the board when I've heard so far. But I'm going to now switch gears and open up to public comments. Those I'll just get my usual boilerplate. Those who wish to provide comments, please use the raise hand feature, which may be under reactions in your zoom. Or if you're dialed in on a phone, you can use a star 9 to raise your hand. You can message Alicia in the chat. If you're having technical difficulties before providing comments, please state your name and address for the record a reminder to all meeting participants. Please refrain from using the chat function to message any comments. To city staff or board members that is, is not part of the public record. However, if a participant is having audio or technical difficulties, you may message staff for assistance. Each participant will have. 2 minutes to speak, and I'll start with Zachary. Sure, talk as our top 5 on street.

[Zachary Chertok]: So, I, I'm in the building and I actually manage the agent for the building right next door. The concern, first of all, in the shadow study is definitely around our first floor units. Our units are stacked one, two. The first floor units are overhung by their balconies. We are not changing the facade of our building because it would be structural. Right now, what impedes any potential of a shadow height, civil engineer by training, I actually started looking at the numbers and the different angles across the last few weeks as we're doing from the summer when we were looking just at the zoning. Is that we have a driveways with between the current building and our and our building that any added height would still allow for sunlight to directly reach those units on the 1st floor going up this high in this close to the property line doesn't it will completely put those 1st floor units in the dark. It's not about shade over the building. It's about shade to those 1st floor units. Right now in the current setup, if you were to put that driveway width back, extend the building further to the back, you would still maintain the lot coverage ratio, which would allow for all the incentives and the unit number and the height, while allowing us that sunlight gap and reconfiguring a garage entrance on the side of the building and actually extending the building to allow a better, more feasible configuration for parking underneath the building. I don't really know why that hasn't been explored.

Along those lines, I think the board has asked everything that I would have asked about the parking. There are CML licensure regulations in Massachusetts for those hydraulic lifts that are state level that can't be ignored, which is why, while we like to see them in New Jersey and Washington, operators in Massachusetts are subject to different regulations for them. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thanks, Zach, appreciate it. I'm going to go to Nicholas Ulig. Can you please state your name and address for the record?

[Nick Uhlig]: Yeah, it's pretty close on the last name. It's Ulig. Nicholas Ulig, 62 Tainter Street. So I'm struggling to put my thoughts into words. I had a prepared statement. But I just want to say that it's quite disappointing to see that we're seriously considering lowering the amount of housing and lowering, well, losing all of the affordable housing in this development over the sake, just for the sake of parking, places to put cars. Now, I have a car. I'm not against cars in all places, but site needs differ. You know, at a previous meeting, there were two comments that stuck in my memory. One was from Member Bagan, who pointed out that despite Medford Square being zoned for higher density, dimensional requirements and parking requirements have played a role in hindering that in Medford Square, which is why it is the way it is and why it's being redeveloped now. And Member Calagaro pointed out the the needs for parking at the senior center because of the nature of the services that it provides and the population that lives there. It has different needs. But this site is not that. Okay. As Member Anderson pointed out earlier in this meeting, the apartments in the 14-unit proposal are quite small. It's kind of, I wouldn't expect, as he didn't, that most of those people would have more than one car per household. And that we are seriously considering a $300,000 investment into machines that have, as Mr. Chertok pointed out a moment ago, like state licensure requirements, ongoing maintenance, and stuff like that, just so that we can have what is, in my opinion, a surfeit of parking, 1.5 spots per unit. That just doesn't sit right with me. And the other alternative is losing more space for people to live in. So this really does show that free parking is extremely expensive. We're being asked to sacrifice affordability. We're being asked to sacrifice commercial space already, even with only the 11 parking spots proposed. There's only one store. We're losing two commercial businesses, and we only have one. Okay, my time's up. I'm sorry, I had more to say. But I really hope that the board will decide to potentially grant a lower amount of parking than 1.5, even if they can't do the 0.8, Because losing out on housing, and especially the affordable housing, would be a tragedy for this development.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. I appreciate it. All right, I'm going to go to Jeremy Martin next. Go ahead, Jeremy.

[Jeremy Martin]: Oh, wow, I thought I had a few people ahead of me. Sorry, I must have gotten in the right order. That's all right. But Jeremy Martin, 65 Burgett Avenue. Thanks for hearing me again. I want to echo some of what Nick just said about how we perceive and how we think about preserving or creating housing at the expense of parking or vice versa. And I think it's really important that we make sure that we are prioritizing housing and affordability over cars which have been long prioritized to an extreme in our community.

I think that this is a great opportunity to introduce density along a very busy and very diverse corridor. I also understand the concerns of neighbors about shadows, and if there are ways that that could be mitigated, I hope the board will encourage and work with the applicant to do that. And then lastly, I've looked through the site plans that were available. There is a beautiful street tree out in front of this existing building and I have seen no plan that indicates whether that tree will be preserved or removed or a plan for replacement. And so again, ask the board to really make that a strong consideration that if that tree is going to be impacted, that it be replaced at the required rates. Thank you very much.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Jeremy. Appreciate it. Cheryl, I'll go to you next. Apologies for taking you out of order. Please state your name and address for the record, Cheryl.

[Cheryl Rodriguez]: Hi, Cheryl Rodriguez, 281 Park Street. This parking, stacking parking solution is not a solution, it's dangerous. Having people moving other people's cars and not certifying everyone is an accident waiting to happen. To deliberately have units with no parking is also an issue. Is the garage even large enough to shuffle cars around on these lifts? Even the developer said it's not ordinary to have residents managing stackers and we should not be guinea pigs here. This is a predatory project. We currently have one car registered in Medford for 87% of our adult residents and thousands more cars that are parked here and not registered here. So we are far closer to one car per adult in the city and nowhere near 40% of residents not owning a car. This is a fake statistic. The first project permitted should not so flippantly cast the neighbor into shadow for the entire morning. The building should be made smaller to not have such detrimental impact on their neighbor. This developer is very dismissive of the neighbors and how he is negatively impacting him. His building is overly large and should be made smaller. He's not entitled to 14 units on this tiny lot. The trash room is very small for a building of this size. You can tell he's just trying to squeeze it in to milk every dollar out of this project. And opening the garage removes the allowance for the fourth story. As Danielle said, we don't need someone who is not concerned with our community and only cutting every corner he can find to build here. What other cost-cutting measures will he implement to drive his profit margin? This is not the type of person that we want to create the first project on the Salem Street Corridor. He's exactly the type of developer that we feared this zoning would bring, and here he is. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Cheryl. I'm going to go to Ralph Klein. Please state your name and address for the record, Ralph.

[Ralph Klein]: Ralph Klein, 172 Park Street, Medford. This project here, they're pushing this. Way too hard, way too big. The person in South Medford on Main Street had a nice plan, looked at everything. This person is not looking at the impact on the city. Try to push it to 14 units, no. The nine units, yeah, we need affordable. But there's 1,500 units going up in Medford with 200 units per building. Whatever percentage, I'm not sure of the percentage in those buildings, but those are gonna be affordable. Losing two affordable units isn't a major crisis. Parking, if anybody's been out driving around the city with the snow, parking, people saving spaces, it's ridiculous. I have, where they put in the sink building, they proposed that rotating parking and it dropped that. The person who said, oh yeah, I went down there and looked, all the spaces are filled at night. I live right around the corner. So saying, oh, they aren't filled, time of day determines when you use it, when you take a survey. And again, with the solar, people need solar, they need their light. I have solar on my home, but you have to have a certain percentage of light during the day to have solar put on your home to make it even feasible. They're looking at putting solar on their building, but they're taking away the other people's sunlight. So what is up with that? What gives you the right to take somebody else's sunlight and happiness?

And all this stuff about cars decreasing? Yeah, the survey was conducted over a period when people were working from home. Now they're starting to make people go back to work. Let's stop the smoke and mirrors. The South Medford site did something right. 300 Salem Street is doing it right. He has full parking, he has nine units, has enough parking. The other thing Medford has to do is, if you're going from one unit to nine as they did on Hadley Place, change your rules for making it affordable. If you go from one to nine, you have to make one affordable. I'll come up with a figure for that.

Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Mr. Kline. I appreciate it. I'm going to go to Caitlin next. Please give your name and address for the record.

[Kaitlin Robinson]: Hi, Caitlin Robinson, 31 Everett Street. Like the previous speaker said, stacked parking had been proposed for the 240 Sink Building 10 to 11 years ago. It was not allowed to go forward, and instead the number of units was dramatically reduced and the amount of parking increased. As I've mentioned before, there is an excess of parking there day and night. I can see it from my house. I find this whole thing absurd, that in a housing crisis, we continue to use parking to obstruct housing. I don't believe that the government should be mandating transportation. I think most people would agree that it would be government overreach if we required everyone to maintain a monthly bus pass. We might say, oh, well, you don't have to actually use the bus, you just need to pay for a pass each month. Because if you don't do that, then it might mean that a bus line might be lost for future residents who may need the bus. I don't think most residents would find it an acceptable reason to be forced to bear this cost. Mandated parking minimums is forcing people to shoulder a cost even when they don't use it. Why is that acceptable and why can't we allow people to make their own choice about their transportation and parking needs? I'm also concerned about reducing the number of units but making them more expensive. We have a housing crisis, we have an affordability crisis. Why do we want fewer more expensive units with an excess of bathrooms and parking? Finally, with the Main Street project, Danielle said that if a project doesn't provide the 1.5 spaces, then the city doesn't want them to be eligible for a street parking permit. Does this mean that if 1.5 spaces per unit are provided, then street parking permits are permitted? What is the sense of that? We require parking minimums. We say that people who don't have cars can't make decisions about their own needs and must have parking, but we don't require people who do have cars to actually use their off-street parking. With the recent snow emergency, I found that parking in my neighborhood was much more efficiently used. People who have off-street parking actually used it, even if it might be more slightly inconvenient to them. Please do not continue to obstruct housing in favor of parking. And just to be clear, not requiring parking minimums is not the same thing as banning parking. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Caitlin. Appreciate that. Let me go to Jane Marcus next, please. Your name and address for the record.

[Jane Marcus]: Hi, I'm Jane Marcus. I'm at 65 Tainter Street, and I am very concerned that we get the parking right for this first project on Salem Street Corridor. I live on Tainter Street, and I walk all around the neighborhood, and on a street like Everett, I see cars in every driveway. I mean, every driveway has a car. There isn't a driveway that has no cars. So let's just face it. Here in Medford, people have cars. They have them on Everett Street. They have them on Tinter Street. And there's nowhere to park during this snow emergency. It's crazy. I've seen battles taking place because people have space savers. It's totally insane. There's not enough parking now. Surely there won't be enough parking if you reduce parking minimums for all these new projects coming on Salem Street. So get it right, because now sets the tone for the entire Salem Street corridor and the entire city of Medford. And if you get it wrong, then we're all going to be in a huge mess. It's wishful thinking to say people don't have cars. Well, they do. They have them in every driveway. So let's not pretend that people don't have cars and have a wishful thinking scenario. I earned my living as an engineer, and I saw when a project is envisioned without any realism, then the project will fail. So have some realism for this project. Understand what we're dealing with here, that people work in places like Burlington, and surrounding areas where there is no public transportation, they need cars. That's just the reality. Let's plan for it realistically. Even if they may not need two cars per household, they certainly need at least one. And it's best to just have the normal Medford parking requirements established for this project. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Jane. Appreciate it. Rebecca, your name and address for the record, please.

[Rebecca Davidson]: Yes. Thank you. Can you hear me OK?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes, we can. Go ahead.

[Rebecca Davidson]: Hi, yes. Rebecca Davidson, 26 Farragut Ave, Medford. I live very close to where this would be built. And I just want to say that I agree with folks who have spoken earlier about the need to maximize housing and prioritize commercial as well. Prior to living in my current home, I owned a condo a couple blocks away. That condo did not come with a parking spot. I did own a car. I do own a car. I had no trouble finding parking in the years that I lived there. I really feel that when we were in this housing crisis, we really needed to prioritize and maximize the number of units that we're building and not use parking minimums as a way to limit the number of units that come into our community. The only reason I think I was even able to get into my condo is probably because there wasn't a parking spot available. That made my condo at a price point that was affordable to me. I really feel strongly that we should not limit the ability for people to be able to purchase or rent or live in this community based on a perceived need that they have that is an assumption of ours. I think that we should be prioritizing building units. and prioritizing building a community that we want to see that is walkable, livable, and that is thinking about the resilience of our community in the face of climate change as well. And that's going to mean that we reduce our dependence on cars and in fact invest in public transportation. Um, and other methods of, of, uh, transportation. So just want to echo what others have said, um, that I don't think we need to be prioritizing parking. I think there is enough parking in the community as is, um, and that it definitely should not be an obstacle to building more units. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Rebecca. Appreciate it. I'm going to go next to, uh, Chris, could please say your name and address for the record, Chris.

[SPEAKER_00]: Hi, thanks so much. My name is Kristen. I'm at all month street and there is no one closer to this development than myself. I am on the 1st floor, probably about 6 feet away from the property line. I have sunlight from. 6 a.m. to about 1 p.m., so to say it impacts just a few hours is absolutely incorrect in the summer, maybe even 5 a.m. I'm excited about changing the neighborhood. I'm able to walk to work, but unfortunately in weather like this with the shoveling and the plowing, Um, even though I'm within walking distance, it wasn't a safe option. So I'm ending up having to use my vehicle and now I'm just stuck on Salem Street. And so although I know, um, parking is, you know, something to consider traffic, um, and to continue to think about the neighborhood, I felt that earlier the development board, when we were hearing about Main Street, I thought that that was, um, just a really great presentation and felt like that organization really cared about the neighborhood and I'm just really not feeling that way about this particular developer. So thank you for doing your job and asking all the great questions and I look forward to seeing what happens. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Chris. Appreciate it. I want to Seeing no one else, I want to close the public hearing and go back to the board and get a sense of what the direction the board members want to pursue. There's two very different approaches here on the table. There's the design that we've had since the beginning, which is the 14 units now with stackers to address the issue. The other alternative on the table for the proponent is a much smaller 9-unit in terms of units, but it's still roughly the same massing. no stackers, but it does not change the shadow or the impact on the adjacent property, which doesn't sound like it's on the table for either scheme. So I want to get a sense. There's obviously compromises here about parking, density, affordable number of units, total number of units, total affordable units. There's a lot of factors on here. So I want to understand the sense of the board, right? First of all, do you want to pursue this ninth unit option or stick with the version we have now and maybe see if we can carve it back or make some other changes? So I'll start with you, Sean, and tell me where you are.

[Sean Beagan]: If the choice is between the nine unit and the 14 unit, I would definitely be more in favor of the 14 unit. I don't think the nine unit does nothing to address the abutter's concerns about the shadow study. And we lose any benefit of additional affordable housing units. And it's only two affordable housing units, but it's two condominium affordable housing units. And I think Some of the commenters tonight have mentioned the project that's been approved on Main Street that came before this project. That project, I don't believe, has any affordable units, because it's an eight-unit project. Yes. It also did get relief for parking. That project did not meet the Medford parking requirements of one and a half per unit they went they didn't come to our board but they went to the zba and got relief to have one spot per unit so it's not um that that project was perfect and this one is riddled with issues i think we definitely have a parking issue on salem street and in those neighborhoods but i Me personally, I think we could work with the applicant's proposal of some combination of traditional spots and stackers to have enough parking in that building that I'd be satisfied. And that essentially, it's going to come down to a business choice for the applicant as to whether that was a wise choice or not.

depending on people's appetites, because it sounds like some units will not have parking, realistically.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, but you're saying that you're comfortable with the total parking, even if the configuration is not correct, when you're saying 14 plus stackers is generally where you're staying.

[Sean Beagan]: I'm comfortable with the combination of, you know, floor level parking and the stackers that he has, which I think is 20, I think he's showing us 21, I'm not going to call them parking spaces. I'm going to say 21 spots to put a car. When I did the calculation previously, I was coming up with 19, but maybe it is 21. It's 21.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It's 10 stackers plus the accessible spot. That's 21.

[Sean Beagan]: I thought he could get less spots because of the affordable units, but maybe that's not how it calculates.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But in any event, that's where I am right now. I'm going to ask the same question to you, Paige. You're next.

[Page Buldini]: Thank you. I just have a question. I think maybe Zach Chertok, somebody had mentioned, is it possible to move the building back, or is it designed that way because of setbacks? I don't know if that was even an option, because I also echo what Sean just said. I don't love the idea of anybody being in shade, but I also don't love the idea of using affordable housing in those units, or any units for that matter. Is that even possible? I don't know.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think Paige, if I remember correctly, there's this, remember they had to set back the top floor of the building because of the relief. If they push the building back, I don't think that works anymore. If that top floor, the back unit would be carved away, not on the side you want it, which is the side of the abutters, but in the back. So I don't think that actually gets you much is my sense of it. But I don't know if Danielle or Alicia, if you have any thoughts on that. I don't know if, go ahead, Danielle, you've raised your hand. Did you have any comment on that?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Um, yeah, so they're, they're, they're putting in that back that rear step back because that's a requirement in the ordinance, I think, because it abuts, um. You know, a property with fewer than 5 units or something, but I don't even, I feel like in practice, that doesn't even make any sense because the way that the shadows fall, it's really the condos next door, despite being multiple. Dwellings and doesn't get that protection because it's a larger number of units. I feel like that things should be pulled back from them. Maybe not the rear and this board is empowered to, to waive some of those development standards and say, in this situation, maybe the step back.

Should be on the left. I don't know. Maybe it's. So there's some balance. Maybe it's balconies or something, so it doesn't look weird. I don't know. I mean, I feel like the architect could maybe figure out how to make it look better. But I feel like this isn't a binary choice between these two. I feel like there's something in between. And just a little bit more creative to give some breathing room. to the abutters.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So you're saying the setback that they have on the top floor could be on the left side, which would cut, which would still give the same amount of real estate, potentially rent, you know, a total gross square feet of the building. And we would grant that relief because of the site condition, right? Because we want to see something that's a little, a little less impactful on the abutters directly adjacent. That's what you're saying, right?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, because I mean the when you the zoning was written in a way saying that this step back in the rear was important. If you have this bonus story, because it's adjacent to it looks like it's a single family dwelling back there. Yeah, but. The way that the lots are configured, that's like the rear yard. And I think from the solar study, that's not actually where the shade is going to be cast. So I don't really see the benefit back there. And that just shows you when you write zoning, you really don't know how it's going to work until it's tested on each lot. And then some things just don't make sense. Like, I don't think that fourth floor rear step back makes sense at this lot. This building really wants it on the left side.

I mean, maybe there could be a choice. Maybe that could help, but I don't think this is not a binary choice for story 9 unit for story 14 units. No, I disagree with that. I think that there's some solution. if we just sharpen our pencils and look at this a little bit closer.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I like the compromise approach, but right now, I guess I'm still looking, Paige, if you could say, in terms of what you value, knowing that there isn't a compromise potentially in between these that is probably not 9 or 14, but maybe it's 14 with a change. Do you have a preference about direction, Paige?

[Page Buldini]: Yeah, I mean, I think that is something that I didn't realize. So Danielle, thank you for clarifying that. But I do like more units with more affordability. I think that's important. And I think being mindful about the parking, obviously, those are the two things that keep coming up, even the last meeting we had. So getting creative with the parking, I think, is also important. But yeah, I echo what Sean said.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK, thank you, Paige. I'm going to go to Ari next. Go ahead, Ari.

[Ari Fishman]: Thank you. I strongly feel that we should not be losing spots and all of the affordable housing to the sake of parking. I think that there, as I said, we're not. built and the developers not building for everyone in Medford. The question is, are there people who would be happy to buy a house with either one spot or no spots? Those people exist. There's many of them who need housing. I also want to echo what Danielle said with room for creativity. I think that moving the setbacks, they also mentioned that restrictions on open space were limiting some of their design.

I kind of, this is me speaking directly to the applicant. Let's be creative. I take the shadow of the condos very seriously. I think that is a significant detriment to their quality of life. That is something that kind of we need to solve. I think we can solve that and kind of look at all the restrictions and play around with them. And kind of my values here are let's make a financially viable project with units of housing, there needs to be some parking, there does not need to be huge amounts of parking, and it does need to not negatively create major issues to the immediate abutters.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. Thank you. I appreciate it. Back to you, Sean.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I guess to the... So what we're imagining here is a building that is narrower but deeper. Is that the suggestion? It's narrower. We're bringing it in on the left side, but we're extending it towards the back of the lot?

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think that might be one version. There might be a version of that where just the top floor is cut back on that side. But I think looking at the whole thing, a couple of feet narrower but deeper is certainly something that is worth considering. My sense of the board so far is that They want the units, they want the 14, but we're willing to be really flexible on its impact on the edges. Try to minimize it on the left, push a little bit deeper, see if we can still get the same amount of real estate. The stackers seem to be okay as a total parking storage area, however you divide up that cake. That seems to be where the consensus I'm seeing.

[Sean Beagan]: So I guess it would be to the applicant then whether they've looked at these scenarios of a differently designed building, you know, if they, if it was possible to waive the open space requirements, waive some other setback issues that are in the back, rear of the building currently, and you made your building brought it in on the left side, but extended it towards the rear. Is that something that you've looked at? Would it work? Could you park cars underneath anymore? Would there be enough room? Have you looked at any of that?

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: Sorry, I didn't realize I could unmute myself. Apologies.

[Chair Doug Carr]: No problem. Thank you, Guy. I appreciate your patience.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: No problem. Have we looked at it? So we definitely toyed with a few different thoughts there. The one issue we kept running in with is the constrainment of the drive aisle and parking on both sides when we begin to squeeze that. What perhaps could be done and I've posed this question and then I also have an update for you guys on the on the, the licensure that Zach had brought up. I went and made a quick call while we were going through this.

There may be, and we'll certainly look at it. And I'm sorry that some of the neighbors have the perception that we don't care or we're not considering this stuff. We've looked at many, many, many options on the site. So we'll certainly continue to explore them. We'll try to find something if you would allow us the ability, right? So these are new parameters for us. If we can be creative with going deeper, We'll certainly explore that. I don't think it hurts to figure it out. So I'll say that and commit to that.

I will also say we may be actually not able to do the stackers as we had imagined. it looks like there would need to be an attendant in the building to really make this thing work based on some feedback that I got moments ago. So I guess we would kind of be between, can we squeeze more parking going further back and offsetting space to the left. So kind of trying to solve, you know, kill two birds with one stone there.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It's obviously hard to design. You're not going to be designing on the fly. So yeah, I think you need to take some time, you know, really think it through. I think you and I want to hear from John and Dina before we, you know, wrap up this portion of it. But it sounds like, you know, maybe some some quick sketches, you know, like I don't think you need to do a full design. I wouldn't even do elevations right now. I would just look at At square foot massing units parking, just don't worry about the elevations that will solve itself once we, once we get to something that we feel comfortable with. But I think you need to run those past Alicia and Danielle 1st, before we have a Pope public hearing to make sure that. They think they're comfortable with it, but they think that's viable. I now understand what you said about the width of the parking. You can't make it 55 feet, it has to be as wide as it's shown.

There are some severe restrictions. We are really tight on all sides on this one, so I appreciate that. I'm going to go to John and then Dina. John first.

[John Anderson]: Thank you. I, I really appreciate the fact that people are really talking about neighborhood context now and how it affects the neighborhood. Uh, I am less concerned about the parking issues as long as the people who buy into this, uh, understand what it means for them, as long as they're not going in blind. So, you know, um, the stackers are out, uh, We can have less parking, but I feel really uncomfortable with this four-story building going in in a neighborhood where there aren't any, nothing is, you can find a few three-story buildings around there. But unless I'm looking at the wrong part of Salem Street, this is a very different kind of building and a design that makes it kind of less obtrusive. is something I would appreciate seeing.

Less jarring to the context.

[Chair Doug Carr]: You look puzzled, Doug. Well, I guess with the new zoning on Salem Street, this is kind of what they want, right? That's what this new zoning is actually directing developers to do. For better or worse, that's what this is about.

[John Anderson]: Well, that's what the zoning says, but Part of our site review is to protect neighborhood context within reason.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Agreed.

[John Anderson]: And so I'm not against four-story buildings anywhere or everywhere, but there needs to be a balance here.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Understood. I think that balances what we're kind of directing Guy to do. I agree. You know, go back, try to, he's heard the comments. I think the nine unit option, it seems to be off the table. We want to work with the 14, but we want to carve it and sculpt it in such a way that it has as least negative impact as possible on the abutters.

[John Anderson]: I would just say that, I'd like to see affordable housing as part of this, but I wouldn't oppose a nine unit solution any more than I oppose an eight unit solution on Main Street. If it's the right building in the right place and serves a purpose and can be developed properly, okay. Again, I'd rather see affordable in there, but that can't be our only concern when we do permitting like this.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I understand. Thank you, John. Dina, you're next.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yeah. So after listening to a lot of the public comments and reading it as well, I am certainly not against affordable housing. But I'm also very sympathetic to the abutters that would have to live next to this four-story building and then lose a lot of the daylight and the shade that they have. I'm also in favor of a parking of a one-to-one for, for each unit, there should be one parking space allowed. Uh, there should also be non-residential parking for anybody that is, is in this building. I think it should be, um, I still don't completely understand why we can't go from 11 and 11 to from, from 14.

But I am very, very sympathetic to the neighbors and the people that have purchased the condominiums and their units right next to this building and will not have shade and will have a different type of environment to look up to every day. I think that we need to be sympathetic when we implement the new zoning rules to also be very cognizant of where these larger buildings are going. And, um, I, I do at this point, it might not be parking a parking requirement of 1.5 per unit, but I do think it is one.

And I think a design needs to be proposed where we can meet in the middle somewhere, and then also be sympathetic to the people that live on Almond Street and live on right around those different areas where those people have spoken of the shading studies that are going to be done. I would like to see Danielle's proposal looked at three-story shading versus four-two. That's all.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Danielle. Ari.

[Ari Fishman]: Thank you. I did just want to clarify that I have a very strong preference for a 14 unit kind of situation, but If it's a question of nine units or no development, I would choose nine units, but with a very strong preference for 14. When you said that nine was off the table, I did want to clarify. And with the new information about the stackers, I'm getting the sense that the developer needs to go and kind of rethink a lot of things. But I want to see something good go up here in that there is a consensus that this is the place for massing.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, so it sounds like what I'm hearing is, and we'll get to Guy in a minute, but if we're looking at potentially 14 units, trying to get at least one to one, 14 cars with or without stackers, it sounds like without, and there's no reason that the garage can't be a little bit bigger. Enclosed than the housing on top of it. You could cut it back on the side a little bit. You know, the parking needs to be with parking needs, but above it, maybe it goes deeper. Maybe we have some relief. Maybe it steps back a little bit on the top floor. and we still get 14 units and roughly the gross square footage. It's a massing test fit essentially. And I'm sorry we're at that point of this, but it's clear that this one is really pushing the boundaries a lot. So I guess we're asking Guy to go back and kind of not start over, but kind of just go in without preconceptions and try to address the concerns you've heard tonight. Anyway, go ahead, Gaia, you raise your hand.

[MCM00001497_SPEAKER_08]: No, I just want to thank everybody for their feedback. I think it's helpful, and I wish we had kind of gone to more of an open dialogue up front and kind of hashed out everybody's preferences, because long ago when we initiated this project, we went to the planning board office, and we were very clear that this is something that we want to work with the city and the division, and that's our goal here and is always our goal. So let me say this. I just want to... categorically try to put priorities in place, okay? We're going to try to keep density as high as possible. I think there's an overwhelming agreement that housing is needed. We hear you. So we have that.

We will, with the new ability to kind of be imaginative. We will go back and try to reconfigure this, having looser parameters to understanding that there's more sensitivity to the building to our left, the residences to our left, and our neighbors. And we will attempt to do both. And then we will come back with a solution That is the best possible outcome that we can come up with while maintaining a feasible development economically for ourselves. So you have that from us. I don't know that we can get to 14 parking spots. We will do our very, very best to get to one-to-one.

In any case, I will come back with something. And I've already, my architect is on On this zoom and she has been Marine has been great. She's been texting me throughout this with some thoughts. So we have ideas already and we'll get to work with them right away. And hopefully we can come back with something to you to kind of get some further feedback because this has been kind of a. roundabout with the parking and qualification and all of that. This has been a longer cycle than we had anticipated, obviously. So we would like to try to come back with a complete thought the next time so that we can get tangible feedback and work off of that one. So we will do our best. We will pick a path for ourselves to present to the board. to get tangible feedback and that will be the option that we will push forward because we, we, we can't have three more meetings, uh, from our end, uh, just based on our contract, uh, to, to try to figure out a concept. So that's on us. We'll take it back. We hear you loud and clear. I just want to iterate that. Thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. I appreciate it. Ari, you had a comment.

[Ari Fishman]: I had been thinking about the math. If we are, it sounds like we're okay with one to one as a possibility. And with the fact that legally, kind of there with affordable can be point 511 plus point five times two equals 12. That Kind of is a potentially easier than 14 and that's on the table for me at least. So I did when we're thinking about creativity. I just wanted to make sure that was explicitly stated.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Thank you. I think we're obviously going to continue this again. Again, I would urge you, Guy and your team to get something down quickly and get it to Danielle and Alicia as quickly so they understand the concerns. I think we're all on the same page about direction. So I think they can give you a good feedback without coming before this entire board. Are you on the right path? Does this make sense? Again, massing, metrics, units, square footage, we don't need layouts of units. We don't need even elevations. If we get that right, I think the path forward will be a lot easier. You shouldn't invest time in detailing a building until we know we're going to get there. I think that's the key.

Thank you. All right, we are going to move along. So we're going to continue this until the next meeting, which is two weeks from tonight. We have a lot already on that agenda. I'm going to move on to the next public hearing.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: You have to pick a date and time certain, state it clearly, and the board has to vote for continuance.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. Sorry to interrupt. We'll make a motion to continue this public hearing to, Guy, if you're amenable to that, to two weeks from tonight on February 18.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Will he be ready February 18th? You are planning to meet with Innes Associates on February 18th.

[Chair Doug Carr]: We do have an agenda item on that one with the Medford Square Zoning Consultant. That's going to take, frankly, a couple of hours. I don't know what else, maybe, Danielle, that is on that agenda right now, beyond.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Uh, guy potentially and the consultant Riverside probably, because I don't think we're going to make it through tonight.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Probably not. Okay, it just might be another marathon night. Because otherwise we're talking about a month from now.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: We threw the chair, I would recommend as much work done possible of looking at this in advance with staff so that things are not being presented at the meeting because. These meetings can't just be like working sessions and seeing things for the first time or me seeing things yesterday. It's it's not It's not efficient. It's not helpful. It wastes everybody's time.

[Chair Doug Carr]: No, I I think I've said that a few times. I couldn't agree more I think we've well, I think we have continued to two weeks from now, but I think that's conditional upon Danielle already seeing something that they think is viable, you know as a direction because I Two weeks is not a lot of time, but having a concept within two weeks and running it past you guys before those two weeks is done, like next week, that's where we should start, I believe.

[Sean Beagan]: I'd move to continue this hearing to the first date in March that this board meets.

[Ari Fishman]: I agree, I think that extra time will be helpful for them to figure out what they want to run it by PDS staff, go back and do edits rich, and then return it again so that we can actually discuss something concrete.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All right. So that's the motion made by John, I guess.

[Sean Beagan]: We need a definitive date.

[Page Buldini]: March 4th.

[Sean Beagan]: March 4th. Yeah. Move to continue to March 4th.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, roll call. John Anderson. Yes. John Began. Yes. Page Buldini.

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Calagaro.

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman.

[Ari Fishman]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, yes. All right, Guy, we'll work with you and Danielle and Alicia as fast as we can over the next couple of weeks to get this hopefully viable for you and everyone else. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. All right, moving on the new public hearing site plan review for 400 Riverside Ave. This is a new public hearing, so I'm going to read the public hearing notice for the record. The Medford Community Development Board shall conduct a public hearing on February 4th, 2026 after 630 PM.

via Zoom remote video conferencing relative to an application by ABLE companies for a site plan review to hear expected changes for interior renovation with exterior modifications for accessibility and signage. There are no planned additions or new constructions to the existing building. The existing building will be retrofitted for a new use. The occupant, Aloka Properties, DBA Ware Street Commerce, which intends to open a co-working and make space in a portion of the building. The subject property is located in the industrial I-0 zoning district at 398 Riverside Ave, Medford Mass 02155.

Danielle, Alicia, do you have any introductory comments before we get into the applicant's presentation from ABLE companies? Go ahead, Danielle. Go ahead.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Sorry, I didn't mean to do that. I had to move locations. This project is Kayla's. So if she's here still, I don't know if she is. I think she was going to try to go home.

[SPEAKER_17]: I see Kayla. Go ahead, Kayla.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Hi. Yes, I don't have any comments before the presentation, but I'm Happy to follow up.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. So the applicants, let's get you. Can we make them co-hosts, Danielle?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Sorry, whoever is going to present and speak on behalf of the applicants, could you just raise your hand so I know who to make a co-host? OK, thank you. Jonathan? make cost there you go you will uh william you'll be able to um and steve you guys will be able to unmute your team um as you need to please don't unmute the general public but you may unmute your members of your team as you need them to speak the floor is yours jonathan yeah hi um

[SPEAKER_16]: Yeah. Okay. Hi, um, chair members of the board. My name is Bill care of worry. I'm with, uh, able company, uh, the, the owner of the building. And, um, we are very happy to be here this evening. Um, sorry, it's happening so late. Um, but we're very happy to be here to present to you. Um, um, this application to bring Ware Street workspaces to Fortnum Riverside. Fortnum Riverside previously was the home of, it was an occupied building until about a year and a half ago, by Boston Retail Products and as a manufacturing and warehousing business that occupied the entire building of 113,000 so of building and they did industrial, they built work setups, shelving setups for things like the Gap and Home Depot and so they had a big operation there. This is a much more modern version of a commercial use and it is a combination of makerspace and it's sort of an industrial version of WeWork focused on makerspace and warehousing for small industrial users and giving them a lot of the amenities that you would typically only get in a larger scale environment.

So, this is a partial occupancy At the moment of the building, they're going to occupy about 47,000 of the entire building. but we are hopeful that they do well and there is a plan, although not a requirement, there is a plan for additional occupancy by phasing over the next three years. So we have chosen to analyze the building as if it were to be done in the manner that they envision for a full occupancy, which is a combination of this and warehousing. And see what else I wanted to say.

Yeah, and so I do have my, that's what I have to say, just we're very excited that we finally have what we think is a great modern addition, bringing, you know, an industrial, a modern industrial user to this area that currently doesn't exist here in the neighborhood. So I think this would really be good for small business. And I have here a member from the tenant himself. I also have my team, and I'm going to hand this over to Steve, who will walk through the application. But I'll be here certainly to answer additional questions as well.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: All right. Thank you, Steve. Go ahead. All right. Great. Thank you, everyone. I'm going to just share The existing condition site plan is, as it was mentioned in the introduction, there's no construction to the building itself, but I think it's, it's always helpful just to see, see where the building sits. So just this here, not a lot to see, but Riverside Avenue is the major thoroughfare. You've got Sycamore Avenue is the industrial private road into the industrial area, and then Ross Street on the other side of the property.

The black line here, this is the current building outline. And then we shaded the portion of the building, it's this side of the building is really the part that the current tenant is looking to occupy. So that's the current application just to give you a sense of how this fits into the scheme of things. There's parking. This is sort of the main parking field that goes into the main entrance, which is located on the left side of the site here. And I'll go over those improvements in a moment. And then there's parking along this side of the building and then another parking field. back here with some really a loading zone in this back corner. Just to give you a sense of how the site is set up today. That works really well for what Jonathan and his team are trying to do here.

It also works well for future tenants that might occupy the other portions of the building. That's good just to give you a sense of how this is parked. A lot of conversation on parking ratios and things like that. So just to give you a sense, there's 93 parking spaces today. We do need, really up front, these modifications are to add some accessible parking. There's no there's no. Accessible parking spaces on the site at all today, so we need to bring some in there. Obviously that makes sense at the main entrance, which is the accessible entrance into the building. So we're adding some spaces there, which. Is really just restriping of the the proper striping, signage, and things to bring it up to modern standard of accessibility. That does cost us one parking space, so we've been able to maneuver that and minimize the loss, so 93 goes to 92, just to give you an idea. uh a sense of that so um how does that compare with the demand and and um we looked at the different uses there's a memo um prepared by howard stein hudson in the application i'm just going to hit the highlights happy to answer questions and i know kayla had some some questions on it as well so happy to get into those but the the gist of the parking summary in that analysis, and they also looked at trip generation. What is the current proposed use versus previous uses that Bill had mentioned? How does that compare?

On a trip generation standpoint, we'll be down a little bit in the peak, in the a.m. peak hours, in the p.m. peak hours. The trip generation, based on the change of uses and adding some office space and meeting rooms that was normally manufacturing before, that lowered the parking or the trip generation slightly. it's effectively going to operate very similar because it is still an industrial type of use. And then, so no real impact to traffic. The parking demand, we did an analysis on the change of uses and the still what may happen in this building, right? There's still half of the building shown here is not occupied yet. So we do want to make sure that we're accounting for that when it is occupied to look at what the full build out of the current occupancy is and then future warehouse use. The demand came out to 88 parking spaces when you don't adjust. I know we talked a lot about how many people riding the buses and the trains and different modes of transportation. The unadjusted number is a demand of 88. The adjusted, if you do take 15% out of folks that would be riding the bus, which we'll talk a little bit about the buses on Riverside going to Wellington. Not that inconvenient to do. So 15% seems pretty reasonable. That would put the demand at 65 spaces, just to give you a sense. So we have 92 existing after the ADA improvements. The demand is 65 with the adjustment for mode transportation. It's still only 88, unadjusted at 88. We have both of those covered with the parking that's there. Steve, that's for the full build-out, right? That's the full build-out. If this building is fully occupied with the use mix that we've proposed, the makerspace, the offices, which are adjacent to the makerspace, and then the warehouse, which is the white, portion, if that was fully occupied, your demand would be 88, assuming nobody's riding the bus or walking.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And that doesn't include the parking spaces along Riverside that are not legal spaces, right? The ones that are end in from the street? These ones here?

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Yes. Where everybody parks today. Yeah, those, um, those are counted in the 93 from the 92. Okay.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But, I mean, it didn't the traffic, the traffic folks and civil, you know, the engineer and city hall, didn't they more or less discount those spaces because they're not, you would never build those today because they're not safe. I mean, for lack of a better term.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Uh, they're, they're existing, so we counted them. Uh, I, I, we can answer those. We can get into that. I'd love to just get through. Sure. All right. The details, because I think Kayla has some questions that may be parking related as well. Very good. Unless Kayla would prefer to.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: I think you can continue on with your presentation and we'll.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Okay, sorry. And I, Chairman, I didn't mean to be dismissive. I just know we're going to talk about that. Thank you again. So just, I'm going to go through the site improvements and some signage, or really the other two pieces, and just give you a sense of what the changes are in this parking area. So again, 88, so the yellow is just to give you a sense of where we're adding striping. So as we're doing some improvements here and creating accessibility from a parking perspective, staff had really great comments of how do we to do some enhancements for pedestrian access. So we're adding in striping to create a path out, and we're taking a portion of the fence down that there's a fence all along Riverside. We're going to take a portion of the fence down. We're going to add a sidewalk connection right out here, which matches up with the crosswalk across Riverside. Gives folks access to both sides of Riverside for the sidewalk access. Also gives access to both bus stops going both directions to and from Wellington. So I think that's a positive connection. It does create an opportunity to add one tree there when we make these modifications. We take the fence back. It creates a little space. So took the opportunity to put an Armstrong red maple in there. And there's pretty good vegetation along there. Some of it's smaller shrub type, but there are some trees that exist there. This will just be a little more of a pop of color and be a good street tree versus what just happened to grow along the street there. I think it's a nice add. Just pedestrian connectivity. Again, this is all striping. There's a little bit of work here, curb and concrete and asphalt, but otherwise, it's restriping of the parking lot and adding appropriate signage.

The other change, I'll flip to another slide, but we're adding signage for the tenant. Go to our application here. Sorry, just so you can get a sense. So we're proposing to add some tenant signage on the building. If you go by today, you'll see the leasing signage. The goal is to make that go away. It's all leased up and add some more permanent signage here to identify the new tenant. We gave zoom in, which is some rough dimensions, approximately 9 by 9, just to give you a sense of scale. But we tried to get it. These are photorealistic renderings by the signed designer, so give you a good sense of what it will look like in the end. So that's the application. Those were all the pieces. Happy to go back to parking and talk about any of those specifics that we didn't cover already.

and whatever slide, if, if there's a slide you'd like to see.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Um, Kayla, do you have any comments or do you want us to dive in with the board comments?

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Um, I have a slew of comments from city staff. Um, I, do I just read them out to you all?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Why don't you summarize them if you can, just might answer some questions before they're asked.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: I will start with, well, we can start with parking. The engineering department, as we said before, the 14 spaces right above Riverside Ave, they want those to be gone. And changes to the curb cuts to make it compliant. Um, We. So if you remove those 14 spaces. Assuming you need 88 for full leasing. You would have a remainder of 78. However, phase one of this project wouldn't be at full leasing capacity. So that has been a question for the board. If the 78 spaces that have been striped, if that would be sufficient for what they are proposing.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Can we tell what the percentage, I mean, is it, it's not, it looks like it's more than 50% for the light gray area for the percentage of the actual total build out. Do we have an actual percentage of that? Just square footage, or you can just do the math. I'm just thinking if we have 88, you took away 14, you said, Karen, so that's really.

[SPEAKER_16]: The gray area or the current lease area and Bill, correct? We have 41% occupied. Just know that the gray area is times, there's a second floor to the gray area too. Um, which is not being occupied. So the, the white, meaning this in, in the site plan, the white that is, that is not occupied is also inclusive of the second floor above the gray. So just to imagine, so it roughly comes out to 41% of the building is, um, being occupied at the moment.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Which is 47,000 square feet for about 47 out of 118,000. Yeah.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Kayla, do you have other comments from other departments?

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Yes. We received from FIRE today that there needs to be a turning radius study done for the entrance, the main entrance. The concern is that if cars are all parked in that the front lot that the fire truck rigs wouldn't be able to appropriately navigate the parking lot.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So that's something, Steve, you can actually provide to the fire department, right? That's part of BOLA's work?

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: We can. I mean, it is the existing condition. We're not changing the dimensions there. So that's what they've been working with since this building was built. We can provide the study, but effectively, it's what's been there.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Yeah. not to, you know, with a use change, not to put words in fire departments, you know, what their qualms were, but it is a use change from what was previously there. And so this isn't unreasonable. The sweet path analysis is what was requested from the fire department. Like I said, with engineering, I think you saw this, but there are ADA and MAAB non-compliance issues along the frontage that extend beyond the initial conversation we had with creating this accessibility path. These will also need to be addressed.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Were there specifics?

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: Yes, there are specifics. The engineering department sent a red line on the schematic on the site plan and a memo.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Danielle, do you have a few thoughts here?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so some of these comments came in quite recently. They were forwarded to the applicant. I mean, the fire department's comments came in from closed business yesterday and then the engineering office had, you had emailed comments and then put together a formal memo yesterday. Basically, this was because it was a change of use, which triggered the site plan review. I don't think we had anticipated that there were some problems there. So the turnaround time to get comments from them back to the applicant was probably quite short.

So yeah, I'm not sure how much time there has been to review their comments. But the main ones that boiled up was that Those head in parking spots are compliant and can't be used. And so the curb cup needs to be. Closed up, I don't know if there's a different parking. Layout that would work, whether it was angled or parallel. I don't. I think it would eliminate all of them, but the feedback that we have gotten from engineering is that that's not a parking situation or scenario that can continue because it's a safety issue. You can't have cars pulling in there.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: Just to clarify, that's those spaces there?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah. So this is what happens with site plan review because even though we try to anticipate all of these or some of the issues that might come up, Not being the transition planners and engineers, we weren't aware that that this was going to be a situation that just arose. So apologies for that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So Steve, I guess, you know, we didn't kind of complete the kind of thought process about available parking, percentage needed, what's left over, you know, like, I feel like that needs to be looked at a little, maybe you've already done that. You know, you could, I agree with Danielle, you can recover some parallel spaces along that building that would be legal and probably be fine with the fire department and engineering. If I had to guess, they more or less said so, I think with what the comment was. So, but I don't I don't sense that you have a deficit of parking when you add this all up for at least the 1st phase.

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: You know, that's correct.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And that's all we're we're not. I don't believe we're approving both phases because this is a potential future phase or are we trying to say a full approval?

[MCM00000653_SPEAKER_10]: The approval is for phase one only. The parking analysis is based on full build to make sure we maintain the ability to lease out the rest of the building.

[SPEAKER_16]: Well, I would I would excuse me for adding my point of view, but. And I'm sure I speak on behalf of the tenant. They would like to know before they. Start investing in building out this business that they are going to, in fact, be able to expand into the remainder of the building. So. But I but but I also do appreciate that all of us would love to, um, allow the tenant to move forward on phase 1 while we continue to.

Right now, there's things to be done to get started on phase 1 occupancy. And so that's, I guess, the immediate goal. But I would expect none of us want to spend money for advancing things along without knowing that we can, in fact, achieve the full plan.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Couldn't agree more. I think there's a lot of support for this project. This is a good reuse of a building that's been empty for, I guess, a substantial period of time, right? So I'm not sensing that we want to work with you guys to make this happen. Obviously, there's some things that just came up, because it was more complicated than I thought it was a week ago, based on what I've heard so far. I don't see anything here that's insurmountable. I just think we've got to work through some details and some numbers and figure this out.

[SPEAKER_16]: Is there a way to approve the phase one and continue to address the full building version? I mean, we could agree that those parking spaces, those 14 spaces would We just wouldn't use them until we came up with a better plan to use them. Nobody needs them now, obviously.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah. Alicia, do you want to jump in here?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I just wanted to ask and confirm. So unfortunately, we got some of these comments late, and we tried to explain to our colleagues that this is not an exterior renovation, but they have concerns about, you know, the fire and the parking and the sidewalk. And so I think what it would be really helpful is to confirm with the applicant, have you seen all the comments that came in today and over the last two days and how, whether you're prepared to say, yes, we can work with these and put these in as conditions or whether you want to review them and come back in two weeks and just say, then do it. And I can tell you there from DPW Commissioner Tim McGivern, just because they have their names in the titles of the files I'm looking at are City Engineer Owen Wartella, Traffic Todd Blake, and then I think the other two was just a letter of support from the mayor. And I think that the other one in the comments file is the letter of support from Kayla about the economic development of this. So I wanna make sure you have those three letters and that you've reviewed them before you say, yes, we can handle everything.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: We also have the letter from the deputy fire chief.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: That's not in the file online that I'm looking at. So did you get also deputy Shea's letter? That's the one that had an attachment that showed he wanted fire turning ratios. And if you're not prepared to just agree to that now, it might be in your best interest to talk to him between now and two weeks from now.

[SPEAKER_16]: Okay. I think we should probably do that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: I just don't want you to overcommit as much as I want to see this at the past. I don't want you to commit to things you haven't fully looked at.

[SPEAKER_16]: Yeah. No, I appreciate and thank you. No, I don't believe our team has actually has spent the time on these documents just yet. Yeah.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: And we're very sorry because we didn't actually expect to get these comments. We thought they would say, oh, it's just an interior change of use. We're good. So.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Kayla, did you have any other comments before we, I need to obviously talk to the, get some initial board comments here.

[Economic Development Planner Kayla Myros]: I think based off of what Bill and Alicia said, I think having more time for the client, the applicant to review the comments will be necessary. So we probably don't need to spend more time on the specific comments now.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, let me just open it up to the board, just if any other, obviously you've heard what's been discussed about, about the parking, about the ADA, about other things. Are there other concerns or issues you want to bring up? And I'll start with Irene.

[Ari Fishman]: It's perhaps the opposite of a concern, which is my understanding is that we only, that they only need those spaces under the most conservative maximum everyone is in the office on the same day and everyone drove a car and everything is at 100% occupancy and no one took a bus. And that's not the world we're living in. People are working remote and people aren't going into the office every day. There are buses, et cetera. So I would love to make life easier for everyone and require significantly less parking, thus that it meets the amount of parking that's already there and comfortably works with a reasonable plan for them. it does sound like we either can vote on part one today or in two weeks. And I, that's, I'm fine with either option, but I think we don't need to really drive ourselves crazy on parking. I'm fine waving it and adjusting that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah. So you're, you're arguing for the, the adjusted 65 space as the threshold, which would obviously make things a little bit easier here. Okay. Uh, Paige, you're next. Go ahead.

[Page Buldini]: Thank you. I think pending the conditions that were sent from the other department heads would be great to know. So thank you. I am thrilled about this. I think this is such a great space for it. The fact that we can have a maker's space for other small businesses to grow and thrive that's already had manufacturing needs, I am 100% for it. So thank you so much. And thank you for being patient with the process. But I'm grateful. And I think it's the perfect area for it too. So thank you.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Paige. Sean, you want to go next?

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I don't know that I have any comments. I thought this was going to be a relatively quick thing that we were going to get approved tonight. It sounds like we're not going to. I kind of feel bad for these guys that they sat around for three hours tonight, honestly. Sorry about that. So I apologize for that. But I understand that, to Alicia's point, they definitely probably want to read and be comfortable with, if there are going to be conditions, they have to, and the tenant and the owner have to be comfortable that they can meet the conditions, however minor or major they may be.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And I think the onus is on us, both in City Hall and us outside on the board, to try to work together to really get the conditions really firmed up so we come in with a 99% checklist two weeks from tonight and just knock this out, if that's in fact the case, which I suspect it will be. Dina, you're next, and then I'll get to Jonathan as well. Just want to get you in there as well.

[Dina Caloggero]: Go ahead, Dina. I am so happy that this project is going through. That site has been vacant for so long. on Riverside Avenue, so this is exciting. Will we get, Danielle and I guess Alicia, what is the parking determination? Can we at least give them the allowance for parking that we can rule on for not only phase one, but for future? I am sympathetic to the developer's understanding that he would want to prefer to build for the future rather than just build for phase one.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so this, this board through site plan review can, um, you know, waive, you know, compliance with the parking. So it's not so they don't have to go to the zoning board for a variance. So you could say that they only, they need less and with these, this use, it's, it's, it's weird. Cause it's like, there's the maker space, which also goes with the warehouse. So it's, it's not different vehicles. that are needed for each use. So it's kind of being double counted. So the calculation is pretty wonky anyways, and probably not realistic. It's probably a much higher number than actually needs to be there. So I know for me, I'm not at all concerned with how much parking is being provided.

[Dina Caloggero]: So we have a lot of flexibility in what we can do so we don't prevent the developer from building something that won't fit future needs. Okay, very good. Thank you.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: We would much rather have a nice walkable sidewalk than a bunch of parking they don't need. I agree. I agree.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Jonathan, do you want to say a few words?

[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, sorry about that. I actually had muted myself, but just quick introduction. My name's Jonathan co founder and CEO of where street workspaces. So we are, I'm also a resident of Medford ironically, but this is 14 cook circle. So I'm also excited about this project, but. Yeah, a little about us. We have two facilities right now, one in Newton and one in Holbrook, both operating very similarly and kind of growing and scaling, which is why we identified this property. But everyone's hit the nail on the head. Basically, what we do is co-warehousing, so we provide maker spaces for on all businesses, whether you're e-commerce, startup, nonprofit, tech companies, anything in between, offer them small warehouse spacing for storage, and then with an element of co-working, so office spaces, conference rooms. One thing to just talk through about parking, which I think Ari had noted as well, based on our two other facilities we have, it is extremely variable when it comes to when our clients are at the facility. Some of the data we pulled out of all of our clients that we have, businesses are probably in the building on average 2.4 times a week because people are coming and going, they're grabbing products out of their unit, they're loading up a truck, they're grabbing a coffee, they're leaving, so it is not like a standard office space where people are parking for extended periods of time, 8 hours, 10 hours at a time.

If anything, we're seeing an average between one to four hours when a business comes in. It's constantly changing, which is a good thing. But again, we're excited to work with Bill and his team as well.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Jonathan. It's really helpful information because I think it echoes what Ari said before, that even with the strict reading of the zoning, What you're saying essentially is that the kind of space you have doesn't really fit with any of those categories, that the way we're measuring it is just different. So the pressure here on parking should be a lot less. And I don't think parking is going to drive this at all. We just want to get, even if the fire department has some concerns, you could lose some spaces potentially. and still make it work. We don't want to, but if there's a little bit of flexibility we need to get some of these other issues resolved, I think we have the ability to do that. It's paint on pavement, right? That's really what we're talking about for striping here. So I think what you have is pretty good, and I think we'll work hard over the next two weeks to kind of button up these concerns and get us as close to the finish line as we can, because it doesn't seem like there's Any issue here that's insurmountable compared to some of the other more challenging projects that we've done both tonight and in previous months.

Any other board concerns? John, you good? Okay. I think I've heard from everyone else. So I guess per the conversation, we're going to continue this until two weeks from tonight and we'll try to really work hard to resolve this issue. So we'll make a motion to continue to the 18th of February. So moved. Thank you, second. Second. Thank you, John. Roll call, John Anderson. Yes. John Began? Yes. Page Buldini?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Colagaro?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman?

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, yes. Six to nothing. We'll see you folks in two weeks and hopefully it will be a short meeting.

[SPEAKER_16]: Thank you very much. Thank you. Good night, everybody. Thank you. Okay.

[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, the last piece, well, there's a few more actually, but the... It's been a long night. Let's be honest.

[Dina Caloggero]: I'm so tired.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm going to try to get through this in the next, hopefully, 20 minutes. The board working session for the Medford Square District proposed zoning amendment. I think, Danielle, you put some meeting notes from that working session in the packet that we've got tonight, just to give you some notes about the conversation that happened. Mostly, it was logistics of setting up all these meetings over the next basically three months. There's almost a meeting every other week, public meeting at senior center, at the library, outreach. There's a whole bunch of things going on. Plus, we're meeting, obviously, internally two weeks tonight with the consultant, and we're meeting with the city council again in three weeks.

And there's other dates as well on that list. That list is part of this packet, I believe, Danielle. If it's not, we can send that around tomorrow. The schedule that Matt Lenning put out today.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I would not have put it in the packets. I don't even think I was able to open that email to even look at it.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah. We'll get that to everyone tomorrow so they can look at this the next three months. But what I wanted to do as briefly as possible tonight is just talk about What are the big concerns for Medford Square zoning? We had a couple of hours of city council, a lot of opinions back and forth, and I just want to kind of get a sense from everyone of what we're going to talk about with the consultant and what you think, what your concerns are for this. And maybe I'll just go around the room here. Maybe, John, do you want to start?

[John Anderson]: Okay, sure. I looked at some of the foundational documents, you know, the Medford Square master plan, so forth and so on. And I'm sort of puzzled as to why this is one district, one zoning district. The master plans identify three separate ones, City Hall, High Street and Main Street. And it seems like the areas are so different. It's hard to imagine It seems like you'd really have to twist zoning around to make it apply sensibly to all three of those areas.

I mean, one's a blank slate. One is sort of a mishmash of stuff that's happened randomly over the last 50 years. And then the other has some real historic context that was sort of built out many decades ago. Right, okay.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: Can I just clarify something? Go ahead, sure. Each of the different MX1, MX2, those are district, those are the things. Medford Square is just the area that's being looked at. You can put different rules in each of those areas. That's why they have different titles, right? The colors, each of those is a different Area I think the use of the word district is just a descriptor term that people are using the area we're looking at. is Medford Square. But you can put different rules on different parts of the square.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Right. But one of the conversation pieces at the city council meeting was that there was not an agreement about where those boundaries should, can, or should be. So I think a boundary discussion is certainly something we want to have within us with Emily going when she comes here for two weeks. If you think about those boundaries, do you think that's in Medford Square or not? And look at that meeting, she already moved that boundary, right? She took away some residential portions that were within that boundary and now they're no longer in that boundary. So those lines are not sacred. So if you think Medford Square boundary is something different, we should bring that up with her as a topic.

[John Anderson]: But that, so everybody agrees these are three very separate things. Does that mean we should take on all three at once?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: They interrelate, right? You walk between them, they all interoperate. Looking at them completely separately would be very disjointed. So you want to understand how when you walk from Salem Street to Riverside Avenue to High Street, you're in one area and you want that area to interoperate with each other. So you might have different rules on Salem Street than High Street or further down High Street, but you want to think about them at the same time.

[John Anderson]: Well, you could say that about all the zoning in Medford.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: You can, and that's one of the things that was trying to happen, but it turned out to be too big of a chunk for everybody to chew at once.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Right. Danielle, could we talk a little bit about the discussion that we had with the working group about breaking out the three parcels, having a different, more, I don't know if it's a more focused or accelerated work on those sections. Can you talk about how that conversation?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, so, you know, there's a lot of concern about you know, how, how long this process will take and. Will it be done in time for the city parcels to be, um, you know, rezoned so that trans can move forward and redevelop them. But on the other hand, you know, there are like, the parts that's within the boundaries of the square along High Street, which are very different. I feel like once you get to the armory, everything is different past there. It does not feel like the square to me. And having that in the mix of being at the same pace and trying to solve, it will take time. And does it make sense to do all that or are we rushing it through so that we can have the transom properties rezone? So I had floated the idea of potentially just doing a PDD for these parcels, a planned development district.

And it's kind of like a placeholder at least, but our PDD process is kind of clunky too. And so I had emailed Valerie Moore, the attorney for transit and they looked at it and they're not sure that it's actually gonna be quicker. That's I just heard from her today. And they were thinking of maybe doing like an overlay or something. So it is getting complicated, which leads me back to thinking that perhaps the part like we're like the ending the zoning at the fake armory and letting the rest. Right be like, Paul Revere's quarter or something. I don't know. It's just so much different and just is not the square. I don't I don't know why it's being brought in at the same time. I don't think it makes sense. Well, that's what no one ever listens to me until the process.

It's so bogged down.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But that's, that's as much boundaries as anything else. I mean, we could, I think what the, what some of the folks were talking about at this, at this working group and Sean, you were there too. They're talking about just saying the 3 city parcels could be different, could be done. I thought they could say, and they could be done faster and as a separate paper. Isn't that what they were mostly focused on?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, paper. Yeah.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But that would accelerate them, right? That would get the, that would address the issue of transom while still allowing us time to wrestle with the rest of the square, the boundaries, the historic stuff, all the stuff we're talking about, like wouldn't be, wouldn't hold those three hostage or delay them because they're obviously something that's been an RFP that has been put out, accepted and accepted. Is wants to get going everyone kind of wants to get going on those parcels, right? The 3 sitting on parcels.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, whichever is more expeditious. I mean, if the PD is more complicated, because there's a special permit thing involved in that, then having this separate paper would make sense. But for some reason, the boundaries and the original thing is some sacred. thing that can't be separated. And I disagree with that. I do too.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina, why don't you go ahead?

[Dina Caloggero]: I agree. I agree with Danielle. I think that if they, if we want to push, look at the Transcom thing is to take that city hall, control it as one, one particular thing we'll work on the zoning there. Then move on. I like the new armory, the old armory, but yes, high street is completely different. I completely agree with you. So handle the city, the Method Square, you can call it major, maybe Method Square minor, whatever you want to call it, but separate it off, push through, do the zoning there. The other thing I wanted to bring up was another point that came up at the city council. was that the parking garage should be allowed use. If you're going to have businesses in Method Square, I bring up the point that I never went to Grace Cleaners in Method Square. You know why? Couldn't park. Couldn't drop off my dry cleaning. So I think we need to, in that table that we're supposed to look at, and I have a bunch of other comments on it, that you need to have the parking garages allowed use, and you need to separate out that's where major, minor, whatever you want to call it, so you can push through the transcom.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Sean, you had a concern with parking too. You talked a lot about that with the city council.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I feel like I'm already starting to sound like a broken record with parking, but honestly, we saw tonight a classic example in that Salem Street project of what happens when you rezone an area, but don't rezone the parking. They rezoned Salem Street, but they didn't change the parking. And therefore, we've had four meetings with that applicant, all focused on parking. And if they had changed it to comport with their denser idea of having denser housing, we wouldn't be having those conversations. And the applicant would have a much cleaner, idea of where he needs to go instead of doing a fourth remodel of his plan.

[Dina Caloggero]: We keep changing the requirements.

[Sean Beagan]: There seems to be a pushback. I was feeling that there's this rush to get Medford Square zoning done so that we can say we got Medford Square zoning done. And like I said, I'm sounding like a broken record, but I keep trying to tell people You can pass new zoning, and if you have the parking the way it is and don't change it, we're still going to be having all the same meetings and all the same special permits, and you're going to be going to zoning board, you're going to be coming here, and we're going to wrestle with parking endlessly. So that has to be part of this. The parking minimums have to be addressed in Medford Square if you want people to reliably know what they can do and what they can't do. And I think a parking garage as a standalone use, we talked about that in the working group. I'm definitely for that. You know, if there's a, there's, you know, we talked about the fact that there are one, there's one lot of land we are kind of all agreed upon would make a great spot for a private parking garage if the,

[Chair Doug Carr]: Owner wanted to do that, but he can't right now because it's not in the system Yeah, I I think there's a lot of support for that on this Sean So I think when we when Emily comes before us in two weeks I think we if there's four or five things we want to talk about that's definitely one of them. It's like it's got to be I completely agree Go ahead page

[Page Buldini]: Thank you. I also have been talking about parking incessantly and a lot, and coming just literally as a board member of the chamber. This is a huge discussion. The tricky thing is we actually had a, in its public knowledge, we had a coffee chat with Justin Singh the day after. And it was great. It was for chamber members. And business owners like myself shared our real life I mean, I literally canceled Wednesday. I couldn't come up here. Boston Ave is not open for business with the snow.

Literally 70% of my clients come outside of Medford. But that's, I'm privileged, not a big deal. We figured it out. So my struggle is, though, the affordable housing aspect of it, when parking and affordable housing instantly are always at a head, it becomes like a, a big fight. And I feel like it's not a clear space. Even today was a perfect example where we had to literally decide affordable housing units or parking. And I feel like it speaks to a person and to whom they are. And there's no judgment either way. But I don't know how we can keep these conversations open or feeling open. if we suddenly are getting pitted against each other, and I don't know exactly how we can continue to be open about that. I also think it's really important to, and I don't think districts or boundaries matter, I'm assuming you guys are talking about the parking garage behind Colleen's, or even the one that's the lot that's across from Mrs. Murphy's. If there are spaces for the garages, the chamber is 100 in support of that. We've been talking to city councilors literally for two years about that. But the business community is feeling ostracized. And then I'm assuming, because I'm talking to some of the affordable housing advocates all the time, because I'm trying to learn, it's just becoming we're all contentious. And I don't know. And it might not be a fixable thing. But I don't know how you can do zoning without parking, but I don't know how you can do zoning without affordable housing. So I don't know. I don't know if anybody can help me with that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: It's a tough balance page. We saw that tonight. You saw passion on both sides. You saw people who are like did not want parking to rule the world. And people don't care about parking and just want housing. And there has to be a middle ground there somewhere. I can see that. I thought the transom design had a garage integrated into it. I would be curious what the chamber thinks of that, if they've even seen that or spent any time with it. Because that's where the boat is headed right now.

[Page Buldini]: So the chamber was a part of that, that I think is public knowledge now, who was a part of RFP. So there was representation, but it was collaborative. And I know that the Alicia and Danielle, you've been awesome discussing with the chamber when we've had questions. So I don't know, though. It's really tricky, too, because like, we are the business owners, and it's hard to explain. I use my business as a perfect example. I'm in it right now, there should be housing above me. It's bossed out. That completely makes sense. And it's hard when you have to talk about the vision, because it's not necessarily, and we saw that today, right? We just talked about it. Some of the stuff isn't going to happen. It can't happen, the setbacks. I'm on a hill. There's no way my side of the street is going to be higher than the side over here, because we're on top of a hill. So that makes sense. But the business owners are the ones that are worried about the impact for the now. And we had two business owners speak about friends that wanted to open stuff in the square. And they can't, because they're not from Medford. So it's like, I don't know, because they're afraid about parking, because it's the square. So it's just these continual bumps that. And I also think it's important that we're walkable. It's so nuanced. But I think that we have to find ways to keep the meetings. I knew the minute I said something about parking, at that joint meeting, I knew exactly what would happen. And that's even when I led with, I support affordable housing, it instantly became that way. And I think that vice versa, when people said, I support affordable housing, or I don't want a car, need a car, it's, I don't know. So I don't know if in the working meetings, if we can continue, because Justin was super open, and it was a way different vibe than when we were there the night before. So I'm hopeful that the working meetings that you guys are having, which thank you for doing that, because that's another meeting, that collaboration is really, I hope, is working.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. What other concerns? So I'm hearing about, you know, the boundaries of the district, the three parcels for transom, the parking garage, and the parking integrated zoning. Those are four topics I think right there that we're definitely going to be talking with. uh, with Ines and Emily two weeks from tonight. Are there any other topics like that, big picture topics that we want to make sure we think about, prep about, and, and, and kind of, um, make sure we don't let her leave that meeting without at least bringing it up and see if we can get, I mean, we really need another map, right? We need to have, we need options. I feel like the map we have just needs to change. You know, we need options. Go ahead.

[Dina Caloggero]: You might want to also consider, like, let's learn from lessons passed about the whole issue about the methadone clinics. You might want to put those in special permit and make some changes to the table of use as well. And what we want to do with that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: OK.

[Dina Caloggero]: Let's not go down that road again, right?

[Chair Doug Carr]: I don't, I mean, obviously Alicia and Daniel could speak to that. That was a bullet dodged that we, I'm not sure we could have, could we have done something about that?

[Director Alicia Hunt]: So let me sort of just, we have to be, I want to be clear about a couple of things. I try to always lead with this when I can, when it's reasonable, is that people who use methadone are recovering from drug addiction which is considered a disability and so if you literally say I am trying to make zoning to keep out methadone clinics that is legally against ADA and or the Americans with Disabilities Act and It could then get the city sued if we actually literally said we were trying to zone to prevent them.

So we have to be careful about what exactly we're doing in the language that we're using, because all of our meetings are public. They're on public record. They're on TV. We have to be really careful about that. And so we might be able to have more frank conversations one-on-one on some of this. we can't literally say we don't want this kind. What we kind of did start to look at is what are the impacts? You don't want doors slamming and people coming and go early in the morning. And so you don't want clinics that are open before eight o'clock in the morning in a residential area where people are living, right? So that's the kind of thing that we can be talking about. And we're not talking just about one thing in particular.

[Dina Caloggero]: I understand Alicia, but can we, isn't that part of the special permitting? Isn't that part of it? So we could restrict, right? Those certain parameters that would allow.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: What you have to say is all medical offices or what we had. So what we were, what we had proposed in the zoning is that neighborhood medical offices are medical offices that are small. They're under five staff and they're only open between 8 a.m. and like 6 PM. And that you could put in the zoning. And you could allow those by right. And then you could say anything else has to be by special permit. Maybe you don't want a large medical office without evaluating it more closely.

And I honestly, I kind of wanted to get that out with you guys here tonight, because I think you'll get a lot of members of the public coming to watch the meeting in two weeks that's advertised is working with the associates and it'll. I'll be less.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, John.

[John Anderson]: Yeah, I just want to go back to transit for a minute, because when I look at the RFP and then their response, It seems like we're pretty far down the road on what we want there. We talk about specific number of units, number of affordable units, types of businesses, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And that's, I mean, it all seems kind of reasonable, but if that's what we've already decided on, let's just get the zoning done to make that happen. Unless we have some major problem with it.

I think the, The last master plan that advocated for an RFP was finished like in 2017. And our RFP looked a lot like what was being talked about back in 2017. So I don't think, unless there's a good reason, maybe there's a good reason, but I don't think we should get this project tied up with all these other issues. I mean, nobody's proposing methadone clinics in that area, right? Parking, yeah, they're proposing a parking garage there. Unfortunately, I don't think it's gonna do much for the businesses on High Street because it's kind of a walk. So it's kind of a separate thing.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, I think we should wrap this up pretty soon, because we still have to do meeting minutes. It's not even midnight yet.

[Dina Caloggero]: I need to get up at 6 and go to work.

[Sean Beagan]: Just a final thought on what John was saying. If we were going to separate that block there into a separate district, That would have to be done at the city council level, right? That's, I believe that's not something we can do. Obviously, we can't approve that.

[Chair Doug Carr]: So I thought we could initiate any, we can initiate.

[Sean Beagan]: a zoning change, I don't know if a district is a zoning, maybe it would be.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: You can. You can make a zoning and send it to city council who would send it back to you for public hearing.

[Sean Beagan]: Right. So I suppose we could do that, but unless there's buy-in at the city council level, we're spinning our wheels. They have to approve it.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think they're all for it. I think they want to move as fast as possible on transit.

[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, well, then maybe that's maybe that should be proposed and we could turn it around very quickly.

[Dina Caloggero]: That's one way to get there.

[Sean Beagan]: If that's the quickest way to do it.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: In theory, and I don't know if in this associates can turn this around. If that's something you want to see, we could ask them to bring with them on in two weeks. zoning that you would then refer to the city council that would look at these three parcels or these three plus the corner here where the senior center and those buildings are, you might as well include them. I don't know, but we could ask them for that to bring a map, brings the language, you can edit the language, I mean, I think it's fair to say that as long as the city owns these parcels, it's not like something else is going to get built on them.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But we're kind of reverse engineering, aren't we? Because we're working backwards from transom, right? Because everyone's kind of on the same page, which is not a problem. It does seem like we could fast track that, because I think there's consensus here. As long as we tackle some of these issues, just to get that out of the way so we don't have to hold it up for months and get that piece of the square moving.

[Sean Beagan]: It would certainly take the pressure off having to rush through the rest of Medford Square zone.

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Figuring out how to save historic properties from being leveled so that These vacant lots can be zoned at the same time. I'm worried about us going down this one-size-fits-all zoning again.

[Dina Caloggero]: As I am, and that's obviously- That's why we took West Method away from it. You know, you had West Method and Method Square. Ay-yi-yi.

[Chair Doug Carr]: But I've been asking multiple times in multiple meetings, find me some zoning protections for historic resources and so far I keep getting avoided and it's like I can't be done and I just don't believe that's true. And I know it is true. I know that development incentives that are more more carrots than sticks that I think I want to, I think we need, we need creativity from MNIST to integrate historic resources into their plan without stifling development. There has to be a way, and I just haven't seen it from them yet.

[John Anderson]: Why have we been unable to declare any new historic districts?

[Dina Caloggero]: can't be the first ones that have done that.

[Director Alicia Hunt]: That would be the historic district commission. There is a process. I'm happy to send you the guidebook on how it works. I know. But it's not zoning. It's not the city board. A city council has to approve it in the end.

[John Anderson]: But the historic district commission has to do that. Yes. But what I'm saying is, if this is part of an integrated package, the city council controls all of this. So you say to the city council, look, make this a historic district, and okay, then we can move on to some other issues. Because then we've got the built-in protection.

[Chair Doug Carr]: I think it's 1 tool. I don't think it's the only tool. I definitely want that. But from what I've talked with Danielle is that the single building district is the way to go because you could do it faster and you don't have to wait for 11 properties. You knock them off 1 at a time and some of them does it all the time. And apparently, I think it seems to be the way. forward. I just think there's going to be some things that might not fit into that historic district that we still want some preservation protections for, like St. Joe's School, that probably are not going to be the same as, I don't know, the Armory, for example, or any of the buildings on the National Register, that still have to have some protection, you know. So I feel like that's one tool, but I think there's a few other tools that we just need in us to kind of expand their tool set a little bit to help us. And right now, I keep all I keep getting is is pushback. And I'm trying to figure out. But yes. Yeah, they they just and and and some of the Councilors, they just of course, I did. But I'm like, why?

This doesn't seem like a big ask, you know, like it's why is it something that is like the Mount Everest when it seems like it's common sense, you know, so. So those are the four big topics. I think we should probably close that out so we can get at least.

[John Anderson]: Can you reiterate the four topics for those of us who are half asleep?

[Chair Doug Carr]: Evaluating the boundaries a lot closer, looking at where the boundaries are of the district. And you're asking about the other one is the transom redevelopment and trying to accelerate those pieces.

[John Anderson]: Yep.

[Chair Doug Carr]: parking in the parking garage, parking with zoning, not separate from zoning per Sean's and several other people's comments. I guess it's five because we talked about some special permit, I think to Dina's spot about neighborhood medical office and things that would give us a little bit of protection about potential disasters we want to avoid. The last one is some kind of zoning protection and historic districts for historic properties, development incentives. I'll email this to Danielle. She can distribute them tomorrow. So we can just have just those five topics is a great menu, I think, to talk, to frame a conversation with Emily in two weeks from now.

All right. Moving on. Minutes. Danielle, we had those, right?

[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: There are two sets of minutes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Two sets of minutes? November, December? Is that what it was? October, November, October, November. Thank you, Christian. All right. So I'll ask for a motion for the October minutes.

[Ari Fishman]: Yeah, I moved to accept all minutes. Thank you. All right. John Innocent. Oh, Sean being him. Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Page Buldini.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Calagaro.

[Dina Caloggero]: Yes, please.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Harry Goffman Fishman. Yep. And myself. Yes, we are definitely running out of gas. I think we should just put off any administrative updates, if you guys are okay with that. There's nothing wrong with that. Yeah, we're fine. All right, motion to adjourn so we can all get the hell to bed.

[SPEAKER_15]: Yeah, motion to adjourn.

[Chair Doug Carr]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Dina Caloggero]: Bye! Bye!

[Chair Doug Carr]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Dina Caloggero]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Chair Doug Carr]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Dina Caloggero]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Chair Doug Carr]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

[Ari Fishman]: Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye! Bye!

Page Buldini

total time: 9.79 minutes
total words: 1802
Cheryl Rodriguez

total time: 1.59 minutes
total words: 323


Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Community Development Board