Energy & Environment Committee: Artificial Turf and Playground Surfacing - 2026-02-02

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3.8-flash from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The committee heard a detailed presentation from city staff on the health, environmental, and accessibility tradeoffs of artificial turf and poured-in-place playground rubber. Members also discussed municipal energy aggregation, smart meters, and a volunteer tracking framework for the Climate Action Plan.

  1. 1:22 Approval of Minutes — Approved the December minutes as written and the January minutes with a typographical correction.
  2. 5:54 Artificial Turf and Playground Surfacing — Open Space Planner Amanda Centrella reviewed the maintenance demands, heat absorption, accessibility factors, and PFAS chemical risks of artificial turf fields and poured-in-place playground surfaces. Committee members discussed procurement specifications to avoid PFAS, infill alternatives, and the ecological impacts of synthetic installations.
  3. 1:04:29 City Sustainability and Energy Updates — Staff provided updates on resolving electricity aggregation mailing errors, evaluating automatic low-income enrollment, fielding concerns about National Grid smart meters and opt-out fees, and preparing solar grant applications for local schools.
  4. 1:31:00 Climate Action Plan Tracking Framework — Josh Ekhart-Lee presented a spreadsheet tool designed for committee volunteers to liaise with municipal stewards and quantitatively track progress on individual Climate Action Plan objectives.
  5. 1:35:41 Committee Announcements and New Business — Members shared information regarding an upcoming forum on the Tufts Park mini-forest, volunteer opportunities for municipal pollinator gardens, and plans to take up recommendations on takeout containers and black plastics at the next meeting.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Energy & Environment Committee

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: We are officially at quorum, which means you're stuck with me for the next hour and a half. Would love to quickly go through attendance. And then we have to do two quick votes on not just the minutes from January, but I believe we delayed our minutes from December as well. So we're going to really cook through these really fast. All right. So let's buckle up and get started. Let's do attendance first. Josh.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Present.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Fantastic, Lois. Present. Benji. I see Barry. Present. Loretta. Present. Kathleen, I do not see yet. Luke, also do not see. Prabita, not yet. Dan, not yet. Bob. Present. Jessica, not seeing. John, nope. Will is here. Paul. Present. Fantastic.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Nice to see you, Paul. Cheers. Nice to see you.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Perfect. With eight, that brings us to exactly quorum. Let's discuss, did everyone get a chance to see the December minutes? I know that feels like ages ago. I'm seeing some nods. I'm going to defy expectation here and say, let's vote to accept those December minutes.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: I will second that.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: OK.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: If that was a motion.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Let's do it. All righty. Going down the line. Josh. Yes. uh lois yes benji oh benji can you hear me okay oh he's muted raise your hand benji if you accept a thumbs up perfect i'll take it uh barry yes loretta yes Kathleen just joined us. We are voting to accept the December minutes.

[Unidentified]: Yes.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Fantastic. Nice to have you. Thank you. I still know Luke, Prabita, Dan, Bob. Yes. And Jessica is a yes from Will. And Paul. Yes. Perfect. The yeses have it. And let's rapid fire move on. to our January minutes as well. Thank you for bearing with me. One last go through. I'd like to motion to accept the January minutes.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I thought there were some edits that someone found.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Yes. Were there any amendments? I think Lois had pointed out one. Yeah, Lois had pointed out a typo on page two. We okay with accepting them with the amendment fixing that typo?

[Lois Grossman]: Very minor correction.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Still appreciated. Get a thumbs up? One other person?

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I can, yeah.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Okay, perfect. Let's go through it nice and quick. To accept January minutes with a typo amendments going down the line. Josh.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: I'm saying so as our January meeting.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: All right, Lois.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Yes.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Fantastic, Benji. I see a thumbs up. From Benji? Perfect. Mary? Yes. Loretta? Yes. Kathleen? Yes. Luke? Luke is not here yet, but Parvitha has joined us.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_29]: Yes.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Fantastic. Bob? Yes. Jessica? A yes from Will. And Paul? Oh, Paul, can you hear me? Oh, I see a wave. I see the wave. Perfect. Sorry. It took me a minute to find you on the window. All right. Yes, let's have it. Very sweet. Yes.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Sorry. No, you are okay.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: It took me a second to find you. All right. Thank you for bearing with me with the administrative bits there. We powered through it like champions. Now we can get on with the rest of things.

[Brenda Pike]: One more tiny administrative thing. The next meeting?

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Oh, yes. Next meeting should be March 2nd. We have a nearly identical calendar here in March. which is actually our next meeting. All right. Otherwise, I think we are A-OK. Let's go to, I believe we have a guest. There's Amanda. You see her box. After we had discussed artificial turf, Amanda took it on herself to start reaching out to folks, figuring out what's possible, what's happening here in Medford in artificial turf world. and I believe has a slide that they would like to share with us.

[Brenda Pike]: And for those of you who don't know her already, Amanda is a planner in my office who focuses quite a bit on parks in the city.

[Amanda Centrella]: Yes, hello, everyone. It's so great to have the opportunity to talk to you all. And I've crossed paths with a couple of you in my work in the city before. And so for those of you, hello again. And for those who I haven't had the opportunity to chat with, I'm so glad that we get tonight. So I will, with your permission, share my screen. We can just have a couple of slides. as a reference point. Okay. Sorry, this looks a little silly right now, but we will share.

Okay, can folks see this?

[Unidentified]: Yes, good.

[Amanda Centrella]: Okay, thank you. So Amanda, again, I use she her pronouns, and I'm an open space planner in the same office as Brenda. So I get the great honor of working with Medford's Parks and Open Spaces. So I wanted to talk a little bit about artificial turf and also poured in place rubber play surface. I thought we'd start with the turf. So just let me put this up here. So just so we're all working with the same foundation, an artificial turf system is usually comprised of these general layers. So there's a plastic fiber grass, fake grass top. There is an infill layer, which can be made of a couple of different things. We'll get into that in a second. There's usually some sort of weed barrier or like a geotextile. There's a compacted base. This is oftentimes like gravel or stone, and then the soil underneath. For example, we have this. This was our detail. for the most recent McGlynn playground turf that was installed last year. And you'll see here the main difference is there's also like a shock absorption pad.

And I learned in doing a bit of digging for this is that this shock absorption pad that we have for this particular system is like a certified cradle-to-cradle product. So it's recyclable without down recycling, which I thought was kind of cool, but it's definitely not the, I would say, the standard for something like this. The city has four artificial turf fields. There's Hormel Stadium, which I believe is the largest edge relay field behind the high school McGlynn playground, and the Brooks Elementary School has a small field.

I don't know all of the components of these other artificial turf fields, and perhaps if there's a real interest, I can do some digging in city records to see how These fields were made, but I do know for the most recent McGlynn playground turf field, the infill layer is made of sand. This infill layer can sometimes be like a rubber crumb, a mixture of sand and rubber crumb, and then there are some other alternatives, which we'll get into.

So pros and cons of artificial turf. I'll start with pros. So a major draw to something like artificial turf is that it has just significantly more playable hours for the field for the amount of maintenance that you're putting into it. This means, you know, within the season on a weekly basis, like more playable hours per week, but also like an expanded season, so longer months of play. In addition, it's not oftentimes or Yeah, if there aren't underlying drainage issues due to grading, you can use artificial turf fields in and during or directly after wet weather, which is hard to do with natural grass. And there just isn't a need for field recovery time.

It is typically considered an option that is appropriate for very high usage and wear. There are, generally speaking, lower maintenance costs and demands, although it is not without a need for maintenance. And there is less water needed for the field. Sometimes these fields are installed with irrigation systems because, as we'll talk about in a second, they can absorb a lot of heat and sometimes not. So there can be some need for water for managing heat of the field. So that moves us to our cons. It does, as I mentioned, absorbs more heat than natural grass fields.

And technically, several of the layers are recyclable materials in theory, but in practice are difficult to recycle all of the components. Um, so there's, like, the fiber up top, the grass fiber and info layer, like, they need to kind of get separated in order to recycle them. And I think that that can be challenging. There is the much higher upfront cost for artificial turf. And studies have demonstrated that PFAS and other forever chemicals and other types of chemicals exposures are possible or are present in these fields. And that polluted stormwater runoff is possible, although it seems that there may be more study needed.

The top layer does create microplastics. And generally speaking, because of these things and the cost, it's not really worth it to consider an artificial turf field for fields that aren't lit, because then you're not making the most of those playable hours. Um, so all of that said, um, I wanted to just throw up a couple of, or an example, a local example of a, uh, artificial turf field that we have at the Brooks elementary school. Um, it is a very real and practical challenge to maintain natural grass fields in this city. Um, there are some best practices that our DPW employs and I want to caveat all of what I'm saying. Or I guess condition all of what I'm saying by first saying that, you know, maintenance challenges with artificial turf and with natural grass, um, are not is not a commentary at all on the quality of work and the work ethic of our fabulous DPW crew. They have been wonderful to work with and so much respect to them. And I think it's important also to acknowledge like that there is just a finite amount of staff capacity with like a seven member crew, which I don't even know if last year of those seven members. I don't think all of those positions were filled. You know, people take time off for family leave or health or or vacation time as well in the season. So, you know, at best we have a, or at most I should say we have a seven person crew and, you know, a finite amount of person power and time or hours that can be dedicated to this work and resources. So I just want to kind of cushion all of this because I'm sure we'll talk a bit about maintenance in this discussion by acknowledging that none of this is a commentary on DPW and more so just about like the amount of time and person power and resources available to our DPW. So all that aside, Brooks Elementary School, so I found some old photos of the field prior to it being converted to an artificial turf field. And you can see at slightly different points in the season, so in an August moment and in an October moment, it was really very challenging to have any sort of crest on this space because of the level of wear that it had. versus, obviously, once the turf field's in place, you don't have that same level of wear, at least showing.

Back up for a second. Similarly, we've had instances with, I think there was an attempt to have the high school football team at playing at the Tufts fields for a little while for one season. And by the end of the season, the first time the the fields were just in such that it was just so hard to maintain the lawn in such a way that it was playable and safe. And so they moved the football team to Hormel, which at that point had already been an artificial turf field. I think maybe another local example that is used as a natural grass field that maybe if you all are interested in taking a look at in the spring season is play stud field, which is used just for Medford youth soccer.

those fields don't have lights. So they're only used for by the day during the daylight hours. And I think once a week for practice and then Saturdays and Sundays for games. And with that amount of play, it is already kind of a challenge to keep up with the maintenance demands for having grass during the season. So I mentioned this all to say that the considerations listed here are really valid and important, and just to kind of give us a picture of what it is like working with each of these types of fields.

There are some alternatives to artificial turf in, and I should specify, the infill layer. I have heard of a coconut husk turf, which sounds really interesting to me. No presence of PFAS, although sometimes, depending on the product, the material may still be chemically treated. The drawbacks to coconut husk turf that I have heard of are that it's a very, very dry material. And so you're constantly, it does require a lot more water than sort of a traditional artificial turf infill. And because it's a very lightweight material, it gets easily displaced. So you just need to more frequently refill it. That said, I'm very curious about learning more about this product and to seeing if there are other local precedents or examples that we could look to to learn a bit more about how it works in practice. And then similarly, there's an engineered wood fiber turf infill product that I think has very similar benefits and challenges to the coconut husk one. And there is a slightly, it seems like anecdotally from other recreation directors, there seems to be a slightly higher incidence of minor injuries from players just because of splinters and a little bit of a coarser material. but not like, you know, very serious injury. I saw somebody had put their hand up for a moment.

[Barry Ingber]: That's me. Yeah. Yeah. Just clarification. So this is just the infill. This is not in place of the polyethylene blades. That's correct. Yeah, yeah. Thank you.

[Amanda Centrella]: No problem. Yeah, there may be other alternatives out here out there. I haven't had too much of a chance to dive into this besides, obviously, natural grass fields. But these were just two that I'd seen and heard of and that our recreation director, Kevin Bailey, had heard from some other directors within the field who have experience with these materials. All right, so actually, maybe now is a good time to pause, because the next slides have to do with the poured-in-place rubber, and just see if folks have any questions or want to talk about any of this. Or if you'd rather I keep moving through and we leave discussion for after. I'll defer to you all.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Hi, Amanda. manufacturer for PFAS free turf Right now.

[Amanda Centrella]: Oh, sorry. Um, so from what I've read, uh, so I've only been involved in one project in my tenure at the city that has, um, installed artificial turf and it was a school project. So I wasn't a decision maker in it. I was just sort of like a, um, a liaison to the city. Um, that said from what I've gathered and looking into this is that. while there are some manufacturers that will claim no PFAS, it's that despite that, PFAS have been consistently found across a number of products. So that it may not be enough to just get the word of the manufacturer, unfortunately. That said, you know.

I don't want to say that there wouldn't be value in vetting or seeking out manufacturers who try to minimize use of or resulting impact of PFAS.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Has the city tested any of this turf material for PFAS?

[Amanda Centrella]: I'm not aware of whether we have. Yeah, I guess my answer to that is I don't think so, but I'm actually not sure. But I'd be happy to look into it. I see you there.

[Barry Ingber]: Yeah, I have a bunch of questions, but I'll save most of them for the end. But one that I want to ask now, because it will bear on how I understand what you're presenting, is it seems to me like there's a difference between playing fields and playgrounds. So I wonder if. The alternatives available in playgrounds are different than the alternatives available in playing fields, and whatever differences you can comment on.

[Amanda Centrella]: Absolutely. Yeah, I think the next couple of slides will directly address that, Barry. I'm happy to answer it now, too, but maybe I'll just check to see if anybody else has questions.

[Barry Ingber]: That's fine. Thank you.

[Amanda Centrella]: Yeah. OK, I'm going to move along then because that actually is a perfect segue. So I'm going to go back to sharing. Sorry, this is not what I thought it would be. Stop. Oh, so sorry. I was so confident when I X'd out of my, what's it called, screen there. So I will just have to pull it back up again. Surfaces.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: I do have one question if you can multitask it.

[Unidentified]: Yeah, go for it.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Do we know how artificial turf interacts with the rate of water recharge? Like, are these more permeable, less permeable for the sake of our groundwater?

[Amanda Centrella]: Yeah, that's a really great question. In my experience, and I checked also with a lot of this information too, was in consultation with our recreation director, Kevin Bailey. who has a lot of great knowledge around this type of product. It's just as good as, or like, there's no difference really between, if it's designed correctly, no difference between artificial turf and a natural grass field, as far as infiltration and permeability. Really, unless the If the underlying grading of the field is creating low points or areas where water will pool, then yes, you will continue to have issues with water pooling. Or if the soil underneath the artificial turf system is maybe really like clay heavy and like it can only absorb so much water, then you'll continue to have that problem. But yeah, that the layers relating to the artificial turf system have not posed an issue for infiltration.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: The only difference is that it's infiltrating through potentially PFAS contaminated material.

[Amanda Centrella]: Exactly. Yes. Gotcha. OK. And with that, I think I can now represent, escape. Okay, so share. Sorry about that, everyone. Okay, so port in place. So poured in place is how I'm going to refer to that rubber safety surfacing that you see on a lot of playgrounds. It is an entirely different system than artificial turf, the type that you would see on a playing field. And actually, here is our layer breakout, like a little sandwich. So there's a layer on top that's this EPDM rubber. in a urethane binder, there is a layer beneath that, that's like a different type of rubber SBR. And I apologize, I do not know what all of these acronyms mean off the top of my head. But you know, a different rubber surface underneath, excuse me.

and within a binder. And then there's a smaller stone layer, and then a bigger, rougher stone layer on top of whatever your natural ground is. So with that in mind, so a local example, I'm going to use McGlynn again, McGlynn Playground. So actually, over here on our left, we've got the turf field. And then on the right-hand side is the playground area. Some big pros for port and place surface is, for me, number one, accessibility. This is a game changer as far as accessibility when it comes to mobility across these play areas. I think historically, a lot of folks may have grown up with, I certainly did, with playgrounds that had an engineered wood fiber play surface, or sometimes you would see sand.

I think when I was younger, one of the schools I was at had little rubber pieces that were all loose. And this material is very different from those in that all of those are kind of loose materials that can be very challenging to move over with mobility devices. And this is like a smooth flat surface. So it's kind of a game changer from an accessibility standpoint. And in a slightly different way that I think is less intuitive, it can the ability to customize use of color and using contrast colors can be very helpful in creating a more accessible space for folks with low vision. So the McGlynn project is a great example of this because that design committee was very interested in creating a universally accessible space. And so the yellow color, for example, is used as an alerting color across the entire site. And so it shows barriers between transition areas, transition in grade. At the top of the slide here, there's a little hill. And the color is alerting to that. It's alerting to this fence fabric over here.

all throughout the site. And then also the designer, the design team was very intentional about creating, using high contrast color of cream against green here to kind of designate like use zones for play areas. So you can see it at the bottom of the slide. There's hard to make out in this photo, but there's like a wall rope that is used over here. There's some stepper climbers over here on the green surface. kind of over you can see just on the overhead here that the cream was used to kind of create these like sort of you can see like by contrast of value and color more easily than you might otherwise. So it's just an interesting thing that I had learned as a part of this process and would like to implement in future projects moving forward if we can. important place has a 10 to 15 year lifespan.

there during particularly the first 10 years, there really are very few maintenance needs for this type of a surface. Maybe you might power wash it to clean it every so often. Infiltration-wise, again, no issues with permeability to the ground below. And I know that it's confusing because I think if folks are familiar with McGlynn, This site used to be all poured in place prior to the renovation, and there were tons of flooding issues over here. And that had largely to do with, I believe, the water table and the way that the whole area was graded. So really, it has to do with your underlying grading and drainage. But since then, I can say with confidence that the surface has been ripped. This whole area has drained much better.

Yeah, and there are no PFAS associated with this type of material, at least in the research that I've done, or nothing conclusive. That said, it is a non-recyclable material and non-biodegradable. So there is, at the end of life, a concern about what to do with this material. Another con is that it has a very high upfront cost. But something I think that's interesting to keep in mind with costs related to city parks is that it tends to be easier to find capital improvement funding, so like a one-off initial budget for installing something, than it is to find grant funding for maintenance and upkeep.

So those are a couple of pros and cons there. There are some alternatives to port in place. I'll go to this one last, but I'm just going to say sand is actually no longer allowed in Massachusetts. And it poses a number of sanitation, burn, and maintenance challenges. And sorry, by no longer allowed, I should say I don't think it complies with ADA regulations for place surfaces. Engineered wood fiber is a classic. It is much cheaper to install than poured in place, but it is no longer considered an accessible surface on its own by the Massachusetts Architectural Access Board, MAAB. So you need to create an accessible roof with a different surface throughout the playground to use this material. And I'll show an example. We have a couple in the city, Tufts Park and placed at park come to mind. There is such a thing as installing accessible pads on top of engineered wood fiber.

I think the city does not have this at any of its parks currently, and I imagine that it would pose some upkeep and access challenges because the grade of whatever surface it's put on, probably engineered wood fiber. It compacts over time, and it settles and changes. And then you have paths that aren't maybe meeting slope requirements for it being accessible or things like that. It's also made out of the same material as traditional poured in place. But it is an option available to us, and we are trying this out at a small park renovation at Logan Park. Um, which happy to talk more about if we want. Oh, sorry. Uh, I will throw in this other alternative that we've, I've just started looking into. Um, it's called corkine and it's actually a European product. It is very similar to poured in place, except for rather than having, um, EPDM rubber in a binder, uh, for that top layer, it uses cork in the same type of binder. The cork is harvested from a cork forest in Portugal.

It is uncommon in the US, this product. I think they gave some examples. There's like one playground in Texas. There's another type of space in New York. It's not a playground, but it's some other, I have to look it back up, I apologize, but it is used in New York. somewhere, and I think California. So there were a couple of precedents. It is more common in Europe. A downside, unfortunately, is that it is about one and a half times the price of traditional port and place, which I think could present a cost barrier. But it is a very similar type of level of accessibility. except that I don't think it comes in various colors. So you don't have that ability to customize.

So sometimes a thing that we can do, rather than having a totally poured-in-place playground, is to have an accessible route in poured-in-place. So you see the red surrounded by another type of play surface, such as engineered wood fiber. know, is I think a good compromise and can make sense, you know, depending on the resources you have available, the play structures you are trying to use, and the community you're wanting to serve. It does present some caveats. So, um, Realistically, from an accessibility standpoint, having a route as opposed to an entirely accessible surface might mean that a child and their caretaker may not be able to be in the same space if they're both using mobility devices. You can see here, there are these kind of weird little islands of board in place, which this is an old playground.

I don't know that it would have been designed this way if we were doing it today, because, you know, if you okay you can get onto the play structure and go down the slide but then you're kind of stuck at the base because there's no like connecting accessible route between these two little islands. Similarly, you are left with, you know, some maintenance, more maintenance than you would with a totally put in place surface usually involves having to these these engineered wood fiber chips, they compact over time, they also, you know, just first they need to be raked. So you would need to be refilling these.

at least once a year, maybe twice, depending on the level of use, to make sure that you're getting the same amount of safety and shock absorbency that it was designed for. OK. And I'll share these slides with you guys after this and just included some references, which we don't have to go over here. But yeah, so sorry, that was a big info dump. Happy to take questions or start to pick at things.

[Brenda Pike]: I've got a question, actually. I was wondering what sort of chemicals there are in engineered wood fiber, because it sounds like it's not just straight wood.

[Amanda Centrella]: Hmm. And that is a good question. I don't know off the top of my head. I do know it's like a treated wood. But that is treated in such a way it's different from like just wood chips. Like it's a much softer, kind of fibrous feeling material. But yeah, I'm sorry. I don't know off the top of my head, but I'm happy to look into it.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: I think something that the committee had talked about back when we first brought this up. Um, mostly we're really concerned over the propagation of PFAS, especially around children. Uh, we were wondering what opportunities you see for, uh, for making these switches. Is like DPW and like the parks, uh, or is the park service, uh, looking to make these changes? Are schools talking about making these switches? And are there avenues for us to begin helping educate folks and help make this switch away from these rather toxic materials?

[Amanda Centrella]: I think that it's probably worth a bigger conversation than with just me. I know our recreation director, Kevin Bailey, would be a great resource to kind of in-person pull into this discussion. I think something for context. So this may not be what you all want to hear, and I'm very open to pushback. But by comparison to a lot of our neighbors, I'll have to get some counts for you all. We have four artificial turf fields across the city, and that's actually a relatively small amount. There isn't a desire from what I've understood to switch any or most of our natural grass fields to artificial turf, and there's not in less, and in fact, there are lots of reasons why you wouldn't want to decide if we're setting aside the environmental piece, which is obviously a very key and essential part of this, but from just like some other lenses, like you wouldn't even want to bother thinking about turf at a field that doesn't have lights already, because you're introducing obviously unwanted pollutants into the environment. You are, you know, it's a huge cost to install initially, And then you don't get to make use of the true benefit of this artificial turf is the playable hours. So unless you have lights, you're really losing out on the ability to recoup on some of those benefits of this type of a system.

So all that said, I think, like, with the city's sort of portfolio, if you will, of play fields. I don't think that there's a strong interest in switching any of them to turf. But I will say that the turf fields that we have are our most heavily used fields in the city. And if we were to switch them to a different type of system, or I guess mainly back to natural grass, it would mean a very big, it would be a huge impact to the way that we program in the city.

I'm not saying that that doesn't mean it's not worth it, but that it would, you know, that that's something for us to think about as a group. The other challenge with our fields is that a lot of them were spaces that were converted into a park use after historically being used for probably not great things like landfill and dumping sites. And so retrofitting the fields like we did to some of these uses, soccer, football, et cetera, means that we can't take advantage of some of the best practices that we normally would for being able to have better maintained natural grass fields. So we can't, you know, there are, to the extent that we're able to, we like to rest fields. So we will like alternate use of them, you know, between or during season so that at some time, you know, this field is resting while we use this one, and you can manage some of the level of wear.

unfortunately, there's not always an ability to do that. Or another thing that we would do, and again, we do employ it where we can, is to re-stripe fields in such a way that like you're, so if you're re-striping them, the level of wear isn't happening in the same exact places over the course of the whole year. So even if you're just, you know, maybe you don't have a full other field to rest and like alternate with, but if you have just a little bit of extra space, you can restripe and kind of move the wear to different parts. And like that makes it manageable. Um, so there are some fields where we can do that, but there are some that we can't, and that's another kind of limiting factor, um, just based on like the type and shape of space that we have available. I do think that there are things that on our turf fields we can do to mitigate some, not all, of the impacts that we're all thinking about, particularly around heat. So these turf fields are not great for, they absorb a lot more heat than natural grass. And so therefore, I think it makes a lot of sense to pair these fields with trees, with other sorts of opportunities for shade. There might be an opportunity to incorporate better landscaping for water catchment in and around those areas, but it's not a perfect way to address all of the impacts of that material. Sorry, that was a very long-winded answer. Yeah.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I just wanted to say that there's an argument to be made about physiologic safety versus physical safety. So I don't know if that has sort of percolated into the city's conversations about using artificial turf. You know, my concern has always been that these materials, we don't understand the long-term effects of these things, and they're just beginning to be realized. And so it would be good if the city could at least going forward, try to put in place some sort of testing, some sort of assessment of exposure. I don't know. It's not terribly expensive to have it tested for PFAS.

I know when kids run on artificial turf, they absorb the PFAS through through skin. They also inhale some of it too, particularly on hot days. Having coached in Medford for 11 years of soccer, I played many games on the turf in high school. And good God, that stuff gets into absolutely everywhere in your underwear. in your pockets, just everywhere. So, you know, perhaps a consideration about if the infill can be PFAS-free, if the infill can be tested prior to, you know, maintenance of these fields. They do require maintenance, I know that. I've seen that done.

These conversations, I think, need to be had in the city. And particularly, it's important to have that with the playgrounds where little kids play. I mean, they are the most susceptible cohort in having having some prevention applied to their exposure to these things. I suppose I'm framing this more like a comment slash question. I don't know if the city plans to have these conversations. You know, these are things you have to consider going forward. New playgrounds obviously will be made, but I would personally prefer not to have any sort of PFAS. And I work with chemicals all my life, so I know the I have a feel for the matter, if you can appreciate that.

[Amanda Centrella]: Absolutely. I want to address one quick thing, Paul, before other folks, just to make sure it's clear. So PFAS found in artificial turf, yes. Not found, as far as the studies that are out there, not found in poured-in-place rubber, which is what is used in playground-like surfaces. So I think, and I don't, you know, I have seen artificial turf used for playgrounds. I would personally not recommend that route for lots of the reasons we're talking about here. And I just think that the poured in place rubber or like some combination of that with engineered wood fiber would be a far better alternative. So just want to make sure that there's this distinction, but yes, hear you on the, on your points around like, Exposure and testing.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Thank you for waiting.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Oh, yeah, um, I. You mentioned that there's not a sort of, like, active effort to look at places with new turf. I was like, doing a very brief scan of the. 2029 SRP extension. And it looks like the only place where there might be a chance of turf coming into the conversation, from my reading of it as a non-expert, is that perhaps in the opportunities for lighting at Tufts Park and expansion of those facilities, that might be a place where community members or folks involved in that planning process might advocate for turf there to extend the playing hours. Is that something you've seen or expect or maybe something this committee might be beneficial in heading off.

[Amanda Centrella]: I think that's a very fair point, Josh. I have not personally heard much yet from community members on advocating for turf, but I imagine that if we get lighting at the playground, or sorry, at the park more generally, and there becomes an opportunity for funding to um, address some of the challenges at that park and, like, revisit design, it could certainly come up. Um, and I think that it would be really like an appropriate thing to for the city to involve this committee in, like, its outreach efforts during that point. There are a lot of challenges with, um, drainage and flooding at that park with those fields and, like, overall maintenance of those fields. Um, so I don't know. I know that there is some effort now it's through DPW. So it's a bit outside of like what I'm, I'm not in the weeds on it, but I know that DPW is working to.

on some interventions to help with the flooding. To my knowledge, none of those interventions have anything to do with artificial turf. I also don't know if they would preclude artificial turf in the future. So I can get a little bit more information for you all on what's going on there and where that stands. And yeah, happy to kind of raise it with some of my colleagues who work on the programming end of this to understand if there'd be a desire from the community or from city staff to consider turf.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Final questions from Barry, please.

[Barry Ingber]: So yeah, I have first, thank you, Amanda. This is like really helpful, really informative. And I feel like I much better understand what's going on out there as a result of your talk. I also want to comment on Paul was being modest. He's actually a chemist with expertise in this arena. So you should know that.

[Amanda Centrella]: Good to know, Paul, you understood yourself.

[Barry Ingber]: So I have some comments, but I'm going to hold on those. I first just have questions. So I just want to make sure I understand properly that there's no crumb rubber or any kind of infill in the playground turf.

[Amanda Centrella]: In the playground, in the port in place, like rubber, yeah, that is not crumb rubber. It's an EPDM rubber. Sorry, I don't know exactly what that means, but I do know from what I've been able to gather online, and maybe Paul, you can confirm or otherwise, that there isn't PFAS typically associated with that.

[Barry Ingber]: Okay, the second question is, you didn't mention car park, which is my neighborhood park, and which when I saw turf newly installed in there was kind of what set me off on bringing the whole issue to the committee.

[Amanda Centrella]: There's no artificial turf at car park, but I'm wondering if I'm misunderstanding

[Barry Ingber]: It's in the playground. The park itself is natural. The playing fields are natural. But there is, I guess, what's poured in place in the playgrounds. And OK, those didn't get mentioned. OK, I just wanted to confirm my reality here. How are these installations? I mean, you referred to high upfront costs. And given that, and I know that a major source of funding for our playground and recreational projects is CPA funds. And CPA funds can't be used for artificial turf. So I wonder how you're paying for it.

[Amanda Centrella]: Yeah, so artificial turf and poured in place surface are two different things. So we can use CPA funding for poured in place, which is that material that you saw at car park, for example. And it's just a flat rubber kind of bouncy, not super bouncy, but surfaced, versus artificial turf looks like fake grass. So yes, so just to clarify there, artificial turf, you're right. There are limited funding sources for that type of a product. CPA does not allow it. I think there's a state grant that we often go out for.

excuse me, that I think also it's not eligible for. So I'd have to look at, I mean, that said, CDBG funding might, if the project qualifies, may pay for something like that. I don't think that there's the same type of restrictions with that CDBG funding. And I'd have to look at other grants. I'm not sure.

[Barry Ingber]: And another question is, I'm really curious about, I know that antimicrobials are really, are commonly part of artificial turf. I don't know if they're part of the port in place, and I don't know if they're safe, and maybe Paul would know that. But I just get concerned about all kinds of chemical treatments, and I'm concerned about in the case of antimicrobials, whether they're safe for humans, especially very young humans. But then I'm secondarily concerned about whether they're safe for the environment, because anything that kills microbes is killing the basic foundations of how our ecosystems work.

So yeah, so I'm just interested in knowing whether those are included in any of the products that we're using, and what they are, and what is known about their safety.

[Amanda Centrella]: Really good question. So for poured in place, which again is that playground rubber, antimicrobial treatment is not common or not usually used. We don't use it, to my knowledge. Cleaning that surface, you might power wash it with water. The artificial turf, I do know that it is more common to use an antimicrobial treatment. I don't know if the city does, but I'm happy to inquire on behalf of this committee. I could reach out to our DPW on what I had reached out to them this past week. But understandably, they've been a little bit bogged down with the snow. So I will follow up with them to get a better understanding of like, what is the maintenance that's overall been involved. And I can ask specifically about that.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I just wanted to mention that APDM rubber is I think it's ethylene polypropylene. It is generally free of PFAS, but when they mold it, Some manufacturers do add PFAS to the molding so that the bits of it, you know, the molded product gets released faster from the mold. So some intrusion into the material happens because of that process. But in general, it's better than the artificial turf. So I guess it depends where you buy it from and who manufactures it. And whether we do due diligence to know whether they're using PFAS. I mean, they're so useful in so many manufacturing processes that it's no surprise. When you put chemists in charge of making stuff, we go out of our way to make it happen.

Me included. That's the issue. You just, I think it would be worthwhile for the city to find out who makes it and if they use PFAS in the mold process.

[Amanda Centrella]: I wonder if a helpful, I'm sorry to cut you off, Paul, go ahead.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: No, no, no, go ahead, I finished.

[Amanda Centrella]: I was thinking, I wonder if like a helpful action item out of this would be, so the way that city procurement, public procurement works is like, Oftentimes, so this material costs tens of hundreds of thousands of dollars depending on the surface area. So that triggers, you know, a formal procurement process. that sometimes leaves things outside of the hands of the city as far as who we source from. Because you put together a list of specifications and drawings, and then you get a list of people who are applying or companies that apply. And you have to choose the lowest bidder. And as long as they meet all of the qualifications. So I think maybe an interesting action item out of this could be like, could we insert some language into our typical specifications for this so that moving forward, a manufacturer has to not use PFAS in the molding process or within the process of treating this material. So at the very least, it's a criteria that the city can point to when we go out to bid. Excuse me.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Sure. Yeah. I want to be mindful of time. I know Barry probably has a pretty substantial list, but.

[Barry Ingber]: I have not. It's not substantial at this point, but I just have a couple of comments. One is that my temperature was highest around the playgrounds, and you've certainly lowered it. I'm not quite at 98.6, but I'm under 100. so I don't have to go to the doctor. Two concerns. One is that even if we pretend that these systems are completely chemically benign, and they're not, but even if we pretend that they are And even if we make them permeable to water, they are still ecological deserts.

They are dead zones, completely dead zones. And I just don't think it's a great idea to be creating dead zones all over the place. The other issue is, that as committed as the city is to zero waste to the point where we don't want to pick up people's trash anymore, to be laying down tons and tons of plastic that is not recyclable and it has to be thrown into the landfill seems to me insane. So I don't know how to even look at those two things at the same time. And that's all I have to say.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: With that. Amanda, you've given us truly a lot to think about. So I really appreciate you coming in and staying for far more than I expected, but you gave us more than I had hoped for. So I really appreciate it. This is a phenomenal starting point. This is something I was getting very excited about, and I'm glad you were too. And we can begin the process of parsing through all the things that need to be talked about. So as you learn more, please keep us in the loop. We want to be the first to know.

[Lauretta James]: Thank you.

[Amanda Centrella]: Great. Thank you, everyone.

[Lauretta James]: Very informative. Thanks, Amanda. Yeah. Thank you so much for coming.

[Amanda Centrella]: Oh, yes. Happy to be here. And I would just say, conversation progresses a bit more, I would, again, up to you guys, but I'd highly recommend we bring in recreation director, Kevin Bailey, so that we can kind of understand like from a programmatic perspective a bit more. Thank you all so much.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Thank you. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thanks.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: I have Kevin Bailey starred in my notes. He'll be going on to our guest speakers list in short order as we talk through things. So our agenda is gonna be a little out of sorts right now. So we're gonna make some small amendments, but I want to, I'll talk about that in a minute. Let's go to our city updates. And a final thought on artificial turf. If you do have questions, if you have more things you want to relay, send them to myself, to Brenda. We'll make sure that everyone hears this.

I think this is a really important conversation that we're just starting. So hopefully that was helpful. But let's go to our city updates.

[Brenda Pike]: Great, and I will try to rush through these so that we have time for other things, but feel free to ask any questions or make any comments as we go along. First off, there were a couple of things where you may have gotten letters in the mail that were confusing about, so I just want to make sure that everybody's aware. So for the electricity aggregation, every six months we do a sweep of of new National Grid basic service customers in Medford to pull them into the aggregation.

But this in December, about 1500 people had already opted out before were mistakenly sent a letter saying that they would be opted in unless they opted out, which created a lot of confusion. And it took us a little bit to figure out what had happened there. And then a new letter explaining it was sent out. So you may hear from other residents that, you know, upset because they opted out once before and we tried to pull them back in again or something like that. That's what happened there. And then also, oh, yeah, Josh.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: could this committee be involved in trying to do the work of opting them back in and convincing them to do that? Or is there some sort of like, when they opt out, they're also signing up for like a, and never talk to me about it again, kind of clause?

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, I mean, our policy is to not reach back out to them. And people get very upset if we they're contacted again about it. So I think you know, we can do some outreach around the aggregation in general, but that's not targeted to those particular people, but just citywide to let people know more about it.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Um, and that's probably just thinking about us as like an alternate body. That's not like from the city proper.

[Brenda Pike]: Okay. Yeah. Yeah. I don't think we could do targeted outreach to them from this group. Yeah. Um, And so we also may be revising the aggregation plan that we file with the Department of public utilities. This is really more of a formality because they changed the. Uh, the, the way that they require plans to be made, and they've really simplified things a lot. And by doing this, we sort of set ourselves up to make it easier in the future to make changes, but we won't be making any changes to the pricing or anything. It's just really a formality. But 1 thing that we might. be able to write into the plan at this point is the option to automatically opt low income residents into the basic rate, the basic option, because we have the three and the default one is the middle one. which has 10% additional renewable energy.

And so we hear from a lot of people saying, well, if a customer is already on the low income discount rate, why not just make them automatically go to your lowest price that you have available, which makes sense and is something that we couldn't do with the way that the plan was written in the past. So doing this, we could set up to do that. What are your thoughts on that? Do you think that's a good idea?

[Barry Ingber]: Yes, and I think that the economic range of people who are on the discount plan is pretty broad, and people in the upper part of that range might be perfectly willing to opt up to the standard Medford plan instead of the least expensive Medford plan. But I think that they should be given that option, and their starting point should be the lowest cost plan.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, I think this makes sense. So this is something putting this plan together. Something we'll be pursuing over the next few months. And we, there is a public notification period. So we would be once we have that together, getting the word out to residents and getting feedback on that before finally filing it with the Department of public utilities.

[Barry Ingber]: And feel free to reach out to me, given my particular background on that issue.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, absolutely. OK, and a lot of similar lines here. You might have gotten letters from National Grid talking about installing smart meters. So this is something that's starting in March. but they sent out the wrong letter, and they sent a letter out to people saying that they had already been replaced, which was not the case, when they should have been saying, in 60 days, we'll be starting to replace smart meters in your community. So I'm meeting with National Grid next week to get more information about this, and especially about the timeline. And then I'm going to work with Medford's communications team to do some outreach about it, just because I want to make sure that residents are aware of this and be, you know, know some best practices in terms of making sure that if somebody comes to your home and says, you have a meter inside and they need to get into your home, make sure you're checking their. their badge and their identification to make sure they're actually who they say they are and not someone taking advantage of this happening to try to scam you somehow.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I did find it interesting though that if you opt to have the old meter, you have to pay. If you opt to have the smart meter, You don't have to pay.

[Brenda Pike]: Yep. That's what they're saying. It's a monthly fee of, I think, $26 for manual meter reads. Yeah.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: And so this is, you know, this is a conspiracy world. I always think anybody installing smart anything is, is, doing more than just reading of electricity. And I don't know. And obviously, I'm just kidding about this. But where does that information go? We talked to National Grid about electrical usage goes I know they're doing this so that they can probably meter what's coming through the grid a little bit better and sort of manage that electricity during high demand times.

[Brenda Pike]: Now, National Grid in general is pretty good about customer privacy to the point where it's frustrating to me sometimes because I want information about how many Medford residents have installed heat pumps using the Mass Save rebates and things like that. And it's really hard for me to get that information because they're so concerned about privacy. So I, yeah, so I would expect that they would have similar concerns around smart meter data too.

[Lauretta James]: Brenda?

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah.

[Lauretta James]: So later on, this is Loretta. So later in the meeting, you gave me a couple of minutes to talk about this. So should I interject now?

[Brenda Pike]: Oh, sorry. Yes. I didn't realize we were getting into that later. I would have saved this for later.

[Lois Grossman]: But I have a question about what you just said. Loretta, could I clarify just something quick? Are we all getting these new meters? Yes. and we don't pay for them. You only pay if you don't get the new meter. Is that the idea?

[Brenda Pike]: Well, I mean, we're really all paying for them collectively through our, yeah, through our delivery charge on our bill, but yeah. Thank you.

[Lauretta James]: So, if you don't mind, since you're talking about now. Yeah. So that's, I had brought this up at, I don't know, the November or December meeting because I got this letter and then you wrote to me and I wrote back, but I didn't get a confirmation that you saw what I wrote, because you asked me if I got the letter, you know, did I get these letters? So the first letter didn't actually have a timeline or, you know, said that there was a cost. It really should have been much more clear. And then when I got your email, I thought, yeah, I think the city should.

um, send out notices because people may not, who are the contractors doing the work? You know, what kind of, you know, that's come out since then. And I did hear about on Facebook, many residents got the letter that it was already installed when it was like, when did they come to my house? So, um, my concern is I did hear from a resident saying, oh yeah, I heard it's expensive if you want to opt out. And I said, Oh, that's sad. I didn't want to say too much, but I had read from other groups from other states that they were being discharged $10. So when you said 26, somebody said 26, I was like, what?

So if you could, when you have that meeting with National Grid, you know, I think if you could bring that up there, you know, maybe there's a survey. I don't remember the group, but there are some people that are against having it for different reasons, like, you know, ear ringing and, you know, from what I read that they want to change them in the letter because the gears on the old one may run slower. So I wonder how much more of a bill, you know, I don't know if that's true or not, Yes, it's more data for national grid, but if you don't want it, that's really expensive, $26 a month. And my understanding is running all the time.

So whereas your normal meter, yes, it may be running. on a lower grade, if you have, you know, like a microwave plugged in or, you know, TV, smart TVs or things, but if it's monitoring all the time, how much of an increase would we expect? I know you don't have the answer.

[Brenda Pike]: Well, so there was some information in the national grid materials that were that were sent out with, like, on the website that they link to. Oh, I think it, it sends, it transmits, like, periodically throughout the day, but adding that all together, I think it only adds up to something like 15 minutes a day. Oh, really? Yeah. And the radio frequency concerns. Personally, I think they're overblown because like baby monitors have like seven times the exposure to radio frequency than smart meters, like video game controllers are like 30 times more. Smartphones are like 12,000 times more.

[Lauretta James]: Okay. Yeah, those are things that, you know, people have mentioned. And the other thing is, just to be careful when they are installing them, that they well, you have to be home anyways, that all your electricity is turned off. Someone had posted to make sure that you are home and that everything's turned off and you don't see sparks. And then I don't know the process of turning everything back on when there's been a change. So that would be interesting to question if you haven't done.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, it's not it doesn't sound like they're scheduling a date with people individually. So that's one of my questions is, are they notifying people the day the specific day that it's going to happen? Like, how is that working? Yeah, yeah.

[Lauretta James]: I mean, we should have appointments. So we're home. But I just wanted to say to the group that, you know, when you're having it done, make sure you talk through, I haven't had any experience with this, I've had the gas meter changed, and that was self-explanatory, they had to come in the house, they told me what they were doing, it was a really bad gas block. But electricity, we have it on all over the house, so we wanna make sure that the main breaker's off, or whatever they have to do.

And that was it, and I hope that you do proceed with them. Information for the public, you know, through the city. I think that's a great. And that was it.

[Barry Ingber]: Yeah, I mean, the price is that that's undoubtedly gone through a department of public utilities proceeding and that's done. It's not going to be changed. It's not going to be impacted at this point. The. Some years ago, the idea of smart meters was a hot topic in the low-income electricity consumers community because these meters were seen as an avenue to basically force people into time-of-day pricing so that how much you pay for electricity would depend on the time of day that you're using the electricity, which makes some economic sense since the cost of delivering that electricity to you varies over the course of the day and the course of the year. But the problem from the point of view of low-income advocates was that most people, and most especially lower-income people, don't have a whole lot of choice about when they run their electricity.

And so there was going to be some serious inequities introduced through that. So it's hard to know whether whether the purpose of this is for that. Time of day pricing would, in my opinion, though I don't know that it's ever been proposed, make a lot of sense for people who have solar on their roofs. Because in practice, when you run the meter backwards, you're getting you're getting paid at, you're paying at the lowest rate for the highest cost energy, and then you're selling at the average rate.

So, you're getting, It would make more sense if you're going to run meters backwards that you would pay people less for the electricity they produce during the day when it's least valuable. And then when they're using the electricity off the grid at night, that they're paying more. So you don't get a kilowatt hour for your kilowatt hour. You get maybe a kilowatt hour for two kilowatt hours, which is the actual financial cost to the system, the generation cost to the system. But I don't know that they're proposing that. But that would make net metering a lot less inequitable. Anyway. That's enough for that. I get one rant per month and that's my rant.

[Lauretta James]: I actually have two questions to what Barry said. Did you say it's a done deal as far as we were talking about the rate if you wanted to keep your old meter that that's already been sort of enacted and because Something's going to be challenged and I remember just reading this the past week that in order to have the discount that the state's proposing because of the high cost of energy for electricity and maybe heat too, I'm not sure, that they're going to spread the payments out. to individuals on their bill, but they're gonna charge interest. And so some senators, some representatives got involved with the state, I think it was just last week, and they had some kind of vote to a national grid, took that back that they will not be charging interest on the deferred payments for the utility.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, so that was during a Department of Public Utilities filing that they were putting through about that. So that was the time when that could be changed, is when the DPU was considering their plan.

[Lauretta James]: So you're saying not now, though, for this new proposal? That there are new meters?

[Brenda Pike]: If they're rolling it out, then the DPU has already approved it. Oh. I mean, it might be something in the future that they might change, but yeah.

[Lauretta James]: And then the other question was, or comment, when you were mentioning the solar, people have solar-generated electricity, I do remember that there were some people that got the new meters, and their bill was higher than when it was with solar. So I'm just wondering, that might have, I don't know. It's an interesting comment. That was all I was just curious about that.

[Brenda Pike]: Okay. Yeah, I don't know about that. Okay, moving on in the interest of time, we are planning to apply for a green schoolworks grant for solar on the Brooks, Roberts and Missittuck schools, and that will be done. after the roof repairs are done on those schools, which are happening, it's happening through an MSBA accelerated repair program. So installation wouldn't actually happen until like 2027, 2028, but we are applying for the grant this month. Nothing big for Electrify Medford, except we're doing Facebook ads this month.

We had the second meeting of the Medford High School sustainability advisory team, and they were just talking about the different aspects that they were focusing on when they're putting together some plans to compare, right? Looking at things like. energy efficiency, embodied carbon, health effects, cost effectiveness, and putting together different aspects and comparing them. So we have two more meetings, and then they'll put together, based on the feedback, they're putting together a feasibility study in August of this year.

And then schematic design will happen February of next year, and then the project will won't be completed until July of 2030. I thought you'd want to know climate equity council is planning a webinar on predatory electricity suppliers with someone from the attorney general's office who spoke at their last meeting. So we don't have a date for that yet, but that's in the works.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: And you'll send us an email when that date is.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, definitely. Yeah. And we're also planning... I'm sorry, could you clarify that a bit?

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: Traditory electricity suppliers?

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, so like the people who go door to door or like have tables outside of the grocery store or something and are like, oh, there's a really low introductory rate. But then, you know, it'll... jack up after six months and then there's a penalty for getting off it, something like that. So that's one of the reasons why our aggregation was created.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: National Grid is not the only supplier?

[Brenda Pike]: No, National Grid delivers the electricity to us, but you can get And that's 1 of the reasons why we have the aggregation right? In that case, we are choosing a supplier. Collectively for the, for the city, but a lot of people individually, not a lot of people. Some people will individually choose their own supplier. And a lot of times it's because they. were offered a $10 gift card outside of the grocery store or something and they don't necessarily know what they're signing up for. Or sometimes someone just gets a hold of their account number and signs them up for it without their knowledge.

[MCM00001610_SPEAKER_11]: I've never paid anyone other than National Grid for my electricity bill.

[Brenda Pike]: Well, it all comes through your National Grid bill, right? You'll see on your bill right now under Supply services, it'll save Medford electricity aggregation. And that's what these other suppliers would show.

[Lauretta James]: Sorry, on the bit. Paul, I have people knock on my door at least four or five times a year trying to get me to switch and they're very aggressive. You know, can I see your bill? I can save you all kinds of money. They're like, they don't know who they are. Doorbell. Oh, really? Yeah. So they try to get in a split and it can be really bad.

[Brenda Pike]: And they target low income. customers in particular, or like residents in like EJ communities. And it can really cost people a lot of money.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: We have a string of information via email that we've moved back and forth as a committee. I'll make sure that it's recent doubts you can skim it at your leisure.

[Brenda Pike]: Climate Equity Council is also planning energy bill checkup events with National Grid and ABCD, similar to what they did at the winter extravaganza. The first one is tentatively scheduled for March 18th at the senior center, but we're still trying, we're still confirming that. And then we're looking to get one scheduled at the West Bedford Community Center and maybe the library as well. And then also, they'd really like to get more involved with trees Medford work, like, working to get volunteers to help plant and water trees, particularly in environmental justice neighborhoods in the city.

The only other things are we have a new facilities manager for the schools and a new facilities manager for the rest of the city buildings. And I'm really excited at the opportunity with these new people coming in with enthusiasm and looking to make some changes. So I think this is a really great opportunity for us. Um, and then I just wanted to mention the high school is doing a commuter challenge. Um, students and teachers are tracking how they get to school. Um, and then tracking it on a map across the country with different goals that they're celebrating along the way. And they're looking to do some more outreach about that. So as they send along materials about it, um, we'll be sharing it obviously in like the city, um, resources, social media, things like that. But I'd love it if you guys could help to get the word out about that too.

That's it for my updates. Thank you for granting.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: In the interest of getting you guys out without too too much issue, I'm going to do a one-line summary of what I hope to perhaps just better done as an email and a brief discussion at next meeting. A follow-up to our trash amendments discussion, we've talked a lot about the issues in play for the pay-as-you-throw system and the biweekly pickup. I'd love to compile a list of potential amendments and recommendations that could create a more equitable and accessible and sustainable option for this system. So something to brainstorm over the next month or two, and we can discuss when we have the time.

And I'll also probably have to cut Josh short, but if you'd like to at least introduce this project, if you think we have the time, I'd love to hear from you, Josh.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: All right, I'm also doing my new technique to get this coach here, which is minute taking. It's hard to jump between the mute button and not. So, um, and the last year, um, we have the committee talked about, um, serving in a sort of watchdog function. I mean, that's too aggressive Brenda, but like, as a, as a accountability partner, uh, for the city, uh, in tracking progress on the climate action plan, um, I'm going to throw a big spreadsheet into the chat. I promise it's not as scary as it looks, but Will and Brendan and I developed a breakdown of all of the different actions in the Climate Action Plan.

and have set, I think, a system that might work for us to set a member of this committee as an outreach volunteer, and then have us sort of provide small updates on each of the many, many actions in this plan, as well as kind of get a universal system for completion status, so we can have a bit more of a quantitative review of the work we're doing, not just the sort of qualitative updates that are written. So I've done a first attempt at getting an update from city staff on objective B1 on new buildings and redevelopment.

What that entailed was just as email to Brenda and a couple of her colleagues the office that are highlighted in this spreadsheet as the city steward and awaiting their feedback. And when there's more specific stuff to do, or a different steward, or a different sort of body that's related to this work, say like Affordable Housing Trust is one of those actions, can reach directly out to the new Affordable Housing Trust. The hope is over the year to work through the various actions and do it sort of objective by objective in each meeting. And just to sum it up, my hope is that folks on this committee would like to volunteer for a certain subsection of the Climate Action Plan to be holding as the committee steward. So maybe for next meeting, we can take the time to look at this between now and and identify which sections folks would feel comfortable volunteering to be responsible for.

[Lauretta James]: Are you going to email that to us?

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Yes, I put it in the chat or I will put it in the chat and that'll also be emailed out I'm sure.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: We'll email it out, and at any point, you can reach out to us and say, hey, I feel very strongly about this objective. I'd like to see to it personally. And we can provide email templates. We can make sure that things are as easy for you as possible. But we'd love to just get extra eyes, extra hands, extra people to work on these.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_29]: This is great. I'm super excited to help with it. I opened the spreadsheet. So do you want us to just go through? So I see a lot of tabs. There's the B, E. There's a T tab with the T3. So just go through the tabs and see what speaks to us and add our names as outreach volunteer. Is that how you want us to?

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Yeah, there's no harm in just directly going in and claiming a section of interest. And if you're interested in something and Lois is also interested in that, for instance, don't feel like it can only be just you alone. If there's two people, that's not violating open meeting law. So things and actions can totally be tag-teamed.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_29]: Awesome. Yeah. And then the other thing I think Will already mentioned, like you had mentioned you already reached out to a couple of folks just so just like kind of what the body of the email or like an email template would be helpful. Awesome.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Our initial email was also like seeking feedback from city staff on like what kind of questions would be helpful. So once I get a reply from them and some guidance on like how they'd like to be contacted, hopefully we can give you a more actionable template.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_29]: Yeah, I can imagine trial and error. Awesome. Board gets a response.

[Lauretta James]: Yeah, I just before the end of the meeting, I don't know if you're if you're done with that, I'll just. OK, OK, so tomorrow night, Trees Medford is having an event at the library at 7 o'clock and that's to discuss and present the plans for the Tufts Park Mini Forest, which Preetha knows about. And it's also on Zoom if you can't attend. I have the Zoom ID if anybody wants to write this down. It's Zoom ID 815-1134-1653.

and it's only an hour, seven to eight. But I was thinking of the Climate Equity Council, Brenda, when you mentioned they'd like to get involved with trees and that fits well. Maybe you could pass that to them because they will be looking for volunteers to help plant this forest at Tufts Park in the future. Thank you.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Plastic new business. Yes, I take for granted the fact that not everyone might be on those email chains.

[Unidentified]: Right.

[Brenda Pike]: Can I do a quick plug for Pollinator Gardens?

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: I really want to hear it.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah, we can talk about it in more detail next week. But I spoke with Lisa Coliani in the mayor's office, and she's really excited if people are interested in helping with Pollinator Gardens. She said there's a there's actually a website with different locations around like adopt a site, things around the city that people could sign up for or suggest new locations. But there are four sites in particular that were supposed to be pollinator gardens and that were planted and have since not been taken care of at all. And she would really love to start with, if people are interested in volunteering for that, like actually fixing those up and getting those in good shape and then expanding outward from there.

[Lauretta James]: Okay. Could you send that out in an email, Brenda? Because I think Paul might, if he has the time, remember Paul had actually given out a lot of seeds at different events, have a strategy, you know, for pollinating.

[Brenda Pike]: Yeah.

[Lauretta James]: And they had posters about that. So that would be, if you could email us.

[Brenda Pike]: And the city does actually have some funding for, you know, tools and supplies and things like that. If people need it to do this work. Yeah. Wow.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: putting together an action item email block. So expect a truly tremendous email that'll just have a checklist of all the cool stuff we've talked about today and all the fun action items so that we can get involved. I guess February is going to be a big month. With that, is there any new agenda? Anything we're missing?

[Lois Grossman]: Nothing missing, but we did send out That note about the black plastic and we would like people to be ready to vote to do something about it at the next meeting.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Yes, I will make sure that we send out 1 renewed action item. On this black plastic, including perhaps I believe you're looking at a few different items.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_29]: Yeah, this is the document that I believe you and Brenda have given feedback on. So if the rest of the committee wants to take a look at it. And then we had proposed two discussion items. So if you can include those, that'll be awesome. Yes. Thank you.

[SPEAKER_00]: I would just I would just add, I would like to hear what people think about the The notion of having a compost only for takeout and how that impacts what else is going on with compostables and garbage pickup and strategy about how to move forward on those kinds of things and how they conflict and support each other. If people could spend a little bit of time thinking about that. So when we talk about it, so one quick example. Let's assume that only 50% of people would actually compost even if their containers were compostable, but 90% would recycle. Are we better off with the containers being recyclable containers or compostable containers? That's just an example of the kind of intricacies of thinking about the issue that it would be great to have people's feedback on.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: It's fantastic. I will relay the memo and those prompts for our action item email. So, everyone can expect a truly tremendous thing. And hopefully it will give you a lot to do while you're still snowed in. Fantastic. Oh, my gosh. This is so exciting. I love all of this. I wish there were more hours in the day. Is there anything I'm missing?

[SPEAKER_00]: I appreciate your enthusiasm.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Is there anything we're missing? Any new business, any old business I forgot about that should be new business?

[Barry Ingber]: I move to adjourn.

[Unidentified]: I second.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Fantastic. Any opposed? No, seeing none. Get out of here. Enjoy the rest of your evening. I will see you all March 2nd, but expect to email sooner.

[Josh Ekhart-Lee]: Or see some of y'all tomorrow at the trees meeting.

[rov34HMcKiU_SPEAKER_27]: Yes, I will see y'all hopefully in person. It's so nice to do it in person and I'll see you in a minute. Well, yes, I'll talk to you later. Very.

[Barry Ingber]: So, yeah, everyone record.



Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Energy & Environment Committee