Historical Commission 1/12/26

AI-generated transcript — the recording is the record.

AI-generated summary. Written by gemini-3-flash-preview from the transcript below, which is the record. It may be incomplete or wrong; it does not report votes. Every item links to the moment it began.

The commission found 36 Mystic Street significant, initiating a public hearing process, and accepted demolition applications for 17 Sharon and 85 Marshall Streets with conditions. The chair also provided major updates regarding the exhumation of the former Cross Street Cemetery and ongoing archaeological surveys.

  1. 0:42 36 Mystic Street Determination of Significance — Determined the property is significant due to its Italianate architecture and historical integrity, moving the project to a public hearing. The owner clarified that proposed work is primarily interior renovation and exterior maintenance.
  2. 16:32 17 Sharon Street Demolition Application — Accepted the demolition application contingent on the applicant providing graphic elevations and sketches showing the scope of change. The commission will hire a consultant to complete a historical inventory form for the property.
  3. 19:49 85 Marshall Street Demolition Application — Accepted the demolition application with conditions requiring additional architectural drawings for proposed alterations. The commission will proceed with a determination of significance next month.
  4. 21:43 Medford Square Zoning Discussion — Discussed an upcoming joint meeting on Medford Square zoning, with members emphasizing the need for historic building protections and potential design guidelines within the plan.
  5. 30:14 Commission Membership and Appointments — Provided updates on the appointment process for two new commissioners and invited further public interest for remaining vacancies.
  6. 32:53 41 Mystic Street Preservation — Discussed establishing a local historic district to preserve the 18th-century structure due to its historical ties to slavery and the Hall family. The chair noted the potential for relocating the building to a city-owned lot to prevent demolition.
  7. 36:58 Brooks Estate and Thomas Brooks Park Archaeological Surveys — Reported that the Brooks Estate survey is out to bid and that lab work for artifact cleaning at Thomas Brooks Park is moving into its next phase. Recent excavations at Thomas Brooks Park identified an 18th-century trash midden with artifacts correlating to the site's history of enslaved people.
  8. 41:11 Cross Street Cemetery Restoration and Exhumation — Announced that the project to remove the City Hall parking lot for the exhumation of remains from the former Cross Street Cemetery is going out to bid. The commission is also seeking funding to restore 85 headstones at the current cemetery site.
  9. 50:05 Hastings Heights and Brooks Estate Neighborhood Surveys — Confirmed that the Hastings Heights survey has commenced and outlined plans to apply for grants to survey the Brooks Estate neighborhood in 2027.
  10. 51:12 Approval of Minutes — Approved meeting minutes and adjourned the meeting.
Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Historical Commission

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Good evening, everybody. This is the Medford Historical Commission's January 2026 meeting. So I will call this meeting to order at 7.03 p.m. Start with the governor's statement. On March 28, 2025, Governor Healey signed into law a bill which extends the temporary provisions pertaining to the open meeting on to June 30, 2027. specific. This further extension allows public bodies to continue holding meetings remotely without a quorum of the public body physically present at a meeting location and to provide adequate alternative access to remote meetings. Language does not make any substantive changes to the open meeting law other than extending the expiration date.

All right, with that out of the way, we'll go over to our agenda, which starts with 36 Mystic commissioners. I sent around the paperwork for this property. It is being reviewed for partial demolition. I'll take a motion to accept the application as submitted, unless you find it's incomplete.

[Peter Miller]: I will make a motion to accept the demolition application.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Thank you, Peter. And a second?

[Kit Collins]: I'll second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK. And Kit Nichols seconded. OK, we'll go around roll call vote. Peter?

[Doug Carr]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Doug?

[Doug Carr]: No, actually. OK.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yes, one. No, one. Sorry. What am I missing? Peter, Doug, Kit, sorry that you are.

[Kit Collins]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, great. So the motion passes two to one approved. Okay, next up we have the determination of significance. Commissioners, I sent around the MHC form B. I'll take a motion one way or the other to kickstart discussion of this property.

[Doug Carr]: I'll make a motion to find the property significant.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great, and a second?

[Peter Miller]: I can second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, thank you, Peter. All right, Doug, go ahead.

[Doug Carr]: Yeah, I think the Form B is pretty clear that this building has got a lot of integrity, a lot of beautiful details. It's grown over the years. Obviously, it's been added on to a few times. some really fine details. It's one of the oldest residential buildings in that neighborhood. I'm pleased to see that the applicant is looking to keep that building and do it, restore it, or at least make some significant changes. But I think this building needs to be protected from the outside as well as the in.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Peter, next.

[Peter Miller]: Good points there, Doug. I walked by the property this morning. It does have some really interesting details on it that I actually hadn't seen before. The window casing trim is quite unique. It's got some ornamental brackets along the eave there that you really can't, don't show up very well in the photograph. that are quite ornate. I don't know if they're original, original, or at the time of the first edition to add the fourth bay to the front there, but it looks like there's some existing window sashes. Again, I don't know if those are original, original, or, you know, like a first wave of changes, but there's some vinyl on the side, vinyl windows, but the windows on the front seem to be pretty old and same way with the doors.

And I think it had a quite interesting history with the local people who were involved with it at the time. And so I think this one rises to the level of significant and at least is worthy of taking a look at. I was also encouraged by the fact that the footprint's going to be left intact and everything like that. My two cents.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Thank you, Peter.

[Kit Collins]: I don't really have anything to add to what Peter and Doug had to say. I mean, I think the Form B makes a pretty compelling case for its history, and it seems largely intact. And I'm delighted that it will, that apparently it's going to stay that way.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, with some changes, but we want to make sure we review it. Great, I'll add my two cents for this particular property, and then I'll acknowledge the general public may have some questions. This is a really interesting example of Italian architecture, so it's almost, For a while, early houses built in the mid to last quarter of the 19th century really held on to that box-like shape. And this is a perfect example where it has just a very box main massing with a hip roof on top of it. And it's, you know, there are other more elaborate examples of this style of architecture in West Medford on the other side of the railroad tracks. On this side, it's more later Victorian style Queen Anne architecture. And just so the community is aware, the commission's current survey and planning project that reviews and documents all of the buildings is focused on this particular neighborhood right now. It's known as Hastings Heights. It was a development that was started in the 1850s. and carried through to the first quarter of the 20th century. But the bulk of it was built out before 1890, and this is a good relative example of the type of houses that we're going to find in this neighborhood, which are well-preserved large buildings on large lots that are subject to potential change.

I don't know. Yeah, go ahead.

[Doug Carr]: Just one other comment before we open up to former Councilor Caraviello and others in the public. I would say that most of the time, the Form Bs are judgment calls. They almost always are. But this one wasn't really much of a judgment call for me because the evidence was pretty overwhelming in terms of significance. I think beyond the social history, the architecture, I think there's a lot there. And I would say that even though the proponents are not proposing to add to this property, it clearly could be a future addition that I think could be quite well done in the future. I see the ability to replace that garage and possibly put more units and still do it in a sympathetic way. So I think there are some development opportunities in the future So I think you can have the best of both worlds here. Preserve the building, restore the building, and potentially add on in the future to get some additional housing in Manfred and additional income because it's a significant investment for the owners who bought this property. Anyway, that's my statement.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. We don't normally take comments for the procedure for determination of significance, but I'll make an exception for tonight because we have such a light agenda. So I'm going to acknowledge Councilor Carr-Viello, you have your hand up, so name and address for the record, please.

[Richard Caraviello]: Hi, Rick Carr-Viello, 74 Prescott Street in Medford. Thank you, Mr. Chair.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Nope, I lost you for a second there. Hold on. There you go.

[Richard Caraviello]: You're good? Yep. Again, thank you for taking my questions, David. I just got a couple of questions. I think earlier in the meeting, did you say this was for a partial demolition?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Correct. The owners are not planning to tear down the entire building, but they're making changes to the interior enough where it impacts the exterior. So they're changing windows, doors, siding, removing partial decks, rebuilding them. So enough to qualify it for review.

[Richard Caraviello]: Okay. When would, if this demolition were to happen, when would it start and how soon would the project start immediately after, if you grant approval or not, or will it sit around for a while?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, I think the owners are planning on moving forward with this project immediately. They were halted during the review for permitting for this project. So it's an immediate project. And in terms of the review process, our review process is a two step. We determine either it's significant or not. If it's not, the project can move forward. If it is significant tonight, by definition, then it has to hold a public hearing, which will happen in 30 days. And then from there, it could face up to an 18 month demo delay, during which time the onus would be on the owner to mitigate the demolition. And, you know, the demolition is enough to warrant review, but it could be that they might be willing to roll back some of their demolition to uh, help mitigate that and just, uh, you know, the commission is very willing and wants to see projects move forward. So.

[Richard Caraviello]: And thank you. Um, are the owners planning on living in there?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Uh, that I do not know. I don't believe so. I believe it is owned by a company right now, but I can.

[Richard Caraviello]: And, um, are they, uh, cause unless the zoning law is changing this neighborhood, uh, that side of the street is, is, uh, is an SF one. Why? Yes, it is.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: It is planned for a single.

[Richard Caraviello]: Okay. It's not a plan to say, and then I understand if they want to put an accessory dwelling, that's, that's a whole nother thing, but, uh, uh, that was it. There's a, and, um, that's it. Thank you for your time.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Thank you. So I'll acknowledge you. Go ahead. Name and address for the record, please.

[CAS00002340_SPEAKER_04]: Uh, this is a BJ. Uh, so I'm the owner of the 36, uh, mystic street property.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. And just to clarify, your intent is to redevelop this property and resale it, right?

[CAS00002340_SPEAKER_04]: Yeah. So with the real estate market, it's hard to tell. So I might keep it as a rental property after renovation. So I also want to point out, it's a little hard to see when people say demolition, it means that we are demoting the building. but the scope of the work is only interior. The exterior, I'm not really doing any exterior work, just maintaining, meaning I'll be changing the windows, the siding, just some patching and then painting. I'm not doing any additional work to the siding. It's really the scope of the work, mainly like interior and maybe exterior, any deck, wood, any rotten wood I will replace, but nothing is changing really outside other than maintenance work.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great, thank you. Just hold on, Doug. I didn't get your address, Vijay.

[CAS00002340_SPEAKER_04]: Number 11, Granton, G-R-A-N-T-O-N, Granton Park, Arlington. But the 36 Mystic Street is, Medford is my property.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, great. That's so yeah, we just need it for the record for our meeting minutes. Okay, great. Any other questions? Ken, I'll acknowledge your name and address for the record.

[Krause]: Thank you. Yes. My name is Ken Krauss. Excuse me. I live at 50 mystic street, about five houses up a mystic from this property. Uh, I just want to support the, um, commission as it, uh, pursues the determination of, uh, significance on this property. Um, I haven't seen the foreign B I'm not sure what's in there, but, um, this, um, property is sort of a, of a bedrock to the neighborhood, uh, that, Has a lot of historical significance and ties to judge Lawrence Brooks and the Hallowell families, which I think at 1 point lived in this house. So some members of the family. So there was a walking tour by D Morris of this 2 block area in 2018. I don't know if that's referenced in the form B, but if it's not, it would be very helpful in terms of. understanding the historical significance of this property to the neighborhood. So I will look forward to future opportunities to comment officially if there's a public hearing. Thank you.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great, thanks. Anybody else? All right, hearing none, I'm just going to quickly hopefully share in the chat feature the MHC form B so everybody can see it just in advance of the potential public hearing, which might follow. Okay, commissioners, any other comments, questions, concerns? Otherwise, I'll move forward to a roll call.

[Doug Carr]: Just one, I think the characterization of not changing the exterior when we're talking about changing windows, historic windows that are probably over 100 years old, and the front door is just, I just, that doesn't add up to me. Like, that's a significant change when you change the windows. I think they can be done Well, I think they can have the same two over one profiles. They might be custom because of the scale, the size. But I think the upgrades to the exterior, I'm pleased to see the siding would stay because that'd be a really tough thing to fix. But the windows being upgraded, I support that. But I think that's not an insignificant change for an exterior of a building from the 19th century. It's very important.

[Peter Miller]: I agree. I think it would be nice if I actually think they're two over two, Doug, but if that aesthetic could be kept, even at their new windows, and then if the vinyl sashes that are one over one right now could be upgraded to match, and they could also be two over two, so that the house was more consistent with its fenestration, I think that would be a good move. And the front doors are pretty nice too. So it'd be great if those could be considered to be kept, add storms to them or something.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay. Thank you all. Okay. I'm going to move forward to a roll call vote. The motion was made by Doug Carr for significance, Peter Miller seconded. So I'll start with you, Peter.

[Peter Miller]: Yes, for significance.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yep. And Doug?

[Peter Miller]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Kit? Yes. Great. Okay, motion passes 3-0. So we will get paperwork and there will need to be a legal ad that's filed with the paper. So we'll get you that legal language and there's a sign requirement. So if you refer back to the the demolition delay packet, you can see where we are in that process, and we'll get you the information you need for that, okay? Okay. Thank you. Okay, next up we have 17 Sharon Street. We're going to receive the demolition application, and then we will hire a consultant for Massachusetts Historical Commission Inventory Form for this property, and also we don't have one for 85 Marshall, so we will do that for a while, and we will have the determination of significance next month. So commissioners, I sent around the 17 Sharon Street application. Any questions, comments, concerns, or I'll take a motion to approve.

[Doug Carr]: Just a quick question, Ryan. There's not a lot of information here, not enough information in my opinion. I don't know if we can request it in time for our next meeting, but it seems like some of the changes under consideration might be better understood and evaluated if we had some drawings about the roof and the changes. It just seems like it's a little light on the package.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, you can make a contingent. We have made contingent approvals for review contingent on having additional information. So if there's missing information that you think that we need to review, I think some sort of graphic illustrating the percentage of demolition of the existing building to remain and then the building to change would be very helpful to this application process.

[Doug Carr]: I guess I'd like to make that motion with those conditions that we accept the proposal, but on the condition that before we evaluate it for significance that we receive some kind of graphical information, elevations, sketches, something that would show a layperson and an architect and anything in between the scope of what's happening here. Because I just think, We've gotten some pretty consistent quality drawings over the last five years compared to the previous five. I think people are taking the before and after elevations and they're doing a good job of giving us enough information so that we can do this as efficiently as possible.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, so that motion's been made to accept the application contingent on receiving a graphic showing the scope of change. Do I have a second?

[Doug Carr]: Second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Thank you, Peter. Okay, roll call vote. Kit, you're first on my window here.

[Peter Miller]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Peter?

[Peter Miller]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Doug?

[Peter Miller]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Great. Motion passes 3-0. So there's a standing order to allow to hire a consultant at the tune of $750 for MHC Form B. So I'll go ahead and do that. We'll have it within 30 days and I will also let the applicants know that would they need to provide additional clarity on the scope of work if it exists. I mean, if it doesn't exist, it just needs to be said. But if it does exist, then we'd like to have it. If it doesn't, then you know, We can move forward without it, but I mean that it just be easier with it so. OK, next up 85 Marshall St. Same deal. Commissioners sent around the application. Anything missing?

If not, I'll take a motion to approve.

[Doug Carr]: I think it's the same situation, isn't it? I feel like this one is also, you know. Looking for. Dormers that are changing again. Alterations beyond cosmetics, yeah, So I would propose the same motion.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK, so that same motion has been made for 85. 85 Marshall St. Do I have a second?

[Peter Miller]: Second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Thank you, Peter. OK, roll call vote. Kit here again first. Yes, Doug.

[Doug Carr]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Peter, yes. Okay, motions approved 30, so I will get those notes out that we're looking for additional clarity on that. Those applications will still move forward with a determination of significance. But, you know, we just. We'd like that clarity just so we have it forward. Okay. The last thing that we have on new business is the upcoming potential demolition delay reviews. Again, we were contacted by 119 Jerome Street. There's some project being planned there. It's a large building. It's immediately behind another building built by Moses Mann, and the house itself has hallmarks of Moses Mann-ness. in design, so we just want to keep tabs on it to make sure that we do it. Other than that, there's nothing currently sitting in our permit system, so we have completely cleared house. There's no projects we're waiting for paperwork, so we are completely caught up and up to date.

Any other new business before I move on? Doug, do you want to talk about the Medford Square zoning here?

[Doug Carr]: Sure, briefly, there's a joint meeting coming up between the city council and the community development board, which I am now the chair of on the 21st of this month. And it should be an interesting, we're just going to focus on Medford Square, not the whole city, just the proposed zoning for Medford Square. I think there's a lot of things that need to be discussed. It's kind of a reboot because City Council has decided to do kind of one piece of Medford at a time and slow down the process a little bit, I believe, if I understand. So it'll be a joint meeting in person in City Council chambers on the 21st.

The zoning plan, just if I can give a 10,000 foot summary of it, the zoning plan for Medford Square doesn't really distinguish between historic buildings and modern buildings that's currently proposed by the city council. I think there's a tremendous opportunity there to fix this plan a little bit, carve out a little bit of protection for the historic buildings. There's at least nine of them on the National Register of Historic Places. and another dozen buildings more that I think are, that this board would potentially find significant if we were to evaluate it. And Ryan, I know that in the past, there's been some conversation in previous years about potential historic district in Reffet Square, but it never took flight, so to speak. And maybe you can speak to that a little bit more, but I guess I urge everyone to attend, at least to understand what's happening with the issues.

Nothing will be decided that night. It's going to be just, I think, more of an informational kind of frame the problem, frame the challenge, talk about what the big issues are, hear from all the abutters, hear from people who own real estate in Medford Square, and try to have what I hope is a civil and good conversation about zoning and the future of Medford Square.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I think there's a lot of opportunity in Medford Square. I think that the open space that currently exists behind City Hall that's being sort of planned for development will be good to really have a rock solid plan. One of the things that I did when I took summer courses this summer over with the American Association for State and Local History as well as the American Institute for Planning Organizations. One of the solid key points that they drove home is without a plan in place and without design guidelines for what you want to see happen there, you know, the development goes wild and could be wild left, wild right, etc. But if you establish an expectation for what you want to build there, then you will get exactly what you asked for out of zoning. So I encourage, if we want to see neighborhood sections developed, then we need to say that. If we want to see them preserved, we need to fight for the historic districts now as part of this project. And I would recommend that it be laid out that we're going to establish a district to prevent or restrict certain areas and control the better control the development that happens there. And we're going to give up other areas that that are not. And I think that should be done in every neighborhood where we say we preserve some, we open the door to the rest of it and allow it to change. So, because not everything is, you know, even in the historic districts, they're not static museums, they're allowed to change over time and morph, but it's controlled, and the rest of it, the rest of the city will change as it does.

In terms of the local historic district, there's major civic centers. I mean everything from City Hall all the way down to the Winthrop Street Circle has all been inventoried, so definitely that should play into an understanding of the historic landscape in terms of what is historic there. Everything between City Hall and Grace Church is really an important understanding to our 17th, 18th, and 19th century landscapes. And there's a lot of 20th century stuff, a lot of 20th century history there. And I definitely think if we pick one area where we sort of shine, that's the showcase of Medford's architectural history. You've got some of the largest and most ambitious buildings and So I really hope that there is, and I don't know if that's just simply worked into zoning or not, you know, some sort of better understanding and better commemoration of the history there in zoning, so.

[Kit Collins]: How far does Medford Square extend?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So the square proper, the formal neighborhood is, I-93 to Winthrop Circle and Mystic River on the south as far as I would say the Lawrence Estates proper. The Lawrence Estates in the Medford survey plan is a part of Medford Square, but it really is large enough to be a neighborhood on its own. And most people who live in that neighborhood would consider it its own separate. So to the commission, it's a large, giant development of Medford Square, but really it's probably all on its own now. But in terms of what is Medford Square, it's that area that I described, the commercial front with all the main streets and then all the residential immediately behind it.

[Kit Collins]: So it's like mystic to Lawrence Ave or Lawrence Road.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, all those houses that are developed in the Bradley Hall estates are sort of are sort of part of Medford Square's early beginnings. And then, you know, now they're just, it's a huge amount of density. And Medford Square does technically extend on the other side of Mystic River, but in terms of how we document that, we document that as Medford Square South. It's sort of its own separate animal, because it developed somewhat independently, because it was divided by the river. And now it's divided by 16 and, you know, all this stuff.

So Doug, you guys are just looking at, in terms of what you guys define as Medford Square, as effectively the bulk of the commercial district, with some residential stuff mixed in.

[Doug Carr]: Yeah, I mean, the boundaries of this zoning proposal, I think, I hope, are fluid, because I think there's some that I'd like to tighten. But I think it's, and I want to understand, I need to be educated on this, because I haven't been part of this process for the last year. I would need to learn from the consultant about what these all mean, because just because something is zoned for eight stories doesn't mean that's the only thing that can happen on that site. Because remember, there's also parking, there's also other components and potential setbacks.

It's more complicated, I think, and I think that's why a nicely paced conversation and an educational process for everyone involved, I think, is an important piece of this. But this is a starting point. You have to start somewhere. This is the first play, if you will, but I'm hoping it's not the last. I'll stop sharing, but this should be available. If anyone needs this, we can, Ryan, I can send this to you. You can put it in the chat if you want.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, we can make that available on our blog. I try to, especially when we have public hearings, try to make information available up on our blogs. I will post that. So, okay. Any other new business before I move on to old business? hearing none, old business, vacant seats. So thank you, Sarah. Thank you, Luke, for both attending this meeting. I sent the recommendation from last month for Sarah up to the mayor's office. And Sarah, I would follow up with the mayor's office last I heard. They were gonna submit it and we're well past the 30 day window now. So unless they didn't submit it, which would, be a blunder, then we should be fine, so.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: I sent an email to Lisa. Let me find her last name. Who was the one?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Lisa Coliani.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Coliani, yes, exactly. Is there anyone else I should reach out to?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: No, that is the chief person who handles the board appointments.

[ir8Km2ErkFk_SPEAKER_19]: Maybe holidays don't count towards the 30 day.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, they might not. I don't know. Okay, great. And then Luke, welcome back. Thanks for participating. So if you decide you want us to push forward with your recommendation, I'm happy to do that at any time. Just let me know. And then you gotta fill out some paperwork with the mayor's office.

[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, certainly. Sorry I missed last month. I talked to Doug earlier. I know you gotta fill out the application online. So I'll get started on that this week. And yeah, any next steps you need to take, I'm good with that too.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, I'll, um, I'll give you a letter, um, just echoing your recommendation so that you can upload that right with your documentation.

[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Thanks.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay. Thanks. Great. So it looks like we're going to have two new commissioners come on board. Um, so, um, we still have an open seat, so, um, I believe we'll have an open seat at that point, um, at some point in the future. Um, so if there's any additional interest in joining the commission, please feel free to email us. Our email is historicalcommission at medford-ma.gov. We're always happy to talk to potential volunteers. We are an all-volunteer board, so we don't receive a stipend. We're one of two boards in the city of Medford that don't receive a stipend, and that is because we are restricted by Mass General Law 40C and Chapter 40D, which is the Historical Commission version of the are establishing law that doesn't allow us to receive a stipend for our work for whatever reason when they established that back in the 70s. I don't understand the justification, but it helps keep us and our judgment pure and clean, I guess so.

OK, next up properties under demo delay. I emailed 41 mystic before the holidays. They seemed inclined to. welcome some level of documentation. Unfortunately, I haven't heard back from them. I emailed them yesterday and didn't hear anything. That's not good prospects. Just so it's all public on the up and up, my recommendation because of this building's importance is going to be that if documentation and some process reviewing or potentially finding an alternative to demolition is stalled or not explored, that I would recommend this project and adjacent other parcels that relate to this building for the establishment of a local historic district. I know it's in a bad location. I say bad location. It's in a location that's conducive to larger development, but I would rather push for the preservation of this particular building because of its 18th century ties to African American slavery and the Hall family of Medford, and because it is one of 12 18th century buildings, to me this is a building to plant a flag on, even to buy it more time. So just something to think about.

[Doug Carr]: Do you think there's any prospects for somebody moving this house?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: I do, but we need the documentation portion of it to explore that Avenue. I have a potential site that it could go to the city owns a. Like a 15,000 square foot lot and which has potential for development. It was taken in 1925 for municipal use. So there's potential for some restriction for municipal use on that parcel, but it was never used for its intended use so. Um, you know, it's available. Um, it's in line with where this building is. So you have to go some distance, but the large roads where it would travel on are sort of.

It is possible to relocate it there. I have talked loosely with a building mover who said, yeah, it can be done. It will be somewhat expensive. But again, if it's the house that you plan to flag on and you want to do it, it could be done. Some people ask how much that usually be. It will be a less than $100,000 proposition to relocate that building, but the work on the building, it's a million-dollar project. We really have to make sure there's a community benefit to doing that. It currently is housing, so it could remain housing.

You know, is it developed into some other use? I don't know. We just, you know, lots of development. And all of that starts with having a rock-solid set of architectural plans so we can really develop that. And again, if we don't have that or can't get a hold of that, I would rather than try to pursue a local historic district to halt the potential for demolition there and then maybe spend some more time forcing the issue. So, okay.

For annual report, I haven't had a chance to move on this. I apologize. I caught that terrible cold that's been going around, so I lost like two and a half weeks worth of work. But we'll get back to it. Everything else below this was the subject of moving forward during that time. So I don't have anything to report, but we will have an annual report in time for Technically, it's due in June. It's due in July for the fiscal year. But we do ours December to December just to make it easy on ourselves.

So I will circle back with that. And Sarah, you volunteered last time. So I will circle back with you. And we'll get on this this time. Sounds good. OK. For the Brooks Estate Archaeological Survey, I have it out to bid currently. I have some firms interested. We're going to CPC for a small grant tomorrow, so I made the assumption that we were going to get it. And if we do get it, then I will be at the committee of the whole meeting the following Tuesday for its approval with city councilors.

So and proposals are due when this coming Wednesday. So assuming that we get the approval from both CPC and city council, I should have the consultant under contract maybe by the end of February at the latest. So they can move forward and then they'll have the report for us in about 30 days or so. maybe 45 days is a little bit more reasonable. So we'd be looking at March, early April for deliverable, which jives with all of the projects that are going on there, like the Brooks Estate Access Drive, and the tree trimming, and the parking lot, and the potential cemetery redevelopment project there of the seven acres that they own. So I'm just sort of pushing that right along.

Any questions? Okay, hearing none for Thomas Brooks Park. I have coming up. The consultants just sent me an invoice for work because they're gearing up to do lab work with us. We are looking for a site. We talked with the Medford schools. They were sort of okay with it, but we're going to try to shift gears and talk to Tufts University, who has a museum studies program, and they have many labs, so we're hoping that we can get access to one. And I would love between six and eight volunteers to help wash and clean all of the artifacts that we pulled out of the ground so that then the consultants can catalog them, and then we will be done with that project. I will say we did pull a lot of material out of the ground this time. We were able to discover the 18th century trash midden, which is effectively their recycling pile. So it's filled to the brim with redware and broken pots and pottery and animal bones of what they ate and all sorts of good stuff.

It's great that that survives. It's very sort of unusual that the house survived well and past that date and all of this stuff remained sort of buried right out in their side yard. And it jives with the history of the enslaved African Americans who lived there that were enslaved by Thomas Brooks and other generations previous to them. So the animals that were mentioned by Brooks history of Medford were found there, so like pigs and sheep and that sort of thing. So it's nice to be able to correlate some verbal history that was written down with some actual physical evidence behind it.

So. So that's it for that project. I have some. I have a tree survey planned trying to get the tree work off the ground and I have one last component, which is a feasibility study that was asked for for the. all the traffic components, the crosswalks, the ADA, access ramps, the street parking and ADA route, et cetera. So there's many different pieces that are sort of in the works to try to finalize this phase two of this project, but I'm doing my best to sort of keep them along. It's just, they're slowing down in procurement, but once we get past that hurdle, we'll be rocking and rolling.

And then the last thing I have is Cross Street Cemetery. Teresa, I think, has an update on whether or not the, there's like two parts. So there's my project, which I'm going, Teresa, did the CPC approve formally the headstone project?

[Theresa Dupont]: We hope to do, it's being reviewed tomorrow at our CPC meeting tomorrow.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So yeah, our hope is to restore the remaining 85 headstones that need immediate conservation. There are some stones that need to be cleaned only, but we're hoping to do that. And I have the RFP ready to bid for that work. And then we have Cross Street Old Site in Medford Square that is going out to bid now.

[Theresa Dupont]: It will be put up to bid this Thursday.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So that's the two parts. That's the removal. That's the complete removal of the City Hall upper lot in preparation for the total exhumation of former Cross Street Cemetery. So that is a big project and that will definitely, I'm sure, Capture the attention of the city, so residents should pay attention to any sort of press releases that we will work with the mayor's office to release to the community and anticipation of that event so that it doesn't come as a surprise. Plus, the parking lot will disappear. So that will also need to be.

[Kit Collins]: Ryan, is the plan to move everybody to the new Cross Street Cemetery?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Well, the plan is to move everybody. So that's the plan. We will move them to a location, but the We think that the existing Cross Street Cemetery is full. We think that they removed all the remains that were there, and some people probably didn't have headstones. And the area that's in the front that looks like it's vacant land is probably full of burials. So we decided, at least on a preliminary basis, that we might explore Some of the land to the side of that location and my thought together with talking with Peter headlands, the landscape architect.

would be to do an interment memorial, acknowledging the fact that the people that were re-exhumed from the current burials now would be acknowledged that they spent 50 years under a parking lot and that we corrected the wrongdoing of yesterday or today.

[Peter Miller]: Thanks. Ryan, when you said that some had been previously Are you saying they were moved to the playstead area?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So there's an area within Oak Grove Cemetery that contains burials based on what we were finding. So when we opened up the trench, we opened up a trench almost across the entire width of the cemetery and in that trench there were 12 burial shafts and out of that every burial shaft contained partial remains of things that were left behind, small fragments of bone, and judging by the location, which was at the rear of the cemetery, which is the oldest part of the cemetery, we think that they just checked locations where there were headstones. We don't think that they checked the entire grounds, because the entire grounds, once they were undertook their work were buried under two and a half feet of sand. So we did discover a full outline of a coffin. We did not check whether there were entire remains within that coffin, but because we found the clear staining of a coffin, we're most likely going to encounter unmarked graves. Now, because of the timeline that these burials took place in, our hope is that they'll have coffin markers on them so that we'll know who the individuals are. But that's part of the reason why I'm suggesting a monument, acknowledging because there will be people that come out of the ground that we just have no idea who they are.

[Peter Miller]: Interesting. So, but I thought you said, okay.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So the number of people that were exhumed from here, there's 400 people documented on the grave markers, but there were upwards of 1,500 people buried in the cemetery, according to Wade Harvey, who was responsible for documenting the headstones back in the 30s and then actually helped with the removal in the 50s. So he discovered that discrepancy and we can't find any records of that or burials. So we are just assuming based on what we found in that one trench that we're going to find many more.

[Peter Miller]: I get that. I just didn't understand what you said about. It seemed like what I heard was that you said that maybe some people had been moved from downtown out to Oak Grove and were in unmarked graves at Oak Grove?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Is that not what you said? Yeah, so the front, let me see if I have a picture of it.

[Peter Miller]: So there might be some unmarked graves somewhere along the front of Oak Grove?

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: So not Oak Grove in the, so the.

[Peter Miller]: But of the downtown site.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, the cross street cemetery has a nice little neat cobblestone wall around it. And in the front, when you walk in, there's a large like lawn area. Right, I've been there, I understand now. Yeah, and that to me says that that's likely occupied space, that is not,

[Peter Miller]: Not for future use.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Right. Right. And everybody was because, you know, everybody was condensed down. Newspapers talk about how they were buried in pinewood boxes and reduced down to the smallest size that they could be. So, you know, there could be many people there or there could be nobody. But I just, you know. I think, you know, what we're going to find is a lot of partial tiny remains, which may or may not be able to be located, you know, connected to a particular person and the potential for intact remains. So we also are doing a a hefty buffer around the cemetery site because it's possible there'll be unmarked burials that were not interred in the cemetery. If they were stillborns or unbaptized individuals or, you know, paupers, they may have just been inadvertently buried around the fringes of the cemetery. That's quite common.

So we're doing everything in our power while working with a consultant to check this ground to make sure it's 100% free and clear because the material that comes out of the ground, it's so hard to decipher that from the surrounding grade. So it looks virtually the same color because it's all mineralized. And they're in like a sandy soil. They're not in earth. So any other questions?

[Kit Collins]: No, just a thank you. I mean, you're doing this so respectfully.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Yeah, these are real people. I, you know, they are deceased, but it is in many cases, other than scant records, that is all that remains of their existence on this earth. So it's really important to just make sure that we treat them with respect, especially given that they spent 50 years under a parking lot and that there is a whole other half of the cemetery under the highway embankment that we can't we can't do anything for.

Thanks. Okay, let's see what else we got. Hastings Heights. Okay, one last thing. So we kick-started Hastings Heights. So we did hire Claire and John to complete the survey. We had a kickoff meeting with Mass Historical for a few months, a few weeks ago, and they're off to the races. They're super excited to be able to be working in that neighborhood. And then we were invited back for the following year for survey and planning grant, which we propose to do the Brooks estate neighborhood. So that's everything. West of along Grove street and West of Grove street. So there's a lot of. interesting sort of sequential development. We're starting at High Street where the Delta is. There's a lot of early 20th century development. And then as you move north, you get into some later 20th century capes and some cool things. And there's some, it does extend over to Playstead Park and some of the residential area around Oak Grove Cemetery proper. But that's for 2020 7, holy moly. So it'll be a while before we see that.

And that's it. The only thing I have left for Old Business is the approval of meeting minutes. Did I miss anything? Okay. Peter sent around meeting minutes. Any questions, comments, concerns? Otherwise, I'll take a motion to approve.

[Doug Carr]: So moved.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And the second?

[Kit Collins]: I'll second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Thank you, Kit. OK, roll call vote, Kit?

[Kit Collins]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Doug?

[Kit Collins]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Peter?

[Peter Miller]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: OK, so 3-0 approved. All right, we need a motion to dissolve the meeting.

[Doug Carr]: So moved. Second.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Doug Carr second, it's not debatable. Doug?

[CAS00002523_SPEAKER_07]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: And Kit? Yes. And Peter?

[Kit Collins]: Yes.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Okay, motion approved 3-0. Thank you all. So our next meeting will be on February 9th. We'll get the word out about the public hearings and we'll have two applications for determinations of significance and I will try to post all that to our website.

[Doug Carr]: Thank you, Ryan.

[Vice Chair Ryan Hayward]: Have a good night. Take care.

Kit Collins

total time: 0.81 minutes
total words: 98
Richard Caraviello

total time: 1.06 minutes
total words: 166


Back to all transcripts

More from this committee: CC Historical Commission