The Medford Community Development Board endorsed an Approval Not Required plan for city-owned land and approved a sign special permit for Herb Chambers Toyota with modified pylon height limits. The board also continued two site plan review hearings to February 4, 2026, and discussed preparations for upcoming joint zoning hearings on Medford Square.
[Chair Doug Carr]: This is the January 7, 2026 Medford Community Development Board. My name is Doug Carr, Chair. I'm going to call the meeting to order. But first, Let's begin with some introductory obligatory procedural matters. This hearing of the Medford Community Development Board is being conducted via remote means. No in-person attendance of members of the public will be permitted, but every effort will be made to ensure that the public can adequately access the proceedings. Anyone who would like to listen to or view this meeting while in progress may do so by accessing the link. that was included in the meeting agenda posted on the City of Medford website. A recording of this meeting will be posted on Medford Community Media website as soon as possible. A reminder that given the remote nature of this meeting tonight, all votes from the board will be made by roll call.
Please know that the project materials for all projects before the board this evening can be viewed on the city's website, MedfordMass.org, at boards-commissions forward slash community development board. And by clicking current city board filings. For those on Zoom, you can also find the link in the chat. So the staff will paste that link. I'm going to call the roll call now. John Anderson. Present. Sean Began. Present. Page Buldini.
[Page Buldini]: Present.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Goffman-Fishman.
[Page Buldini]: Present.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Dina Colagari is not here, I don't believe. And myself, Chair Doug Carr, I am also present. So let's kick it off. Danielle, can you introduce any staff at the meeting or on the call?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, myself, Daniel Evans, senior planner in the office of planning, development, sustainability, and also joined by director Alicia Hunt, the director of PDS. Oh, and also have our graduate student intern, Christian Zepeda-Lepofsky.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Very good. Thank you. So a couple of agenda items here before we dive in. There's two public hearings that we're continuing that were discussed at the last few meetings, the site plan review for 255, 257 Main Street. This public hearing was continued for the meeting on December 3rd, and I believe also on the 17th. And given that we are waiting on a revised set of plans, we are gonna continue this item so there's be no discussion about that project on Main Street at this meeting.
Similarly, we'll also be continuing the public hearing site plan review for 360 Salem Street, which I know had a lot of comments at the last meeting in December. We're still waiting on a final determination from the building commission. on whether the project qualifies for high frequency transit or not. So we will also be continuing with this item without discussion tonight. So neither of these projects, 255, 57 Main or 360 Salem will have any decisions or discussions tonight. So if you're here for those, you're obviously welcome to stay and listen for other meetings, but nothing substantial will be discussed on those two projects, those two sites, because there's simply, they're going to be continued and we haven't determined the date yet.
Are there any questions from the board on that?
[Unidentified]: Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Hearing none, we will jump into the agenda items that are going to be discussed tonight. So the first one is the endorsement of approval not required ANR for City Hall Mall and Clippership Drive. That's item AA-2025-5. And Danielle, could you please introduce this item and explain the ANR and what the purpose of this is?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Mr. Chair, actually, I'm going to pass this over to Director Hunt, who is kind of heading that one off.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Go ahead, Alicia.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: This particular one is being put forward by the city to remind everybody an A&R is an approval not required. And that basically is the subdivision of a parcel into two or more parcels. legally so they can be filed with the registry of deeds as separate parcels and legally recognized as such. And the role of this board is to make that statement, that agreement, that they meet the requirements to be subdivided as such. And we can read through, I don't know if Danielle, if you want to talk about what those are. Maybe actually we should say what those are before I show the plan. I don't know which is easier. Should I show the plan first and then we'll just step through the things?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, let's show the plan.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It has to be on a public way and it has to have good access. So let me just show you. I apologize that there are just so many lines on this plan. There really, really are. What you're seeing here, and it is in fact very complicated, because there are in the three deeds and 19 parcels that make up the three lots that are these parcels. And so these parcels, the reason they're all on here is because they refer back, many of them to the same deeds. And so there's this parcel up here, this is the commuter parking lot, just to orient you, actually, maybe I should start here, City Hall, this is City Hall. And so there's this has been one big legal parcel. There are two other parcels on this map, we're not actually talking about them. But the surveyor says they need to be here. So this, this lot that has City Hall on it is one large parcel. And basically for the purposes of our project with Transom, our project to redevelop these lots, we are not, we did not put out to bid the parcel, the area with City Hall on it for the redevelopment, but rather this area over here. So I'm gonna, sorry, I'm trying to work the Adobe here. Okay. So what you see, this dark line, is one legal parcel with this really funny shape over here. That small two-story, two-and-a-half-story brick building is not part of it, but this whole thing is one large parcel. And so this A&R is basically saying that we would like this to legally be two separate parcels. And so this line down the middle is the new lot line that would make this one parcel on this side, lot one, and this one is being called lot or because of the other parcels that are on this plan that you see here. And so what we're asking the board to verify is that, in fact, when you draw that line down the middle, you still have two legal parcels that are on a both of them are on a public way.
or a way which is certified and maintained as a public way, that, or one, so that one, and, sorry, I'm going through the cheat sheet. Do the proposed lots shown on the plan meet the minimum frontage requirements in the local zoning ordinance or bylaw? The minimum frontage in a C1 zone is 20 feet or 50 feet, depending on the use. So there are many lines here that this one is marked at 258 feet. This one is several hundred feet as well. Clearly, these are more than 20 and 50 feet.
Can each lot access onto the way from the frontage? Yes, in fact, they currently have driveways opening onto those ways. And does the way in which the proposed lots provide adequate access? I can assure you we get lots of emergency vehicles down these. And does each lot have practical access from the way to the buildable portion of the lots? And clearly, like what we're asking you to verify is that they do. And this one is the lot where the buses come and where the bus stop is, and this is the lot where City Hall works. So that's basically the request. In this case, you all would vote to agree that this is an ANR. And I have previously been authorized by the CD board that rather than each and every one of you coming in here to sign this document, I will sign it on behalf of the board. and then we will file it with the Registry of Deeds. Sure.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia, I think it's, go ahead, John, please.
[John Anderson]: Quick question. Along that new lot line, there's that sort of crosshatched area. What does that signify? That's an electrical easement. OK.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, it's underground, John, so it doesn't, you just can't build on top of it. Sure. That's fine. Yeah, I think it might be worth spending one more minute to say that this is tied into the RFP that you want to develop these lots, right? You have a pretty ambitious plan to put a lot of mixed use, a lot of housing at all three of these parcels as part of this RFP. And so this step is necessary in order to allow that to happen because it was not one lot. You can't build on half of the lot behind City Hall. Therefore, it's two lots. But the other two are somewhat good to go compared to this one.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: The others we don't have any question about. I mean, there's this one. They're weird. And the property owner is going to have to do like his deed research and everything on them. But these are the two existing. They already exist as they exist.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So yeah, we're talking about potentially hundreds of units of condos or apartments are potentially buildable here.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right. And I personally am not prepared to go into the difference between parcels and lots because there are actually this is a list of all the parcels that are on here. I know those are the lines. These are plan references. This is when you deal with very old property owned by something like the city, the deed references. go back quite a long time. And things are very, I think this is the deed rep. No, this is plan references, books and pages, I think. Sorry, I've seen so many different versions of this. And then I asked them to generate ones that's legally appropriate for this purpose. So this doesn't actually have all those other little parcel lines on them. I don't even, this is what the surveyors and the lawyers said we needed to move this forward. So I went with it. Honestly, I might have, if I had realized there was an electrical easement, I might have asked to have the line run along it. I didn't see that on the previous version, but at this point, I've gone back and forth with these surveyors so many times, it would be easier to just get this done and get this file.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yep. So are there any other questions from the board about what we're doing here or about the plan in front of us? Hello.
[John Anderson]: Go ahead. Quick question. This development that's proposed here is obviously going to be very significant. And we'll be getting into it at a later date. Are there any documents that we could view that would sort of help us get up to a little bit up to speed so when it comes along, we're not starting from scratch?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So there are a number of, there is the original proposals, the RFP and the original proposals on the web. Um, but we are going to be working through the Medford square zoning coming up very soon. That's actually the first hearing has been advertised. Um, and then we are still negotiating with the developer exactly what and where and how, and what is this all going to be the land disposition agreement. Um, so there isn't like a really concrete thing to put in front of you at this time.
[John Anderson]: I'd be interested in the RFP if you could show me where that is. Sure, it's on the web.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: We can get it to you guys from the web. Thank you.
[Sean Beagan]: Go ahead, Sean. Alicia, are we designating and separating these lots because the lots are going to be sold or contemplated being sold to a developer, or is this for lease?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: It's all for lease. OK. It's cleaner this way. OK.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, Alicia, I think Transom's submission is, is that online as well, somewhere from last year?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And I was just trying to remember exactly where we posted it so that I could share that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, I agree with john and john getting a look at that is kind of a prep to think about the zoning coming up in method because I think all 3 of these sites are looked to be pretty up zoned in terms of height mass compared to the rest of the square from memory. So we'll be getting into that obviously in due time. All right any other questions from the board on this? Hearing none, I'm going to ask for a motion to endorse the plan.
[John Anderson]: So moved.
[Frank Marinelli]: Yep.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And the second. Second. Okay. I'll do roll call vote. Sean Began. Yes. John Anderson. Yes. Page Buldini.
[Page Buldini]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Fishman.
[Page Buldini]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself. Yes. I think the motion passes, and we're good to go on this item.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Thank you. I was searching the web for the RFP. Honestly, we need to get up a good. We've just hired a consultant to help with some of the economic development aspects of that, and I'm going to ask them to help me put together a web page with sort of some of the background and everything on this, because I'm not clear that we have one right now.
[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. All right, next item on the agenda again this I mentioned this earlier that the, uh, the 255 to 57 Main Street, the public hearing is site plan review is going to be continued. We're not going to be discussing this tonight because we're still waiting on revised plans. There's still some paperwork that needs to be filled out. There's still some new drawings coming. So. We are not going to be discussing that, and we're going to continue this. The question before us is, when do we want to next take this up? We need to set a date, I think, legally. There's really only two options.
The meeting on the 21st is spoken for. So unless you want to have another third meeting in January, we'd be talking about the 4th of February. And I think that's a reasonable amount of time to do this. I prefer it not to be rushed. I prefer to have everything in order. But I welcome any alternate comments or other ideas about when we do this, including from Danielle and Alicia. Any thoughts from the board first?
[Ari Fishman]: Sounds reasonable to me.
[Chair Doug Carr]: The 4th?
[Ari Fishman]: I agree as well.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay, john and john, are you good with that?
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, I defer to whatever the majority wants. It's fine with me. Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And john. Yes. Okay. So, um. Danielle's do we need to take a motion to or just set the date for the assume that would be February 4th.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, you should. Just make a motion to continue it to February 4th.
[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. So I will make the motion to continue the public hearing for 255-57 Main Street. Seconded. OK. Roll call. Sean Began. Yes. Ari Fishman.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Page Buldini.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: John Anderson. Yes. And myself, yes, motion passes 5-0. So we'll continue that on February 4th. The next item is very similar. We're talking about continuing the public hearing for 360 Salem Street site plan review. This is CDB file number SPR-2025-4. Again, this was continued from the last meeting on December 17th. We still have not received the final determination from the building commissioner on whether the project qualifies for high frequency transit or not. We'll be continuing this item without discussion to a date certain. That date logically is going to be February 4th, which is just four weeks from tonight. I entertain a motion to continue this hearing on 360 Salem for February 4th.
Go move. Second. Thank you, Sean. Roll call. Ari Fishman.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Page Buldini.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: John Anderson. Yes. Sean Began. Yes. And myself, yes. So the motion passes and we will continue that on February 4th. All right. Next up on the agenda item is a new public hearing. This is the application for a special permit for 400 Mystic Avenue, CDB file number SP-2025-5. This is a new hearing, so I'm going to read the public hearing notice for the record. The Memphic Community Development Board, CB, shall conduct a public hearing on January 7th, 2026, after 6.30 p.m. via remote, Zoom remote video conferencing relative to an application by Ashbury Boston T, LLC, DBA Herb Chambers, Toyota Boston, for a special permit pursuant to section 94-6.2.21 of the zoning ordinance. That's the signage ordinance. to allow for the installation of signage that would exceed the maximum size and quantity allowed. The subject property is located on the commercial subdistrict of the Mystic Avenue Corridor, District MACD at 400 Mystic Avenue, Metro Mass 02155.
Alicia or Danielle, do you have any introductory comments before I pass it off to the applicant?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes, sure, Mr. Chair. Yes, so this was This auto dealership was granted a special permit as well as site plan review from this board. When was that? Frank would know. Some time ago. I think there might be a few of you on this board that were on it. I think Ari might be the only one.
[Ari Fishman]: It was early in my tenure, which means I'm the only one still standing.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: So, at the time when they submitted for site plan review at that time, they could have asked for the signage package, but it was still very early on. They didn't have the details finalized like they do now. So. There's the provision in the sign ordinance that allows them to come back for a special permit to have more signage and the. the findings that you make is basically based on, you know, the unique factors of the building, you know, the use of it, how it's, you know, where it's sited. It's, you know, it's kind of, it's not the findings that you need for like a variance. But there are some, you know, unusual situations with that site up against the highway and the nature of the business that it, really would need more signage than the one primary, one secondary, one pylon sign. It's just a very large site that our signage doesn't really lend itself for this kind of use. So there's this provision to ask for more that's not through a variance process. So that's where we are today. So just looking at the signage, not the, the operations of the property that's all locked in, been approved, and is under construction.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yes. Thank you, Danielle. We're not too far away from completion, I don't think. I've driven by there many times. It doesn't look like it's got more than a few months at most. I'll turn it over to Frank Marinelli. Please introduce yourself, and I understand you have a PowerPoint you want to share.
[Frank Marinelli]: Yes, thank you, Chairperson Carr, members of the Community Development Board, Frank Marinelli, and I'm Land Use Counsel for Herb Chambers Toyota. In July of 2024, and Danielle has covered it very nicely, we were before the CDB for the special permanent site plan review approval, which the CDB granted and enabled redevelopment of the former Century Bank property. So this is now an over $50 million investment at 400 Mystic Avenue, transforming a five-story vacant office building into Herb Chambers Toyota in the city's commercial subdistrict of the MACD, as Danielle mentioned. And since the 2024 approvals, Herb Chambers dealerships, including this dealership, were purchased in July of 2025 by one of the nation's largest automotive groups, Asbury Auto Group of Atlanta, a publicly held company with 177 dealerships in 15 states. With us tonight on Zoom are members of our development team, John Welch, who's the former development director with Herb Chambers and now with Asbury. Our civil engineering team for the redevelopment, Gabe Crocker and Dave Newhall. of Crockett Design Group. We also have Laura Milligan of Patterson Sign Group and our architect, Lee Hemenway of Regent Architects. So there's 100% continuity and diligence to bring the Herb Chambers Toyota to opening in the next few months, as the chair mentioned. Tonight's hearing, as Danielle pointed out, is for the proposed signage for Herb Chambers Toyota, which we believe is reasonable in scale for the size of the building and tasteful in design. The wall signage you'll see tonight on the facades of the five-story, 173,530 square foot building, are the wall signs that were shown on region elevations which were part of the July 2024 CDB decision. The region elevations dated May 29, 2024 are cited in the 2024 CDB decision. And as Danielle pointed out, the signs can be allowed in site plan approval or afterwards as we're doing tonight. The detailed sign plans have now been filed for each sign. So tonight we hope is an adjunct to what was conceptually shown to CDB in 2024 with the wall signage and the primary pylon. And you can see that in slide two which we have up right now. This is the elevation that was submitted back in May 29th as stated of 2024 as part of the CDB decision reference there. But it shows the wall signage that we're going to talk about tonight and also shows the the primary pylon, which is less than one half of the total height of the five-story building. The five-story building is approximately 75 feet high. And as I said, the primary proposed pylon at 35 feet is less than half the highest point. So to scale, it's reasonable in relation to the five-story building. And there is a second pylon that is 24 feet high, about one-fourth, I'm sorry, one-third the height of the five-story building. And the smaller pylon is located about 145 feet east down Mystic Avenue of the primary pylon, creates awareness for the certified pre-owned product. The need for signage is critical. As the board knows, signage ensures dealership identification, timely, safe, motorist lane changes and turning movements to and from the dealership and to and from the busy surrounding road network. There are also three helpful onsite directional signs. So we believe that what you'll see tonight, the proposed signage is reasonable for a unique property and modest for a facility of this size surrounded by roadway and view corridors on all sides. As you can see on slide number three, 400 Mystic, as Danielle pointed out, is at the easterly end of the commercial subdistrict of the MACD. And this subject district with slide four will show you that we have many diverse commercial uses in the district from automotive to storage to eating establishments. But the 400 Mystic site is unique. There's no commercial property like it in the district. Yet signage that works for a 2,000 square foot restaurant on a small lot does not work for a 173,530 square foot building as here on a 4.87 acre lot.
So we respectfully submit as Daniel Evans pointed out that you know special permit is really a case-by-case analysis on the on the factors and next slide will show you present some of the facts that we would respectfully submit support the special permit under the criteria of the special permit. We have a site that's located at the easterly end of the commercial sub-district We have a building with view corridors from every side and surrounded by roads on all sides. Mystic Avenue to the south, I-93 to the north, I-93 ramps to the east, Mystic Avenue, Fulbright to the west. The wall signage, very importantly, is just 1% to 2.2% of the related building facades, which we will show you. As I mentioned, the pylon is less than one half of the overall 71% 70 plus feet of the five-story Herb Chambers building. The secondary pylon is less than one-third of the over 70 feet of the five-story. The Herb Chambers building, as I've stated, is 173,530 square feet and unique. There's three small on-site directional signs helpful to safe and efficient on-site circulation. We have a multi-story sales showrooms offices converted from a vacant five-story office building. three stories of new service bay, indoor parking on two floors in a new addition, multi-story car elevator, staggered building facades, and a regularly shaped 4.87 acre lot and 316 feet of frontage on Mystic Avenue and even greater boundary length parallel to I-93 and the I-93 ramps.
So in the past year, as the chair mentioned, we have been under construction and I want to thank Danielle Levinance for working with us for the past two years and Alicia Hunt over the past two years and we've had a very positive experience with the building department and all of the city departments during the construction over the past year and these photos slides seven and eight will show you the state of construction. I took these on December 31st, so pretty much up to date for the ongoing construction.
As the chair and the members know, the vacant five-story office building is really a challenged asset class in New England throughout the country today with declining demand for office. The CDB's 2024 approval allowed a single user, Herb Chambers Toyota, to take a challenged asset, invest tens of millions of dollars in it, create new jobs and new commercial tax base for Medford and economic development. And again, slides nine and 10 will show you the resulting over $50 million redevelopment investment. The zoning ordinance 94-6.2.20 provides that the CDB may, as Ms. Evans pointed out, by special permit or in site plan review, which we had in 2024, approve larger or additional signs that would be appropriate for the size of this building and the location and the size of this lot. And we believe that we meet all of the considerations under 94-6.2.20. And I'll just go through them briefly. The nature and the use of the premises, as we pointed out, the size of the building, the five stories, the showroom, the multi-story car elevator, the three-story new section, approximately 36 service bays, 2 floors of indoor parking on 4.8 acres and over $50M development in the commercial sub-district. Secondly, the architecture of the building is another factor that the ordinance provides for consideration. And again, that is all of the the characteristics of the building that we talked about, and most importantly, the fact that we have building edifices from 15,813 square feet south-facing to 18,502 square feet north-facing, and the wall signage affixed to those facades is only approximately 1 to 2.2% of the particular facade square footages. Next factor, but consideration of the board is the location of the site with reference to the street and again very unique. We have a site that is surrounded on all sides by roadway and view corridors, Mystic Ave to the south, I-93, north and south lanes to the north, the ramps to the east and Fulbright and Mystic Avenue to the west. The next factor under the ordinance is the compatibility of the signage and visual scale. And we think again that with reference to the size of this building, the five stories, the height, the approved building at 173,530, when you have just 1% to 2.2% of any facade, with the wall signage. This is very reasonable and modest for the size of the building and the location and the roadway systems. Next, the factor, the fifth factor under section 94-6.2.20 is not substantially detrimental to the commercial sub-district neighborhood. And we think this is pretty obvious because we again took a vacant building in an asset class that is very challenged in New England and throughout the country. With the investment of tens of millions of dollars, we've converted it into a single user, not something that the city had to worry about would be vacant with abatements and so forth or multiple tenants, but one user, reputable brand, Herb Chambers and Toyota.
We'd like to complete the development with the reasonable proportion that signage that we're requesting, which we respectfully submit is not substantially detrimental, but instead a substantial improvement. So with that, Mr. Chair, and we'll go through each of these as quickly as possible, but wanted you to know the details of all of the signage. So on the wall signage on the southerly facing building that's toward Mystic Avenue, we have what we showed you. The first one we'll talk about is the Toyota badge kind of to the left of the front doorway. And the next slide will show that elevation from Regent and Associates. And the next slide will show that all of the dimensions approximately 15 feet 9 inches by 11 feet 3 inches and that's 177 square foot sign but really it's 87 square foot on the logo and 42 square foot on the lettering but we create the rectangular box which Laura Milligan of Patterson Sign is on this call. She's the sign expert but you know it's 129 of actual signage, but we've got it listed as 177 overall. That's the emblem and the lettering that you'll see recurring on a couple of other sides. The next slide shows the Herb Chambers lettering above the front door. This is very reasonably sized at, I think, 31 square feet. We'll see on the next slide.
30.47 square feet, 1 foot 9 inches by 17 feet 5 inches. Again, very tasteful and just identifying the on-premise brand, the on-premise use. The next slide is the service reception. So this is really just identification for Our clients that come in and line up at the 3 high speed service doors and this is very reasonable at 35.4 square feet stating service reception exactly what it is and helpful to clients. The next slide. is we wanted to show you the traffic controllers. These are red and green that are above each service high-speed service door. And obviously, if it's red, the client doesn't come in. If it's green, you can enter and the door goes up. Those are less than one square feet each. The next slide. is the Toyota emblem and the Toyota lettering at the top of the subway base, which you saw on the rendering. And this is 28 square feet on the logo and about 56 square feet on the lettering for Toyota. So overall, 84 square feet. And again, that shows on that elevation. The next slide, again, is the composite of the four wall signs that we've talked about. And again, this goes back to the 2024 hearing that Danielle had referenced. And we do have the primary pylon shown there too. So next slide is, again, the elevation that was part of the 2024 hearing. And the next slide is a summary. of the southerly facing building facade. So we have 177 square feet on the top on the badge next to the left of the front door. We have a 31 square feet Herb Chambers letters above the door. We have 36 square feet on the service reception and we have 84 square feet at the top of the facade. Toyota and the logo is approximately 320 square feet, 328 square feet, which is 2.07% of the 15,813 square feet of total southerly facing building facades. The next slide, we're going to show you the northerly facing building facades towards I-93.
And the next slide is the rendering that was part of the 2024 hearings, and Gabe is circling where the northerly faces are at the end of the new service building and on that side of the existing five-story former Century Bank. The first sign on the northerly faces is again the 177 square foot emblem and in Toyota that goes on the northerly at the end of the service building, the new service building facing I-93. Same dimensions that we spoke about. The next sign northerly, then that shows the elevation where it is. The next slide is the very small parts designation so that anybody that's coming in for parts, if they're in the business of picking up parts, they know which door to enter. That's only seven and a half square feet, so that's very helpful in identifying that door. The next, and that's on the northerly base, the next sign on the northerly base is below the time and temperature, which as you know is the time temperature is existing from Century Bank and it's allowed by right in the commercial district. We have the Toyota logo and the Toyota lettering, same size as you've seen before, 84 square feet under the time temp. The next slide shows the orientation of that view angle out towards I-93. And on the northerly base, the next slide is, again, the elevation and the logo and the lettering underneath the time temp. The next slide is the Herb Chambers lettering above the time temp. And that is a standard 63 square feet, 62.46 square feet. And that recurs with symmetry on the north side and on the easterly side, which you'll see. So that's it on the northerly side. And the summary is 177, the badge on the northerly face of the service center, the 7.5 square feet above the parts store. the 84 square feet Toyota logo letters under the time temp, the 63 curb chambers above the time temp for a total of 332 square foot wall signage on the northerly side, which is 1.8 percent of the total 18,502 square feet of northerly facing building facades. The next slide shows the easterly facing building facades and the wall signage that we have there.
Again, symmetry and balanced with the northerly side, you'll see the same signs on the easterly side with the different orientation. The first one is the Toyota badge and logo, and that's at the end of the new service, three-story service building easterly facing. The next slide shows that on the architectural elevation. And that slide shows the orientation, the view angle facing I-93, excuse me, on the easterly facing service building. The next slide is the dimensions, which we previously spoke about, but presented again, 177 square feet, the 15 feet, nine inches by 11 feet, three inches approximately. And then, and that's the next slide shows again, where it's placed underneath the time temperature on that edifice. And the next slide shows the view orientation towards I-93 and the I-93 off ramp with the easterly facing signage. So that again is the The next slide shows the dimensions that we've spoken about on the previous sides, the 28 square feet on the logo, the 56 square feet on Toyota lettering, total of 84 square feet. And the next slide shows the Herb Chambers letters that go above the time temperature on the easterly side, same as we had on the northerly side, same size. as well, 63 square feet approximately and then 62.46 to be exact. And then looking out again the view angle of the time tamp which is existing and have the century bank labels above it or on it. And then that shows the composite of the northerly and the easterly orientations. The next slide shows the summary of the easterly facing building facades, the 177 square foot Toyota emblem and letters that was on the service building and the 84 square feet of Toyota logo letters, which is beneath the time temp, the 63 square feet of Herb Chambers letters above the time temp for 324 square feet, which is approximately 1.9% of the 16,476 square feet of total easterly facing building facades. The next slide we're going to show you the wall signage on the westerly facing building facades towards Fulbright, towards Mystic Avenue. and that it's kind of tight the wall the Wesley is tucked in on the on the left side of the of this orientation this looks out to its mystic avenue and then we have an actual photo of now that's the westerly facing edifice.
affixed the same Toyota logo, which the next slide will show, the same 84 square foot, 28 square foot logo and 50, 56 square foot Toyota lettering. And that's where it goes at the top of that edifice. And then we have the next slide with the orientation of that signage was westerly facing. And we have the next slide with the Herb Chambers standard 60, possibly 63 square feet that we showed you on the other sides. And that goes above the Toyota logo and lettering. The next slide is the summary of the westerly facing, which is just the 84 square feet standard Toyota logo and letters and the 63 square foot Herb Chambers letters above that for a total of approximately 147 square feet.
which is 0.8% less than 1% of the approximately 18,321 square feet of westly facing building facades. The next slides are going to show you the three on-site directional signs that we're proposing which we feel are helpful and attractive as tablet monument style. Each less than 21 square feet, 20.41 square feet for each of the three. The first one shows the directions when you come in off of Fulbright Street. So we'll show you now the Fulbright Street placement, the ingress and egress to and from Fulbright Street to and from the dealership. So that directional sign A is what you will see coming in and going out. The next one directional sign B is directly in front of you when you come in off of Mystic Avenue. It's to the left of the first high-speed service door, so you see that when you enter the site off of Mystic. And again, it's helpful to the client to know where to go, and that was the intent of these small monument signs.
Monument sign number C is if you're coming in, it directs you to the showroom. And if you're leaving, thank you for visiting. And that goes at the apex of the middle parking field right there. So those are the directional signs. They're small. We believe they're appropriate. The next slide, we're going to show you the two freestanding pylon signs. One is 35 feet high by 10, but they're sleek, they're thin, this one is less than one-half the height of the five-story building. Then we have the second pylon that we're requesting, which is 24 feet high by 10 feet wide, not overbearing, not obtrusive. They fit very well with proportionality of the building and the site. The next slide shows you, the schematic of the 350 square foot Toyota pylon monument style again 35 by 10 and then we show you the location of it which is right when you come in right there on that embankment at the entry and then we have the second pylon well that first that's the pylon that conceptually was shown back in 2024 and this is the rendering that was referenced in the 2024 approval decision. Then we go to the second pylon, which is the certified pre-owned cars are a product that's on site. Many people are buying pre-owned vehicles these days, and this is 24 by 10.
Again, the same tablet textile pylon, non-obtrusive, appropriate in size, less than one-third the height of the five-story facility. The next slide shows you where that's going, 145 feet separation to the east from the primary pylon. The next slide is the summary of the pylons separated by approximately 145 feet, and both are more than six feet, which is a requirement in the ordinance of 94-6.2.12.5. You have to be at least six foot setback where 8.9 and 6.9 feet respectively for the two proposed pylons. The next slide is the Just some comps of Toyota dealerships in the area. Brockton has two pylon signs. One is approximately 60 feet high. Lynn has three pylon signs. One is approximately 35 feet. Westboro has two pylons, one approximately 20. 31, approximately 19. Danvers has two pylon signs. They're approximately 20 feet. And McGee has two pylon signs, approximately more suburban locations, certainly not with a five-story building. And Toyota or Braintree has a pylon that's approximately 74 feet high. It has an expressway location. on Route 3, and it pretty much dwarfs the building facade that is next to. But in comparison to Medford, we have pylons that are much more tasteful and below the building height, one-half to one-third of the height of the building. We have a photo of this pylon, which is is the 74 feet. We don't have anything like that that we're proposing here. Again, we feel that the signage we're proposing is proportionate and reasonable. And the next slide shows some comps that Patterson, Laura Milligan, who's on the Zoom call from Patterson Sign Company, provided these other locations on the east and in the east and southeast where Patterson has performed multiple pylons, higher pylons, and that's just for point of reference. The next slide, our conclusion that we respectfully request the reasonable and necessary signage presented completing the over $50 million investment in economic development, transforming the commercial sub-district site in the Mystic Avenue corridor district and fulfilling the special permit criteria for approval of the requested signage. Chairperson Carr, I again want to thank the staff of Planning and Development and Sustainability, Alicia Hunter and Danielle Evans for their work with us over the past two years and also the building department during the construction process which were near Completion and all of the city departments, we had a very positive relationship and hope that we can conclude the project with this signage. Thank you. And we're happy to answer any questions that you are the board of the public may have.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sure, thank you Mr. Mayor. If you don't mind keeping up that rendering, I think it'd be useful in case someone needs to go back and look at a specific side of the building. I have a few questions before I get to the other board members. The two pylons you mentioned, one is 35 feet high, one is 24 feet high. I see the 35 foot here, the 24 foot is not shown. Why are they different sizes? They're so close to one another.
[Frank Marinelli]: I guess that they are separated by 145 feet, but, you know, Gabe is the project engineer, but it's hard to approximate where we're talking about on the rendering. But, I mean, if you want to. It's a little, it's a little right. It's shortly just off the screen.
[Chair Doug Carr]: It'll be right over here. Why is one 11 feet higher than the other? Maybe we wouldn't want the pre-owned to do our domain sign?
[Frank Marinelli]: Yeah, well, I mean, I think for the branding purposes, yeah, you wouldn't want the pre-owned to basically make the primary the secondary. We want the Toyota brand to be front and center as it is with the 35 foot. Sure.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I'll give you my broad perspective here is I don't see a lot of issues with the scale of the signage because of the site location. This is, in my opinion, it's highway architecture largely on one side and Vista Gavina was not exactly a historic district either. It's a large commercial zone. I don't think anything here personally, I can't speak for the board obviously, but the scale doesn't bother me. But I do think it's odd that you proportion the pylons to the size of the building like if this was a 10 story building.
Would it be, I wouldn't want it to be 70 feet tall or 60 feet tall. The other ones you showed, especially the one down in Braintree, is kind of insanely large. That's meant to be seen from another area code, from what I can tell. It's really big. I agree, this is a little, this is more reasonable, but like, If they were both 24 feet high, I wouldn't have a problem with that either. But I understand the hierarchy of branding. I get that. The main Toyota sign versus the pre-owned is a reasonable distinguishing feature between these two. But the proportion of the building to me is not relevant. I don't think if this building was 3 stories tall, I would want this to be 40 feet tall, for example.
[Frank Marinelli]: And I would agree with that. I think that this is, as you said, it's highway architecture. It's different than any of the suburban locations. And 35 feet is appropriate, but probably appropriate even for a higher building. Very good.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm going to open up to the board members for questions and comments. Anyone want to chime in here?
[Ari Fishman]: I'll just chime in that having seen this project from the beginning, it's been a joy to drive past it and see progress being made. This seems reasonable to me and I'm excited to see the project come online.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Ari. Go ahead, Paige.
[Page Buldini]: Thank you so much. I appreciate being able to see this for the first time and the signage. And I'm appreciative of the way that the Century Bank, the former Century Bank building was kept. I know that that was a big cornerstone in Medford for many years. So to see that repurposed and to still appreciate what it looks like, I think is a really wonderful thing. So thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. I appreciate that. I agree. I hate to see a building go unused for any length of time. It's not good for the building. It's not good for the city it's in. So I'm going to move on to Sean. Go ahead, Sean.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, a beautiful project. Really appreciate you know, a very large monetary investment in the city in this building. My only concern I would have would be with the 35 foot pylon sign that I took a drive down Mystic Ave today. That 35 foot sign, I think would morph any other sign on Mystic Ave in terms of height. I don't think there's another sign Perhaps the Atlas liquor sign is 30 feet tall, but it's hard to judge, and I don't know that this... rendering that we have in front of us captures a 35-foot Toyota sign, or maybe it does. Maybe Attorney Marinelli can educate me on that, whether this rendering actually shows us what a 35-foot tall sign would look like. I think for advertising purposes and for awareness, The location of the Toyota pylon, you're only really capturing an audience on Mystic Ave. I don't think you're getting any benefit from Route 93 traffic out of this pylon, whereas I know the sign that you're talking about in Braintree, which acts almost as a highway billboard, it's so tall, and you see it as you're coming down 93, and it really does look more remind you more of what a billboard would be on a highway than a sign at a Toyota dealership. So, yeah, the height there concerns me a little bit, and I'm also thinking about future applications from other perspectives. There's a number of car dealerships on that road. None of their signs approach that height, not even close. So that would be my only concern. But otherwise, I have no concern about any of the signage on your building. I think it's all appropriate. I have no concern about the 24 foot pylon. I think that is just a few feet, maybe four feet above what is allowed in any event. I think 20 feet is the height limit in the signage ordinance. So my only concern would be that 35 foot height sign.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Sean. I greatly appreciate that. I actually, to build on that comment, I kind of agree with that because the building has signage on all four sides. Essentially, it's one big billboard, essentially advertising for long distance views, right? So this Toyota sign this pylon sign is kind of repetitive. I'm not saying we get rid of it, but I'm just saying right behind it is a building that has the exact logo on all four sides, so you're not going to miss the fact that this is a Toyota facility. So, Sean, are you proposing or thinking, considering that they should both be 24 feet rather than go for the extra 11, 35 feet for this one?
[Sean Beagan]: I'd be supportive of two 24-foot signs for sure. Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I'm going to move on to John Anderson. Go ahead, John.
[John Anderson]: Thank you. Of course, I join in joy at the fact that this is being redeveloped for such a timely purpose. I have a sort of different view on the signage. I think the sort of monument style signage is very useful for the person who's driving along the road. And they're trying to figure out where do I enter this place? I mean, that sort of grounds you, okay, this is where we want to go in. And you can't really miss it when you're driving up and down the street there.
And the wayfinding inside the campus there I think is all very appropriate and very helpful for people who are trying to get their parts of service or whatever. I guess, I don't know, I don't share the same view as the board that using the building as a billboard is what we're really looking for here. I thought that the purpose of signage, the reason we did the signed ordinance in the first place was to help businesses make their presence known.
I didn't think of it though, as an opportunity to do advertising. So for example, you wouldn't, if you had a one day store, you know, you wouldn't be allowed to cover the window with a big ad. It just seems to me that I just don't like the idea of using the building as a giant billboard. Oh, and by the way, my biggest concern initially was with the, what do you call it, the pylons. And I appreciate seeing the one that you've come up with. I would have liked to have seen the other pylon as well. And I wonder if the two could be combined. uh, you know, because you really want to identify, I think of the BMW dealer up the street. The first time I drove by and I said, Oh, that's nice. There's a BMW dealer here. And then I said, okay, it's for pre-owned. It doesn't, you know, this is not where I go if I wanted to buy a new BMW, but I would go here if I wanted to get repairs and that sort of thing. So I think in terms of identifying the building, its purpose, and telling people where you enter, I'm great with that. The wayfinding inside, I'm great with that. The building as a large advertisement is not personally something I think is great.
Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, John. So John, again, to kind of dive a little bit deeper here, are you suggesting that we combine both pylons into one rather than have two separate?
[John Anderson]: I think, well, I'd like to see it in a rendering, but I think it's an idea worth pursuing.
[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. Paige, do you have any comments?
[Page Buldini]: Well, now I have a question. When it comes to Mystic Ave, I just did a quick Google look at it. And I know that there's a clear channel billboards, which are different, obviously. And I know that Scrub-a-Dub, which is behind here, has a sign. But I think they're under new management, which I could be wrong. Would that change, then, to speak off of what Sean said about the way that Mystic Ave would look going forward? would we have taller signs? Is that a good thing coming from a business owner? Obviously, differing opinions to John, but I think it's important with advertising. So I'm interested to see if there's other, if there's any way that we could go back to the look when we saw, I think there was a Google Earth look of Mystic Ave. It might be a little outdated, but I didn't know if there was any other signs, just so we could see to scale.
[Frank Marinelli]: Well, I pour, there are billboards.
[Page Buldini]: Yeah. And it might not be, but just now out of curiosity. Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: There's a billboard right here on the Volkswagen site.
[Page Buldini]: I think there are three.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And then there's, I think there's another one there and then there's the signage for Scrub-a-Dub here.
[Frank Marinelli]: Okay. I just make the point that it is a unique site. We're, we're surrounded on all sides by by roadway and view corridors. And when you read the purpose of the signed bylaw, we're being very tasteful in design and proportionate. But one of the purposes is to enhance the economic climate of the city. And we're doing that with the investment that we've made per the CDB decision in 2024. And again, it's an over $50 million investment. And the city is not dealing with a vacant building. or trying to rent it to multiple tenants, as had happened in the interlude between Century Bank and Herb Chambers. There were multiple tenants and there were vacancies, and that's not a good thing. When you have a single user It's like we represent Dix in certain buildings now, and Dix has taken over Lord and Taylor or Nordstrom, for example, and you don't have a lot of 100,000 square foot users when you have an anchor store go dark. And I'm sure that the board knows that and appreciates that.
We felt that we hit it right in terms of the proportionality, the visual scale, all of the things that are called for in the zoning ordinance. We addressed comprehensively if we can take a look at the pylon concerns, but certainly on the time and temp and the signage that is appropriate for these facades, it's 1% to 2.2%. The proportionate proportionality is. is evident in terms of the minor use of the facades for the wall signage, and it's tastefully done. I know Laura Milligan from Patterson's side is on the Zoom, and perhaps she has something she can add to on. I just unmuted you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Go ahead, Laura. 35 versus 24.
[SPEAKER_05]: Thank you so much. So just in reference to the 35 foot versus the 24, typically with Toyota pylons, the main brand pylon is typically larger. We do see a majority of signs throughout the U.S. I do work with, you know, throughout the U.S. being 30 or 35 foot tall. And then secondary pylon, which is what would be the certified used vehicle pylon, would be something slightly smaller. So this would be the next size down that we've proposed based on having the 35-foot pylon. I know, John Anderson, just referencing your request to possibly merge the two, I do know throughout the nation, there are no merged main brand sign and used vehicle pylons that are combined. So I just wanted to kind of elaborate on that as well.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Laura.
[Frank Marinelli]: You're welcome. Just for scale also, there is no other five-story building. And it is an approved building with the car elevator and the new three-story building is a tremendous investment. And just talking with the project engineer, we believe that's over 40 feet on the new three-story. So that provides some context in terms of the foreground of that 35-foot pylon with the service building in the back.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Understood. I think Sean Began mentioned earlier that the sign ordinance was 20 foot limit and you've got, was that correct, Sean? And we're going to obviously 24 and 35 for this one. The percentages that you are quoting of the facade, can you clarify versus the ordinance what the delta is between what's allowed and what you're proposing?
[Frank Marinelli]: Sure. If we were to And again, the ordinance may be appropriate for a 2,000 square foot restaurant on a very small lot. We have 173,530 square foot building approved and built. And it's on a 4.87 acre lot. The ordinance, if you went by, and with all due respect, and I think the chair knows that one size does not fit all. So that's why this is a case by case analysis. and we feel that we've got it right in terms of this business, in terms of the single user. But if you were to adhere to 100 to 300 square foot on a primary wall sign, we would just get the badge next to the door and we would get a 40 square foot secondary sign on the wall sign. It would not fulfill the purposes of direction, of safety, of convenience, turning moments into the site of enhancing the economic climate of the city, which obviously the 2024 decision has done a great deal to enhance the economic climate. And this is a business, and again, one of the purposes, the interest of businesses and business owners, and it's a commercial sub-district of the MACD, of the Mystic Avenue corridor district. You know, when you go further west, You have mixed use now, the tendency and the hope that more residential will be created in those other sub-districts. But this sub-district of which we are squarely the centerpiece of is entirely commercial.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Mr. Brown. Danielle, you've got your hand raised. Go ahead.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yes. I can speak to what would be allowed and And what they're requesting, so some of the signs in their package are actually exempt. So the wayfinding signs, provided that there's no branding on them, are exempt from number of signs and size of signs. So they don't actually need permission to put the wayfinding ones. Regarding the pylon signs, Sean is correct. The maximum size is 20 feet, but you can only allowed one. The maximum sign copy on them is 60 square feet. So I think I believe that they were complying or close to complying with the size of the signage, but yet they were too tall and you can only have one and they had two.
And regarding the wall signage, the amount, You can have one primary sign and one secondary sign. But if you have frontage on more than one road or a parking lot or a view corridor, you can split that in half and so share it. But the maximum is 100 square feet for that primary sign. So they'd be splitting it 50-50. But then there's the provision to increase The size, depending on how far you're set back, you could go up to a max of 300, but it's not set back far enough. Like the way that the lot lines fall, they would have to be set back very, like 400 feet to get the 300. So the wall signage made a lot of sense because it would just be so small, you wouldn't even, see it.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I couldn't agree more. And I didn't mean to suggest that we're going to try to live with it. And Mr. Marino, I want to make clear that this is not about, it's about aesthetics. It's really about choices here. You have signage on four sides of the building. There are a few buildings in Medford who could even say that. This is a lot of signage, as John Anderson mentioned. I agree with him on that. There's a lot here. But I think most people, seem to be okay with the building in a broad, general sense, but the pylon is tall and there are 2 pylons and. And it's behind a building that is basically only a few feet taller. It's, it's, you know, it's a vertical. It's a vertical billboard is what a pylon is. You can see this from a mile away in three directions if you're on the highway or on Mystic Avenue, but the pylon is very tall. Several of the signs are 20 feet higher and 10 feet lower. I think we're asking questions, can they be combined? Can they be a little shorter? We don't want to see an arms race on tall signs on Mystic Avenue for the next 25 years either. You know, so these are just questions. I think the fundamentals here are good, from what I see. But I think we've had a good round of conversation. I want to open it up to the public now, if that's okay, and we can circle back at the end.
So I'm going to If anyone in the public would like to raise their hand, I'll just make a few comments here. Those who wish to provide comments can use the raise hand feature under the reactions on your Zoom. or if you're dialed in on a phone, you can use the star nine to raise your hand. You can message Alicia in the chat. If you are having technical difficulties before providing your comments, please state your name and address for the record. A reminder to all that meeting participants to please refrain from using the chat function to message any comments to city staff or board members as it is not part of the public record. However, if a participant is having audio or technical difficulties, you may message staff for assistance. Each participant will have two minutes to speak. Is there anyone who would like to speak from the general public?
I don't see anyone. Is that correct, Alicia?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Checking, but I am not seeing anyone.
[Unidentified]: Okay.
[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, well, hearing none, I guess I will close the, it's rare that we have no public comments, which is not a bad thing. So I'll close the public comment period, and I'll open it up to the board for any further discussions.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Can I just make a comment?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Hold on one second, Alicia, go ahead.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yeah, I just sort of wanted to just share to the board, because the board is, I do want to make clear that in Medford, our signs don't stop The fine zoning is the exact same across the entire city. This is not customized zoning just for Mr. Gav, that it's the same across the entire city. and that it has not been updated. As long as we're aware of, we do not actually have any awareness other than adjustments to be in compliance with state and federal law regarding political signage. Medford's the signage section of our zoning, my apologies.
has not been updated, just because I know some people are like, well, if this is the way the zoning is, this is not an area that has really been truly contemplated to like consider modern economic development, modern transportation habits, modern any of that has not gone into the thinking on Medford's zoning, signage zoning. And it is something that is on our to-do list, but I don't think we're gonna get to for several years.
[Chair Doug Carr]: That was going to be my next question. Alicia is obviously, since we're going around the city zoning, top to bottom, it seems like this is obviously something that needs to be looked at.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And it's apparently our, when we did have some, uh, zoning lawyers look at our signage, I was told that it is quite complicated and it's not simple and standard. Um, and which is why it was not actually touched in the recodification at all. Um, other than to remove things that were no longer in compliance with federal law. Um, so and in our list of things that the city is looking to work on in the zoning project, this is fairly low down on the list of priorities. Yep.
[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, so going back to the board, any other comments or any direction that people would like to propose for this project in terms of hearing? Go ahead, Mr. Anderson.
[John Anderson]: Thank you. First, just a comment. I'm sorry, I've forgotten the lady's name, said that there were no cases of a pylon having both the brand and the fact that it was pre-owned certified. If you actually go up the street to the BMW dealer, which is also Herb Chambers, I don't know whether you call it a pylon or not, but they have a sign out front that serves the same purpose, and it's got the BMW logo, and then right underneath it, it says pre-owned certified. So it is possible, and in fact, that's what caught my attention to that particular site.
Also, I wonder if one of the city staff persons could comment on what the vision is for Mystic Avenue. I know there are some billboards there. So in that context, a building that has a lot of advertising on it might be appropriate. What's the vision for Mystic Avenue? I don't mean this to sound disparaging, like sort of like a section of Auto Mile or Route 1 in Saugus. I mean, what is the vision for this ultimately?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: I could speak to that a little bit. This sub-district of the Mystic Ave corridor district was the one remaining portion of Mystic Ave where we were allowing these kind of auto-oriented uses. We found that this part of Mystic Ave was appropriate for those. It's not a very walkable area. It's right off the highway with the ramps there. We wanted to focus the opposite end of Mystic Ave, as you get closer to the square, To be mixed use walkable, getting away from the auto uses.
For example, this, the car dealerships that you see up further up the stick are non conforming. Now, they're not allowed, but, of course, you don't kick someone out just because they're a preexisting nonconforming use, but. Repair shops, any auto uses car washes are not allowed further up. Mystic have this commercial area. It was reserved for that understanding that these are uses that you don't. You want to completely zone out of a city there no necessary and. This is an appropriate spot for it. Regarding the billboards, billboards aren't actually allowed. I don't really know the history behind those clear channel ones. They had some kind of special approvals from city council probably decades ago. I know that they can be beneficial. They provide, I think, advertising for city events and purposes every now and then.
But billboards aren't allowed. Someone just can't decide to put a billboard on top of a building. Someone actually inquired earlier this week if they could put a billboard on their building. It's a revenue source. Other cities you can do that. You can't do that here. So no, we're not looking for billboards and expanding the auto mile. We have more than our fair share. I don't know, Alicia, do you have anything else to add to that?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think you really covered it, that it's both the, it's almost the both end, that down here, yes, the automobile, the scrub-a-dub is actually under renovations that was approved through a site plan review. These things, there is important to have a commercial industrial area, but once you get further up the street, we're trying to, push things towards a mixed use walkable area. This is so close to the highway exit ramp that actually you'll note that on their site plan, they do not extend the sidewalk all the way to the exit ramp. And that's intentional so that people actually are kind of forced to cross Mystic Ave before they walk across the end of a highway entrance ramp. So this end is acknowledged as the more auto area.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you. Go ahead, Sean.
[Sean Beagan]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like from my position, I'd like the board to be able to act on this tonight for this applicant. I really don't want to cause them to have to come back twice for this. And I'm wondering if the applicant would be open to perhaps a motion to approve subject to the two-pylon signs each being slightly shorter, say 25 feet and 20 feet. If they don't want them to be the same size, would they do like a 25 foot and a 20 foot? Is that, I'm not putting that forward as a motion. I'm just throwing that out there as a, as a proposal, as a kind of a proposal to see if other board members are on the, Same page as me in terms of trying to get some approval for them tonight, because it does seem like they're substantially close to being done with this project.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, before I kind of survey the board informally, I guess when I look at the signage on the building, none of it says about the pre-owned. It's all about Toyota brand and Herb Chambers, right? And so this pylon is almost as, it's like the two pylons to me are not representative of what's in the building because We didn't put pre-owned anywhere else on the building. There's a half dozen or signs that say Toyota and Herb Chambers, but pre-owned only exists in that second pylon, which to me suggests that just one pylon slightly lower perhaps should do the job if you want to have a monumental sign saying pre-owned go this way as you come in. No one's going to miss that, obviously. I could be in the minority here, but it seems like overkill to me because given the amount of signage that's on this building. But again, I want to hear what John Page and Ari, your thoughts on this as well.
Paige, do you have a preference? So I'm sorry. Good. Are you raise your hand?
[Page Buldini]: No, that's okay. I can wait for you can go 1st.
[Ari Fishman]: Oh, thank you. I do agree. I would be since we're, I think we are fundamentally very close to. Approval of design, it seems to be 1 aspect of it. That's under debate. I would like to approve as much as possible. I'm not weighing in a huge amount on the pylons. They didn't strike me as remarkable at kind of 1st glance. I am hearing the concerns from the rest of the board. But yes, I would like, I agree that we should have a motion if possible today. And if the applicant wants to speak up about if they have any preferences, I'd be very interested in hearing that.
[Page Buldini]: Thank you so much. I completely agree with Ari. I think you said that very well said, and with my fellow board members. Just a quick question for clarity, Frank. Is two pylons normal for the brand? Is that just your brand identity? Is that something that's really important? Because I think that would be important for us to know. But I think what Michael shared.
[Frank Marinelli]: Thank you. I think that Laura can address the, The wider experience with Toyota, but I would say it is. Certainly not uncommon and it is common because we're talking about on premise science here, meaning that what is put on the on the sign is the business and we have a 5 story 173,530 square foot building. I looked at the neighborhood. There's nothing close to that. There's no precedential effect. This is. This is a unique building as we've tried to establish with all of the criteria that is necessary for the special permit. To Alicia Hunt's point, I think that it is a case-by-case analysis because signage codification was not adopted for the MACD any differently, but under 94.6.2.20, the special permit can be granted.
for all of the five criteria that we addressed. I think the largest building on this corridor is the public storage, which is about half the size. I think it's like 90,000 square feet compared to 173. So we have a very unique building, a very unique lot, the four sides. I appreciate and I know the client and chambers appreciates the comments of the board. I think that this is very tastefully done on what has been planned. In terms of the two pylons, we'd like to try to consider maybe 30 feet on the primary pylon and then have the certified pre-owned because it is a product on premise. This is not a billboard like you have on Mystic Avenue. This describes what we sell and what the business is all about. It's a classic on-premise sign. We're not doing anything that isn't related to the site. But we could consider something if the board is bothered by the height of the primary. We could consider, I think Laura talked about a 30-foot product and she knows best because she's manufacturing the signs and put the Toyota dealerships nationwide. But We certainly want to work with the board, but we need to have certain brand awareness. There's a busy road network on all four sides here that we want people to get in and know where they're going.
We think that we fulfilled the purposes of the special permit as we described in the presentation.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Mr. Marnell, would you consider a 30-foot pylon that combines the two together? Because I feel like that's a reasonable compromise.
[Frank Marinelli]: Can I ask, Laura, what is your experience through the chair? Is that something to get from the expert on the signage, please?
[SPEAKER_05]: For sure. Thank you, Frank. And thank you, Chair. From previous history, we've always had two separate pylons separating the branding. So, the used, the certified used vehicles or the used vehicles would have its own designation. So, that own pylon as well as, you know, you would have your primary pylon.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Right, but when they go into the site, they have a sign that goes one way for the pre use and one way for the maintenance, right? Or the new cars. Is that correct?
[Frank Marinelli]: No, I don't have any directional. We don't have a directional that separates pre-owned from new. Correct. Yeah. Directional assist, showroom, or?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Showroom versus maintenance. Yes.
[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah. Showroom, service reception, parts and accessories, and shipping receiving. The certified used vehicle pylon would be the only, I don't want to say advertising, but the only thing that would designate that the dealership offers the certified used vehicles.
[Sean Beagan]: Go ahead, Sean. Yeah, I was just going to say that, you know, I'm not opposed. I, for one, I'm not opposed to them having two pylons. I would just like to see the size brought down a little bit. I know that. Herb Chambers and I'm sure for other dealerships. Selling the certified pre-owned product is very important to them and I think the two pylons, I would say the main Toyota sign kind of denotes the new and then you have your separate pre-owned as another option. I know that is probably a good part of their business model of these certified pre-owned vehicles. So I don't have a problem with them having two pylons, especially out on this lot, which is, frankly, on the outskirts of Medford and right next to the highway. So I don't think the two pylons bother me. I would just like to see the height brought down to something a little bit more reasonable.
[John Anderson]: John Anderson. Just a quick question. Does this dealership only sell certified used cars or do they sell new cars as well?
[Frank Marinelli]: No, it's a class one license, which entitles to sell new and used vehicles. And that's their plan. yes okay that the both products are available which again goes to uh laura's point um and to uh mr beagan's point we we can go back with the chair's permission to Laura, but, you know, I think 30 and 24 are prototypes. And I don't know if, Laura, you want to comment any further on the sizes that, to Mr. Began's point on height, we've already brought down the primary, but I think the 30 and the 24 would be certainly doable.
[SPEAKER_05]: That's correct. We do have a 30-foot pylon. So if the board would like to reduce it, that would be the next size down that we would have in our brand program.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And Laura, what's the next size down from 24?
[SPEAKER_05]: 24, I believe, would be a 22. And then the next size down would be a 19. OK.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I guess I'd like to propose that we have two pylons, one 30 feet and one 19. So it's one's within zoning and one is not. I think that's, to me, that strikes me as a reasonable compromise. Again, I would open it up to the board if they're feeling comfortable with that. Maybe starting with you, Sean.
[Sean Beagan]: Yes, Mr. Chair, I'd support that proposal. John Anderson?
[John Anderson]: Yeah, that's fine as long as, that's fine for the pylons. Oh, I have one question, and then I'll quit beating this drum. How many times, how many instances are there of the Toyota logo and name on the building? Total? Total.
[Frank Marinelli]: Well, there's two on the satellite, and then let's go around to the- Try to decide whether it's five or six. Yeah, again, there's so many staggered facades, and the new three-story is about 140,000 square foot addition. So I think to concentrate on numbers, the percentages of what they take up on the facade is really, I think, a relevant inquiry. Because when you look at the 94-6.2.20 special permit criteria, it talks about visual scale. And our visual scale is 1 to 2.2 percent of the various facades. But the answer to your question is two there. On the northerly facade, we've got the one at the end, and we've got the one at the top on top of Time Temp, which I think Century Bank had their name on top of or close to Time Temp.
on the northerly, and on the easterly, that's symmetrical to the northerly, the horizontal Toyota logo in Toyota, and also the badge on the service center. And then on the westerly, just one Toyota, one Toyota horizontal under Herb Chambers. But again, they're all very modest in size, in relative context. to the size of the facades, we're talking about 84 square feet with the logo and the horizontal lettering. Okay, thank you. Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, so I think I'm looking for a motion to approve the package with the following changes. One 30-foot main pylon for Toyota, and I think we determined an 18-foot for the pre-owned pylon, correct, Mr. Mayor?
[Frank Marinelli]: I think Laura said 19. 19-foot. 19, so 30 feet for the main, 19 for the other one.
[Chair Doug Carr]: and the rest of the signage approved per the package. Would someone like to make that?
[Sean Beagan]: I can make that motion, Mr. Chair. I would move that the applicant's submission be approved subject to the main Toyota pylon being no greater than 30 feet in height and the pre-owned certified pylon being no greater than 19 feet in height. Can I get a second?
[Page Buldini]: I second that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, Paige. I'll do a roll call. Sean Megan? Yes. Page Buldini? Yes. John Anderson? Yes. Ari Fishman?
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, Doug Keller? Yes. The motion passes 5-0. Thank you very much, Mr. Marinello. I appreciate your patience and the city is really looking forward to this project being completed. It's an excellent addition to the city.
[Frank Marinelli]: Thank you, Chairperson Carr, and on behalf of Asbury and Herb Chambers Toyota, we thank all of you board members for your support of this great economic development for the city. Thank you.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Thank you, sir. All right, so what we have left are meeting minutes, so I'm going to ask for any edits to the draft meeting minutes dated 10, 15, 25. Are there any edits, or if not, we'll ask for a motion to accept the minutes.
[Ari Fishman]: I so move.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Second. Yep. Second. Thank you, Sean. All right. Uh, John Anderson? Aye. Sean Began? Yes. Ari Fishman?
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Page Buldini?
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And the last item is there's some zoning project and other administrative updates. I'm going to turn it over to Alicia and Danielle on that one. We have to talk about a couple of different things coming up. Go ahead, Alicia or Danielle.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: She muted herself.
[Chair Doug Carr]: There you go.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I have a remote. I have a button and my button turned green and my screen muted myself. I was very confused. And so I had to try and find my mouse. Sorry about that. No worries. Go ahead, Alicia. So we have advertised a joint meeting of the Community Development Board and the City Council for Wednesday, January 21st, which is the date of your next scheduled meeting. to consider the Medford Square zoning. The proposal as it has been referred by the City Council at this time is the original proposal that came from the City Council. There is some level of expectation that there might be edits to that through this process. For example, there had been identified some residential parcels that maybe should be removed from that and only look at MX parcels and not try to do any residential parcels at all.
In order to, I think it was to minimize confusion. It's just exactly what was before the board before so that people have experience with it. We are in the process of finalizing the scope and contract with Innes Associates. They do have that meeting on their calendar and we do expect Emily Innis to be present. to be able to speak to what was there, what it means, how it works. That does not mean you shouldn't propose edits. It just means that she's there to provide that background and that the members of the public will be able to speak to it.
It is my expectation that you might Well, let's just say we'll put it all out there in front of you. We won't have any edited maps at that point. I think we might ask them to prepare a map that removes the residential pieces that had been previously requested to be removed from it so that it would be available as an option should the board like that option and for the board to be able to see it. We are asking Chair Carr and Council President Bears and myself and Danielle and their clerk, Rich Alizio, to have a pre-meeting to just talk procedure. How should this run? How does this work? So that before the meeting starts, we all have some So we may send out some email to the board sort of saying, here's what you should expect the day of. Here's how a joint meeting will work. Because unless you have watched them in other communities, which you may have, you may not have ever seen that before. So we just want to make sure everybody understands the process for it. For this situation, I'm personally encouraging people, board members, to come in person. I think it will make things smoother if people can look at each other across the room and take body cues and stuff with so many people being present as part of it. If you cannot, you cannot, and you should just say so, and there will be a hybrid option. And Rich Alizio and I, we're gonna ask to have Medford Community Media staff, Kevin Harrington available, sorry, he's the director, available as well for that meeting to make sure things go smoothly as well in the technology piece of it.
So that will be Wednesday the 21st. The agreement with the city council and the mayor around the zoning is that we would only take one portion at a time and members of the public and members of the board will not be asked to consider other zoning in other parts of the city while this one is open and being contemplated. When this one is done, then there will be a discussion of Boston Ave and the Tufts Institutional Zoning. The consultant will be working in the background to get that ready to be putting that forward. But we expect that it might, we are not contemplating that you will vote and close this hearing in one meeting. So.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I can assure you that will not be the case.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I just wanted to make that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Can we just start briefly, just to show our hands if you intend to be there in person on the 21st? Okay, so that's five for five here, and then obviously you can let us know. So we're getting more than a quorum there for sure, which I think will be good. So that's a good sign. I will say that I spent a couple of days over the Christmas break looking at the zoning map for Medford Square, and I literally went through every building. I didn't walk it because it was cold, but I literally walked it through Google Maps and down the street. And I've known that city my whole life, that neighborhood. And I made an assessment of every building that I thought was either that I knew was historic, or that I thought was worth saving, or that I thought I wouldn't mind if this building went away. And I've got a diagram that I'll share with you guys later in the week that shows that. This is just my thoughts, my opinion. It comes out of the historical perspective, but I'm a developer architect. I'm not afraid of new development and housing. I don't believe every old building should be saved. I feel like there's a lot of work here. I think when we get to it, I feel like this could be a long process because I think there's a wide gap between. I know what I see should happen in Bedford Square. and what the current map shows, which is almost 180 degrees against that, even though it's got some really good points in it, and some excellent areas where new development should happen, like the three parcels we saw tonight. They've been flat and empty for 30, 40 years. All of them should be redeveloped, but that's a conversation we're going to have with the city council and with the city, with the Medford people who show up on the 20th, the beginning of the conversation.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I just want to caution you about having open meeting law like deliberation outside the meeting. You may want to send stuff to me and Danielle. And then we can provide information to the board. Anything we provide to the board should be available to the public. So I just want to sort of, whether you want to bring something with you to the meeting versus you want it to be available to the board and the council to contemplate in advance, send it to us so that you all do not, you cannot start emailing each other about what you all think about the square in advance.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Understood. Go ahead, Paige.
[Page Buldini]: Just real quick, just so I know for clarity, I know I'm very excited for this meeting. I think it's really important. And I feel lucky that I can be there in person. Would there be other opportunities? Or is this just like a one-time thing to be meeting with the city council?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I think that once we open a joint public hearing, it has to continue to be joint. Although in theory, the CD board could, I guess in theory, Danielle's wondering about that, could continue their meeting. Because what I was explained by the lawyer is that what would literally happen is that one board, the city council, would open their meeting and do roll call. And then they would pause, and the CD board would open their meeting and do roll call. And then it would be run by one of the chairs. you know, the meeting would be run, but if there were votes, each board would then take their own vote separately. So if over the course of the evening, it became clear that the CD board wanted to have additional meetings and the city council wanted to say, why don't we continue to a date certain of the first week in March? and the CD board continues to mid February, the CD board could meet and meet and then declare that their next meeting was that first week in March and come back together as a joint meeting. Legally, that's possible.
Whether they, you know, whether that wants to happen, you know, I think that's a great question.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah, in my experience that these initial, like, kind of like kickoff meeting is joint, but then the planning board can continue the public hearing. On their own, but this is a good question for legal. It's been a long time since I was involved with something like that.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: And it was in a different city, just for reference. Because we get different legal. It's fascinating. We'll say, but X city's lawyers said they could do that. And our lawyers will say, we disagree with their lawyers. Go ahead, John.
[John Anderson]: So just to be clear, the public hearing will be on what topic? Medford Square zoning. Just Medford Square.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Just Medford Square. We have severed West Medford from it. It's just Medford Square.
[John Anderson]: Super. Who chairs the meeting?
[Chair Doug Carr]: I think it's going to be Zach because he obviously has significant experience, but I'm going to be kind of there with him. But he's going to, if one person needs a chair, I believe it should be Zach from a senior perspective.
[John Anderson]: And other than the public hearing, on Medford Square, is there anything else on the agenda? No, we've actually been very careful about that.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Okay. Yeah, so nothing that came up tonight, the Main Street door or Salem Street will be discussed that night. It's purely Medford Square and it's going to go on for four or five hours, let's be honest here.
[John Anderson]: So we won't get distracted into, What do we take up next after this and things of that nature? OK.
[Chair Doug Carr]: This is too big to be an agenda item. Thank you. Go ahead, Sean.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah. Alicia, has there been any thought to biting this off in maybe even smaller chunks than the entirety of Medford Square? I'm thinking. You have that area over by city hall that we discussed tonight, which is essentially undeveloped land. I'm just thinking some of these areas, even within Medford Square, are going to be much easier to discuss than, say, when you get over to High Street and you start talking about buildings from the 1700s and buildings that are on the river that are going to fall into the river if we do any substantial changes to them. Just kidding.
Has there been any thought to kind of biting it off at even smaller chunks like that?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So I would actually just remind you that just because something is zoned doesn't mean that it's technically possible that they can build it. that it would get built, right? And it doesn't mean, so one of the, I think you all know, but we have had a lot of trouble with the public saying, well, why can't I see a rendering of the building you're gonna build? And we say, but we're not building a building. We're just making the boxes that they're allowed to build in if they should choose to.
But nobody's definitely doing, I'd like to think that the project on the RFP parcels behind Medford Square is definite, but literally there's not a contract signed. There are no other projects proposed. This is just saying what they could do if they want to. And it's an interesting question about balancing the rights of the property owners. One of the things that we did hear was property owners saying, I want to be allowed to build taller and bigger. And I look at those buildings whose backs are literally on the supporting wall of the Mystic River. And I think to myself, well, the Conservation Commission has to approve you doing anything.
the structural of being able to build there has to be able to happen in order to do it. One of those buildings, once in my memory, wanted to put in underground parking and they were basically told and I don't know if they were told by the city by policy I think it was actually a no that you can't literally literally can't that like three two feet from the edge of the supporting wall of the river and these other buildings
[Chair Doug Carr]: They tried to build that illegally from what I remember. I don't know if that was true, but they'd someone that I thought they were. They stopped the construction of that because they were worried about structural integrity of the whole building per Sean's comment. Is that the case?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I don't remember it that way, but it may actually be on the edge where I was the energy coordinator, and there was somebody else was the environmental agent, because I was certainly not staffed to the CONCOM when something like that happened. So it must have been pre-2012.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Could not, it is, I mean, they, they could actually create a SketchUp model with the maximum volume of building that could go there for every single site. That would not be hard for them to do as planners, right? I mean, that could take somebody two hours to do if they had any SketchUp skills at all to show what the absolute, you know, it's 60 feet tall.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: This is what people were asking about. The difficulty is that it's not just what is the allowed height and what is the allowed setback, but it's also how are you meeting the green space requirements? How are you meeting the stormwater? How are you meeting the parking? So it's actually quite complicated to figure out what you can actually build there. I mean, you can put blocks that say this is the max possible, but those blocks don't contemplate, well, where are those units, apartments or offices or R&D? And how much parking do you need? And where are you putting the parking? And have you arranged for offsite parking or are you trying to do it onsite, right? Like that's where things, when the rubber hits the road, it gets way more complicated than just saying, this is what the box is.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: But I do think we have to be careful because you end up with people saying, well, my property is zoned to do eight stories and my site is unusual and different from all the other parcels in this district. And therefore, I should get a variance and be able to do this. So we have to be careful that we're not just zoning for things and then just kind of casting aside. Oh, but they can't do that there because then they can make this argument that they've got an unusual lot. And then they're not getting the highest and best use, and this is a hardship. And they should be granted all these variances so that they can be able to take advantage of the zoning. So we have to be careful there.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, that was my point in saying, you know, and we can talk about this in the 21st, you know, are we better off just doing this and maybe smaller chunks than blanket zoning an area and I agree with Daniela. So if you if you put something in the in the zoning that's possible, someone's going to try to do it, you know, I would think and You know, I agree with you, Alicia. I also agree with what you're saying, Alicia. I totally get your point that just because we changed the zoning doesn't mean anyone's going to be able to do much with that change. You know, parking is going to be a huge issue that's going to have to be discussed in Medford Square. I mean, most of those buildings have zero parking, right? Correct. So.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, and there's the plan that I, you know, there was some discussion of a historic district in Medford Square that does not exist right now that would change the character and nature of what could be proposed for some of those important buildings. Some of them, there's at least 7 or 8 buildings in Medford Square per Sean's comment earlier that are not only on the state register, but the national register of historic places in the square. And that's not true on Salem Street, and it's only true for a handful of buildings beyond Medford Square right now in the city. Go ahead, Paige.
[Page Buldini]: There's a quick question, just so I don't, because I don't know about much about historic neighborhoods. Is that something that couldn't affect change the zoning, or would it already have to be done, like a historic district, per se?
[Chair Doug Carr]: I think that's a question for the consultant. I guess I would propose that any zoning that we do in Medford Square has some historic district component. I don't know what its limits are or what's in it. Things like Chevalier Auditorium, the Bigelow block, which is the cover of every planning document that's been ever put out by the planning department in the last 100 years, it seems. Obviously, I'll get everyone a list, or at least I'll go through the chair to Alicia, so people can know which ones we're talking about. Because you may not know them all, because some of them are literally buried. Like that building's from the early 1700s.
Look at it closely. It predates everything in the square almost that's there now. So we have a lot to chew on. I agree with Sean. It's tough to capture from Route 93 on one side all the way to the Medford Rotary and Route 60 on the other. That's how far this thing spans in the map right now. It's a pretty wide net cast to find what Medford Square is. So there's a lot of work to be done, a lot of thinking, a lot of debate that needs to happen. And we'll start it on the 21st.
Any other questions or comments?
[John Anderson]: Go ahead, John. Quick question. What's the timeline? In other words, when we open a hearing on Medford Square, is there some timeline in which it has to be wrapped up?
[Chair Doug Carr]: Sounds like no, Alicia, right?
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Yep. There's no legal timeline.
[Chair Doug Carr]: OK. I think it's when we get it right. Good. It's certainly not one meeting, obviously. And I think the public, you know, think of all the property owners and it's going to be a big one. Um, okay, are there any other administrative updates? Because I think I do want to get to a couple of the, like, John Anderson, your, your suggestion for some improvements in our procedures. I want to talk about that. But before I do that, Alicia or Danielle, is there anything else we need to talk about?
No. So, at our last meeting, I asked folks to think about what you're interested in, any subjects that you want to take on, changes we want to make, procedure updates, anything. And I got one from John. John, do you want me to put your piece of your text on the screen? Sure. Let me do that. Hold on one second.
[Unidentified]: OK.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So John put together some thoughts about streamlining site plan review. And John, why don't you explain this? You wrote this. Give a brief summary if you could.
[John Anderson]: Well, yeah, we have these sections in the city ordinance that describe what criteria and how we're supposed to look at proposed site plans. And I think we talked about this before, that we ask the applicant to actually say how their project addresses these points as part of their initial application. Anyway, let me go on. Then section by section, there are some sections which we could talk about and are appropriate for us to discuss that are sort of aesthetic or a But then there are some.
criteria that are clearly the realm of a specific city agency. For example, there was some discussion of what, there's some rules about lighting and how much light sort of impacts neighbors and things of that nature, which I would have no idea how to deal with that. And things that could sort of be written off as it does not apply, you know, like handling of radioactive materials, that sort of thing. And then there are things that require very specific comments from city agencies, you know, the engineering, uh, fire. Uh, so if we know who needs to, who needs to address each of these topics, uh, I think we can get through it much faster and we'll know where we are in terms of doing the review. And then try to establish a normal timeline for the site review process. Cause you know, as it's, it's been said that some developers get sort of grumpy if we don't approve things fast enough and we send stuff out to city agencies and they do it when they have time and you can understand they have lots of things to work on.
Uh, but I think we need to set some, set some standards, you know, like a city agency, whatever they say they need, you know, is it two weeks to respond? Is it a month to respond? If we don't have that, if we don't have some markers there, we can't say how long it's going to take to complete the site review process. So I guess what I'm saying is we need to perhaps be a little more comprehensive in terms of addressing all those points that are outlined in our charter, but also make sure that we can get it done in a timely manner, getting all the input that's really important.
[Chair Doug Carr]: All right, so let me stop you there, John. Danielle or Alicia, could you address the timeline side of things, what John was saying, what a normal, does that exist? Again, he and I are both brand new to this, so I don't think I have much to compare it to, but can you talk a little bit about that as an idea? What have you seen?
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: This is really timely because I fired off a very lengthy email, I think today, about how the entire process needs to be revamped. It's going to require changes to the ordinance. It's going to require changes to the CD board rules and regs, and it's going to require some internal staff policies to put in place. That way that there is a predictable pattern of and timeline of the pre-application from the conceptual stage of an idea to meeting with individual departments so that everyone's, you know, the ducks are in a row, you know, looping in the mayor's office for some of like the big picture things. When we get a site plan review application basically just dropped on my chair while I'm on vacation and then this two week clock starts, like that's just untenable and it can't be anymore. I've never worked anywhere where that sort of thing happens. We need to have a filing day to have an appointment where there's an intake and we go through the checklist and we make sure it's complete.
And that way we're not getting these applications that we didn't even know were coming in or We'd heard about them, but then you don't, you don't hear from them for like six months and then you have the stack of papers. You're like, what do you just, these are too big to just land on your chair. Um, and so we're, we're, we do need to, to come up with a better process. And 1 of the things that we wanted to do with the, you know, the zoning updates, you know, not just changing the zoning districts. and what you can do on them, but also there are processes. Is what projects triggers site plan review? Right now it doesn't really make a lot of sense. It's if you're a major project, that's a defined term, and then there's a list. And some of them just don't make any sense. So convenience store, that's a major project and requires site plan review. But then something gigantic won't need it, as long as it's under 10,000 square feet. It's very strange. So we need to modernize that, we need to have a process for minor and major site plan review. As John was saying, we have this full list of performance standards that are very kind of like cookie cutter, one size fits all, that the zoning attorney who has a lot of cities as clients just kind of put in there. A lot of it doesn't even work for Medford. But we weren't really part of that process, but that recodification that was very much driven by the city council at that time, which still, there's no planners on the city council. So it's from a different lens from the day-to-day, from the folks that actually uses zoning every single day and can spot problems a mile away and how is this even in here?
I'm rambling, but basically, yes, John, I'm 100% behind, we need to have things just a little bit more organized and less ad hoc in reaction areas so that we can pace things better.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I accept I'm very confused, Danielle, by some of your statements, and I apologize that we're sort of airing this here. We have a process that when an application comes in, Danielle reviews it.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: And then we get 2 weeks, but we don't have a time. We don't have a set day that we take them in. That's not normal. That's not normal. That's a Medford exceptionalism.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: We send it out to all the department heads for comments after the 2 weeks, but we've reviewed it.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: But there's some things in there that I can't look at a stormwater report and know that it's completely it. It meets all the needs that Owen will have. And then once I can see, oh, check, we have it, and then we send it to them to review. And then they have their six weeks or whatever it is to review. And then they see that there's all these deficiencies because no one had the conversations up front of what intersections do you want me to look at? And they've done all the traffic studies. But now it's a weird time of year, and to study at this time of year, it doesn't even make sense. It's a lot more upfront work that needs to be done, not just receiving it. If you would let me.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Let's make it clear. There is a process. You don't like the process. No, I think it sucks.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Yeah.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: But that's a very different statement than there's no process.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: There is I didn't say there wasn't a process. I said, it's very, it's not organized.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Alicia is this process is the process written down so we can understand it a little better.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: One of the difficulties it's in the zoning. One of the difficulties that you're seeing the disconnect is that the process asks the what the department has been asked for for many years is a letter. statement about the project questions things that they're looking for. What it doesn't do is send them a list of the performance standards and ask them to respond to the performance standards that were written into the zoning. As Danielle mentioned, they were written in by a lawyer in 2022 without really any input from staff or planners or anything. So those performance standards exist, but I'm not sitting here telling you that those are actually perfect and great and you should hold every project to them. They exist because a lawyer decided to put them in there and the city council said yes, and they voted on it. And there's been no opportunity to really review those and consider those and make change to those. So there is this disconnect. We have been in the process of moving things on to CitizenServe to make things a little bit more formal, to have more date time stamps incorporated, to make sure they automatically go so it's very clear who's replied and who hasn't replied on these. But that doesn't speak to the timelines. The timelines that are in there are Medford timelines that Medford wrote at some point and created, there's nothing under state law that says we have to hold them to. I would love to see things be organized, coordinated. and responded to it in a timely manner and ask department heads to respond. They're not going to respond in a week, but if you give them three weeks or four weeks, yes. And I say that because sometimes it's one person. And what if they're on vacation for the two weeks, right? What if it's not that they can't get to it? It's that what if they have an urgent project that they can't set aside to look at this, right? So we do need a real timeline and a process, an organized way like through the online system so that everybody can see who has responded and what did they say, the way we do for things like building permits. We've recently in the last few months moved the zoning applications to the online system so you can see what other comments people are putting in on them. So some of this is working and some isn't. And as Danielle was saying, some of it is codified in zoning. Some of it is regulation by this board. And some of it is simply policy that the staff can set. There's like staff can say, we only accept site plan review applications on Tuesday afternoons, and you have to make an appointment. But we've never done that. But we could. But that then what we don't want to turn into is a city where a developer applies, and then it takes them three years to work through the application approval process before they can build. And we want to be careful that we don't hit that end of.
[Chair Doug Carr]: I couldn't agree more, Alicia, but I think that the compression that I see, it doesn't, I agree with Danielle on that. when things come in, it's so tight, there's simply not enough time to be able to digest things and react in time. And just give an example, if for Main Street, right, they have revised drawings, we didn't get them yet, Danielle, but to John's point earlier, if we were gonna have them, we were gonna have them fill out their description of how they comply with all these zoning uh allowance you know uh sections we need time we need time for them to get do that with the final drawings us to see it plus their reaction plus the final drawings time to react and then if we don't agree with it we should not have the meeting because we're wasting their time and ours right i mean we almost had that tonight we almost had them back and it would have been A waste of their time and ours, because we weren't ready.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: I don't want to cut you off. We agree. This board can say we will not accept any new materials prior than the Friday before the Wednesday meeting period. The difficulty is that. there's a deadline for the developer is when they get it to Danielle. What if Danielle's not working Friday? What if she's unavailable on Friday, right? So is the deadline actually the Wednesday before in order to give her two days to say, yes, this is what we were expecting, this is the right stuff, and then forward it to the board. You might notice you get a lot of packets from her on Saturdays. Because the developer pushes things to the end of the day Friday.
[Chair Doug Carr]: which you guys are not even open to afternoon, right? You're not even there afternoon most days. Go ahead, Sean, you had a comment.
[Sean Beagan]: Yeah, a couple of things. I think what John's getting at, which I think is great, and I know we've already kind of started doing it, is let's help out the planning department by putting more on the applicant. Let the applicant do a little bit more work. Their attorneys will be happy to do it. All their staff will be happy to do it because they're going to get paid, right? Puts less on, makes less work, makes this process easier to digest for everyone, lets us focus, hopefully makes Danielle and Alicia's job a little easier. So I think that's a great proposal, John, is these kind of worksheets, these additional worksheets for the applicants to fill out. And if they don't fill it out, send it back to them. You know, your submission's not complete. You got to fill this out.
I think one of the problems I see in Medford as a whole is that there isn't enough staff in City Hall. And I think I'm hearing that from Danielle, and I'm not surprised. There's not enough staff to do this amount of work. I mean, since the short time I've been on this project, we've done huge developments. I mean, as board members, our part of this job is the easiest, I think. I mean, I can't imagine the hours that Danielle and Alicia probably spent on those larger projects out by Wellington before they ever got to us.
So I think that us as a board, if Danielle and Alicia, if you're not happy with the way the zoning is written in terms of how this board does its job, perhaps we can have a subcommittee within the board to consider changes to that zoning. And we can recommend it as we did on Salem Street, That's kind of one of the first things we learned this new board is we can recommend zoning changes to city council. So why don't we start recommending some zoning changes to city council that'll help this board and it won't, it doesn't make city council have to do the work. We don't have to wait for them. We can do it and just put it in front of them and say, hey, approve this to make our life a little bit easier over here.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: So these sorts of administrative changes that the staff want is one of the things that they did write into the scope for the consultant that during the Medford Square section, we would be working in the background to put together the legal language for administrative changes requested by PDS staff and the building commissioner.
[Sean Beagan]: Great.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: That's part of what this can be.
[Sean Beagan]: I would just encourage you both if you're not getting the response that you want, put it before tell the board and we can make the motion, then they have to consider it.
[Director Alicia Hunt]: Right. We're still waiting for the mayor to sign the contract with the consultant on that. So and Danielle and I can talk tomorrow. Are you in? You're not in this week, are you? You're in tomorrow. You're out tomorrow and Friday. Yeah. we can talk on Monday about which are the things that we have the authority to just set policy within our office and do it.
[John Anderson]: And I also point out that we have a lot of wiggle wiggle room on this board. We can waive any part of those sections that we choose. And in fact, we did that recently. And there are also some rather vague and open ended sections when We review, you know, the impact on the neighborhood or the impact on the community. That can stretch quite some distance. Agreed.
[Chair Doug Carr]: So John, I thank you for, you kicked this off and I think it's gone in a positive direction. Obviously there's some legwork to be done here about what we need approval from the city council, what we can do internally. The other component that obviously I brought up was the fact that there's like 14 different zoning sections, John, and that spreadsheet that we created for that one applicant that we're gonna use going forward. So, you know, I, I think I've got a separate presentation. I want to make to this group about design to talk about that. I think I propose a Danielle and to Alicia that perhaps there's a, there's a, there's a, there's a, there's a, there's a, there's a, there's a. but design should be a subcommittee of this group that would hash things out rather than try to design in front of 100 people. It's very inefficient. I've been through many cities and towns in Massachusetts that have exactly that, so that you kick it to the subcommittee and they hash it out and they come back with a product. You don't have to accept it, but at least it's gone through Some critical thinking not in an open public meeting, even though it can still be that they need to look at what's legally allowed.
[John Anderson]: That's that's what you guys do in the historical commission.
[Chair Doug Carr]: It's a different animal, I think, but that's how we operate in the Historical Commission and the results have been, I will present the results at a separate meeting when we talk about design after the zoning meeting down the road when we get a little further along. Just how you can, I can show you what we started with and what we ended with and how much better it was because we had an effective design review process in the lens of historical only, not new building.
[John Anderson]: Actually, we didn't finish my little memo there. There's another paragraph at the end, which it's too late to get into that in much detail. But I would just like to put it on the table. Can you put that back up again?
[Chair Doug Carr]: I can indeed. Hold on a second.
[John Anderson]: Basically, what I'm saying here is that uh, Medford has a master plan and it advocates, albeit rather vaguely, you know, affordable housing, livable neighborhoods, green space, preservation, existing neighborhoods, and everything that all the zoning changes impact those things in a major way, in a general way. And when we do site plan review, it does it too. And, I don't think the city has or we have an approach that balances some of these things, you know, like affordable housing, preservation of existing neighborhoods. So, for example, in Medford Square, you could say, well, if we tear down that old building, we can put up this great building with a bunch of condos and a lot of which would be affordable. You know, how do we balance these things, livable neighborhoods, so forth and so on?
And it would, I think if we work with the city council and have some sort of understanding of how this would work, we can have a much more positive effect on the city's development. But it's too late to get into that now.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Yeah, we are coming up on 9 o'clock. I think I think I think I want to kind of pause at this point unless anyone has any other ideas. It's been a long night to go longer than I thought, but for good reasons. So let's. let's focus we're going to obviously shift focus and prepare for the meeting on the 21st is our next focus uh two weeks from tonight in person and let's let's do what we can to educate ourselves uh you know look at take a look at the map if you haven't. I'll send my comments to Danielle and Alicia and they can distribute it per their request as all documents should go through them.
And then let's prepare to engage the city council and find in a couple weeks and Talk to your neighbors. What are they concerned about? There is a balance between affordable, open space, development, historic preservation. There needs to be one, and I think there's a common-sense consensus that can come out of this. I'm convinced that that's the case. Any other final comments? Otherwise, I'll take a motion to adjourn.
[John Anderson]: All together? I'm so moved.
[Chair Doug Carr]: No, it's not going to be. Second. All right. You go ahead, Mr. Anderson, the comedian of the group, clearly. Aye. Sean Began. Yes. Page Buldini.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: Ari Fishman.
[Ari Fishman]: Yes.
[Chair Doug Carr]: And myself, yes. Thank you, folks. We'll see you in a couple of weeks in person. I haven't seen some of you guys in a long time. Cheers. Take care, everyone.
[Senior Planner Danielle Evans]: Good night. Recording stopped.
|
total time: 2.38 minutes total words: 430 |
|||